Murad Mahmudov: Monetary Revolution, Blockchain Archaeology, Bitcoin's Prospects
Murad is a well known bitcoiner who really burst onto the scene last year with a couple great medium posts and twitter threads and, of course, some fire podcast episodes. But Murad hasn’t recorded a podcast for a while and I was grateful to be able to talk with him today. He recently cofounded Adaptive Capital, a crypto hedge fund and in this episode we talk a bit about how it’s going at Adaptive Capital, about the near to medium term prospects for the bitcoin price, Murad explains some of the onchain analytics he uses and explains how and why he uses technical analysis in combination with the onchain analysis. We then get into the nature of money and the possible socio-cultural outcomes of bitcoin.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? I hope you all are well. Thanks for joining me today for a banger of a discussion about Bitcoin with Murad Mahmudov. But first a word about Layer1BTC.com.
Layer 1 is your source for the best Bitcoin merch. Shout out to Nick Ward, the designer and Bitcoiner running the show over there. He's got shirts, hats, hoodies, mugs, and stickers. So many designs to choose from. You can click on partners and choose Citizen Bitcoin to shop for merch that supports this podcast.
That includes the default Keynesian Recovery Center design. Bitcoin is teaching us all what money really is. And that's nothing short of revolutionary in this day and age. So that's Layer OneBTC.com. I'm proud to be a partner of Layer One alongside with Stephan Livera and Peter McCormack. Good company to keep. And Layer One is a great Bitcoin company.com.
Alright, let's dive into this one.
So, Murad is a well-known Bitcoiner who really burst onto the scene last year with a couple of great Medium posts, many fire Twitter
Threads and of course some epic podcast episodes with the likes of Marty Bent, Matt Odell, Pierre Rochard, Michael Goldstein, Pomp, Stephan Livera, and Alex Svetsky. You should definitely check those out if you haven't listened to them yet. But Maraud hasn't recorded a podcast for a while, and I was grateful to be able to talk with him today.
He recently co-founded Adaptive Capital, a crypto hedge fund. And in this episode, we talk a bit about how it's going at Adaptive Capital, about the near to medium term prospects for the Bitcoin price. Maraud explains some of the on-chain analytics he uses and explains how and why he uses technical analysis in combination with those on-chain analytics.
Of course, then we get into the nature of money, Austrian economics, talk about the possible socio-cultural outcomes of Bitcoin. It was just a great time. Turned into a banger of an episode. So here we go.
Alright, I've got Murad Mahmudov on the show today. Really excited to welcome you, Maraud. Thanks for coming on. Thank you for having me. Yeah, absolutely. Maraud is from Azerbaijan, a post-Soviet country between Turkey and Russia. He came to the U.S. To study at university, and as I gather, discovered Bitcoin while in China for a month to study or for a semester to study abroad.
Is that right? That's correct. Cool. You then worked on Wall Street for a while doing analysis work, and recently co-founded the crypto hedge fund Adaptive Capital along with Willie Woo, David Puell, and your brother, Masir. Correct. It's pretty co it's pretty cool, man.
So can you tell us more about Adaptive Capital and like what you guys are up to and how things are going for you? Yeah, absolutely. So adaptive capital is a hedge fund that I've started with David Priel, Willie Wu, and my brother. Essentially, a lot of my Princeton and Goldman friends launched crypto funds like late 2017, early 2018, at the peak of that recent bubble that we had.
I'm really happy that I didn't because frankly, a lot of those funds are not doing so well with having invested a lot early 2018. Instead, what we've done is I met my partners, David Peel and Willie Wu early to mid-2018.
And really in that period, instead of kind of launching a fund straight off the bat, we did a lot of research. We do research in an area which is called on-chain analytics. Some people refer to it as chain archaeology, but it's essentially very similar things. As you guys may know, for the first time ever, we have a technology that is both a money and a payment network at the same time.
And we believe that by studying kind of the payment or the settlement, settlement side of it, you can uncover certain predictive analytics, particularly in the medium to long term, which help you with price anal price predictions. We believe a lot of a lot of the things that are happening on-chain have certain predictive powers, and really that that's what we focus on studying.
So things like wallets, transactions, mining pool and hash rate behavior, and different kinds of derivatives thereof. And essentially that's what we focus on, and then we kind of combine our on-chain research with order book analytics and kind of traditional technical analysis, and trade trade the markets kind of in the short to medium term based off of our research.
Cool. And what's your overriding goal for adaptive capital? Are you guys pricing your returns in in like fiat money or in Bitcoin? Our goal is to make money for our investors, and all of the all of the fund is accounted for in USD. Sure. Okay, makes sense. Even though you might personally prefer something different a different way.
I understand that you have investors that you, you know, are used to a certain way. And we're I guess we're a little early since Bitcoin's not quite the unit of account globally. We'll get more into that. Before we move on to talking more about like how you guys work at adaptive capital, because I have quite a few questions there. I think it's cool that you discovered Bitcoin in China.
I mean, I think it's cool that you like you know traveled all the way to China and there and it was there that you discovered Bitcoin. So is there some kind of insight about Bitcoin that you gained from being in China, like discovering it while you were in China that you might not have gained, say if you were like in the States? Yes.
I think I was really happy for to be in China at that exact point in time. While I was at Princeton, I spend almost a year abroad in China, and that coincided, as you said, precisely with the last last bubble that we had. So late 2013, early 2014, I was there.
What happened was a bunch of my foreign friends, some other kind of students from America, mostly in Europe, who were with me, they were literally bringing bitcoins on their laptops from abroad because a lot of the Chinese exchanges still didn't have a lot of liquidity yet at the time.
