Justin Moon: Hardware Wallets, Private Keys, Bitcoin Education
Justin Moon joins me to discuss hobbyist hardware wallets and securing your private keys in general. We also get into Justin’s work as a bitcoin educator with Mooniversity and Buidl Bootcamp, and the broader future of bitcoin education.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin and we're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? What is up? Hope you're all well. Thanks to those of you who have taken a minute to rate and review the podcast recently.
It's helping a lot with discovery on various platforms. If you've been around a while but haven't rated Pod yet on Apple Podcasts, please take a moment to do so if you're not using Apple Podcasts and your podcast doesn't have a way to rate or review us. Sharing the episode on Bitcoin Twitter and letting us know what you think about a particular episode or the podcast in general is a great way to give back.
Appreciate you all. Alright, so I've got an episode with Justed Moon for you today. Justin is a Bitcoin educator. He runs Moonaversity, a great intro for non-technical Bitcoiners to understanding how Bitcoin works and how to interact with the system via the command line and code.
And Justin also runs Buidl Bootcamp, a more intensive course that dives deeper into coding with the Bitcoin system.
In this episode, we discussed hobbyist hardware wallets, securing your private keys in general. We get into Justin's work as a Bitcoin educator and the future of Bitcoin education. For Justin's rabbit hole story and background, check out TFTC episode 46, Tales from the Crypt episode 46.
And Stephan Livera also did an episode with Justin about the early days of Buidl Bootcamp. That's SLP 36. So check those out as compliments to this episode if you want to hear more from justin
Alright.
Here we go.
All right, hey, Justin, welcome to Citizen Bitcoin. How's it going, man?
Pretty good. Pretty good. It's a hot, sunny day here in Austin, Texas. But I'm ready to talk some Bitcoin. Oh yeah, that July August heat is heat wave is about to hit hit Texas. Yeah, it's been raining though. I think it rained this morning. Which helps. Nice. Drops the degree, dread off the temperature a degree or two, but not much more.
So before we started recording, you were telling me that you had a pretty crazy weekend in in the heat of Texas. Let's get into it, man. Let's let's let's tell the listeners about what you've been brewing up this past week and what's got you all excited. Yeah, so one of my friends probably my first Bitcoin friend. I went to a conference like two a year ago, exactly a year ago, and my was the went to a hackathon, the hackathon was before the conference, and you know, sit down at the hackathon, and of course everyone at hackathon is super introverted, they're all programmers, so they're all sitting there buying themselves, and so I just start going around asking everybody what they're working
On, and all of a sudden there's this tall Russian guy with a big smile. He's got this big box of like gear, all these little mini computers. I wasn't I hadn't worked with them, like Arduinos and stuff. Asked him, he's like, Oh, I'm I'm gonna build a lightning hardware wallet. At you know, in the hackathon. I'm like, okay, I'm working with you.
Because everyone else's ideas were like boring web apps and stuff. And then we ended up recruiting like probably 20% of the hackathon. We ended up having like 14 people on our team, and that was great. And we you know over two days we hacked C Lightning.
We just like modified one file in C Lightning and made a Arduino board that could sign like channel routing requests and like invoice payments. And so it was kind of a lightning hardware wallet. It was more like a like we were joking the over the weekend, it was more like a lightning button.
It wasn't like a complete hardware wallet because it's you know the keys are just sitting there in plain text on the Arduino itself. But like strictly speaking, it was probably more secure than using C Lightning on your host machine. So that was kind of cool. And you know, we've been in touch over the past year, but he he was in coming to the US for for the Bitcoin 2019 conference.
He just did like seven talks in different places over the last month. Because he has no he now has a hardware wallet company called Crypto Advance, and they're doing some really interesting stuff. And he decided to stop by Austin to visit my meetup and do a two-day hardware wallet hackathon like workshop. So the first day, you know, he's basically giving us a brain dump of everything he learned about hardware wallets, and then the second day we sat down and we made a little hardware wallet using Arduino and everything.
And then and that was I mean that was great. We had like maybe 10 people for the probably like 25 people for the first day, 10 people for the second. So pretty good showing. It's still amazing that still amazing that more people don't show up for these things, more people don't find it interesting. But I mean it's plenty. And yeah, so just another indicator of how it's like.
Yeah, you go to like Big City, and it's like I mean, every time I'm at Bitdevs, I'm like, how is it that in New York City? It's like, how is it that in a city of 15 million people, there's only like a hundred that care about this stuff? It's just unreal to me. You know, and especially like there's you know, there's just legions of banking programmers and high frequency trading programmers and like brilliant technical people all over you know New York City and Austin as well.
You know, we have the University of Texas and a bunch of bunch of companies here, and for some reason they're all you know, none of them care. So it's it's you know, a very small percentage. So that's always like, yeah, that's kind of a reminder because sometimes you feel like you're you know you missed the miss the vote or something.
But I don't I don't think that's true. Great, you know. Well, I always out at Bitcoin 2019, and that definitely made Bitcoin feel small to me. And that was my first Bitcoin conference. I you know, to me, my Bitcoin experience has been completely online. I've gotten to know a lot of people through Twitter and Discord and you know, just Telegram and all that stuff, chatting with with Bitcoiners.
But when you know, most of the people that you've learned from over the internet over the over a couple a few years are all in one place, it definitely makes Bitcoin feel really early handy. Yeah, I know. I agree. And so so then yesterday Stepan and I, or I guess the day before we had a talk with a friend who had some really good ideas.
He's it's like hard really understands cold storage well, and all the different trade-offs. And so, you know, then yesterday we sat down at the library and we were we were hacking on a pretty interesting idea. So the idea is like you could make these little hardware wallets. So like one of them, if you want to Google it, if you're listening, you can Google the M5 stack.
It's this little little computer that you can get for like 25 bucks. It has a tiny screen, about an inch and a half by an by an inch, and three little buttons on it and a really nice little case. And you can this is what we may be used at the hackathon, but you can buy these like extension boards for it where you just plug it in and you can get like basically like a game boy looking keyboard.
So this looks like a little mini game boy. That's cool. I'm looking at it right now. And yeah, you can m5 stack.com. Yeah, right. You could pretty easily turn this into a cold card, like very similar to what a cold card does. Like you could just put that keyboard on there and build a firmware that is basically a cold card and you know, have this like be an open source hardware wallet.
And of course, like the you know, there's no like secure element. It's if if a hacker got physical access to the vice, the device they're gonna get your key. But I mean, I think that's basic, that's almost always true. If the if the hacker gets physical access to your your device, they're gonna get your key. But yeah, that's even true for like Trezor and Legends.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. I mean, they're always like sh firing back and forth at each other, you know, like you know, publishing their exploits, but it's like the exploit is always like if you get physical access to the vice, I can get your key off it. And it's like that's sort of not news anymore, you know. You should you should I mean you should maybe just embrace that fact.
And that makes like these sort of like like open source commodity hardware things a little a little more appealing because like you know, one of the big things is like a supply channel attack, like some somebody implanting some you know, like fiddling with the device, you know, to you know, modifying it with like modifying the firmware or you know, some of these things you can verify yourself, or like putting a little you know, a little Wi-Fi chip in there that just like broadcasts out all the some of the state to some you know somewhere else to presumably you know steal your keys that way.
On like a commodity hardware thing, it's like they're they're not gonna know this is gonna be used for Bitcoin, like they know it's gonna be used for Bitcoin with a Trezor or a ledger, or the you know, maybe the microcontrollers that they use, they're not gonna have any idea what it's what it'll be used for. So I think that that it kind of mitigates that class of attacks where you know, so you know, when it's being shipped to you or in the factory, it's it's you know, some bad actor modifies it somewhere.
And if you use it in combination with with some of these more developed, more you know, like more sophisticated hardware wallets like a Trezor or Ledger, I think it improves your security because it's just like it's like genetic diversity.
You know, you have this like this thing that is engineered and you know sold two million units and they got a big team, and then you have this other thing that it's like a tiny little open source thing, nobody knows about it. It's like they're they're just they're two very different like if somebody's gotta hack both of those to get your coins.
