All episodes
Episode 43

Basement Bulletin w/ David Bennett: Libra Hearings, Bitcoin Businesses Growing, Upcoming Anniversaries

July 26, 201965 min

We’re joined by David Bennett of the “Bitcoin And…” podcast - a fave of mine - we dissect how the Libra hearings relate to bitcoin, talk about product announcements from Lolli, Lightning Labs and Saifedean Ammnous, preview a couple important bitcoin anniversaries coming up in August.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are well today. Before we get started, I want to take a second to ask you to check out Layer1BTC.com for some great Bitcoin merch. Shout out to designer Nick Ward, who's got awesome looking shirts, hats, hoodies, mugs, stickers, and more.

There's so many designs to choose from. You can click on partners and the top menu and choose Citizen Bitcoin to shop for merch that supports this podcast, including the default Keynesian Recovery Center design. Bitcoin is teaching all of us default Keynesians what money really is, and that is nothing short of revolutionary in this day and age.

That's layer1btc.com. One is spelled out, layer one btc.com. Alright, let's do this.

I'm leaving tomorrow morning to convalesce in the lovely Rocky Mountains of Colorado, so we had to get this month's Basement Bulletin episode in a few days early.

These are episodes that we do where we recap the month in Bitcoin with a fellow Bitcoin podcaster, and we record them from the basement of an old church in Lawrence, Kansas, that is now the home of my friend Tommy. Some of you don't know this, but Tommy and I started this podcast back in 2018 as just the two of us, a couple of relative Bitcoin noobs, talking Bitcoin and using it as a forcing function to help us learn.

It definitely helped a lot. And earlier this year, I branched out into interviewing Bitcoiners. But Tommy and I still sit down once a month and record these episodes, and I always look forward to them. This month, we're joined by David Bennett of the Bitcoin and podcast, a fave of mine. And we dissect how the Libra hearings relate to Bitcoin.

We talked about product announcements from Lolly, Lightning Labs, and Safety Namoose that were announced this month. And we preview a couple of important Bitcoin anniversaries coming up in August. Here we go.

All right, for the July 2019 basement bulletin recap episode, we are back in the basement of the old church in Lawrence, Kansas, where Tommy lives. Last last month. Oh, yeah, last month we were in San Francisco recording the basement bulletin from a rooftop. It was a rooftop bulletin last one.

That's correct. All right. Well, this month we've got our special guest host this month is David Bennett from the Bitcoin and podcast, one of my favorite Bitcoin podcasts. David, how's it going, man? Welcome to the show. Thank you. Honored to be here, man. I'm doing fine. I'm doing fine. Awesome. Good to hear it.

You just got back in Colorado. I'm just about to head there. It's a great place to be this time of year. Yeah. Oh I just want to go back. I'm really itching to just last summer because we were moving from Lubbock to where I live now. We had to take that entire summer to do stuff like you know, move, get the kids registered, and all that stuff.

So I it has been a long time since I've missed out on a summer vacation in Colorado. Man, this year when I got up there, I was like, if I had gone one more year, I'm not sure if I'd survived. You were Jones and oh, it was bad, man. It was terrible. I so I'd love to hear a little bit about how you got into Bitcoin, man.

I listen to your podcast all the time, but I haven't heard your Bitcoin story yet. Yeah. Well, it's kind of there there is a bit of a variation, but generally speaking, it's the same, it's the same story. I heard about it, you know, probably 2000.

I might have heard about it really early, like 2010, 2011. And I didn't pay, and like most people, I didn't pay it any mind because I didn't do the deep research that it takes to understand why you don't dismiss this stuff. And you know, I just I just let it roll.

And one of the reasons why I let it roll is that I used to be a video game junkie, and especially MMOs, MMORPGs, and almost every single one of them always had either some kind of issue with gold being, you know, the money supply or the economy being a wreck because somebody figured out how to duplicate something.

Okay. And you know, you come at Bitcoin, you come at Bitcoin with, you know, if if you've been in computers or are on the internet, know anything about Napster and what happened to the recording industry and why duplication always ends up being the problem. So I didn't think this was going to be any different. Well, fast forward and I start hearing about Dogecoin and the Doge Racers, you know, the racing car and the sledding team or whatever it was, and I thought it was funny and rather endearing.

And then I just started, you know, kind of listening. Well, at the same time, I started getting into things such as permaculture, regenerate regenerative agriculture, and found this guy's Bitcoin, or not Bitcoin, his podcast called the survival podcast is Jack Spearco.

Okay. And I had listened to him for two years, and then one day he just goes, You guys, you're gonna need to look into Bitcoin. And that was the event horizon of the rabbit hole, and then everything else is pretty much the same. That was in the summer or the beginning of 2015, and I ended up, you know, through Coinbase or Coin, what is the hell name of the oh well, I ended up with my first Bitcoin in 2015.

Sept September the 11th is when I looked through my history was my first actual buy, and I didn't didn't schedule that to be that way. It just so happens that I got my first Bitcoin on September 11th. So and then I just yeah, I've kind of been here ever since, you know, like red pilled some of my co-workers before I had to leave that job and felt pretty good about it.

That's awesome, man. How long have you been doing the podcast now? It's been well over a year, hasn't it? No, a little under September again. Yeah, September of twenty yeah, September of twenty eighteen. And so I'm coming up, I'll be coming up on one year anniversary here, and you know, I think it's gonna be mid, I think it's gonna be mid September, it may be towards the end.

I need kind of need to look so I know what the hell what the hell's going on. But you know, yeah. So the whole reason that started is that you know I kept finding these great podcasts and people telling me all this stuff and you know how it works and why it's important, and then I finally got to the point where I'm like, okay, I think I get it.

And then it was kind of the same thing was being reiterated, and I'm like, I really want somebody to read me the news. Yes, somebody to sit down and tell me what the hell's going on today, so that you know, so that I well, just so that I know what what's going on today.

And I couldn't find anybody that was really doing that. So I just said, and it was totally crypt crypto economy's fault, because he was one of the ones that I was listening to at the time, and he's like, I wanted somebody to sit down and read me these papers, and I'm like, yes, that's a good idea.

Yeah, yeah. And you found that niche. Like there were there were several like kind of newsy YouTube shows, but all of them were crypto, right? And it was and they all kind of like went away after the bubble popped in this last bear market. And yeah, so like the big Bitcoin and fills that niche perfectly for the news stuff, and there's not really anybody else doing it, and you do it really well.

