Matt Odell: Mining, Governance, UASF, Self-Sovereignty, Privacy and Bitcoin's Future
Matt Odell and I went for over two hours talking governance, mining, UASF, self-sovereignty, Austrian economics, Canada, privacy, Venezuela and Bitcoin's future. We also drank some Laphroaig and got cosmic for our boy Marty Bent.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. Okay, Bitcoiners, I am excited to bring you this one tonight.
Matt O'Dell of Jack Dorsey Bitcoin Maximalist Outing and Rabbit Hole Recap Fame. Join me tonight for another long discussion about Bitcoin. A quick shill before we get into it though.
Check out CitizenBitcoin.shop for some cool emoji-based Bitcoin themed stickers. You can pay with Lightning or On Chain via OpenNode, or you can pay with Dirty Fiat via Stripe if that's your thing.
They're doing important work on the front lines, spreading Bitcoin awareness and adoption where it matters most right now. Our podcast music is from the song Moon in the Sky by Hobotech from the free music archive. So shout out to Hobotech. Thanks for contributing the mood to the Citizen Bitcoin Pod.
Alright, on to the show.
My friend Tommy and I started this podcast in January 2018 to help us learn about Bitcoin. This year I felt I was ready to branch out and discuss Bitcoin directly with the people from which I've been learning for the past couple of years. Citizen Bitcoin is all about understanding what's happening here, about achieving clear thinking about the changes we're going through, about learning how to adapt to those changes that Bitcoin is and will bring about.
To do that, I want to talk to the brightest minds in Bitcoin and continue to have my sit-downs with Tommy to talk about what we've learned. Tonight, I have another great one for you. Matt Odell brought the fire, and my favorite Scotch, Laphroaig brought the smoke and the cosmic for us.
This is, of course, not financial advice.
This is just two Bitcoiners talking bitcoin. As always, do your own research.
So here's my absolutely unedited two-plus-hour Bitcoin discussion with Matt.
Hope you all enjoy it. Alright. Alright, Matt Odell. Hello, how are you, sir? How's it going? Happy to be here. Yeah, this is fun. I'm really glad that you accepted my invitation. I had to bribe you with a bottle of scotch.
No, that's not how it went down. I offered a bottle of scotch to you because I thought it would be a lot of fun to share some Laphroaig while we chat Bitcoin today. Yeah, I think I actually agreed before you offered me the Scotch. I think we agreed to a morning episode, and then you were like, Can I buy you a bottle of Scotch and switch it to an evening episode to spice it up a little bit?
Yeah, yeah. I was thinking to myself one day, I was like, you know, I'm gonna talk to Matt. And I've you know been a fan of the of your pod forever, since you guys started Rabbit Hole Recap and to Tales from the Crypt before that. And love how you guys are always you know like sipping on something and I think it kind of loosens things up a little bit and makes for a more laid back and fun atmosphere for conversation.
Yeah, I mean I just think Scotch is it's a good fit for Bitcoin, you know. Yeah, it seems like a Scotch topic for me, for sure. So what do you think about this Lafroy? It's pretty good. It's pretty good. I mean that was the easiest offer to accept when you told me we should switch to a night episode and a bottle was involved.
I've recorded my I think I was I just listened to your most recent podcast with Peter. Yeah, when I went on Peter's pod, not only was it one of my only sober pods, yeah, but it was at like 9 a.m. Right. And like just not that's not my element. Can't handle that.
Yeah, all right. So we made the right call then. But this this shit is really good. I don't know how to pronounce it. I'm not gonna try and pronounce it again, but I'm really enjoying it. It's yeah, it's a little cheers, man. Cheers. It's a little intimidating the spelling, but it I think it's pronounced Laphroaig. And it's a classic Scotch whiskey been around for a long time.
Very smoky, full flavored. Good stuff. So alright, man. I would love to hear. I don't think I've heard it out of all the pods I've listened to with you on it. I want to hear, you know, like when you fell down the rabbit hole.
When did that happen? Give me give me the backstory just a little bit. Actually, you probably did this this with Marty on the first, like way back when, but it's been a long time since I've heard it. So I'd love to hear like just a reader's digest version of your rabbit hole story. And who were some of the first people who you really learned from in Bitcoin when you fell down the hole.
I well, first of all, I went through like a two-year reader's digest phase when I was a young young lad. I didn't I didn't remember that until you just mentioned it. Anyway, it was I first I first found out about Bitcoin in 2012. I had a buddy who fell down the opioids rabbit hole.
And his his buddy was buying all their drugs off of Silk Road. Yeah. And he told me about it, and I was just like, you know, dude, like you're my good friend. You were really smart in high school, but oh that's such an interesting idea, you know. But I just completely dismissed it because he was my like junky friend.
Right. Yeah, exactly. It was just like, you know, I it it w it just went in one ear, out the other. I didn't even think twice about it. And I think you pe you hear that a lot when you talk to people that the first time they hear it, they just they almost just completely ignore it.
And so when you start, it keeps coming up. And then what really what sealed the deal for me was in early 2013, I had like a developer friend bring it up to me, more from like an engineering perspective. And he was you know sober, straight edge.
You know, he happens to actually be Muslim, so he he's never done any drugs or drink in his life. And he told me about complete opposite type of person, right? Oh man, that's perfect. That's a perfect like just contrast for what Bitcoin is. Like it just it touches everything and everyone, makes no, it doesn't care who you are, it's permissionless, all that, you know.
That's just like the per the perfect contrast between that one friend and the your developer friends. Yeah, it's exactly. I was like, so I said to myself, I was like, okay, so these two exact opposite types of people have mentioned this to me. I was already very much, you know, a nerd and love technology and was already in that kind of world, and I couldn't believe that I had never really noticed about it.
Like, how did it like pass me by? So I started reading up about it, and it immediately clicked to me because I had been using I had been using this betting site in college for sports betting, and that was around the time when they did the Visa MasterCard blockade in the United States.
So they stopped our funding options, the way to add and remove funds. So I had like 400 stuck on this betting site, right? And you know, we were like I was in college back then, so that was like a decent amount of money for me. Hell yeah. Were you betting? Were you betting basketball? No, I was mostly betting football.
But I do it every year with March Madness it just makes it so i suck in march madness i'm like oh yeah i get killed but but it's it makes it you know even just like five bucks on a game makes it way more fun to watch the crazy part was oh but that's besides the point so let's continue so i so we're like in 2013 i'm like this immediately clicks for me i was like just just for gambling alone just for gambling in america alone this thing makes sense literally like the most like the tiniest market
You could you know like this tiny little niche i was like it could just completely dominate and what like bitcoin at that point was trading at like 80 bucks 90 bucks so the market cap it what what it was like in the millions right it was like 90 times like 11 13 million or something 14 million at that time so it was like it was extremely low i did the math in my head i was like okay and then it started spiking that was when it the 2013 had the two runs it had the run to 250
And then came back down and went to 250 and then right and then came back down to like 50 ish and then went like crazy all the way to like 1150 and then mount gox came down and then it went all the way back down to like 150 right and then we were in the bear yeah, so like I was like FOMOing in the 250.
Yeah. And that was like my that was like my introduction. That's when I came in, and it was just like it was literally almost all Andreas on Tanopolis videos. Right. Like it was like he was like the person to watch and to and it was Reddit and IRC and I just like I like I like jumped in full force, and then basically when the bubble popped in 2013, the second bubble.
I got wrecked a bit. I was down like 50 percent. Yeah, and I was living at home and was out of college, and I was like shit, you know, I'm down all this money on this thing. I need to know like everything about it, right? Like I like before I tell my dad that I just got completely destroyed here.
I just need to learn absolutely everything, and it's just completely taken over my life since then. It's amazing. Yeah, in 2014, I launched a site. If you think Bitcoin news and noise and scams is bad now, like 2014, it was like so much worse.
So in 2014, I launched a site called CoinPrices.io. Right. And it was it was basically the vision was kind of what Masari is now, but like not as shitty, but like not as right, not as like altcoin rich, but the idea was you get prices and you'd basically get like a highly curated news feed where only the important stories that there was no noise, and it was only from like vetted resources, and I would read every article before
I posted it. And basically the vision was like I wanted like an app and I wanted to be able to like blast my thoughts out to people. And I like started a newsletter and everything, and I ran that all through the bear market. So I was like literally every day I was like finding like three really good articles of the day or two really good articles of the day and posting it on this news feed, and it like just really reinforced that learning process, and then Bitcoin Twitter blew up, and I was like, wait, like this Twitter is like literally just what I wanted to build at
Coin prices. I can just like blast out to all these people and discuss and have a rich comment system and everything. So I just closed down the site in like 2016, and I was just like, okay, I'm just I'll go over to Twitter and I'll see what I'll see what what happens next. Awesome.
So then you're on Twitter. And I was on Twitter, we had the block. Right. Yeah, UASF happens and the whole block size debate. That's kind of when I came in, was like early 2017. I was just trying to get my feet under me. When you know, and shout out to Andreas, because like he's still the gold standard, I think, for most Bitcoin noobs.
You come, you know, you find his stuff, and I think you know, if you I think it's pretty clear after you've gone through some of the noise that there's a lot of signal coming from Andreas,
And so I think people kind of gravitate towards that at first. Went through you know, Internet of Money and one and two, and Two and then the big Bitcoin standard dropped. And I and I was I remember being a bit confused about the whole fork debate and the scaling debate and everything, but waited through it and came out the other side, I think, on the on the c with the correct conclusion that you know that Bitcoin was making the right choice, and it really just came down to me to the fact that Bitcoin was scaling while prioritizing decentralization.
And if you're going to like the benefit the benefits of Bitcoin are that you've got censorship, inflation, and confiscation resistance, and you can't have any of those things if you don't have decentralization, right? So it seems to me like that's where you prioritize. I think and then the UASF thing was was also really interesting too.
And there's a big kind of, I guess one of the main splits between Bitcoin and its you know two major forks is that the two major forks don't really think that full node operators matter that much. Like I assume you think that full nodes full node operators matter.
Why do you why do full node operators matter? So what matters the most is what the market values okay.
The full node operators play a role there because you are exercising your own right to verify the chain based on the consensus rules that you've agreed to. So you're you're verifying that that's the case. I personally
I
Run three nodes right now. I've been running nodes forever. Not forever, since you know, for like five years now or something. It's my way of verifying that everything is going according to plan. Right. At the end of the day, if all the hash moves, right?
Yeah. It's a messy situation. The full nodes can't stop that. Right. They can spin up a ton of more nodes. We saw that happen during the whole the whole fork wars that happened in early 2017. They were they were embellishing their node count by just spinning up AWS nodes.
And the thing is who was who was doing that? The miners or like businesses or you know, the miners didn't agree with the Bitcoin Cash Fork because the miners didn't move over, right? So it was mostly like a couple key Bitcoin Cash proponents, right? You know, you have like the Roger Vears, jihan.
And but we also had like funny business going on with like Bitcoin Unlimited and Bitcoin Classic before that, right? Which also had inflated node counts. So that could be like, you know, like the Brian Armstrongs of the world and whatnot. Right. Anyone who wanted to push an agenda, once once people know about a metric that's being measured, they want to inflate the numbers, right?
Sure. So there's there's no way to prove how many nodes are on the network. It's it's how many real nodes are on the network because it's not Sybil proof. That that's the whole reason proof of work exists, because you actually have proof of work. So you know, like money is being put into this endeavor, so it's not like a bot, it's not fake.
Right. So what I think is is the crux to all of this is that the market is really what's deciding. The user activated soft fork was important because it actually it pushed the narrative because no one wanted disruption.
But at the end of the day, the majority went with the soft fork to begin with, right? Everyone when the majority of people updated their nodes, and that's the day Bitcoin Cash was born, was the day that SegWit was activated. They had that whole agreement where they they had the Segway 2X agreement.
And I remember I said when the Segway 2X happened, I was like, okay, fine, like we'll just we'll do SegWit now and then we won't do 2x later. And that's like exactly what happened. But but these things. I one of the reasons I got more active on Twitter was because of these four wars, because it's actually like I think is like one of the most more fascinating parts of Bitcoin.