And what they were doing is they were essentially bringing bitcoins into the country and selling it at like a seven to eight percent premium and essentially making money that way. And some of a couple of them later ended up working at Bitfinex, others at Coinbase, but I was really kind of fortunate to get exposure to the space relatively early on.
Some of those same guys kind of pointed me to Ethereum in early 2016. I'm not personally a big Ethereum believer at the moment, but that proved to be a lucrative trade, as you may imagine. Obviously, as anyone else, I hope I wish I invested more at the time, but I'm I'm I'm happy with kind of what what I did at least.
And yeah, I mean, in I don't want to generalize too much, but I think it's very few people in in the world, and in Asia in particular, that really invest in Bitcoin for the purposes of all these kind of, and this is going to sound a little bit cynical from from coming coming from me, but there's very few people who are investing in Bitcoin for the purposes of really kind of this cyberpunk ideals and self-sovereignty and privacy and decentralization, or even like breaking
Central banks, etc. I think almost everybody, like eight out of ten people, and that ratio is probably even higher in Asia. So when you think about kind of Japan, Korea, China, they're really they're really investing to make money, I think. Be it in the long term or be it in the short term, mostly short to medium term in my opinion.
They're essentially momentum trading Bitcoin and chasing chasing quick returns. Frankly, myself included for the most part, if I'm being honest. And essentially, I think we need to be realistic in that regard. I think some investors are here for kind of the aforementioned noble goals, as I've said, but really for the most part, everybody's here because Bitcoin is kind of like the fastest moving asset.
And this volatility is exciting. Yeah, and it's it's obviously you know provides opportunity, lots of opportunity for gains. You know, traders and speculators love the volatility. Absolutely. I would say that it moves a lot faster. For sure. And well, A, because it's so immature, right?
And it's like Bitcoin's size, even though kind of in the aggregate scheme of things, like 200 billion or whatever, it's quite a lot of money. But relative to the total addressable market of money or or kind of these monetary goods, it's still a relatively small number. So that means that it can be volatile and it can still have a lot of room for growth, which makes it an attractive bet.
But more importantly, unlike a stock, it there's no kind of there's no straightforward straightforward way to value Bitcoin, right? And because because there's no cash flows, really, I like to say that the kind of an appropriate way to think about Bitcoin is think of it as gold when humans kind of first started to discover it, right?
In the grand scheme of things. And because the world in aggregate is still kind of learning about really what it is and how it works, and the percentage of the world that is like in this asset class is still quite small. And more importantly, because it's priced kind of subjectively and cognitively, like at any given point in time, Bitcoin's price is essentially kind of a weighted average of everybody's kind of local opinion of it at that point in time.
It lends itself to a lot of volatility, right? And once again, as I've said, this volatility lends itself to being an attractive asset to trade. Sure, yeah. So from your vantage points at adaptive capital, what do you think? Like, where do you think we are in the process of institutional adoption?
It sounds like speculators and traders and Wall Street types are getting more and more excited about Bitcoin because of the exact reasons that you just talked about. Are you seeing like anecdotal evidence from where from your position that that's the case? I think the institutional participation is growing slowly.
We need to kind of keep the expectations managed, so to speak. I don't think there's any kind of multi-trillion dollar asset managers that are probably some of the most conservative investment participants. I don't think any of them are here yet. But from what I hear anecdotally and on podcasts and talking to other managers, some of the smaller and the medium-sized kind of global macro players and kind of factor investors, some of the arbitragures and quantitative quantitative funds, they are slowly starting to dabble.
Most more so kind of mate portfolio managers themselves in their own per personal accounts, which I think is totally totally to be expected, but some of them are doing it out of the funds also. Really a lot of them needed to kind of revise some of their LP agreements to be able to include this asset class into kind of a list of assets that they can trade and to slowly make their own limited partners comfortable with this thing.
But from what I hear, there are more and more funds that are kind of allocating one to three percent of their portfolios to either long-term or short-term trading of this asset. Very cool. And that's how it all starts. You said a few minutes ago that you think very few people come to Bitcoin for the cypherpunk ideals of kind of privacy and decentralization.
I certainly agree. Like my experience was I my hook for Bitcoin was when I finally understood the opportunity, you know, that was available to make returns and to make money. And I continue to be very excited about that, and it's definitely a motivator for all of us to learn more about Bitcoin and teach about Bitcoin and you know, kind of spread what we've learned.
But one thing I've I've certainly learned more about Bitcoin is also incentivizing this sort of development of the infrastructure and personal responsibility that is needed to achieve privacy in this digital age. I had given up on that idea. I was kind of had embraced or resigned to the idea of radical transparency, complete loss of privacy in this digital age.
Have you started caring more about privacy or thinking more about privacy since you got into Bitcoin? Probably less so than others. I'll be honest, like frankly, I don't have a lot to hide, really. Privacy in particular isn't something that I was particularly like caring about at any point in time.
I think I would definitely agree that Bitcoin in terms of financial privacy, Bitcoin kind of reinvigorates hope where it once may have been lost, almost exactly like you've just outlined. To me personally, though, it's really I think like in the long run, as I always say, it's really the unprintability of additional units that I think is going to be revolutionary.
And in the short term, like practically in my life, for example, like recently I sent like a couple thousand dollars through Bitcoin from Azerbaijan to Brazil, right? And before that, even sending like $3,000 to another like second or third world country to me would be unthinkable.
Like I would probably have to go through like three different banks and get a bunch of approvals, get a bunch of like checks. Why are you sending this? To who are you sending for what reason? Get some local government's approval to do it. Or if I went through like transfer-wise or money gram or whatever, I would have to pay like 11% in fees or whatever.
But really, like in the long term, I think it's about sound money that will by far be like that's the investment thesis for the long term. And that's like the true kind of the that's the cultural bend that's going to change like the fabric of society or whatever. I strongly agree with all the other quote unquote thought leaders. But in the short term, it's kind of the as volatile as Bitcoin is in the long term, the fact that I can send it to anyone anywhere to me is just like still like after five years, after six years, it's still completely mind blowing.
It really is. It's it's incredible. I've sent some money, you know, I've have some friends in developing countries and have sent them money over the years for various projects or whatever that they're working on. And yeah it's always been either you know take the hit on the large fee cut from Western Union or something like that or you know spend weeks and weeks trying to shepherd a wire transfer through whatever you know the international banking system.
So yeah it's it's a huge thing. I do think the privacy thread is really important. I've come I've come to I you know I definitely started like I like I said earlier like more where you are like I just kind of given up caring about privacy. I don't have a lot to hide. I don't really understand why radical transparency is going to be a big problem for society.
But I've definitely thought more about it recently and like the idea of privacy itself not being like you know hide about hiding something but about maintaining some like personal space personal boundaries and the analogy that got me was like you don't like leave the door open when you're going to the bathroom kind of thing right you want privacy for that although it's not like an illegal thing or something that you need to hide everybody does it but you just like want privacy for those for for those moments you know and same thing with like it's just kind of like a fundamental part of being human.
So if you can kind of take that away then it allows like it's a slippery slope to all kinds of like you know Orwellian nightmares right so I think that the thread of privacy as it will affect culture in the future and the and the fact that Bitcoin is providing like the incentive to build out that infrastructure and to teach people about person the personal responsibility required for privacy is going to be like a one of those things that really does change the fabric of society too like it's one of those threads.
So yeah and I've heard you talk about this before but I and I wanted to bring it up with you because it's one of those things that like I feel like I went through this whole process because of Bitcoin and I was at the very same place where you were you know about privacy just two years ago you know but it definitely changed a lot since then.
Yeah let's let's get back into talking about I want to talk about technical analysis with you. There's a vocal cohort of Bitcoiners who think that TA is a bunch a bunch of hogwash and I know that you know I'm sure that you don't like and I know you don't rely on it like exclusively I know you combine it with on-chain analytics and other you know fundamental analytics but why do you trust and use TA so just to be clear TA isn't something that can like predict the next sort of price
With a hundred percent certainty. But I think it's a tool or it's rather one of the tools that can give you a small edge so you can use it to try to give yourself like instead of the usual 5050 odds to make the odds 55 45 in your favor if if if that if that makes sense right and the idea is that if you do that well enough over a over a large number of kind of bets, in the long term, you will kind of make more money than you lose with with with this kind of active trading.
But I think it comes coming back to the topic that we've already discussed. I would say that really TA is about several things, but most importantly, gauging emotions, particularly greed and fear, which I think are some of the two strongest emotions in humans in general, and particularly with respect to financial markets.
And it's also about identifying trends and kind of taking advantage of that trend. Again, because it's hard to value Bitcoin fundamentally like a stock, like we've already discussed, Bitcoin is prone to emotions more so than even other asset classes.
And add to that the fact that relative to other asset classes like bonds or or traditional commodities, as you may know, Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies in general still have a very large retail component in terms of stakeholders and traders. And because of because there's a lot of retail, kind of less generally less sophisticated players, the emotions are more pronounced on the price chart.
And that's why that's kind of these are kind of the two big reasons why I believe TA works better in Bitcoin than even other asset classes. Do you think that the like the unprecedented transparency of the blockchain, which allows you know for the on-chain analytics that you guys do, do you think pairing those two things together also makes like TA more useful in Bitcoin?
Absolutely. And it's kind of I think there's a lot of synergy there. It's kind of one plus one equals three type situation. I think in especially in terms of like probably less so like super short term, but for medium-term investing and trade or training, kind of making sure that the TA and the on-chain and the order book stuff, when they all kind of align in one, you can really get the odds in your favor.
Nice, nice. So you've had a couple of kind of high profile public bets with Matt O'Dell and Marty Bent. You and Marty won the first bet. Marty and Matt won the second bet. So first I guess I gotta shout out to Marty who's two and oh in this matchup. Were you surprised that Bitcoin sort of rocketed out of this recent bear market like it did?
And like now where do you think we're going in the next you know few months, year or so? Yeah, so actually we had three bets thus far, and they are they are certainly winning the third one, but and then I won't was over on August one was over on August 1st, right?
So you have another one that's outstanding now. Well, no, so that that's the August one is the third one, right? And we had two okay, we had two previous ones kind of in the bear market and kind of the reversal market. But okay, gotcha. I missed one. Yeah. So the boys had to buy me Korean barbecue for the second one, and now I owe them a sushi dinner for the third one next time I'm in New York.
But they definitely got me with this third one. But yeah, I was I was quite surprised. I think we essentially had something like a front running of all the of the coming halving. And obviously, this this bull market is accelerated a little bit faster than than the previous ones, because there's more and more people that are aware of kind of what's happening.
And Bitcoin's kind of this reflexive nature, so to speak. But yes, I was definitely surprised. And I think many people were.
In a similar kind of situation in the 2016 market, you had a similar kind of near 300% growth, but it happened over a longer time period. Now, despite Bitcoin being bigger, it has grown once again around 300% off of the bottom from 3K to 13.8K almost.
