Basement Bulletin w/ Coinicarus: Lightning Network Nodes, Coldcard, Multisig, Little Bitcoin Book
Coinicarus, host of the Fun With Crypto podcast, joins me and Tommy to discuss August 2019 in bitcoin. We talk Lightning Network, Casa, Nodl, Raspi 4, the Sats App, Coldcard MK3, Justin Moon's multisig proof of concept, the Little Bitcoin Book, and, finally Craig Wright is officially recognized as a fraud.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Hello and welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm here sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how it goes out there, Bitcoiners. Hope you all are well all over the world. Hope you're having a great weekend. It's time for another basement bulletin episode here on the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast.
These are our monthly recap episodes where I sit down with my friend Tommy in the basement of the old church he now lives in, and we are joined by a Bitcoiner for a laid-back chill discussion about the past month in Bitcoin. This month we're joined by Coinicoris, host of the Fun with Crypto Podcast, and it was a good time.
Before we dive in today, I want to take a minute to sincerely thank all of you.
The podcast has grown a ton since I started doing the interview episodes earlier this year. We had another big leg up on the monthly downloads chart this month, and we've had at least one download in 108 countries around the world. It's amazing. Bitcoin is truly a global phenomenon. So if you're new here, welcome.
Thanks for joining us here at the dawn of the Bitcoin renaissance. I invite you to go back through the archive for some epic interviews with great Bitcoiners like Matt Odell, Brandon Quittem, Dan Held, Ansel Lindner, Hodlonaut, Pierre Rochard, Marty Bent, many more.
And if you can give back by taking a minute to rate and review the Pod on Apple Podcasts, it really, really helps. And if you've been around here for a while, hey, I appreciate you sticking around and for all your support. It's been a ton of fun to be on this journey with you all. All right, let's dive into this one.
All right, man. We're back here in the basement in Lawrence, Kansas of this old church. You know, Tommy, I think we should call this thing the Church of Satoshi. You know, maybe we can get like a tax exempt, a tax exemption on all of our Bitcoin investments and all of our like business activity. Are you down? No, I'm not down right now for them, man.
Just keep it the basement bulletin, dude. All right. We've got I've been out all week in the real world in the fiat world all week. So no, this is great. He's not gonna suffer any of my bullshit today. He's he's in like serious business.
Mode.
All right. Well, we also gotta welcome Coin Icarus. A friend. Yeah, what's up, buddy? Welcome to thank you for having me on. It's awesome. I'm so glad to be here. Yeah, man. Coinicoris hosts the Fun with Crypto Podcast. He's been throwing out some awesome interviews with Bitcoiners lately and really carved out a niche for himself.
Covering the Lightning Network. He does a round table with a lot of the people who are leading the charge of on educating people about lightning nodes and really experimenting with different hardware and some cool just some cool projects going on. So yeah, definitely check out the fun with crypto podcast, and I'm excited to have you here today, man, to talk about August 2019 in in Bitcoin.
Thank you so much, man. As you know. You know, like I met you like when did we meet? About a year ago, and you know, your Citizen Bitcoin podcast is one of my favorites, and I always I always recommend people to it. So I'm so glad to be here. I need to have you on my show. Yeah, we should do that. That would be fun, and I definitely appreciate all your all your support, man.
All right. So let's dive in here. There's been a ton of stuff that we can talk about at Lightning Network since we've got an aficionado on the show with us. Let's get in, you know, or expert or influencer, which you can pick your word. Oh god. I just interview the people that actually know what they're doing.
Yeah, yeah, that's what I do too. Yeah, we learn a few things along the way, though. Yes, we do. It was actually a Feynman move there. That was pretty good. So, anyway. Yeah, yep. Tommy loves to drop drop the Feynman reference. Loves Feynman. I and like it's okay to say I don't know.
Yeah, right. He's a he's a legend, man. He's a legend. Anyway, all right. Tell us about him. About Feynman. That's all right. I don't want to get going. This is a hero. Those who teach those that's how we started this podcast. Those who teach learn. So that's the fundamental underpinning of citizen Bitcoin. I don't know if you know that. We decided what we'll do is yeah, what we'll do is we'll pick a couple topics, we'll study them separately, and then we'll get on and we'll do a podcast, and then we'll do one.
You know, and it's like fishing, you know. One's better than none, two's better than one, and then we'll just keep going until you know we stop ourselves out, and here we are. That's how we started. This is what it and this is what it's turned into. This is amazing. Yeah, man. So all right, so this month in lightning. There's a lot to look at.
I think the first thing to point out is Andreas Antonopoulos and Roast Beef and Renee Picard have announced that they're collaborating on mastering lightning. This is a pretty big deal. Yeah, that's definitely huge. I mean, I've tried to talk to Roast Beef, and it's like he he's so busy actually doing work, he has no time to respond.
I've tried contacting him multiple times. He's difficult. That's fantastic. That's actually fantastic. It is. We spend our time on Twitter like shit posting and you know, putting out podcasts and all that, which you know is important work, but getting marked by Rubini, stuff like that. That guy's next level and keep keeps his head down and just super productive.
Yeah, he's amazing. So having those three together is is kind of a dream team. And you know, mastering Bitcoin was you know and has been and will continue to be incredibly important to recruiting new developers and new talent to Bitcoin and really you know allowing developers to get in the game, you know, and just and start working.
I'm pretty sure that most people who are core devs now or have any kind of commit to the Bitcoin core repo have read that book, and maybe it was probably the first their intro into into programming with Bitcoin. Absolutely. And I mean if anybody's ever actually heard Andreas speak, I mean his writing is is absolutely like anyways.
To me, his writing is exactly how his speech is. Like he just to me, he's he's a very friendly, approachable guy, and I like the way that he presents the topics. Yeah, I mean, he's the original Bitcoin evangelist, and I mean, you know, Internet of Money Volumes 1 and 2. But he did wander into Ethereum, though.
Yeah, he did he wrote Mastering Ethereum, that's true. And Bitcoiners gave him for you know, not not everyone, but there was definitely a loud cohort of Bitcoiners that give him a bunch of shit about that. But you know, I buy his his reply and you know he pushed back, he's like, dude, I'm I'm just interested in this technology as a whole.
I learn by you know, writing books and diving deep on these things. That's fair. Actually, that's fair. Totally fair. That's completely fair. That's the right answer. I didn't know that was the answer. So I think I have to reverse course now on on this. Yeah. Undo I'll change my mind. Presented with new facts, I'll I'll I'll change my mind.
That's what a wise person does. Exactly. Yeah, he's so mastering Ethereum and mastering lightning is going to really help push forward lightning development, which you know, developing on the lightning layer is a lot easier and more accessible to a wide range of talent, I guess.
More a more wide range of talent than the kind of arcane art of protocol, you know, base level protocol development. Yeah, exactly. You know, because now all of a sudden you're opening people up to like, you know, Python and easier languages that they can use, you know, to write like nice shells and everything, so it's it's pretty cool.
