The Bitcoin Rabbi: "Bitcoin Money", Bitcoin Education, Bitcoin and Religion
The Bitcoin Rabbi and Brady talk about his new kids book "Bitcoin Money," hear his rabbit hole story, talk bitcoin education, bitcoin and religion and get his take on what a bitcoin future will look like.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing well. What a week it's been for Bitcoin.
The price has really rocketed up from the bottom. It's been up about 25% in the past week alone, about 50% over this past month.
We may finally be out of this bear market and starting accumulation toward a new bull market, a new wave of adoption heading into the next halvening in about a year from now,
Which is all pretty exciting. A lot of Bitcoiners had a great time at the Magical Crypto Conference in New York this week, including today's guest, the Bitcoin Rabbi. But before we get to the show, as has become tradition here at the top of the show, I need to ask you to take a minute to rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin podcast on iTunes.
If you have an iTunes account, we're up to 25 ratings now. And thanks to the Crypto Curator for leaving a review this past week. I really appreciate it, man. Thanks in advance to any of you who have been enjoying the show and are willing to leave a rating review for the podcast. It really does mean a lot and helps push the podcast to the top of the search results.
And with that, let's get into the show.
The Bitcoin Rabbi is, like me, relatively new to Bitcoin,
Having joined the fun during the 2017 bull market. And like me, he has taken up the mantle of Bitcoin education and content creation with his new kids' book, Bitcoin Money, a tale of Bitville discovering good money. The Bitcoin Rabbi shares his rabbit hole story with us.
We talk about the inspiration for and the production of his book. We talk about Bitcoin education more broadly. We get into Bitcoin and its similarities to religion. And the Bitcoin Rabbi shares with us his experience at the magical crypto conference this past week. Here is my discussion with the Bitcoin Rabbi. Hope you all enjoy.
Alright, hello, Bitcoin Rabbi, the Bitcoin Rabbi, I should say. Welcome to the podcast. Hey, thanks so much for having me. Yeah, man. Really appreciate you taking some time to come on and talk Bitcoin and talk about your book that is seems like it's flying off the shelves.
I see lots of people talking about it on Twitter. My kids absolutely loved it. It's called Bitcoin Money, a tale of Bit Bill Discovering Good Money. A kid's book. So you might have seen it out there and about on Twitter. And we'll definitely gonna get into the book. But before we do, I'd love to hear your kind of Bitcoin tale, your rabbit hole story.
How and when did you get into Bitcoin? And can you share with us your journey learning Bitcoin? How did you approach learning Bitcoin and whom did you learn from? You know, it's fun talking about this, like the background story. It feels kind of like at this point, taught in giving my introduction, it's like the background to like a superhero, like you know, and then you know, this is the origin story.
I feel like there are some there are a lot of like really exciting or you know ancient stories. But I mean I'm a I'm a 2017 you know bull market hype noob if you will. So same here, same here. You know, my really my older brother who I'm very close with introduced me to Bitcoin in the first meaningful way in mid-2017.
He tells me that really early on, actually, in I think he's even said 2011 or something, when you could do mining on your like on your laptop with your GPU, he did some mining, but one of those kind of stories where he doesn't even know how much Bitcoin he got and then the computer crashed and that's gone and you know, better not to think about it.
And so he kind of forgot about it for a few years. But in 2017, you know, he we started, you know, we kind of follow tech news. That's always been an interest in my family. And so you know, I started looking into it. And my initial understanding was based on like headlines of news when Bitcoin price was crashing and it's like, well, fake internet toy money is crashing.
You're you're like but please don't you know don't don't take your own life. It's just play money. And I'm like, well, that's you know, I thought it was kind of like you know, like I don't know what video game money was or something like that. So had my interest, even though I was always had an interest in you know let's say go I wasn't an investor, but gold and Austrian economics was something that interested me.
And so then once I realized that Bitcoin is that and fits into that and it works. So it it was really like within a day, within half a day of coming to that realization that this is the real thing, mostly you know, the first day was just diving into Andreas Antonopoulos videos on 2x on YouTube and then coming out of it and saying, you know, okay, this is this is life now, like this is part of it.
And pretty much from that point on, it's been something that I've been following, you know, every single day since then, and just getting more and more into it. From at the beginning, it was just like, oh, this is a cute thing that will you know, put like, you know, buy a little, see what happens. But the more that I learned about it and really all the politics that happened around like all the forks and the attempted forks brought more information out to me.
I was like, I need to figure out what's going on here. And that's when I went deeper into the rabbit hole. I was I you know, I was determined to find out what was going on, why were there all these different opinions, why are all these different types of coins, you know, why why do some people only like Bitcoin? Why do some people like various other coins?
So I was pretty determined and I found tons of great information. I mean, Twitter and all of the, you know, all the regular names of on Twitter, all of the fantastic podcasts that are that are out there. I was just able to find that information and it's it's been great, you know, it's been a great couple years of learning and I try and learn new things about Bitcoin every day.
I'm a really not technical person. You know, I was always interested in it and have been interested focusing on the economic perspective because that's something that I'm not an expert but I can understand a little bit of but I'm trying to get more and more on you know building up my technical understanding skills of Bitcoin along the way but I've got a lot to a lot of ground to cover there.
Yeah and that that hard fork the whole block size debate you know and the Bcash hard forks happened November 2017 which was you know the Battery August no there so Bcash forked off on on August first August four first or August 30th yep I don't know you're right and I don't know what it's then SegWit 2x was the attempted fork in November and then that failed that was really that's when I first set up my my first my full node that's when I understood what you know after all the marketing
Of you know of Bitcoin we want a faster cheaper better Bitcoin and I was like well why would anybody be against that and then I found out what a full node is and I was like oh I've got to have a full node so there we go and now you know since that time I've been running you know running my own node yeah the B cash thing that I was thinking about in November was like right around Thanksgiving when it had that massive pump close to like 50% or like basically where I got really close to the market cap of Bitcoin.