Thank you. So like putting that into your rotation, like, you know, there's pick out some some good interview podcasts, there's several of those going now. Crypto economy with guy Swan is like audible for Bitcoin articles, that's gotta be in your rotation, and then Bitcoin and fits in there perfectly for news, so yeah. All right. Well, let's get into the news then from this month.

The I think the biggest news probably from this month were the Libra hearings for me, anyway. You know, they had a big effect on my sort of prognostications about how this is all going to play out, how governments and in particular the United States government would react to Bitcoin.

I'm I'm ultimately after this month more optimistic after these Libra hearings about how the U.S. Government will deal with Bitcoin. Let's get into the details about what exactly happened. But before we do that, Tommy, what was your reaction? And then David, what was your reaction like in to the hearings as a whole?

Well, the interesting thing for me is I actually presented to a global conference. It was the Alliance of Mergers and Acquisitions Conference. I had a presentation that I put together on was really blockchain technology and the coming disruption of blockchain technology on middle market businesses.

And it just so happened that my presentation, which was planned out like two months in advance, the day before my presentation were the Libra hearings. And I actually and so so that just made things pretty interesting from the standpoint of what I was covering.

Now, just to from the overall I'll get to the hearings in a second, but in terms of the conference, the interesting takeaway in the conference is that I decided in terms of my presentation that I was going to center it around Bitcoin, even though the people in the conference were just blockchain, blockchain, blockchain.

So I set it up that way and went through it. And I think that I guess there's two takeaways for me from the conference and presenting and just how the people reacted. First of all, it's still very early, just from the standpoint of big well, just Bitcoin itself and blockchain technology adoption.

A lot of people actually thought that blockchain was being put in place all over the place in sort of in terms of use cases. And it's related to the, I think a lot of it's related to the ads that are out and the discussions that are made. And I made I made it pretty clear at the conference, which people were surprised, that when it comes to blockchain uses, most things are either in the pilot or or I you know idea stage.

From the standpoint of the Libra, you know, Libra itself at the at the and my view on it is that I personally think that there's going to be, and I'm just kind of jumping to the chase, jumping to the, you know, jumping to the end of it here. I'm I'm going to be very surprised if it it if it ends up being actually put into place and adopted.

Libra. Libra. Yeah. Just because I mean, I mean, for example, one one of the things that I took away from, and because I was at this conference, I didn't get to watch the, and I had other business going on. I didn't get to watch the hearings, but one of the snapshots that that really was really at home with me was a question from one of the, I believe it was a senator based on asking Marcus, well, what are the bylaws, you know, with respect to what's going on with with this, you know, organization with the 27 companies and Facebook, right?

And the bylaws aren't in place. So what that basically means is you've got a group of 27 companies that have, I don't know if you've used the term committed or exactly what, you know, in terms of the funding, but the idea being that they've actually said they're going to do it, but it's not signed and closed in terms of the there's there's not bylaws in place right now, you know.

And one of the things that the senator said was, well, well, as part of the reason here that you've got the 27 companies that are involved, and they're in right now because they're afraid to not be in, and the devil, you know, he didn't say this, but I'm saying this that the devil's in the in the details. Then I'll say one last thing because I've kind of gotten long-winded here.

Is that is that from the standpoint of Libra, I don't think it competes with Bitcoin at all. No, period. No, not at all. David, what was your takeaway in terms of like the impacts of your thinking about how the US government will react to Bitcoin?

Well, just you know, just to clarify, I was in the mountains when those hearings came out, so I didn't I wasn't watching them. What I have yeah the input that I've gotten is is all the input that you everybody else has gotten from everybody else's reaction that that did watch them.

So I'll just cave, you know, there's the caveat. I agree that Libra is not in competition with Bitcoin. And my general thesis, one of the general thesis that I work from is that I'm not a shit coiner, but I see the I see that there's a potential value in the shit coinery, but only as a shield to Bitcoin, because they're so much easier to go after.

There's so I mean it's as if you're a regulator, you've got to regulate something. It's like it's in your nature. And if something looks like it can be regulated, then you're going to go regulate that thing. But while you're regulating that thing, the thing that really kind of can't be regulated or doesn't lend itself well to regulation is able to gain yet more traction, put down even deeper roots.

And I lump Libra in with any of the other altcoins. So there's that.

My favorite part is the fact that the term shitcoin is now on congressional record in testimony.

I think that's there's something that there's something honestly beautiful about that because it's like this guy, he didn't even he didn't even blink. Was that Warren Davidson that said that? He says there's Yeah, Warren Davidson, representative from Ohio. Didn't even blink, didn't even pause, just sounded like one of us, you know.

And I'm like, man. So and then you've got Patrick McHenry. I'll read your notes up here. Is that the world that Satoshi Nakamoto, author of the Bitcoin white paper, envisioned and others are building is an unstoppable force. So we've got people already in there that get it.

And my so now my huge question is how many more of them are there that get it, but aren't saying anything yet? And the more time that goes, the more time that passes, the more people are going to rotate into Congress that had never been in Congress before, and they are more likely now than to own Bitcoin than they were two years ago, five years ago.

Exactly. So, yep. You know, it's I don't even and the last thing that I'll say is that I wish I could tell you how the United States government or other world governments are going to start approaching the regulate the regulatory thought process, but there's no way that I can answer that and have any credibility whatsoever because for me to say that would be utter BS.

I have no idea. I it it what I can't, what I will say is that I think there's the potential that you might see some type of civil war inside of Congress between Congress people, regulatory commissions, and even within commissions themselves, because the second that you own any of this stuff, and no there's no law that says you can't own it, all of a sudden you're gonna protect your bag.

And if you're in if you're a regulator and you hold Bitcoin and you're in a regulatory commission, it's gonna be really hard for you to just go with the flow. So it's gonna be interesting to see the die the internal dynamics work themselves out as the pressure starts to build on both Congress and the regulatory agencies.

And I might be completely you know full of it on that, but that seems to be the way that that my gut reaction goes. Yeah, yeah. And that that's exactly what that my takeaway too, and why I said that I am now more optimistic about how the US government's going to react to Bitcoin. What I saw happen was astonishing.