Me too. So I actually disagree with a lot of people. A lot of people say like hard forks are always altcoins. I think hard forks aren't something you should be concerned, like be worried about. It's it's a feature. Like if the market demands that there should be a hard fork in the future, like the then that fork will become the dominant chain.
Right. And then that's you know, that's how we upgrade. The market didn't demand it this time. The market clearly said, we don't want we don't want Bitcoin Cash, we don't want 2x. You know, before the 2x fork date happened, the reason they bailed was because the futures were horrible.
Like to avoid a lot of this messiness, like you need established futures markets before the forks happened, right? Otherwise another way. Yeah, yeah. So so before before 2x happened, before 2x happened, you it was like it was like clearly trading way below, right?
Where you know, of below the regular chain, and basically everyone gave up on it. All the major New York agreement proponents gave up on 2x before we actually hit the fork date. And then when we hit the fork date, the block stalled. But that was besides the point that they had already given up on it at that point, basically. Yeah, I mean, they they wrote like a week before the fork was supposed to happen that they were calling it off essentially.
So there were just a couple of people left that decided to try to go for to try the fork, which ended up failing. Exactly. So I my theory is that nine times out of 10, miners will go the way the market demands, yeah, whichever they think is more valuable for them.
You have to remember that their rewards take a hundred blocks to mature, so they're thinking more long term. They don't they don't want they want it to be as conservative as possible, so like Bitcoin by design is resistant to change, but that doesn't mean that if we don't hit like a critical mass where like a change is absolutely needed, that it won't change.
It just means that it needs to hit that critical mass. Right. Yeah, so it's something that I kind of that I distilled it down to in my brain, then because you know you're kind of always trying to distill everything down into a tweet, which is another feature of Twitter that maybe is underappreciated, but but this it really forces you to distill your thinking down to very simple declarative statements.
And so the one that I arrived at was miners want to mine the chain users want to use, you know. And so exactly, yeah. So the miners are gonna follow the signals of the market because they are in this business to make money, and so they're gonna you know mine the chain that the users want. So it's not like I think I get the drift from the other, you know, like BSV and BCH camps that they're more of this like miners make all the all the decisions and have all the power in that regard.
And that might be the case, I guess, technically speaking, but when it comes to the incentives of the network and everything, the miners are following the users, like they're gonna go where the users are going because that's where the money is. I mean, that's it's like completely as backwards logic from the SV camp, because if miners are dictating, then their network that has 1% of SHA-256 hash power, like is complete garbage because the miners have already decided that it's garbage.
So even if they are like kind of right. Like I but I don't think miners decide. I just think miners follow where the money is. Exactly. And they they put the hash rate, their hash their hash rate, their proof of work, like you said earlier, is you know, is what's important.
It's why it's civil resistant. That's why that's the difference between like a verifying full node that's not mining and like you know, a full node that has mining behind it is basically that they're producing proof of work, and that hash power is what secures the network. And so that does matter. And so but the incentives are aligned so that they're watching where the users are and what the users are doing, what the users want, and that's where the hash power is gonna go.
So it's it's not like yeah, I think they're just missing a critical piece because they're like not leaving out the insent the miners' incentive part, you know. Right, exactly. And you have so you have like two pro you have you have two aspects here. You have futures markets ahead of time. I guess you have three. You have future markets ahead of time, you have like social signaling through like social media and stuff.
Right. And then after the fact, you have actual trading. It could get really we got lucky that it wasn't that messy. It could get pretty messy. Yeah. That's unfortunate, but you know, it's it's a distributed system, so like that's what's gonna happen.
I think all forks that I mean if you don't if you don't think that like governments managing monetary policy isn't messy, then you know you're not really paying attention. So it's you know, it's another way that society is going to arrive at at a consensus and decide like how the economy is gonna operate, right?
It's hard to arrive at that that kind of a consensus. But this is sort of an ingenious way to do it without having without empowering, you know, a small number of people to make all the decisions for all the rest of us. Right. And that that's that's why investors will and miners will tend to prefer not changing, you know, not forking.
And I that's a feature because it makes us resistant to being hijacked. But yeah, exactly. So I so I have two theories that go along with this. I have I have that first of all, if if miners do go against our interests and we end up in a situation where the chain that we think is more valuable, the chain that we run our nodes on, ends up in a lower hash rate situation.
We can we can change we can change the POW and then brick all of their hardware. So that's a it's a nuclear option, it's not great for either of us, but we can do that. The second thing is is if if a minority fork fails, if a minority fork is like a Bitcoin Cash or or even further a Bitcoin Cash SV, umce it fails for a certain amount of time, like it's done.
Yeah, it's gonna trend to zero over time because at any point we could release we could fork the current Bitcoin UTXO set, the current ledger of value and transactions, we can fork that and make bigger blocks or do whatever their feature is. And then that new fork will will almost every time by the market be valued higher because it has it has the most valuable UTXO set.
It's all the value in my mind is in the UTXO set, is in the is in the ledger that that we all agree is is the Bitcoin ledger. So the farther they get away from that consensus point, yeah, the it means it failed and it's gonna go, it'll it'll it'll trend to zero at least in Bitcoin terms.
You know, it might like stay around or whatever, and miners are incentivized on the Bitcoin chain to attack it when it becomes profitable for them. So, like if we see if SV or well, Bitcoin Cash is a whole nother story because they implemented centralized checkpoints. So I as far as I'm concerned, they're already dead. And then Bitcoin Cash SV, like if they ever like if they stay around and we get shorts and stuff like that, and they actually have like exchanges that are supporting them and accepting deposits, and miners can make money fucking them, like that's what's gonna happen.
Like they'll get they'll get fucked. But if they just die, then then it'll just die. But either way, they're gonna die. Yeah, so like a fork has a certain like a you know, maybe a few weeks or a few months to become the ledger of truth, you know, that we all agree or most of us agree on. And if it's doesn't become the truth, the real money, the real Bitcoin, then it, you know, in that short amount of time, then it's just not gonna have a chance to come back.
That makes sense. Right, then it trends to zero. Yeah. And I remember that night the Bitcoin Cash like came close to Ninja launch, the ninja launch on Coinbase, right? Yeah, was that it was like right around Thanksgiving to 2017, and I was up all night watching the drama. It was you know kind of amazing. Yeah, those those motherfuckers listed it on like a Tuesday night right before Thanksgiving.
Yeah, and I remember all the texts I was getting. It was like so so, for instance, right? Bit main at that point should have they should have had balls. They should have, if they had at that, everyone talks about 51% attacks and everything. Yeah. If Bitmain was really all in on Bitcoin Cash, which they basically were, they were like 90% all in.
But they sh what they should have done in their for their own sake is they should have gone all in. They should have just that day, if they had switched all their hash rate, you know, they control maybe 40 to 50% at that point. Maybe a little bit higher. If they just moved it all to big Bitcoin Cash, like we would have had we would have had to change POW.
It would have been a fucking mess. But they they were too scared. They were too scared that they were gonna kill their golden goose. They were too scared that it was gonna fuck everything and that they were just gonna get completely fucked. So they didn't make that move. But they could have, and us running nodes wouldn't have protected against that. We would have had to restart the POW, you know, do it do a completely different algo.
One theory I have is like we could we could steal an altcoins algo that already has ASICs, and basically lure their miners over. But either way, it would have been messy, it would have Bitcoin would have been fine, but it would have been really, really fucking messy. So like that was like a huge bull signal for me that that didn't happen, was you know, that was like the turning point.
It was like if Bitmain isn't gonna make their move now, like they're not gonna make their move. Right. In that scenario, then so let's say Bitmain switched all their hash power over, right? So like you said, operating a full node or whatever group of Bitcoiners operating full nodes couldn't stop that from happening.
But we'd have to basically update our full nodes to a new fork with a different proof of work on it. And at that point, it does become important what what the verifying nodes are running, right? So yeah, it can't stop it can't stop that attack in that scenario, but it it can be part of the solution, right? The to the counterattack, I guess.
Yeah, I mean, it's it's part of it's part, it stops the attack in part because your node tells you that shit's wrong, right? Right. Like it's your it's your way of verifying what's going on. It doesn't actually stop the attack.
The game theory is what stops the attack, right? It's the market game theory at work that that prevents the attack. And then when you're restarting a POW, like that's could be an issue. Like if we do GP, like people don't realize like, first of all, ASICs resistance isn't a thing. It's all bullshit.
There's no such thing as ASICS resistance. Eventually you'll find a purpose-built computer that can do better than a general purpose computer at whatever you're doing because that's how physics works. Right. So in the beginning, when you're a GPU mined coin, like that's a major, major issue. So you can do different things, you know.
Like in the beginning, if they switch over the hash, we'll still maybe have 50% of the hash, maybe a little bit less. So we're like under threat of potential. What they would do is at the same time they do that, they would attack the Bitcoin chain, right? With like block withholding attacks and stuff like that. So we'd have to, you know, maybe you'd like see what the situation was on the ground.
Maybe we'd implement some policies on exchanges, like wait a hundred confirmations and like hope like the market figures itself out. And then if you realize like that's not gonna happen, then then you start discussing POW changes. And I actually think like the cleanest way is to like, especially now, if like it were to happen today, like you take you take an altcoins algo that is like kind of like a shit coin but has ASICs already, so that it's not just GPUs, and you basically lure those miners to come to come mine your chain because all of a sudden they have like a cash grab opportunity for them where they can make way more
Money. All of a sudden they're miner instead of being a shitcoin miner is is a bitcoin miner, right? Yep, yeah. And you could probably you could probably encourage them to come over. But I think that that was a really big turning point because the market has matured so much, and we have so many competitors that now that we've passed this bit main boogeyman, I think it's less and less likely that we'll ever be in a situation again that we'll have like a single entity like that be able to really dictate so much hash.
So that's really good. Yeah, that's huge. That's a huge hurdle to pass. Yeah, because I mean Bitmain has been around for a long time, and they haven't been. The key was the key was they ramped up in the bear market, they like emerged in the last bear market, and they basically just like just kept over-leveraging themselves, but everything just went up, you know.
So it worked out great for them, and then they just got hit at the top, way too over-leveraged and have way too many Bitcoin cash bags, and it just like fucked them. Yeah, okay. So they they hadn't been there, they weren't around until like 2015-ish then. I mean, yeah, the ASICs didn't enter ASICs in general didn't really enter the game until 2013.
Okay. If you look at like the hash rate chart, it's like just parabolic, it's pretty fucking crazy. Yeah. So they were like in the right place at the right time, and they just went balls to the wall. And it worked out for them while the market was going up. And then when it turned, it just fucked them hard. And that was like the most bullish thing that could happen to Bitcoin.
It's fucking fantastic. This is like a good six months. Yeah, that phase, that phase where you're going from from GPUs to ASICs, and then not only ASICs, because you need you need the algo to be widespread enough that you have multiple ASIC manufacturers.
So there's these two hurdles that you have to get through. You have to get through the GPU bootstrapping phase, and then you have to basically get through the ASIC bootstrapping phase where you're you're hoping that all these foundries around the world and stuff will start producing the chips. And we passed those two thresholds just recently. Like this is you know, in the last two years we passed this threshold, and that's a really, really big deal.
Nice. That's awesome. All right. But meanwhile, like Ethereum and shit is like they're like, oh, we don't ASICs are bad, and they're actually setting themselves back, you know. So I thought I thought we finally had put that out the window. And I, you know, I guess not. So people are gonna need more case studies to learn.
Yeah. All right. So let's shift the focus a little bit and let's talk about economics, the economic side of Bitcoin. The state of the of like global socioeconomics is pretty crazy right now. I think it's been crazy for a while.
I call it runaway Keynesianism. It's kind of the default now. And I, before Bitcoin was a default Keynesian. This is the term I've come up with for myself, which is, you know, most universities and most sort of places where you might get educated about economics and the way the our global economy works, teach the same idea.
So we have this monoculture of economic thought out there. And we right now currently have 17 countries with double digit inflation, according to trading economics.com. Venezuela, right now the inflation rate is over 2.6 million percent, you know.