Yeah, it's something that I could probably do. So that's that's saying something. Yeah, right.
Trying and failing.
So it seems like the growth of the lightning network is sort of plateaued a bit after kind of a really hot parabolic start. What have you heard about kind of maybe the cause of the reason of that? Maybe that there's just kind of you know, a certain number of people who are interested in bootstrapping the network.
I've also heard that there are a lot more TorNodes on the network, and that those aren't necessarily, or at least fully private nodes, I guess, that aren't necessarily broadcasting their you know, their presence to be caught up in in some of these explorers, like 1ML, for instance.
Yeah, I think I think there's a certain number, obviously that we that is unknown, you know, that are that are private. I can say, though, from my own experience, at least for 1 ML, you know, you gotta go, you gotta register your node. I mean, it pops up and it's not owned by anyone, and then you register it. And I can say that even my Tor nodes have appeared, but so I mean, so in terms of going back to your your question, the original question though, which is you know, why maybe why have we plateaued?
I think you raised some good points about that. Maybe we've gotten all the enthusiasts in, you know? Like it's it's a different level of enthusiast, I think, than the enthusiast that is obviously actually writing code at the at the base layer. You know, somebody like me is obviously you know far removed from that layer. I don't understand it even close to the way that the experts do.
And I, you know, only lightning allows me to actually be able to under you know understand it a little bit more at a code level. And I can't really write code. So, but you know, to go back to what you said, I mean, I think that to a certain extent, maybe we have plateaued, you know, for that reason.
But in terms of development though, it's you know, nothing has changed. It's kind of the same way that when like Bitcoin was at like 3200, you know, and everybody was crying about the price. And you know, for anybody like us, like who was paying attention to the dev, I mean, who cares? I mean, it didn't even really matter. All right, 3200, great. I could afford a whole lot more.
You know, like that's that's really what that's all that really happened. You know, but the dev just kept on going and it's still just going. Like they just keep building around it. So to me, it's like sure, you know, maybe we've plateaued in the near term, but all that means is that we're now gonna find that next step that's gonna allow the next level of enthusiast to enter.
And actually, by by that, have you have you seen the SATS app from yeah, I have seen the SATS app. I've got it installed and I've been using it. Yeah, my SATS tag is is at Brady. Cool. Nice and simple, and it's kind of fun to get your first name. It's like getting early on on the Twitter handles.
And yeah, it it works. It works. I mean, I've had the definitely had the app crash a few times or like you know, just air out several times in a row. But just had to restart the app and things were fine and started working again. You know, but it's it's the first the first release, so you expect some bugs for sure.
Yeah, exactly. But the point I'm trying to make is is that you know, like now all of a sudden you've got a person who's not even so knowledgeable. I'm not talking about you, I'm talking about like the average person that's like not so knowledgeable that can you know has to set up the same level of skill as an at-home router, and now is able to install an app that automatically connects them to always have the ability to have lightning payments.
Yep, from their own node sitting at home, so it's from their own node self-sovereign, full Bitcoin citizen. Exactly. It's amazing, yeah. Yeah, it really is. Yeah, it's really amazing. Have you started selling anything through it? No, no, but I've been, you know, sending money back and forth to certain people, and I gotta give a shout out to Fartface 2K on Twitter, our buddy Fartface.
That's right. Got got the first the first leg of the lightning torch from from Hodlinot back in the day, and you know, back in the day that was like what six months ago. But it feels bitcoin time. Yeah, man, it's bitcoin. It's Bitcoin time. We're ancient now. We did that forever ago. The sweater's worn out. So true.
Yeah, it was a long time ago. Actually, it does feel like that though. That's a good point. But we yeah, we were passing sats back and forth on the SATSA app on Twitter one night, and the dude sent me a hundred thousand sats as a tip for the podcast. So shout out to my boy, appreciate you, man. Yeah, that's awesome. That's gonna pay for my like son's first home someday, right there.
That's amazing. Once we read sat dollar parody. He's such a cool dude. Yeah, he's a very cool dude. So thanks for that, man. And yeah, I also got a nodal this month. I got it set up nice. Yeah, it kind of went through a roundabout. Well, the first package basically got lost, and I was yeah, the first I ordered the nodal the note nodal, probably guess is a better way to put it to say it.
I ordered the nodal before Bitcoin 2019, and it got lost in the mail. And so I saw Keto Minor at the conference, and he's like, Oh shit, man, I'm so sorry, I don't know what happened to it. You know, and I had Citizen Bitcoin on the mailing label like an idiot, and he's like, I wonder if I wonder if the fact that it said Bitcoin on the mailing label had something to do with it.
So I started feeling really bad, and I was like, you know, these guys are out their money, what are we gonna do? And I and I didn't, you know, I was just kind of gonna consider it a loss because I, you know, those guys are struggling startup and don't necessarily have a lot of extra oh yeah capital or whatever. So but they were really they're really cool, and I got a surprise one day in the mail.
He sent me another box. And then about three days after I got that box, he texts me, DMs me on Twitter with a picture of the original nodal that was meant for me with like 14 different like you know stickers and postage things slapped on top of it. It somehow found its way back to him, so he wasn't out of the box, which I was really.
Happy. Probably went all the way around the world. Yeah, it is.
Some crazy story there. So I've got that set up now and running you know side by side with the with the Casa node. You know, there's definite like UI advantages to the Costa node. I think they're definitely killing it on that front. The nodal, the nodal is definitely better on the hardware fronts.
It also has a couple other like software packages. So if you're looking for like I'm I'm basically planning to use the nodal as more of a routing a routing node and using the cost as sort of my personal node along with the key master and all that stuff. So that's kind of gonna be my personal space if I'm gonna use it to spend money.
But I've got some projects that I'm working on that I'm gonna need a node to back up, and I'd like to get the nodal all hooked up on that so it can, you know, send and receive payments for for some apps and hopefully build up some good like channel connections for so that it's useful for routing.
Very cool. I actually do not have a nodal or nodal, however we want to pronounce it, but I do I'm going back and forth. I never know, you know, because because of HODL or HODL. I don't like the way hodl sounds. But no, I like HODL, but when it comes to the node, nodal makes more sense. So yeah, I don't know.
Exactly. I don't say the other one. I don't say the I haven't actually heard that. I just say HODL. I don't say the other one. Whatever that is. Exactly. I don't say it. Noodle and nodal. Yeah, that's good. It's like pleb and plebe, you know, like it's it's just interchangeable. I was talking about that with the last person I interviewed, Optimus Fields.
You know, yeah, yeah, yeah. So going back to the Nodal, when I was talking to when I was talking to Matt Odell, and you know, shout out to you know Tales from the Crypt, they're definitely awesome. And he he totally loves the user experience. He said that it's and Marty, absolutely. He he said that he loves the user experience.