And it all happened much quicker and so really i think like you need to we need to realize that bitcoin is still particularly relative to traditional asset classes is quite illiquid and a lot of the future mining supply has also kind of been spoken for so to speak and so really you only need a relatively small amount of buying pressure to come in at any given time for Bitcoin to really move sharply.
And these are kind of some of the dynamics that we've been witnessing, I think.
Sure. It's kind of the plan B effects.
Getting that knowledge out there might have increased the probability, I guess, that we're going to front run the next halving.
Totally. Yeah. So let well let's talk about stock to flow analysis real quick. I mean, do you have you gotten into and studied that stuff? Yeah, for sure. I think Plan B's work is very insightful. I personally subscribe to kind of his theories. I think that like money or these like quasi monetary goods, they it's the only product in the world where stock to flow is in itself a val the value proposition.
A lot of a lot of non-believers think, oh, like just because there's less of it or whatever, that doesn't make it valuable. But I disagree. I think if you really try to analyze why Bitcoin is valuable from first principles, and it kind of took me a couple of years to kind of fully understand as well, and I'm still learning every day, but I would say it's about assurances, right?
And it's about three assurances in my opinion. One is assurances of unprintability. The second is assurances of unseasability, and the third is assurances of censorship resistance. So really it's about storing wealth in terms of like inflation, it's about storing wealth in terms of like from a technological point of view, and it's about being able to send those units as we've discussed anywhere in the world without any authority being able to stop you, right?
And stock to flow ratio is exactly the other way of saying strong assurances of disinflation that get better and better every four years, right? So, really to me, stock to flow is synonymous with these kind of assurances or guarantees. And really, not even with gold did we ever have these kinds of disinflation assurances, let alone coupled with these other additional perks and bonuses that that I listed.
Yeah, it's absolutely right on. So let's talk a little bit about the roles of speculators and traders versus that of hodlers in Bitcoin. What do you see? Like, how do you see the them playing in like interplaying together and what are their kind of separate roles? Yeah, so a lot of kind of a lot of the Bitcoin hardliners, they think that speculators and traders are completely useless.
I strongly disagree. I think they play an important role in providing liquidity. So traders were some of the they were some of the force that were buying at 3,000 and that they that they were selling at 20,000. And some people would say it's a bad thing, but I think it's a good thing because over the long term, these are the people who reduce volatility in the markets as well as increase liquidity in the markets.
And if you as a long-term investor and as a pure strict hodler want Bitcoin to actually become this kind of store of value-like asset over the long term, you want the volatility to be gradually reducing and you want the liquidity to be gradually increasing. And traders, even though you can say it's a zero-sum game against like among traders, I think they add an important function that I've that I've that I've kind of outlined.
Yeah, and so what about hodlers? Like, how do you and how do hodlers affect like the like price swings and everything? Totally. And I think hodlers or if if you consider hodlers to be kind of long-term investors or gradual slow investors, I think they are the people who are in aggregate responsible for Bitcoin having essentially a higher low every year, which which is something that we witnessed, right?
And as a long-term store of value, other than the decreasing volatility and the improving liquidity, what you want is like Bitcoin may not still be a great short-term store of value, but it's been a very, very good long-term store of value. If you think in in in like two-year or three-year terms, it's been remarkable. In almost any kind of two-year section that you can outline, you would end up with more purchasing power, right?
And I think this ever increasing flow of hodlers and ever increasing a flow of long-term investors and accumulators, that's what's been allowing us to have kind of higher lows every time, which is also super super important for building global global faith in this system.
Yeah, so it's almost like speculators and traders are kind of responsible for the highs, like driving driving price up during the bull market. And then hodlers are responsible for kind of holding the floor in the bear market, the new cohort of hodlers that have come in during the last bull run, the strong hands, the hodlers of last resort, as they've been called by Trace Mayer, are there to kind of keep that floor and totally just kind of keep marking marches us up.
Yes, and I would also say that whenever kind of a long-term investor wants to this continue to slowly accumulate, it's likely there's a high chance that it's some kind of an active trader that's on the other side of that transaction. Right, right. So you've you've tweeted that by far the most important metric in cryptocurrency adoption is this market cap.
And that claiming anything else is is crypto virtue signaling. Why is market cap the most important metric? Yeah, I mean, this doesn't really apply to shit coins, which a lot of as we know, a lot of the market cap can be really easily inflated there. But really, it it applies kind of to Bitcoin or really like the top five, top ten.
And what I mean by that is when it comes to what like I'm one of those people who think that essentially like the money use case and specifically the store of value case is probably like the only proven thing that blockchains are used useful for at this point in time. Everything else is kind of kind of bullshit.
I mean, you may have like prediction markets or some of these other kind of DeFi things. I think they are at best super super early right now, and at worst really overhyped. But but in any case, even if those prove to be useful, they're still like a thousand times smaller when compared to money in terms of like the size of the market, right?
And so really simplifying it a little bit, every cryptocurrency or any kind of crypto asset, they are competing to be this like money-like system, right? Obviously, Bitcoin is far by far has like the biggest like first mover advantage and liquidity, network effects, etc.
But I think that if you are comparing these store value candidates, really it's its price, or to be more precise, it's market cap is is by far one of the biggest moats, so to speak. And really when they're competing against one another and kind of new parties start to be engaged, they would much rather be investing in something, or they'd much rather be holding something that's already big because with size comes liquidity, with size comes like network effects and financial infrastructure, etc.
