Tomer Strolight: Don't Tell Me There Are No Heroes in Bitcoin - E122 Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2021-07-09 [00:00:14] Welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. My name is Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Now, how's it going out there, all my Bitcoiners? Wherever you happen to be in the world today, thank you for joining me here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. [00:00:34] Today, I've got a great conversation for you with Tomer Strolight. But before we dive into it, let's check in with Swan. Things are still humming right along at Swan, even though we're in this accumulation zone here between 30 and 40k. We are continuing to build. [00:00:52] Jan and his team have started work on our app. So we'll be able to launch iOS and Android at the same time in the coming months. It's looking really good. I am excited to get my hands on a test version of it to start running it on my phone and see what's going on there. It's looking really good from the screenshots I'm seeing and I am very excited about it. [00:01:14] I know a lot of you have been looking Swan Private is still growing extremely quickly despite this kind of down price action. We've got a lot of high net worth individuals and corporations and entities signing up for Swan Private. So we're building out that division. And we found that we've sort of built a unique niche in the space by providing really high quality, responsive client services to this sector. [00:01:44] Corporations, for instance, have a really, really hard time, especially medium-sized businesses, setting up accounts at Coinbase and the like. Months and months go by sometimes without word back from them. We have built an experience, an onboarding experience for corporations and entities that we seem to think is unparalleled in the industry. [00:02:08] You can be onboarded in less than a week. We will be with you the entire step of the way, communicating with you during the whole process, making sure you understand what's going on and there to answer any questions and concerns that you have. It's been a great experience that a lot of our clients have really given us great feedback about. [00:02:29] So if you are a corporation or an entity of some kind, a trust, a 401k, and you want to start buying Bitcoin for your entity, check out swanbitcoin.com slash private. And that will get you into our Swan Private division, our team there, and they'll make sure that you get what you need and have all your questions answered. [00:02:50] And of course, if you're just opening a personal account at swanbitcoin.com, we are dedicated just as much as we are with Swan Private to helping you out and giving you personal attention, making sure you have your questions answered. We have a very responsive client services division there. And we're there to help you, you know, learn about Bitcoin. [00:03:11] Our obviously, you know, dedication, like we're very dedicated to education. That's what I helped to run at Swan. And that's part of what we do at client services as well. So it's a big part of providing service to our customers is teaching them what's going on. [00:03:30] And that's why we've had just crossed today 1 million trades and 99.9% of them have been buys. And that's because we have educated our customers and while they came in educated too, in a lot of cases, but we have educated those newcomers about this being a long-term game that you just need to accumulate slowly over time. [00:03:50] And, of course we have no, no sell button as well. You can sell if you write into our support team, of course, but, we have no, sell button. So you'll have to, write into us if you want to sell that has helped in, we've actually had some, some people write in and say that they were about to panic sell and the fact that there was no button, you know, helped them, helped prevent them from selling because they had to write an email in. [00:04:15] So interesting feature and not a bug at Swan that we have no sell button. Okay, let's dive into this episode with Tomer Strolight. [00:04:39] Tomer Strolight is a longtime Bitcoiner who has recently started writing about what he has learned, the insights he has gained over the years. He has been extremely prolific as well. He's written dozens of articles. You can find a compilation of them at swanbitcoin.com slash whybitcoin. [00:05:04] And you'll find a compilation of a series that he wrote about why you should buy Bitcoin, why we need Bitcoin. And it's fantastic. He's continued to write as well. And he has one that he will be sharing with us today in this episode about why there are heroes, that Bitcoin is filled with heroes. [00:05:27] It's titled, Don't Tell Me There Are No Heroes in Bitcoin. And we're going to kick this episode off with a reading of that article by Tomer, and then we will commence the discussion. I hope you all enjoy it. I certainly did. Here we go. [00:05:53] Don't tell me there are no heroes in Bitcoin. There are no heroes in Bitcoin. This expression is often cited in the Bitcoin community because many people once elevated to that status have fallen from grace. It's better, some suggest, just to have no heroes in Bitcoin in the first place, so as to avoid the pain of having to slay our heroes. [00:06:17] Let us ask ourselves the question, what are heroes? Heroes stand up for the little guy. Heroes act courageously to resist wrongdoing. Heroes fight for what is right. Heroes protect the weak. Heroes achieve extraordinary outcomes. What do these heroic traits mean in Bitcoin? [00:06:38] What does standing up for the little guy mean? First and foremost, it means not taking advantage of that little guy. There is an endless stream of new people coming to Bitcoin and seeking honest education. They are looking for answers to questions that everyone must ask when they begin their journey. They must have their questions answered honestly. [00:06:59] Furthermore, the whole Bitcoin project is itself a movement for all the little guys out there. From the unbanked, to the working class, to the socially ostracized. They are the little guys whose ability to save for their futures is robbed by the incumbent financial system. They are also the same little guys whose little wealth is being greedily eyed by the promoters of cryptos trying to lure them into traps masquerading as something similar to or better than Bitcoin. [00:07:29] Heroes would stand up to all of these exploiters. Next, what does it mean to courageously resist wrongdoing in Bitcoin? The attackers of Bitcoin in the arena of public discussion day after day. It means taking on the economists and institutions that attempt to dismiss and slander Bitcoin, opponents who speak for institutions that control all the fiat money in the world. [00:07:54] It means confronting altcoin promoters from hundreds of projects who attack Bitcoin, each with their own brand of misrepresentations. What could it mean to fight for what is right? It means exactly that. When something is right it or subvert it, it means fighting to preserve and protect it, like fighting for the ability for everyone to run a full node. [00:08:16] In Bitcoin, this is always the fight to retain decentralization. What might it mean to protect the weak? It also means ensuring that those who cannot speak for themselves or defend themselves still have the ability to use Bitcoin through anonymity and privacy. And finally, what does it mean to achieve extraordinary outcomes? [00:08:35] We'll come back to that. Don't tell me there are no heroes in Bitcoin. Bitcoin is replete with heroes. It's not hard to find them. Go to any Bitcoin or crypto room on Clubhouse any time of the day, any day of the week, and you are likely to find some Bitcoin hero gently and patiently explaining to someone new, some little guy, how to use Bitcoin as a shield from the inflationary forces which central banks use to rob their savings from them. [00:09:02] If an influential skeptic from the traditional banking system shows up to frighten and intimidate the little guys, you will see the Bitcoin heroes, undeterred and unintimidated, fighting back, informed with better facts, presenting better logic, and pointing to better real-world results, all with down-to-earth terminology. [00:09:23] When the misleading claims by altcoin promoters get pushed on unsuspecting naive beginners who are still early in their journey, you'll hear Bitcoiners share their own tales of having themselves been lured and tricked in their early days. They place the truth ahead of their pride, warning others not to make the same mistakes they made. So don't tell me there are no heroes in Bitcoin. [00:09:44] There are in fact many, and they are called upon all the time. This, though, is just the day-to-day, run-of-the-mill role that heroes in Bitcoin play. There are also extraordinary times where heroes are needed. Let's discuss the heroes of the fork wars. There's a whole book written about one series of events where a lot of heroes came out to perform one heroic task after another. [00:10:07] I refer to 2017's scaling wars, or the block-size wars as some call them. It was an extraordinary situation. That war, as it was called, actually cost us many heroes. It is in part where the saying, be prepared to slay your heroes in Bitcoin comes from. It took place during an historic moment of truth for Bitcoin. [00:10:27] At stake was nothing less than preserving Bitcoin's essential and necessary decentralization while also simultaneously allowing it to scale, without sacrificing either decentralization or scaling to each other. Just figuring out how to do this required extraordinary breakthroughs from Bitcoin's developers. Today, we are hearing tremendous news of the success and rapid growth of the Lightning Network. [00:10:49] However, had Bitcoiners not fought that war, had they not won it, had they not exhibited heroism, we would not be hearing those stories today. Bitcoiners were up against powerful enemies back then. The first enemy was none other than the most powerful maker and user of Bitcoin mining equipment, a company called Bitmain. [00:11:09] Bitmain opposed activating the feature that would make the Lightning Network possible, a feature called Segregated Witness, or SegWit for short. They had their reasons. They were the usual reasons the wealthy and powerful resist change. They wanted to preserve their wealth and power. Bitmain used their power to block the activation of this feature on the Bitcoin network. [00:11:29] Bitcoiners had to respond. Corporate interests, a single corporation, challenged our right to advance the network. And Bitcoiners did respond. They mounted a movement to develop and run software that took Bitmain head-on. They threatened to reject the blocks mined by Bitmain and any other miner who refused to activate SegWit. [00:11:48] It was a huge gambit because Bitmain controlled much of the mining power. The risk was that we would end up on a nearly dead chain, facing extremely slow blocks for a very long time, and worst of all, with far less security, vulnerable even to 51% by Bitmain. But Bitcoiners knew it was all or nothing. [00:12:09] Either retain the decentralization of Bitcoin or lose the whole project. So they risked it all. They stood up for the little guy against the big guy. They courageously risked Bitcoin itself, putting it to a life or death test against Bitmain. They fought for what was right. They advocated and explained to other Bitcoiners why victory would only come if nearly everyone joined the battle. [00:12:31] It worked. Bitcoiners en masse threatened Bitcoin itself if it wasn't going to be able to remain decentralized. Seeing this and knowing its whole business relied on Bitcoin's existence, Bitmain backed down and ceased the action they were taking that prevented SegWit from activating. So don't tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin. [00:12:52] However, this was not all. That was not the only front on which this war had to be fought. This war also had to be fought against some of the most powerful companies in the Bitcoin and crypto space. Partway through this first battle, Coinbase, BitPay, Bitcoin.com, Bitmain, and a total of 58 companies announced that they had met in private and committed to a plan that became known as the New York Agreement. [00:13:16] It proposed creating a hard fork of Bitcoin to double the block size as some form of bargain to appease Bitmain. This compromise would have harmed Bitcoin's decentralization, it would have made it more expensive and difficult to run a full node, and it would have set a precedent that corporations could meet in private and modify Bitcoin. [00:13:34] While Bitcoiners were resisting and fighting Bitmain's attack, these companies attempted to use their clout, their leverage, their pull, and their power to take control of Bitcoin. So once again, while still fighting the war with Bitmain on one front, Bitcoiners confronted this second attack. The users of Bitcoin stood up to these men and their companies and said, no, we will not run your hard fork. [00:13:57] The developers of Bitcoin said, we will not develop your hard fork. In the end, these incredibly powerful and wealthy companies could find only one developer amongst all the Bitcoin developers to co-opt into their attack. All the other developers laughed at the proposal, discredited it, and turned down the money offered to do the development work. [00:14:17] So Bitcoiners had to fight not only to get others to run a version of Bitcoin software that would eventually force Bitmain to capitulate. They had to also fight to get nobody to run the software proposed by the largest companies in the space, the ones with the customer lists and websites and marketing budgets and money. [00:14:36] To fight on this second front, Bitcoiners had to dedicate more than just their time, their energy and their minds. They had to risk their capital too. They had to demonstrate to the market the overwhelming support of their decentralized Bitcoin against the replacement coin proposed by the wealthy and powerful companies. They had to wager their Bitcoin in future markets to demonstrate their conviction. [00:14:58] They had to go long on the Bitcoin with segregated witness and go short on the New York agreement coin. They had to surrender the custody of their coins to make these bets, sending their coins to an exchange and risking loss of funds. Many risked all their Bitcoins in driving down the price of the hard fork version. It worked. [00:15:17] Seeing the conviction of Bitcoiners led to the 58 companies capitulating and withdrawing their proposal. Had that hard fork been victorious, these Bitcoiners would have lost their entire stack, which for many of them was their life savings. They risked it all, every last Satoshi, for the sake of Bitcoin's future. So don't tell me there are no heroes in Bitcoin. [00:15:38] Yet this still was not all. We fought the war on a third front, because in one final desperate move, powerful Bitcoiner, launched another attack on Bitcoin. They created and released their own new coin on the same day that SegWit activated, just as the Bitcoin heroes were expecting to celebrate victory. This was a hard fork of Bitcoin that did not activate SegWit. [00:16:00] It was a version that enticed each Bitcoiner with an equal amount of its new coin. It was a version that misrepresented itself as the true Bitcoin. It had the backing not only of Bitmain, but also the Bitcoin.com website. Again, money, clout, and power attacking Bitcoin. And so we had to fight on this third front without any rest from battling the two prior attacks. [00:16:22] Battle weary, we did not get a chance to rest and celebrate our victory. We had to fight a new attacker, and we did. So don't tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin because I fought alongside them in those fork wars. We fought attack after attack after attack to protect the little guys who often were our own selves, Bitcoin, a decentralized money controlled by nobody, corruptible by nobody, could live on and have a chance to realize its potential destiny of changing the world for the better. [00:16:53] Don't tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin. There are more heroes than you can even count. There have been countless more heroes. Consider those Bitcoiners who created and worked on and lived on Bitcoin Beach for two years in El Salvador with no guarantees of success, two years of their life, without pay, without venture backing, without any mature technology to easily roll out on day one, without even any assurances that they might not be arrested suddenly and without notice for using Bitcoin. [00:17:23] Don't tell me there are no heroes in Bitcoin. Consider the early Bitcoiners who had to endure wild volatility, more of them having bought Bitcoin at its highs than at lows, and having to find the conviction to hodl through the wild swings as onlookers laughed and criticized. They did not know the project would survive. They did not cash out. [00:17:43] They stood strong. Don't tell me there's no heroes in Bitcoin. Consider those who still hold and don't sell when Bitcoin is under attack. Heroes. What about those who invest their earnings every week instead of going along with the fiat system and its short-term rewards? Heroes. There's the developers who contribute to Bitcoin, any compensation and certainly not with the high salaries and stock options they would get working for venture-backed startups. [00:18:09] Heroes. What about all the content creators who research the true facts, counter misconceptions, and misstatements and offer them to the world, often for free? Heroes. There's the business operators that courageously resist governmental overreach to protect the privacy of their customers. Heroes. How about the Bitcoiners who build their own nodes and figure out how to compile the code to run it on those self-built nodes and who also teach others how to do this? [00:18:36] Heroes. The sentinels who patrol Twitter, Clubhouse, Telegram, and other social media platforms for scammers, who explain patiently and slowly and repeatedly to newcomers why Bitcoin has integrity, why it is a one-way trade, why those other crypto projects are centralized, have leaders, and are in fact corporations. [00:18:56] These are heroes too. And those who fight and struggle in underdeveloped nations to make Bitcoin available for a purely humanitarian mission? Heroes. The ones who started out with nothing themselves and figured out Bitcoin, and who now help others struggling little guys learn how, for the first time in their lives, to save money and develop a long-term perspective? [00:19:18] Heroes. Those who seek freedom for Ross Albrecht and Julian Assange? Heroes. Those who save for their families' futures? Heroes. Even those who have made mistakes and are prepared to admit them and get back on the right track? Also heroes. So don't tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin. [00:19:37] There are almost entirely only heroes in Bitcoin. Bitcoin was founded on heroism. Let us not forget the greatest Bitcoin hero of all, Satoshi Nakamoto. The very inventor of the idea of Bitcoin. A hero who had the genius to create what no one else was able to create before. [00:19:59] A hero who was able to devise the solution to a problem that mathematicians and computer scientists claimed to have proven could in fact not be solved. He solved that problem. He wrote the code that implemented the solution. He launched the project. Single-handedly. He carefully protected his true identity so that he could, disappear and make Bitcoin into truly decentralized, leaderless, incorruptible money. [00:20:31] He then had the actual courage to do the disappearing, to forsake all the fame that would come with being the inventor of Bitcoin, to abandon the fortune that came from being the original miner of Bitcoin, to surrender the power that might come with being able to pull the strings of Bitcoin. [00:20:50] No other crypto asset has any person of this ingenuity, of this integrity, of this genius, vision, and commitment. None have a creator whose greatest act of heroism is to decide to not be here now for the good of the project, to not take credit for or advantage of what he created. [00:21:10] So don't you dare tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin. We have the greatest hero in our ranks. Bitcoin is likely the greatest invention that we will see in the 21st century. It is certainly the greatest invention we have seen in it so far. What else comes even close? It has been so widely imitated. [00:21:30] Tens of thousands of imitators have come and either already gone or are on their way out. Yet Bitcoin has never once been duplicated. It has risen to a trillion dollars in value faster than any other asset in history. It has done so without hiring a single employee, without spending a single dollar on marketing, without raising a single penny from a venture capitalist, and without borrowing a single dollar from a bank. [00:21:56] It has done this because of Satoshi and the Bitcoiners who followed. What an extraordinary and unprecedented achievement. Heroes can help a single person, and heroes can change the world. Starting with Satoshi Nakamoto followed by so many others, a group of heroes armed with their minds, with their conviction, with their integrity, are doing just that. [00:22:20] They are changing the world through this project called Bitcoin. A project started by the hero, Satoshi Nakamoto, an enterprise supported, continued, and developed, firstly by the early Bitcoin heroes, afterwards by tens of thousands of heroes, for over 12 years so far, and one that will continue to be advanced by millions more in See for yourself then that there are, there always have been, and there always will be heroes in Bitcoin. [00:22:49] Let's finish with a brief epilogue. Take a look in the mirror. What do you see? Do you see one of the little guys? Maybe. But if you choose Bitcoin, it is a little guy standing up for himself and not being a victim. It is someone with courage resisting wrongdoing. [00:23:10] It is someone fighting for what is right, doing something that protects the weak from the powerful. It is the face of someone doing something beyond the ordinary, something extraordinary. It's someone doing their part in making a seeming impossibility possible. It is the face of someone making an idea into a reality. [00:23:31] The idea of a decentralized, non-government, engineered money that will last forever and be available without restriction to anyone, anywhere, and anytime. Bitcoin does have heroes, and if you're looking in the mirror right now, chances are you are seeing the face of one of those heroes. [00:23:50] So don't tell me that there are no heroes in Bitcoin. Just be one. [00:23:59] That's it, Brady. Bravo, sir. I was just giving a moment there to let that sink in. Very moving piece. I really appreciate how it highlights the tenuous nature of Bitcoin. It finished up there and we often talk about how Bitcoin will last forever, Bitcoin is incorruptible, et cetera. [00:24:25] And in terms of the code and what we've seen over the past 12 years, certainly has been. And the promise is that it will last, you know, because it is engineered money into the future. It can be adapted to any hardware that is developed into the future, any sort of coding techniques or languages, et cetera, that may be invented in the future. [00:24:49] But also it is quite tenuous. There is a small band, you know, you highlight 2017, there was a small band, relatively small band of heroes who fought against powerful interests and nearly lost. It was certainly a close battle and at times it was very tenuous. [00:25:10] And that's what made them heroes, right? Is that they fought in face of and in spite of the fact that they may lose. And so I feel like this does highlight the fact that Bitcoin does need a collection of individuals who are willing to fight on behalf of it. [00:25:29] And now, maybe more than ever, as Bitcoin is starting to grow onto the international stage and facing bigger and bigger challenges. So what are your thoughts on the tenuous nature of Bitcoin and where we find ourselves now and the call from Bitcoin for heroes to fight in its defense? [00:25:52] It's a great question. I think probably what motivated me most to write this article is the recognition of the type of person that Bitcoin draws in. Starting with Satoshi Nakamoto, someone who was prepared to stand up and solve a problem. And then all the early Bitcoiners who the potential of the idea and took the risk to hold on to it and to run it. [00:26:20] And then all the people who joined in the four cores and all the people who are joining now, and we keep getting to different stages of the then they fight you. And the people who are fighting us now are a bigger group. And there are passive people in Bitcoin, people who merely invest in it and view it as an into fiat money but there are many and i don't i want to say many more maybe i don't know if if there's many more who recognize this but who are in it because they know that there's something right here and that they know that they're fighting for something right and [00:26:59] I think that makes them heroes that you know it we all have it in us we the potential to be heroic beings to stand up for what's right, to protect the little guy, to be part of a fair system and to not back down. And this to me is the most beautiful thing. [00:27:19] I mean, there's so many beautiful things about Bitcoin, but this is at least one of the most beautiful things is it allows us to harness our collective heroism to stand up and create something new and powerful. And that if one soldier has to rest or one soldier falls one hero disappears. [00:27:42] It is not a setback to the movement. The movement can continue to go forward. And the episode that I talk about in depth in that article about those 2017 fork wars, we had a lot of people turn on Bitcoin. [00:28:01] A lot of people take a bribe or try to take control of Bitcoin. And so they went from the ranks of Bitcoin to the ranks of attacker of Bitcoiners and Bitcoin. And we just kept marching on. And I think this is, it's such a glorious story to tell. [00:28:21] The history of Bitcoin, starting with this anonymous creator and with these committed users who never backed down in the face of corporate interests, in the face of the powerful, who used their ingenuity, their determination, their conviction. Story for the ages. [00:28:39] And this is just kind of chapter, you know, if I review it from this heroic perspective, this is just chapter one of Bitcoin heroes. This is like volume one, issue one, save this comic strip. The supermen are going to, there's going to be 50 issues a year for 50 years or a hundred years of this because Bitcoiners really care about this. [00:29:02] Yeah. It's interesting. So we were using the word heroes and words like fighting for, and putting at least your well-being, your savings on the line. In the case of Ross Ulbricht losing his life, there were the analog in history that we often point to, and there might be several of these, but the one that I think of often is the American Revolution and the fight to decentralize power from the monarchy in England. [00:29:37] And there are some analogs here because we are fighting to decentralize the power of the printing press of money from monarchical power over money that we think has led to abuses of all kinds. And so this, though, I'm thinking of Nic Carter's piece, The Most Peaceful Revolution. [00:30:00] Yeah. Yeah. So this is heroes of a different nature. You know, it's not, you know, conscripted farmers marching against the redcoats, etc. We don't meet on the field of battle with muskets and fire bullets at each other. [00:30:21] I would say during the American Revolution, they were also the intellectual heroes of that era, too, who wrote the essays and the papers and the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. And they were in it for intellectual reasons. [00:30:40] It wasn't just an armed struggle to see which gang could achieve power. It was an ideological struggle, as you point out. And so I think at this stage of the Bitcoin revolution, which we all hope will be a most peaceful revolution, as Nick writes, it is. [00:31:00] It's a battle of an idea. And we meet in the field of exchanging fiat for Bitcoin and holding Bitcoin and converting fiat for Bitcoin and the intellectual field all the time. And that's one of the early things that i point out in this essay is it's every day it is a battle of ideas because bitcoin is when you see it when you understand it when you research everything else you come to an objective conviction that this is the money that the human race deserves and needs [00:31:38] To thrive and to flourish but we're not the you know we have people with different ideas is. We have the whole fiat regime, which for just about everyone live has been around for the majority, if not the entirety of their lifetime. So there's so many people who don't know better. There's so many people who are paid by the fiat system to preserve the fiat system. [00:32:00] And it's very hard to get someone who is paid not to see something to see something, which is the battle that we have on that end. And there's people who have been raised in the fiat regime who can see that there's something phony about it who say well i'll create my own phony fiat system which is the entire altcoin industry i you know it's it is the wheel has been invented we don't need the wheel reinvented and they're all claiming to reinvent the wheel but they're actually the key one of the key parts of this invention is that tatoshi went away he didn't make a fortune off of this he doesn't take the fame he doesn't take the power [00:32:38] That's his sense well that's not right we know the name and of the person who is still who created them who's still in charge of them who can pull the strings who is at who is getting the fame the power and the money from it and so they haven't reinvented anything there other than the fiat system they have they haven't they haven't reproduced and that i mentioned that point it's an important point that says bitcoin's been imitated thousands and thousands of times and never duplicated and this is it's easy to duplicate the code it's very hard it's impossible to duplicate the [00:33:16] Discovery because satoshi is the only one who just you can't have a second discoverer and it's also really hard to implement the most courageous act of heroism that he did or the most heroic act which is disappearing without the fame without the fortune without the power we haven't seen anybody else do that yeah i think there there's been one the mimble wimble people who were but obviously that was, I mean, it's a conglomeration of all of these circumstances, right? [00:33:50] You could stay anonymous or pseudonymous and put a new cryptocurrency out there, but you cannot recreate the network that's already been built. You cannot recreate the value or for that matter, the exact properties of Bitcoin. Even if you ran the exact same code, the properties of bitcoin this is it it does it doesn't need reinventing right yeah jan prisker has written the book inventing bitcoin i suppose we could make some funny jokes about other people who have who are the authors of the book called reinventing bitcoin attempting to reinvent bitcoin [00:34:28] But it doesn't need the reinvention like if someone comes up with a great new insight in the space as segregated witness was it fixed a bug and allowed for the lightning network to happen you can adopt bitcoin with it and i do kind of point it out it's it is like reinventing the wheel you know someone invented the wheel we like satoshi we don't know who invented the wheel they don't get the fame the power there's no patent on the wheel that this person gets and i mean it was so long ago that people probably didn't even have names at the time that the wheel was invented but we don't need to re we don't need to reinvent it the people who go down in history [00:35:06] Are the people who use the wheel and build something out of wheels they build it's the same Same thing with Bitcoin. It's not a reinvention of money. It is an improvement upon money. And the idea has been around for a long time and it's been compared to gold for a long time. It's an improvement upon, it's a perfecting of money, which has been around for a long time. [00:35:27] You said, you mentioned there that there's this, you build up this conviction until you reach an objective truth. And some people, like newcomers that might be listening, will sort of recoil at such language, such certainty. [00:35:48] Exactly. So can you explain why conviction in Bitcoin or why an understanding of Bitcoin might be objective as opposed to subject? Sure. It's almost, I guess the question is, what allows a person to reach a position of topic and this is a philosophical point within the branch of philosophy called epistemology which is how we know how we know things and everything is known within some within some kind of context but i think if if we look to scientific theories for example [00:36:26] Because we will agree we know that matter is made out of atoms now and we know that the theory of gravity holds within a context as you start to approach the speed of light or get to things as small as quantum objects those those rules don't necessarily apply in or they apply only with the right context in there but we have these proven theories right we have this conviction that matter is made out of atoms and that's because we were able to conduct lots and lots of experiments and have insights over time. [00:36:58] And we saw that everything pointed to this theory of the atomic theory of matter and nothing contradicted it. And we did have to evolve and adapt it over time. And I think this is the Bitcoin theory of money is this theory that we're essentially learning more and more and more about. [00:37:17] And I don't think one could have had this conviction back in 2011 when it was still early and we didn't know if it was unhackable and we But the evidence mounts. When Bitcoin continues, Bitcoin can be attacked any second of any day, 24-7 by anyone in the world. And the prize for attacking Bitcoin gets bigger and bigger and bigger as the price of Bitcoin gets bigger and bigger and bigger. [00:37:42] And yet nobody has successfully attacked Bitcoin. We start to see how the decentralization of it means that you can't kill it easily. You take out parts of it here and there. And it turns out that it's good for it, right? Life if you subject life to stress you don't kill life life adapts and now it's now it can deal with a pre-stress situation the post-stress situation at the time that we're recording this we are probably 24 to 36 hours away from the biggest hash rate difficulty adjustment negative in the history of bitcoin something like 27 of the hashing power has disappeared within the last two weeks [00:38:20] It turns out it's good for bitcoin right we were all we're all for years watching the exponential But what does it show? It shows that Bitcoin cannot only absorb more energy when it's exposed to energy, it can also easily adapt to having energy withdrawn from it. And in this particular case, the energy is being withdrawn from one of the causes of the biggest criticisms of Bitcoin, which is too much of the hashing energy power is in China and China has banned it. [00:38:47] And so the consequence is, for two weeks, we had slightly slower blocks. And on the other side of this gate is more decentralized and Bitcoin demonstrated it can withstand this kind of attack or this kind of stress, this kind of pressure. And so we will have more conviction. [00:39:07] I mean, we have it even going in because we can see the light at the end of this tunnel where we had to wait 13 minutes for blocks sometimes on average. Two hours this morning. Yeah. Well, I mean, I've waited for two hours. Yeah. I'm just pointing out. I've waited for two hours before. Yeah. Because there's natural, there's normal variance but i think when you average out over it's a 27 difficulty adjustment so it's 13 it's 13 minutes right right like that that's that's what we've experienced on average this period and so when when that's over and done with everyone who said oh the biggest risk bitcoin has is china will ban mining because so much mining is there now [00:39:46] What now now you see now we all see right before we had an argument now we have evidence a fact an experiment done in the real world that shows us bitcoin survived this too but bitcoin didn't there's a web there's a twitter account that says did bitcoin die today and every day they publish the word no i'm pretty sure that on tuesday they will they will have published the word no for another five days from now so this is what i'm talking about when i talk about the conviction of it and when you look at what are the important tests, these tests of decentralization, these tests of nobody being in control, these tests of it keeping its promises, [00:40:25] It's continuing to maintain an uptime, no double spending, no breakage of the mathematics behind it, no inflation bugs, no people in charge, it's doing it. And I think one of the biggest questions that people always have, well, won't this technology be replaced by something else? [00:40:45] That's the point I'm really trying to make about the wheel. No, we never had to replace the wheel. We continue to make improvements to the wheel. Even when we built airplanes, they still have wheels on them. Everything has wheels on it. I'm standing here. I've got a stand-up desk. There's a chair. I know I should have sold it. They've all got wheels on them. [00:41:04] I've got a whiteboard. It's got wheels on it because it's the most efficient invention we ever came up with ever to move stuff on land. And Bitcoin's the most efficient thing we've ever come up with to store and move value. And so it's, it just keeps getting more and more to the point where it's proven with conviction. [00:41:24] Nothing can ever be a hundred, hundred percent certain in all contexts forever, but it doesn't have to be like, we built this whole civilization with a theory of gravity and a theory of atomic matter and, and all these other things, which we know are right within the context that we need them for. And we'll continue to build our civilization with a better theory of what good money is that is modern money. [00:41:49] I just think that, you know, the people who appreciate the monetary aspects of gold and aren't Bitcoiners simply haven't looked at Bitcoin because it's got all the monetary aspects of gold, but better. Right. And so it's kind of like they're stuck in primitive times. [00:42:08] It's like they still want to use a wooden wheel, even though we now have the rubber wheel and the inflatable tire and all these different variances that make the wheel better through technology. I'm not sure what the mental hurdle is, but it's going away. There won't be people in 20 years who still hold that view. [00:42:30] Yeah. So that's definitely a great description of how you can arrive at conviction in the network and a theory of networked money. And Bitcoin is an implementation of that and has proven that theory that this is the best way to do it, the most efficient way to do it over and over again. But there are well-studied properties of money that we can call a theory of money that has these what have proven over thousands of years to be sort of objective properties of good money. [00:43:02] And there's these competing theories out there, like the Keynesianism, for instance, it says, no, these are better properties for money. And now that we have the ability to, we have economic science or whatever, we can actually improve upon these previously objective sound money or good money. [00:43:26] And it's interesting because we have these two competing theories. Now we have an implementation of the gold type of money again, but it's not able to be co-opted, which gold was. So we're left without competition of theories of money for practical implementation of those two theories of money to compete against each other. [00:43:48] Now we have Bitcoin and we have this theory of money, we might have arrived at this near certainty that Bitcoin is a better instantiation of the objective truths of money than the dollar. But we don't necessarily have to, no one else has to ascribe like we do to that idea and we'll see them compete against one another. [00:44:12] Yeah. So this is it. I mean, there's modern monetary theory, which is what they're calling the evolution of Keynesianism today. And there's, I'll call it the rational theory of money, which is what Bitcoiners ascribe to today or the sound theory of money. [00:44:31] And they have very different belief systems about what we can do with money. But one is certainly, the modern monetary theory certainly says, if you put some people in charge and allow them to print money them to set the price of money, they can build a better economy than others. [00:44:52] So it's just another version of totalitarianism, authoritarianism, right? Monarchy, however you want to label these things, some system where there are a few people in power who claim that they're going to do good for everybody else. The 20th century showed us through horrific, horrific circumstances, is what happens when you give complete power, total authority to a small group of people. [00:45:21] People are corruptible. People are fallible. And the modern monetary theorists, I think, reject that fact. They say, put us in charge. We will do what's good. And when things don't work out, we'll just do more of what we think we can do. [00:45:39] It's a very limited set of tools they have. Money or they can change the speed of the printer. They can, in theory, slow it down to zero, but they can change the speed of the printer and they can set interest rates. And they think that they're going to fix the whole world with these interventions into civilization. It seems, and again, the experimental evidence, if we talk about conviction, it continues to show that it doesn't work, right? [00:46:04] They keep having to say, we need to print more. We need to print it faster. This, each crisis that is created through money printing is more severe than the crisis before. So, you know, it's something that's meant to generate stability and steadiness. What we actually see is greater and greater volatility. So there's tremendous evidence, again, to prove the theory wrong. [00:46:24] And to prove a theory wrong, you don't need hundreds of pieces of evidence, right? If you saw one thing that fell up, you'd say, okay, well, there's something wrong with the theory of gravity. It's not proven anymore. And you see countless contradictions to the modern monetary theory. So I think it's a false theory. It's easy to demonstrate that it's false. Doesn't prevent people from clinging to it, especially the people who benefit the most from it, interestingly enough. [00:46:49] So what about the idea that gold does not allow us to turn those knobs at all, or Bitcoin, to turn the knobs of the speed of the printing press or interest rates? Well, I guess you would still be able to buy up debts or whatever if you wanted to buy up bad debt or something with Bitcoin. [00:47:12] But let's say for instance, I often hear that the Great Depression was caused by a lack of monetary control over the supply and that we would have been able to dampen the harsh effects that came for years and years out of the Great Depression and onward. [00:47:32] So this often gets, as pushback gets cited, that having no control over the monetary supply actually causes booms and bust cycles to be worse. Well I'm I'm pretty sure like I'm not I'm not the great historian about the Great Depression but I'm pretty sure that there were lots of government interventions with decreasing the price of money and that there was that there was some form of inflation that led to a stock market bubble and everybody putting their money in the stock market at crazy unreasonable valuations that led to the Great Depression and then we and then there was tremendous [00:48:11] Government intervention once it kicked in in an attempt to fix it, which likely made it worse. So I'm not, I don't, I don't, I don't want to be the expert that you have on to talk about the history of the Great Depression, but there was, there was a new deal and the new deal was a tremendous amount of government intervention and it kicked in right as the Great Depression. [00:48:30] You know, when we look at history, it's like, oh, the years of the greatest depression are the years of the, of tremendous government intervention and control and attempts to redistribute and fix the system. And maybe So I think as historians, we might have people argue about whether or not, in fact, the Great Depression was as bad as it was because of increased intervention by central authorities into the economy rather than the other. [00:48:56] Well, there's a lot of history that argues, and I'm diving into it more and more just because I am interested in what happened there. But most of the history books will say that the New Deal saved the economy, the seizure of gold and the repricing of gold to give the government more purchasing power, spending power in the short run, save the economy, etc. [00:49:17] And same thing that will be said about what happened last year. Yeah, thank God. Thank God we all locked down and shut everything down and put on masks. And everything else because otherwise we all would have died. So this is what people who control. Now, no matter how many people say a thing, it doesn't make it true. With history, they say that the victors get to write the history books, those in power. [00:49:42] And so they write history from their perspective. There's still a lot of opposing historic records. But the truth, the objective truth is still the objective truth. Would the free market have sorted out the economy? I'm certain it would have without the New Deal, but I don't have an alternate version of the universe to experiment with it. [00:50:13] So we have the universe we have, which is one in which the Great Depression took place. We ended up with a world war afterwards. With the situation getting to the point where all the gold in the world had to be seized and we had to implement a fiat money. So like, it doesn't really look like things got fixed thanks to the new deal. [00:50:34] I mean, you, you don't have to blame all these things on the new deal, but it wasn't like, okay, it got fixed and we've had, we've stably lived in a monetary system as was implemented at the end of the new deal for a hundred years. Wrong. Like we've had multiple shocks. The system didn't hold up. The system needed to continually be intervened with to a greater and greater and greater degree. [00:50:57] And so I think this is really the fundamental problem that we see with that history of this intervention from a sound money to a government manipulated, government controlled money is the oscillations are clearly getting bigger and bigger and bigger. The recessions are getting bigger and bigger and bigger. The volatility is getting wilder. [00:51:16] Exactly. My, my thought here is that sure it can work for a while. Right. And maybe it did help very possibly. And, and probably likely it did help the government with spending money and employing people maybe, you know, but the, you know, then, then the world war, world war two happens and creates massive demand for jobs and, and, really helped reinvigorate the economy in the United States. [00:51:41] You know, as a, as an outcome of, you know, just a massive mobilization of [00:51:47] Military, creation of military [00:51:51] Power, et cetera. But then it happens again, and then it happens again, and you kick the can down the road, and you create this moral hazard that if you've done it once, you've got to do it again. And here we are. So at some point, it blows up, and that's been the idea for a long time. [00:52:10] And the economic response to COVID was unprecedented in terms of money printing and the increase in the money supply in percentage terms. And I think personally that it was a good thing to mask up and to social distance and you should isolate yourself if you're sick and things like that. [00:52:32] But just the money printing and then maybe lockdowns lasted too long and that had a bad effect on the economy as well. Arguable. But it's the money printing. It's that response. And anytime there's a crisis like that, you have a greater and greater response. Happens again, you know, 10 years from now, it's going to be, you know, doubling of the display. [00:52:52] Yeah. And I think this is the trap that instead of actually thinking about what the best way to solve the problem is, because there's this bandage, which we call money printing, right? We can take more and more extreme measures without really having to think about their actual consequences, because we think the money printer fixes it, right? [00:53:10] We'll tell all the small businesses that they have to close down in regions and that they can't have customers come in, but we'll print money and hand it out. And so that will fix the problem. And it doesn't really fix the problem. Like production doesn't continue. People become depressed. People become confused. People become addicted to the free money without the work. [00:53:29] They stop providing value to other people. So the economy, the actual pricing system of what people want versus what people get breaks down. And we end up with less choice in the economy. We end up with less fulfillment, less engagement of the human mind and printing piles of money and handing them out to people to consume fewer and fewer goods and less and less variety of goods isn't progress, isn't fixing things. [00:53:56] It's seeing a problem and replacing it with a whole different problem that you think is potentially lesser, a smaller problem or a better understood problem. But but it is it is not it's again it's not a human way to really solve the problems we're not we're not applying our minds to solving these situations we're doing something really mindless which is just printing lots of money and handing it out and i think you know when when the dust settles and everything is clear we'll see oh my god all sorts of people got money for nothing tremendous amounts of money for nothing a lot of people got really badly hurt you know i was [00:54:36] Federal Reserve call and they said, you know, we're continuing to do what we're doing until we get takeoff. They expect the economy to take off. So what they're, you know, even though it's, but it's not working what we're doing. We see that the poor are, are the most affected, most damaged by this lockdown thing. We still see that the rich are doing fine. [00:54:55] Like they acknowledge all of this stuff. The same things we say as a criticism of the monetary system, they're not denying it. They're just saying, let's, let us keep doing what we're doing we expect everything to be fine at some point in the future. And this is the mistake of the modern monetary theory. Those things that they expect are going to get fine, sometimes the storm settles down, but it's this wildly oscillating system that, you know, these things that oscillate, they cross the neutral line at various points in time. [00:55:24] And so they say, oh, look, modern monetary theory worked. Oh, no, it's too low. We got to accelerate. Oh, no, it's too high. And they cannot get this thing in any kind of harmony because it's a disharmonious system. It's not a freedom-based complex system there's no i mean you know the conceit that you can control or you know a system it's as complicated as the american or global economy is is insane with two dials that's it there's two there's two dials and so it is a it's a preposterous it is a preposterous notion it's a preposterous theory it's a repeatedly proven false theory but that doesn't stop the people who are in charge of it who who are the ones [00:56:02] Who least suffer the consequences of the fact that it's not working not right so we're you know you're handing out you know checks checks to people and you know say look these these people are in need of money we're going to print money and hand it out to them you know it's it's hard to argue against that that you need you know for people who don't haven't studied haven't studied money to argue against that that's a good idea but then they're hitting on the other side you know groceries are up 20 over the past few months and yeah there's inflation that they've created so but but again let's remember the nature of the problem it's it's cast for broken legs for free because you're the one who's [00:56:40] Gone around breaking people's legs. You're not the hero in this story, right? And so if you've imposed lockdown on people and you've told them that they can't live their life free to earn their money, and now you say, look, here's free money. You haven't done a good thing. You've tried to offset the bad thing that you started. And now you look at the thing that you're doing to offset the bad thing that you've started and you're seeing it's causing all kinds of other problems too. [00:57:06] And it's out of your control to fix it. Like it's, which is inflation in this case, it's causing this inflation and you don't know how to stop it because if you put a stop to it, then these people, then these people who you've tried to help because of the problem that you caused for them, which was locking down their business are going to go broke. So you're caught between a rock and a hard place. And of course, you shouldn't have gone around breaking people's legs in the first place. [00:57:26] It's the broken window fallacy over and over again. We don't create economic value by shutting down businesses or damaging them. If we let people make their own decisions, some people will make mistakes and they'll deal with the consequences. Maybe they'll learn they shouldn't be business people, or they'll learn how to run their businesses better. [00:57:46] Or they'll get sick and learn that they shouldn't have gone out. Yeah. Life comes with risks. And I think this is maybe epistemologically, twice in a single podcast, the biggest error that these theories pursue, which is they try to erase the laws of nature. [00:58:09] They try to erase the fact that life comes with uncertainty and that life comes with risk and that life comes with some element of danger. And that the solution to these things is a scientific understanding of what those causes are and how we can use nature to change it. We can't gloss over nature. [00:58:29] Sir Francis Bacon has this famous quote that's roughly translated to command nature, you must first obey it, which means you have to understand the actual laws of nature in order to then invent things from them. And these theories that do away with, well, what's the nature of money? [00:58:47] We can just print it ad hoc, at will, [00:58:53] Unlimited, violates, the actual theory of money, which is that it needs to be scarce, that it can't just be printed out of thin air. And that when it does get printed out of thin air, it causes tremendous volatility and leads to some kind of collapse, usually a monetary collapse. And so this attempt to refute the laws of nature is what's causing these concerns. [00:59:16] And if I just bring it back to Bitcoin to Bitcoin and the heroes. It's like, these are people who are saying, I'm not going to continue to subscribe to a flawed theory and be a subject and a victim of a flawed theory. I have my own theory. It doesn't have government backing. [00:59:34] It doesn't have government force behind it. I like that. It has a different kind of force behind it. It has the force of math and the force of physics behind it. I trust those forces. Those are forces that are, as Francis Bacon says, from the laws of nature. And they are more powerful than the force of government. [00:59:55] Because a government arbitrary decree, you know, if the government said the value of pi is three, not 3.14, I think there was once a historic moment where the church said something like that. It doesn't change it. And so there was some politician the other day that says the government must have the right to reverse bitcoin transactions and it's like well okay go for it like reverse the laws of math and physics pass a law and see if you could like bitcoin doesn't care math doesn't care right because it it's inviolate it's inviolable inviolable it doesn't it doesn't change so we have we actually have an [01:00:33] Ability to enforce a monetary system which opt into a monetary system regard. And I think that's kind of what's driving when we talk about this idea of Bitcoin derangement syndrome, which seems to affect people who are really committed to the modern monetary system. I think that moment kicks in when they actually look closely enough at Bitcoin and see that they can't change it, that they can't corrupt it, that they can't control it by decree. [01:01:00] And that for them is a moment that drives them into this seeming derangement, this panic that says well get the hell away from this thing this is dangerous we can't i can't control it or you know it's and i think this is this is the epistemological error that they make which is are they that terrified of the law of gravity are they that terrified of mathematics are they that terrified of the second law of thermodynamics or any of the laws of physics they're dangerous right you know like physics is dangerous planes if you don't engineer them correctly will drop from the Understand the laws of physics [01:01:38] You can never build a plane in the first place [01:01:42] I think this is why Michael Saylor is one of Bitcoin's great friends because he's an engineer at heart and he realizes That Bitcoin is this engineered money and when you engineer something properly and you can listen to hours and hours of him Going on about the engineered nature of Bitcoin and the engineered nature of any invention right science doesn't care if you want it to work you need to understand how it works and you need to engineer a solution that corresponds to the laws of nature that's what's beautiful about bitcoin this is engineered money engineered properly absolutely yeah lynn alden is the same [01:02:20] Way she's a engineer by training and i think that really helped her appreciate and understand when she understood you know got to the monetary understand the monetary aspects of bitcoin and It is interesting. We have very few, I'm trying to think, I don't know all of the people involved in the high offices of the modern, of the fiat system. [01:02:45] I don't think many of them are engineers. Right. I don't think any of them, to my knowledge, are engineers. They've studied political science, they've studied economics. But those are interesting fields because they're social sciences, right? They're not physical sciences. They're not the natural sciences. [01:03:04] And everything that we actually get reliable systems out of are the natural sciences. Yeah, I think I've heard Michael Saylor speak about Bitcoin as a new element, a newly discovered element or an invented element because it is so based on physics and immutable laws of physics and it ties into energy expenditure so directly the laws of physics into the digital realm is really interesting. [01:03:36] What do you think about, this is something I've been thinking about the last few days, the idea that El Salvador enforcing the acceptance of Bitcoin, enforcing economic actors to accept Bitcoin. What's your gut reaction on that idea? [01:03:55] And do you think it is in any way incongruent with the non-fiat nature of Bitcoin. Sure. Yeah. So again, I think there's context to this, and Bukele has been really clear about the context to this, which is, I'll offer my own opinion on what could be done differently, but I think he's done everything he can to offset. [01:04:19] He's not saying, I'm forcing you to accept Bitcoin and hold it. I think he's saying, I want Bitcoin to be an option for the people of this country, [01:04:30] And people are still free if they don't like Bitcoin. The second they accept it, I'll convert it back to the US dollar for them. So I think he is still leaving freedom for people to say, I don't choose Bitcoin. Part of saying, my first article that I wrote in my series, which became this e-book called Why Bitcoin, the article was called Why Choose Bitcoin? [01:04:56] And it said nobody will ever be forced to choose Bitcoin. And so people are telling me, yeah, your first article made a mistake. And so I certainly am opposed to forcing people to choose Bitcoin. I think one of the things that will happen, and so if I was going to write the law my own self, the rule would be what you want to get out of the way from is the government is going to treat Bitcoin when you want to spend it as though it were a vehicle and then convert it into money. [01:05:27] And then you have to do all this tax calculation on it. So you can't actually really spend it. Like every time you want to spend it, you have to do some big accounting transaction and claim gains or losses. I think that's kind of, that's a government thing that stands in the way of Bitcoin becoming a means of exchange. And so I would get rid of that. I would say you can spend Bitcoin, right? [01:05:47] And that would be the easiest thing. But it's very easy to sit in the, you know, and say this is how i would run a country when you're and then criticize somebody who's running a country that doesn't have its own currency and that has tremendous crime and violence and tremendous poverty bukele looks like he's doing a genuine hard-working effort to make this thing work he's putting he's he's putting a lot of risk into trying to make this thing go he's put it you know to be the first nation on earth to do this and he is giving people the freedom to not choose You [01:06:26] Must accept it, but I will immediately cover you. The government will immediately stand behind you and convert it. So I don't see it as any terrible forcing of Bitcoin down people's throats. I do think one of the important things when it comes to choosing Bitcoin is like today, you know, 12 years ago, it was a really crazy idea to choose Bitcoin as your monetary standard. [01:06:48] And today, it's still a really difficult thing to say, I choose Bitcoin as my monetary standard. In fact, for those of us with conviction to say, I choose it as my store of value. Like I'm, the Bitcoin's my store of value, but it's, it's hard to say, well, it's my means of, it's my means of exchange because, well, medium of exchange, because it's really hard to exchange it. [01:07:09] And we still have these tax laws that make it hard to exchange it. As time moves on, as more and more of this kind of thing happens, the ability to choose Bitcoin is going to become easier and easier and easier. It's going to become an obvious choice. It's going to be like the choice to breathe in air. And so and so it people people might say oh i'm i have no alternative well it's like yeah you have no alternative to breathe in air too because it's kind of obvious right and so it's not that somebody's forcing you to do it it's everybody in the world has chosen bitcoin you're welcome to not use bitcoin but it's kind of like you're welcome to not live in civilization like you're welcome to stroll into the forest and try to live without the modern amenities of our scientific [01:07:47] Civilization but then you have to live with the consequences of not being in that in this network and so yeah this is just the nature of money this i mean this is yeah you know the nature of money throughout human history you know sure yeah if you're in a civilization that uses yeah if you live in a civilization where they use seashells and you show up with salt it's like it's just never gonna be like i'm not gonna use i'm not gonna use the internet i'm going to use brady I'm going to use Brady net and be over here. [01:08:16] No, like in that civilization, if you should like four people on my network. Yeah, exactly. If you're using, if everybody's using seashells and you show up with beads, they're going to say, you've got a shit coin, right? Right. That doesn't make any sense to us. And so, so I think we're moving in that direction where everybody's ultimately going to use Bitcoin because it's, everybody uses the wheel, right? [01:08:35] You don't see people rolling things on square wheels and you don't see people carrying stuff around in their bare hands when, need is a dolly, which is a platform with wheels attached to it. They use it. And so that's the direction we're moving into. The wheel is this engineered solution for moving stuff, and Bitcoin is this engineered solution for moving value. [01:08:58] Well, let's wrap up with a little speculation on the coming challenges. We started out with the idea of Bitcoin heroes had risen to several challenges throughout its history. I feel like we're at an interesting inflection point now that we're, as we just discussed, tipping over into the nation state territory. [01:09:20] And how do you think this might play out? You can give us a couple scenarios if you want or whatever. Over the next five, 10 years, as nation states react to the growing influence and adoption of Bitcoin. Yeah. Part of the exciting thing is it's hard to predict. [01:09:41] I think this notion, I have a very optimistic belief that Bitcoin is inevitable, but the way that it rolls out, and it's inevitable because no matter which way it rolls out, out of a million, billion different ways, the ending is the same. The path is the same because it's the scientifically sound system of money. So it will win out against crazy theories that don't correspond to reality. [01:10:02] But exactly how it plays out is going to be real interesting. If I was to say, where, given the theme of the essay that I read, where are we going to see heroes rise? We're going to see heroic movements within nations that may or may not be political, like within the political structure of the nation. [01:10:21] I think El Salvador began with a beach, right? And it made sense over there because the president could come to the beach and see that people actually had a sound money that they were using and that it actually worked. So we'll have perhaps more of these grassroots efforts that will not be a beach in some countries. [01:10:42] There might be a village in some countries. It could be anything in these other countries that will be grassroots. There will be political top-down movements that either help Bitcoin or try to oppose Bitcoin. And there'll be heroes needed in those situations. I think there will be inventive opportunities for heroes people who actually do raise the capital and build the businesses to create these great mining a bitcoin mining solutions with stranded energy coming from volcanoes or inventing fusion energy and having the motivation and the cap you know and the compensation to do it because you can mine bitcoin with it so and the scientists who [01:11:20] Invent those things and engineer those solutions to capture that energy we're going to see some of some of those things happen. We're going to see software heroes develop easier ways to use Bitcoin and, you know, and they'll be competing in a free market of ideas and innovation to try to see who can come up with the best solutions to make it universally accessible to everybody on earth. [01:11:42] So I think that, you know, as Bitcoin continues to grow and we'll see people invent all these higher layer solutions or these inventions that utilize Bitcoin, just like we saw people, heroes who took the wheel and invented the automobile and the airplane and all these other things that use it that i think is the is the coming future but predicting any individual thing like saying oh you know it'll be paraguay next and then venezuela after that and then estonia is is it's you know that's that's kind of gambling but the principles behind bitcoin are incredible it is this sound it like it's sound it's based off of nature it [01:12:21] Corresponds to the It corresponds to the laws of nature and to the theory of money, the rational theory of money. And so it's going to do amazing, wonderful things. I think the other really incredible thing, kind of my last thought on it, is it takes us away from having this belief in a flawed system of money, which distorts us. [01:12:44] I want to say it distorts our souls. In order to earn fiat money in a lot of instances you have to do what the fiat overlords say or play in their game which grants money to not people who are creating value for other people but people who are playing in the industries that benefit from being close to the money printing so it turns us into puppets and living in this world that's completely over financialized which is like 25% of our economy how many really smart people graduate from school because it makes sense to a job that doesn't really add any value to the world in finance, but they're [01:13:22] Investment bankers or financial advisors. We shouldn't have to need financial advisors who don't know what tomorrow's stock market will be worth so that we can gamble on the stock market because we know it's too dangerous to not gamble on the stock market because everything's been financialized. Those people could do things that they love to do and things that are valuable for other people if we if we see the sunset on the non-valuable economy that is what rises in the in the shadows of an irrational fiat money system so i think that's kind of that's the most exciting thing for me which is people will really get to be themselves again and we've this [01:14:00] Whole fiat era has has really distorted that i think it it's a whole topic for another deep deep discussion but the main the main cause of it is because you know how the hell that happens. I mean, the main cause is that you have to spend your entire life working in the fiat system because you cannot save money. [01:14:19] It's inflated away from you, which is an insidious tax. And you can't, that's why, you know, I can't remember the exact number, but it's crazy. Something like 50, 60, 70% of Americans have less than a thousand dollars in their savings account. They don't have access to these assets. They don't have access to save for their retirement. [01:14:38] It's not just inflation, right? It's the fact that the system, because it looks at GDP as a number and says, if any month GDP goes down, if that number goes down from the previous month, we're going to print more money to stimulate the economy. So the economy is overstimulated. [01:14:56] Nobody really cares. If people figure out how to manufacture things cheaper and the free market causes prices to go down, which it has in many, many things, so people get to save more money, well, that looks like negative GDP growth. And so we get all this unnecessary stimulus because real consumption, it has been growing, but measured consumption, GDP is going down. [01:15:20] And so we get these interventions because the theory of money is a flawed theory of money and they don't want a recession. They don't want to recreate the Great Depression. And so everybody is encouraged to consume and the economy encourages overconsumption. I was saying this on another podcast the other day. [01:15:39] It's like I'm 51 years old. I was born in 1970, one year before the fiat standard. And when I was a little kid in school, obesity wasn't really a problem. Maybe one kid in the class who was overweight because we hadn't had this sugar, we hadn't had this overly marketed hyper-stimulated, we didn't have the same amount of Wellpheiser, but we didn't have this overstimulated thing of buy candy. [01:16:04] Like Halloween was the candy time. It was crazy. You got candy. You didn't have it year round. The cereal wasn't quite candy all the time. There wasn't this widely available sugar. Pepsi made its mark by making a big bottle of pop available. Because pop was hard for people to get. [01:16:23] So we weren't nearly as driven to consume. And the fiat system came in and it freaked out over any decrease in consumption. Like its only measure, its only goal is increased consumption month over month. We need growth in consumption. We must have growth in consumption. And so it is this thing that turns us, well, if you're just going to keep consuming more and more and more, well, what's going to happen to you? [01:16:48] No wonder we're going to get obese for one because you just keep shoving stuff inside of you and all around you and we're surrounded by garbage and then we're concerned there's too much pollution well you forced us to buy all these things if we didn't buy these things you would have said you would if you stopped buying these things you freaked out so like let's get we don't need crazy and we don't need to be surrounded by garbage we don't need to eat constantly we can we can be healthy. [01:17:14] We can find value in our time spent with other people doing things we love to do. That's kind of what I'm trying to get at, which is the distinction between what the fiat system says, which is no, no, we need economic growth at all costs. Don't, don't spend time walking in the forest, talking to your friends, unless you're, you know, consuming data and drinking beer or pop or, or something that's creating economic value, because the only value we put any value on is economic value. [01:17:43] There's a lot of things that money can't buy, I guess is my point. And they shouldn't be totally cast aside by our system of rule. We should be happy with what we need rather than endlessly pushed to get what just drives a number as measured in one central bureaucrat's office. [01:18:07] It definitely does set a tone or standard for a culture the way the an economic theory it obviously sets a tone and a standard for the culture because it's money is is really the foundation of civilization in terms of bringing people together and finding efficient solutions to problems etc you know that's that's aside from all of the you know kind of philosophical and spiritual and cultural aspects of a society. [01:18:37] But when you're talking about organizing the society and making it function, the money is the foundation. And if you have a money that just overwhelms with the enforcement or impetus to consume, it's going to change a lot of things. [01:18:57] So yeah, you have the ability to actually save money. Maybe you have to work 10 years at a job. You don't particularly love. And then you have the savings to create a business or, you know, pursue your craft in some way that you really love and find fulfilling. And it's, it really would change the way society operates in the experience of humans in society. [01:19:20] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I, I, I'll kind of finish off one point, which is, I, I've now written three articles on Bitcoiners. This, this one that I just read being the third one. The first one was about Bitcoiners not being toxic, saying that, in fact, we have integrity, and that's what society is labeling, or our critics are labeling as toxicity. [01:19:39] The second one was called Rich or Poor, Bitcoiners Have What Money Can't Buy. And it's really, it's all about this. And it already shows how Bitcoiners have opted out of the system of consumption, right? We have this low time preference. We are studied. We care about money. We care about science. We care about getting to truth. [01:20:00] On all these other truths, right? There's a very broad spectrum of how Bitcoiners view the severity, seriousness, and appropriate reaction to COVID, for example. But they're thinking, they're engaged. And one of the things I point out is that one of the things money can't buy is intelligence. Bitcoiners' minds are active because they're questioning the system. [01:20:21] They're trying to understand what's going on. And so that's creating intelligence, which happens to be something that money can't buy. There's a bunch of things that I talk about in that article. It's much shorter the one I read here. But it is interesting to me how we're already starting to live in the future, which is a more freed system, freed from the goals of the monetary rulers and more our own choices about what we value, what we want to learn about, what we want to do with our lives. [01:20:50] And that's already something that even though you can't spend Bitcoin anywhere as easily as you can the US dollar, it's something that becoming a Bitcoiner, even withholding very little of it, even being poor, is a benefit that you get from becoming a Bitcoiner. Thank you so much, Tomer. I really appreciate the conversation. It's been great the past few weeks to get to work with you a little bit at Swan. [01:21:14] It's so fun to have you contributing your fantastic writing skills to the squad. If you have not checked out Tomer's work, 21 Ways, you can find that. No, that's Gigi. That's our friend Gigi. 21 Ways. Which is terrific. Why Bitcoin? Yeah. [01:21:33] Why Bitcoin? You should check out 21 Ways. Gigi and I keep talking about how he's in my brain and I'm in his. But I wrote Why Bitcoin? The series, which is 26 articles if you go to the Swan Bitcoin version, 25 if you get it off of my medium. You get a bonus article. [01:21:53] So that's swanbitcoin.com slash why Bitcoin. 21 Ways is Gigi's new book coming out hopefully this year. Thank you for correcting me there. I've worked with just too many great writers. It's a terrible problem that I have. It's awful. All right. Thanks, Tomer. I'm actually very flattered to be mistaken for Gigi for a second even. [01:22:13] So it's terrific. Thank you. Thank you. Take care. You too. [01:22:31] Thanks so much to Tomer for joining me. You can find Tomer on Twitter at TomerStrollite. That's T-O-M-E-R-S-T-R-O-L-I-G-H-T. And I am at CitizenBitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast is at CitizenBitcoin.world. Share this one with family and friends. [01:22:50] We are here in a great zone to get your family and friends starting to stack. Accumulation here between 30,000 and 40,000. And it seems like there will be another surge coming in the next few months. And if not, hey, bear markets are great to stack. So get them on board at swanbitcoin.com. [01:23:11] Get them on board with the Citizen Bitcoin podcast and we'll take good care of them. And thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin podcast in their feed. Also check out the podcast I've created for Swan, the Swan Signal podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal live broadcasts that we do on YouTube and Twitter live on video. [01:23:37] We have a couple of Bitcoiners that join us. We have discussions about Bitcoin and economics. You can subscribe at swansignalpodcast.com. And if you have any questions from me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at citizen bitcoin on Telegram. All right, that's it for this week. [01:23:56] Take care out there Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world.