All episodes
Episode 20

Bitcoin and Taxes and Bitcoin Reports from Cambridge and the BIS

January 30, 201940 min

Tommy and Brady discuss bitcoin, lightning network and taxes and recent reports from the University of Cambridge Judge Business School and the Bank for International Settlements.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. We are here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going, Tommy? It's going well. It's going well. A little bit, it's actually cold here, frigid.

It's cold. It's about what, zero degrees right now? It's actually it was negative three, and this is Fahrenheit scale. And that's it's it's four. It's actually four. It's it's above zero. It's actually like super crazy up a little bit farther north than we are. Yeah. Arctic blast time here.

Polar Vortex, yeah. Four is actually, that's my favorite single-digit number. What's your favorite single-digit number? Seven. Seven? Okay. I don't know. Lucky number seven, maybe. That just popped in my mind. Haven't been asked that question for a long time. I won't ask you what's your favorite double-digit one. We can save that for later. My favorite non-single-digit number is 21 million.

Why? Because that's the cap for Bitcoin. There you go. There you go. So very fast. Very quick on the uptake. Boom. A couple of things to mention before we dive into today's topics. I was I have been on a couple of podcasts over the past month.

I published the episode of PayPod that I was on. It's a payment industries podcast, and the host Scott Hawkins is doing a series on Bitcoin. I was one of those episodes. I published it to the feed this morning. It'll so it'll come in to your podcast app right before this one.

It's what it's definitely worth listening to. There's some overlap between our Bitcoin turns 10 episode and that episode because they were both kind of like looking back at history of Bitcoin a bit. But I still think it's worth listening to, so I thought I'd throw it on the feed. I was on another one as well, the Bitcoin and Markets podcast, hosted by Ansel Lindner, which is one of my favorite Bitcoin podcasts.

Been listening to it for a couple of years now. It's a great podcast. If you're looking for another one, another Bitcoin podcast to add to your rotation and haven't subscribed to Bitcoin and Markets yet, definitely do that. It's one of the best in the biz. And Ansel has a Discord server that I'm a part of, and I'm also also subscribe to on Patreon to his podcast on Patreon.

And he hosted a community chat with about six of us who were on the Discord server and published that episode to the Bitcoin and Markets feed. It was a good discussion, pretty wide-ranging, and it was a lot of fun. So check that out as well. I think one of the most fun things that we talked about in that Bitcoin and markets episode was taxes.

We had a good 15-20-minute conversation about about how taxes work with Bitcoin. And one thing that we were considering is how Lightning Network might change how taxes are calculated or or I guess enforced with Bitcoin transactions.

So as we I mean, we've talked about this before a bit. I think one of the biggest impediments to Bitcoin being used as a day-to-day payment system, especially in the United States and other sh other jurisdictions that tax Bitcoin similarly to the United States is the way that it is taxed. It's treated as property in the United States, it's taxed as a commodity.

Any time you buy, sell, or trade Bitcoin, you have to calculate your gain or loss relative to the US dollar and then report that as income or or losses on your tax returns. So then you essentially have to, if you wanted to use Bitcoin for all of your day-to-day payments, you'd have to report every single transaction and calculate the gain or loss that you've had relative to USD.

Well it even enters into it even enters into a situation if you stay within Bitcoin. So in other words, if you if you use like what what you did with your visa card where you can actually use Bitcoin and it's converted at an establishment in US dollars.

I get that back and forth. So okay, so then you're converting, so all right, you're but even as we understand it, even let's say you want to buy a car, $35,000 car. Right. And let's say I've got let's say I've got the car and you've got the Bitcoin, right? I'm willing to sit there and say, okay, I'll take 10 Bitcoin.

So you give me 10 Bitcoins, so you started with 10 Bitcoin, you end up with 10 Bitcoin, so there's been no, you know, there's been no change. So you still have to go through the whole calculation on that, even though you're e even though you don't go into US dollars at all. Right or an or a euro or what I mean, I guess we're talking specifically to something else.

I guess or yen, but I guess we're talking specifically to the you know the US United States. Right, because in Japan actually Bitcoin is treated as a currency and it's not taxed like it is in the United States. It's a legal currency in Japan and in Switzerland. So eventually, hopefully that will happen in the United States. And so in that particular case, then you don't have the same if you're staying within if you're staying within the internet.