Etc. Etc. Right. And so that's why I think like raw size is like super super important. Do you look at just the basic market cap, or do you have some kind of like market cap plus metrics that you use? Yeah, I really agree with the idea that you need to kind of adjust it for liquidity and look at the order books and stuff like that.
Yeah. Because yeah, you need to combine things like like true volume and particularly the depth of order books. Otherwise, like we mentioned, like any shit coin can just like make like sell one coin for like $10 and then pretend that they're worth trillions, right? But it's pretty liquid, so that means completely nothing. From what I can gather by looking at the order books across exchanges, Bitcoin is like way more liquid than anything else.
So it's like market cap is like far more legit. And if you go to like top 10 or top 15, you really oftentimes need only like a million dollars or even less to just completely like crash the market. So it's it's not the same, you know what I mean? It's not the same. Right. Yeah, yeah. So liquidity makes the market cap metrics legitimate or not, basically.
Yeah, absolutely. Because at the end of the day, if you kind of study like this these things from an Austrian or Hungarian point of view, it's really about like money is about finding like the most liquid good, right? So it when it you translate that into kind of the technicalities of the market, it's about being able to quote unquote either buy or unload a large amount of this kind of commodity in a way that doesn't move the price itself.
And really, nothing can come close to Bitcoin in that regard right now. Yeah, yeah. So, what are some of your other kind of favorite but maybe lesser known indicators or metrics that you guys like to use and maybe explain how they work? Yeah, absolutely. So I would say that there's kind of a lot of cool things that we look at.
I really like the work of an analyst named Renato Shirakashi. Yeah, he has he has he has come up with some very very cool signals. Of his signals I believe is called SOPR, and it kind of tracks short-term aggregate profitability of the market by studying when exactly certain UTXOs kind of move.
And comparing that with kind of local price, it tries to predict how much losses or how much gains the market has at any point in time. The theory there is that usually kind of the market mean reverts to that kind of neutral point. So whenever market has too many gains, you're likely to see kind of short-term sell-offs, and whenever market is has too much losses, you're you're more likely to have like kind of buyers step in and kind of revert it to the neutral side once again.
We do a lot of analysis of kind of mining pool and their wallets and kind of the coins that and really what percentage of the coins usually relative to their past they hold on to as opposed to kind of sell immediately.
We found that there are some very, very interesting signals in that regard as well. And then Willie Woo, one of our partners, likes to study different, really different kinds of volumetric approaches, so kind of short-term volume on chain, long-term volume on chain, really the transactions of smaller stakeholders, the transactions of kind of top 200 stakeholders, things like exchange inflows, outflows.
Some guys from token analysts have been doing remarkable work in that area. But really, you if you want to get good signals, you want to combine kind of four or five of these at the same time to have what's called confluence, right? And that's what we usually try to do. So when you're looking at the percentage of coins that miners are selling, kind of relative to the a number of coins that they've sold in the past, what does that indicate to you?
Like how can you use that to understand at what point like what's point in the cycle, the market cycle that we're in? Yeah, so it really's like not very straightforward, and sometimes the same exact kind of form of their behavior can mean different things depending on where we are in the grand cycle. But essentially, miners and mining pools, they themselves are speculators also.
So the very basic theory here is that when they think that we are at a local top, essentially, they're much more likely to sell. And whenever they think that the market is really oversold here, they're more likely to hold for at least several months or several weeks and then potentially try to sell later.
And that's kind of a very very kind of basic gist here. When they are selling kind of absolutely immediately, this the instant they they mine the coins, one would think that they aren't super bullish about the market in the short to medium term. So that's kind of a very, very rough gist. But of course, it's not like the only thing that you should be relying on.
It's something, it's like one of the 20 things that you want to look at. Right, right. Yeah, that makes sense. I just wanted to understand how that worked in particular, because that's that one's really interesting to me. And one that I've been talking with some friends kind of behind the scenes about and looking at some charts related to how miners are dumping or not dumping coins.
And yeah, I think there's definitely some insights to be gained there. So let's talk a bit about the nature of money, Austrian economics. Did you learn Austrian economic ideas before or after you fell down the Bitcoin rabbit hole? Yeah, so I took a couple of kind of monetary econ classes at university.
Obviously, very little of it was like of Austrian variety and just more traditional kind of neoclassical economics, post-Keynesian economics, things like that. I've always like I've always considered myself a libertarian even before Bitcoin and had did a little bit of reading on kind of Mises.org and other websites even before I was kind of into cryptocurrencies, but it obviously it was particularly afterwards that I read kind of more works by guys like Hulsman and a
Rothbard, etc. So I would say a little bit before, but mostly after. Right on. So like right now we're we're in the midst of these kind of I see it as like these two great money experiments, monetary experiments, and both of these monies that were that are kind of competing against each other's now, that these types of monies have been devised by humans, which is itself sort of a historical aberration, you know, as opposed to being discovered like you know, monetary metals, speed, shells, etc.
We have the fiat regime of centrally controlled money that has no monetary metal backing it at all. And then the first money that's been invented by humans that cannot be co-opted by a central authority has a fully predictable, unchangeable, strictly scarce monetary policy. So, how does Austrian economics help us understand how this battle between these two monetary experiments will play out?
So there are several there are several kind of ways in which Austrian economics, I think, aligns with Bitcoin very well and kind of explains some of these phenomena very well. I think one that I already briefly touched on earlier kind of in our conversation was kind of some of the earliest ideas by Menger regarding regarding how like goods come in at least in the free market, goods goods compete in terms of saleability, and then kind of in a very
Emergent way, what the way I see it is that humans kind of try using different goods as monies both across space and across time, and then eventually without any central planning, just through kind of local pockets of different kind of groups or different teams behavior, if I may, they they come, they realize that oh, okay, this one is like the best.
And there are several kind of characteristics that allow for that to happen. Obviously, like we are all familiar with like things like durability and things like divisibility, like e easy tr transportability, etc. But I think that safety and a couple of others have kind of really explained it well in the sense that everywhere around the world, different communities try different things that even communities that never even spoken or met before.
And some of them have tried like glass beads, others have tried copper, etc. That all kind of roughly fulfill those other criteria that I mentioned. But at the end of the day, kind of unprintability proved to be, or right, once again, like the stock to flow proved to be kind of the right.
It proved to be like kind of life or death, or or kind of the most important make or break type type criteria, in the sense that you really over the long term game theoretically, both you as an individual as well as kind of your village or your community, you want to use as your savings vehicle and simultaneously as your medium exchange, an item which even the most kind of technologically advanced societies around the world, they can't like easily produce to come and sort of completely inflate your your civilization.
You know what I mean? And so that's how I believe people first converged on like bronze or copper, and then what silver, and then finally gold. Because irregardless whether you're a poor society or a wealthy society, gold essentially like defends you from enemies the most.
And that's because yeah, even even for the most advanced, like let's say Europeans at the time, even to them, like making and refining and digging for gold is very, very expensive and energy energy costly process, right? And it's and you want you want your money to be kind of energy costly and effort costly to produce.
That way, essentially you can go to sleep. I think like at the end of the day, and this is kind of my own, not not even Austrian theories, but my own personal theory.
I think almost from like a psychoanalytical point of view, you want an item which reduces your anxiety the most.
And the one that makes you sleep the best. And so I think even you can make an argument that by whole by storing your wealth in gold, your your quality of sleep, semi-jokingly speaking, is better than if you do it in like flowers or even silver, right? And once again, like if you hold dollars, you are sleeping better than if you're holding like rubles, for example, right?
Let alone like Zimbabwean or Venezuelan currency. And similarly, I think with blockchains, the ones that are going to become money are going to be the ones that it's once again comes back to these assurances, right? And it one of those assurances is anxiety reduction. So I think like Bitcoin is much better than Ethereum, for example, at making you sleep good and making you worry less, right?
With Ethereum I can personally I can personally testify to that. Right, right. With Ethereum, we see so much technological risk and so much uncertainty, which might be a might be fine with software, but it's really not good for money and for these like saving vehicles, right? And so I think like being making you calm is very, very important functional money.
Yeah, absolutely. And it I think your brother, and you've talked about this too, but Messier talked about this on Pomp Pomp's podcast. The idea that we're, you know, with fiat money, we're trading our time, which is the a very strictly scarce asset that we have, probably the most valuable and important asset to every human being for an asset that is easily inflated away by at the whim of you know 12 people basically in the US dollar.
And that's you know, that that's very anxiety inducing to think about once you kind of realize that. So it's almost like humans sort of intuitively understand this trade-off, and you they it you know kind of gravitate towards the good that has the best stock to flow ratio and the most liquidity eventually, right?
And that that becomes the money. And so we have this idea of Bitcoin maximalism that kind of floats around there, and it started with as sort of a an I guess a I don't know, a way for Vitalik to sort of diss Bitcoiners, you know.
It's kind of kind of the same way that you know Orange Coin good number go up, it was used as a way to like mock Bitcoiners and that we only care about you know the number going up, et cetera. And we've with both of those, you know, kind of taken it back and embraced it and used it. To me, there's like kind of two fundamental pillars of Bitcoin maximalism.
And one of them we just talked about, the monetary pillar, that you know, market chosen monies, organically arrived at monies that are free from being co-opted, you know, tend to go toward one. And then we have network protocols, and we've seen that you know through the growth of the internet and the maturation of the internet, that those network protocols tend to go toward one.
So that when you have a you know, network protocol for the transfer of value that is basically money, that you're gonna end up you know tending gravitating toward one. Do you identify with the term Bitcoin maximalist? And like how do you define it in your head? So to be completely honest, I really only like two coins.
And those are Bitcoin and D-cred. A lot of my like strictly Bitcoin hardline friends are going to hate me for saying this. But essentially, like I only hold two coins personally.
Like in my personal account, that's Bitcoin and Decred.
And roughly roughly distributed like 80% Bitcoin, 20% Dcred. Okay. A Pareto distribution. How do you or why do you why do you hold Decred? Yeah, I simply I don't think that Decred is going to unseat Bitcoin, but I think that it's better than Litecoin, Bitcoin Cash, Ripple, and others.
So really to me, it's more of a just a kind of an outperformance play. I think that if we are ever going to have kind of three or four chains survive rather than just one, then I think that there's a high chance that decred is going to be in that top five.
And Dcred right now being in like number 31 or 32, I think is simply undervalued. I think, for example, just I think like things like Litecoin don't differentiate against Bitcoin at all. There's essentially absolutely nothing that Litecoin can do that Bitcoin can't. But with D-cred, I think differentiates in a very interesting ways at the same time.
I think like the hybrid proof of work proof of stake is super interesting from a security point of view. That's one. I think the governance, like a different different form of governance is very interesting. Different form of funding is very interesting. Obviously it's it's like a completely different quote code base in a completely different language, and different kind of hashing algorithm on the proof of work side.
And I think that the Dcred developers are really quite talented. They've built a completely different standalone Bitcoin node impl full node implementation. Completely different to Bitcoin Core. And the Lightning Network itself is rooted in the code that they themselves have previously built, which is a little known fact.