And that's what I was that's what I was thinking of but yeah the fork was up it was it was definitely in August. Yeah it was so that was such a dramatic time you know with it was yeah price with the whole Bcash thing with the Segway 2X thing with the whole ICO craze like it was a very there was a lot of drama I mean it was so that was that's what kind of thrusted me into I'm not going to just be a you know sideline viewer I've actually got to become a little bit more active in this interesting yeah you've got to understand why like the reasoning behind the block size debate like what what
Are big blockers attempting and why the like the people who are against raising the block size limit were saying that that it was important to do that and then you've you know discover the importance of you know prioritizing decentralization because that's basically the most important quality of Bitcoin that makes it different from all from every other money and gives it its properties of censorship resistant and inflation resistance and confiscation resistance and yeah so there you know you have to start getting a little bit you don't have to have a like a c understanding of coding but you have to start understanding sort of the way the system works and yeah that was under nodes
If you don't understand the importance of running a node and the importance of at least being able being able to run a full node you won't understand Bitcoin like that's the whole point of it is the is the that's where the decentralization comes from which is where the which is where the limit supply comes from.
I mean, you know, that's that's the whole purpose of it is that it can't be changed because it has this decentralized network. Yep, exactly. And so yeah, you've got to prioritize that. And it was just too risky to set a precedent of increasing the block size, especially at that point in time.
And you know, and people who are against the you know the 2x part of SegWit SegWit 2X were basically saying like, you know, we don't need to do this yet. We don't need to do this right now. First of all, SegWit is a you know an effective block size increase. We move to block weight and it you know doubles we can have up to four megabyte block weight and kind of average at around two 2.2.
So it's it it's a it was an effective kind of doubling of the block size so to speak and also we just don't need to do this yet like you know the networks got we need to try to scale in other ways and prioritize the ability to run full nodes for Bitcoiners wherever you are in the world on whatever kind of hardware you know within reason and some reason and then and whatever kind of internet connection.
And yeah and the whole point is the whole thing that the whole reason this system works is because of consensus because there's the shelling point that you that this shelling point was built around the code of Bitcoin and around the not just the code but the concept of it and for any kind of change to happen I mean that's if you can change one thing then you can change any you know then you could maybe change anything.
So that's that's something and you know that's maybe we'll get with whenever we're ready to get there that's a connection that I've recognized between Judaism and I would say that I originally Judaism and Bitcoin, and I originally came to Bitcoin, you know, from my so to speak secular understanding of economics and money and but since being in it, I've tried to make connections and find similarities.
So that's consensus and community. That's that's definitely part of that. Awesome. Yeah. Well, let's let's actually dive into your understanding of economics. And you're one of the seemingly one of the more rare people who had kind of an appreciation for sound money and some of the principles of Austrian economics before you found Bitcoin.
There are more of us default Keynesian types who have you know just not really been exposed to those ideas until we found Bitcoin. So how did you come to kind of appreciate gold and sound money and those kind of those principles of Austrian economics?
I mean, from coming from politically like the right side of things growing up, that was I feel like that was always I was always exposed to this idea of you know of kind of the libertarian side of things in general, which applies to not just the economic policy but also the you know the fiscal policy and all things that you know people should be able to live their lives and spend their money and you know do their business.
And I think that the part of an extension of that is that you don't get to take away their take away an excessive amount of their money by taxation or by inflating their money away. And you know, you said a default Keynesian, people, I guess take you know, the financial world and the economics and the dollar because they don't see that there's any other option, which, you know, before Bitcoin, there wasn't really an option.
You couldn't really opt out with gold. You can invest in some gold, but you weren't really make your own like side economic world that like we kind of like we have with Bitcoin. So it was just kind of like a hope, maybe we'll get there, maybe gold will, you know, resurge. But I you know I tried to read, I'm not I'm no economics expert, but I read not even like the classics themselves of Mises and Hayek, but you know, I grew up in the YouTube generation where you can get all that information from podcasts
And from you know learnliberty.com. That was a great like summaries. I was a big fan of Milton Friedman and his talks. So you know, a lot of what I learned growing up was from YouTube and videos to be educated about sound money and the value of not having inflation.
But I think that the ideas are are are not something that's so complicated. Like I don't think that it's something that you need to become a professor in economics to understand the idea that if you print money, you're devaluing all the rest of the money. And it's you just look at history, that's not the way things have been.
That's not the way the world always worked. And if you go back to you know, go into the Bible, you know, money was gold and silver. And so the question isn't why should we have sound money? The question is how did we get to this type of money that we have now? And it and I don't even know that people are so aware that the money isn't backed by anything.
You know, your average Joe citizen do they know that there's just printing presses and it's at the whim of whoever decides that day however much QE there needs to be to sir you know to make the economy work how how they want it to work.
I think that if people understood that and understood that there was a way to undo that I mean nobody voted to print more money and you know print money and give it to the banks. Nobody there was never no one was ever asked their opinion if they think that that's a good way to run the system. So I think that just being introduced to it any the average person will understand that hard money and sound money is better than than bad money.
Yeah and what's cool about Bitcoin is that it is even better than gold and silver in terms of censorship and confiscation resistance and inflation resistance especially because I mean it's we've people have figured out ways to inflate you know gold supply by you know money and all that point is that it's gold is not and I actually I taught like I kind of address I don't address all of these issues in my book about the failures of gold compared to fiat and compared to Bitcoin but I mean the fact is that gold is all centralized because it's it's not it's not easy to it's not very portable it's
Not very divisible you know it's not easy to verify and so you end up it's I forget who used these terms, but I it's actually impossible for a person to or extremely expensive for a person to run their own fully verifying gold node, so to speak.