So I mean I you know I know that they have the ride the lightning interface. I use that with the Raspbi Blitz, and I do love I do love the ride the lightning interface, and I know that they are absolutely you know working hard, and we're we're gonna get an update from them pretty soon. So it you're gonna continue to see it get better, you know, for for for the nodal.
Yeah, I think so too. And like the UI is not bad, like it's it it's just you know, single-click install of Bitcoin, single-click install of LD. Everything single-click install. You know, it's just not as polished. I they I don't they don't I don't think they have like a professional UI UX designer on it at this point.
But that can definitely improve. What you want now is the functionality, right? So you just you just click everything, you get it up and running. And there's some you know basic config options that you can set from the from within the UI, the web-based UI. And that should get you know 90% of users where they need to be but then you can also SSH into the box and you know if you want to like do some additional settings some more advanced config stuff you can do that too and there's a telegram group and those guys are super responsive in there and they'll just like basically they'll
Be like all right here's the command you need and you can kind of search through the history of the telegram and you know just cut and paste commands you know command line commands that you that you'd need to adjust like a fee rate on a channel or something like that and that stuff will all get added in you know probably to like RTL and stuff eventually too maybe it is there now I don't know if you can adjust fee rates channel fee rates on RTL or not now but it's might be possible I don't know I think you can I just don't remember right that would make sense I use the Casa a lot yeah the website is just N O D L dot IT yep
Nodd.it yeah those guys are killing it man and it's it's great to see these two sort of different approaches you know like the Nodel is sort of more of a tinkerer's approach more of an engineer's approach it's you know beefier on the hardware side and they're coming out they're doing a partnership with samurai and so you know in the coming months you'll be able to run a dojo on on any of the notal boxes and connect your samurai wallet from your phone directly to your own dojo on your own node which is gonna be pretty sick.
And then they're gonna actually come out with an upgraded box too a red samurai branded dojo box that's gonna have better hardware than the current edition of the nodels. So that's pretty cool too. That sounds so sweet. I'm I'm definitely gonna get one.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Your collection is like off the hook right now. Thank you. Yeah, tell us about your experience with making Raspy Blitz nodes. Yeah, so I mean I obviously I started with version one dot I think it was one dot oh and it it actually came from getting a Caza because I got the Casa and I felt really comfortable with it and to me it just seemed like okay you know what this is too easy so so I figured all right let's I'm gonna step it up and then I'm gonna try to go for a do it yourself node.
So in terms of like in terms of cost, right? I've I've written an actually an article about this on Medium, but in terms of cost, you're you're you're maybe looking at like a hundred and fifty to a hundred and eighty dollar difference depending on the type of you know, the type of accessories that you buy in between a raspy blitz and a Casa node.
And then because like the Raspbi Blitz, I think is what is it? It's 299. I think it's 299 to 399 USD. I'm not sure. No, it's the Nautil, I think that's 399. Anyways, yes, yeah, the Nautil is 400. So yeah, I'm sorry. It's you're you're looking at about you know, you're looking at about you know 150 to 180 difference between the two.
And the experience though, in terms of building it and everything, the instructions that Roots all made with with his team, it are absolutely they they are top notch. I mean, for something that's like nobody is nobody is getting paid to do, and they're all just collaborating, it's absolutely phenomenal. And even the user experience of setting it up, so it you have to I wouldn't say like it I guess it's going to be biased right because I'm thinking it's not advanced to have to format you know like an SD card and make it bootable you know for so that you can actually run from it so to me that that seems like all simple stuff but you know maybe
To somebody else it wouldn't but I would say in terms of you know technical ability it's fairly simple to get you know to get a Raspbi blitz up and running so they they've definitely made it a lot easier and lowered the barrier to entry for a do-it-yourself node that's awesome that's awesome and that's the next one I've got to add to my collection is is a Raspberitz base node yeah and it sounds like there's some really good sync times people are achieving with the Raspbi four the and it's yeah it's definitely a big step up from three you have to get the four I actually I got the four I mean I'm sure you saw some of my tweets
And it it's so unfortunately it's not gonna fit into one of those cases that I build because the case that I'm using right now is not the depth isn't enough so essentially on the four you have to get a different type of external hard drive and you or you get the official RAS RPI four or rat or yeah the RPI four expansion board I think it's X825 I don't remember a hundred percent but you have to get the special expansion board to support an SSD drive.
And I recommend I recommend to anybody to get a solid state. That's what SSD stands for, a solid state drive. Because it has no moving parts, it reads and writes a lot faster. People have given the argument that it's constricted by the speed of the USB bus, but at the end of the day, even with that constriction, it's gonna read and write a lot faster than if you use a standard 7200 RPM drive, which has spinning parts, and that all takes more time.
Like there's more caching time and everything. So I always there's also a higher risk of hardware malfunction when you have moving parts in the equation. So you know what? Like it's like I do agree, and it's like I say so, but I know that SSD drives for some reason right now, I guess it has to do with the technology.
They still, you know what, I could be wrong, but they still may have a higher failure rate, at least on the lower quality ones. So you definitely like you know, you definitely wanna this is one of those areas where you do want to spend the extra cash. Yeah, yep. And the Nodel does use an SSD as well.
The 400 nodd comes with a half terabyte SSD, and then you can get a $500 nodd with a one terabyte SSD if you want. Sick. Yeah. I want to shout out Brian Vu, who started a node operator's guide to the Lightning Galaxy this month.
So that's the first post went up August 15th. Definitely will link to it in the show notes. I am super excited about this series. It's actually it's a route, it's a guide to building a routing node on the network. And it's when I after I'd gotten the nodel set up and I was like, all right, how do I get started?
You know, what's the strategy here to make this a useful routing node? And I, you know, I put a question out on Twitter and definitely got some good feedback. There's some good stuff all you know on the web out there now, but it's gonna be really cool to have directly from the Lightning Labs you know, a guide that's gonna pull all that stuff together into one place.
So that's a cool development from this month as well that we should that you guys should check out if you're interested in attempting to run a routing node. I'm definitely gonna check that out. Thanks. Yep. All right, so let's give a shout out to Rodolfo and CoinKite.
The Mark III cold card dropped this month, and it looks great. It's got a new secure element that will always brick after 13 failed pin attempts, and that's like enforced in the secure element itself and can't be bypassed by code at all.
It's got some other improvements as well that will help make it a little bit more future proof. So some like signature, like it's got some more memory on board so that it can handle some more advanced signature signature schemes, multi-sig stuff. It's got a little bit better LED screen as well, it's a little higher resolution, OLED going on.
This this thing just keeps getting better and better. So I think at this point, it it seems like probably the best quality hardware wallet that you can get. Yeah, I would say so. I mean, I definitely love the cold card. I have one. I actually have two of them. There's one that I keep in mint, it's still in the package, never been opened.
I just I love yeah, I don't know if like i if you ever see the packaging, it's the i it's that the Genesis block. Like that's the print on it of the Genesis. That's awesome. So it's it's so cool. It's it's such a cool wallet, and anyway, so but the yeah, the one that I actually use though, it the only like the and I don't think it's anything on them, but like it doesn't, you know the I think it's not even really cold card, also.