I think I think that's probably better than having to hack a Trezor and a ledger. Because it's like that's kind of doing the same thing twice. Whereas with this thing, they might have, you know, the evil maid might be in your house and she might not even know which one's your hardware wallet, you know. It's like or heat, yeah, yeah. And underlying all this, of course, is like you're mentioning, like, is is multi-sig, you know, should be used in combination with hardware wallets.
So it's it's like yeah, putting all of these things together and then diversifying the hardware you're using with along with multi-sig is you know the way to is probably the best way to go for most people. Yeah, so that's what we were trying to so I think the second piece to this, you know, like so the idea. So one of these things would be like a little cold card. The other one we'd want to do is if you also Google the M5 stick, the M5 stick costs five dollars.
It has a tiny little case that only has one button. But you there's a new one called the M5 Stick C or something that has two buttons and a little color screen. But it also like it it has like Bluetooth actually. So you can you can like send transactions to it from your phone, which is insane.
So this would be this is this is basically like a ledger. So you could build like a five dollar ledger, you know. So you get like three of five multisig on just these for 25 bucks, which is really really cool. Wow. So that would be another cool one. And another idea we had I had was like you could, you know, try to just get the microcontroller Trezor uses and just make a you know, Trezor's firmware is all open source, unlike ledger.
So you can just, you know, make a Trezor, get the get the screen they use, get the thing they use, and you know, make the hacky little case, and you got your little open source treasure. You know, and it's like so these that that one would just be kind of a troll. But the two with oh, and then there's the more advanced one, so that Stepan built.
He has it it's it costs about I think it costs like maybe 150 bucks total. It has like a really nice screen. It's I think the iPhone, it's a STM microcontroller using the iPhone 4 screen. And then he also has a QR code scanner on it. So it's a big screen and it has a QR code scanner.
So you can do this amazing, and this is kind of what he's prototyping for his product at Crypto Advanced. You can do this amazing you know, air gap with your, you know, let's say your machine running Electrum or Bitcoin Core, where you just like you know, to prepare the transaction, you do it in Bitcoin Core, you create a create a PP P PTSB or P PSBT, sorry.
It's early PSBT. And then you scan, you know, you prepare that as a QR code and scan it with your hardware wallets. You just like wave your hardware wallet in front of your computer. And then on the hardware wallet, you sign it, and then the hardware wallet displays a QR code and you just like wave it at your webcam again, and then it's like loaded back onto your your you know machine with Bitcoin Core or Electrum.
And that's like a true air gap, doesn't really exist. And you know, there are some reasons. Like I learned this weekend at the hackathon. I guess the Stuxnet virus that was implanted in Iranian nuclear facilities was actually was actually implanted using USB drives.
So USB, you know, if people wonder if like you know you can totally trust the USB connection to your Trezor. It's like I want to learn a little more about this, but I guess that that's what happened is they had these USB drives, and the like NSA just thought that well, if if we you know stick this exploit in you know a million USB drives, about one of those will reach Iran nuclear facilities.
And so that was like how they implanted it, according to one of my friends at that that was that was at my meetup. So you know, there's a Bitcoin meetup. Yeah, there're a female article about it. Yeah. Yeah, I gotta I gotta Google it. I mean, I just heard about it a few days ago. But I'm really curious about that.
And I think yeah, I'm I'm really curious about that. And you know, so so like the air gap makes a lot of sense. Another thing we were talking about is like an audio cable. So like if the little the on the little M5 stick or the stack would be really cool if we could just use send an audio cable because it's it's the data transmission there, excuse me, is a little is a little simpler.
So but but the QR code's like the holy grail. So if you could get like a you know the what he has now is like 150 bucks if you want to put together yourself. That would be pretty cool, you know, have a you know multi-sig between a few of these devices and you could also you know add in treasures or ledgers, and I think it's I think it's better than just using like a treasure and a ledger.
As long as it's as long as it's like a open source, heavily peer reviewed project and a commodity piece of hardware that has been used for you know a million different things, so you can trust that you know the code that is used on the firmware itself is good because there's a lot of people looking at it.
And there's a lot of people modding it and you know, playing with it and trying to break it. And there's you know the fur the hardware is good because it's you know been used for a thousand projects. So this is kind of like the idea. We want to start playing around with this stuff and you know, try to get a little platform going.
And you know, one of the other things is you need some like software assistance when you're you know doing some of this some of this multi-sig setup so we were trying to just create like a simple web server that could run and you know do the relevant you just click a couple buttons and it'd do the relevant like command line things for to like prepare PSPTs and you know to watch the addresses you have that sort of thing and you know prepare transactions so just be like a little GUI for multi-sig using sort of these wallets and
You know maybe if we did the audio cable it would know how to talk over an audio cable. If we did the QR code it'd have a QR code scanner. So that that would be kind of the that's like a thing we're I think we're gonna try to work on because I've been I've been fiddling with these hardware wallets for maybe a year now here and there but I've never really made one that's usable like like a setup that I would actually use with real money.
So that's kind of the goal. That's really cool man. I love this emerging hobbyist hardware wallet scene. It's pretty fun. Yeah it's fun. I mean it'd be cool if you can get hardware wallet companies out of it too. Like I mean one of the yeah I mean like like a real you know it'd be fun like I've I've heard some talk or I'm I don't forget where it was maybe it was like maybe it was like slush or something like the guy from Slushpool was talking about how you could have like you know someday you could have like you know a bunch of these like these pools would get together they get big enough where they could just like sort
Of begin to like have some sort of a communal like a forge where they could put together or where they could make new what do you call the ASICs, right? Or you know, whatever's being used, and you know, just sort of like start to you know manufacture in almost like a communal way, like you know, the community gets rich enough so it can afford to like you know get some of these bigger resources.
And I don't know anything about mining, so maybe maybe I'm imagining it, but the idea is kind of interesting. I think you get a similar thing with like hardware wallets, you know. If you could have, you know, if they get big if we get big enough, you could start to have these like group efforts where you can create like a really secure like a secure element where you really actually can't get the key off it, you know.
And this could just be like a piece that goes into many different hardware wallets, and it could go into hobbyist projects, it could go into real ones, and ideally as much of it could be open source as possible. So it's really like a you know a community thing. I think so, like I think that could be pretty interesting, you know. But you know, I bet the price has to go up a fair amount before that's like cost effective.
But that's kind of a thing to dream for. Like I think the I think the hard hard the hobbyist hardware hobbyist thing is has legs, and I hope it continues. You've seen it have a big impact on the full nodes. Yeah, exactly. I was yeah, the hobbyists have made the full nodes way easier, right? Like you think about it, you know, Pierre Richard dedicating like a couple months of his life to build this you know, free project, node launcher.
I use it. It's great. You think Grasp by Blitz, that's one of my students is one of the maintainers of that. You know, they've probably put, you know, conservatively 500 nodes in the network, maybe a thousand. Like there, I think they're yeah, they're they're they're like Telegram help channel has a few hundred people on it, I think.
So, or maybe a hundred. So it's you know, they've put a quite quite a few nodes on the network. You know, the staticus with his guides and you see like the cool thing about hobbyists is like if you if you contribute to one of these things you can evolve to like a paid position and that's what Staticus has done and I think my my friend who's who's who's working on Raspberlit will probably do the same thing here pretty soon because like you know there's a cool thing is when you when you get to the point of interviewing like there's a lot a lot of the applicants to these jobs like don't have an open source footprint and it's you know if you have that it's
It's really compelling you know because like the people that run these Bitcoin companies are are huge open source advocates so like they see a Harvard CS degree and they nod their head and they see like you know a ton of commits to like an interesting like leading edge Bitcoin project and they drool you know like it's it's it's they're a lot more impressed by that than the Harvard degree I think so it's a higher quality proof of work it's it has proof of work yeah and it's more relevant and it's I mean it's also proof of I mean proof of like I don't know what you want to call it but like sort of
What what your motivate like what what your motivations are you know like if you're gonna go and do something for free it means you really care about that thing and you know if you refuse to if you if you don't do something for free it might mean you don't care about it so you know the lack of an open source footprint so so yeah that's I think that's a this hardware, this this hobbyist thing is is really great.
And it's it's it's cool to see it extend from software to hardware. But I think you know if you think about which is which is more important, like the hobbyist or like you know, the you know running a full node or having your own private keys, like in my view, the private key is a hundred times more important, right?