When Warren Davidson said to Meltham Demir's, there's shitcoin and there's Bitcoin. Do you know about that? Can you tell us about that? And Melton's like, yep, I got that. You know, that moment was amazing, right? And then to be followed up by Patrick McHenry calling Bitcoin an unstoppable force.

It made me realize like the same way that Bitcoin is incentivizing the development of first of all the technology itself, right? And also incentivizing through right now the development of an education industry built to teach people about what is happening here.

We're seeing all kinds of great content coming out. I see I think we're at the beginning of what will become like an actual you know for profit industry to teach people about Bitcoin over the next decade or two as this as adoption increases. In that same way, Bitcoin very you know possibly and I think now probably will sort of incentivize its way into being basically legalized and used by you know having holders in government it's happening in Ohio you can use Bitcoin to pay for your taxes now in Ohio obviously Warren

Davidson was probably part of that I would imagine or if if not part of that then was influenced by that because he's seems to be holding Bitcoin now and yeah these these people will then be incentivized across the aisle to basically legalize Bitcoin as a as a hopefully eventually a legal form of currency in this country Tommy you were shaking your head sounded like you have to well no no I well I've I've got a couple a couple things for first first of all not only do you have it within Congress okay you've got a state states rights versus federal okay and if you drop

Right into Wyoming and what's going on, Wyoming. Yeah, they're the they're they're what racing way ahead here. So not only do you have the issue of within you know Congress and you got the House of Representatives and the and the you know in the Senate, and then you've also got the governmental agencies and so on and so forth.

But the other thing that's going on here, the speed with which everything's happening here, it it's it's a situation where I don't know how the regulation, how you how they can keep up with it in terms of what's going on here and how they actually, if you really think about it from the standpoint of the world we're world we're in.

So that's the other aspect you've got here. 100% of it. Yeah, we were gonna say, David, I agree a hundred percent with that. And then and then the other the other thing I was gonna bring up also that that isn't really well, it's kind of sort of discussed, okay, but is that Bitcoin's global, and the U.S.

Is only really about 10%, if I understand it correctly, is only 10% of the overall action that's going on globally. So you have a situation where we sit here in the United States, and understandably so I'd caveat that by saying that's hard to know. It's impossible to know for sure on on like what percentage of like transactions are originating in the United States with VPNs and all that stuff.

But anyway, yes, well, it's not it's not it's not half, right? I mean, let's let's say it's impossible to know, but well, but let's just say your point that that Bitcoin is used around the globe is uncontened. Like I don't get that. So my my so my point is is that and then I totally understand that the actions with the US because because it's the reserve currency, right?

So that's where all the action is from the standpoint of looking, looking forward, looking forward on this. But that is a backdrop. The other aspect of this is because of that, you have a situation where a country has got to be very careful because they end up behind the curve from a technological standpoint.

If they regulate incorrectly or too ham fisted with this, it can it's like water. It can it can move elsewhere. So anyway, that was my only other comment from the standpoint of looking is is those two is those two things. Yeah, well, we also had during the midst of the Libra hearings. Steve Minuchin came on to Squawkbox on CNBC, Joe Squawk.

Joe, what's his name? I can't think of his name, his last name right now, but he goes by at Joe Squawk on Twitter. So that's what I call him. Kernan. Yeah. Joe Kernan. Yeah, I call him Joe. I call him Joe Squawk. So he's I stopped watching CNBC, so I don't I don't I stopped watching that about that. Yeah, I just years ago I don't watch it. I just watched the clips of Joe Joe Kernan becoming a Bitcoiner the past the past couple of months, which is which has been awesome to see.

So Joe Kernan is is interviewing Steve Minuchin, and he's talking about how the dollar is used for money laundering and other criminal activities. And because Steve Minutian's like pointing out, well, the Bitcoin is only used for you know criminal activity, blah, blah, blah. And he's like, come on, the dollar's used for criminal activity too. You know, like and Steve Minutian literally looked in the camera and was like, no, I'm gonna push back on that.

I don't think the dollar is used. We have great anti-mongering money laundering laws and enforcement in this country, blah, blah, blah. And Joe's face was hilarious. I turned it into a GIF, put it up on on Twitter. It got passed around quite a bit, but it's he has his face is just like all confused and crunched up. He literally laughs, like laughs at the Treasury Secretary for you know trying to pass this off as fact.

Well, but the Treasury secretary's in a tough spot, right? I'm gonna tell he's in a tough spot, right? Because he he he can't give that up. Well, yeah, he's got to defend the shit coin that is the US D. Well, he's he's over the he's over the whole, he's over the whole thing in the Treasury Department. He's over all those areas that are directly related, you know, to what's going on here, right?

So from the standpoint of him saying that, what what else is he gonna say, right? He's he's gotta hold the line, right? So I'm taking I guess I'm taking the other position. I understand that it's it's ridiculous. But even even so, like I think there's other Treasury secretaries that wouldn't have the like gall to actually look into a camera and say that the US dollar is not used for criminal activity.

Like that's just I don't know. Let's just get well, let's go back to the who was the Treasury Secretary under FDR when they took the gold thing out, or who was a treasury secretary under Nixon. I just pulled a bunch of shit back then, too. Sure. Come on. Sure, but that's just such a like obvious lie that it's it's actually hurts his credibility and the credibility of the institution of that that is the U.S.

Treasury to try to say something like that to American citizens. It's just in it's just stupid. It's politically stupid too, I think. Well, it you know, I get the I get the def, you know, I get the what Tommy's saying, definitely. But you know, when when I heard it, all I swear to God, when I heard that said, the only thing that went through my head was all the times that you pick a state, pick a city, any state, any city that boasted of the drug bust they performed last month, and they show all these bags of coke and heroin and guns.

And always there are stacks of United States 100 bills wrapped up perfectly in frickin' cellophane. And at that point, I'm like, oh, so you were it, y'all. You I'm sorry, Mr. Dollar, you were just an innocent bystander. Clearly, you had nothing to do with this.

And I'm like, yeah, man, it's I mean, I if I if I guess if it had been me, and no one's gonna get me for treasury secretary, nor should they. If it had been me, though, I probably would have tried to figure out some other way to just say, yeah, we get it. Bitcoin's worse, and here's why.