It's like even maybe Trezor, but like the user interface, right? Like you have to either go to a website, you know, or in this case, you have to use a completely different piece of software. You know, like you pretty much have to connect your cold card to Electrum. I mean you could you could use it with other th with other with other wallets.
I but that's the only one I've ever used it. What if you want a multi-sig? Yeah. So it it's it's like it has like, but the reality is is that it's meant to be like a bulletproof wallet, and that's if you're actually looking for the bulletproof air gappable wallet, that's that's the one, you know.
So if you lose your pin, you're dead. Pretty much. Just letting people know that, right? Yeah. So if you if you lose your pin, then you try to do your attempts, you better better be trying pretty hard because after number 13, you're done. Right. But it's only it's what eight digits, the pin on the cold card.
Is that right? Or yeah. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, yeah. So yeah, that's that's easy enough to remember. I don't know. I'm just then you can you know, I just that's the way this works, right? I'm just oh yeah. Well, you know, there is there's no no bank to call or credit card company to call.
Responsibility. We're all about personal responsibility here. That's right. Personal responsibility is a good thing. What do you mean you forgot your pin, you dumbass? Enforced, it's forced by the protocol. Yeah, so this is looking good. I'm gonna have to get a Mark III. I'm waiting for something else there.
I'm waiting for Casa to add it, add support for the cold card to their multi-sig key master service. Right now you can only use Trezor or Ledger. I know Elena Vernova is there and she was the original one of the original founders of Trezor. Is this hardening against side channel attacks new too, or is it just improved?
It's improved, yeah. Against side channel attacks.
I was just looking at this cartoon that's on the blog post about the cold card Mark III. So I'll I'll throw this in the show notes as well. Shout out to those guys. Keep up the great work. Let's take a look. All right, Justin Moon dropped a project, speaking of multi-sig, just a few days ago. So this is kind of a proof of concept.
It's only able to be run on the test net right now because it's just way too early to try to run on the mainnet. That's you know, too reckless even for some of us reckless Bitcoiners. But he's got basically like this nice web interface to create a simple multi-sig PBST, partially signed Bitcoin transaction with Trezor or Ledger or Cold Card or all three.
You could do a two of three with three different devices. And it looks pretty sick. Like, I mean, you know, like we were talking about earlier, the only other like kind of fully supported multi-sig wallet out there is Electrum. You can do it with Bitcoin Core, but it takes a little bit of tinkering. Electrum has got a full UI for that process.
But this is pretty sick. Like, you know, through the through your browser you can make this thing happen. I think it's so cool. I look gotta give a shout out to Justin Moon, right? Like he's he he's he's he's actually building on Bitcoin and helping others build on Bitcoin, you know? Like there's all those shit coiners out there that went out to go and rent seek off of Ethereum and try to, you know, create the new and improved, and he just sat there and was like, you know, Bitcoin's the shit and I'm just gonna build on it.
Yeah, and he really just came into Bitcoin like not even two years ago. Oh, yeah. Like sometime in twenty twenty seventeen, twenty eighteen, something like that. And just hit the ground running, man. Biddle Bootcamp, he's got a hodl bootcamp now to help teach people how to secure their private keys and become a you know, a wise hodler.
And he's got Mooniversity, which is kind of a an intro, sort of a one oh one class before you would go into Biddle Bootcamp, which is more kind of upper level stuff. And I and I did Mooniverse, it's only fifty bucks. It's a series of videos that he's put together.
He's got a Slack channel for support. And you go through and you know, query the blockchain, learn how to use the basic commands on the command line, and even build a web based blockchain explorer, which is pretty sick. And it's you don't have to know anything. You literally get a link from Justin in an email, and it fires up this service on the web that basically is an entire coding environment that you need just on the web inside your browser.
Don't have to download anything. So even so, even I could You could do it, Tommy. Yeah, hell yeah, you could do it. Then I can talk about it the next next bulletin. Dude, you'll blow your own mind, man. How that's hard that's hard to do. So Justin Moon's thing is called junction. That's really cool. I'll link to his thread about it.
He's got he's got a GitHub repo that you can check out. You can clone it and try it out on on the Bitcoin test net. Oh man, that's really cool. All right, let's see. Oh, the little Bitcoin book. That's next up. Little Bitcoin book. I've got my copy right here.
Have you read all the way through it? I skimmed it the other day, a couple days ago. I sat down for about 30 minutes and just skimmed through the whole thing. I think to a close re a closer read probably take a couple hours. You know, it's only it's about a hundred pages long. It is a great intro, just for my skimming of it.
A great intro into Bitcoin. I think this, and I think it was intended by the authors, and it was and let's shout out the authors real quick. From all over the all around the world, too. Timmy Ajiboye, Luis Buena Ventura, Alex Gladstein, Lily Liu, Alexander Lloyd, Alejandro Makato, Jimmy Song, and Elena Vernova wrote co-wrote this book together this this summer.
And yeah, it's it's like a great intro. You can it's a lightweight book, it's not intimidating at all. Like if somebody that doesn't know as a primer, they could like at the beginning, they could it really would help them understand. Yeah, no, that's what it's for, right? Yeah, that's how they do it, right? So it starts out by talking about what's right the first chapter is what's wrong with money, which I think is the place you have to start, right?
Like why and what the why do you need Bitcoin? Because we have major problems with our money these days right starts that then it goes into what Bitcoin is talks about Bitcoin's price and volatility because that's definitely a an a concern for pre-coiners then why bitcoin matters for human rights which you know Alex Gladstein who's a co-author he is head of the human rights commission is that right the HRC I think that wanders off a little bit doesn't it for Bitcoin to start getting into human rights in a first book oh I don't think so I think it's I think it's a really important argument to make in the first book and like I said Alex Gladstein is
A co-author so I'm sure that that was important for him to get into that chapter. Then it talks about you know a the l this I did read this chapter pretty closely because I thought it was really interesting a tale of two futures so it sort of talks about what a world would be like if we continue on the path we're on now versus a world where we adopt Bitcoin widely and so that's a really cool chapter and then it just has about 20 pages of QA just questions common questions that's that pre-coiners might ask about Bitcoin so like how reliable is Bitcoin who is Satoshi Nakamoto is Bitcoin a Ponzi scheme you
Know the all these questions so it's this is great I suggest that I think it's eight bucks on Amazon. I'm gonna buy like five or six of them and give them out to some people who I think will actually will actually read it and maybe get them to pass. No current current no no coiners or knobs, or what do you think?
Well, this is the thing we kind of we talked about this month, and I think Michael Gladstein, Michael Goldstein, excuse me. I was got I was thinking back to Alex Gladstein. Michael Goldstein sort of laid out a big black boom. There's you got no coiners, right? Yes. People who have looked at Bitcoin and said, no, this is this is bullshit, this isn't real, this is stupid.