Yeah, and Bitcoin's used for day-to-day payments much more often in Japan. So that I think the situation where if you look at it from the standpoint of trading currency, then if you have Bitcoin and you're you're doing all your transactions within Bitcoin, then it's a situation where okay, it's cool. Right. So then, you know, you could do you could do it in the United States, and your hope would just be that well, you know, you would not re like the way that you could get around it is just not report all of those transactions to the IRS the way that that they want you to.

That's a bit risky on chain to do on chain. Oh yeah, the whole idea of the idea of chain analysis. Yeah, right. You know, if you're if you're really good with your opsec and your operational security and can maintain your anonymity, it's possible to do that on chain, but it's it's difficult and it's not definitely not something that the average user can do or would be willing to do.

But I wonder what we were talking about on that Bitcoin and markets episode is how the lightning network might affect this. It's kind of around an end around this problem because you're trading you're just trading back and forth Bitcoin transactions, but it's a peer-to-peer system. Onion the onion network is it it's onion uses onion routing, which is much more private way to route transactions through the network than just using normal TCP routing.

And it's it it makes it hard or impossible for you know, nodes, lightning nodes that are not directly the one directly before it comes to your node or they're one the node that you're you're routing to from you from your node to know where it's going.

And so it's a lot more private. Plus, you know, there's a bunch of transactions that are aggregated before they're settled onto the main chain. So it's hard to tell or maybe nearly impossible to tell exactly what you've been doing you know with your transactions on the lightning network. So I think it it makes it you know unit makes it impossible for the state to verify transactions that were made.

Like it is might be possible to do with chain analysis on on the blockchain because the blockchain's obviously you know a public ledger broadcast broadcast to all the nodes on the network. So yeah it'll be interesting to see as lightning network takes off in the United States and other jurisdictions that tax tax Bitcoin transactions like this see if you know how people Bitcoin users deal with it and how the IRS responds I just don't see how they can enforce the current mode of taxation on the lightning network you know what

I'm saying? I yeah I don't know. So it's just it's just interesting when you when you're when you really look at it because it's a it's a situation where somebody were to decide in the US to do everything in Bitcoin and they were just going ahead and like we said, it just they're actually converting it at the cash register to whatever the coffee or sandwiches are or you're at the at the regular store or you're buying a grill or you're out you know buying an appliance just the amount of time and effort it would take to just calculate up up you know what what what that

What the number is oh yeah it's it's insane it's it's obviously not something that a normal user everyday user would would would be willing to do only a diehard Bitcoin user that's dedicated to using Bitcoin for payments would be willing to go through those hoops so you either have to be willing to always mention it I mean from the standpoint of I haven't done anything in any of this so I don't know standpoint of how this all works so yeah other than other than reading about it so we're gonna talk about a couple of things today beyond that little initial convo about taxes and Bitcoin

There is a new paper that was released recently called the second global crypto asset benchmarking study this came from the Cambridge Center for Alternative Finance which is part of the University of Cambridge Judge Business School it's quite a thorough report definitely worth perusing we'll link to it in the show notes we thought we'd kind of go through some of the main findings from this paper which they have called out sort of in the toward the beginning of the paper so the first of the six

Main findings in the study is that millions of new users have entered the ecosystem but remain passive. So the total user accounts at service providers in in the crypto asset space, the crypto space now exceed 139 million with at least 35 million identity verified users, the latter growing nearly four times in 2017 and doubling again in the first three quarters of 2018.

Only 38% of all users can be considered active, although those definitions vary across the services, of course. So, I mean, this is you know good evidence of adoption and growth or since in 2017 and 2018 for sure.

Businesses in the crypto space are increasingly operating across segments. So the cross-segment expansion observed in 2017 has continued. 57% of crypto crypto services service providers are now operating across at least two market segments to provide integrated services to their customers compared to 31% in early 2017.

So this is talking about multi-coinery and it and it's rapidly expanding. So multi-coin support is nearly doubled from 47% of all service providers in 2017 to 84% in 2018. So crypto service providers are adding coins, adding support for other coins beyond just Bitcoin.

Obviously driven mostly by kind of the emergence of Ethereum and the IC, the same thing, the same factors that drove the ICO craze and how easy it was to create. ERC20, right? Right, right. There's information in the report about mining facilities.