Meaning you can't verify your own gold transactions. You need to have a centralized service verify your gold transactions for you. So it leads to the same problems that big blockers have. You know, it's the same problem. Right, right. Absolutely. Yeah. Well, yeah, look, let's get into the book.
Bitcoin Money, a tale of Bitville discovering good money. What inspired you to make the book? So I all through all of my Bitcoin studies and everything. I think that I got to understand how Bitcoin works, why it was invented, why Satoshi made this, and it wasn't because we didn't have a good means of you know buying coffee, it's because of the because of the central banking and the money printing supply, money printing of the central banks in the bailouts.
So I you know, when you have Bitcoin and you know it's a totally new kind of money, so it makes you think of well, what is money and how how did we get to money and why is one money better than another? So I actually wanted to make a talk, you know.
I once you know about Bitcoin, you want to tell everybody about it. So I made a presentation called which I have been giving, and I think my next one is in two weeks, called Bitcoin and Judaism. And I go through the history of money, how money fits into Jewish history and Jewish law and modern law, and I'm trying to basically dispel fears of you know, of I speak to the youth groups and you know, community, Jewish community centers and dispel the myths of Bitcoin that
It's all terrible and for you know terrorism and drugs and all kinds of awful things so I basically had all of this information about money and about Bitcoin and I was like well I've condensed this down pretty well into a well formatted 45 minute presentation but maybe I could do it even more condensed and I tweeted out actually to Sefadina Moose author of the Bitcoin standard you know does anybody have a version of your book but you know for kids because that was my idea is is you know
It explaining to people in a one sitting you know one shot one sit-down why Bitcoin why is why was it created why does it work why would the people believe trust in it and why do we think that it's going to become you know the dominant or a major asset in the near or distant future.
So I have a seven-year-old daughter she or my oldest daughter is seven years old and I said you know I'm gonna write a book that she can understand and an adult so it's a it's really an adult book or disguised as a children's book. So I just I wrote the whole thing in I mean the I put out the whole story, you know, I laid out the chapters in one morning, you know, I sat for like several hours and wrote it all out.
And then my wife is a graphic designer and she does lays out books regularly and she took it from there. What what I wrote would have basically been a blog post if it was just up to me and my skills. But my wife was able to take this and get an artist and put it all together and you know so we spent about a month putting all that that together and then self-published it and you know I made sure that it was something that my kids could understand and my parents so you know it it ranges the age gap from from very young to very old and it's great for anybody who just doesn't get Bitcoin.
They just don't get it they don't know why anybody would want it. So that was really my motivation and that's how I got it you know from from concept onto paper and out there. So it's been published I think we published it on April 1st so it's been out just for about six weeks and it's been amazing the response from the community and the orders a lot of people paying with Bitcoin people paying with lightning and you know it's been a lot of fun to get it out there and see the response from everyone.
Yeah and it's really well produced I gotta say like you know kudos to your wife and the artist the illustrations are wonderful the layouts great I mean it's it's a high quality product. Thank you very much. Really appreciate that. So are you guys I this kind of the subtitle of it like a tale of Bitfill discovering good money sort of makes me think like there might be other Bitville stories have you talked about that or thought about making this into some kind of like a series of books about money and Bitcoin.
Yeah, you know, I haven't I have thought about it. I haven't really you know, you're not the first person to ask me that. Before I get there, I've been asked more about translations. And so I've been spending since the book came out, or no, not really, since the past three weeks or so.
I've been working on translating it. I so before I work on a second book, I would love to see this book translated, you know, to every language in the world because I want it to, you know, I want kids everywhere to be able to read it. So I put out just on Twitter and just in the community asking for volunteers to help me because it's not a very the text is not very long.
It's only 3,000 words. So people have stepped up and we've got already, they're not available for print, but we have the translations. We've got German, we've got Spanish, Russian, Hebrew, French. So like all of these, they're all just coming out and being edited, and like I've got teams of people working together.
So that is these are gonna be coming out over the next weeks and months, these different languages, so that everybody can, you know, get this idea. And I think that's pretty important because this is like really the basis of, you know, why before we get anywhere, any other steps, I think answering why Bitcoin and that kids understand and this next generation, because they're really the you know, the next generation, the ones that were born with Bitcoin, and after Bitcoin was invented, they're gonna grow up and Bitcoin is going to be their money.
You know, we are just kind of laying the foundation for it. So once I've got those translations out, other ideas I've thought about are what, you know, what are the most important things about Bitcoin other than that it's good money and that it's hard sound money. I've I've thought about focusing on the concept of running your own node, on the idea of holding your own keys.
So it's because I want it to be something that is not technical because so that it fits into my purview. But and also something that is not going to, you know, the technology is changes so much and so many aspects of Bitcoin change and develop. So I want to write books that are not not going to be like out of date by the time they're written.
So something, you know, I don't want to give like an explainer of how to how to safely store your private keys because that information obsolete and they you know it's always developing and getting better. So we'll, you know, we there the I there's definitely stay focused on the on the on the why question instead of the how question. Yeah.
Yeah well because you know there are people will learn that people will figure these things out and it's there it's always better to get the most up to date. But I the thing about my book is I think that even in 20 years it's going to be up to date. The truth is I might be able to I only briefly touch on the Lightning Network at the end of my book and I don't really you know delve into it that much so that might be another place to you know if if once we kind of fully understand how it's going to work and that's gonna be stable then maybe that will be another direction to
Go in of explaining that to kids because that's another thing is that our kids are probably going to be spending a lot less time on the main chain and a lot more time transacting and using second layers. So they're, you know, if they are learning all about how the main chain works and then they never see it, it would be like us, you know, I it all reminds me setting up nodes and you know opening your your ports to have you know port forwarding and then setting up your lightning chain and lightning network and then balancing your channels and all that.