Insane. Yeah. So,
The I there was a great thread that Obi-Wan Kenobit had on Twitter today about about Bitcoin and economics and Keynesianism and kind of the shift in 1971 off the gold standard. And he posted the video of Nixon, and the explanation is just you know, now that I'm a Bitcoiner and know the alternative ideas, it just sounds so crazy.
And it's it's amazing to me that he got away, you know, that basically got away with that. And the banks got away with that over 60 years or so from the time the central bank was started and then up to the time the gold standard was was basically given up. It only took about 60 years to kind of make that plan happen, I guess.
And the quote from Obi-Wan Kenobit is that Keynesianism gives the illusion of prosperity, but it's sapped generations of wealth. So there's this, it's amazing that it has this sort of we you just keep printing money. It's like a Ponzi scheme almost. So you just you have this illusion that there's prosperity and wealth that's growing.
But really the inflation is just sucking away the value over time. And it's just it just happens sort of behind the scenes, and it's hard, it's hard, it's like a sleight of hand almost. So this is happening all over the world right now. We have kind of it's causing extremes on either end of the political spectrum as well, so that we sort of got the choices are coming down to in a two-party system like in the United States, it's coming down to like socialism or fascism.
There's nobody kind of arguing for small governments anymore in in US politics, for instance. And then you have this third choice, Bitcoin, you know. So I guess my first question is just kind of with that kind of intro to this section of the discussion.
Like, are first of all, are you are you what I call a default Keynesian? Like, did you grow up that way as well? And did you learn about this alternative economic thought that Bitcoin is kind of built on the Austrian economics? Did you learn about it after Bitcoin or did you have some knowledge about it before so we don't learn about this in US schools, right?
Like I was I guess yeah, I was a default Keynesian. I you know, it's pretty fucking crazy how recent the 71 gold standard was. Yeah. You know, people are like the biggest argument is like, oh, well, this is the way it's always been. It's like this is not the way it's always been, so you're wrong about that.
The I don't know how how old are you? Do you mind me asking? I'm 39. So I graduated in 97. Okay, so I graduated high school in 2008. So I was very much shaped by that collapse.
You were, I mean, right there during like right, yeah. And you're you're looking to leave the house and kind of starting to think about your future, and everything's crumbling. Right. So I saw that happen to me. I saw that happen to our our country, and everyone was like, oh, I'm so I'm like so caught off guard, like didn't expect this to ever happen. And then I saw QE happen right afterwards, right?
Yeah. So that happened. So I actually was not default to Keynesian before I had I had discovered Austrian economics before I discovered Bitcoin. Bitcoin solidified it for me. It was part of the attraction of Bitcoin, the asset. You know, my family my dad has works in real estate.
So there was there's very much a connection there between you know, he always said, you know, bricks, it's all about the bricks. And it was like very much a connection, real money, non-inflatable, actual value. And so when Bitcoin when I when I was when I got introduced to Bitcoin, and I was like, holy shit, like you literally have, you know, you have a plan B.
You have a way of opting out of this system and protecting your value. You know, we also had at the same time, you know, I had all these things shape my childhood. My my I guess my going into adulthood at the same exact time as I discovered Bitcoin.
I had the 2008 collapse, and then I had the Snowden documents that got released. Right. So I knew they were tracking all this stuff at the same exact time. And I became more focused on personal sovereignty and privacy and all these things that that Bitcoin really encompasses.
You know, one of the interesting things is you mentioned like Keynesian is is they it seems like it's prosperity when it's it's really robbery. But but the reason it seems like it's the reason it gets by is because it's great for the rich people.
Like if you overlay if you overlay the SP chart on that 1971 decision like it's just basically host parabolic right like the everything just goes crazy. And same with real estate you know several times has been through several bubbles and like you said you know like your your dad said that that was a place where you could park your money you know and there was some real value there.
It was a sound it was a sound and investment a sort of sound money I guess a way to store your wealth and same thing with equities and so all this money's getting printed and the rich are getting access to it first and so they're socking it away in you know real estate and equities and it just can drives all that stuff up and you know it sort of dribbles down I guess to all the plebs that are out there working for wages and then all of a sudden you know like something that cost or was worth a million
Dollars in like 1971 is worth like you know five thousand dollars now right man do you remember you remember who wants to be a millionaire like that was a big fucking deal a million dollars yeah right right. Right. How long ago was that? Like then if they had a show now where it's like, oh, you could be a millionaire it's like okay, I guess.
Yeah. Like what? Yeah. Yeah. You can't just I mean, you can't just print money forever and not have inflation. Sorry. That's not that's not true. Not true. Well, we've had real inflation, right? Like in the in the things that people actually spend their money on. Exactly. Exactly. And that I mean that's just gonna keep happening. You know, prices, I think we're sort of on the verge of prices really catching up with the amount of money that's been printed because more of it, like when you get things get frothy like this, and then money's gonna start coming out of equities and real estate and all that stuff, and we'll get another bubble bursting.
And then price inflation can start can start really kind of ramping up at that point if you can't if they can't keep control anymore. So, you know, and we're gonna see like quantitative easing is already being talked about, like they're planning the next rounds of it. So just it's just gonna keep happening. And thank God we have we have Bitcoin to as an option.
So
So if Bitcoin is this kind of alternative financial operating system, and it enables economic self-sovereignty for the first time, really. What do you think would make what I call a good citizen of Bitcoin? Like this is one of the reasons I named this this podcast, Citizen Bitcoin, is the idea that we're heading into this like era of self sovereignty, and we've got to kind of all learn about what it means to be a citizen of this new self sovereign economic operating system, a good citizen Bitcoin.
So with that, what do you think would make a good citizen Bitcoin? What do what should Bitcoiners be focusing on learning and ramping up as they kind of discover what Bitcoin is and then come into the system, right? What what are what are your values for what would make a good citizen of Bitcoin?
Well, first of all, I loved your podcast name to begin with. And I immediately I immediately understood that take. And then when I was listening to the Peter pod, it was actually an homage to your your dad's what your dad's radio show or something. No, he had a blog called Citizen Brand, because he's he works in public relations and branding and communications with and stuff like that for nonprofits and corporations in Kansas City, and his his thing was always connect like being transparent, like your brand value will be most rewarded, I guess,
By being transparent and being a good citizen in in the world, you know, people will build up trust and all that stuff in your brand. And so his idea of a citizen brand was like he he invented this idea of like the for like it he was Lee Jeans was a client, all right, and they were trying to raise money for breast cancer research, and so they had a casual Fridays thing, they started in like the mid 90s or early 90s or something.
You bring five bucks to work and you get to wear your jeans into the office, which like in the early 90s was still kind of a cool thing to do. Like nobody cares now, 20 years later or whatever, because we all wear whatever we want and into most offices. But then it was kind of a big deal, and so people paid five bucks, and it was a it was a pairing a nonprofit in corporation and kind of having that impact on your brand.
And so, yeah, that's that's where it came from. And it's the same kind of idea here. It's like how can we teach people new to Bitcoin to like do this the right way? You know what I mean? Okay, so I would say the only thing Bitcoin asks of you as a Bitcoin user is to be greedy.
That's the only thing that is expected. And that's the beauty of Bitcoin is that if you act in your own self-interest, the system continues and prospers. I what I do in terms of education, Twitter and podcasts and whatnot, is is not necessarily to benefit Bitcoin.
It's to benefit the individual users, right? When when it comes down to it, your desire to be greedy and to be selfish should lead you down the path of learning about it as much as possible, about running your own node, about learning how to take back your privacy and contributing back to this system that will give you value in return by the price going up, right?
You want to increase adoption because your Bitcoin ATM company will make money doing it, and the Bitcoin that you hold will go up in price. So you want to increase education because stakeholders that own Bitcoin, if they are more educated, then the system is more secure because the people that hold it understand it better, right?
So all these things are selfish, greedy things, and that's the beauty of it. Right. It's just another one of the examples of the incredible incentive structure of Bitcoin, and it just relies on basic human greed, which which is genius, I guess. Yeah, I mean, like, I don't do this like out of the kindness of my own heart.
Like, I do this because I know that if Bitcoin succeeds, like I'm gonna be loaded, right? And I also I also know I also think that in a world with Bitcoin is a fairer world, is it is a better world, a more productive world. But at the same time, I also know like it's gonna, you know, my my bags will go up in price, right?
Like that is like a pretty crazy in incentive structure there. I think I think every bitcoiner needs to realize that at the end of the day, you have to look out for your own. You know, you have to make sure that you understand this as as best as you possibly can, that you protect yourself, that you don't, you know, trust someone else with your private keys and lose your fucking Bitcoin.
Like everyone's gonna be trying to take your Bitcoin. That you don't that you don't let con con artists trick you into thinking they're Satoshi, you know, and following them along their little adventure because you met them at the round table, you know, a year ago.
Like these things, these but but at the end of the day, like look, people got tricked, you know. People there was plenty of reputable people that thought Craig Wright was Satoshi. Like literally two days after that came out, I was like, he's not fucking Satoshi, you know.
But plenty of people figured got tricked. And look, Bitcoin was fucking fine, right? Like Bitcoin didn't care, but like some people got wrecked. And like, so it so there's like two different things here, you know. It's like it's like what what you had that saying, don't ask, don't ask what what the country can do for you, ask what you can do for the country.
Like with Bitcoin, it's really don't ask what you can do for Bitcoin, ask what Bitcoin can do for you. And it just comes back.
But really, what you're asking is like, what can Bitcoin do for me? And you end up in this beautiful fucking feedback loop where Bitcoin benefits. Yeah, it is it is pretty beautiful. And you're right. Like, you know, I have this same I guess, you know, beautiful vision of the future that you know, this is sort of the third option, the red pill that will get us out of out of this very unfair system that we're in right now, create a better future for my kids and for humans in the future in general.
And yeah, like I have that vision, but you know, that's you can't rely on you know human goodwill to build the basis of an economy because that's just not the only incentive that humans work on. And so yeah, it makes it kind of it's just it's genius that you can use greed to create you know to create a globally beneficial system, basically.
Now, from from well, first of all, it's not red pill, it's orange pill. Credit to Nic Carter for that one, yeah. Oh yeah. I think that you
Could have value, but Bitcoin you have a situation here where
You have the LaFroy just got to me. I'm like completely what what were you talking about? Yeah, we were talking about Bitcoin being based off greed, but generating something that's beneficial for all of society, right? Oh, right. My I remember my point. I apologize, guys. Sorry, listeners.
Hope you're on one and a half X. So basically, there's two different standards I have, right? As a Bitcoin citizen, like honestly, like just act in your own best interest and Bitcoin will benefit, right? That's awesome. Yeah. As a Bitcoin citizen, in terms of a public citizen, in terms of someone who's a public figure on Bitcoin Twitter or other social media channels, or is involved in the dev process, or is giving presentations at different events, sure, right?
They have to be held to a higher standard. Like if you if they're acting out of complete self-interest and they're shilling shit coins and they're pumping their own bags and they're leading people down dark holes, like they need to be fucking ostracized, right? Like you can't you can't just like let that slide.
Like that it's too important. Bitcoin, yeah. Yeah, and we get I mean we get a bunch of shit for it for being toxic or whatever. You know, and all that comes down to it. No, it's Bitcoin's immune to it. Yeah, it's bit it's Bitcoin's immune system. You have to Bitcoiners to be if you're a good Bitcoin citizen, like you shouldn't stand for that, right?
Like I think that is, and but but that's out of your own self-interest, right? Like you shouldn't stand for that because that hurts people and hurts the reputation of Bitcoin, and they should just not be tolerated. They should be shunned from the community. Like there's there's there should be no softness there.
Like automatically like they are acting to fuck over people to fuck over Bitcoin. They should not be treated with any kind of it's real it's a pure meritocracy, right? And so what you can't like if you're going to you know fuck up your your own merits like in in the eyes of the rest of the community or the people who are interested in Bitcoin.