And then and then redirect, you know, Joe from something else without actually having to say probably what what I think was very well as a contender for one of the stupidest things ever said on CNBC. And quite frankly, that's a lot. Yeah, yeah. It was it was a straight up lie. You know, and it it reminded me of the alternative facts.

Like it was like I think it was early in Trump's presidency. His his spokesman spokeswoman was out and called some lie that that Trump told an alternative fact, which I loved. I had never heard that. Yeah, so there's there's alternative facts. Ever since I became, you know, embroil or like ever since I made my home in down in the depths of the rabbit hole, I have I have no political awareness anymore.

I mean, it was it was one of the reasons it pushed me. I think it helped push me into the rabbit hole because I was like, all of them, and it doesn't matter my party affiliation. I was like, none of them like me, none of them care about me. I don't know any of them personally, and yet they keep doing all this stuff to me, and I'm like, I just I'm cyanora, pal.

I'm out of here. Yeah, I have well plus you can't control any of it either. It's a fool's errand to spend any time on it. Agreed. Yeah, yeah. And Bitcoin is it's a nice little side benefit that it'll it'll in, you know, basically distract you because you're paying attention to something that's you know more important yeah and actually might you know change the world it's something that that you know that will actually teach us something I mean I don't need to learn about you know Bitcoin if I were to just forget about Bitcoin tomorrow I'd still have developed an interest in what economics actually is beyond high school and the whole Ferris you know if you ever seen the Ferris Bueller

Movie that where the economics teacher in high school is just droning on and on and on about voodoo economics and I'm like this was my high school economics class there was no way you're gonna get interested in that it's just not gonna happen. And now I'm like oh this this can be interesting and here's why because it actually does matter they just made it so damn boring that we all forgot about it and they can do whatever the hell they want.

Yeah Bitcoin's paying you to learn what money really is I like that well the and well the other you know and the other aspect of it too is is that when you and when you start being focused on Bitcoin and just how all the different facets and aspects of it. You know I used to be let's say 20 years ago 15 20 years ago I used to be heavily involved with politics and then you know arguing about it and trying to debate and shift people's opinions and so on and so forth right and it it I don't do it anymore.

And I think a lot of it has to do with with Bitcoin I also just think in the times that we're in right now it's just you've got so much information flying around. You get people that just go ahead and find their point, right or wrong or indifferent, and then no one changes their. It's just it's a waste of time. I already said it, fool's errand. Yep. So it sounds like we're all in agreement about the fact that Libra probably won't ever get past the regulators, the global set of regulators and hurdles that they're going to have to pass to be used.

And just that those two days of hearings, every single aspect of it, beyond just the pro-Bitcoin, the directly pro get pro-Bitcoin stuff that was said on the congressional record, every aspect of every question that was asked was highlighting exactly why we need Bitcoin.

Because Facebook is and the corporations that they have partnered with are centralized institutions trying to create a money to quote unquote help the world in some in what whatever ways that they claim. Every single government, major government throughout the world, as soon as this was announced, pounced right away.

The ECB, most countries in throughout Europe, the United States government, pounced right on it, and they're basically saying, no, you know, this is this is not gonna happen. Why should we trust you? That was the other big thing is you know, it was there was a lot about trust. And Facebook's trust is certainly like at a probably an all-time low after what's happened about that past few years, and for good reason.

I mean, they've violated users' trust over and over and over again. And money is essentially about trust, right? So it's laughable that this company is trying to say, like, hey, you know, we've fucked you guys over over and over and over again, but we're gonna actually we're gonna we're just gonna make this global money now. Is that cool?

Like you guys will trust us to do that, right? Yeah. Yeah, no, we're not. Well, and we don't have to trust anybody with Bitcoin. That's the thing. So just yeah, it was highlighted over and over again. Well, but I to j this is jumping into a different area, kind of okay, but it's tied to Libra. But but my view is from the standpoint of a corporation and Facebook, they they they have to do this because as we move forward, I think what's going to happen move forward, you have a situation where the double spend problems eliminated with Nakamoto consensus.

So you've got a part, you know, peer-to-peer basis, and you have a situation where privacy standpoint should reach a situation where consumers or users can go ahead and provide their information if they want to, or otherwise it's going to be encrypted. So these corporations, the 27 corporations, other corporations that are right now just mining this data and making money off of it, they're not going to be able to do it anymore.

So I think from the standpoint of Facebook looking at it, they're basically saying if we don't get out ahead of this, we're we're not gonna have a company anymore because we're not gonna get paid for our ads. But I mean I could be wrong. I'm just throwing that out there. No, I'm possibility. I kind of I tend to agree with that, and it seems to me to be like sort of a oh a knee.

I'm gonna call Libra at this point, given what you just said, a knee-jerk reaction, and you're gonna see more of that. I guarantee it. And even if like even if they knew that Libra was it, you know, was gonna either be overregulated or or over, you know, regulated into the dirt before it can even get out of the gate. I don't even think they care about that.

I think what you were saying about getting out ahead of it is actually the real impetus behind Libra, whether it fails or not, simply so that they can at least position themselves for maybe a new idea that they have in the future. Personally, I'm not sure how anything is any of that's gonna work because you know it would like what you were saying, man, was that the trust in these guys, and it's not just Facebook, man.

I don't trust Google, I don't trust Facebook. I don't, you know, I'm not, I mean, I love Twitter, but I don't trust them either. You know, this whole trust thing is is starting to become so important that it's it's bleeding into the mainstream, and other people that say that, well, I'm not doing anything wrong. I guarantee you they're they're taking a second look at privacy and what that actually means because never had to before.

Yeah, privacy is definitely a threat to their business model. Well, but look, I'm gonna and I'm gonna jump into this real quickly, and you guys just stop me if I'm getting way too off track with this. But I mean, just look very simply at credit reporting. Okay, why in the hell should anybody's credit records be with somebody else without their approval?

Agreed. I mean, why shouldn't it be a case where you do your transactions, they're all done privately, and then if you need to go get credit somewhere or get a credit card or whatever you're doing, whatever the hell, a house, a car, whatever the hell it is, you provide your information up to the point where someone on the other side agrees that okay, we're you're okay, you're gonna get the loan or whatever.

Why in the hell has somebody got a credit score based on all their information that should be private? Why? And that's a whole business, a whole area. It's just a crazy thing. And they drill into people the importance of your credit rating and so on and so forth. But why in the hell should anybody have that any of that information at all?