And then there's pre-coiners, people who just haven't really looked at it yet, right? So there's a there's a there's a difference between the two. And so he was talking about how trolling the no coiners is completely justified. But we want to be welcoming and kind to the pre-coiners. Well, but I think I think there's a third category.
Well, but the but the question though is is it have these people that are no coiners actually looked at it? And other people not always. No, I mean, but I mean, but the idea is there's a group that just takes the mainstream media, central bank, you know, large corporate, the bigger, you know, the regular multinational banks, and just takes their argument without actually going in and knowing what Bitcoin is.
So basically they throw all the arguments out and they just laugh at you, basically. And so I would put that in the category of somebody that hasn't really looked at it. In other words, they're just taking so there's I guess what I'm saying is I think there's an in-between category. Yeah, yeah. And he was, and Michael definitely talked about that too. He was saying that there are basically like you know, do some basic research before you come at us with your you know, FUD over and over again, the same thing over and over again.
You know, have you read the Bitcoin standard? Have you read the Internet of Money One and Two? You know, do you understand what what we're trying to do here and how this thing works? Well, that's it's really exactly. And I mean, I've actually run into it. I gave a when I gave a talk, I gave a talk, it was a primer on on supposed to be blockchain technology and Bitcoin, and then I was the one that put together the agenda because I was giving the talk and I centered it actually you know that that Bitcoin is the mother of all blockchains and went that way.
But but afterwards in the breakout there was a there was an executive in there that was giving me a hard time about the price of Bitcoin. He was just going on and on about how volatile it is and everything like that. And I said I said listen that's not that's not the real point here. Okay. You know and anyway he just started laughing. So I'm just saying there's that that type out there as well.
Sure. Yeah. Yeah what what's your take on this pointoris. Yeah I mean you know when it when it comes to that I obviously I think you know Bitstein is make makes an excellent point right and it's really difficult like we got to tread that line of like trolling the no coiners but like still somehow maintaining enough like dignity to be welcoming you know to the pre-coiners it's like no no you know we're trolling this person because they're they're being an idiot but if you're willing to listen you know we're gonna explain it differently to you like so yeah but it's
Yeah I actually that yeah that's a but actually that's a true that's a terrific point because there's some people that actually want want to understand it and want to learn more. I do and I think that's yeah I work with I remember being that position yeah go ahead go ahead I was just gonna quickly say I actually work with a with a hardware engineer who like so I went in to go take a look for these cases you know because I wanted to you know build some of these cases up for the for the nodes and yeah so I went to go ask him you know about the dimensions and whatnot and you know he obviously asked me what I was doing with it so I explained it to him and he right away was like you know about Bitcoin?
Okay so you gotta tell me you know it's like he's like so you gotta tell me more because I just don't get it like it's like a lot of them and they're like the thing is this right like people naturally don't want to appear you know they don't want to appear stupid they don't want to appear gullible or uninformed or uninformed you know they don't want to appear had you know so it's like it's it's difficult so it is like you know you walk that thin line and the problem is is that when you hear these ridiculous arguments even from some of these people you know it's too the price is too volatile it depends on where it's coming from if it's coming from a guy like that where he's clearly wanting to understand
How it works and he has a question about the volatility it's like okay let's understand this but if you know you're gonna go to a person and you're talking to them about Bitcoin or right away they come to you and they're like Bitcoin's a scam the price is so volatile like yeah that's exactly right you're gonna get your head ripped off like you don't deserve dignity
Yeah, you get,
I mean you might get a chance or two but there's you know some of these no coiners that that just have been saying the same thing over and over and over again for years now and you know the I'm there you know of the listeners out there who have been around for a while there is you three or four people that just popped into your head when I said that you know who they are but I but I think your your point just made the you made the crux of the whole thing you just made a great point and I and that's one of the things I pointed out to people when it comes as it relates to this world of blockchain technology, when that's discussed, and it's more you know, the corporate and general public, that thing, and then that's a whole different and Bitcoin
And part of it with with human nature is if if it's been around long enough and it's in the paper, to your point, somebody doesn't want to admit that they don't know, right? So you say to them, have you heard about blockchain or have you heard about Bitcoin? And they'll say, Oh, yeah, you know, and then if the next question is, could you please explain it, you know, in in a minute and a half?
They just look at you like the lights are on, you know, nobody's at home, you know. In other words, you know what I mean? So that's I think that we're far enough along that that's a big issue in terms of trying to get, you know, and being able, for example, like your hardware engineer, hardware engineer, hardware person where they're comfortable enough with you to say a one-on-one to say, hey, you know, help me out here because I'm I'm interested, you know.
Oh, yeah. And once I explained it to him, he was like, That's incredible. I'm like, that's right. I'm like, There you go. You know, like because he can actually understand the beauty of it, you know. It's like right. So I think it's like that kind of brings up a good point, too, right? About the difference between the no coiners and the pre-coiners. I think it depends on the background they come from.
Like it's interesting, right? I've got this hardware engineer, he's super excited, he's pumped, he thinks this is interesting. I work with software engineers that right away give the answer that Tommy, I think you mentioned about the you know the Fed, like, oh well, you know, it's not insured by the government, so I can't trust that, you know.
And it's like, really? I mean, as well, you know, it's it's like have you looked at what they're doing to our money lately? Have what they've been doing for to it for 200 years? I mean, you really and you care about this? Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, people pre-coiners don't understand what money is, and this is that whole comes back to the whole thing that we've been talking about on this show for a long time.
The default default Keynesianism. This is just the way things are now, and the and we think that the US dollar is money, it's not money. All right, the US dollar is a debt-based currency. And there's a big difference between a debt-based currency and money. Right?
Debt-based currency can't be a store of value. It's not a store of value.
It is an inflationary debt asset, I guess. Not debt asset, but like, yeah, you're basically holding something that represents United States debt. And that's not money. Money should also be a store of value on top of being a medium of exchange, and then eventually a unit of account.
And that quality, the store value quality of the United States dollar and all fiat monies has been completely killed, completely destroyed by by Keynesian ideas of how monetary policy should be run. So yeah, it it died in 1971, finally, after being pummeled for decades.
That's right. The store value quality of money it's gone. Exactly. And you know what, like not just the in the US, but you know, can Canada's the same thing. I mean, almost the whole entire world is is the same way. So the second that you don't have an underlying, you know, an underlying commodity that has some type of store value qualities that people respect and value and that agree on, you're you're you know, to your point, you know, we're all just default Keynesians, and that's exactly right.
I mean, when I went to school, I only started you know what's funny? I only started learning about money by by watching conspiracy videos, like a as as a kid. Like it's like that's where you start to, and you sound like a I'm sorry to say this, like you sound like an idiot, you know, like you're explaining this to people and they're like, Oh, okay. And now here we are, you know, like 20, you know, 20 years later, twenty-five years later, because I'm old, and all of a sudden it it's like it's almost cool, you know.