Yeah, this is good. This is good, this is good stuff here. I think this is really good here. Right, right. Yeah. Yeah. So the study estimates that as of mid-November 2018, the top six proof-of-work crypto assets collectively consume between 52 and 111 terawatts of electricity per year.

So the midpoint estimate of the estimate about 82 terawatts is the equivalent of the total energy consumed by terawatt hours, right? Terawatt hours, yeah, consumed by the country of Belgium. But this also constitutes less than 0.01% of the world's global energy production per year.

And also notable, and this has been you know out on Twitter for a while and confirmed by some other studies as well, but a notable share of the energy consumed by mining facilities is supplied by renewable energy sources in regions with excess capacity. And you know, that's simply because you know, Bitcoin mining is sort of an arbitrage on the cost of energy.

It's gonna go to where it's cheapest, and the cheapest electricity you can get is basically free excess renewable energy that is otherwise wasted. Right. And these this is a little bit anecdotal in term just because I don't have the backing for it, but right off the top of my head. But my understanding is that hydro in China is two cents.

Super cheap. So that's really there's also excess hydro that's you know just un goes unused because it can't be stored or transported at a time when demand is low, right? And so there's energy being generated that just literally is gone. It can't be stored or used. And then my understanding, my understanding also, and this is just a statement, I'm not we're not we're just talking about energy for possibly cheap or inexpensive energy.

Yep. My understanding is the Iran generates most all their electricity with subsidi it's subsidized with natural gas. So they use natural gas and allegedly their cost and to somebody's cost is one third right now of it's under a cent.

You know it's closer to one more whatever point is that the actual cost or is that the cost that's subsidized by the government. That's the cost that you can you can utilize to go ahead and take the take the electricity at that cost for somebody there. Okay for a potential mining business. Yeah so the and the point being I heard that and so you know I don't know how from a decent source I don't know I haven't been able to you know confirm that but I mean the idea is is that and there's been some activity there in Iran also but the idea of going to the cheapest you know cheapest place to utilize the you know utilize

Electricity for to for the mining of Bitcoin understanding that the way it's portrayed or has been portrayed in the in the press a lot of times is you get the whole situation of it's really rotten because it's not sustainable and then they just pick out for example here Belgium right you'd have to take all of Belgium's you know electricity in in order to that total energy in order to mine the Bitcoin and but the point is actually it's it's one one hundredth of a percent of the global energy production and where it's

The where it's being pulled from is typically places that it would just to your point earlier it it's it's not going to be used anyway. It's just it's just vaporizing, it's just gone. Yeah, there's the example it's used often of the natural gas refinery or energy production facility in Texas that will just off-gas, they'll they'll flame off excess natural gas that it's it they it's too expensive to transport for them compared to what they could sell it for.

So they'll literally just burn it off into the atmosphere. That instead of that happening, the it being burned off in the atmosphere, there are mobile Bitcoin mining sort of just in containers, like ship containers or trailer containers, you know. And those they're plugged in basically to that energy source, and you know, you can it's it's a kind of a way to store energy because you can store the value of that energy as a bitcoin and then use it later.

The energy company could use it later. So so energy companies are just are starting up mining operations or you know, partnerships with with mining operations and doing this, and it's actually incentivizing the growth of cheap renewable energy and help and helping that those you know, the production of renewable energy company or companies that are producing renewable energy to save some money or to make some money in ways that they are just like basically losing it right now.

So it's pretty cool. It's it's not well it's not what you would expect on face when you see all of these sort of fudster articles about the colour. Well, and the other the other part just to add on all that is because I think this is an important aspect of what we're talking about with energy, because you've got you've got renewable energy from the standpoint you got hydro wind and solar, but particularly wind and solar.

Because when you specifically look at wind and solar, it's very volatile as it relates to a standard electronic sorry, a standard electrical transmission system. Right. So at some points in time the wind's heavy and you're you're producing a lot, sometimes you're producing very little. Or it's dark, yeah, right. So what what you have is is that so that's volatile, but then you've got a situation where potentially, and I didn't we didn't bring this up before the forecast before the podcast, but it's something I read the other night.

The fact that that you've got new pro flexible electricity demand projects in such areas as water purification and hydrogen electric electrolysis could prosper in the coming area era of plentiful wind and solar generation. So the idea is is there's there's potential possibilities to fill in with this aspect of renewable energy, and Bitcoin is one example, but there's some other ones that people have been thinking about, the two that the two that I just mentioned.