The one way you're gonna do that the quickest is you know be a scammer. Try to trick people lie to people try to steal money from them. Yeah and so if this is a meritocracy that you have to have zero leeway for that kind of behavior. And then you reward you know with public praise and encouragement and all that the people who are actually building value on the system and not scamming people and lying to people you know people are just trying to find the truth and it was hard for me to find those you know try to figure out exactly who was trustworthy I guess and
Not a scammer. So bad it's so bad right so much out there. Yeah it took a while and it was confusing but it was kind of a fun game to be honest I mean that's like it was dude it's fucking difficult man when like CNBC's chilling ripple you know yeah cnbc chilling ripple at two dollars it goes up to three dollars like that's fucking it's hard for for new newbies to ignore that kind of shit you know and it's it's almost impossible.
Yeah and the scammers are flashier. They offer way flashier things. You know, I'm like, I'm like, you should dollar cost average with money you're willing to lose, you know. And they're like, You're gonna make a hundred X. Yeah, exactly. Like you can't like tomorrow, you're gonna make a hundred eggs tomorrow. Like it's really hard to compete with that.
But it's literally why I do what I do is like because I hate seeing people get fucked. And you know, I if I if I can save like a couple people, then it's all fucking worth it. Absolutely.
And I it also makes it'll make me feel less guilty when hyper bitcoinization happens. Because at least I'll be like, guys, like there's public proof that I've been shouting this from the fucking rooftops this whole time. So yeah, again, like you know, your own you're doing it for yourself and it and it's the right thing to do for Bitcoin, it turns out.
But Bitcoiners are awesome, like I'm doing it for them for sure at the same time, but I'm not doing it necessarily for Bitcoin. I don't know. You know, I it just happens to be that all these people are like minded people that I tend to like. Like when I meet up with them and stuff and meet them in person for the first time and interact with them online, like they're people that they're like minded people, right?
And I want them to share the same knowledge that I have have learned the hard way over the years. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it's it seems to be a pretty cool group of people, and just I've enjoyed, I've learned a ton. And that's the thing that I appreciate the most about people in in Bitcoin is this they're you know, good thinkers, you know, people who have thought cle hard and eventually clearly about the world, and I've learned a ton from them and just from from studying Bitcoin in general.
So my my favorite my favorite thing to do is get into a drunk argument with someone who is an extremely intelligent person about Bitcoin that is that it's a pre-coiner you know they had they they they're not on the Bitcoin chain yet. Yeah yeah like try to and try to convince them and bring them around.
Yeah it's really it's really interesting because like people are so used to you know how it how it's always been as air quotes but you know how it's always been right it is really finance people. Yeah I have this group of I haven't really done it with finance a finance person that would be fun.
I have this group of guys from high school that I see at least once a year we always get together for a weekend once a year. And last year was really the first time I got to shill Bitcoin to them for a little while and they you know put up with it for a little while and then weren't interested. And this year interestingly I'm getting a lot of texts like almost I think all but one of them have texted me asking me questions about Bitcoin and like let's talk more about this when you get here I've been doing some reading so they're slowly coming around and it's gonna be I'm looking forward I think we're meeting in like a month or so looking forward to talking to those guys because they're really smart dudes and I
I think they'll really be interested once they you know get the hook I guess and so it sounds like a couple of them are really coming around. That's that's where like Bitcoin really like as an investment really clicked for me was when I realized like every single one of us motherfuckers are like trying to convince like our six friends to like buy some Bitcoin.
Yeah it's true and then you get like one of them and he tries to convince his six friends you know and at the end of the day like you can't stop that like it would all we could be wrong about all this fucking shit yeah and there's still so many people that are gonna buy it and this is gonna go up in value like they would like we'll address that at a later date like I think I think Bitcoin is fucking game changer but at the end of the day like literally all of us are just out there shilling just constantly yeah and I mean we wouldn't like most of us wouldn't still be doing it if we didn't actually see something here like we're not most of us aren't like doing this for years coiners
Yeah year after year after year because we bought some bags and we're trying to sell them like that's not we're here because we see something important that is worth shilling I guess oh no yeah let's let's be honest here like my fascination with Bitcoin and me going down this rabbit hole has by far granted me less admiration for my peers than more admiration yeah right like I had like a three month window in 2017 where I was a genius but like besides that like I was a fucking idiot to them like that's
Like really that's what it is like they come to me now they're like what is Bitcoin dead yeah you know like I you know oh you lost all that money you know it's like okay guys like it was at 800 in 2017 like we're doing all right but but but but in their mind right like I'm I'm still the underdog.
I love that underdog logic, you know but I but it's still very much like I believe in this. I think it's gonna I think I think it will benefit everyone, even the people that don't buy in early. Yeah, but but like it it very much is a situation where like people are incentivized to try and increase the worth of Bitcoin once they hold it, right?
And they're gonna shill it out to the people that they respect and love and want want them to also make money on it at the same time, right? Like I had I have this thread where I talked about on Twitter, like people came up to me in 2017, they were like, dude, like why didn't you tell me to buy Bitcoin? It was like, guys, I've been telling you to buy Bitcoin this whole fucking time.
You thought I was a fucking crazy person because I lost I was down a shit ton of money, right? Yeah, and then like the price and Mount Gox happened and everything. I remember when I found out when Silk Road got busted. Yeah. When I was I was I was in the bathroom on the toilet when Silk Road got busted at the office, and I was like oh my god.
And it was like it was that was like a huge legitimization of Bitcoin, and really was yeah, yeah. I don't know, it's pretty crazy. But I love it. I would I no regrets. It's it's it's a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and people are dismissing it as beanie babies, and they're just gonna they're betting way more than we're betting.
Like they're I don't know how you live with yourself if you dismiss like one of the greatest wealth transfers in our fucking short history, yeah, and you dismiss it as beanie babies in 20 years down the road, like good luck, man. Yeah, and there's you know, some no coiners that have just been aware of Bitcoin for a long time and just in you know, entrenched in their position and just never gonna change, you know.
Yeah, fucking E Man. Fucking Eamon Segir or whatever. I don't even know. Yeah. Uh-huh. Yeah, I found out after I started the podcast with Marty that I actually have horrible pronunciation skills, and that that's why I was really good online, like on Reddit and IRC and Twitter and shit.
But like I but I'm now I have to work on my pronunciation because all this all this time for like the last six years, I've been just reading it and in my head, just pronouncing everything horribly. But anyway, he like first talk shit about Bitcoin at like 11. Yeah, you know, like he was way ahead of me. He discovered it before me. Right.
And like once you dismiss it, like you get entrenched. You just you need to look for ways to justify your missed opportunity. Right. And you just can't be wrong. Yeah, we have all these people, like I remember Nathaniel Popper of New York Times.
I presented in front of GE with him, like a bunch of GE executives during the bear market. Yeah, I like but up until the bear market, I was really good at as part of coin prices.io. Kind of. I you know, I did I did basically I was really good at my anonymity and privacy with Bitcoin.
I was like one of those you in the 2013 Bitcoin world, they were really good about teaching you, you know, you use names, you always stay anonymous, you don't expose your name. Because we really thought that that there'd be a possibility here that it would be illegal in in the United States, and you just didn't want to associate your name to it.
Yeah. And I mean, I think we passed that point, which is fucking really bullish, but that's besides the point. So in 2015, I just try like destroyed my anonymity because Bitcoin was down the shitter and everyone was talking shit about it. And I couldn't let that stand for two reasons. Because I fucking love Bitcoin.
And then, like, the second reason was like a greedy reason. I was like, if I cement that I'm bullish now, when the price goes up, people will be like, well, that guy called it, right? Right. So I did a bunch of like guest articles and like entrepreneur.com, like payment source, like TechCrunch.
They automatically like take your credentials more seriously if like you're the CEO of Coin Prices.io. You know, it's like the fucking website, man. Like it's ridiculous. Yeah, but I fucking did it, and GE invited me to speak in front of their executives in 2015. That's amazing.
That's amazing. And Nathaniel Popper presented with me. We were on the state, we were on like the presentation thing together. And this guy had just written the book Digital Gold, right? Right. He literally like outlined the investment thesis. I mean, in two words in the title, you didn't have to read the book. It's digital gold, like that, like it's gonna go up in value.
It's it's got to touch such a tiny market cap. Like it's fucking gonna go up in value. Didn't buy any because he was a respectable journalist that would never mix his bias with with his what he covers, you know. And he was really bearish in that in that 2015 presentation.
And now, of course, like after 2017 and after the fucking run-up, like literally everything he writes is way, way, way like digital gold was a little bit bearish the way he did it. It was like a little bit like kind of conniving the way he phrased everything. But since then, yeah, he dugs, he digs his heels in even even more so.
But there is a reverse here that I think a lot of these skeptics do hedge themselves and they do buy some Bitcoin, and you don't know they buy Bitcoin because it's it's secret. I had one of my buddies who I he was my college roommate, and I like pitched the shit out of Bitcoin to him. And in the bear market of 2015, like he scooped up like a bunch in the 300s.
Nice, and like he didn't tell me he he didn't want to admit that he hedged himself on him being wrong to me, yeah, until we're when we got like 18k, he told me. He was like, and I was like so proud of him because all my other friends that I convinced, like they made me walk them through like how to run your node, how to properly secure your coins, how to do all this other stuff.
And this kid, because no, none of them sold. I have very strong group of oh good of college friends who I've who have turned over to the dark side, but he he was the best out of all of them because he didn't want to admit to me that he was buying it, so he did all the research himself, he learned how to do it all himself.
He he pulled his coins off of Coinbase, he transferred them to his own full node, he stored them in cold storage. I didn't have to fucking tell him a thing because he didn't want to admit to me that he was hedging himself. The Bitcoin incentives are so strong that even if you completely philosophically disagree with the direction it's taking, you still might secretly buy some just to hedge yourself, so you're not like 20 years down the road, you're like, What the fuck did I do?
Oh man, I mean I did that with the forks. I did that, I had I held Ethereum for quite a while, you know. I was like, what if I'm wrong? What if proof of stake is right? You know, and when you're at first, at first there's just so much to learn. It takes a while to develop that conviction. And so I think it makes sense just like for your own like sanity to you know maybe pick you know the three or five that you think have the best chance instead of just committing to one and right at first.
And it you know, that helped me. My conviction is is much stronger now, you know. But which three of five do you choose? Well, I held I held Bitcoin Cash and I held Ethereum for quite a while. Those are the only two that I really held. It was like the Coinbase and the Coinbase Mafia.
You just held the Coinbase Mafia basically. Yeah, I just wasn't like I would I even wrote like I wrote a blog post about why Roger was wrong about scaling and everything. I was pretty sure, but I kept having these like late night, like laying in bed, like self-doubt sessions. What if I'm wrong? Yeah, what if I'm wrong?
You know, like be humble, dude. Like, you know, you could be wrong. There's a lot to learn here, there's a lot to know. Yeah, and it's just you know, I think that there's people, some people are more self-doubtful than others, I guess, just in general. And I think I'm probably like kind of in the middle of the road on the as far as that goes. But yeah, I you know, and I was like, you know, what is it when it I sold all my Bitcoin Cash like around that that time, like the that weekend basically that was after the ninja launch.
Thank the Thanksgiving weekend. No, like I sold it that night. I sold it that night. Like when it when it was going up, yeah, like 4200 bucks. Damn, dude. Good for you. Well, I stayed up all night and I was like, I'm gonna watch this and go, and I just you know, I was in a good group of people, they were just like, oh man, this red candle's gonna be amazing when it hits, you know. That's my favorite part.
Yeah. So I got a got a pretty good deal on that. But then when it got like just dropped down super low during the bear market, I was like, Look, I can scoop up you know, and so for like three months during this bear market, I was like, I was holding on to some Ethereum and some Bitcoin Cash, and then it like kind of came to my senses.
I was like, Come on, man, like you're you're right. Just just you know, dump the shit. Let's let's move on. So yeah, I did that. I mean, I admit to it, it happened, but it it was it was a result of you know, like a few nights in a row of just being like, all right, what if you're wrong? Look how cheap it is to like cover your ass just in case you're wrong, you know.
Anyway. No, I respect that. I you know, well, first of all, the thing with forks is like go back to our previous conversation. Like, one of the nice things is like if you're actually a bitcoin stakeholder, if we have a contentious fork that comes up, like you can just chill. Yeah, you know, you can get your like I'm not yeah, like the current the current badge of hold all forks, like they can go fuck themselves.
Like they've just lost shit tons of money. Yeah, but but in the beginning, yes, absolutely. You know, wait a month, you know, wait, see how it plays out. You don't have to be like super educated. You just you can just wait, and like, yeah, like you lose a little bit of bonus off the table because like maybe you didn't you know sell bitcoin gold, you know, when you could get 10% for it.
But yeah, but you can you can sit there and you can wait to see if like if this is and if this is a real thing of value, does does the market move this way? You get you get one of each. Yeah, it's harder for new people who come in after the fact that are like, oh my god, like which is the real Bitcoin? Like that's like a whole different ball game. As far as Ethereum goes like it's really funny you brought up proof of stake because I've been arguing against proof of stake for like the last four years.
Yeah and it's still not even that close on the fucking horizon. So who never knows yeah my my most popular article on coin prices.io I released during the Ethereum pre-sale during the ICL and I could have bought that shit for like what like 15 cents or something like that.
Jesus and I wrote this article about how it had unbounded inflation and they didn't care about centralization and like literally all the problems that it faces today I wrote an article about and I was like this is probably a really bad investment and I like I like hedged my like I was like kind of soft about it I was like this is my opinion I think it's like probably a really bad investment and it became my most popular article on coin prices because all the Ethereum guys like as the price went up would just come
Into my comment section and be like yeah dude really we're at 2x now we're at 4x now and like literally all the way up to a thousand X like that's what I fucking fucking had to deal with. And I like that's part of it that's part of it too is like you know you look at some of the stuff like you know if you are just being greedy like trading shit coins is a way to make some money.
And you know there they're there's a lot that are super cheap, you know, at this point. And I guess it it's probable at this point that there'll be another round of insanity. Just because there's going to be. Yeah, maybe even maybe even several more.
And so do you bet on that or not? Like, yeah, what is the look? I was talking with Ansel Lindner about this. Like, what's the ethic there? Like, once you sort of have this knowledge and this conviction, like is it alright to dump on shitcoin holder bag holders and stuff and then like and make some more Bitcoin that way or not?
I think I think that you know, back in back in the day in like the good old days of 2014, the you were still a good Bitcoiner if you traded shit coins to get more Bitcoin, yeah.
I think there's absolutely nothing wrong with doing that. I think the market is irrational. I think I was completely right about Ethereum, but it went to 1500 first. I could have made a lot more Bitcoin if I traded that. Now the ethical issue is shilling it. You should never be shilling shit coins, totally.
I have never I've never shilled a shit coin. Part of it is so easy to fall down that rabbit hole of shilling your bags. So many people have done it. One of the reasons why I have such good momentum on Twitter is because I've never fucking done it. I will never do it, and it's never gonna fucking happen, and I will look down on any person that does it.
But if you trade them in the background, yeah, you know, like whatever, like you're making more Bitcoin. And like to think I agree for the most part that Bitcoin will be the dominant monetary base of our future. I think that monetary economics push towards that.
Everyone wants to use the most liquid, the most secure asset, the most secure money. But shit coins aren't going anywhere, like they're not like we're gonna have proper, you know, altcoins that are like a slightly above a shit coin, we're gonna have shit coins, like they're gonna exist for a long, long time.
Just the majority of them are gonna fail, and new ones are gonna be born, and like that's like kind of the beauty of Bitcoin's evolution, because we get to they all are running basically tests for us to see if if there's anything that's of use that we can finally hit a critical mass and then fork into.
So I think altcoins help Bitcoin. I think I think the altcoin casino is a major major use case of Bitcoin, especially right now. Like the only way to trade into the altcoin casino is is to get in with Bitcoin, and they're all it's all denominated in Bitcoin, you know.
Like the first guys, everyone's talking now about like let's denominate shit in Satoshis, right? And Satoshis doesn't really ring off the tongue, which is why I came up with stacking sats. I really like sats as a unit. But like since yeah, exactly. But the people who first priced shit in Satoshis, who started visualizing what is Satoshi meant to them and how much value that Satoshi had was altcoin traders, like they were pricing everything in Satoshi's way before us, yeah.
And I, you know, and it plays off. I mean, the reason it'll exist is because it plays off of the same thing I was just talking about. That that kind of doubt, that self-doubt when you're trying to understand a pretty complicated new thing, I think it's pretty natural for a lot of people to feel that. And then it's also pretty natural for a lot of people to you know take advantage of that and sell some sell some scammy shit.
And so yeah it'll come back in. There are some there are some that aren't you know very scammy necessarily true totally true. Yes. The incentive is definitely there for you know and the ones that are like most successful tend to be like the scammier ones like the Tron-esque things the ripples things and BitConnect was yeah like a bit connect.
Yeah exactly but yeah I just I think that if you believe I believe in free market I believe in personal sovereignty I believe in people making their own decisions I believe in the market being correct over the long run if that's the case like you should never be threatened by altcoins.
Like if if there's any if there's any value in an altcoin like we can fork that into Bitcoin. If it's completely different than Bitcoin some magical technology that doesn't exist yet like we can fork the UTXO set of Bitcoin into it.
So there is absolutely nothing that we can't fork with the quite the with the with with the actual critical mass of people to fucking do it. And once you start talking about like this magical stuff, like all these new all all this new bullshit that everyone peddles. Yeah. Like you don't have to even worry about 51% attacks or anything because most of this magical bullshit involves either different algos or different technology altogether.
So you could literally with zero risk, you know, basically like let's like let's use Stellar or Ripple as an example, right? Like you can make a Ripple S network, a Stellar S network, you know, Stellar is a fork of Ripple with a new UTXO set. You can make a stellar that that just starts with balances of everyone that has Bitcoin.
And there's no risk there for Bitcoin holders. We just all got a bunch of stellar Bitcoin or whatever you want to fucking call it, Bitcoin feature or whatever. But we all just got that for free. Zero risk. And if it fails, it fails. But if if Stellar is actually some amazing technology, then we're good, right?
So there's no threat from altcoins. They benefit Bitcoin. You shouldn't like ask the state to stop them, because that's just not Bitcoin of you. And let the market play itself out, and the market will most definitely, you know, choose Bitcoin over the long run.
Well, they'll choose the most secure true ledger, the most fair ledger we've ever had in the history of mankind. Amazing. All right, let's let's the third sort of chapter of this discussion. All right, privacy. I know this is a big important priority for you as a Bitcoiner.
This week we saw Canada sending out questionnaires to Bitcoin holders or suspected Bitcoin holders that included questions like asking if the if they use cryptocurrency mixing services or tumblers. If so, what services do you use?
Can you provide us with the tracing history along with all the addresses you mixed? Why did you use these services? Francis Puliot was pushing back. He's obviously a most people, most listeners will know who he is. He's a Canadian Bitcoiner, runs Bull Bitcoin.
He was pushing back against the try, you know, attempted collection of this information. He tweeted out that there's an easy like here's here's how you can get cash for Bitcoins in Canada without having to use a bank account, a P2P platform, or a Bitcoin ATM.
You register for a credit card that's not linked to a bank account, you withdraw a cash advance at an ATM, and then you use my bills or Bull Bitcoin, which are his businesses to pay the card balance with Bitcoin. So then you've got cash for Bitcoin without you know having to without giving up your anonymity.
And so then he actually got replied to by the head of the revenue authority in Canada, basically the equivalent of the IRS. And he just his name's Jared Adams, he just said duly noted. And then Francis was like, I'm curious what you meant by washing machine, because he he tried to play off this little joke where he said like washing machine.gif.
You know, obviously alluding to money laundering. Francis, like, I'm curious what you meant by washing machine. And he's like, I bet, I bet you're curious. So there's also already this this sort of pushback from from Bitcoiners, which I love against the government like in this kind of collection attempt of information.
So, like if this happened in the United States, and you got this request like what options would you consider i don't want you to like tell me what you think you necessarily would choose but so how would you evaluate it it's going to happen in the united states okay francis should have been a little bit more delicate if i was him because he's like i mean look they're following him on twitter right like like this dude's like a known bitcoiner that's not it doesn't seem to be it doesn't seem to be his style but you know that's that's his
No he's very in your face style and i love it i love it but you know it was it was definitely on brand for him yes it was i all of people don't respect it enough all of us known bitcoiners like we're putting our fucking heads on a plate like if i yeah if if i truly at the end of the day like i said to myself in like 2013 like matt you need to get as much bitcoin as possible when this is all settled and done like you have to have like the plan is to have as much bitcoin as possible like I want to have more bitcoin than the person next to me if that was truly my plan like I should
Have never ruined my my privacy like I should have I should have I've should have stayed as just some random anonymous account I had like plenty of anonymous accounts on like Reddit IRC Bitcoin talk and I purged all those accounts and I went like public in in the middle of the bear market because you know, I don't know, because everyone was calling me a fucking idiot, and I just had way too much ego.
Like I shouldn't have fucking done that. But now, like the cat's out of the bag. So I think like having actual real faces advocating this movement is like really important. So I've dedicated myself. I've dedicated to myself to that. Also, like Coinbase, like fucked me. Like they they gave the IRS like all of my withdrawal addresses and purchase history from 2013 to 2015.
Thanks, Coinbase. Yeah, so I got docs like super hard. So like it kind of just like threw it out there. I was like, fuck it. I'm like, I'm going public. But I would advise like most Bitcoiners should just of all never fucking connect your public identity, especially online to Bitcoin.
You really shouldn't even tell many people about it, like just your closest friends, family, even them, like maybe not, you know. Like it you have to like balance, I want to shill it to my six closest friends versus they you know keep keep it as close in it as possible that I own Bitcoin. Don't text about it and stuff like that. So like that's the first step.
And like the second thing is like you should expect this, you should expect this to happen, and you should be ready to disclose addresses. Like if you're a publicly known Bitcoin figure, yeah, like you can't like I can't just be like, I don't have any Bitcoin.
Sure, like that's like I can't like what I don't have any bit, like I lost all my Bitcoin, and but but I'm I'm running a podcast and fucking voting accessing five hours a day on this, you know, like oh yeah, but I like you can't do that, right? So like you need to be ready to have like at least a certain amount of funds to disclose to them, and you have to make sure that those funds don't connect to anything else, that you have to make sure they don't connect to any transactions you have or any kind of things that you know you'd prefer not to be seen.
So it's important to get your ducks in an order now. Yep. You know, it's important to be like when my government forces me to disclose my addresses, I'm ready for that. And if you're gonna disclose addresses, you want those addresses to have run through CoinJoin, Wasabi wallet, because you want to break up that transaction history, you don't want them to know everything you fucking did.
And if you do that after they ask you to disclose, that's super fucking obvious. Yeah, and all these governments aren't on top of their shit. So like if you live in like a Western democracy, like CoinJoin isn't banned. I like I really hope like they don't ban it anytime soon, but they might at some point, but like you have plausible deniability on that being fucking banned because they never explicitly said it.
So like you should do it now, right? You should have like certain addresses, yeah. Even if you're not doing anything like illegal or whatever, like that you should want to hide, like you should just do it anyway because privacy is important, privacy matters, and it helps everyone, right? Like you doing running your coins through a coin join will help everyone else's privacy as well, because the more Bitcoin we can get to be coin joined, the more private the UTXO set becomes in general, right?
Right, you're hiding in a crowd, so you need more people. That's why recently I made it like my mission to basically get as many people as possible to use Wasabi because I want I think it's in like important like we were talking about like what makes a good Bitcoin citizen. Well, like I'll appreciate you way more, like if you like help like honest Bitcoiners, yeah, like protect their privacy, you know.
And we have we have like a phase here where like they're ignoring us, kind of, you know, so like you should be prepared for that. Like you're buying from a KYC exchange, like if you if you plan on not disclosing, which I'm not advocating because that is breaking the law of whatever country is forcing you to advocate, and we're being recorded right now, so I would never say that, right?
But if if you were to not disclose, like all your shit from a KYC exchange is linked to you, so like you should probably mix that, right? Like, you don't want them to know you Coinbase shouldn't know every single transaction you make with Bitcoin, like even if you're a complete law abiding citizen, like they shouldn't fucking know that.
Right. And they and they've they've obviously invested money in chain analytics technology. They have to in their defense, like they have to. And like a lot of it, a lot of it right now is like plausible deniability, like their chain analysis isn't that good. Sure. But they have the majority of making an effort of some kind.
Yeah, the majority of criminals aren't actually mixing, right? The majority of criminals are just fucking doing things, and they're like relatively easy to get caught. Yeah, and Coinbase just wants to say to the regulators, you know, we're doing our due diligence, and all the other exchanges, they also all the ones that connect to fiat, they all have chain analysis companies, and they're like, you know, we're doing we're we're we're checking all the transactions, but the and that's not to dismiss the fact that neutrino is like a fucking shitty ass company and like hacking team, you can go fuck themselves.
That's besides the point. But we know your position there, yeah. But so the problem here is though, is that because we are using an immutable blockchain, that even if their tools right now aren't that good, you could get fucked.
Like, think about like the Me Too movement that's happening in the United States, right? Like you get fucked for a transaction that was like six years ago, that they like finally got their act together and started really tracking the transactions and their database is better than ever because everyone disclosed their addresses and like 90% of people disclose their ad like every single person that discloses their address, yeah, increases their database, makes it that much more effective, right?
So, like you don't want to be in the position that like five years down the road, they're like, you did this, you can go, you're you know, you're going to jail or you're gonna get fucked. Yeah, that's messed up. So when you use Bitcoin, when you use cryptocurrency in general, like you have to realize that all these things that you're doing are there forever.
So if you don't do them properly, like they're gonna be able to go all the way back. They're gonna be like have a little time machine where they get to go back and just fuck you, make an example of you. So you have to be careful about it, and you have to like take it into your own hands. You have to yeah, and like all of us like we hold Bitcoin, and a lot of times you know, you hold Bitcoin for these black swan scenarios, right?
Like where you where you have like some kind of political economic crisis in your own home, wherever you're wherever your country is. Like we often get like very American centric, but like you're in Turkey or you're wherever, and like shit goes to shit. Yeah, you know, at that point, it's too late.
It's too late for you to pretend to your government that's out to fuck you that that you're that you don't own Bitcoin. But if you if you bought Bitcoin from a KYC exchange two years prior and you mixed it right away, then there's some plausible deniability that you either sold it or you lost it in between those two years, right?
But if they know the exact address where your Bitcoin is, they know it's still fucking there. They know you didn't get rid of it, they know exactly how much you have, and they can just fuck you for it. Yeah, so you have to be prepared. So my Bitcoin is all fully KYCable, like KYC and transparent point. Like I hold it on a ledger, you know, except for what I have on my lightning node, and it's all from like Coinbase and Cash App and Kraken, which are all KYC exchanges.
I've never used I've never used local Bitcoins, although I do want to try it out at some point, but so I want to start using Wasabi, and what is like how should I approach it? How I mean I heard you talking on I listened to about half, I was able to listen to about half of the episode with his name's Alex, the guy from Wasabi, right?
No, Adam. Adam. Adam, sorry, right. Yeah, with Adam. Yeah. With Adam. Well, he's been keeping his name secret for a while until it until Wasabi blew up. Now he's there. Yeah, and it's so it sounded like we shouldn't be joining like joining transactions or UTXOs back together after they've been run through with Sabi's.
Well, we disagree on that. We disagree on that logic. Yeah, so you think it's okay, but not, but he thinks it's not, or vice versa. Okay, look, the most private way to so Wasabi mixes your transactions with other people, right? Right. So basically you have 50 people all contribute, they have a default amount.
It's 0.1 bitcoin, right? So what is that like $380 right now, right? Every CoinJoin process 0.1 Bitcoin? Or can you go higher than that? Okay. Technically, like right in the beginning, like if you send like two Bitcoin in the beginning, it'll split it mostly into 0.1s. But like if someone else on the network wants to like coin join like a 0.4 with you or like a 0.6 with you or something, it'll do that like once or twice.
Okay. To like speed up the process. But at the end of the day, when you finish all your mixing rounds, because it does multiple rounds basically, you're gonna end up with a bunch of point one outputs. You're gonna end up with a bunch of 400 outputs. Okay, and you're paying a transaction fee, an on an on-chain transaction fee for every one of those coin joints.
Yeah. And you're paying them a fee, but the fee is negligible for them. It's like 0.003%, or whatever it is, it's like at the end of the day, you go through the whole fucking mixing process and like they didn't take that much money. Right. But there are there are like many on-chain fees that are being paid, right? You're doing like yeah, so point being like do this now while fees are low, kind of thing.
Like right. Well, so that's an issue. They they use the new address format, BEC32, which is the new native SegWit address format. So so you have the lowest on-chain transaction fees possible, and they intentionally choose fees that are pretty low, so like you don't actually get confirmed like the net the absolute next block.
Right during the coin join process, it like it'll take like eight, 10 blocks. So like actually, your if you send more Bitcoin to Wasabi, it'll go quicker because it needs to wait for the confirms before it'll go through another set of you get what I'm saying?
Like the more you send to it, the quicker it'll go because it needs to wait for the confirms first for each transaction before it goes through another coin joint. Sure. So so the argument is so the problem with Bitcoin transact. Well, the pro the way Bitcoin transactions work is the more inputs you have, the higher the transaction fee.
Doesn't matter if the inputs are like one cent or whatever, you know, like 200 Satoshis, or I don't even know what one what one cent now is like a thousand, ten thousand Satoshi, whatever it is. It doesn't matter if it's like 10,000 Satoshi transaction or whatever, the number of inputs you have that go into each transaction to dictates the size of the transaction, not the amount, not it's not the amount of bitcoin that dictates your fee.
It's it dictates how many inputs are put in, how many transactions are put into your transaction, right? Right. So yeah, because that that is the that's just more bytes, right? And then so the fee, the fee is based on the number of bytes in the transaction, basically. So yeah, so the issue with wasabi is if it ends if you take 10 bitcoin and you put it through Wasabi, you have a hundred outputs of point one.
Okay, right. So if we hit a fee crisis again, your your transaction fees are gonna be higher than they would be if you know, like let's say you wanted to send like thousand dollars, you're gonna have to use three. Let's say you want to send, I mean, we don't know what the price of Bitcoin is.
So let's in the next fee crisis, the price of Bitcoin's gonna be way higher. But let's say you want to send like 0.4 bitcoin to someone, right? You need to use four four inputs to send that, right? And so and that's that's a lot more. So if you had a one Bitcoin input, then then you have one input, and then you get your change, you get your change UTXO back.
So you just have the one input, yeah. So there's a balancing act here, right? So the most private way you can use Wasabi is that you just leave them in the point one outputs. Sure, okay. But your your fees might be higher in the future. So if that's gonna stop you, like I think it's better to combine some of them and do it anyway.
Like you're still in a better, you're in a more private situation than you were pre-wasabi, even if you combine, but you'll be in the most private situation if you never combine them. How how exactly does combining them reduce your anonymity? Well, because you're connecting those outputs together, right?
So if what you should definitely not do is like send two Bitcoin to Wasabi and then get 20 20.1 inputs, 20.1 outputs, and then combine them all into one two bitcoin transaction. Like if someone looks at the blockchain, they're like, okay, two Bitcoin went in, and then two Bitcoin went out, right?
That's connected to you. But if you do smaller amounts, like in different random combinations at different times, yeah. Then it's gonna be harder for them to connect it to you. And if you use wasabi, wasabi lets you s change up the anonymity set, so how many people you mix with, sure. So you can raise your default anonymity set to like 200, 300.
Okay. Right? It defaults at 51. You'll pay a little bit more for that. Negligible. Right now it's negligible. Yeah, okay. Yeah. And then you combine after the fact, like your privacy reduced is like, you know, like it would be more private if you didn't combine. But like it doesn't really, I think it's still a huge net benefit for you to combine.
Now the third thing is if we do implement Schnor, yep, which I think we will, I think there will be pretty much no opposition to it. And it's really nice that we have all the Bitcoin cash haters and everything just like they all got wrecked and they all left us. Yeah. So like they're not like really in the argument anymore.
But once we have Schnorr, you'll be able to combine signatures. So you won't have that issue where you won't have that issue where if you're combining multiple inputs, it it hurts your privacy. Right, because it won't be right if it won't be visible on the blockchain, it'll be all hashed into the Schnorr signature.
Right. So if you're like a long-term holder, and you think Schnorr is actually gonna pass, like we'll actually get Schnorr, then you don't actually like if you can just if you just keep them in point ones, like you'll be fine, you won't have any fee pressure. Oh, cool, that makes sense. But but it's like, you know, do I want to bet on that?
Do I want to do whatever? Look at the end of the day, we're gonna be mixing for the rest of our lives, is like the way I look at it. Yeah, and I think if you're gonna let that hold you back, like just combine them up your anonymity set and just combine them. And that's the difference between being no power, he's like an engineer, and he's like, Well, the most private thing you can do is like don't combine.
Yep. Yeah, and he's not wrong. I agree. But it's practically speaking, don't let don't let perfect be the enemy. And what no para says, what no para says is like the most private way to use Wasabi is you use it as like a spending wallet. So like you send one Bitcoin to it, and then every time you buy something with Bitcoin, you buy it using Wasabi.
And like you never actually consolidate into a separate wallet that might not respect your privacy, doesn't have good coin control, mixes UTXOs together, sends all your transactions to a private server. Like you don't have to deal with any of that because you're just spending straight through Wasabi. And like that's fucking great. Like I agree, dude.
But like you need to get to the point where like all those transactions are mixed first before you could then use it as like you know, like I so like mix your whole stash, fucking store it as securely as you can store it, you know. Hope Ledger's not sharing all your fucking information, and then you know you use Wasabi as your spending wallet.
You can do both, you know? Yeah, and I just I think it's a net benefit for everyone if they just use Wasabi. Yeah, I mean your hodl the stash that you're hodling, it still makes sense to go ahead and wasabi that stuff and then bring it back to your hardware wallet. But you have to do you would I need to get a new hardware wallet or like just like reset my hardware wallet basically?
Okay, so I know those those are using new they're using new addresses every time, right? But is there any way to like connect it to that particular device or anything? Yes. So first of all, you're using Ledger Live, I'm assuming, right? Yeah, so yeah, receive, yeah. I mean, I haven't used I haven't actually used it much because most of most most of my Bitcoin I brought like into that ledger device before ledger live was out but whatever they whatever they had but right you're using ledger's app you're using ledger so i was using their node and everything to do all that yeah right so so if you use ledger you're trusting ledger with all of your public keys basically
Right so you're trusting that that they're not logging this shit you know they they seem like good people like they're probably not logging it but they might be it's just they're they're a trusted third party right but it's worth noting that they could be compromising your privacy and if if if you ordered if you ordered your ledger from ledger to your house or whatever like they have it connected to your name and your home address and all this shit.
Yep. So if if they wanted to be a honeypot like that could be an issue. All right so yeah but that that was why does that matter I just I just wanted to put that as a no it's good to be thorough I appreciate that yeah and a lot of these things are like if you're not if you don't live in America and your threat model is like just your own government like you live in like Uganda or something like Turkey like the Turkish government like ledger isn't getting compromised by the Turkish government right like it would be it would be like the Europeans or America or whatever.
Like it would be so like that's not even a threat to them. But but it's worth noting and like the way basically you would get around that is you would you would set up an electrum personal server with your own full node and then you would use Electrum with your treasure. I mean with your with your ledger or your treasure.
Either one doesn't matter. Right. But either way. And that's better because I'm not I'm not using ledger, like I'm not sending transactions through ledger's node. You're not using Ledger's node. Yeah. Exactly. Okay. Use Ledger's node they can try can track all your shit right simple. So I need to get Electrum set up first. And then with Sebastian. And then I don't want to scare people.
Like I don't want to like you can use ledger. If you were you if you were already using Ledger. Yeah. And if you're already using Ledger live you're already trusting them with all that shit. So if you use wasabi with it, you know, you're still better off. Then only Ledger can find it. I get that but like you know I want to like I think I'm at the point now you know that I've been holding for well you know over a couple years now.