It reminds me of doing LAN parties in the you know in the early 90s, setting up a bunch of desktops in a room and playing you know, playing old computer games with them. So it's like it's so art, you know. Nowadays you just I think you go on Xbox Live and they take care of all of that for you.
So it's gonna be the same way, you know, in the future. People the it's gonna be a totally different experience of how they actually use Bitcoin. Yeah, I think the LAN parties analogy is really good. And I think I might be a little bit older than you. I was in my like tens and teens in in high school in the 90s. And I remember running BBSs on my mom and stepdad's like we I had them by a modem, and then I convinced them that they needed a fax line for for their work and ended up using that fax line to like host people calling into my BBS software, you know, and like there was all kinds of like I was you know, like digging into the you know initialization
And setup files and all that stuff, and it just yeah, it reminds me a lot of sort of the very hands-on nature of lightning network right now, and it'll that'll all get abstracted away in 10 years, it'll be you know completely hidden behind beautiful UI UX and yeah, so it's fun though, it's fun to see you know, kind of relive that you know, from the beginning of see the beginning of the internet really take form from like you know, even pre dial up stuff to like then dial up and then broadband and now we're kind of back with Bitcoin seeing it all happen again from the very beginning, and it's it's it's a lot of fun to be a part of.
Yeah, but it's moving so much faster now as the thing becomes because there's the internet and because there's already all of this UX stuff. I mean, I've been watching since the I guess I there was already the Lightning Network. I guess it was in beta. I don't even remember, maybe it wasn't anything.
I don't think that they could do anything before SegWit got put in in 2017. But like 2018, early, I think they announced that it was on test net, and then like reckless people forked the code and just cause it was just test net to mainnet was just like changing a test net to equal zero or something like that.
So even though Lightning Labs didn't want people doing it on on mainnet, they they did it themselves, and you had like 10. So I was watching this whole thing, but because I wasn't technical enough, I wasn't able to get on myself. So I'm just watching and like once a week I would I would Google, you know, how to how to get on Lightning Network.
And every week it was like too hard still, too hard, too hard. And then there was testnet, but I was like, I don't want to do test net. And then finally, after months and months of waiting, it must have been like November to November, December of 20 18, and Pierre Richard and announced the launch of his node launcher, and I was like, there we are, there we go.
That's it. And I finally, you know, was so excited to get my lightning set up and have been on and I've been on Lightning and using it like on a daily basis since then. What do you use Lightning for? So initially, just for silliness and games and testing and playing around.
You know, a lot of testing with my brother. I bought some stuff on it, you know, some products. But I since my book launched, I accept Lightning payments. I set up a BTC pay server, and I've got my, you know, I've got the node and I've got the lightning, and it's it's accepting lightning payments on a regular basis.
So I've got my lightning on my and I just you know, I every time a new wallet comes out, I just download it and test it out just because I want to see what they are and see which one is better. It's actually it's getting to the point where it's too easy. Like it's so it's like now I mean I've got like five lightning nodes that I don't need.
I mean, it's not like I'm interested in really spending any Bitcoin, so but I've just got all of these lightning nodes, and it's like, all right, this has gotten to the point where I'm not it's like it's not interesting that I can just download something and it works now. Like that's it's too easy. Yeah, it's like I came here for I came here to learn command line, but I didn't manage to do that yet.
So one one more quick question about the book. I noticed that there's at least a few characters that are inspired by real Bitcoiners. Obviously Satoshi is a main character in the book. And then there's Lizzie and Lolly at the end who I assume are were inspired by Elizabeth Stark and Lalu, aka Rose Beef on Twitter and GitHub from Lightning Labs.
Or any of the other characters inspired by by Bitcoiners that it maybe I didn't pick up on? Oh, yeah. Every single character, every name. No wonder is is based on either a real person or a concept. So lit it all of the all of the characters that run their own businesses on pay on first chapter.
Yeah no no no the first all well the in the first chapter it's that one's pretty basic. That's Alice, Bob, and Charlie. And those are the those are the you know the primordial Bitcoiners that that are doing all of the all of the theoretical Bitcoin transactions. Those aren't real people, but those are you know bit there's they're you know they're the Bitcoiners in everybody's imagination.
But then the rest of the characters you know you've got I don't know, I don't feel I'm not sure if I want to spoil all of that. Okay, yeah, fair enough. Fair enough. You know, that's that's part of the fun is trying to figure them out on your own. I d they're not too hard. If you know, if you're on Bitcoin Twitter and you follow some of the main characters there, they it should be pretty easy to figure out between what their occupation is, what their name is and what they look like.
You'll try to do that. Yeah, there's definitely some hints in the pictures as well. And yeah, so I you know I figured that that was the case, but it it's cool to know that all of them are, so I'm gonna go through back through and try to figure them all out. And that'll be a fun little game. All right, cool. So you know, this I assume, you know, since you've created the book and put it out there and that you know think that Bitcoin education is important and obviously your kind of desire there to spread it, and we're all sort of incentivized to spread the spread the word about Bitcoin
To evangelize it, so to speak, to educate about it, and there's a new crop of content creators and educators that come along with every wave of adoption. And so, you know, you here here you and I are from 2017, the 2017 wave, like, you know, I've got a podcast going, you're putting this book out, we'll continue to do that.
There's a lot more of the world, obviously, to onboard to Bitcoin as we move forward over the next couple of decades. And of course, not everyone's going to want to like really dive deep and become completely obsessed with learning the history and the economics and the intricacies of the technology and all that. But, you know, no matter how great the user experience gets, there's gets there's there's always going to be like some education needed, especially about like what money actually is and why people are moving from sovereign fiat to Bitcoin.