Like I mean really once you once you receive coins, and it's like if you go and check on like 10 different like block explorers and ask your friend who runs a full node, like if your transaction shows up, it's like you can pretty you can be pretty sure that you know, even though you don't have your own source of consensus or you don't have your own like node of consensus that it made it in.
And like I think you can get by without having your full node if you're I mean it's obviously better if you have one, but you don't have your private keys, it's like you have an IOU. You don't you like you don't own Bitcoin? So that's I think that's way more important and making some of these little simple ways to you know, like it's it's hard, like what you know, you have a new friend get into Bitcoin, right?
And they say, okay, I want to own my private keys, how do I do it? Like, what do you say? Yeah, I usually tell people to get a ledger or something. Yeah, but that sucks, they're expensive, right? Yeah, they are. They're you know 70 75 bucks or something like that, usually, right? Or you can usually you can find them for 50. But yeah, they're pretty expensive.
But I mean this kind of models. I'm working is 150, 160 bucks. Like Yeah, okay. Yeah, the newer ones for sure. Yeah, and these well, the ones that I you know, I got the thing. They're giving them away at at or ledger nano S's at Bitcoin 2019. But I think wasn't there I don't know, some security vulnerability that was that was revealed in the past couple of weeks.
I think there's all kinds of problems with the old treasures like they or the old ledgers. Like we were talking about on at the hackathon. We didn't actually download some of Tabana's saying how like they don't display the I forget exactly what the problem was, but when you're doing multi-sig, they don't display the like output address or something.
So it's like they don't they don't display the right address, partially because the screen is so damn small, and so you really don't know where you're sending your coins if you're doing multi-sig. As far as like the I might I might be getting it slightly wrong because I didn't see a demo, but like that was one of the things he was really concerned about. And I mean these like at the breaking bitcoin conference in Amsterdam a couple weeks ago, they you know, the ledger guys did a big old kind of self-indulgent hack reveal where they were talking about some hack on the Trezor fur some hack of the Trezor that allowed you to like get all the coins in a couple minutes, and it was unfixable.
And so they they weren't they didn't say exactly what it was, but it's like it's kind of weird. It's like every conference ledger gets up there and like you know, produces some like hack of Trezor and you know pats himself on the back. And they also they also like they they found some like free Android wallet or like some Android wallet no one had ever heard of.
And like at the biggest security conference of the year, they like reveal they can hack it, like oh impressive, you know, like what the fuck? That's it's kind of it's kind of weird. But but yeah, I mean we like the I mean Trezor to Treasure One's $75. But they're they're kind of expensive, right? Like if if my buddy's got a thousand dollars on Bitcoin or something, like you can't spend a hundred or seventy-five bucks on Trezor One.
Well it exactly. And I would I mean, I would suggest like if somebody had a decent amount of money or you know, quite a few thousands of dollars at least I would recommend like a Casa multi-sig solution or something like that. Some some comparable thing. But yeah that's all that's even more expensive and that's an annual payment. So yeah if it's somebody who's just getting into Bitcoin then you know to me the initial answer is always just gonna be like get a ledger or a treasure.
Yeah it's a little expensive. So like I mean that would be that would be the cool thing is if you could if you could you know what I would like to be able to do is my friend gets some Bitcoin right I'm like okay you see this little M5 stick you know like I'm gonna put your thousand bucks on this thing and just don't lose it just like put it somewhere safe or I mean maybe at that point like a paper wallet might mail do like a you know one of two multi-sig with a paper wallet in this something like that like that would be kind of interesting so it's like if you want to spend it you can plug in your hardware device and you know a little UI shows up and you can
You know spend it you can have like a backup and or I guess you just you don't you don't need multi-sig you could just do you know just have the seed words and store it somewhere but I think that would be I mean that would be a little more because it's like one of the hard yeah one of the hard things is like all of our you know all of our our recommendations are not really they're they're for people who have like thousands of dollars in it but as as you onboard like new people like most people are not gonna put a thousand dollars they're gonna put 20 in you know it's like stacking sats right the stacking stats meme is great but there's not really like there's not really a it feels like there's we're
Missing a decent offline way of or we could improve the ways that these people who are stacking SAT for the first time store their keys. So that's that's just kind of the idea here. It's like it'd be cool to find something else there. I mean I guess a lot of them probably could you know maybe recommend Electrum, but the tricky thing about that is that you're just the privacy is terrible.
Maybe it's a hot wall or like a wallet on your phone. I don't know. I don't know the answer. Yeah. I and I think that this hobbyist hardware wallet kind of scene that's developing will probably help out with that. Like you said, there's gonna be some businesses that emerge, there'll be competitors to Ledger and Trezor that are offering like, you know, more budget alternatives, lower entry point cost entry.
And you know, you could see something like like a some kind of stacking sats app like an Amber or a Cash App be like, all right, you know, put on your your weekly, you know, dollar cost averaging purchase of ten dollars. Once you get to a hundred dollars, or once you get to fifty dollars or whatever, we're gonna send you in the mail this, you know, you know, five or ten dollar hardware wallet, and you can withdraw for that, you know, and then kind of just get people going.
And then once the value of their Bitcoin goes up, then they can start looking at the you know, the more robust solutions. Yeah, that's actually an interesting idea. I mean, the one what we're saying is a different amount, like depending on how much you've bought, basically, how much you have, you're you know, how much security you're interested in buying really changes.
And the only people that really know how much you've bought are the exchanges, right? Well, you know, assuming chain analysis doesn't know. But you know, that's I mean it'd be interesting, like that would be cool if they would sort of like, you know, like that's the beautiful thing about Cash App is that it's so simple to begin, you know, and it's like they don't even tell you about on-chain fees, they just pay them.
You know, they just keep it so simple. And that's great. And as you advance, you're gonna want to know a little more. And so it'd be cool if they could sort of like, okay, you know, once you, you know, you've now bought a thousand bucks or 500 bucks or 200 bucks, whatever. You know, you want to learn about how to, you know, a couple options to store these keys yourself.
That would be that would be cool. I mean, I guess a lot of these companies probably a lot of the exchanges probably don't want you withdrawing, honestly. Because I've had a lot of them have designs on fractional reserving in the future. So they want to be customing as many Bitcoin as they can. But yeah, they might, but I think that there's gonna be, you know, if you if we do our job as educators, you know, and we teach people about not your keys, not your coins, and all that stuff.
I think that there's definitely going to be a place for Bitcoin company to provide dollar cost averaging into Bitcoin, provide education about what the hell it is you're buying, and provide you know security solutions so that you can hold your own keys. And like if a company would do that, like a cash app would do that, I think they'd earn a ton of trust and you know, just like admiration from the Bitcoin community, and then that in turn gets them, you know, basically organic marketing, because all of the you know, Bitcoiners who are doing education about what Bitcoin really is and how to, you know, be a sovereign, you know, citizen of Bitcoin, will promote their services,
You know, and just drive traffic their way. Yeah. Yeah, man. So that's this is this is an interesting thing. I think it's what I like, you know, it's so I've been in Bitcoin a year now, and I know you know, I think I understand it now. Like I've been careful to like not really participate in governance until I feel like I actually understand it, you know.
Because there's that there's that meme, you know, I just learned about Bitcoin. I'm here to save it. Try not to be that guy, you know, try not to be that guy. But so I think I find I got my head wrapped around it. So it's like, where do you, you know, it's like, and I bet a lot of your listeners are the same way. It's like, you know, spend some time, understand. So like, you know, if you if you want to, you can't contribute everywhere. Where do you want to contribute? I'm I realized I was good at teaching.
So like I'd never taught anything before. So like teaching is one way I can help. But you know, you're teaching, you really want to be a practitioner too. Like you really want to try to contribute individually. And so I'm I'm you know, so it makes you a little more credible as a teacher.
So I'm trying to figure out some of the places to like contribute to the ecosystem. And I, you know, this you know, you circle around lightning, but to be honest, like I don't find lightning as interesting as everybody else does. It's like I don't think the end, like it's it's it's a it's it's a new payments thing. And it, yeah, it's you can scale the network, which is really important, but like the thing I really find interesting is like this self-sovereign, like monetary thing that you can stick on a Raspberry Pi or on a little Arduino, you know, like you can you can replace banking as it is basically on one, you know, with
This just a little bit of software and you know, very little hardware requirements to run it. It's like the to me the interesting side is really like the private keys and the peer-to-peer network, you know, like this this robust network that like you know, maybe or maybe not, maybe we it it may be or may not be attackable by like a nation state.