Yeah. Yeah, and kind of related to this, mining is actually it was is found by this study to be less concentrated than commonly perceived, and this is another sort of FUD item that you hear a lot that that mining is extremely centralized, and it's actually decentralizing, it's growing less centralized.

It's less concentrate concentrated geographically as well, in hash power ownership and the manufacturer options than it's commonly depicted depicted. The mining map in the report shows that hashing facilities and pool operators are quite distributed globally with growing operations in the United States and Canada.

So this is all this is all good news. The report is full of visualizations of the data that they're presenting. We will again link to it in the show notes and definitely worth checking it out. Yeah, and the top six proof of work crypto assets. We're just figuring that that you know it's Bitcoin for sure.

And what were the other ones we listened to? Ethereum, Bcash, Litecoin, yeah, maybe Zcash. What are the other ones that they were talking about? Yeah, so probably Zcash. Those are the criteria that they live in. But those are the ones that they used as the as the grouping in terms of the consumption of the terawatts per per hour of electricity as the underpinning.

So anyway, this report you can it'll be in the show notes. You can download it. It's it's fascinating. I just started looking at it a couple hours before this podcast, and it's I'm gonna make make a point of reading it. It's actually got a there's a significant amount of material in there that's extraordinarily interesting.

It's actually caused me to look at some other areas as well in terms of going down the rabbit hole. But that's that's one of the reasons why I find Bitcoin so fascinating. There's so many different ways you can go with it. Like, for example, getting getting off on a discussion about renewable energy. Right, absolutely. All right, so for the next topic, we're gonna talk about another paper, another PDF that's out there on the web.

This one was published this month as well by the bank for international settlements, the BIS. Sometimes known in Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter as the final boss of Bitcoin. If you believe that Bitcoin is a competitor for central banking or an alternative to state run central banking, then it would follow that the bank for international settlements, which is basically the central bank of central banks, is the kind of final boss of the beat of the Bitcoin protocol.

That's where it's really kind of challenging. Yeah, what was the final boss again? That was from some what was that again? Oh well, you know, there's the you've deemed him the final boss, which we've decided is perfect, I agree. And where did he come from again? The final boss. Oh, well, you know, the final like video games often have a final boss. I think he looks kind of like the final boss of the Legend of Zelda, one of my favorite games, Ganon.

Okay. So you're gonna look up Karsten. I can't think of his last name right now. Karsten something, the head of the BIS. Aka Gannon, aka the final boss. All right, there's our There's our resident Doug Gunner. Gunner, the mascot of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast.

He's named after the Arsenal Gunners. North London is red. Big game this weekend. Yeah, against Man City. Artic Arsenal Man City, big game for the Premier League at the Emirates. Yeah. The Tommy and I are gonna are planning on on watching that that game together, actually.

So let's get let's get back to the to the show. Yeah, Bitcoin are the BIS released this paper written by This is a good segue, by the way, from what we were talking about because we're gonna get into some things that were tied to this paper. So written by Raphael Auer for the Bitcoin or for the Bitcoin, the Bank for International Settlements.

The title of the paper is I don't know, it's it's a little it's not just a little, it's a lot. Kind of over the top. Beyond the Doomsday Economics of Proof of Work in Cryptocurrencies is the title of the paper. And in the paper, the author takes a look at the security model for Bitcoin, which we know relies on incentivizing miners to compete for using proof of work to find a hash for a

SHA 256 hash and that therefore win the right to create blocks. And this proof of work is the way that we kind of arrive at a consensus that these particular transactions are valid now, and the deeper the block is in the blockchain, the more assured we can be that the transaction is final is finalized, right?

So the paper argues this paper argues that the only thing that's basically subsidizing miners at this point, bitcoin miners and in is the issuance of new Bitcoin or the block reward.

And we know that the first four years of Bitcoin, the block reward was about 50 was 50 bitcoins per block. The next four years after the halvening, 25, we're at 12 and a half now, the fourth halvening will happen sometime in 2020, around like or May or so of 2020. Yes.

And that will reduce the block reward for for miners to 6.25 bitcoins per block.

And

The idea in the paper is, and this idea has been around for a long time and discussed amongst Bitcoiners for a long time, is that once the block reward goes away in 2140 or so, the last bitcoins will be issued, and then their the cap will be reached and no more bitcoin will be created.