So how do you think Bitcoin education might change in the future? Right now it's just kind of you know, go out there and make it happen, do your own research, which I think is you know really important and you should verify things on your own. But I do see a place for maybe even an industry and Bitcoin education industry to grow to support that demand for like what's going on here and answering that question, helping people kind of get started at least.
So have you thought about how Bitcoin education might change in the future? And if so, like what do you think about it? Well, you know, yeah, as a as a rabbi, education is kind of the main focus of my life, both as a you know, personal education and family education and community.
I mean, my profession is I'm a teacher. I teach, I'm I am I am a ordained rabbi, and I but I'm not a pulpit rabbi, meaning I don't have my own synagogue where I am the community head. But so I what I do is I'm a teacher in a in a Jewish school.
So I teach elementary school, middle school, and high school. You know, all different ages and all different types of classes. I actually do both Jewish subjects and technology subjects. And I we my wife and I do graphic design and web design and photography, videography.
I'm not an expert, but we do some of that with our work. So I also teach some of the extracurricular classes, as well as a few presentations in Bitcoin. So education is very important to me. And particularly with young people, I think, you know, that they're one, they're going to be the most susceptible to it.
That they're going is that the right word? They're they're the most accepting of it. That they are going to that when you haven't lived your entire life you know, under fiat currency and not just fiat, but under physical fiat currency, the idea of not of digital currency its own on its own is kind of is foreign and scary.
And then a digital decentralized non-government is I mean, you know, my my father is a is he's willing to kind of look into it a little bit and finds it interesting. He actually told me, and I wrote this on the book, that he's been trying he's been listening to me and my brother Yakon about Bitcoin for two years.
And he said, nothing made me understand it until I read this little kid's book. That was the only thing that that was the only way I was able to understand. And now I think I've got the idea. But even so, you know, I older people, there's just something that is going to be always hard for them. And so I think that focusing on young people that the one, they should know economics, and for for both for their personal self and for their understanding of how government and how the you know the monetary fiat monetary system works and how it doesn't
Work and the benefits and lacking of it. So that's I mean that's where I'm putting my most of my energy because I mean and not just kids but but like college age, teenage level, the people who are just coming into it because they're just getting introduced to this. And you look at all the polls, the polls say that that young people today, they get it.
I mean, they are they are getting it and they are understanding that you know, quote unquote cryptocurrency is the future. You're not gonna find people who are born in the past gen in the past decade buying gold, I don't think. And you're not gonna they're not gonna be buying government bonds. And I think that they don't, you know, I ask people my I'm a bit I'm in my I'm just about 30, and people my age and younger don't believe that there's going to be you know, social security and all of these things in in 40 years or 50 years when we're adults.
It just the math the math doesn't add up. So I'm definitely not counting on it. Yeah, people are just they're going to be getting it. So I another thing that I which I wasn't quite sure how is I was going to go about it, but I think almost as important because I think that that the idea of Bitcoin is so powerful and like so intuitive that like we should have digital money that's decentralized that is limited in supply.
But the m but another thing is to warn people about altcoins and not to get caught up in in investing in crazy things and you know believing anything anybody sells you, and you know, that's what I've seen, and people, you know, people who say they were all in on something one month and then say there was a scam the next month.
So I do talk about that in my book and I talk about it to everybody that I know. I think you know, I'm I'm pretty passionate about that, you know, that aspect as well. So and I think that's where there's going to be more of an issue because the people like the idea of Bitcoin, and then they think, well, if Bitcoin's good, you know, maybe I should just go for whatever the next the next best Bitcoin is.
So I think that's where a lot of focus has to be of how to nicely you know, I'm not a I'm not an aggressive or an attack I don't really like to attack people or you know call people names or anything, but I do believe Bitcoin is the thing to be focused on and not to the exclusion basically of other coins.
So I think that we have to think more about how we can in a nice and thought out way explain this to people who are entering the space. Yeah. The so when I talk to my kids about this, and as I meant, I'll mention at the top of the episode that I recorded about a six minute sort of conversation about the book with the with my kids.
And I sort of skipped over when we were reviewing the book, the chapter, I think it was the fifth chapter, about the copies of Bitcoin. And just because I was like, you know, that's maybe just something that we can let's let's it was wasn't super important. But my son, my four and a half year old son, when we were kind of wrapping things up, he was like, Oh, but dad, you forgot about the part where they made copies of Bitcoin.
And like, you know, they then they didn't want to use the copies of Bitcoin, they just wanted to use the original one. And you know, this would have been like three days before that we had read the book. We'd only been through it once, but like that really made an impression on him. And to the point where he was just like, You gotta, you know, I gotta make sure I that I mention this. Yeah. And I and I didn't think, you know, I thought that that was like a detail that maybe we could gloss over a little bit, but it was like it really stood out to him and like he got it.
And he thought and he knew it was important, which was cool. So yeah, well that's so that's chapter six, that's the last chapter in the book. And it's the one I almost didn't include in the book. I actually didn't want to include it, but I just felt like it was so you know, basically the book was done, and then I just decided that I had to put something in there to because I feel like that's going the natural progression is that people will say, what you know, what comes next, or what about something else?
Why can't there be a different Bitcoin? Why that can't there be two Bitcoins? Why can't there be something better than Bitcoin? So I did include that in the book, and I do now that I wrote it, and now that it's in there, I think it's I'm really happy, and I think that people it's actually one of my favorite chapters, and I'm really happy to hear that your kids is liked it as well.
Yeah, absolutely. Well, I did want to talk to you a little bit about Bitcoin and religion. And I thought we could start with, you know, I first of all, Bitcoin gets often compared to religion. Critics will call us like cultists and sort of use it in like a negative way. More and more I feel like Bitcoiners are sort of embracing the idea that Bitcoin is kind of is similar to religion in a lot of ways.