Oh man, I am right there. I'm riding the boat with you on that. I've I've been thinking about credit for a long time, what it means, why is it even here? You know, how does it, how does it destroy or empower if empowerment is anywhere in that thing. But I you know that one is a God, that's such a difficult, you know, such a difficult one to unwind, you know, for various reasons.

One is because we've haven't been having to deal with it for so damn long, but also so much so many of the business models in the world are wrapped around credit. So if you unwind credit, you know, then all these corporations, they have a completely different set of problems to have to worry about as to how they're gonna move their business model back into profitability.

Right now, credit's a major tool as to whether or not people are gonna make money given house loans. And you know, you're right. You're I'm I understand I'm not talking about eliminating credit at all. What what I'm basically saying is is that that that whole area continues to function.

It's just that I am I as an individual are in control of my information, who I give it to or not. Yeah, and that that is coming with you know, on on the heels of Bitcoin and this technology that that big, you know, this kind of new technology sector that Bitcoin is inspired. You know, and I think it will be done, it can be done and will be done with Bitcoin on the Bitcoin blockchain itself as well.

For instance, there's the Microsoft identity product that was that is built using the Bitcoin blockchain, right? And that's kind of similar to what Block Stack is doing as well. Of course, Black Stack has their own blockchain, but they're creating these like private data lockers and a universal login so that you can basically say, like, all right, this be you get this piece of data, you get this piece of data, you know, and you can pick and choose, and it's like it's literally opt-in to give your data, and you have to, you know, you're in complete control of it.

I think Microsoft's identity solution is probably headed somewhere in that direction as well. And Block Stack this month, since we're in the monthly recap, was recent was approved by the SEC for the first I see legal ICO, basically. They're they're doing a coin operating. But I'm really I'm really glad you brought that up because it's almost to me like Microsoft is actually figuring out what the what the you know where you it's they're going where the you know Puck is going, as they say, the skate to where the puck's going to be or whatever, Gretzky or whatever whoever it was, but but who's saying, but it seems to me that that's along the lines of what we're talking about in terms of this you know, identity component of it, right?

And then just one last thing on the credit is that the whole idea is if it if when it's a situation where individuals are are are in control of your their credit, and it's your it's totally your point, David, it disrupts the entire model right now. It's gonna disrupt Visa, MasterCard, all these people, it's gonna disrupt these rating agencies because they got it all set like a machine now, right?

Right. So so it's gonna be a completely different delivery mechanism with respect to what's gonna happen. And it's gonna it's it's a tremendous amount of opportunity in that area too. But the de facto in-place folks are not gonna be happy about it. No, they're not gonna be happy about a lot of things, and you know, proverbial proverbial blood is coming.

It just it depends on how bad is it gonna be and how you know how intense is it gonna be and how long is it gonna last. But you know, these upheavals happen all the time. There's a you know, a fractal pattern of the universe is explosive growth and then long periods of senescence, where basically the same system is you know in place, whether it's geologic or biological, or you know, I'm talking about like stuff like evolution, where you know, evolutionary biologists will look at at you know you know, like all the species on the planet and say, we're pretty sure that at one point or another evolution was really mainly really slow,

Except in a couple of instances where within a hundred years a whole new species, you know, would be derived. Cambrian explosion. Yeah, yeah, that that that kind of thing. And you know, that pattern isn't just for biology. That pattern can happen in in geologic, you know, timescales, it can happen in economic timescales.

It's like being being able to identify when one of these explosions is is on the cusp of happening or or you know, fully blown, like we're seeing right now, we're we're at the head of a can't of an explosion, and none of these things are oh, polite, let's let's say they're usually pretty rough.

And you know, I don't want to be a doomsayer or anything or or scare the piss out of anyone, but if anyone has got the idea that this is just going they're going to slowly walk away and go to their graves and stop yelling at clouds, I don't think so. I think it's gonna be rough. But the good news is is we got people like Warren Davidson and Patrick McHenry and other people that get it, and they'll probably fight on the inside to say, you know, the lunacy that we've been experiencing or allowing to occur over the last hundred, you know, a hundred years, we have a chance to stop that.

But it would still be rough. That's all I'm saying. Yep, yep. I hear that, man. I agree. Yep, agree completely. Totally agree. And speaking of grumpy old men yelling at clouds. Let's let's chat for a second, and we don't have to spend too long in this, but I just thought it'd be fun to don't get me going.

Yeah, to get Tommy going. So Tommy's best friend Nurial Roubini. He blocked me first, by the way. Yeah, he blocked me way ahead of everybody. Yeah, Tommy's been trolling Nuriel Roubini on Twitter for a long time before it got before it was cool. I went to NYU.

And so I the way the way I got blocked is Rubini had some type of tweet, and I actually retweeted it and I and I put on their NYU, the business school, the undergrad, and the blockchain. Copied them all. And I copied them all, and I said, if this is true, why are you people paying tuition to go to school at NYU?

And then I got blocked by the way. He'll do that. NYU alone's gotta protect. I've been blocked for for quite a while. Probably not as long as you, Tommy, but but I'm definitely like I'm months in the hole of having to go to Rubini's. Yeah, yeah, just real quick. I had never been blocked really blocked before.

So for like the first 10 minutes, I wasn't sure what what to do, whether that was you know what the hell's going on, but then I then I found out later it it's become an increasing badge of honor. So it's yeah. Yeah, well, Rubini debated debated Arthur Hayes at some conference in who's that in Taipei. Who's Arthur Hayes?

Arthur Arthur Hayes is the CEO and the founder CEO of BitMEX. Oh, I know who you mean. Okay, okay. Yeah. Yeah, they they call they they hyped this thing up and called it like the throwdown in Taipei or something like that, kind of like throwing like I don't know, comparing it to the thriller in Manila, some big debate or something.

Rumble in the jungle. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I watched maybe 10 minutes of it, but I just can't stand watching Roubini, man.

Did he have his glasses on or did he take them on and off or what was he doing? Did he do the glasses thing where he looks down and then pulls them off?

No, he actually wouldn't even look at Arthur Hayes. Like he he obviously just absolutely hates that guy. So his he had the opening, kind of the opening remarks, Roubini did. And he's sitting next to him in a chair, but he's his whole body language is like he's completely turned away from Arthur Hayes, you know, like has his shoulder literally like turned away from him and calls him a drug pusher and a degenerate.