Like if you want it, like there are some papers discussing how you could you know, like what it would take to like grind the peer-to-peer network to a halt. So yeah, I think this is the kind of stuff I want to work on. You know, like really securing the base layer and allowing other people to you know to operate securely on the base layer rather than maybe some of the like application type stuff that's above.
So this is kind of the direction I think I'm heading. That's awesome, man. I think it's a really important direction to go in. And if that's what you're interested in, yeah, there's gonna be plenty of work to be done. Because you know it's that's that's the basics, right? That's the that's the fundamentals. So you've if you if we can't get Bitcoiners to use this stuff safely and securely, then you know, there's what's the what's the point?
So that's kind of like the table stakes to get into the game, and I think it's really important. Yeah, I think I think one of the interesting things, like one of the cool things about the hobbyist walls is it can kind of make like private key management when you think about private key management for first principles, it's about the least fun, scariest thing on the planet, you know.
Yeah, yeah, right. Like private key management's not fun. It's like it's like yeah, it's like chewing glass as Elon Musk says. It's like it's just so scary. Like staring into the abyss. It's like so scary. There's so many ways to screw it up. One little idea of controlling your own funds and not having some kind of corporate middleman there to sort of like call and be like, oh, where's my money?
Find my money. It's your remote it's your responsibility, figure it out. Yeah, so somebody got on my Wi-Fi network and all my money's gone. What do I do? You know, like personal responsibility is stressful, but it's also a good thing. Yeah, so so I like the I like this idea of the hobbyist stuff. And I mean, that's what I try to encourage in my classes, like, hey guys, you know, like because many of the people who sign up for my class aren't super sophisticated programmers, right?
And so what I what I do is like I don't like I always struggle. Should I promise, you know, should I try to say that I'll help you get a job? And I think with a lot of them, it's gonna be hard to find a Bitcoin job just because it's like, well, well, it's beginning better now, but in the bear market, it's like nope, people are firing employees, they're not adding employees.
So it's like you can't really, you know, so even if you're really good, you might not be able to get a job. That's changing now. That's changing. Like I now I'm starting to do these like monthly like jobs threads, like a post about everyone who's hiring. And you can see there's it's it's growing. So that's that's cool. So, but but still it's like, you know, almost by definition, anybody who works on Bitcoin technically is underemployed, you know, in an economic sense.
They could be making more money if they went to work for a bank. You know, every one of these Bitcoin programs you know, if they went to work at well or at Chase Bank, their salary would like triple, you know, because it's just like their skills are more well put you can get paid more.
It's kind of like game development, right? Like everyone wants to be a game programmer, so game programmers are aren't paid very well. So similarly, like many people want to be a Bitcoin programmer, Bitcoin programmers aren't paid so well. So it's kind of tough, but I think the real value to learning these skills isn't necessarily your ability to go get a job, it's your ability to like operate intelligently in a new economy that you're going to exist in for the rest of your life if if we're right, right?
If we're right, you're gonna need to learn to operate here. And like, I mean, I there's a guy, you know, a well-known person on Twitter who's who comes from a finance background, who's messaging me the other day on on Twitter, and like you know, he's a really bright guy, really bright guy. But he's not very technical. And you know, he's trying to understand the differences between like PIP 32 and BIP 39.
And someone was scaring him about so BIP 32 is like a hierarchical deterministic wallet, meaning like, you know, it's hierarchy deterministic means you can have one private key and generate many of them, and it'll always be the same. Deterministic means it'll be the same, right? And so hierarchical means like you can do that, but you can actually have a tree, right?
So you can get like a deterministic wallet by just hashing your private key, maybe some you know, add in something else. Or yeah, you can just do it by hashing the private key. And so that means you could get like a million private keys from just one base one, but it's just like a chain, right? And so hierarchical deterministic means like you can have one private key, but you can sort of like hash them with some extra information and you can get like this tree structure, and that's what with a wallet that many of us use.
And then there's BIP 39, which is like seed words, right? So instead of having to deal with like a private key itself, you get to deal with these seed words, which you can memorize. And so he's trying to, you know, explain the trade, understand the trade-offs and the security, and it's like, man, that's really hard if you don't like learn a little programming.
And if you don't you know, like it's almost not understandable the differences in the security trade-offs. If you don't like mess a little, you know, mess around with like you know, trying to, you know, learning a little bit about hash functions, learning a little bit about randomness, learning a little bit about all these different topics that are involved.
It's it's hard to make a decision on your own, right? And like the person I'm talking to, I'm sure, you know, like I didn't suggest it because I know you wouldn't want to, but you could say, you know, you could get some help for this. But it's like, no, I want to custody them myself. Like, I don't want to be using, like, I want to understand what I'm doing. But you know, like, how are you gonna do that if you don't learn some?
So that's that's like you know, it's that's been a personal struggle of mine as I teach this class. It's like it's really I'm observing it's very hard to like it's very hard to get jobs in the space. Like, why are people still taking my class? And I think the real benefit is is that you know, you can secure your own wealth and you can operate in this economy, you can begin to contribute you know, really contribute in your spare time.
And I think once we hit a bull market, like in a year or two, I think a lot of my students will get really, really interesting jobs. Like when, you know, when all of a sudden it it opens up again, like I think they'll all be in great shape. But maybe for the next six months, you know, it's gonna be hard because no one's hiring, right? No one's hiring. Or you know, relatively speaking, it's like I can do this Bitcoin jobs thread, right?
And I can go through and post every Bitcoin job. And like the if you look in the comments, like right, like the tweets are like all 200,000 impressions or something. Like so, like every everyone in Bitcoin saw that tweet. Or everyone on Bitcoin Twitter, yeah, not everyone in Bitcoin, probably 5% or 10% of the people that are in Bitcoin, so to speak, because like most of them aren't aren't on Twitter, but like the ones who are employers are, and like there wasn't much, I forgot Bitstamp, right?
Which is you know, at least they do bit Bitcoin stuff. A lot of it isn't Bitcoin, but you know, the third Bitcoin jobs there. I forgot like Vol Bitcoin in Canada. Like I forgot like two or three, but it's like wow, I can fit them all in one tweet thread, you know. It's like everyone, everyone is trying to get me to like make a job board in the comments section. It's like, no, the whole point is that there aren't enough jobs for a job board, you know.
Like you have to make a shitcoin job board if you want to make any money on it. You don't need that yet. So like it's it's yeah, it's it's still such a niche thing. But I got I got faith that it's it's gonna grow. And I think so, yeah, I think now is like a good time to I know that some of the people that invested in you know took some time in the bear market to learn and to get skilled up, you know, and they're now I got like the two people who've interviewed with Lightning Labs recently.
Like I got you know, one of them just got a job with Gotana. There's a lot of them that are just starting to get you know, opportunities, and most of them weren't programmers before. So so yeah, it's I think that it's like if you learn these skills, it's it's gonna really pay off in the future. Yeah, I agree completely.
And I and I'm seeing a same parallel, a parallel along with Bitcoin development. Just this kind of more general, broader Bitcoin education kind of industry starting to be born now. And it's gonna it's gonna be more than just educating developers, it's certainly gonna be a big part of it. But it's also, you know, educating corporations, educating hodlers, you know, just about how to hold your private keys or you know, the various options, right?
Just basically what this thing, the thing that we've all done in this, you know, just kind of haphazard organic way, trying to figure out what the hell is going on here, is starting to be a bit more organized and formalized, and I think we'll eventually be presented as, you know, here is you know, one or two month kind of like of your time, maybe 10 minutes a day is all we're asking, and we'll ramp you up, you know, what took us a year and a half to kind of figure out and put together.
We've sort of distilled down and we'll ramp you up to understanding what's happening here so that you feel comfortable holding your own private keys and understand the basics of how the system works and the basics of like the future that we're heading into right now and what's happening. I think the demand will be there for all kinds of you know that range of Bitcoin education in this next bull run.
And we're gonna kind of start to see some businesses that are dedicated to Bitcoin education, such as your own. Yeah, I think it's it's really interesting. I know that you've done obviously you have Buidl Bootcamp. That was kind of your first foray into Bitcoin education. You recently launched Mooniversity, which I signed up for that.
Gone through the first few lessons on the city. Yeah, you and Stefan's and there's Stefano's. I went through the first time.
Stephan Livera was the first one across the finish line. I still am preparing a shitpost aimed at
You know, Peter McCormack, Marty Bent, a few of these other ones, and I'm gonna say, hey, Citizen Bitcoin Stephan Livera made it across the finish line. You guys are about to attain a level of podcasting, you know, unseen until now. You guys better get in on the end. Yeah, man. Get up there.
Yeah, Matt. Get in there, get in there. Yeah. Where are you guys at? Pomp, get in here. Pop needs to be in there. So yeah, Mooniverity, we'll talk about we'll talk about that too. And also you've done some corporate consulting and education. So can you just give us kind of the rundown of your three sort of education, I guess, businesses that you've got going now?
Yeah, well, first off, I want to say like I had this sort of the MIT Bitcoin com conference a couple months ago, and I like we were doing a panel and I said something interesting. I hadn't like sometimes when people like interview you say interesting things you didn't know you knew. So like I said there's one interesting thing that I remember that was so it's like in the event that Bitcoin moons, like let's say it goes to a it to it it becomes a reserve currency or it becomes the gold in the minimum case.
Give it if it if it really succeeds. I think that one of the questions is like, why did it take so long? Right? Why like at minimum that's gonna take another 10 years probably? You know, it it's probably gonna take another 10 years to get there. So why did it take 20 years for that to happen?
And I mean I think I think part of the answer is just like people didn't understand it, you know. Like I look at myself and it's like I think at any point, like if you had given me like the Bitcoin standard, for example, or or like locked me in a room with mastering Bitcoin or any of these like things that we view as good now, you know, like in the future we'll hopefully have better better options than anything that exists now, like my bootcamp included, like these will all look kind of crappy, hopefully, as we learn to explain it more.
But if like if you locked me or you or in one of these rooms in 2009, we probably would have understood it right there and like moved in heavily. Like, you know, like really pursued it. Maybe 2009 is a little early, but you know, like you know, once it once it had like was worth a dollar, once we people are actually starting to use it, like if you'd like given these explanations to people, I think many would understand it, but I think many never got the explanation and still haven't got the explanation.
Like it was only like last year when I got an explanation of Bitcoin that made any sense at all. You know, and I've been hearing about it for five years. So so like that's that's kind of the one of my big points is like, you know, I think that that's why I work on education is like I think that's the thing that speeds up.
It's just like that's the reason. If it if it take if it happens, the reason it took so long is because we just couldn't explain it. And it took forever for sophisticated people to understand why this was was going to win. So so yeah, that's why I just think that you know you need you need a lot more of this education stuff.
And I think I think you're right. And I think the other part of it is people just kind of need the proof, right? Like they need to see it. They need they need to see it working over a certain period of time, which is why the Lindy effect is a thing for people. We just and when you know money is is a lot about trust. We have to be able to trust that you know there's going to be value in this thing in the future so that we can you know trade our you know stored value now in the future for something that we're gonna need.
And it, you know, so that element of like you got to show me that this thing is actually working over a long period of time and is is trustworthy, you know. So we may have been able to like read the Bitcoin standard in 2011, but a lot of us would still would have been like, ah, this thing's only two years old, dude. Like, I don't know, you know, like I'm not gonna put a bunch of money into it. Exactly. But you put some in. So yeah, I think I think you're right.
And as it goes, like I think 20 years. Well, if you look at it another way, 20 years is a very short amount. It's like maybe I'm completely wrong. 20 years is a very short amount of time to monetize an asset, right? Especially something that's never been monitored. It is pretty friggin' quick, like bits spread across all compute, like you know, across a hundred thousand computers in the world, like it's actually maybe it's too fast.
Who knows? Seems slow to me though. And you look at like just the power. Yeah, well, to me too. And but you look at the power of the network effects of the US dollar right now. You know, and like the all of that like just has that the momentum has to be slowed, you know, as well. So it's like it's not just Bitcoin sort of pushing forward itself, but it's also having to switch the momentum.
So yeah, I mean I think these guys got it covered. Just keep these interest rates as low as possible. It's at the top of like yeah you know negative interest rates the first decade where there's no recession in like a century or something. Let's just keep interest let's try to get interest rates to zero.
You know it's just yeah just just six and it'll be fine. It'll be fine. Oh my God. It's it's I mean if you look at it if you look at it you think about it that way like fiat money system is the big experiment. It's not Bitcoin.
Bitcoin is actually you know a tried and true monetary policy that's built on top of the internet is it's like basically gold. I mean it's like maybe you could argue gold has a small inflation and Bitcoin doesn't and you know you have to have the electricity on for example it's like there's there's there are recur there's like a recurring cost to operating the network that has to be paid it's like a little bit different economically but you know largely it's pretty similar the implementation as like a distributed peer-to-peer network is highly experimental might fail who knows but like just the basic economics I think are pretty similar to gold and yeah you're right like fiat money never been tried before and
You know, I mean it's it's it's tough when you're like talking to a normal person about this. It's like, well, how do you explain that the last century was like a bit of a you know we weren't really wrong a hundred years ago? Like how do you explain that? Because like the world's a lot better than it was a hundred years ago. Right?
Like the world's a lot better than it was 10 years ago or 20 years ago. Like how would that how would that happen? How could how could that happen if we'd caught something so wrong at such a fundamental level? And I think that's one of the tough things that you know some people have. It's a difficulty people have when they encounter this, is like it just it questions assumptions that are kind of deep, but it seems to conflict a little bit with their lived experience.
Yeah, you know, and fiat money that like this stuff can work on a short-term basis. Like, you know, and when I mean when I say short term, I mean like you know, decades. It can work for a while. You can you can make this stuff happen. And that's why it that's why it pairs so well with governments, and governments love it so much because they're like, yeah, let's let's get the short-term fix in.
That's the politically popular thing to do, right? The people who are looking for that the next 10 years of their lives, like, yeah, let's just go ahead and bail ever bail everybody out. Let's, you know, let's just kind of try to stem the tide of this thing. But that's just kicking the can down the road, and eventually you just can't keep doing that because eventually it ends in hyperinflation or some kind of like you know, massive economic event one way or the other.
And yeah, we've been able to manage it for a while now. It's we've only been off the gold cinnamon completely since 1971. And it's only been since about 2009, 10, 11, 12, 13, like the past, you know, past decade that we've really just started printing insane amounts of money, quant this quantitative easing. And so it's really despite like, you know, we've kind of been on this road, but we're really starting to see the ramifications of it like now, I think finally.
And yeah, and so it's it just makes the timing of Bitcoin's release is almost like prophetic. I mean it's just adds some more like mysticism to the like to the mythology birth mythology of Bitcoin because it came out literally at this moment where fiat money is kind of like all right, this is what happens, right?
Yeah, fiat money's true face showed there for a couple months. And then it and then it was able to hide again. But Satoshi caught them, right? As they were, you know, disappearing again. Yeah. And so all this, yeah, I think you might be right. We might need to see the dollar fail to for people to really be convinced that this monetary policy, this fiat monetary experiment is not workable.
Yeah, I mean that's that's tough. It's like it it that that just gets so cosmic, I'm not able to think about it. But like at the end of the day, you know, like there's some some no coiners on Twitter arguing like nobody pays for anything in Bitcoin, and it's like, no, it's not that's not true, man. I ran a run a business where like people pay like I've had so many people where you know, like they can't pay me using Stripe, for example.
I just tried to use Stripe because people are requesting it for my Buidl Bootcamp. And it's like, you know, I just like Indian kid want to take my class, you know, like the credit card infrastructure in India is really bad. He like couldn't pay me any other way. And in Bitcoin, he was transaction was confirmed and you know, got a few confirmations in a couple hours, and it's like how else would he have taken my class?
Right? Like it's it's it, you know, there's all kinds of things that there's a whole classes of payments where that that can't happen without Bitcoin. And I think so people are gonna want like regardless of whether the dollar fails or not, people want this. Like it's helps. It may not be able, like hope hopefully it can take over everything.
Maybe it won't, but it like that's not really it almost it's like besides the point, like people will find Bitcoin useful for its exchange value, no matter what. Like that that is unless that there's like some catastrophic failure of the network or society society completely collapses and we go back to like barter.
People are gonna find this useful. And like to actually to what degree they find it useful is just like a market question. Like hopefully, you know, like I think people will always be able, like the world's so open now, people will always be able to exchange and they'll always find this valuable. I think they'll find it more and more valuable over time. But yeah, we're well the cool thing is we don't have to collapse to barter, you know, because we have Bitcoin now as a fallback option.
If electricity stopped working, it's like my point. You know, I would have to be yeah, okay, gotcha. Yeah, it would have to be like an absolutely just catastrophic collapse of everything. Yeah, yeah. So let's get back to the so like the Yeah, we got we went down a nice little rabbit hole there. But yeah, let's get back to let's talk about your corporate consulting work and your experience with Fidelity.
Where else have you done some actual things? So I did a few, I've done a few for like a couple smaller Bitcoin companies. One of them was an ATM company in Florida. I forgot I figured their name now, but that was like the two day workshop down there. I did one, I did like a week of workshops at it's like Bitcoin programming workshops that in in New York City during bit blockchain week.
I called it Bitcoin Week, which was kind of cool. So you know, black blockchain week at hundreds of people. My little thing had like 15 people every day. But it's just kind of cool. It was like the first day I taught people how to code. Never done it before and everything was in the format of or in the context of Bitcoin. And then so I introduced or I turned that into an online class called Biddle or it's called Mooniversity.
So like the idea is like, I want to get to the point where I can have like a you know from zero to like you can read the Bitcoin core source code or something. Like that that would be really cool as if it was like a go at your own pace, just like self-serve you know, educational platform where you could just like watch a little 10 minute, 20 minute videos over the course of some months and get like kind of up to speed.
So there's all kinds of stuff you wouldn't learn, but all the Bitcoin specific stuff you'd really learn, you'd understand like hashing, digital signatures, networking, you know, how the internet works, Bitcoin transactions, Bitcoin scripts, you know, the all this stuff style. So like a very narrow little band of programming, but all the Bitcoin stuff, and do it in like a bite-sized format where it's like you never have to sit down for more than like 20 minutes at a time, go kind of go like one video at a day, and you get you know, if you're interested in private keys, you can learn a lot about that and wallets and learn about that.
If you're interested in lightning, go learn about that. So it's more self-serve than like my bootcamp, where it's like I say, hey, this is the format every day, this is what we're studying. And if you're not interested in something, you just gotta learn that or skip it, you know. Like that's kind of the idea of what I wanna what I want to get to in the future, and like one person can't do all that. So what I want with Mooniversity is I already have like two people making courses for it.
Like I want to take like a third of the revenue and split it with other people who create courses. So like if if you know, somebody, you know, if if I get you know a hundred units of revenue and I have two people helping me, one of their videos gets like 10 views, the other one gets like 20, and mine gets like 20, then the guy who got 10 views will get, you know, he got like 20% of all views, so he'd get like 20% of the you know, third of revenue we split.
So this is too much math. But you know, like the idea is like they they would get so he would get like what a he got like you know something like 10% of revenue in that model or something, or a little less, like seven or eight percent. So like he'd get like a chunk of the revenue. And the idea is like there's a lot of people who've put out good Bitcoin content, but you'll almost universally notice that they stop after about three months, you know.
Many of them stop. And the reason is is they're not able to monetize it. And like the great thing about Bitcoin is that you have this volunteer ethos. Like people will volunteer and do stuff for free to help you know to help others sort of on their journey, and it's beautiful.
And that's you know, that's the whole way the network was created and bootstrapped and is maintained today. It's like many of them are now it's getting more professionalized, which is good. And Bitcoin itself kind of incentivizes that a little bit, but it's just yeah, because you own the asset, right? It's not like you can get immediate, you can't monetize it immediately. So, you know, we have we all have needs, but we can't wait, we can't wait 10 years for Bitcoin to move into to pay for our first time.
But exactly, it's like if you're if you're just gonna be like putting stuff for free on YouTube or something, it's like after a certain time you just have to stop because you need to pay the bills. And so like that's kind of what I'd like to address with Mooniversity, is like if you people want to put together little things, it's like if you put together a good little course, you'll get kind of paid in perpetuity as people find that interesting.
So if I could help the Bitcoin the various Bitcoin educators, and you could just these could just be somebody who knows some little thing no one's ever heard of, says, hey, I know this thing, I'm gonna put together this little video, upload it, and you know, people like it. Like, that's great. You don't have to be some well-known person. Like it's more like about getting the long tail of all these people who understand Bitcoin, but don't have a platform to, you know, to share that understanding.
Like it'd be cool to put together something for them. So that's like the long-term vision for Mooniversity. Is like mostly in like a screencast format. So I've been working on some stuff like that. Like I've I'm hopefully today I'll finish like a class where I we build a block explorer. So if you go to like explore atjustinmoon.com, you'll see a little block explorer.
So we're gonna build that from scratch. It's it's pretty cool. It you know, it's like an introduction to web development, like learning to do RPC with your full nodes. You'll learn a lot better at how to like interact with a full node. What the different, we'll learn about some of the different implementations. So, for example, if you want, like if you go to that or you know, blockstream.info, and you try to search an address on like you know, it'll actually be able to search the address.
But the Bitcoin core RPC, the thing that you can use to talk to your full node, doesn't actually support address searches. Like you can't give it an address and just find all the transactions that are associated with that, because that requires the maintenance of a the creation of an address index, right? So basically for every transaction, you gotta like note which address it corresponds to so that you can serve that request when someone asks without having to parse the entire blockchain, which could take hours or something.
So Bitcoin Core actually doesn't support that, but stuff like BTCD or Lib Bitcoin does. So we, you know, in the class we work with BTCD a little bit and we find that it's it's almost the same, but there are like little you know inconsistencies in the APIs and stuff. So it's a it's a pretty cool project. So it's like that's kind of the idea is hopeful hopefully some of the stuff will be project-based, and we'll do some stuff with hardware wallets on there.
So hopefully over time it can be like a cool little like you know, you pay like 25 bucks a month or something, and just you know can learn as much as you want, learn to your heart's desire. So that's that's the idea with Mooniversity. And yeah, the some of the like you know, doing classes in person is always fun because you know, if you're teaching online, it's like you don't ever actually interact with the humans.
So it's like it's it's I think I think you need sort of this like human interaction sometimes. So it's fun to get in a room with people who like don't get Bitcoin yet, and you know, try your best to help them, or maybe they get Bitcoin, but they don't know how to interact with it in a technical sense. So like you know, you try to like get them up to speed as fast as possible. So I did one yeah, the ones in New York City were really cool.
It's like you know, got all these people. Like one thing I noticed is that I think like by the fourth day, the last day I had like six people or something, and four of them had come to like one or more days previously. So it's like I by the end I was getting like all these repeat customers, which is which was always a good sign. And it's funny, actually, one day this is really funny.
One day I we were doing lectures about or like like exercises with the Bitcoin peer-to-peer protocol. So it's like, how do you format a message on over the internet and you know, send to a Bitcoin node such that they'll respond to you and so you know, such that you can exchange messages back and forth, which is you know the gossip network in Bitcoin.
And so this is at the bottom floor of a co-working space at the top floor was the Ethereum core devs. And so like Lubin was there, Vitalik was there, they were all there. And what they were doing apparently, like I just have one friend who's like you know, sort of like bi curious, he's into Ethereum and Bitcoin, right.
And so he's into Volf. And so I was talking to him, and he's like, So what's what's going on today is that we made Ethereum 2.0, right? And there are five implementations, and what we neglected to do before making these five implementations is agreeing on the peer-to-peer protocol, like the wire protocol. How do you format messages back and forth, which is exactly what we were like talking about downstairs, you know, and which had largely been on change since Satoshi defined it himself.
And so they had five clients that couldn't talk to each other, and so now they had all the core devs together hanging out, trying to figure out how to get their implementations to talk to each other, which is kind of funny. It like shows you the contrast between Bitcoin and Ethereum, right? Like Bitcoin's where product protocol hasn't changed and won't change.
I mean, it's changed like small, but not really much. And then Ethereum, like they go and make a whole new implementation that has all these magical features, but they forget to do something so simple as like get their five clients to talk to each other. So that was kind of a funny story that happened there. And yeah, so so so that was really interesting, you know, meet some hardcore Bitcoiners, and then I went the next week, I went to Fidelity, and that was that was also interesting.
Like, you know, no nobody who took my classes worked at worked on Bitcoin in their digital assets division. They were all members of this they have this club club, bits and blocks, which is really interesting. Like Fidelity has had this like basically Bitcoin focused club for like five years, right? And they've been like publicly mining Bitcoin for five years, right?
They've been they announced like five years ago we're not in Bitcoin, right? So they're there's sort of this like outlier in the traditional finance world, yeah. Where they actually get Bitcoin, and you know, their CEO is a fan of Bitcoin, and I think that's a big reason why they push forward and they they think blockchains are stupid, and you know, like in all most cases, and you know, they're they're they're they think Bitcoin as money makes sense, which is interesting because like I don't think any other publicly traded besides Square, no other publicly traded finance company agrees
With this assessment. Yeah, it is super interesting. And I think I think they're gonna they're gonna benefit greatly by being an early adopter in you know, as compared to their corporate peers. And it's in so yeah, it's interesting. It's like they're sponsoring all this like education for their employees that don't even work on Bitcoin, they just want this knowledge to be like spread throughout their company.
I think that's really like a intelligent thing to be doing. And I admire them for it. And yeah, so I think I think Fidelity is a pretty interesting operation. And yeah, it's it's it's it's that that was pretty cool. So, you know, got to meet all these people who work on, you know, you work on investor reporting and work on you know the risk team and all these different aspects.
You get to see how big an operation like Fidelity is. It's like the everyone has these like very, very particular jobs, but they're all like they sound quite different. So yeah, that Fidelity is an operation, man. That's awesome, man. It's cool to be able to get visibility into something like that. And I it's super encouraging to me as a Bitcoiner to know and know about companies like Cash App or Square and Fidelity are out there believing in Bitcoin, supporting it, educating their workforce about it, it's it's it's a bullish thing for me, man.
Yeah, that's the I mean it's it's a nice to have like I think one of the five things that you know like this is like the basically the like I don't think we need to overamp like like Bitcoin doesn't need them. And not not Fidelity in particular, like any of these companies. Like they didn't we don't need them.
I mean you need on ramps. You need way people places that you know that's probably why the last bear market took so long is like the on ramps were so impaired with like Gox crashing and everything. And I wasn't around back then so I don't I don't know but like you need on ramps of course but you know Bitcoin is done fine without any mainstream support.
And it's great if they will support it but we don't necessarily you know need it. Yeah no I totally I totally agree with that. I think they need Bitcoin you know exactly they have a lot more to gain from Bitcoin than Bitcoin has to gain from them. Yeah how much money Square is making from Bitcoin. Like they're making like 100 million dollars a quarter or something not not maybe not profit but like they're selling a lot of Bitcoin.
Yeah. Yeah and I think that's exactly what I meant. I think it's bullish because I think the more that corporate America or corporate global corporate corporations see Bitcoin as a viable new money and start to embrace it, it's will help make I think it's it's not necessarily bullish for Bitcoin's adoption necessarily, but I think it's or like per se, but I think it's bullish for Bitcoin for like a sort of a peaceful transition if there is going to be a transition from fiat money to a Bitcoin-based global economy.
I think that that kind of leading corporations adopting it and making it available and making it normal, you know. Like Yeah, I think I think having rich people behind it, like you want the elite, you want these like what you really want is like everyone in Congress to have some Bitcoin. Like if we could all to collectively like airdrop Bitcoin to everyone in Congress in a effective secret manner, that would be the greatest thing in the world.
Because you know, they're not going they're they're just like they're they're not they're they they criminalize things that are like that they don't use, you know. Like the that you know, you want you want people to have a financial interest in it. And so yeah, that that part of it is is is really true. You want people to, you know, you do want the like there's sort of a some sometimes you see people like I think some like some certain early class of Bitcoiners were kind of hipsters, it's like they they liked Bitcoin because it was like edgy and different, right?
But maybe they were indifferent to like the actual value proposition. And like now that it becomes popular, it's like they complain about how you know now now they like don't like it as it becomes popular because they're hipsters, right? Like hipsters like things by def this, like that's the definition. It's like they like things that aren't popular, and then when it becomes popular, they hate counterculture.
Yeah. So it's like it's not defined by any values in particular, it's just defined by it's just opposition. If you are actually a fan of the Bitcoin proposition, it's like, yeah, you want everyone owning this. And like you know, you why would you want this to become popular? Isn't that the whole thing we're doing here? It's like we want this to take over. What the hell?
Yeah, eventually there'll be some hipster fork of Bitcoin for like the counterculture. It's like cash basically. I mean, maybe not there, because they have, well, this is a business blockchain or something. I don't know. I don't know. That's not really accurate. Bcash wasn't really. BSV seems to be the statist chain, and B and Bcash seems to be sort of the you know, this is payments, goddammit.
This is these are payments. This is for payments, yeah. All right. Chain. Yeah, but yeah, I can see someday like Bitcoin gets mass adoption, and then there's you know, your people who are prone to counterculture, will just fork off and have their own little like counterculture coin, counter Bitcoin coin.
Yeah, but I mean I think one of the things about Bitcoin education is like it needs to happen on all kinds of different levels. So like I address a little part of the spectrum, you address a different part of the spectrum, and it's like you just sort of like graduate between these different, you know, like it's great. The we have a good like book scene now, you know. You have like you have like the Bitcoin rabbi money book for kids, and then like so like anyone can get that.
Like, and then you have like inventing Bitcoin, which is like 80 pages, right? So that's like a next step, and then you could move on to like I don't know what you do next. Like, you know, the Bitcoin standard would be a good one, I guess. Like that's more a little more sophisticated, more of the economic side, and you could move on to like grokking Bitcoin or mastering Bitcoin or something.
You know, then you could do Jimmy Song's book, Sovereign Individual. Sovereign individual. You could sort of like go through, you know, then you can read some Austrian economics or something, like some learn a little because they have a lot of interesting stuff about money. Ethics, you have this whole you have this whole spectrum, and then Jimmy Song's book is great for more programming side if you know kind of have some experience programming.
And so it's like it's it's great to have that. And so I think hopefully we get more and more of that where you just get this like wide spectrum of choices as you come in and can kind of you know there's like always a next step, and you don't you don't just you kind of get stuck. So yeah, that's I think it's it's pretty bull, it's it's pretty amazing to see how much is there that wasn't there.
The Bitcoin standard wasn't even there during the last you know bull market. Like I bought that thing like right after it came on, and that's what kind of got me interested. Yeah, me too. I think it was like late 2017 when it dropped, right? Yeah, maybe it wasn't. So I mean it was basically the bull run was already over.
Maybe I wasn't close to being over, yeah. Yeah. So yeah, this this bear market has definitely seen a big explosion in Bitcoin education content. And I think that's sort of pre-saging what the demand presaging and then what will fill the demand that will come in the next bull run.
And if you look back sort of in the 2015-16 bear market, there was a bunch of on ramp on-ramp building. There was a bunch of like you know, new exchanges that came online that were basic basically everyone can all the Bitcoiners are like, Look, we had a big central point of failure with Mount Gox, and so we've got to really diversify and build more exchanges and on-ramps.
And that's what got built out, and that's what helped fuel the 2017 run. And so now we're we're we're kind of looking back and being like, dude, it was hard to figure out what was going on here. There's a lot of confusing stuff going on, and it was hard to you know, kind of find the right path and the right track. We need a lot better Bitcoin education. So during this bear market, a lot of that was done by Bitcoiners.
And yeah, I think it's gonna be fascinating to watch over the next couple of years to see if that sort of groundwork that we've been laying during this bear market really pays off in terms of less ICO scammery going on and more like, all right, Bitcoin's the thing, and let's just focus on Bitcoin and learn about it. Yeah, it's I mean it's really amazing how you like think of how wobbly it was was like, you know, Bitcoin gets its start, like you know, it's like the most decentralized network ever or something in like the node sense.
You know, it's like all these like pseudonymous people just like running it voluntarily at their own cost, and then you have one on ramp, right? Like talking about centralized, right? And then and then that thing crashes, and then pretty soon like you know, you have you have one mining pool that's mining like 60%.
Like, what? And then you know, now that problem's gone. So like, you know, those are two scares of our key extreme centralization. We had Andreas, you know, like that's what we had. We don't understand Bitcoin. There's only one guy that's smart enough to explain it. Yeah, right.
And now we have quite the diversity of podcasts and books and courses and conferences and all that. So it's yeah, it's definitely grown up a lot over this past couple of years. Indeed, yeah. I'm I'm all conferenced out. I wanted to come to Bitcoin 2019, but I was just like, I've been to everyone since last year, basically.
So detox, man, this is too much. Yeah, I hear you, man. It was it was a lot, it was an overwhelming week. But I'm glad it was that was my first one. So I'm really glad that I that I went to it. Awesome. Yeah, yeah. All right, man. Anything you want to share with the listeners? I've got links that I've I've been taking notes during our conversation.
So I'll load up the show notes with links to everything that you mentioned. But anything else. The big the big point of view is like the thing I try to communicate that I don't think anybody else really communicates is that all right, this is like kind of the thing I try to stress is like there are there's a lot of utility to learning some basic programming skills in Bitcoin.
Like it really helps you understand how a lot of things work. Like you maybe you have like a fuzzy idea of what proof of work means. But if you actually learn some basic coding skills, you can like implement a little thing that does proof of work for some silly application, right? And you know, you can you can be a very beginner and do that.
Like we cover a little bit of proof of work in my Mooniversity, and you know, same thing with digital signatures, and you can really understand Bitcoin a lot better. And there's all kinds of like useful things we do. So in Mooniversity, we you know load up a CSV file of Bitcoin's price history. And you know, we try to find like what was the craziest day in Bitcoin's history, like where the price moved the most.
It moves like 30% on one day. And like, you know, you can do that if you learn some basic Python skills. You just write a loop, you go check every line in the file, and you know, you can learn to do like these useful things in your daily life. And so the you know, you might not want to become a professional programmer, you might not want to become a Bitcoin core developer, but like it can help to just learn a little bit and you can you know learn enough to find useful and then turn you know that's kind of the level you get to, and that that can be very useful.
So that's why that's what I kind of encourage. Just like you know, try to learn a little bit. At the very least, you'll have a little bit better idea of like what is running on your node, you know. Like what does it mean to have like a software? Like what does it mean? What does it mean when you run code? Kind of, for example. So I think I think that's that's that's what I'd encourage.
And you know, if you want to check out Mooniversity.io, that's the little intro class I made. It's the first version, so it's not perfect. But it's pretty cool. Like I put you in a real like developer environment in your browser. So it's like in your browser, you have a text editor, which is like it's kind of like Microsoft Word for code. And then you have like a real Linux terminal.
If you ever heard of the terminal, you know, it's like we enter commands and it's like Linux, but it's running in your browser. So it's cool. You get this real environment like what a real programmer would use. We don't have to install anything, it's a one-click setup. And you can do stuff like query a Bitcoin node using Bitcoin CLI, which is the built-in command line tool, the terminal tool for Bitcoin core, Bitcoin D.
And you know, you can learn to talk to your full node, you can learn to build a block explorer on top of your full node, you know, personal block explorer, stuff like this. So you know, it's like these are skills that are really useful you know, in in your future Bitcoining. Yeah, and I can totally confirm. It's 50 bucks.
It's absolute steal this knowledge that you're gonna get as a Bitcoiner. And it's and it's super easy to use. Yeah, one click on a link that Justin sends you in an email, and you're, you know, it's called Gitpod, I think, right? Gitpod. Yeah, Gitpod. Gitpod's amazing. Gitpod just like fires up in your browser.
You have what looks like VS code, which is kind of one of the most common text editors out there for coders to use. Looks almost exactly like that, full full featured. Plus, there's a terminal that just starts booting up and Bitcoin core and syncing with the chain. And it's like all of a sudden there's a testnet node syncing the chain.
It's insane. Yeah. And you can see it all happening right there. It's really cool to see. And then just starts walking you through just step by step, like, here's what's happening, here's how you interact with the code. And like, yeah, you know, I have some web development background myself. I'm kind of more of a product, like kind of manager type person now, but I've definitely done lots of like you know, web coding in the past.
And so I'm familiar with this stuff. But as like if I put myself in this mindset of like I have never touched code or seen a line of code in my life, like it it is easy to do, it's easy to use. And then Justin's right there with you in the videos, and there's also a Slack channel where you can ask questions and get some support.
So yeah, there's there's absolutely like no reason not to do this. And you can get it, you can go through it really quickly if you want to. You can get it done in a few days. You can do it in a couple of weeks, you know, just depending on how much time you have per day. But I would encourage all Bitcoiners to support Mooniversity, and you'll you know it's a great deal.
Thanks, man. That means a lot. Yeah, absolutely. All right, dude. This was fun. It was really good to get to talk to you. Look forward to meeting you in person some good day. Keep up with the great work. Yeah, hopefully we have this Bitcoin 2019 in Austin next year, you know. And it'll be Yeah, they're already selling Bitcoin 2020 tickets, actually. I think it's gonna be in San Francisco in March.
But the funny thing is all my block boom is coming on. All my foreign friends like this, like the Stefan who is here, is like he's like such a bad impression of San Francisco. He's like, oh my god, that's the worst city ever. Yeah, man, it was pretty bad. It was pretty rough there. I gotta say, like, yeah. I was I was sort of shocked.
I went out with a I stayed an extra day. I have a really old friend, good old friend that lives in Oakland, and he's he's a doctor in San Francisco, you know, and he sees this stuff all the time. His wife also helps Citywide, which is like the homeless the homeless shelter there, the homeless services system there.
Yeah, so she's like in the thick of it all the time. And we went out for his birthday, because it was that week and it was last week, and we went out to a show, and so we're like walking through down, you know, downtown San Francisco to get to this show. And you know, like my friend and his his friends who are sort of immersed in this stuff all the time are like just trying to have a good night out for his birthday and sort of just have the blinders on, you know, and are like you know, pointing out the beautiful sky and all this stuff, and we're just surrounded by masses of homeless homelessness and misery and suffering, and just I it it was yeah, it was it it was kind of surreal,
You know, and then m you know, lump that all in with meeting Bitcoiners for the first time, you know, that I've been learning from for two and a half years, and like the precipice that Bitcoin is on right now, and sort of what we're all looking at is sort of the next few decades that are gonna be kind of crazy. And just putting all that together in like one whirlwind of a week was absolutely insane.
Yeah, man, absolutely, absolutely. Yeah, so in Austin next year, let's get the word Boston, Austin's better. Yeah, let's I would love to come down and hang out in Austin for sure. Bitblock Boom is happening in Dallas in like next month. But yeah, we need a we needed an Austin conference because there's you know, they're they're they're quite far away from each other and in quite different cities.
So I'd rather hang in Austin. Well, I mean thanks for having me. It was a lot of fun and I'll look forward to coming back and you know maybe once we get all these little hobbyist hardware wallets out there we can we can do another thing and I'll I'll try to convince people to use them.
Yeah man I want to I want to make one so we'll be we'll be posting yeah we'll be posting some like setup some basic setup videos and I'll be including them in my courses and stuff so yeah time will tell thatass perfect nice all right man have a great week enjoy the holiday and I'll see you on the internet take it easy
Big thanks to Justin for his time it was great to hang out and chat Bitcoin with him as always let us know what you thought about the episode Justin is at underscore Justin Moon underscore and I am of course at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter we would love to hear from you all right that's all for this one take care out there Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Justin Moon joins me to discuss hobbyist hardware wallets and securing your private keys in general. We also get into Justin’s work as a bitcoin educator with Mooniversity and Buidl Bootcamp, and the broader future of bitcoin education.
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Citizen Bitcoin Layer ONE merch collection
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show: Justin on Twitter Mooniversity Buidl Bootcamp M5Stack M5Stick Stepan’s company Stepan on twitter Student on USB drives Justin Moon’s block explorer Moopniversity project