In the good ways, right? That yeah, that's yeah, I was just gonna say that. I mean, as a very religious person, I mean, I in the one way I would say Bitcoin is not like my religion because you know my religion is my the core of my belief of who I believe I am and you know, my soul, and you know, that's what I believe in.
Bitcoin is not doesn't touch me like you know, if if Bitcoin something happened to Bitcoin and it disappeared tomorrow, I would still be the same person that I am. You know, I pray and I do you know, read the Torah and you know, do the things I do. It wouldn't change my life all that much. So in that way it's not like religion, but the things about religion that I do think are positive is that it's people who are different from each other agreeing to come together and find consensus, find things that they agree on, and then work together to make some kind of positive contribution.
And that's what I, you know, that's a same similar thing about religion. Particular, you know, let's say in Judaism, there are lots of different types of Jewish people from all over the world, and they've got different customs and different styles, but there are things that are like the there are the consensus points and the shelling points.
So you could say even though we've got I try and compare all of these things, like we have there are different implementations of Judaism, but they're they're only they're soft forks, they're not hard forks. So we do have compatible, we've got compatible software, and then we're able to come to consensus. So I think and that's the way, you know, that's a way a community works together.
And the and the point is is that it's all voluntary in the same way that you know, that that Judaism I'm and nobody's forced, you know. I'm I'm Jewish, then I don't force anybody to be it or believe it of this, but anybody who wants to be in the community can be, and we all just agree to work together.
You know, if somebody doesn't want to, that's they're you know, they're allowed to. That's fine. So the same way with Bitcoin, somebody wants to people want to be in it together and work together on Bitcoin, that's fine. If they wanna fork off and make their own coin or their own religion, you know, whatever. It's it's a voluntary community. So I think that's a positive comparison between the two that both are are good in that aspect.
Yeah, absolutely agree a hundred percent. I think I don't think there's anything to add there. That was that was perfectly put, I think. All right, so you went to the magical crypto conferences past week in New York. And mentioned that you mentioned that you wanted to talk about it. Yeah. So how was it? Yeah, I'm at a great time. So it was my first conference.
I have been the only other time that I met real Bitcoiners was I went to New York City also for a NYC Bitcoiners meetup, which was which is hosted by Pierre Rochard and he was very kind he moved it usually they have it on Friday nights and but that doesn't work for me because the Jewish Sabbath Shabbos is Friday night to Saturday night I don't go out or I don't use electricity or things that's that's our day of rest and so he made a special event on a Sunday evening so that I could come and meet people and it was really you know
That was maybe 15 people or so but it was it a really cool time so that was about two months ago and then this was my second event and a lot of the same people that were at the and the you know the little meetup were as well at the magical crypto crypto conference but it was about like 750 people that's what I or no like 800 people I think they posted which was great and it was at like a nice little conference hall in downtown New York and it was just so cool to meet lots of people that I see them on the Twitter
And you know I see their faces or I see their avatars or something and then they're real people and you know I talked to them and I met them and I it was it it it had a very fun like a very friendly attitude that's what they were going for. You know it's kind of the I showed pictures to friends of mine who are not at all in the Bitcoin space and they were like what's with the cartoons and silliness and all that you know there were people in there were people in suits but there were also people in in you know casual wear so I said, look, you know, there's the real fancy blockchain conference consensus.
And then this is the you know, the cute, fun, you know, casual side of things. I the one so I sat there, I had a booth, I sold my books, it was great. I sold out every single book that I brought with me, was sold out. Yeah, that was fantastic.
And I though the one thing I kind of regret is because I was so busy doing that, I didn't get a chance to listen to the speakers. But I was told that or I one, I knew that all of the speeches were being recorded. I actually went back and I'm I haven't listened to all of them yet, but I've started and listened to some of them.
So I got to make up for what I missed there by sitting and doing my thing, which I think that that worked out nicely. To you know, spend the time that I was there and couldn't make back by meeting people and talking to people and selling the books and signing the books and that kind of stuff. I was it was just it was cool to meet.
I'm like a lot of people that I really respect in the space and really appreciate their work. You know, a lot of the team from Blockstream. I got to meet Adam Back. I met Jack Maulers, who does a Zap Wallet, which I use all the time. Jimmy Song, Samson Mo, like the their you know, they are just people that I've been listening to and following and who have been educators and influencers.
I mean that in a positive way, and people who have positively influenced me in in my education of Bitcoin. So it was just great, you know, it was a really fun experience. I'm glad that I got to be there and meet them. You know, I'm not gonna go to I've got I've got a you know full-time job or you know, part-time part or full-time as a as a teacher plus other work that I do and five kids.
So I'm not gonna be able to make all the conferences that are all over Europe and all over the place. But this one was in my you know my backyard in New York City, so I was able to go in there, and so it was it was very cool. It sounded great, and I'm I've watched a few of the videos from it as well. Are there a couple that you have watched since you came back that you want to like shout out that you thought were particularly good.
I you know, I really I've only none that I can really like explain over what they you know the none off the top of my head that I'm I'm trying trying to catch up with them and I still have more that I still have more that I have to go through.
It's that's that's the tough part about being a Bitcoiner is having so much material. Things are happening so fast from so many angles. You know, there's there's the on-chain of what's going on in you know, coming out from Bitcoin Core and the development. Then there's the block stream, all the stuff that they're doing and like side side their their side chain and liquid, and then there's lightning, and then there's the like regulation and financial stuff that you know, those are even two separate things.
So like to it's my wife has has asked me, she's like, so is Bitcoin just like your job now? Yeah. She's she's gotten over the years, she's gotten more understanding of it, especially, you know, now that I have a book and now I'm like actually, you know, doing stuff you know, but but it it it is all it can be a full-time job just to keep up with all of the stuff that's going on.