So I'm at the point where I want to like kind of level this stuff up and I get it like I don't want to scare people away from getting in at all listening to this. But I think a lot of the you know the audience here is is kind of in the same boat as me and I think we'll get a lot out of like learning from you how to level up to the next level.
You know like we're all I think all of us are using hardware wallets or most of us that are listening are using hardware wallets at this point. Yeah it's like it's a difficult position where you're I'm like trying to find like I try and find a balancing act where it's like accessible but also advanced you know yeah yeah no I think the audience of this podcast though is like a little like a little bit more on the like we're using hardware wallets at this point.
We need to figure out what to do next to help protect our privacy and help increase the privacy of other Bitcoiners and just those kind of best practices you know I guess so right now the easiest way to interact with a hardware wallet and not give treasure or Ledger all your information is is to do Electrum personal server with your own node and then you connect through Electrum with it.
And Electrum has all these nice built-in coin control features as well. So you can pick which UTXO you send and stuff. Just like that's in Wasabi has really great coin control features, and that's one of the things I like about it. But Wasabi is a hot wallet, which is on your computer with no hardware wallet. They are working, I no power brought this up in the most recent episode.
They're working on hardware wallet integration, which would be fantastic. That's huge. Because then I could just be like to people, just everything should just interact through Wasabi, and you know, you got Tor and all that all that jazz. Okay. Can Wasabi run off your own personal node too? Yes, which is beautiful.
Cool. So wasabi, if you're running a personal note on the same computer that you're running Wasabi on, yeah, you don't even have to fucking switch any configuration. It just automatically pulls your block data. It just knows, it just detect is the coolest second thing ever. Okay. And besides the point, Wasabi is connecting through Tor.
They use this filters, they use these filters to bring in the block data so it's not exposing it to the actual node. So actually, the way Wasabi set it up, they basically did like a double blind tour. So even if you don't use your own full node, it's pretty fucking private.
Okay. So we're talking about what we were talking about was where do you send it back? You send it from Ledger to Wasabi. Yep. And then it's time to send it back. Do I need to create a new wallet? Yes. But that's what I thought. You don't need a new seed.
You don't need a new seed. We have something called BIP44, which is it's it's an account number, so it derives news new addresses, a whole new set of addresses from the same seed that are not connected to each other. Okay. So if you're on ledger live, it's called add account.
Okay. And if you're on Electrum, it's called BIP44 account number, which defaults to zero. So you can switch it to one, two, three, four, whatever, however many wallets you want. And when you want to go back, you pick the number that you're trying to access. Like you have to put your seed in, but then you also have to put in the account number of whatever. So you create a new account off of your same seed.
And the reason you do that is because so many of these wallets, I mean, if if you're using Electrum personal server, yeah. And Electrum with your with your hardware wallet, it doesn't matter as much because you have coin control, so you're picking which UTXOs you're sending out. But if you're using like Ledger Live, like if you have other Bitcoin in there, it'll automatically combine that shit when it sends out a transaction.
So if you did Wasabi and you send it back to the same wallet that you already have Bitcoin in, like it's gonna get linked to your pre-wasabi Bitcoin. So so what I say is like create a new wallet, and the easiest way to do that is is to create a new account, and then you have the same seed, you have all the same things that you're already securing with, and you don't have to worry about that shit.
Nice. Okay, so I don't have to get like a new ledger. No, you just create a new account on on the same seat, and you'll get a whole set of new fresh addresses that are just completely disconnected from the other set. Excellent. All right. I'm gonna get this all set up. I'm also working on getting BTC pay server set up on that same node.
I'm using Pierre Rochard's node launcher. And I just confirmed with Pierre, I'll let everyone know. March 29th, I'm gonna record an episode with Pierre, which is super exciting. We're gonna do just a bunch of a bunch on lightning and BIP 157 and all that stuff. So look forward to that. But I'm using Pierre Rochard's launch launcher.
Yeah, it's dope. And it's I met Pierre. I met Pierre for the first time like a year ago, a year and a half ago, maybe. Yeah. And like I knew that dude from online since like 2013. I was like such a little fanboy. I was such a little fanboy about it, and like he embraced me and just like he's he's the best.
He's what I can do up, dude. Yeah, cool. I'm excited. I literally I'm like all Linux now. I have one machine that I like set up with Windows and ran the node launcher just so that I knew how to run node launcher on Windows because a lot of people that I talked to were asking me advice on running no launcher on Windows.
Yeah and like he's fucking killing it. I fucking love it. It's the easy it's the easiest way to set up a bitcoin, a Bitcoin and lightning full note. Yeah, that's what I did too. And I've I'm on this kick now. Like I'm doing it for this podcast, and I just want to test out all this stuff. I've been in like web product development for my whole career basically.
And so I love testing the products and letting people know, like giving feedback, you know, go on GitHub. And I've done it with you know, posted a few things on Zap and all that, like just trying to help people out with a little bit of feedback here and there and troubleshooting some things. And so I had a little box and I posted that this thread yesterday that I shared with you, DM'd it to you about my nodes.
And I bought this little box, it's like a hundred and twenty dollar computer, it's like the size of a little Casa node, basically the same exact size, but it has an Intel processor and four gigs of RAM, and then you just add in a little two and a half inch hard drive. And so I thought it would be a great little bit. Yeah.
Throw that in. And I put Linux on it, and that was the first like lightning node that I ran about a year ago and did everything on command line and stuff. And that was a lot of fun to kind of get back to that. Because I've I'm at that point in my career now where I'm doing more managing than coding. And it's just really fun to get back in and like get on the command line and code some stuff up again.
Or at least feel like you are. So that was cool. But then I, you know, I want to try out the node launcher. So this comes pre-installed with Windows 10 on like a little SD card, basically, that's inside the device. So it doesn't come with enough, like you need storage, but it comes with the operating system pre-installed on a little 32 gig SD card.
So I fired up Windows 10. And within I'd say seven minutes, I was syncing from the Genesis block with the node launcher, super easy. It's in the process right now. I'm gonna install LND and then BTC pay server, wasabi wallet, and Electrum.
And I can I install Electrum on Windows? Yeah, of course. Yeah, I mean fuck Windows, but you can't. All right, I get I get that. Yeah, I totally agree with you. But I can't. And this is like I'm doing this because you know I want to help other people too. And lots, most a lot of people run Windows. So I want to do it. The majority run Windows. People don't realize the majority still run Windows.
Yeah, yeah. So I'm excited about it. I'm still I've got about a year left to sync up, and then I'll get all this stuff going. And I'll coin join my s my my HODL stash and send it back through Electro Electrum, and it'll it'll be a lot better than it is now because it's just out there in the open on the blockchain and very very I guess anal analyzable at this point.
Yeah I think it's really funny when like Luke Luke Jr. Key he talks about the Bitcoin blockchain is being too bloated and we need to reduce the block size and stuff. Like this whole idea that I can sync from Genesis with basically a Raspbi if I wanted to like which is ridiculous but I would never do that.
Like takes like a month. But you could do it you know and meanwhile like Ethereum like you need like the most powerful server ever to like fucking to like fucking run it. And like we're like oh my god like I need to buy like an Intel computer with like for 200 and like then I can sync in 15 hours or like two days or something like fuck you man.
Like that's ridiculous like that's this little thing cost me 188 bucks. It's been syncing for eight days. I think it'll probably take about 10 10 days to two weeks to finish. Oh shit. Which is not terrible it's not terrible. What's your internet like the bottleneck is the is the validation it's not the internet.
Exactly yeah so yeah I have a hundred megabyte per second download so the bottleneck is the validation. Yeah it's just this it's a mobile processor. So it's it's an Intel add-out process. So that's why it's so damn good. I have two of those. I have two of those bad boys. Yeah. So at home. It takes a couple weeks, but it's still, you know, and that's I get it.
Like, I understand that that's not the user experience that we want to have for everyone. But I mean, like my 900 desktop computer, like fucking running Linux, like I was able to sync within 10 hours, 12 hours. The fact is that it though that it's possible on that little device.
And if you if you if that's what you had the funds for, or that that's what was accessible for you. Like, all right, you wait two weeks and that's that sucks. But you can still participate, you know. Yeah, you're running a node on a global decentralized financial network. Like that's insane. Yeah, yeah.
And you, I mean, there's no way that you could, you know, run an Ethereum server for 120 bucks. No. It just not possible. Not at all possible. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, we this is why this is why we are it chose this path, you know, as as Bitcoiners to prioritize decentralization.
And we all got we should we should be able to validate what's going on on the network. And that that's what makes Bitcoin good. I mean, that's that's the value proposition. That's what gives you the censorship and resistance and the inflation resistance and the confiscation resistance and all that.
So yeah, exactly. But my point is like it's a balancing act. Like you shouldn't like we don't need to run it on a fucking $20 computer. We don't need to run it on like a $40 computer. Like, yeah, that would be great, but like we are at the same time, like we're trying to set up a global financial network here. So like you need to you and it needs to be a balancing act, like I bandwidth, I think is like the biggest restrictor.
And the block stream satellite helped a lot with that because it doesn't affect your bandwidth, it's just blind, just automatic download. But yeah, it it needs to be a balancing. Like let's not like get too crazy, especially when it involves like changing consensus rules and stuff. Like this is a change resistant system, as you talked about earlier, and like it's already nimble enough, like if anything, you know, what most people don't realize about us small blockers is that we were mostly all big blockers before we realized why that was bad.
Yeah, like we started we started with we should just scale the system by just increasing the block size, and then we realized like that is not like a tenable future, but it we will probably have to in the future at some point, you know. And I'm not gonna advocate for it now because I'm not a fucking sadist, but when it when we hit like like when we hit like a critical mass and like it's absolutely fucking necessary, like it'll fucking happen.
But until then, like we stay the course and we stay conservative, and we don't do consensus changes to reduce that on unnecessarily when we have I mean personally, I think more people are running nodes now. Like more real people are running nodes, like real economic nodes than than ever before, you know.
It it doesn't matter what your numbers say, like we have like real people running more nodes than before. Yeah, it seems that way, and it you can't tell with those numbers, you know, who's real and who's just some kind of script that put out a thousand nodes on AWS or something. Exactly. Yeah.
Alright. So just to wrap up, and I'm I'm gonna ask you to get a little cosmic. Do it for Marty. So we get through all this the next 10-20 years, like the state attack that's the state attacks that are coming and the hard fork decisions that we have to make, and we get through everything, and Bitcoin becomes the native current the native money of the internet, and then you know, inevitably the native money of our human economy.
Tell me what that future looks like to you. Like I assume you've you've daydreamed about it or something. Like, what do you see in a you know for 30, 40, 50 years from now in in a Bitcoin world? What's it what's it look like? I think it looks like a bunch of little local nation states that are connected globally more than ever before.
But that are completely wouldn't say self-sufficient, but like they're governed on a more local level. Okay. And a more decentralized form of governance than we have now. Right. And they're probably more socialistic in their in their little in their little localities, but they interact in a like a global capitalist system.
Cool. That's like straight free market and free trade everywhere. You know, like the idea the ideal utopia here is like instead of a hundred and fifty countries, you have 20,000 little ones.
Right. And you have the seasteaders and you have the guys going out to space and you have all of them doing all these different crazy shits. And every single little locale is just trying to benefit their own little locale. Right. And but we're all connected through Bitcoin. We're all connected through mesh networks.
We're all connected through drone swarms, through, you know, all these these crazy things that are all culminating together at the at the same exact time. 3D printing, you know, like like I imagine a world where like you send an order out to another locale, and they produce they they receive your payment, they produce what you need, they a robot, a robot produces what you need in a 3D printer, then it goes to a drone, and then
The drone delivers it in like almost like an onion routing type scenario where like it passes off to another drone, passes off to another drone, and then it comes to your locale, and then like you're paying them in a non state currency, basically Bitcoin, yep. That that they they that they can trust, and then they they then you take that product, and then maybe you add something to that product, and then you pass it on or whatever.
Just like super local creed oriented governance. It's like it's like that's what the dream future is. And like some people will call those, I guess, citadels. Right. Like they'll have like Bitcoin citadels. Like with super rich Bitcoiners that are that are controlling the different areas.
And then my I look, all the super rich will have a ton of Bitcoin. They won't all be original Bitcoiners, but I don't know. I think I think a lot of the issues we have is that we have hit the situation where we have just these massive societies, and yes, yeah.
People can't coalesce on the same principles and the same ideas when they're like done. Yeah, like yeah, like that we can sustain like 120, you know, like meaningful relationships. That's what we're capable of, right? And then I think that also applies on a social level as well.
So like one of the reasons I live in Lawrence, Kansas, it's a hundred thousand people, which is like a manageable-ish size for me. Like that's what I like, you know. Kansas City's great, New York's great, Chicago's great. I love the big cities, but like I have like this community here, and I know the town pretty well, and I feel like the town's kind of responsive to my family's needs to an extent, you know what I mean?
I have eight million neighbors, yeah, exactly. And that's that's it's it's a relic maybe of kind of this this age of centralization, like these technologies and the way that our economies developed required, you know, these locuses of capitalist activity.
And so, you know, it made sense to that every you know, like all this activity was sort of aggregating in certain places around the world and so we have these these major cities around the world that are the kind of hubs of international global economic activity and they're big because they've got to support like that importance there's just all kinds of economic economic activity having happening there so they've got there's a lot of people that need to support that but I can see with Bitcoin in a future that's you know we have economic self-sovereignty and individuals are their own bank we've separated money in state that removes a lot of that
Centralization power away from the state and sort of re-orients politics to be more local I think less power at the federal level because they're not controlling the purse strings anymore. So yeah that's sort of yeah their their main power is is control of the money.
Exactly. So like once once we distribute the control of the wealth we separate the state and money right should it sort of seem like it would sort of naturally kind of come to more a more a more yeah more local decentralized kind of government because that's just what humans want I guess kind of naturally to have control over their their communities I guess or have some I mean I didn't I still think we'll have like big ass city states you know like we'll still have like you know like 15 million people in New York or whatever.
Sure. Yeah. But like it'll just become more local across the board. I think. Yeah. I mean that's that's that's the future I hope for. There's there's other paths we could take, but that's a good one. I think every yeah, I think everyone I think everyone benefits way more from that than all the alternative paths.
That's that's the one that's the one I'm hoping for. And like that's also where I come from when I when we think about all these decisions that we're making with Bitcoin now, like you have to think like 20, 30, 50 years ahead of time. And that's fucking crazy for a human to have to fucking think about because we don't we're not trained to think that far ahead, you know.
So so like your network needs to be resilient against drone swarms, like anonymous drone swarms that you don't you don't know who's fucking doing it, but there's like 300 drones like outside with C4 on them, like trying to blow up your nodes. Yeah, you know, yeah, yeah. And like and then after that's all done, you don't know who did it because they're all off the shelf parts that could have been produced in any fucking city state.
You don't fucking know, you know, like it could have been produced anywhere. Any 3D printer could have made that. So like you're like questioning where that came from, you have no idea, but you need it to be resilient enough that if 100 nodes get knocked out, 200 nodes get knocked out, you know, a bunch of miners get knocked out, you're still good.
You're the that money is still good because all the individual parties benefit from a single individual party can benefit dramatically from some type of black swan event. So you need you need it to be cost prohibitive for them to do that.
Yeah, and it th there's another aspect of Bitcoin's incentive structure, you know, like it, and it's well, it's really, I guess, an aspect of sound money. That it makes you think more long term, right? It extends your your time preference. And when you have this this fiat money that's inflationary, it just you it incentives you to really just kind of focus on the near-term future, and you want to you want to spend it more quickly because it's it's not gonna hold value and all that, but with a with a kind of sound money that holds this value, then you start thinking more
Long term. You start thinking about positioning your children and your children's children and your you know, yeah, your great grandchildren. Yeah, you start thinking because you're like, oh look, I can I have there's a tool now that I can sort of accumulate and like through through my through my labor and my thoughtfulness and my planning, I can affect my future, you know, descendants.
And that's gonna, I mean that that incentive right there will be the way we solve those problems, you know, those potential problems, like like how to defend yourself against drone swarms. Like we'll be incentivized to figure out you know a market-based solution for all that stuff because we all want to protect our Bitcoin for our kids, you know?
So Yeah, I was I was talking to someone about this the other day, and it's actually really interesting is that in the past, like politicians, if you didn't have kids, like it was a non-start. Yeah, like we have a lot of politicians nowadays that don't have any children. That's true. And it's like you so you start questioning the incentives, you know, like Angela Merkel, like she has no children.
Like, what is she actually does she actually care about 20 years in the future? Does she care about 30 years in the future? Does she only care about the four years? You know, like the next four years. Or whatever. Like her her, yeah, like when her re-election happens, like that's a fucked up incentive system.
Yeah. Like you need an incentive system that that actually benefits like smart long-term thinking. Yeah. And I mean, I don't think you need to have kids to be concerned about the future, because you know, you've got family members, and I'm sure there's like you know, nieces and nephews and all that kind of stuff or whatever, but and I think it's I get that choice.
I mean, having like being a parent is fucking hard. You know, it's a lot of work. So I get I get the choice, and I have you know, people in my family that have chosen not to have kids and all that, and I get that. They still have you know, the I think the incentive to make a better future for their nieces and nephews kind of thing.
Sure, definitely, but I think as a politician, it's different though, yeah. Politicians are held to a higher standard, and they should be, yeah, right. Like they're they're running the fucking whatever your government is, they're running you're running your life, so like their incentive model should be like I get what you're saying, though.
I mean, it's not it's not like you're saying I don't think you're saying like you have to have kids to be a politician, but I think it's a sign like the fact that fewer politicians have kids is a is a kind of a sympathetic. It's a simp a sign, it's a red flag and a s and a symptom of Keynesianism. If you look at Europe, if you look at Europe, it's not Angela just Angela Merkel, like there's a ton of them.
Like, I'm pretty sure Theresa May doesn't have kids. Like, like there's a bunch of them that don't have kids. The French guy, Macron, he doesn't have kids, yeah, right. Right? Like, there's a bunch of them. It's it's it's a trend. It's it's so I'm I'm not saying like I'm I don't have fucking kids yet. You know, like I'm not saying that you have to have children, I'm just saying that our government systems, like their incentives aren't inherently set up for long-term thinking, they're actually inherently set up for the opposite.
Exactly. So, like the one thing that you had hedging that was that they had children and they were like, Well, we don't want to leave the shithole for our children. Yeah, and now we're seeing that less and less. The one thing you had hedging that, like after we got off the gold standard, especially, right? And now, exactly. So now it makes sense.
Like, it just it makes sense that you would have more people interested in you know being part of governments that that don't have kids because the govern the whole government, the whole system is run for the next four years for the next political cycle. Like, it's just exactly it's it's yeah, exactly.
All right, man. This has been super fun. Thank you so much. I'm really looking forward to meeting you in person at some point. Like, I'll I'll make my way to some Bitcoin conference, and yeah, you're gonna come for blockchain week, like our week we have. Yeah, I'm thinking about that. It's worth it, it's worth it. Don't come for consensus, like, don't pay for consensus.
Right, just come for all the side events. Yeah, it's it sounds like there's a lot of good stuff happening. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, just come for the side events, it's worth this. Don't pay for consensus. Definitely do not pay for it's worth this conference. Yeah, I would definitely not do it. Well, we'll show you a good time if you come to New York, and I would love, you know, if I'm if I'm ever in Kansas City, like you're the only person I know who lives there.
So yeah, man, I'd I'd love to show you around. It's actually it's a good it's a good town, it's a fun place. So yeah, I'm thinking about coming up to Nor New York for the kind of anti-consensus Bitcoin conference. I'm looking at that one or the one in Austin, which is happening. Yeah, yeah, highly recommend.
I haven't been yet. I'm I'm thinking about going this year. I'm not sure if I'm gonna go. Okay, right on. Yeah, I think I'm gonna choose between those two. Maybe I'll just like just do them both. I gotta figure it out, but you should definitely go to the one in Austin. It's worth it. I've heard such good things. Yeah, I can drive down there pretty easily. So yeah, exactly. Like you should definitely just do that one for sure.
And then, like, if you want to add on, if you want to add on blockchain week, then you know you do it. I might do that. My co-host Tommy, he works a lot in New York and Chicago and he has tons of miles, like airline miles. So he's always like, Man, Brady, just tell me. Just tell me what conference you want to go to and I'll get you a ticket. So that's yeah, you should come up.
It's a good time. And the side effects are like a the side the side events are really it's a really good with so many people flood into the city, it's pretty fucking crazy. And we actually have more people in New York than you'd expect, which is surprising because like the bid license, like Ben Lowski can go fuck himself. Like completely fucked us over, and somehow we still ended up with like a major Bitcoin crew over here.
We have a very good, very good Bitcoin crew. Nice. All right. I'm gonna consider that like very seriously, and that would be a lot of fun to meet up in person. And thank you so much for taking the time tonight to hang out and talk Bitcoin. Really appreciate it, man. Can can I show my pod? Oh yeah, of course. We're we're tales from the crypt.
Search Tales from the Crypt on your favorite podcast app. And I specifically record rabbit hole recap with Marty Bent, which is on that same stream. And that's it's weekly news, just the top news, and no bullshit. We usually consume alcohol with it, mostly scotch, and it's it's a good time.
So that's tftc.io. I feel like the overlap of TFTC listeners and citizen Bitcoin listeners are probably like close to 100%. Yeah, it's like super high. But Marty wouldn't Marty wouldn't forgive me if I didn't if I didn't put my of course if I didn't give my free show out at the end.
If you're somehow not subscribed to Tales from the Crypt yet, make sure you go do that. It is there's maybe three or four Bitcoin podcasts that are like listen to it as soon as humanly possible, as soon as it pops up in my in my podcast app. And Tales from the Crypt has been one from basically the beginning. So and it got even better when when Mac joined joined Marty and started doing the weekly rabbit hole recap episodes.
They're they're great. Yeah, damn right. Hell yeah. Thank you. I appreciate I appreciate the endorsement. And also obviously, subscribe to Citizen Bitcoin if you haven't already. Yeah, that'd be great. You should do that. We're gonna have more of these interviews coming up. I'm gonna keep trying to interview as many of the prominent Bitcoiners that have you know been important to my my journey, and hopefully that will help all of you out as well.
So with that, I think we'll say goodnight. Thanks again, man, and take care. Thank you, dude. Stay humble stacks sets. All right. We out. Awesome. That was great. I think we did really well. Oh man, we went for well over two hours.
Yeah.
All right, Bitcoiners. So what'd you think about that one? Let me and Matt know on Twitter. I am at Citizen Bitcoin and Matt is at Matt Odell. If you got this far, chances are you enjoyed the show, and if that's the case, please do take a couple moments to rate the Citizen Bitcoin pod wherever you get your podcasts.
We're just getting going here, and every review right now is worth like ten reviews later on, so I'm ten times more appreciative if you could take some time to do that for us now. It'd be awesome. Thanks for joining from all over the world. I never get tired of looking at the map of the podcast downloads.
Bitcoin is truly global, even for this little podcast. So wherever you are in the world, I'm glad you're here and take care out there, Bitcoiners.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Matt Odell and I went for over two hours talking governance, mining, UASF, self-sovereignty, Canada, privacy, Venezuela and Bitcoin’s future. We also drank some Laphroaig and got cosmic for our boy Marty Bent.
Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/citizenbitcoin
Citizen Bitcoin Podcast: https://citizenbitcoin.world
Citizen Bitcoin on Medium: https://medium.com/@citizenbitcoin
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the episode:
Tales from the Crypt: http://tftc.io
Canada’s bitcoin information request forms: https://news.bitcoin.com/canada-tax-agency-poses-probing-questions-to-cryptocurrency-owners/
Francis Pouliot responds to Canadian government bitcoin information requests: https://www.ccn.com/canada-scheme-audit-bitcoin-tax-evaders
Wasabi Wallet: https://www.wasabiwallet.io/
ObiWanKenobit thread on fiat’s attack on bitcoin: https://twitter.com/ObiWanKenoBit/status/1105882193199394816