He did, yeah, yeah. See, I missed this whole part. Oh, yeah, just unleashes on it. Did they do the human trafficking too? Did he throw that one in there for good measure? Oh yeah, of course. Yeah, he just you know unleashes everything, says every it says the same thing over and over again. I just can't listen to him anymore. Can't do it. I can't do it.

So like I yeah, credit to Arthur Hayes for even sitting next to it in next to you know in a chair next to that man for however long it was. I did kind of fast forward toward the middle a little bit and to see if I could catch some more substance or whatever. And I saw a clip about so Roubini said something about how Bitcoin does five transactions per second, Visa does 20,000 or something, and Bitcoin can't scale.

I was I was disappointed, I gotta say, in Arthur, because he did not even push back on the scaling stuff at all. He would just like basically said in response, don't really care if it doesn't scale, it's used to, you know, be like for for privacy and self-sovereignty.

And didn't talk about Lightning Network or or anything. So he's basically just going with the protocol protocol layer, and he's not talking the base layer, and he's not talking about the Yeah, Rubini doesn't know anything about Lightning Network, apparently. So whatever. That guy, man, that guy just for yeah, we don't we don't even score.

He's a no coiner, man. Yeah. He's even worse than a no coiner. I don't know what you because he attacks on top of it. Yeah. Well, he's just he, you know, he basically bashes people with his Nobel laureate, which to me, again, like politics. I'm like, I've lost all respect for the for the Nobel Prize because of people, you know, understanding that when you start talking to people like this that have a Nobel Prize and you hear what they have to say, you're like, what in the hell's going on with this Nobel Nobel Prize committee?

It's like this guy doesn't understand. One of one of the ways that he was quote unquote making an argument was when it came to the security of the Bitcoin system, and he would just say it's not secure. And Arthur Hayes did push back on that and gave a couple of examples, especially like you're talking about, I think you said something like it's a 200 billion dollar honeypot, and nobody's been able to crack the egg.

I think I'm good with the security. And frankly, he probably should have gone a little bit further than that, but that was kind of good enough. So the rebuttal for Roubini was yeah, well, he should have just well, but but Noriel actually rebutted that and said it's not it's just not secure.

I mean, so his argument that this old man is sitting there going, it's something is X. Somebody pushes back and says, and if Norriel will just go, no, if you didn't hear me, I said it's something as X. Like, that's not an argument. That's just you standing there yelling at clouds.

And the so the man has no debate skills. He knows nothing about Bitcoin. It's like that Francis woman that writes for the Wall Street Journal and Forbes. I can't remember her last name. But they it's like that this oh good God. Oh, good God, you had to bring her up. Sorry, man. Sorry, and true. Oh my god, she's terrible, man.

Should we give it a trigger warning? They should be married to each other. Francis and Rubini should marry marry each other. But in in either of Yeah, they should do it. They should do an NFT podcast. But you know, in in either event, you know, I had I was you know doing my due diligence, you know, me and Brady were kind of like going back and forth on Twitter right before the show where I said, Look, I tried, I really tried to get through it, but I could only get through half before I had to turn it off because it was wasting my life, you know.

And I get the feeling that it probably got I well, I get the feeling that it probably got worse towards the end, where Arthur Hayes probably just shut down altogether because he's probably realizing these are minutes of my life that I'm never going to get back, and I just want this done. True. And I mean, it was it was maybe somebody should just do like arm wrestle, proposed to arm wrestle.

All right, well, we'll stop, we'll stop taking minutes from our listeners' lives by talking about this guy, yeah. And just but just to clarify, he does not actually have a Nobel laureate, or he's not a Nobel Prize. Oh, he was always doesn't. Oh, Krugman does. That's the Krugman. No, he doesn't have one. It's Krugman, but Krugman.

But Krugman does, but it's an international economics, doesn't have anything to do with what he didn't trade, but everybody anyway, Krugman's kind of I wait. Sorry. I'm not gonna talk about it. I think your loss of respect for the Nobel Prize still stands, but Krugman doesn't. I'm sorry I brought up no, it's okay. My apologies because that's even that's all right.

So let's see what else happened this week. Let's get into the fun the good stuff. So Lolly, Lolly is an app that allows you to earn sats back when you buy stuff online. I've used it a few times, it works great. And they have started adding grocery stores to the app, which is freaking amazing.

They added Safeway. They've got over 750 stores on the like merchants on the app now. They're adding them like crazy, and they're adding more like useful merchants instead of you know something you might use once in a blue moon for a gift or something, they're they're adding like grocery stores and hotels and you know all that kind of good stuff.

So I think there's there's more and more of these because like Casa has released an app to its users called the Sats app. And it also has a SAS back, like a rewards program. Our friend Alex Fetsky, friend of the show, has the Amber app, which is launched in Australia, does the same thing and does dollar cost averaging and rewards.

He's great, by the way. Yeah, he's a good dude, man. And I think this is you know, and Alex Edelman, I did speak with him for a little bit at Bitcoin 2019, amazing guy as well. He has a great point, I think, that this is sort of the next way to really spur adoption is earning sats, right? Earning some Bitcoin.

Because everyone shops, everyone eats at a grocery store, and everyone shops and buys stuff. And so if you can just install this little you know, extension in your browser when you're shopping and automatically get some Bitcoin back. Now you find, you know, you got some skin in the game, right? That's a lower bar or like barrier to entry than having to like even fire up cash apps.

That's fantastic. It's great. And buy and buy something, right? Fantastic. So yeah, and I think eventually these apps will turn into lightning wallets that you can just use and spend from, you know, spend from your rewards app right there. So I think this is a really good development, and I think it'll help with adoption for sure. I'm I'm down with Alex's you know hope that this will really help out Bitcoin adoption.

Do you use Lolly David? Yes, yes, I do. I do I do when I can, and now I'm gonna be using it more if and only if the following occurs, and that's if they get the United grocery store chains on, and I've been I've been on Lolly's ass trying to get them to you know to do stuff like this.

I'm I'm always you know I'm always plugging Lolly because they're one of my absolute favorite companies in the space. And I kind of want to talk a little bit about the safe way deal. And I it's on my I talked about it this morning on on Bitcoin and so but what I'm thinking is that the Safeway deal may be a test run for a larger deal because the parent company of Safeway is the Albertsons brand.

Now Albertson owns 21 different grocery store brand names, and four of them or three of them come out of the Market Street group of companies that they bought. I think about it was either four or five years ago. But Market Street compete kind of tries to compete with HEB and get in, you know, getting into that Whole Foods type of you know, food porn and our chickens are hand fed by Sherpas at 10,000 feet and all that kind of crap.

But you got ACME, Albertson's, Albertson's Market, Amigos, Andronico's, Carbs, Hagen, Julasco, Lucky, Market Street Pavilions, Plated, Randall, Safeway, Safeway Community Markets, Shaw Star, Tom Thumb, United Express, United Supermarkets, and Vaughn's. If the thing with Safeway goes good, and Albertson's, you know what?

If they just say, let's just deploy it to the to the entire family of companies, then the 982 stores of Safeway turn into something like 10 to 15,000 stores, if not more, like overnight. Amazing. So I'm on Alex's butt to just go ahead and slay the beast and cut the head off and go right to Albertson's.

And I'm starting to think that maybe that's what his plan is. And Safeway is the test run. So if you guys, if any of your listeners are out there shopping at Safeway, make sure to make Lolly shine and use it. Absolutely. Yep, absolutely. Got to keep this, keep this ball rolling. I think it really is a great way, a new avenue to increase adoption for sure.

So I think we should, it's a good thing to help for Bitcoiners to help out this company. Well, what watch out, you know, like all of our you know, listeners should be on guard for the following narrative that it will inevitably occur. Oh, cute. So your Bitcoin was really just reward points all the time. And my put the way the way that I'm going to combat that, and I've already combated it a couple of times, is like, no, what you're discovering is that big is that Bitcoin can become whatever the hell it is anybody that has an idea wants it to become for them.

And that ends up leading to the mutation rate that Bitcoin is starting to display. It can be money, it can be a store of value, it can be an investment vehicle, it can be a messaging service. And now it's reward points. And it doesn't make it any less valuable. In fact, it makes it more valuable because its ability to spawn offspring that have new and useful features is beyond anything that any other shit coin will ever be able to hope for.

No doubt about that, man. Well said. Here, here. Another awesome thing that launched this month is Safedin Amusa's Bitcoin Standard courses. He's teaching his first one. He calls it ECO21. You can find it at safeadine.com. And I went ahead and enrolled and was there for the first lecture last week.

It was great. There's the syllabus is pretty intense. There's you know a lot of reading to do, but not too much. Like it's it's gonna he's he's saving is kind of pushing you a little bit, but not too much. And you know, you can get it, you get out of it what you put in. You don't have to do the reading if you don't want to, you can just show up for the lectures or whatever.

You know most of it already, right? No, I don't think so. I think I'm kind of want to go up to the next level, you know. Okay, I just thought because you're pretty up on all this stuff. I mean, I've read I've read a fair amount, yeah. But yeah, I'm you know, I and I just wanted to also see how he was running the show, you know, because I'm curious interested in interested in Bitcoin education in general.

I'm curious I'm curious also. I just was okay. Absolutely. Yeah, so that's happening. I think we're gonna see more and more Bitcoin education offerings and like better quality, you know, incre of increasing quality over the next year or two. So that's really cool. You should check that out. David had pointed this one out to me, sent this to me on Twitter.

This is really cool. I hadn't seen it yet. But Lightning Labs released an app called LND monitor. The L it's LND M O N L N Dmon. And it's just Dockerized, like it's all in a container, super easy to install.

Lightning Network Monitoring app. And so it's got this awesome dashboard of all kinds of you know, like channel counts and node funds and pending channel HTLCs, channel bandwidth, channel commitment fee rates, you know, the most active channels, all that stuff, so you can keep especially will be helpful for folks who are running routing nodes on the lightning network to get some insights it all in one place.

So it was really cool to see this come out as well. Yeah, I was I'm I'm happy about this. Lightning's on a roll, man. I'm happy about this, and well, everybody seems to be on a roll. I mean, it's like you got Lollied that has like this this insane ability to do business development, so they're constantly delivering new people in their system.

You got the Lightning Labs and all those guys, and you know, you got BTC pace server that's just on fire all the time, and it's like I it's so hard to keep up. But this one, this LN Demon, I get I don't know if that's exactly how you should pronounce it, but that's the way that I do, is of a special, you know, is of special note because the ability to go and interrogate the entire network, bring in the data and then massage not massage it, but but put it into a system that you can view as a chart or some visual aid, you know, because it's

Like I was my early days, I was in the sciences a lot. So being able to functionally present huge huge data sets and put them in a system or put them in a thing that you can just show somebody and they get it is so powerful.

And analytics, right? Yeah, the yeah, the analytics is is so important, but be the visual representation of that is just makes you just end up being sort of like a superman because you're armed with exactly what's going on. And like once this stuff gets into the system, I guarantee you're gonna be able to automate certain, you know, either even other, you know, certain other things because you're able to understand at a glance what the hell's going on today.

And one of the one of their examples was you can get a handle on if if your channels are closing at an expected, you know, at a nominal rate, or for some reason or another, you're getting a whole bunch of channel closures all at once. That's automatically you want to go look at that, and you might not even see that happening unless you go pound through, you know, pages and pages of raw numbers, and nobody really first of all, nobody wants to do that.

And second of all, even if you had to, you're gonna miss so much. So having the visual representation, and none of us saw this coming. Nobody had even hinted about it. They just they oh, by the way, here and I'm like, God, I love you guys. Just dropping it. Yeah, it's fire, man. So a shout out to Lightning Lab, shout out to Lolly, shout out to Safadine.

Thanks for doing great work this month. And we've got a couple of anniversaries, important anniversaries coming up next month that we want to just shout out to make sure you're aware of. So, just in a few days, August 1st will be the two-year anniversary of the Bcash Hard Fork. The Bull Bitcoin is celebrating it with a UASF party that day, which sounds pretty cool.

And then that's gonna be down his way, that's gonna be in Texas, right? Or is it gonna be in Canada? I don't know. It's probably in Canada. I think it's probably in Montreal. Well, just because is it what date is that? Oh, you're talking about BitBlock Bloom? Yeah, is it the same date around? Oh, no, it's in Texas. Okay, no. Yeah, BitBock Boom is in Dallas. Yeah, that's what I meant.

But yeah, and Bull Bitcoin, they're in Canada, right? Yeah, bull bitcoins in Montreal, I think. Okay, yeah. And the anniversary of Nicola Dorier's BTP BTC pay server tweet. Well, it was it was a tweet at BitPay, where he said that he the trust his his trust in BitPay has been broken and he's going to make it obsolete.

That was the that moment was the inception of the DC server. You totally love this. You think that's so badass. It is totally badass. You just love it. It's utterly badass. You taught me it by the way. I had no idea. That's that's mixing them together, and I and I and it caused great consternation for for you until I got it clarified. Oh, and he thought BTC Paco. I would thought it was the same, but they were the same for for like an hour and a half.

Nicola would actually. You basically were like, dude, stop it. You thought for a while, I was teasing you. I wasn't teasing you, I had it wrong. I mixed them together. God forbid if I ever do that again, David. Holy smokes. I think Nicola would probably be happy to hear that, actually. Yeah, so shout out to Nicola, August 17th.

BTC Pay server, the birth, the inception. Nice. I'll just gotta say, because it's a tweet, it has a timestamp of 9 58 p.m. So I just I just love that because you'll be able to celebrate to the minute when Nicholas pulled the plug at BitPay. That's a great observation.

I didn't even think about that. That's cool. That is awesome. This is just something silly I found I came across. All right, there's well it's not just silly, but it it's it's actually a scam. But it's it's so so it could be said. By the way, David, we don't usually cover this type of thing on the city. No, but this was just this this was too funny.

All right, this is the silly part of it. So there's this site called M MGC Token or something, MGC token, some scam. Looks awesome. And on the front, it's it's like it's it's actually people in the crowd. I think it's a Chinese thing. Or Korean, perhaps. I am you know, I don't I don't know writing characters from from that part of the world because I'm sure it's Chinese.

Chinese, there you go. Thank you. All right. So the at the at the bottom of their of their page, the front page, they have a list of their team, right? There are two guys in here. There's a guy named Springsteen Brain. His name is Spring Springsteen. So I think they they meant to say Brian Springsteen.

No, no, no, I don't think so. Brain because he's smart. And Springsteen because he's cool and American. Oh, I thought maybe they spelled it wrong. No, no, no. You mean it's Springsteen. There's another dude named Abercrombie. No way. Right here. See what I'm saying? Come on. Okay. Just they're fake, they're fake people are named Springsteen.

How about this guy? Alfredo Aguire. Yeah, I don't know, man. It's just it made me cry yesterday. I was just like, I couldn't. The Springsteen brain one. Oh, good guy. It's too much. I'm arguing with you about it. You know, it's too much. Springsteen? I thought they meant a Brian Springsteen, but no, it's Springsteen, because that's just he is he's their genius, you know, director of technology.

Does he do? I have no idea. Well, he apparently gives hostage level video performances. These two of them, he's on both sides of it. Yeah, yeah. It switches back and forth, makes you think there's five people, but there's really only four. But Springsteen brain comes up every every time on either the left or right, which I was like just looking at, going, oh my god, the hubris.

Well, now to be to be fair, you there is that Nic Carter tweet. And Nic Carter's like, I can't stop laughing at this crypto project that hired what appears to be an out of work actor to pretend to be a team member named Springstreens Brian. And if you have you watched that video, there somewhere or another I picked up a video where, yeah, some somewhere or another, and I can't remember where it is.

I thought it was here at the Nic Carter tweet, but in in either event, there was this video, and he's it's this dude, and he's giving this talk, and it's like it's so horrible that one of the I think it was one of the other tweets from Nic Carter said that it was that it was hostile, like something like it looks like a hostage video, you know, like sort of like that that remember when Roger Verr was apol apologizing for Mount Gox and it I swear to god it was like dude you got a gun held on you or something, bro?

Yeah, yeah, right. Yeah, oh man, this is this is too much. I mean it it looks like satire. And you know, but the th the fact is that it's it's reality and it's and it's super sad. Yeah, I hope we don't see too much of this in the next bull run, but who knows?

You will. I mean it's inevitable. We'll see players. I got some I gotta it's inevitable. And the scammers are back out on Twitter too. So I've been blocking those guys. Are they really? Oh, yeah. Gotta be careful out there, folks. Be careful. Just just stick to Bitcoin. Just stick to Bitcoin for now. You'll be you'll be you'll think yourself later.

There's plenty to learn, plenty to study. And yeah, everything else is really a distraction at this time. Do your own due diligence. Yep. All right, guys. This is a lot of fun. David, thanks so much for joining us, man. Really appreciate it. Keep up the great work on your pod. And Tommy, you have any last David, thank you so much for joining us.

It's it's much appreciated. So it really helps us out to have your insights on our program as we continue to go through this. So I appreciate it very much. Yes, sir. I was I was absolutely happy, you know. I was just all kinds of happy and looking forward to this. I was like going, oh man, I'm gonna be on another podcast. He's like it's like this is great.

I just love it. So yeah, absolutely, man. You know, if you guys ever want to have me back, just just hit me up. And if if I'm not like wrangling up kids and doing other stuff, then I'd be more than happy to come back, man. All right, fabulous. We'll do it again, man, for sure. Okay. All right, guys. That's hey. Take care, David. Thanks, David.

Enjoy your weekend. Bye bye. Thanks again to David for taking some time to join us today. We had a lot of fun. Hit us up on Twitter with your takes and questions.

David is at B E N N D 77. Tommy is at Cannon's Call. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin. If you appreciate the podcast, you can give back and help us out by sharing the episode with your friends and family and on Bitcoin Twitter or leaving a rating and review on Apple Podcasts.

Appreciate all your support. That's it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

We’re joined by David Bennett of the “Bitcoin And…” podcast - a fave of mine - we dissect how the Libra hearings relate to bitcoin, talk about product announcements from Lolli, Lightning Labs and Saifedean Ammnous, preview a couple important bitcoin anniversaries coming up in August.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer ONE merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the show:

Bitcoin And… podcast lndmon Saifedean’s Academy “Bitcoin is an unstoppable force” Nicolas’ epic tweet BTCPay Server

Downloads