Yeah, I would love for Bitcoin to be a full-time job, and then I think that's the goal at some point to get there. And yeah, let's let's just keep lugging away and maybe we'll we'll make that happen. All right, so finishing up with this fun question. What's a Bitcoin future look like to you 50 years from now?
Wow, 50 years. That's pretty exciting. You know, I for I was talking with one person that I met at the conference. I don't want to say who was, but he he said, you know, all these people make these price predictions, but you know, it'll be a hundred thousand dollars, it'll be million dollars or something.
But we're talking about a strictly limited deflationary asset, which if you just map that out on a chart, it trends towards infinity. So that's the that's the price. You know, I guess until fiat collapses, or then you can't price it. Then you, you know, that that point, how much is it worth in fiat?
But anyways, the one that's actually one of the things I really like about Bitcoin and Bitcoiners particularly, and Bitcoiners over no coiners and over multi-coiners, is that the vision of a Bitcoin future and a and the economy that it will provide for the world or that it will help you know encourage is a very positive and a very you know bright future.
That that's what I mean from a Jewish perspective. I mean, we are we our religion is that the world is is on its way towards a bright it's called, you know, the messianic or the future of the Mashiach, which is a world that is as perfect as it can be, a world that people are happy and successful and have plenty and have health and all these things, and you see it, I mean, with with all of the developments in technology, all of the developments in medicine, all of the developments in education and information, it makes sense that we would have developments in our financial system as well in
A way that is fairer and you know, more provides more for every person. So that seeing, you know, w I don't know if it's gonna be tw ten years or twenty years or fifty years or longer, but I think that the future that Bitcoin that the goal of Bitcoiners, I mean, they're not I'm not in this to get rich.
And I don't I'm I'm I mean that seriously. You know, my the my I'm in Bitcoin for what I believe that it will be a positive thing if the world in the next generation for my kids and beyond is has a monetary system and an economic system that ha that gives more opportunity for for everybody.
So I'm very excited about it from that perspective and I hope that I hope that's the direction that we go, you know. I we could it could not work and it might go somewhere else, but that's a vision that I can see and that's why I that's why I'm passionate about Bitcoin because I see that it could be part of that whole broader picture of how the world goes towards a better place.
Here, here, man. Amen. I agree completely. And, you know, it's you when you start learning about Bitcoin, you know, you can get you definitely get excited about the idea that as we move from fiat into into Bitcoin, the value or the you know fiat value of Bitcoin is just gonna go up and up and up.
And that's you know definitely exciting. But then I think you kind of evolve into understanding that there's you know this is bigger than making me rich. Although you know the that would be that would be nice. And like Matt Matt Odell, you know Matt Odell points out like in he did on our episode like Bitcoin it works because it you know it it works on human greed or human self-interest, right?
Not necessarily greed, but at least human self-interest. And we're all kind of you know we're out there taking care of ourselves and our families and our friends and like and the people in sort of our Dunbar number of 150 people or whatever and that's that's what we do as humans and Bitcoin works with that. If you're a good person and you become rich and you can do more good things with your money.
So I mean it is it's not a bad thing to have money and to do good things with it. So it's all about that's why I say Bitcoin is kosher if you use it for kosher things. You know so that's it's no problem to my father always told me you know he told me when I went to be a rabbi he said you know you can be a rabbi but but you know be being a rabbi is not a an oath of poverty so you know it's it's wealth is all about what you do with it and how positive you are on the world around you.
Yeah, exactly. And so the rest, I mean, the rest of that that expands into a future where we have a society that does can't inflate away your your wealth or take it away from you, and you can you're free basically then to build it and use it to benefit you and your family and your community.
And so yeah, it it seems like we'd have an economy that is based on a system, a monetary system that is much more fair, encourages much more just general prosperity, encourages people to prosper from the things that they love instead of sort of forcing them into doing some sort of production or job that they don't necessarily want to.
Yeah, and I yeah, I agree. I think it's just gonna be if it all works out, can promise to be a much better economic system and basis for our society than we have now. I wanted to say that I one this is one point very powerful from say from the Bitcoin standard book that you know I didn't quite get before I read the book about not just that when your money is inflated away, you know, it's not good, it's like hidden taxation, but when when you have to spend your money, you're not it's
Not it doesn't just change your finances, but it actually has an effect on your whole mindset. You become a high time front preference individual, and that you start looking at the world from the perspective of short-term benefits, you know, of feeding your desires at that moment.
Whereas if you know that every single time that you hold back and save your money, it's actually a benefit to you, you. You're you've got that extra benefit to look at where is my best long-term interest. And so it's it really has a it has this chain. I write it, I write this very briefly.
You know, everything in my little kids' book is brief, but I do address this idea that things work better and the people are better when they have a more long-term perspective, and that that's another thing of sound money that that provides that.
Absolutely. Absolutely an absolute key in transitioning us from sort of a short short-term or short-term thinking. Which you know we do, it happens individually, like fiat encourages that individually, but it also encourages it on the you know societal level. So our government, you know, spends in the in that way too.
Corporations and the way we fund corporations and quarter to quarter profits and all that stuff. These are all thinking short term and about the immediate future. And it, you know, on an economy based on sound money, you would you know be rewarded, a corporation or governments would be rewarded for thinking longer term and investing for the future.
And yeah, it just it kind of changes the mindset on all levels from from the individual up to the larger, you know, societal level. Well, I think this has been an awesome conversation. Thanks again for joining me. It was really cool to meet you. Maybe we can meet in person someday.
I think maybe I'll have to come up to that magical crypto conference next year. Yeah, well, they are deciding if they're gonna do it in New York again or somewhere else. I think most of the votes were to do it again in New York. It's good, there has to be like a counterbalance to consensus. But but we'll see. You know, I'm sure there will be other opportunities. We're both you know, in this part of the world, not too far from each other, I think.
So you know, we will you know we will we will see when we meet when we pass pass our our our pass cross again. Absolutely, man. Thanks for taking the time again tonight. Have a great weekend and talk to you next time. Alright, take care.
A little bonus for today's episode. I read Bitcoin Money to my kiddos a few nights ago for the first time. They are close to eight and about four and a half now. And tonight before I recorded with the Bitcoin rabbi, I sat down with my kids to talk about the book and find out what they learned. Check it out.
Alright, guys, so we got this book, Bitcoin Money, a tale of Bitville discovering good money. And we read it the other night for bedtime, right? So what'd you think about the book? Good. You liked it? Two thumbs up. What do you say? Bitcoin. Bitcoin.
Do you like Bitcoin? Uh-huh. It's interesting. So did you learn a little bit more about how Bitcoin works and why we use Bitcoin in this book? Yeah. Alright, let's talk about how it started. There's some kids in Bitville. All right. Alice and Bobby and Charlie. And they each do their own thing. They sell Alice sells Lemonade.
Yeah, and Bobby likes to mow yards. Yeah, and Charlie likes to. Make pictures. Yeah, and they like to trade them back and forth. Then they realized that they were trading them back and forth, that they ran into a problem. Like Charlie didn't always want some lemonade or need his lawn mode.
And Bobby and Alice didn't always want Charlie's pictures, so they kinda had a had a problem. So they started using money instead, that's right. And money made it easier for them to trade back and forth, right? And they they talked about what kinds of money to use or like what they could use for money.
So what were some of the things that they talked about, they thought about using for money, do you remember? Glass clippedes, locks, bike pots, and trees. And what were the problems with some of those ideas? Rocks it it was getting really hard to carry. Yeah. And glass clippings, they were too much of them.
Yeah, I and the tree and if they carry them, it was they would spot them beautiful. Yeah. And it's kinda big, right? And the bikes you can't always take bikes apart. Yeah. So Alicia's made up like wood.
It's kind of polish the shot. Well then they have the idea to use gold coins from their friend Goldie. And that worked out alright for a while. Mm-hmm. Right? But then they ran into the same problem that they had with the rocks. Uh-huh. They don't heavy to carry around. So what did they do instead?
Make paper money. Yep, they made some paper. Paper dollars. Yeah, and the paper dollars were supposed to represent the gold coins that were super heavy. And that worked out better, because it was easier to carry around the paper, right? Yeah, but then they made too much. Yeah, they made way too much of the money of the paper money because it was easy to print, right? They had a printer at home.
And so these guys thought it was just too easy. It was it would be smart for them just print off a bunch more, right? Because they could have it and use it. Yeah, but that'll be they could keep they keep the whole batch for themselves. Yep, and they kept the whole batch for themselves. The other kids only got a little bit of the new money.
And what did it do to the value of the money? Make it lower. And made it go down, right? Because the more you make, the less the more of it you make, the less valuable it gets. That's called inflation. Wait, what what are those? That's the paper money, and she has a lots and lots of it on her lemonade stand because they've been making so much of it that cost of lemonade's gone up.
Why does she have a sad fit? Well, I think she's concerned about how the money is losing its value, right? So then who comes to town? What's it? Remember that guy's name? Yeah, it starts with an S. Satoshi.
Yes. Satoshi. And Satoshi had the idea for Biton. Bitcoin. That's right. And Bitcoin solved the problem of printing too much money, right? Because you can't print more bitcoins. It's really it's too hard. Yeah.
Yeah. And every because everyone has to agree to print more bitcoins. And people won't do that because we started using Bitcoin because for the main reason because you can't really make any more of it. And then they made it into an app. Yeah, they could use it on their phones and make it into an app.
And then what and then at the end with the they were starting complaining that Bitcoin was a little too slow, so too. Lizzie and Loli. Yeah, Lindsay and Lolly. Lolly and Lizzie and Lolly. Yeah. They made it they made it faster.
Yeah, do you remember what they how they did that? Lightning. Lightning. Yeah. From the phone. Lightning from their phones. They made a thing called Lightning Network. To make Bitcoin payments faster and cheaper. Yeah. So did you guys did you guys like this book?
Yeah, yes. But before the very end. Uh-huh. When when he went bye-bye, they took gave me a copy of Bitcoin. Oh, you remember the part about the copy? Yeah, when Satoshi went bye bye, they they started making some copies of Bitcoin, right?
And what happened to those copies? Did people Fredcoin? Fredcoin. Did people use Fredcoin? No. They just wanted to use the original Bitcoin. Yeah. So it turned out that the Bitcoin copies weren't good money. Yeah, that was an important part that you were.
So did you guys like this book? Did you learn something? What'd you learn? What's one one thing that you that you learned from this book? I learned that paper buddy, is it that good? Or you two just wait different things for buddy, is it that good? Yeah, and trees are are a really bad.
Trees are really bad as a form of money. Yeah. Oh even better than rocks. Even better than rocks. Yeah. And what what's a better form of money that you learned about from the in this book? Bitcoin. All right. Thanks, guys.
All right, that was a really good time. I had a ton of fun getting to talk with the Bitcoin Rabbi and sitting down to record that little bit with my kiddos. I hope you all enjoyed it as well.
One last plea before I take off to log into iTunes and rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin pod if you found it to be valuable to your Bitcoin journey. So until next time, take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
The Bitcoin Rabbi and Brady talk about his new kids book “Bitcoin Money,” hear his rabbit hole story, talk bitcoin education, bitcoin and religion and get his take on what a bitcoin future will look like.
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show: