All episodes
Episode 4

The Bitcoin Standard, Bitcoin Scaling, Sidechains

April 12, 201840 min

Tommy and Brady discuss tweets that caught our attention this week about sidechains, The Bitcoin Standard book, bitcoin maximalism, and an interesting Lightning Network use case idea. We take a look at the bitcoin price and at why Roger Ver is wrong about scaling bitcoin.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

You ready? Hello and welcome back to another episode of Citizen Bitcoin. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. And we are here to help you guide you along that path to becoming a citizen of Bitcoin. You can find us on YouTube at Citizen Bitcoin. You can find us in your ears only via podcast.

You can find us on iTunes, you can subscribe via RSS in your R in your podcast app. You can also find us on Medium, Twitter, of course, at Citizen Bitcoin. And today we're gonna talk about some tweets we've been looking at that's kind of made us think. We're gonna look at some news, we're gonna take some take a look at this crazy price action, and talk about maybe why why it's happening.

Yep. We're gonna look at a medium article that we published at Citizen Bitcoin on Medium about why Roger Veer is wrong about scaling Bitcoin. And you know, who knows what else will come up in the process.

Stealing Bitcoin, you mean? Oh yeah, because he's a big Bcash guy.

That's right. All right. So we're gonna talk about the Bitcoin Bcash scaling debate and why it's basically over at this point and why Roger is you know, same old arguments are Roger just is I think they call it like a dog a dog with an old bone regarding hanging on with B cash.

That's true. That's a good way to put it. Alright, so let's dive into some tweets that caught our attention this week. This one's from Armin Van Bitcoin and Tommy. Yeah, I brought this up. This is tied into what I'd say the educational part of the show and also us learning learning more about Bitcoin and just crypto assets in general.

I've read recently quite a bit of information regarding side chains and also side chains and trying to compare them to tokens, and just for me it was a lot of confusion. So I thought I'd start with we'll probably get into more, we not probably we will get into more detail in later shows, but just to bring up this fundamental point on side chain chains.

So I'm gonna read this and we're gonna go to a chart after I read the tweet. Side chains allow Bitcoin users to move their coins to a different, completely different blockchain with its own set of features. This allows users to test and enjoy new functionality in a manner that does not impact the main chain, main blockchain, without the need to create a new digital currency.

So anyway, there's a there's a gra a graph here, and what it is is in the center of it, there's a big circle which represents blockchain, and then on one side of it, touching it, there's the beta releases which go in and out. There's beta releases that can be done outside of Bitcoin and then put into interact with the actual blockchain.

And then on the other side of this chart is also a two-way peg between blockchain and side in the sidechain. So the side chain, a side chain, for example, would be would be lightning. Also within within the side chain itself, there are micropayments, and they're also research and development can done can be done, and also just a list of the side chain extensions.

These are just examples of what a sidechain could be, yeah. Right. Native asset issuance, smart contracts, real world property registries, and then the final one would be secure handles. Yeah. So identity. Yeah, so go ahead and jump in in terms of summarizing on this because you do a good job.

You know, understand sidechains better than I do. But the idea is there were there's misinformation with respect to Bitcoin itself and some of these side chains in terms of people or groups or anal, whatever you want to call it. And I don't know if you use they're just misinformed and trying to claim certain things as if a side chain is a new token of Bitcoin that's not going to work and that type of that type of thing.

Yeah, so a couple of things. First of all, I don't the lightning network is not technically a sidechain, although it's very, very similar, okay, because they're both pegged to the blockchain. So they're basically they're very similar. But a side sidechain is a good idea. This is we didn't set this up prior to the show, but this is exactly why I wanted to bring up this topic and get into it more so we can all understand this in a more empirical or base level situation.

We can explain it in 15 seconds rather than go in it this way. Yeah, and I'm certainly not an expert either, but so a sidechain is referring to a specific type of technology that some people are are working on. Both the Lightning Network and Sidechains use a two way peg, a smart contract to peg a you know what something that represents Bitcoin on a sidechain or in on a layer two solution like the Lightning Network.

So it would be more to it would be more settled to a beta release, kind of how the beta release is hooked into this, or is it also it kind of right? Yeah, I mean, this is all done with two way the same idea. So it's a two-way peg. So the examples, just to summarize, the examples we've gone through so far are a two-way peg to beta releases, which would be to improve, ultimately, hopefully improve Bitcoin's blockchain.

And then the other two-way peg we have going on with respect to Bitcoin itself is a side chain. So, right? And so and the lightning network is also a two-way peg network. And another two-way peg would be the lightning network. But a two-way peg is just a way to say that there's assets that are on a side chain or assets in the lightning network and that are settled settlable to the main chain.

They're pegged to the main chain. So it inherits these all of these side chains and the and lightning network inherits the censorship resistance and security of the main chain, right? This is a way to take all of the features that you know alts are testing and pegging them to the to the main chain, which is why I keeps you know talking about this kind of idea of you know, alts are the blockchain is a tree.

Coins other than Bitcoin are what we define as alternate or altcoins. And there are

Thousands of them at this point, have branched off into the and testing all these different ideas, and you know, it'll kind of start to it'll reach a peak and it'll start to come back in and collapse in to a single protocol, which is what we've seen in history. And the point being is that some of these two-way peg ideas, you don't need an you don't need an alternative coin.

You don't need an all, in other words, you can use the idea and without I would call without reinventing the wheel. In other words, some of these ideas on these alt coins, sooner or later, what's gonna happen is people figure out, or it is happening, they figure out, well, it's just superfluous. In other words, they're doing things that are already embedded in Bitcoin itself and Bitcoin and its blockchain that it's not necessary to run through all the extra other than an attempt to most likely it's an attempt to make make some profit off of it.

So, and you can call your the token that represents Bitcoin on a side chain, you can call it whatever you want. So it could be a part of a publishing platform, and maybe they'll call that token the Gutenberg or GUTS or something like that. And it would actually be backed by BTC on the main chain, right? So that's the idea of a side chain, and we'll we'll continue to explore those amazing you know potential for that technology in Bitcoin.

All right. So here's a tweet that I'd like to share today, and it's one that I made about Saiphidine Amus's book, The Bitcoin Standard, which is absolutely excellent. I'm reading it right now on Kindle. And this was a quote from chapter three that I wanted to share on Twitter, got some good traction because I just think it's it's really kind of insightful.

I'm gonna read it the excerpt from the Bitcoin Standard, chapter three. Gold offered no mechanism for restraining the sovereigns and had to rely on trust in them, not abusing the gold standard, and in the population remaining internally vigilant against them doing so. This might have been feasible when the population was highly educated and knowledgeable about the dangers of unsound money.

But with the ev with every generation displaying the intellectual complacence that tends to accompany wealth, the siren song of con artists and court jester economists would prove increasingly irresistible for more of the population, leaving only a minority of knowledgeable economists and historians fighting an uphill battle to convince people that wealth can't be generated by tampering with the money supply.

That allowing a sovereign the control of money can only lead to them increasing their control over everyone's life, and that civilized human living itself rests on the integrity of money, providing a solid foundation for trade and capital accumulation. So this is I kind of grew up a default Keynesian.

My family's democratic family, and you know, I think in the past 40 years, Republican families or Republicans as well with default to Keynesianism. It's kind of become a actually a shared belief between the two political parties, one of the few, and is a belief that printing money to you know outrun macroeconomic crises, right?

And so when I took my macroeconomics class in college, I definitely didn't get a fair comparison or evaluation of competing sound money ideas. So this is really an education for me. Bitcoin has forced me to learn about Austrian economics, kind of give it the serious attention it deserves.

And Sayvin's book has been probably well the best so far that I've read in terms of summing up all of these ideas and you know, problems even with gold, which was the most sound money in human history. So great book. I recommend checking it out. I do think that it is actually, and I did I tweeted this before I saw that Amazon is advertising these three books along with the Bitcoin standard.

I tweeted that the first four books that anyone who is curious about Bitcoin should read are Andreas Antonopoulos's The Internet of Money One and Two and Mastering Bitcoin. So those are the three advertised here along with the Bitcoin standard and the Bitcoin standard. I think these three give a great foundation of the technology.

I think this one gives a great foundation of the economics and the money. I think the other thing, and I have not, it's on my list. Right now I'm reading Skin in the Game by Taleb which actually is excellent. I'm about halfway through. And the only thing I would comment about is some books I generally read read through the Kindle or online also at this point, but some hardcover cover books are important to go excuse me to go ahead and purchase to keep to reread as almost like a researcher library book.

I would put the like Taleb's book and skin in the game and then anti-fragile I just read, and I also read the original, you know, Fooled by Ram to Randomness and Bet Black Swan also. But those are books that I go back to and reread, and I think that's the same thing with the Bitcoin standard.

I just wanted to point that out. Yeah, it's especially I'm a mix between books, but on hardcover, I think it's important on certain ones, you're better off rereading the hardcover books than reading new stuff that's so so totally agree with that. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, so I think.

Oh, I was gonna say one thought that I had was that anti-fragile in particular, I think is really applicable if Taleb's book are really applicable to Bitcoin. Since we've talked about the idea of anti fragility and Bitcoin quite a bit. And Taleb's book's excellent because it goes all the way back. I mean, for example, it goes back to Hammurabi's code, and I it's it's just it's just really, really well done.

And it's done in sections anyway. It's just it's just I don't you know, I don't want to sound like a fanboy, but I sound like a fanboy of the whole thing. A little bit. Well, but it it's it's I really like his work, and it's and I think it his work's gonna stand the test of time. So I really like this guy's work as well. So I'll point out that the author of the Bitcoin standard also has a class on Udemy that you can sign up for.

And if you go to say Fadina Moose's website, you can get a link to sign up for half prices like 12 bucks, two and a half hours of lectures, notes, and quizzes to check your knowledge. I just enrolled in it and gonna be checking that out. All right. This is another tweet that I brought to the table today from Ansel Lindner, who hosts the Bitcoin and Markets podcast.

And he just brought up this interesting idea on a way to use the Lightning Network, and it kind of goes into some example an example that I think would illustrate how you could also use a sidechain since the Lightning Work is very similar to sidechain technology. So an interesting platform would be one where authors, reporters, content creators include an ante, like you would put in a put up in poker an ante, something that gets you into the hand with every article.

So you put up an ante with every article, then recoup that stake from consumers of the context of the content via lightning bitcoin payments. So content could be ranked by some algorithm of the size of your ante, the historical profit margin, upvotes, downvotes, etc. And then the platform, the cool part about it is that it's is more than just micropayments for content creators, it creates a cost up front to deter against spam, fake news, and propaganda, right?

Because it you could actually ante more if you have proven through your proof of work history, the history of your work that your content is valuable, right? And so you feel confident that you can put up a larger ante because you're gonna get that back in payments, micropayments from people who are reading your work, right?

Well, right, you would get it back, and then also potentially plus more. So you would, you know, it it's an it's just a really, really good concept. And so, and obviously, when you start looking at it, you could sit there and try to point out the negatives that occur with respect to people coming in and trying to trying to take part of it. I don't know in what way, but the general concept is is actually excellent.

It's an idea worth exploring, and maybe I'll see if Ansel wants to talk about it off offline a little bit more. I'm really intrigued by it. All right, so next up is I caught this just through reading. I thought this was important to just reinforce. I'm gonna read it's from Reddit. I'm gonna I'm gonna go ahead and just read it here.

Three basic facts show Bitcoin is the most secure and trustable financial system that the world has ever known. No other financial system in the world can boast any single one of these facts, much less all three of them. First bullet: every single transaction is 100% guaranteed to be completed exactly as it is specified.

Every transaction exactly as specified, zero exceptions. Next or second point, no other person, government, or entity can access your funds. Access is available only to an individual who has the exact and unhackable cryptographic key. And then finally, the system is available 24-7, 365 via thousands of global decentralized, independent, redundant computer systems.

Downtime is impossible. So, and the final point: the vast majority. Well, this isn't a point, but this is just finishes the whole the whole post. The vast majority of people are just starting to come to this overall realization will be a fun ride as this concept becomes widespread, common, and accepted.

So the main main part of this is a lot of attacks going on with with Bitcoin and in terms and mainly it's from the I would call it the standard old time centralized crowd centralized banking and just big organizations that type of situation where I'm not even certain that they're aware of these three points with respect to with respect to Bitcoin so that that's that's what I wanted to cover.

Yeah yeah this advantage the advantage of this technology is certainly not widely understood at this point and we're at that very early stages of adoption so that's why the just the future is has so much potential orders of magnitude of growth ahead all right wanted to highlight that Bitcoin maxim maximalism seems to be gaining steam that's the idea that there is going to be one protocol that wins out as the development of networks the history of the development of networks has has proven to us and more evidence that that is happening Jack Dorsey the

CEO of Square and Twitter has stated that the world ultimately will have a single currency the internet will have a single currency and I believe that that internet will be Bitcoin and that that internet that that money will be Bitcoin. So we're right, and Jack Jack, you know, Jack is controversial from the standpoint of on you know with the Twitter platform and he's not you know he's not well liked by everybody.

There's a pretty strong group that it you know from the standpoint of censorship on the Twitter platform, which is a completely different political issue. But the whole the whole point here is is that this he he's running two very very strongly growing platforms. He's a I would call a technology expert.

He also knows knows payments very well and that whole complete you know whole area in addition. So he's somebody to be square diving in. Yeah, square diving in. So he's he's he runs a public a large public company, so he's involved with understanding, you know, he has to be involved with a successful public company.

He has to be understanding of or be aware of all the regulatory impacts and so on and so forth going on across the area. So I mean he's the he's legally responsible for that. So so the idea is we put him up there because we think that that he has a significant amount of credibility to wait to weigh in. Right. There's there's been a lot of due diligence beside behind the decision for Square to go, you know, all in on Bitcoin and offer Bitcoin on the Cash App, and you can now withdraw your Bitcoin to an external Bitcoin address.

So I've actually bought Bitcoin on the Cash App, sent it to my Android e clair Lightning wallet. Yep. And it works perfectly, seamlessly. Opened a channel, was able to that was on an earlier show, right? You should I did show it on the test net on the earlier show, but I do need to show it on the mainnet. I haven't I haven't recorded.

So but anyway, we it's just part of the show also is we want to make sure that that everybody understands that we attempt to look at this full circle. So, from the standpoint of Jack, we just want to let everybody know that we understand some of the situations and controversy related to him that would not be specific to his statement on Bitcoin.

Yeah, but I think it's I mean, I think it's I take it as a great signal overall. I do too. So all right, so let's talk about price. Had some action this morning, Tommy. Had some action on the charts this morning. And we actually you know the action's good because you may be able to pull those. Where do you keep those rockets in your closet?

Do we keep those rockets? Or do you actually keep them on your computer? Actually, on your computer, right? I keep them right up here. Let's see, let's see if we can find the rocket in real time here. Where did my rocket go? It's hard to reach in type. Oh my god, there it is. There it is.

Boom. This is my little emoji chrome plug-in. So then all I have to do is throw it in here. We got ourselves a rocket, Tommy. It's kind of small right now, but that's right. A small rocket. I guess a small rocket's good. A little small little rocket there.

So yeah, and we actually looked at these levels last night, and I was pretty excited to see that they held up almost almost perfectly. So you can see this is the daily chart here going back all the way to November, the mania run-up and the bear market from the past four months.

And what I've been doing is is drawing lines on the down various downtrend lines, and I'll zoom in here a little bit. This is now a four-hour chart going back to middle of March. So you can see the downtrend lines that have been respected. We've had a lot of accumulation on this long-term sort of base uptrend line.

The base uptrend line is has been right around what is it? Right now it's it's between it's been about six thousand, between about six thousand,000 and then up here it got up to like sixty-eight hundred. So this went from 6,000 to 6800 over the past months. So if we're looking at a bottom, a bottom line, we can just we can roughly throw out there 6,500. We're just sorry, 6,500, right?

6500 to 6800. So as a as a bottom number, and so with the chart, it's been bouncing off of that number roughly within a couple hundred US dollars either way, off of off of that number. So we've got a lot of support in this big support zone here.

It's confirmed many, many times. And we knew that you know at some point it's gonna compress down between these two resistance levels, and this is just the action, this is how you know the market decides what a price is going to be. This is price discovery right here on a chart. And once there's been a you know a debate here, plus at this point, shorts, the number of people shorting Bitcoin had risen to all time, you know, very high levels for the past couple of months.

And what happened how do we know that? There's a there's a chart you can short the number of shorts. That was BitMEX, but you can also short on you can short on bit Bitfinex, I know for sure. Well, you can short in the US and the on the in the exchange in Chicago, right? Isn't that CME C B OE? Yeah, so that's pretty small.

But I this is just for the viewers and listeners, just the whole idea of if you're you're talking traditionally shorting, it's it's it's pretty obvious, I think, in terms of how that would work through a broker or whatever, and we won't get, but just in terms of this particular market, it's still relatively new from the standpoint of shorting.

Right. Well, you've been able to do it on BitMEX for at least a couple of years. There you go. But in in terms of the big US markets, yeah. So what happens though is something called a short squeeze. And so shorts will rise to a level that is unsustainable. And then a bowl will come in with you know deep pockets, and there's tons of you can see the large amount of volume here on this four-hour candle, and basically liquidate all those shorts and kind of reset.

So what happens is somebody you know, people that are shorting or groups or whatever you want, you know, just generally, you know, man A or woman A, it it has a short position, and all of a sudden it starts if it goes the other way and this and Bitcoin starts going higher, they they finally just anybody call it panic and they'd say, Oh my god, I gotta cover that.

I gotta cover that before it keeps going. So if it goes from like sixty-eight hundred to seventy two hundred to seventy five hundred, and you're sitting there and you're going, you're in your basement with your three Bitcoin or whatever, and you're going like, Oh my god, I gotta sell this, I gotta sell this, and there's people all over the world trying to figure out. So that's why you get such a huge gap. Yeah, there's too much on one side of the boat.

There's too many people and the boat flips, you know, goes to flip the other way. Exactly. So yep. They they start buying spot on the chart, buying the equity the position itself or the asset itself, and making up that for that loss that they just incurred by buying up. So all those shorts then become longs, at least for the short term, short-term longs, I guess.

But you can see these these downtrend lines, the one down about eight thousand. Yeah, and the one that it hit that you so just for and we for purposes of looking at this, we the number that you I mean, the line that you had that we needed the resistance was at what's that number on the green. Today it's at 8,000. And the one prior was at 7700.

Okay, so 7700. So in the last twelve hours, it was the particular Bitcoin was right around 65, 6600, 60, right, right, just throwing generally high six thousands. And once it moved, the resistance was at 7700, which it punched through a little bit, and it's bouncing up against the next our our next line, which is 8,000.

So that's where we're playing. It's catching support on this first line here that it broke that it broke through, which is exactly what we're catching support at 7700. So it's confirming there. And we can take a look at the 15-minute chart, zoomed all the way in now, and you can these are the same lines. So you can see that there's a massive run-up over about 45 minute period, and now we've we're catching support here, which is exactly what we're gonna see, which means it it was a sustainable, you know, run up.

And maybe this is where the price should have been. And we'll we'll see. But so the idea is it's only 15 minutes, but or you know, or so it just so happens we're live, you know, going live on this with the show, but it looks like the new support line may possibly be 7700. Yeah, so yeah, it I think this is positive, obviously, for price action, and it's sustainable.

We'll be able to keep keep the support, hopefully. A lot of the cell pressure seems to be gone, and I do think that there was a lot of money, a lot of Bitcoin being sold for fiat to pay for US taxes, which are due on the 17th. I know I had to sell some Bitcoin to pay for those crazy gains. And so it's all it's all part of it, so that's the way it goes.

Yeah, I saw one number that estimated at $25 billion, which is you know about 15% of the market right now. So that's a good chunk. All right. And I saw this one, so I wanted to throw it in. You know, we've got basically fit thousand dollar this morning. So we got like a thousand dollar price rise, you know, today, right?

And so crypto Twitter is talking about this price rise, and I've seen some posts that are like, how do you increase your net worth by 17% in 45 minutes? And they show the chart. Of course, they didn't show the four month, you know, 75% retracing. And you know you notice they don't they don't put these when when you know, exactly. When it was 10,000 and then they and then went to it went through the other way into for four digits, they there weren't people saying, like, you know, what do you think of those dollars in your bank account?

And it's like, well, wait a second, they really, you know, anyway. Yeah, so I liked this reply. It's Morpheus from the Matrix movie, staring down at like Neo, who's on the mat, you know, he's staring down, he's like, You think those are dollars in your bank account? You know, so see the light. P our people are measuring Bitcoin and in in dollar value and their net worth and dollar value.

I think the idea here is there is no dollar, right? There is no spoon. It's Bitcoin, and we need to start using Bitcoin as our unit of account if you're really, you know, bought into the b Bitcoin maximalist DC. Understanding right what we already just said, it's it it was the other way just recently, so we can't get we're early into this whole Bitcoin, so you can't get too carried away.

I mean, this is kind of piling on a little bit, so on on the on their part. Yeah. All right, so we're gonna finish up the show today with a brief discussion of a medium article that we posted on Citizen Bitcoin. I wrote it up last week about the Bitcoin Cash or Bcash or BCH.

They did a really nice job with that. I mean, is that are those is that actually yours right there, the retweets and the likes? Yeah, yeah, we've got some traction on Twitter here. This is a quote that I pulled from. It's a really good art. You know, I it it's it's it's a really good article. I thought it was really, really good, and but understanding we're in the same we're on the same team here, so I'm you know, but I mean I thought it was and that's really good.

Forty four retweets and a hundred and 110 likes, nice. Yeah, so I pulled this I pulled this quote out. Bitcoin is scaling, and it's scaling in a way that prioritizes decentralization and center censorship resistance to preserve individual sovereignty over one's money. Alright, so we'll just take a quick look at this article, maybe sum it up in a few minutes.

Head over to Medium and read through it. And I think we decided right before the show, we really like this sort of this idea of crypto economy quick reads. It's a podcast, and they this guy reads out some of the top articles in Bitcoin and crypto. So we'll post a link on that. But yeah, yeah, I really dig that podcast.

Yeah, we think we recommend. So I might start reading some articles as well because I think it's helpful to have the audio format. It's it's great for me to come to consume, I think, in a in a in a busy life. You know, you can listen while you're driving, while you're walking, while you're riding your bike, while you're working out. When I'm walking my dog Gunner, doing your house chores, all that kind of stuff, cooking dinner.

The Arsenal Gunners in the league.

We got Walken Gunner, who is the Citizen Bitcoin mascot. We gotta get Gunner on one of his shows.

We'll have to show we'll have to show Gunner on the show. He's he's he's a rescue, but he's he's a cool dude. So I will put onto the podcast feed me reading through this article, an audio version of this article sometime this maybe this week or weekend. But we'll summarize it quickly here for the main show. All right, so Roger has recently went to the Satoshi's Vision Conference.

I think this happened a couple of weeks ago. He gave a keynote speech there, and he's just reiterating the same old kind of basically disproven at this point, Bcash scaling arguments. And so this article was my attempt to sort of pull everything together into one place. And you gotta hand it to the guy because he's he's extraordinarily persistent.

That is true. He reminds me of Earl Angrabe, who was who was the last House of Representative guy when he was at Velbo University, he was the last guy to defend Richard Nixon, and they were yelling at him from the crowd, and he said, Don't confuse me with the facts. I have a closed mind. So that's pretty much Roger, I think. So yeah, that that sounds about that sounds about right.

So you can watch his presentation, it's about 20 minutes long, and then he takes a QA afterwards. The first half of his presentation, he's he lays out the sort of broad crypto and sound money is great for the world. It's gonna serve as an economic economic stimulus package for the world, accelerate innovation, reduce wars, make the poorest 10% better off, overthrow corrupt governments, raise happiness, all of these great you know, benefits of sound money on a global scale.

It's all well and good. That's a lot in one quote, if you really think about it. It really is. If you could just do half of one of those things, it would it would be absolutely fabulous. But doing all those things, so that's what Bcash is gonna do. Well, that's what sound money is gonna do. And we I think we all agree with that to the for you know, in general. But then he launches into his critique of the Bitcoin Core project, right?

And now Bitcoin Core is not a coin, it's not a payment network. Bitcoin is the payment network, Bitcoin with the lowercase B is the currency, the asset. Bitcoin Core is an open source software project that implements the payment network, the peer-to-peer network that Bitcoin is run on.

And Roger has been trying to rebrand the idea of Bitcoin as Bitcoin core, that it's something different than it used to be. Well, the other thing also we should point out here is the these two slides and just the snapshot or picture screenshot, it says Bitcoin.com. Yeah, right. Bitcoin. Roger. And what's the story with Bitcoin.com.

Yeah. Roger is, as he likes to point out all the time, quote unquote, the world's first person to invest in Bitcoin in Bitcoin companies. And he was basically the Al Gore of Bitcoin. Would that be a fair thing?

Because Al Vigore invented the internet, right? He does Roger does like to point that out quite a bit. Of course, Roger's not technical. He, you know, at this point I hope has some technical understanding of what's going on, but I'm not sure that he does based on the arguments he keeps peddling. Bitcoin.com is he bought that domain in the early days and he's been running it for a long time.

It's provided a Bitcoin wallet. And recently, Bitcoin.com has started you know pushing Bcash over Bitcoin. And Roger has been out running a campaign that basically boils down to, and he's even said this, I think word for word on a tweet, Bitcoin Cash is Bitcoin.

So it's pretty confusing for people who are coming to cryptocurrency or coming to Bitcoin, they're curious about it. And you know, Roger sort of hides behind this, you know, seemingly righteous claim to the Bitcoin brand, right? Part of it is somebody somebody new may, you know, they may take except you can have a situation where somebody thinks they're getting Bitcoin and they're actually getting B cash, and they it's like what it's 10% of the value of Bitcoin is B cash at this point, might even be lower.

Yeah, so after this, you know, Austrian economics. Yeah, exactly. After this Austrian economics sound money is good opening, he immediately launches into this to insinuating a collusion, conspiracy between the government, which I assume you means the US government or a government is what his slide says, and Bitcoin Core, the open source project, and Blockstream, which is a Bitcoin-based business, a technology business based in California.

All right. So the slide says, if you are a government, how would you stop this? Next slide. Advocate for one megabyte blocks to intentionally create high fees, less privacy, slow confirmations, and unreliable transactions. All right. So the insinuation obviously is that there's this conspiracy. When he reads the slide, if you listen closely, you can hear in the background dozens of kind of gasps or laughs when this slide is revealed.

And he kind of reads the room and then quickly disclaims. I'm not saying that I they did this out of malice, maybe it was just ignorance. Despite the fact that he's standing next to this slide, it says intentionally create. And the word malice and intentionally create are basic are synonyms here in this case. So well, the other thing that's very important in terms of this slide, as we sit here, and over the past, I don't know, several months, I think, there are no longer, as it relates to Bitcoin itself, Bitcoin.

There are no longer high fees. No. There was there was never less privacy, I don't think, right? There are no slow confirmations now. And there's also never been unreliable transactions, as far as I understand it. So in terms of putting this slide up, right now, today, it none of the points, high fees, less privacy, slow confirmations, or unreliable are valid.

Right. So and okay. The article goes into, you know, first of all, it's also invalid that that anyone was advocating for one megabyte blocks. All right. The Bitcoin core community, the consensus that it was arrived at is that we would use SegWit, segregated witness, and I get into the details of what SegWit is here in the article.

Segregated witness to create an effective doubling of the block size from one to two megabytes on average, right? The theoretical upper limit of SegWit at full adoption is four megabyte blocks. But on average we can expect them to you know settle in around two megabyte average, it's a doubling of the block size.

So no one was advocating for one megabyte blocks. No one was certainly no one was advocating for you know intentionally creating high fees, intentionally creating slow transaction times. That did happen. It absolutely happened, but it was not because people you know advocated for one megabyte blocks. It was a massive increase in Bitcoin buying during this you know 18-month bull rally, combined with inefficient USD to BTC services, so like Coinbase, for instance, which is one of the main USD to BTC ramps in the United States, they finally in January optimized their Bitcoin transactions.

They started batching them. The UTXO set, the unspent transaction outputs that is on on the Bitcoin ledger, massively consolidated due to this transaction batching. And so we're you know be able to fit a lot more transactions into a single transaction. It's just reducing the you know cluttering.

So the ongoing situation too is it's a it's a dynamic situation here, all right. And so it's it's it's not just a snapshot in time. So it looks to us, or it looks to me that Roger took a snapshot in time and he hasn't updated it. So the snapshot he took on that slide, even though at the time he took the snapshot, a couple of things on there that that he puts on there were in our view inaccurate.

He doesn't update it. He just sticks with it and brings it along.

Right. And we also decided to scale in a way that enabled Lightning Network. And we've got that deployed now. So SegWit makes Lightning Network much easier to deploy. And so there you go. Obviously, Lightning Network is it's low fee. It's free in most cases at this point. It's extremely fast, basically instant.

So that's not what the plan was. The other thing is this is our view at this point. If something and we're we'll update our view, and let's say in six weeks or eight weeks, something happens with Bcash or something's new on it that changes changes what the situation is, which which we doubt, because it would have to be very dramatic, then we'll shift our view.

We're we're not gonna be like Roger, that we're just gonna snapshot our view and then keep it forever if there's new overwhelming information that would cause us to, you know, because that's the that's the good way to do that. Yeah, I think I think this closing sentence is you know kind of sums up that sentiment. You know, the article and what we're talking about now is our understanding of how things stand at this moment, right?

But one of the strengths of the broader Bitcoin community is diversity of opinions, diversity of predictions, and you know, we all use the market the mechanism of the market then to voice our predictions and those decisions, and we arrive at a consensus. So that's what we're that's what we're here to do. Yeah, so we're more along the lines of we, you know, this is more me, but Marcus Aurelius, right?

So if one of the you know, one of the things in terms of a mindset or how you're looking at it is your ability to change your change your opinion based on new facts. So there you go. I think that's a great place to wrap things up. Definitely check us out on Twitter, Medium, YouTube, the podcast. You know, it'd be super helpful if someone could take ten minutes if you're listening on iTunes or on Apple and give us a rate rating and review.

We've got one right now from me. So I would love to get some more rating and reviews that helps spread spread the word. Oh and one thing I wanted to share let's see. Last thing Jameson Lopp who is a Bitcoin developer and a must follow on Twitter has a Bitcoin resources page which is one of the best places to go on the web to send people who are new and start reading and writing and listening.

We submitted under in a pull request Citizen Bitcoin to the list of podcasts. Thanks Jameson for accepting that pull request including us in the Bitcoin podcast list there. We appreciate it. Super cool so we're on JLOP's Bitcoin resources page. All right. That's it for today.

Thanks everybody for next time.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Tommy and Brady discuss tweets that caught our attention this week about sidechains, The Bitcoin Standard book, bitcoin maximalism, and an interesting Lightning Network use case idea. We take a look at the bitcoin price and at why Roger Ver is wrong about scaling bitcoin.

Links from the show below.

Newish to Bitcoin? Confused? Overwhelmed? We feel you. Follow us on YouTube, Medium and here for useful breakdowns of news, the social & economic implications of bitcoin and easy to follow howtos. Weโ€™re just making the leap from learn to teach, your early support is huge. ๐ŸŒ๐ŸŒŽ๐ŸŒIf you find value in this content, please subscribe, like, rate, review and share!

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/citizenbitcoin

Citizen Bitcoin on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCi_fqW5K7-eLUXcLU-dR3eQ/featured

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast: https://citizenbitcoin.simplecast.fm/

Sidechains tweet from Armin van Bitcoin: https://twitter.com/ArminVanBitcoin/status/978291979208536064?s=03

The Bitcoin Standard tweet from Brady: https://twitter.com/bswen/status/983901356200267777

The Bitcoin Standard book: https://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Standard-Decentralized-Alternative-Central/dp/1119473861

Dr. Saifedean Ammous Udemy course: https://www.udemy.com/understanding-macroeconomics-for-university-and-business/learn/v4/overview

Lightning Network publishing platform idea tweet from Ansel Lindner: https://twitter.com/AnselLindner/status/984115149299748865

Three bitcoin facts not widely understood yet: https://amp.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/8bgjlw/3_basic_facts_that_show_bitcoin_is_the_most/?__twitter_impression=true

Jack Dorsey the bitcoin maximalist: https://twitter.com/bswen/status/983709064730497024

Why Roger Ver is Wrong About Scaling Bitcoin: https://medium.com/@citizenbitcoin/rebutting-roger-why-roger-ver-is-wrong-about-scaling-bitcoin-10ca4799975d

Jameson Loppโ€™s bitcoin resources: https://lopp.net/bitcoin.html

Cryptoconomy Quick Reads podcast: https://cryptoconomy.podbean.com/

Bitcoin and Markets podcast: http://bitcoinandmarkets.com/

Downloads