So how are miners then rewarded or incentivized to provide hash rate to secure the blockchain at that point, right? Well, there is a fee market, there's all there that will replace ostensibly the block reward for Bitcoin.

Yep. And the other idea is that the relative value of Bitcoin will be increasing over time. So the value of six point two five bitcoins in the early 2020s would be worth about the same or more than twelve and a half bitcoins in 2016, 2017, right?

So you're kind of relying on the increasing share of Bitcoin taking an increasing share of global money, and therefore increasing in relative value compared to other forms of money, and therefore as the block reward decreases, you're actually maintaining or increasing the relative monetary incentive for a miner to secure the network.

Well, exactly. And well, the other thing is paper is written in twenty did it come out late twenty eight, not twenty nineteen, right? Well or within this paper, yeah, it's January twenty nineteen. Okay, so it came out twenty nine, it just came out so but the idea is is I think it's one of these things where you have to say he doesn't know. Well, yeah, I mean, we have very little experience with how the fee market will work.

Well, he doesn't know, he has no idea what the volume's gonna be. Right. And so the answer on that is you know, he can go ahead, but I mean it's and go ahead and hype, you know, hypothetically say what's gonna happen. But the but the fine Richard Feynman answer would be, you know, I don't know, I don't know. This is where it is right now, and I you know, I don't know.

Because there's too many, there's too many things too many, way too many factors too. Way too many variables, variables. But if you want to go ahead, if you want to go ahead and try to knock down Bitcoin, you can basically say, you know what, when they're not mining these blocks, you know, might not mining and getting big rewards or you know, of Bitcoin, then that's it.

Well, okay. Yeah, how does he know that? Well, yeah, you don't know the future price or relative value of Bitcoin. You need that information to be able to answer that question. You don't know what the transaction volume is, you don't know what the block limit size is going to be the this the limit of the body. Well, I haven't finished this part of this paper paper, but I don't think in the paper, as I understand this other article that was written that was talking about that this which will also have in the show notes.

Yeah, the block the block wrote yeah an article published six days ago called Bitcoin Post Issuance, an existential threat that goes along through kind of the same arguments and well and then provides six potential solutions. Well we'll also argue this one article here by Larry Sirmac is Bank for International Settlements argues Bitcoin and then in quote is not sustainable without bro block rewards.

Right. So they might as well just put bank for international settlements argues Bitcoin, Bitcoin, market zero. Right? Yeah, market zero. Market zero. It's over. Yeah, there's there's several pieces of information that we I mean you can't you it it is impossible to say with absolute authority as the headlines in these papers and the articles covering this paper are that this is the case that Bitcoin is not workable inherently.

There are several pieces of information that you need to have to be able to make that prediction that we don't have right now. And you know, if Bitcoin succeeds I mean, obviously you need Bitcoin to succeed for it to stay secure and solvent. Okay, so we're assuming a world in the future in which Bitcoin is is succeeding.

Okay, and by succeeding I mean it's taking an increasing share of value from from extant money from existing money, okay. And you will we'll eventually get to a point where we're building out you know second layer solution, third layer solutions, and the main chain will sort of increasingly take its role as the alternative to g you know state-run central banking.

And as that happens, then the transactions on the main chain will be aggregated transactions from the subsequent layers from layer two or three. And they'll be it'll be settlement transactions for large institutions, nations, huge companies, you know, banks, etc.

Making final settlement of lots of aggregated transactions on the subsequent layers. And those train those the value of those transactions on the main chain will be huge, right? So we can have we'll have a fee market competing for that block space, and we need to have this is another reason why we need to have a block limit, and why I think Satoshi gamed out that we needed to have this block limit and kind of threw it in there toward the end of his kind of you know stewardship of the Bitcoin protocol and code is that you've gotta you can't if you have an unlimited commodity, you can't

Ever have a market for that commodity. You need to be a you have to have a limited commodity of some scarcity for it to have some value, right? If you want to have a fee market, you need to have a limited block. You know, and there are lots of potential solutions that we can come up with to if we want to optimize, like Nic Carter has, and I'll put this in the show notes too, but a thread from January 22nd that talks about this idea, and he in there says, Here's amusing.

What about the following? Define an appropriate security spend, say 10 million dollars a day. So we need 10 million dollars a day to secure to spend on miners to secure the network to incentivize them to secure the network. So you wait for for fees to mature somewhat, so sometime in like 10, 15, 20 years or whatever, the fee market starting to mature, then you add to the code a some kind of dynamic block size that optimizes for fee revenue.

So rather than a static block size and unstable fees. So as you have this dynamic parameter that could target, you know, this $10 million a day or whatever we decide is kind of the acceptable security spend. And when fees are low, you constrict the supply and drive up the cost of transacting by you constrict the block size and or the supply of block space.

And when fees are high, you open up block space to decrease the fees and kind of give it some relief. So the static variable that you set is the kind of targeted security spent instead of the block size limit, right? And that's something that that could you know make a more sane fee market, maybe and allow us to achieve what the fee market is supposed to achieve, and that's the security of the chain.

So I think that's an interesting idea. And there are other ideas too that that's you know what we can that we that will be debated when when we need to arrive at a conclusion about this. Right. Well, and stop me if I'm jumping to the wrong thing, but this idea of a of a an attack to take over Bitcoin, for example, right?

And the and the concept would that an attack would just rent the hash rate. Right. And then they well, yeah, the whole paper assumes that it's easy to rent 51% of the hash rate on the drop of at the drop of a hash. Right. And so and so with my engineering background, you know, I had a professor, one of the greatest things he ever taught me, which is very simplistic, I probably could have learned it without going to engineering school, but it but all the best things you do learning.

Well, well, but I mean the idea is is you got to think operationally step by step. Start at the very bottom, right? Yeah. So if you're gonna start with 51% of the hash rate, you have to go out and actually procure that. It's not like the idea is, well, you look and you say, I'm gonna rent, I'm gonna rent some hash rates. So you go look and it's it's in very, very low denominations, right?

In terms of renting it, right? But if you actually went out and tried to get the one 51%, you'd be lucky if you could rent it all, okay. First, first of all, I think. Well, yeah, and in the in the paper, it says right here: note that the economic attack vector outlined above crucially assumes that any amount of hash power can be rented at short notice.

You know, and that would only have been a realistic possibility for a modest network of users, but not for Bitcoin. Right and says right there in the case. Well, so then why is it even why why is it even addressed as it you know as being you know as being a situation, right? So I mean it's brought up.

It doesn't it doesn't seem like it it justifies the title of a doomsday. Well that's the whole point. That's the whole point. Because if you sat there and you sat there and said, okay, we're gonna do this, you'd have to build out a plan, right? I mean, the other way that I've seen too, this is just from some other work on on a panel that I was on on a blockchain technology, was was a situation as to well, what would it really take?

Well, the other way to look at it is how much would it cost to buy all the all the equipment to be able to do the hash power piece of it without renting it, right? Yeah, and it's like three and a half billion dollars. Okay, so you start getting into all the components of this and you say, like, you know, wait a second, okay. Is someone is someone gonna put up three and a half billion dollars?

The other aspect of it too, and correct me if I'm wrong, but when you go to attack it, you have to do it all within ten minutes. Well, you and you well, you have to sustain it for longer than ten minutes, because if you did it for ten minutes, you might be able to rewrite one block, but then you know, if you give up the hash rate, then it's you're just gonna get rewritten by that's all that's my whole point is the block that you that you submitted to the network is basically gonna get dismissed, you know, right?

So right. So the point, yeah, so the Because it's gonna be it'll be seen by all the honest nodes that there's a double spin there and still get orphaned. Right. And so so if you so if you get in there to try to do it and you take eleven minutes, then you gotta go redo it. You know, in other words, you basically would have to do it in like a minute, right? You've got to you've got to say you've got to be able to sustain it for a long time.

Right. To really be able to basically take over Bitcoin. So not only do you have that, so the point is we got this article where where it's just from the standpoint of looking at the very root or the assumptions of this, right? You step back and go what what what's the story that I mean how did this be.

It doesn't even also doesn't even take into account that that Bitcoin, you know, the community could get together and hard fork to a different hashing algorithm. I mean, in the worst case scenario, right? You could just get rid of SHA 256 and move to a new hashing algorithm, and then you're basically rebuilding the mining industry at that point, and you know, the difficulty adjustment would happen.

And then what right I'm I'm done with we're done with this, right? For now. I mean, you know, and so so the so the idea the idea, and by the way, if it was actually if they actually made a legitimate shot at this, we would go ahead and give kudos for it, okay? But it doesn't look that way. The other the other thing that I don't like is where it it they they write Bitcoin has survived many attacks.

Making it sound like it didn't survive other attacks. It should be said Bitcoin has survived all attacks. They're all so it's just it's just you know, it's just I don't know. I'm I'm gonna stop. There's obviously some bias there, but yeah.

So well, I mean, the way I the way I'm talking about it the last 10 minutes, it's like I'm totally by, you know, I'm totally biased, but I'm taking the position against somebody that's basically saying that is already said that it's it's zero. Well, look, it it's not that we're not saying that this is not something to be concerned about, or not something that we should should not worthy of discussion.

Agree, or whatever, it's not a potential issue. It is a potential issue, and it has and is and has been discussed. Thanks for clarifying that. Yeah, that's good. It is it is being and has been discussed in Bitcoin for a long time. You know, how are we going to secure the network after all the bitcoins issued and the and the block reward goes away? It's been talked about since the very beginning.

And there are definit what this what papers like this and then articles that kind of you know attribute lots of authority to papers like this miss is that there are a lot of assumptions being made that you can't make yet. We just don't know, like you said. It it reminds me of when I was an engineer, I worked in the in the steel industry and Bethlehem Steel Corporation, which is long no longer, they used to make steel with integrated steel.

So they would make it with the iron ore. They still do that in some places, but the idea there was a newcomer called Nucor that had a new technological process where they could just pour the molten steel and convert it into coils before they had to go through a bunch of steps and all. And so at the time, it would be like Bethlehem Steel is like the Bank of International Settlements.

They actually had a report that they put together that said that that that was impossible and new core is new core's process would not work. Now newcore is like one of the it's a lot, you know, it it overtook everything in the in the US. And so my point is is that you have a situation where you have the technology on one side that that's that's moving moving along, going through, and they're just doing what what what they're doing.

So yeah, new core, and then this case is Bitcoin. Sure. And then you have then you have naysayers that are gonna tell you why it won't work, or it isn't gonna work. So anyway. That's what we call some FUD. That's what we call FUD. Alright, well, that is our function. Anyway, I had FUD Busting for the day. Brady, thanks for letting me throw that war story in about the about the steel company.

I like your old war story. I think it's relevant actually, though. I think it's relevant. All right, man. I think that's it for today. We will we'll be back with another episode in you know two, three weeks. That was fun. You got me fired up today. I usually don't get so fired up. We're still working on getting Tommy his lightning node, which I am hoping it sounds like he's gonna get done this week.

I've been working on mine at home, you know, connecting to some other nodes of the network and figuring out how it all works. Yeah, the whole key is getting the lightning node, but but then not having it just sit sit somewhere. Yeah, you gotta figure out how you can do it. Yeah, yeah, to use it, yeah. Yeah. Well, maybe I can do some stuff with you. Yeah. So we're gonna we're gonna continue working on that and we'll use it for some podcasting fodder in the future.

Alright, y'all. Take care. And thanks everybody. We'll talk to you next time. Bye-bye.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Tommy and Brady discuss bitcoin, lightning network and taxes and recent reports from the University of Cambridge Judge Business School and the Bank for International Settlements.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/citizenbitcoin

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast: https://citizenbitcoin.world

Citizen Bitcoin on Medium: https://medium.com/@citizenbitcoin

Links from the show:

How bitcoin is taxed in the United States: https://www.thebalance.com/how-bitcoins-are-taxed-3192871

Cambridge 2nd Global Cryptoasset Benchmarking Study: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3306125

Bank for International Settlements argues Bitcoin ‘is not sustainable without block rewards’: https://www.theblockcrypto.com/2019/01/22/bank-for-international-settlements-argues-bitcoin-is-not-sustainable-without-block-rewards/

Beyond the doomsday economics of “proof-of-work” in cryptocurrencies: https://www.bis.org/publ/work765.pdf

Definition of a 51% attack: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Majority_attack

Theoretical cost of a 51% attack on each network: https://www.crypto51.app/

Bitcoin post-issuance: an existential threat: https://www.theblockcrypto.com/2019/01/24/bitcoin-post-issuance-an-existential-threat/

Nic Carter thread on fee market and block size limit: https://twitter.com/nic__carter/status/1087698624426004480

Downloads