You know, it's like you understand how money works. Well, that's it, that's it. Like, and the gold bugs have been banging their heads against the wall for decades trying to you know tell this story, but there was nothing out out there that could actually there was actually a living demonstration of Austrian economics and what money really is. It was gone.
For me, anyways, with the gold bugs, and I do have gold as a store of value, not very much of it, but I can say this. It the difference is it's already had its chance. Like gold had its chance, it didn't work, it's not gonna be money, it's it will forever be a store of value, i.e. A collectible, and people will have it as jewelry, but it it will just never have the qualities that Bitcoin has because the world isn't going back in time.
We're we're going ahead, and ahead is digital, and ahead is I'm sorry, it's it's just not gold. So I yeah, it's it'll never go to zero, you know, Bitcoin solves the centralization risk. That that was the thing that killed gold too. And especially it's it's so much easier in in modern day two. Gold's I'm gonna take the counterpoint. I mean, gold's at what sixteen hundred dollars an ounce now?
Yeah. Yeah, but people are using it as a store of value, but it's not it's not a money. 1100. Well, if if you have a situation where the internet goes down and you have gold and silver in terms of trading it to get I mean, would you if it get reaches a point where gold goes to five thousand dollars you know, an ounce, would you know, and somebody figures that out and you could trade two coins for a boat or whatever, or car it would be more like a car.
I don't know, man. If if the internet goes down and there's some kind of crazy apocalypse that happens, I'm I don't think like you know, achieving sound money is gonna really be up there with the list of concerns. You don't think you could trade it to get food? Like silver. Yeah, I'm sure you could. You could trade a lot of stuff to get food. You could also I mean the Bitcoin network can also run off the internet.
We don't even need the internet anymore.
Well, yeah, well, I mean, I get the I can make the whole argument with the with the Bitcoin and then just gold's just gone. Okay. But I have a I have a view that they're they're compliment and in some cases they're complementary in a great degree. And then we've got and I was bringing up the Brady and I talked about this earlier, but the whole point about money and the fact that we have a situation right now, and we talked about it several times on the podcast.
At one point it was fifteen trillion in negative interest rate debt. And when we first started talking, it was around twelve trillion, and now it's surpassed seventeen trillion in negative interest rate debt around the world, right? And so the I mean the point is is that at a certain point that some of the traditional folks are gonna are gonna put look to put some of their money in gold, which is gonna drive the gold.
And I guess your guys' point about a sore value as a way to go, but I have a tendency, I can see leaping to the full blown Bitcoin maybe a little bit later, but like right this minute, I don't think you can write that I agree with that. And you know, like Savadine says in his book, like probably the best hope for nation states to not give up their control of money to or at least you know, some control of the money to Bitcoin, is by going back on a gold standard, you know.
They might actually be able to compete that way and kind of honestly, honestly run the monetary regime and have it based by you know on on some sound money. Oh yeah. And he's right. I mean, that really is the only I mean to me anyways, it's the truth.
Either the money becomes you know, good money that people want to hold, or it stays shit money that people need to get rid of. Well, I mean, in and this is this is gonna go off track for like 45 seconds, but now it rolls you had Venezuela. Now look what happened in what's going on with Argentina.
Okay, Argentina is actually a sovereign default, as it's listed, but the rating agencies and the rest of the other governments in the world, the central banks in the world are afraid to call it as a outright hard default. So as of today, they were calling it a virtual default, which I don't know what the hell that means. But I mean, can can you imagine?
I mean, the IMF got involved, International Monetary Fund got involved with allegedly bail bailing them out and saying everything was okay, and now they're just the currencies just dropped completely through the floor in the last week. Well, that's only virtual. You know, they're virtual is only virtual. But I mean, yeah, and that's the well, that's the other part of this.
It drives me crazy. And I told Brady, and I've I've been on this for a long time. The concept of well, like that, right? Virtual default, and then the cont because nobody wants to own up with to it because they don't know what to do, right? With the situation. It's like calling money printing quantitative easing, right? Exactly. But but but but it's just to the point where Brady and I were going through, I said, you know, that there's negative interest rate is an oxymoron, right?
I mean, they should it should be a different term. An interest rate is something you receive for loan for consideration for loaning something, you know, loaning money to somebody, right? They should call it I don't know, a schmuck fee or something. I don't I don't know. But they can't make us feel bad about it. You've gotta you've gotta feel like you're contributing something or you know you have to feel good about yourself we right I'm I'm surprised they even use the word negative in there no but like seriously come on Keynesians you can do better than that like maybe call it inverse inverse interest you know that's so that sounds a little bit more interesting a negative you know that's or contribution
Fee contribution fee your you know the patriotic fiat fee is kind of like what kind of contract I'm gonna loan you know I'm gonna loan you ten billion dollars as a you know and so so what kind of contribution fee do I have to give you for you loaning you this money yeah I think the fiat fee is what we should call it start calling it actually that's good yeah the un anyway that's off track a little bit but I mean it's crazy right I mean I don't know why anybody's not jumping up and down saying there's 17 trillion in negative interest rate what did we call it fiat fee debt I
Was just thinking that's insane could be the undesired outcome fee that's another good one maybe we're sorry maybe we should maybe we should tweet this out and see if we can come out with the best that's right make it a competition yeah we need to we need to meme negative interest debt because that's just that's yeah we gotta we gotta take back these he who they who control the language control the ideas right that's right I was talking with some Bitcoiners on Twitter about that earlier today were you yeah yeah we ratio the St.
Louis Fed pretty hard. They they tweeted yeah they tweeted out you know it was like it was like click confirm send or something like that what and then it's as simple as that what else should people know about digital money transfers question mark and then I had some like stock photo of these people on like looking looking at a phone right and so yeah so we just put I was I'll I'll I'll pull it up because this is pretty good.
I thought they were gonna I thought they were gonna tweet back at you. Don't you know what the St. Louis Fed does oh crap is Twitter down oh wow can you imagine? Did they did the hackers get to Twitter get oh maybe I'm just logged out I don't know this is crazy. Hold on I'm still getting notified yeah right before we start right before we started recording Jack got hacked I'm sure you all know about this now that somebody put either either oh yeah no it's not done here we go yeah so that that was great Jack lost his mind or Jack is a racist somebody tweeted one or the other yeah that was that was crazy
And not a good look for Twitter I you know if they didn't move two factor authentication up the priority list after today I don't know what else will make them do that seriously yeah so so I wrote I wrote back they should know that they are not using money at all but rather a debt-based currency backed by nothing but the broken promises of a dying empire they should know that they should buy Bitcoin educate themselves and prepare for the coming monetary revolution you put that on there yeah responded to so they they got three likes on their on the St.
Louis Fed we've got we've got 19 right now and nine retweets. Oh man send me the link yeah it's I'll add to your strength. I will. Yeah, so I followed all the Fed accounts, like the regional Fed organizations and or Fed banks. And yeah, I'm gonna have a lot of fun over the next couple of months just ratioing the hell out of them with Bitcoin propaganda.
Nice. It's what they deserve. I think so. I think so for what they perpetrated on us. Oh, yeah, they don't know any better. There's some people who don't get it. I'm sure the person running that that St. Louis Fed Twitter account was like, what the fuck is going on?
Who are these people? Seriously. Seriously, I bet you they were. Yeah, we have all right. A couple of a few quick things to finish. Oh, yeah, go ahead. I could add to this. They they most likely they most likely know about Bitcoin and like it.
That would be yeah, that would be hilarious. Like Bitcoin sign guy. I really I really don't think they know. No, I really don't think they know very well. I mean, I yeah, I'm sure there's plenty that don't. I want to believe. So I know, but no, I think most of them think it's just gonna disappear or something.
Well, we've already got a few Bitcoiners in Congress, and that's only gonna increase every election cycle. That's right. You know. Let's hope so. Let's hope so. Russell speaking of you know, more mainstream adoption. Russell Okung, who is a I think he's left tackle for is it the San Diego Chargers?
Yeah, for the Chargers. You watch the NFL. I used to watch the NFL and play fantasy football a lot, but I just don't really anymore. Kind of gave up on it a little bit. I'm watch more how about you, coin. I watch more soccer this day these days. I'm not a I'm I don't watch team sports at all.
Yeah, all right. Yeah, I'm totally boring. Bitcoin you're not boring, that's actually really solid. Bitcoin is better than sports ball. Plus, it's got a lot of college basketball. I'd like to watch college basketball and soccer. Yeah, we live in Lawrence, Kansas, so this is Premier League soccer. I like a team from London. So anyway, I like the Arsenal cool college basketball is our religion here, so you know you can't really escape it.
You get indoctrin indoctrinated from the moment of birth. We're totally digressing, but the freshmen came in, okay, here, and they have a week long program, and like for two or three days, they they teach the freshmen coming in the proper chance at the basketball game. So they teach them the chance and all the rules and everything.
Oh, that's hard. It really is. Yeah, so they all they have the and how they're supposed to clap and run through it all. I'm telling you, man, Church of Satoshi Satoshi, we can start it all down here. We can do hodl chants and we can like pray to the Genesis Blossom. Sorry, I got into that again. Speaking of some mainstream.
I won't be warming up for for now, but maybe later on in the year I'll start to warm up. You keep up on me, you probably get me to No Man. You know, you're all serious now with your big like New York business travel and stuff. Come on. Give me a break. I'm just tired of you know, come on. So Russell Oakung, left tackle for the San Diego Chargers, is came out as a big coiner a few months ago, man, which is which is awesome.
And he's also on the NFL's collective bargaining committee. Like he's he's yeah, he's one of the guys who like organizes all the players in the NFL and negotiates, helps lead negotiations on behalf of the players with the with the team owners. So he's I mean the dude's a baller, he's super smart.
And he fell down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, and Bitcoiners were just all on top of it and saying, like, here's here's the right, you know, where to get the right information here's how to learn you know and get up to speed as quickly as possible. Not even a few months later he's hosting a Bitcoin conference in LA this weekend a big called Bitcoin is put it together you know really quickly and he's got a bunch of big speakers he's calling it the most diverse Bitcoin conference in history when is that this weekend it's happening this weekend in LA so people are gathering right now as we speaker going through I'm I'm sure he is but yeah
That's I think this is a big deal and this is I think just a way that and we s we talked mentioned earlier that there's already a few you know Bitcoiners in Congress one by one as you know people with large audiences and power and influence you know will become Bitcoiners and look how quickly they can use their platforms to represent Bitcoin right a couple of congressmen you know have basically one called it called Bitcoin an unstoppable force on the floor of the United States Senate.
The other one it was a congressperson in one of the committee chambers call us put the words shit coin into the congressional record that was during the Libra which was totally awesome it's totally awesome right so there that it just starts happening and then Russell Okung you know comes in and he gets it super quickly and just starts organizing and working you know these guys, people like this are are gonna start like being more and more common.
Like we only we had a few of them this year. We're gonna have dozens next year and then hundreds and then thousands, and it's just gonna, you know, literally be as as was called in the US Senate an unstoppable force, man. I totally agree. I love seeing, I mean, you know, it's it's exactly this. I like to see you know, if I'm going to see a public figure, you know, endorse something in this space, then I want to see them endorsing Bitcoin.
So this is this this is definitely beautiful. And I know like I've seen like some comments on Twitter, you know, from you know, from from people that are like, you know, give it time, he'll become a shit coiner. But I think that at this point, you know, not only are our memes the best, but like we have the best information. So, you know, and we've got the longest track record and we've got the most data.
And, you know, I think that in this case, like, you know, we just we just win. So
Yeah, I mean, yeah, the seven network effects that Trace Mayer identified years and years ago, you know, if you they're just they're all they're all true, and you can see them happening and weaving this sort of tapestry as as we you know through society, through our economy, and slowly but surely you know Bitcoin is just kind of infiltrating everything, and we'll you know eventually be woven into this you know beautiful new society that I keep calling the Bitcoin Renaissance.
And that's that's what I'm really looking forward to and increasingly convicted day after day that we'll you know we'll be able to get there. So it's pretty sick. All right, so there's a hurricane that approaching Florida right now. Sir. And it's called Hurricane Dorian. Look at what's happening, and it's approaching Florida.
Yeah, and so I saw I saw a great meme. I was like, you know, once once you see that there's a Hurricane Dorian out there, you're like, all right, Bitcoiners have got to be on top of this. So there's a like it's a it's a map of the hurricane's expected path hitting Southern Florida, which is where the Craig Wright trial just happened. Where he and we'll talk about that here in just a minute.
We got to spend at least a couple minutes laughing at Craig. But there he's got a picture of Dorian Nakamoto on one side with his like furrowed brow and stuff, that that famous picture of him, and then Craig Wright flipping off you know, the audience wherever that that conference was when you know just flipped his lid, literally. Yeah, and it's just it's like it's like don't you know, don't like don't incur the wrath of Satoshi, you know, like you're gonna send hurricanes will get sent at you.
That was some good shit. Yeah. So yeah, Craig Wright, there's a case going on in Florida. Dave Kleiman, who has passed away since passed away. His family was the was the other party in the suit. And Craig was claiming that he and Dave Kleiman were Satoshi Nakamoto.
And they basically were claiming that half of whatever coins Satoshi owns should belong to their family. And what was great was if you and I'll link to this in the show notes, but if you read the summary of the court's findings, they are it's just a laundry list of potential fraud and perjury committed by Craig Wright.
And you know, God, it's just so hilarious. It's so amazing. How much time, you know, how many tweets did he spend, like, when he was just bullying people on Twitter, saying, like, welcome to the law. I'm gonna use the law button to get you, we're gonna see what's true. You know, like over and over again. And now the you never think it was gonna happen.
Oh, yeah. And you could tell the judge was aware of all this stuff and just couldn't stand this guy, you know. And right now he's waiting basically waiting to see if the state of Florida is going to find him in civil or even criminal contempt. It's just I mean What do you guys think they're gonna be? He's a f he is a fraud.
He's officially labeled a fraud by the state of Florida. All right, he's by the law, he's a fraud. Craig Wright's a fraud. By by the same law that he so respects. Oh, what an absolute clown, man. It's I'll see you in court. But you well, maybe I won't. Well, he'll see you in court, but his evidence won't quite be there, and he might be able to get to it, but he can't, and okay, maybe.
Yeah, yeah. Peter McCormack. Oh my god. Peter McCormack's engaged in a lawsuit with him in in England. And he's already talking with lawyers about US-based lawyers, about counter suing Craig Wright for fraud and perjury, if if the state doesn't press charges against him first.
Did well, does he have any does he have any money? Craig Wright? I don't know, man. Probably who knows? Who knows? Did you see the tweet from from Peter McCormack where you know where he claims ownership of the white paper by scribbling out and like pretty much drawing like a child? That was an absol that was an absolute riot.
Oh man, he's he's a legend. I mean, just just for that was a riot. Just for the way that he like rushed in and took on Craig Wright and his bullying bullshit on Twitter and made himself a target. You know, it's just awesome, man. I think that that's you know, a little like an actual service to Bitcoin and the community.
So like, you know, cheers to Peter for being a badass on that front. So to because we're discussing the fake Satoshis, there's the you know, there's that there was that you know, that that guy, I don't actually know what his name is, but the one that came out as Satoshi Nakamoto, like he did this countdown.
Yeah, yeah. I heard about this and I didn't even look into it because I just rolled my eyes. But what happened? So there's the sky, like essentially there was this countdown on this like website. I don't even know what the URL is. I don't care to, you know, even if I did remember it, I don't really care to share it. But essentially, like, you know, each each day or every couple of days, he would release another clue about who he was, and he claims to be Satoshi Nakamoto, and then he released this ridiculous looking picture of his legal name being James Bilal Khalid Khan, and then he writes that he'll forever be known as Satoshi Nakamoto.
Like it's just it it's completely retarded. It was just a obviously was a marketing stunt, and essentially the marketing company was involved with this guy. I think I don't know the exact link, but it was much more than just like the marketing company working for him and creating this marketing campaign.
So like I think he was trying to give exposure to the marketing company through this ridiculous campaign. So, yeah. Yeah, I mean, you know, using using these things to just to try to I don't know, enrich yourself or whatever.
I mean, that's the definition of you know, a fraud. I mean, Craig is the definition of fraud, and so are the these guys. It's it's hard not to try to find ways to kind of leverage you know Bitcoin's like popularity and this like you know what this has got to be one of the biggest mysteries you know, that I can think of.
Like this is where is another instance that you know somebody has dropped a world-changing technology and no one knows who it is still to this day. But they totally got it because it had to be that weird. Oh yeah. It would end up like but my point is the fact that it actually like act actually was pulled off is incredible.
Exactly. Yeah, sure. I totally agree. It's it's almost too perfect, it's almost too good. The Immaculate Conception, as it's been called by BitSeam. Exactly. And it had no other way. Like, I mean, it it actually wouldn't be Bitcoin if it was anything else.
You know, yeah, or if we knew who Satoshi was, that would make a big difference. You know, like there would be there would be a central target to focus on. I agree. Forever. There'd be a head. And yeah, just can't that just can't be the case.
Yeah, so BSV is you know, what who knows what's gonna happen to that. There's the believers are still there. I'm sure there there'll be there'll be some hardcore believers that just won't give up on it. I did see Kevin Pham break away or whatever, saying that he's no longer a bel a believer in BSV.
This guy just doesn't know how to like make a decision and stick with it, he doesn't know how to develop any conviction. He d he goes all out. Well, it's weird. Not long term anyway. He's like a he's like an addict to short term conviction. He was like all about Ethereum for a long time. Then he went hardcore Bitcoin Maximalist and you know jumped jumped again to BSV. Well, Dark Pill at Dan Dark Pill.
He's got the tweet ETA on Kevin Pham claiming he was a Bitcoiner all along. Yeah. And gloating that he made a shitload of money dumping on his followers. Anyway. Yeah. Yeah. Dan is Dan has just savaged Kevin Pham past in the past few months. Low time preference conviction.
Exactly. Or sorry, high time preference conviction. High time for yes, exactly. High time preference conviction. Yeah. You know what's interesting though? I've already seen some tweets from some BSVers where they're they're mentioning they're like, well, you know, Hulcom what is it?
Like he's he's still he's still entitled to half. You know, so if he's a fraud, Halcom he's entitled to and like are are you kidding me? Is that really what you understood? That's that's what I got from it. The same thing too, and I couldn't figure it out. I said, Well, who are these people? No wonder they're BSVers or whatever. I mean, yeah, what a mess, man.
All right. Enough enough time, give it to that man. We just we should just start ignoring him, I think at this point. The saga, the saga is over, and everything else is just I don't know. It was interesting until this moment. Yeah, the old like they say out in New York or New Jersey, he's dead to us now. Yeah, he's dead to us.
Dead to me. The saga of Craig Wright has has come to an end. Finally. As far as I'm concerned. That's okay by me. Hopefully, hopefully there's an epilogue where he gets, you know, some jail time, some sweet, sweet jail time. That would only be I don't think that's gonna happen to you. Let's just let's just trade let's let's let's trade Craig for for for Ross.
Like, let's get Ross out and just put Craig in. And we'll just like swap him out. Yeah, exactly. That's what should happen. Yeah, Craig and Calvin. Craig and Calvin. We'll give you Craig and Calvin and you guys give us Ross back. Exactly. That's that seems like justice. Fair trade.
Yeah, exactly. Alright, dude. Thanks a lot for joining us, man. It was a lot of fun. Thank you for having me. Keep up the great work on the pod. Hey, thanks so much for taking the time out to be on the podcast with us. It was great. I really enjoyed it. Thank you, guys.
Alright, alright. That was a good time, as usual. What'd we miss? What takes do you agree or disagree with? You should let us know on Twitter. We'd love to continue the conversation there. Coin Icarus is at C-O-I-N-I-C-A-R-U-S on Bitcoin Twitter. Tommy is at Kennon's call, and I am at Citizen Bitcoin.
If you appreciate the podcast, you can give back and help me bootstrap this thing by sharing the episode on Bitcoin Twitter, recommending the pod to friends and family who are asking you about Bitcoin. And leaving a rating and review on Apple Podcasts is a big help as well. I really appreciate your support. Alright, that's it for this one.
Take care out there, bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show:
The Node Operator’s Guide to the Lightning Galaxy, Part 1
Justin Moon’s web-based multisig proof go concept, Junction