So I think on the all on the off chance that there's ever going to be kind of two or three currencies in the future in the digital realm, I think decred has a solid chance of being there. But really, it's kind of a long-term speculative play for me. But I just think it's the second best after Bitcoin. Right on. That makes sense. It's kind of a hedge.
And yeah, you know, like you gotta play it, you gotta play the game the way you think it's gonna, you know, is best going to benefit you. And that those those sound like reasonable hedges, hedges to me. I don't know much about Decred, but maybe I'll look into it. Yeah, all right.
So let's let's move on to talking about the Bitcoin monetization process and just the implications of Bitcoin in general in the future for humanity. So right now, I mean, you've talked about this on Twitter and in podcasts, etc., about the idea of like narratives that drive Bitcoin, right?
Kind of from its early stages and where we are now and into the future, what the narratives that will push Bitcoin through its monetization process. What narratives are driving Bitcoin right now? How do you expect these driving narratives to change over the next few years as we progress through the monetization process?
So I think a lot of people try to kind of create a narrative that Bitcoin is slowly becoming this kind of macro hedge. I personally don't ascribe to this narrative, but you know, like stories, they kind of become these self-fulfilling prophecies, and there are these kind of funny or interesting memes that at least get people through the door, so I don't mind.
I think a lot of Bitcoin's price action is internal to the crypto community and the Bitcoin community itself. So really it kind of built off of its own momentum and off of its own kind of buyer and seller exhaustion in the medium term. But at the same time, though, we've seen Bitcoin correlate with the Chinese yuan recently.
I think there's a solid chance that that's been more of a coincidence rather than like a solid kind of like economic flows that have led this to happen. And Bitcoin is certainly not a hedge to the stock market yet, absolutely not. And yesterday, or over the past three days, over the past week, we've seen like Bitcoin just collapse horribly as the stock market was also collapsing.
So I think Bitcoin is still very early and very immature to be kind of fulfilling these stories. But really I think people essentially people want context or they want structure. Because I think like the root of all anxiety in the human mind is really the chaos of life and the unpredictability unpro unpredictability of the future.
So people want some narratives or some one sentence type news to kind of explain events, but really it's just a futile attempt to explain reality, which is like much more complex than it is. Sure. How do you think a recession will affect Bitcoin if we have a kind of a global downturn in the economy?
So like the go to or the consensus opinion here among my friends and some of the other analysts in the space, and I'm typically wary of kind of carroting other kind of consensus opinions, but essentially I think if it's a recession of the 2008 variety, where essentially the stock market collapses and you have like growth slowdown, et cetera, and like kind of the other kind of risk on assets completely go down, then it would be bad for Bitcoin, I think.
Because it's still in the grand scheme of things, merely a call option on kind of a future money, which is still once again immature and still super early and doesn't have that robust kind of strength or fortitude yet. So I think if the stock market completely collapses, I think Bitcoin collapses as well.
Because and that's because any of those asset managers or global macro players that have a little bit of Bitcoin, they'll just dump it, I think. And any kind of speculators that are kind of teetering on the edge of confidence, so to speak, they would probably dump it. And because people gravitate towards kind of more liquid goods in in times of fear.
That being said, if it's kind of an inflationary session, something that we've seen in Cyprus or something in in the past, or it's something that many, many banks like seize accounts around the world, or just many, many central banks just super like print the money way, way, way too fast. So it if it's one of those like inflationary type crises or sovereign credit type crises, I think there's a higher chance that Bitcoin would do better.
Now we need to be we need to be wary of the fact that the former type of kind of deflationary sessions are four times more common and four times more frequent than the inflationary ones. So the likelihood is kind of the likelihood that Bitcoin collapses during a crisis is higher, but we really need to study the roots of the crisis and then kind of go from there.
Yeah, and it does seem like if you look at the macro situation with negative instrument negative interest rates you know, in very important economies around the world now and you know, many other kind of secondary economies around the world, and maybe coming to the United States. It seems like we might be headed more toward one of those inflationary recessions this time.
So I mean, that's been called many, many times by gold bugs throughout history, though, and you know it hasn't happened to any extreme yet. What do you think about the stock to flow narrative that plan B is really championing and seems to be catching on, especially combined with like the 2020 having in in May next year, roughly Bitcoin stock to flow will match gold's roughly.
And then in 2024, it'll become the hardest money humans ever known with the you know lowest stock-to-flow ratio, sorry, highest stock to flow ratio, right? In 2024. Yeah, do you think that that's gonna catch on and like be an important narrative amongst if not retail then you know institutional investors?
Yeah, I think the stock to flow narrative is legit. And I think it's going to be a huge driver. And I think it's the fundamental explainer of everything at this at the same time i would say that essentially bitcoin's adoption the way i see it is simply very slowly more and more people around the world realizing that it's like way more scarce than any other kind of system of units that was that people ever had in the past right and i don't think that halvings themselves like cause price spikes like like let's
Say like sh in the medium term before or after the halving but what I always say is that instead of having like it instead of having like spiking a or or rather causing a price rise locally what it does is it has a slight positive effect on price permanently like throughout the years irregardless of the time right because if you think about it halvings like the presence of halvings and the 21 limit are functionally the same thing the reason there is a 21 million limit is because there are halvings right because there's a there's a predetermined schedule of having so I
Think that Bitcoin slowly grows in price if you kind of think about humanity not as one individual but as kind of this giant octopus as a giant kind of global consciousness if if I may right essentially that that entity that that that global superstructure it slowly learns like little by little about like the true scarcity, right and it's and it's realizing that it's even more scarce than diamonds or or whatever, right?
And as that happens, you essentially have the steady price rise and these steady higher lows. And obviously, friends tell their parents and friends tell other friends, et cetera, and the kind of the virus spreads. But that's how that's what I think is happening in the long term. In the short to medium term, I really think it's just the price themselves that's carrying.
So when people stop selling, like we saw at 3.1k, or rather that people are unwilling to sell at that price anymore, or kind of the amount of people that are scared, their numbers get exhausted, and the coins get transferred to stronger hands, and let's say another bull cycle begins. Like in the short to medium term, really I think most like I think people come to Bitcoin, as I've always said, because they see in the news or in the websites or on Reddit that the price is rising.
So and you kind of have to combine these short term short-term simply price going up with a long-term kind of a more fundamental type explanations that to see kind of the full picture. Right on. What do you think will be the kind of socio-cultural outcomes of Bitcoin? How will Bitcoin affect human society, our governments, markets, culture, and then also how will it affect individuals?
Yeah, absolutely. I think I strongly believe and ascribe to a view that a lot of Bitcoiners share that Bitcoin is going to really make a lot of us more stoic and more patient. And we are all going to be working on kind of longer-term projects and really think three times as hard about how we spend every single unit of money that we have as opposed to today.
And I think it's going to make a lot of us like more patient and more disciplined, and even more cultured, you could say. I think like some people go as far as arguing that like we can't see it like directly, and it's like hard to prove empirically, but money is just such an important thing because that's something that every single person just cares about all day long and works for and saves and accumulates, et cetera.
And it's both something that like makes us happy and gives us a lot of stress. So if you change kind of the nature of money, the way it works, the way it gets distributed and printed, etc. Because it plays such a big role, it's likely to have these like very almost unpredictable, in this case, positive in my view, kind of these ripple effects or these butterfly effects, right?
And in terms of government, I think all governments are going to get smaller. This is this is kind of a little bit a little bit risque of me to say, but I think it's it's going to defund governments essentially. And I think that a lot of big countries around the world are going to be split into smaller entities.
I think fundamentally a lot of the governments today are way too big. Just I don't think I think like fundamentally people, let's say in one part of Russia or in one part of America, they don't really care. Like somebody in South California doesn't really care about somebody in North Maine, right? That's my view.
And but they but relatively speaking, they care more about like their street or their town or their community or their neighborhood, right? So maybe not like overnight, but I think more and more you will have like we will have more countries around the world, more kind of Venice, and more more of these kind of city states that we used to see more in the in the past.
And for better or worse, I think that's going to lead to a lot of interesting effects. Yeah, I just think that you can argue that, and a lot of libertarians argue that some of the biggest problems that we have in the world, all the World War I, World War II, nuclear weapons, Vietnam War, ancient Asian Orange, all these bad things were because simply because the governments have too much money, both because of taxation as well as because they control the money printing, so they get the senior age, right?
You can argue that you can argue that over the long term, Bitcoin will obviously it will eliminate the their ability to print, but it will all especially during times of war, so they would have to tax, and if they have to tax, they have to go and ask citizenry for approval, and that's much harder than kind of stealth taxation through inflation.
And I think in general, as controversial as this may sound, I think like let's be real, like Bitcoin and all the crypto stuff with all the technologies will probably be a little bit harder to tax as well. So in general, I think the revenue of governments will get less, and like people will demand that it be spent on like medical stuff and rather than kind of defense, which I think a lot of the big countries around the world are really spending excessively on.
Like, look, like a person in the middle of Nebraska doesn't really care about the size of the airplanes or or the amount of nuclear warheads. They care about getting like the like getting their children healed in the hospital or or whatever, right? So I think the governments, just like people, will have to be a lot more prudent and they will have to answer to the citizenry like in a much in a much more disciplined manner as well.
And I think like in the much more accountable. Exactly. And I think in in general, this will be better because I think the quality of products at the risk of sounding stereotypical, but like Germans are known for like like very quality, like chocolate and consumer goods.
And I think we will have more and more of that culture of multi-generational businesses, multi-generational projects, be it consumer goods or artwork or anything else. I think people will care and focus more on their craft with the long term in mind.
And I think that'll just gonna lead to more refined goods and refined cities and refined products, and I think that's gonna be very good for society. I think that that's a beautiful vision for the future of Bitcoin if if we should be successful in this in this effort. It I will think I think it'll be nothing short of revolutionary for society in general.
So again, I appreciate your time, man. Keep up the great work, and thanks again for joining me. Absolutely. Thanks for having me, man. Alright, take care.
All right, that was a fantastic time talking to Maraud. Thanks again, Maraud, for taking the time to join today. So, what did you all think of the conversation? What questions or thoughts did we surface today? You can let us know on Bitcoin Twitter. Maraud is at must-stop Murad, M-U-S-T-S-T-O-P-M-U-R-A-D, and I, of course, am at Citizen Bitcoin.
If you appreciate the podcast, you can give back and help me out by sharing the episode on Bitcoin Twitter. That definitely helps a lot. Just post it and along with a recommendation or just a quote that you really liked. Tell people on Bitcoin Twitter why you liked the episode and why you like the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast.
You can recommend the pod to friends and family who are asking you about Bitcoin. You can leave a rating review on Apple Podcasts. We've kind of been stuck at 33, 34, 35 reviews for like a month now. So if you haven't done that yet, just take a minute or two, go to Apple Podcasts and leave a rating. And a review is kind of cherry on the cake.
So I really appreciate all your support. It means a lot to me. It's been a lot of fun to bootstrap this podcast together. All right. That is it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show: