Bitcoin Turns Ten Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-01-03 [00:00:14] Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. All you fellow citizens of Bitcoin out there. It's 2019. It's been about six weeks since we published a pod. Tommy, how's it going? It's going great, man. We took a little break there. Yeah, we did, but it needed it. [00:00:32] Yeah, we need well, you know, just the way it, you know, just the way it kind of laid out. Had some travel and just couldn't connect it together. I guess we could have forced it, but it's better to do it now because you know why? Why's that? It's the birthday of Bitcoin. It is today is is the is the tenth birthday of Bitcoin. It's pretty amazing. [00:00:51] It's a birth birthday, man. Yeah. January 3rd, 2009. The Genesis block was mined. And so today we're gonna spend some time talking about the first 10 years of Bitcoin, the history of Bitcoin, where it came from, what what happened, what how we got to where we are today. Might do a little bit of speculation on what the next 10 years might look like. [00:01:12] What where we might be well we talked about just for everybody understand we talked about it before we got on on the podcast here and I my answer I probably have it's probably not a good answer, but maybe it's maybe a Richard Feynman answer. I don't know. Well yeah, I mean nobody can't we can't know. [00:01:31] We certainly can't even. I mean ten year ten years out is you know it's kind of hmm. Yeah. Well we'll talk about what we what we might be able to expect coming up this year. That that's something that we can that's fair we can speculate with the with more information. And I might make some wild speculation about 10 years from now. Not you. [00:01:50] Are we bring it are we're gonna bring out rockets? Oh, the rockets are coming out. Rockets. There's some people that were doing rockets on there they did some rockets on tw on Twitter. Yeah, I think I think the rockets are gonna be going sideways for for quite a while longer before they start lifting back off again. [00:02:10] Anyway, so did you have good holidays? Love the rockets. Yeah, how about yourself? How about yourself? It was good, man. It was good. Good time with family. Took a little break from work. Got a got a little crazy there toward the end of the year, kind of wrapping some projects up and a lot of my my son turned four in December, and so we had kind of some birthday celebration stuff to handle, and we were busy and we tried to get a pot in there in December. [00:02:37] But it just didn't work out. So it was it ended up being a nice break. You know, actually last time we talked recorded an episode was the day of the hash wars. And I just thought before we dive into Bitcoin history stuff. I forgot about that because we actually were on there with the hash wars and Bitcoin Cash stuff. [00:02:56] Yeah, and so what the heck's going on? Actually, it reminds me because we were we were always kind of yeah whatever on well Bitcoin I think big. In other words, we were we were underwhelmed by by Bitcoin Cash to begin with. Right, right. It was kind of fun fun to watch that day. [00:03:18] Both of them price wise compared to Bitcoin are are pretty low. They're like Bitcoin Cash 0.025 or like a basically and if we yeah 2.5% of a Bitcoin. Yeah, but yeah, exactly. And if we use the fiat, it's 163.48 US dollars according to CoinMarketCap. [00:03:38] And then Bitcoin. Oh, BCH is up to point oh four of a four four point two percent of a Bitcoin. Bitcoin S V is two point three percent of a Bitcoin. So Bitcoin Bitcoin Cash is sort of made some separation price wise. So I assume Yeah, what happened to the other Bitcoin one? [00:03:56] I don't know. They're gonna they're gonna do their thing. But actually the answer is we don't really SV. I don't know. Anyway. Well, actually, wait a second. It is what it is. S V. S V. Yeah, it's it's eighty-eight dollars and eighty cents. Yeah. So there you go. [00:04:15] Bitcoin cash is is ABC is worth twice as much as S V. Volume 79 million in the last twenty-four hours on S V. Bitcoin Cash, 250 million roughly. Yeah. And Bitcoin 4.4 billion six billion. [00:04:36] Four billion. Yeah. There you go. Sop womp w anyway, yeah, well, the other thing too from earlier in the year on is that we covered the what is it? I always promised Bitmain. Bit main, right, right? Yeah. And at the time we were like, you know, they put put all their kind of chips on Bitcoin Cash, right? [00:04:59] Yeah, they made a big I mean in terms of just very generally made a big bet on Bitcoin Cash and it's definitely been hurting them pretty bad. And they're at I think I mean it just seems like Bitcoin or the Bitmain is at at risk of that they're not it looks like they're not gonna be able to IPO in the Hong Kong exchange. That might be a good one. [00:05:17] Which we kinda thought that that might be falling through. Yeah, that's and it looks like the company itself is in trouble of just like actually staying alive. A lot of layoffs have happened. I think eighty percent of the employees have been laid off or something like that, I read, and of course Jihan Wu is out. So now Jian Wu is who again? [00:05:36] He was the CEO of Bitmain, yeah. And he was the one actually kind of teaming up teaming up with Roger and Craig, and then they split off. You know, forkers gonna fork, man. That's that's what they do. That they they believe in hard forks is the way to govern Bitcoin. It's like a wild west movie where everybody's got you know, everybody's got a gun on maybe not wild west, maybe Pulp Fiction or something like that, where everybody's got a gun trained on the other person. [00:06:01] You know, I try to keep I try to keep tabs on all this stuff a little bit. But the idea is is everybody's just you know, yes, it's like that double cross. It's like that scene good and bad and the ugly at the end of the you know, where each each of the characters, main characters have a gun on each other. Yeah, well that's you know the one thing about that movie, right? Isn't that the good, the bad and the ugly where it's or no, that's outlawed Josie Wales with Clint Eastwood in it where he said, Are you a bounty hunter? [00:06:25] Yep, yeah. And then and then he and then says it's a living. Then Dying ain't much of a living boy, and he shoots him anyway. Anyway, I like that one. All right. We're used back to birthday Bitcoin. So happy birthday, Bitcoin. You know, the your illegitimate stepchildren, you know, notwithstanding. [00:06:48] We are excited to talk about I mean I think this is a big deal, you know. Ten years is one of those psychological numbers kind of like going over a thousand dollars for the first time or a hundred dollars for a first time, or one dollar for a first time, you know. Ten years is is I was talking to someone earlier today, and you know, I told him it was it was Bitcoin's birthday, and we were you know in the midst of a conversation, and he was like, Well, what what else is going on? [00:07:14] I was like, Yeah, you know, I'm still into this Bitcoin thing, and today's the 10th birthday, and he's like, Oh wow, 10, it's been around for 10 years. That's that's impressive. You know, that's that and I think to somebody who doesn't know much about Bitcoin or whatever, if you just kind of psychologically say to them, you know, this thing's been going without fail for 10 years, it is impressive. [00:07:33] Well, and the other thing and makes a difference. It's important to use this definition because we have in the past it the Lindy effect, or just the L-I-N-D-Y effect. Yeah. And I'm just gonna say, just real quick, what the definition is. The Lindy effect is a concept that the future life expectancy of some non-perishable things, like a technology or an idea, is proportional to their current age, so that every additional period of survival implies a longer remaining life expectancy. [00:08:06] Where the Lindy effect applies, mortality rate decreases with time. Yeah, so and it and it makes sense. That's just backing up the 10 years. Trust is a is a major factor in with money, obviously, right? So the longer that Bitcoin survives, the more trustworthy it becomes. [00:08:28] And that makes a big difference in the way people estimate it, you know, or think about it. So I think it's a big deal. So I think this would be a good day to talk about sort of the history of Bitcoin, where it came from, just kind of run through the story and hit some of the highlights and just kind of do some reminiscing a little walk down memory lane. [00:08:51] So a lot of people, of course, think that Bitcoin was the first cryptocurrency, but it's not. It's just the first one that really worked and was decentralized enough to work. The attempts before were failed for various reasons, but among those reasons were was the fact that they were centralized efforts that were able to be you know I guess regulated out of existence eventually. [00:09:20] So in the 80s and 90s, David Chom first proposed in in 1982, David Chom first proposed the concept of ecash, and he talked about using cryptography and to create untraceable payments so that there were and he was focused on privacy. [00:09:44] And so he created a company that was based in Amsterdam called Digicash, and Digicash issued a currency. It was a you know a centralized effort, obviously it was run by this company. It's you know Chom was a brilliant guy, and the effort, you know, there was quite a few raised quite a bit of money, quite a few really smart folks working on it. [00:10:11] And it worked to an extent, but it never really caught on and took off. Then in 1997, Adam Back invented hashcash, and that's where proof of work comes from. So this is here's one of the kind of pieces of the Bitcoin puzzle was invented in nineteen ninety seven. [00:10:32] Adam Back invented, and of course, Adam Back works with with bro Blockstream now. Hashcash was invented as a solution to email spam. Right. So you could use hash cache to basically pay postage for email which would disincentivize people from sending out tons of spam because there's a cost to it. [00:10:53] Email right and then the concept maybe this wasn't this deal specifically but I remember the idea and maybe Andreason talked about it from A16Z but the idea is at that point he was with Netscape in the nineties, yeah. Yeah and then maybe and then and somewhere in there but the idea of at a certain level maybe you tell somebody at at a certain number you're paying 'em to open your email. [00:11:19] So in other words like okay here's a dollar right here's five dollars now understanding you gotta figure out how you would yeah and there's there's a service built in Bitcoin that does that. I can't think of the name of it right now. Well actually wasn't that twenty we're bouncing around here but I think this is an important point. Wasn't that 21.co might have been that they changed the name to Earn Earn that's it. [00:11:38] That's the one that was 21.co okay they changed the name to Earn and then it got then it got acquired by Coinbase. Okay. And then but the idea is is their CTO is a A16Z partner, the guy whose name I can't that he's actually Balogy Shini Basan yeah. Yeah he he he went in there on that and so that was the idea between behind Earn was that particular I think that was a particular that's the one I was thinking of yeah. [00:12:03] Or you could say you could say if you wanted an expert they had people listed so if you wanted to pay somebody a hundred bucks or whatever. Yeah. If you want somebody to read an email send it to their earn inbox pay five bucks or whatever or whatever the just think if we would have done that with our podcast to begin with, we'd we'd it would be incredible. [00:12:21] Yeah, with all that incoming oh my god incoming you know messages that we get on the free systems. [00:12:31] Anyway, so, okay, let's get back to that. Yeah, [00:12:33] The next year 1998 was a big year for sort of the seeds of Bitcoin because Wei Dai, who was referenced in the white paper, his project B Money was a cryptocurrency it was a it was a proof of work, it used some it was built off of Adam Bax's proof of work system was put forth or like the described. [00:12:58] And then Nick Zabo also put out a similar proposal for Bit Gold and Umving and also was based on proof of work. So solving proof of work gets you bits, and the last bit of the string is used to create the string of the next transaction. So that idea of the chain of blocks wasn't was included in Bitgold. [00:13:19] So those were both just proposals, and but no code was ever no code was ever written. Then in the earth late 90s, early 2000s, you had the peer-to-peer networking revolution, right? This Napster came out, BitTorrent protocol was written, and that was sort of the final piece of the puzzle. [00:13:41] So you've got hash cash's proof of work, and then BitGold's like idea of blockchain, and some ideas from from the way that proof of work was adapted in way as B money, and then you bring in the missing, the final missing piece, which was the peer-to-peer networking. [00:13:59] And in 2008, of course, October 31st, Halloween. Satoshi Nakamoto sends the Bitcoin white paper to the cryptography mailing list and described Halloween, right? That described a way to solve the double spending problem, the Byzantine General's problem as it's known as in computer science. [00:14:23] Yep. With proof of work and a peer-to-peer network. And in a way that is completely decentralized and doesn't rely on a central server or central authority. And that those that kind of peer to peer and jump on me if I'm going out of turn here, but the idea is is that that it was pretty genius on this peer-to-peer network because it was really low tech and it works on Nakamoto, what's called Nakamoto consensus, right? [00:14:49] In terms of how that is all worked out, right? Yep. So you didn't have to have a situation where you had these big corporations, multinationals spending all sorts of money. It was at the entry point for somebody to become a node. Right, right. Yeah, nodes could nodes could were free to join the network at any time and drop off the network. [00:15:09] You mean go nodes could come back on the network, and be able to trust that the longest chain with the most proof of work is is legitimate and has no double spends. And we and just to step in because we're going through a bunch of years here, just to mention this we're going through an article that has a lot of links on this, and so just we're gonna include this as part of the show notes. [00:15:35] Yeah, we'll we'll include our sources here. We all yeah, we always do that. Brady Brady does it. I shouldn't say we because Brady does a weird team, but he he does a phenomenal job with the case. Yeah, we'll definitely include our sources here in the show notes for the video. So you'll be able to see guys because we're we're going through each year, and each each year actually has what we're talking about backed up in in significant detail as we go through this. [00:15:58] Yeah, we're pulling from several different sources and we'll include them all. So then on January 3rd 2009, exactly 10 years ago today, the first Bitcoin, the first block was mined by Satoshi. And then the code was shared a few days later on January 8th with the cryptography mailing list, and people started talking about Bitcoin. [00:16:25] Halfinny began running Bitcoin and tweet the first tweet about Bitcoin ever was from Hal Finney on January 10th, 2009, just simply running Bitcoin was was what it said. So he had downloaded and started running Bitcoin. Hal Finney was the f you know a cryptographer that'd been around for a long time on that mailing list and was very well respected computer scientist. [00:16:46] Satoshi sent 10 bitcoins to Hal Finney as the first Bitcoin transaction between two individuals. And then I thought this was I was going through some of the old emails on the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, which is a great resource, by the way. And if you haven't gone to the Satoshi Nakamoto Nakamoto Institute.org and click on the Satoshi section, which is the URL Satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org, you'll find all the stuff that that was ever published by Satoshi. [00:17:21] So emails, forum posts, all this stuff. And it's just fascinating to read through. And you can also get that if you're in you know you're listening to this podcast, so you're into audio, you can get that in audio format from Audible in a comp compilation called The Book of Satoshi, which is fantastic. [00:17:40] One that I love to kind of just turn on and listen to, you know, a couple times a month, I'll turn on and listen to a bit of that. And it's it's just great to kind of dive in anywhere once you've gone through it all. But I found this email from January 16th, 2009. Fra that Satoshi wrote in response on the on the Bitcoin list. [00:18:01] I think this might been it might I think this was the first thread on the Bitcoin mailing list. So this is not on the cryptographers mailing list anymore. It's on the Bitcoin mailing list that Satoshi started. Bitcoin version 0.1 released, and it was a response to Dustin Trammell. And Satoshi responds, I would be surprised if 10 years from now we're not using electronic currency in some way. [00:18:26] Now that we know out a way a way to do it that won't inevitably get dumbed down when the trusted third party gets cold feet. It could get started in a narrow niche like reward points, donation tokens, currency for for a game or micropayments for adult sites. Initially, it can be used in proof of work applications for services that could almost be free but not quite. It can already be used to pay for pay-to-send email. [00:18:46] The send dialogue is resizable and you can enter as long a message as you like. It's sent directly when it connects. So there were actually messages that were included, a messaging system that was included with the transactions, so you could send messages back and forth within the Bitcoin system itself. Then it finished it concludes with kind of what's become a sort of semi-famous Satoshi quote. [00:19:08] It might make sense just to get some in case it catches on. If enough people think the same way, that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Once it gets bootstrapped, there are so many applications. If you could effortless effortlessly pay a few cents to a website as easily as dropping coins in a vending machine. So there's Satoshi speculating 10 on 10 years from the time of this email, which is right about now. [00:19:33] Because this was this was sent on this January 16th, 2009. Uh-huh. And you know, Satoshi it is not surprised because there's plenty of people using electronic currency in many ways. And you know, thanks Satoshi. Well done. It's it's kind of amazing what was started in the in this in those first few weeks of January 2009. [00:19:56] So in 2009, Bitcoin was just this kind of curiosity. Coders, cryptographers working on it, talking about it on the mailing list. And in 2010, there was kind of a seminal moment in May of 2010. [00:20:14] A Florida-based programmer named Laszlo Hany? I don't know how to pronounce this Polish name. I think it's Polish. Sorry about that. K-N-Y-C-Z. Yep. Sent about 10,000 bitcoins, sent 10,000, exactly 10,000 bitcoins to a London man in exchange in exchange for two pizzas. [00:20:37] So 100 10,000 bitcoins in exchange for two pizzas, which cost about $25. So that values 2010, they must have been pretty good pizzas. That's pretty good. About a quarter of a of a cent, a fraction of a penny. So that was the first time that there was a trade between a US dollar value established for Bitcoin. [00:20:59] And we don't know whatever happened to that, right? Those the Bitcoin. Yeah, it doesn't identify who this who this London man was. Who so apparently Laszlo sends 10,000 Bitcoin to this man in London who calls a f some pizza place in Florida and orders pizza to Laszlo's home. [00:21:19] I think he just wanted to see you know he this guy wanted to see it work. So just a couple of months after that happened, Bitcoin's value finally broke the penny threshold. So one Bitcoin was worth a penny sometime in the summer of 2005. So it at $4,000 per Bitcoin, that's 40 million dollars for that pizza. [00:21:39] Yeah, there you go. Current prices, right? Yeah. Roughly. So [00:21:51] The question is if somebody left that on a machine somewhere, right? Would you would you, you know, and ended up in a landfill, would you mine for it, try to get it back? That that's actually happened. Did they ever get it? There were I've definitely seen pictures of a person in London who was combing through a garbage dump for a computer that had Bitcoin on it. [00:22:15] That was happening in 2017. That happened in 2017 during that big deal. Did the guy find it? I don't think so. Or the gal find it? I don't think so. Huh. So Mount Gox was. I mean, how insane do people think would think if somebody was doing that, right? I mean Oh, yeah. Well, you know, it's a lot of money sitting there. [00:22:33] It's a good war story for in any event. So yeah, there were a lot of coins lost early because the you know, people didn't really understand what what was gonna happen, you know, at this point. That's true. It was very early. Mount Gox was was established in July of 2010. In February of 2010, there was a site called the Bitcoin Market. [00:22:53] That was the first Bitcoin market that popped up. Slush, the first mining pool, also mined Bitcoin successfully for the first time that year. So mining a lot happened in 2010. Yep, a lot happened in 2010. 2011, Bitcoin passes the dollar threshold for the first time. [00:23:12] It was mentioned in, [00:23:15] Well, there was an article about Bitcoin in Time magazine that year. [00:23:19] It was all over Slashdot. You hear a lot of people, early Bitcoiners on podcasts and stuff, talk about how they found out about Bitcoin on Slashdot. It was a nerdy tech site back in the day. [00:23:37] And so in 2011, Bitcoin saw its kind of first big spike. It went over $30, but then crashed back down to 10. That was in 2011. In June Mount June 2011, Mount Gox gets hacked. Serious security breach compromised ten tens of thousands of accounts. [00:23:57] They lost m hundreds of thousands of bitcoins. And that is that whole event is still ongoing today. There's still some kind of there's legal fallout of that is still is still happening it's still ongoing at this point. [00:24:16] 2011 Litecoin was released. The you know the silver to Bitcoin's gold was the way Charlie Lee described it. So it was released in late 2011. And yeah, well, Litecoin just the odd thing for me about like Litecoin is it's it's similar to Bitcoin except it has four times the amount of coins, right? [00:24:42] Right. And it and it also has block times that is four times faster. So two and a half minute block times as opposed to ten minute block times. And then the other thing is Charlie Lee sold all his Litecoin allegedly, right? Yeah in 2017. Not allegedly, like he publicly announced that he sold it. Yeah, so he sold it all, so now he comes back in. [00:25:02] Didn't they recently? This is something that happens since our last podcast. Didn't they end up advertising on an MMA fight or something like that? Like coin? Yeah. Yeah, Litecoin sponsored MMA fight. I don't know. Anyway. The whole idea with Litecoin, it's it's kind of like I think if if you want to back there's no there's no reason, I think that you really have to be be really aware of the colour. [00:25:30] The lightning network about my opinion, the lightning network makes Litecoin useless. It was probably useless before that even. Useless? Yeah, useless. Because yeah, because we don't I mean, the only reason that we had silver, you know, but like throughout human history that humans decided that silver was a good idea to have around instead of just using gold is because gold was too valuable for smaller payments. [00:26:00] So if you were gonna try to buy some make a small transaction with gold, you'd have it was hard to divide you know, divide it down to this tiny to the tiny amount that you needed. Well then you had the multiple. Silver was more abundant, so it was and you had the multiply there was like a ratio right that's been broken a long time ago now, but yeah, and then it was it silver was pretty much demonetized once you know we had paper gold, and we saw that happen. [00:26:26] So with Bitcoin that you don't have the you know the divisibility problems that that gold has, and you don't have it's digitally transferable, so you don't have the you know issues of transfer as well from being heavy and whatever. So there's no reason for for a silver to Bitcoin's gold. [00:26:46] But you know it was a good meme, and a decent it's a decent idea. It sounds good until you find out what actually is going on. Yeah. So 2012 was another year of increase in price across the hundred dollar threshold for the first time in April 2012. [00:27:06] In 2013, the price was pretty choppy, but it eventually got up across the $1,000 threshold for the first time. So that was 2013, just marching right along. And then it cracked crashed in 2014 through 20 2014 2016, the Mt. [00:27:29] Gox, the big Mt. Gox hack hack happened. So Mountgox was hacked again and it actually like bankrupted Mount Gox. They found out that they had lost a lot of Bitcoin that they were unaware of. The a hack was basically the hacker was stealing Bitcoin from Mount Gox over a long period of time and before they became aware of it, and there was just no recovering from that. [00:27:53] And that is that event is what the legal fallout is still happening from, actually, not the 2011 event. Well, but but the right, right, exactly. Exactly. But the idea the situation that's unusual with Mt. Gox is that and it could kind of ties to not your the whole idea of not your keys, not your Bitcoin, is that people that had Bitcoin on the exchange at this point, as we're getting to the very end of this administration and winding this whole situation down in Bitcoin, the idea is, and I think there were some discussions. [00:28:29] I don't know exactly where we are right now on it, but the idea was okay, we're gonna get you your value back for your Bitcoin, but we're gonna actually you had six Bitcoin or whatever, let's say it's a hundred. You had a hundred bitcoin. We're not gonna give you the a hundred bitcoin back. We're actually gonna take whatever the value is today. [00:28:48] And so what ends up I think it was the cash value from when the when Mt. Gox went bankrupt. Well, I don't know. Okay, so which is not which is why a lot of those people are upset because you got a situation where where Mt. Gox is in quote completely completely with the assets are much much greater than the liabilities because you have a situation with the value the underlying value changed so much, yeah dramatically that that you know so you've got a you have a situation where you'd want to you'd want to say as a as an investor in the deal, just give me my Bitcoin [00:29:26] Back. Right. Totally, absolutely. And then but that but they're they're basically saying that in some cases based on where somebody got in, let's say somebody got in at 150 bucks, and I don't know what the number was. Let's but let's just choose an argument, you know. I mean, just lay it out. 150, and then when it happened, how much was it? [00:29:46] What was it three something? Well, 300 something? It it is it I think it happened right after it peaked at about a thousand dollars. So it can't be a good one. And it happened, but I'm what I'm saying is I'm I think the Mount. Ox number was maybe it was in the two or three hundreds, but the but the point is is that if you invested and had your had your coins, you had Bitcoin, I'll use a hundred. [00:30:08] You had a hundred bitcoin. No, I get right? Yeah. It does it's it sucks. A lot of people are upset about that. So then then of course that led in then of course it led into there's the 2017 full cycle. By June, Bitcoin was worth over three thousand dollars. [00:30:27] By December, I think we peaked at 197 something, 196 something, in December. And of course we've December just a year ago. Yeah. The in in August of 2017, of course, that we should know the Bitcoin Cash fork happened. [00:30:48] And that was you know kind of a seminal moment too. That was the whole scaling debate came to a head, and the on-chain scaling proponents decided to go hard fork away and create Bitcoin Cash. The second layer lightning network solution scaling solution proponents stayed on the Bitcoin chain and so 2018 we've been in a bear market of price, but but we've seen an absolutely phenomenal growth of the lightning network. [00:31:22] So if you look at the numbers for lightning network in 2018, the lightning the network capacity went from zero to five hundred and fifteen Bitcoin. Public nodes went from zero to four thousand eight hundred. What does that really mean? What do you mean? Which part? What what is four thousand mean? [00:31:41] Four thousand eight hundred nodes. Oh, is that nodes? Nodes, yeah. Okay. And channels, went from zero to sixteen thousand. So there's sixteen tho t at the end of twenty eight. That's better than sixteen thousand channels. That's better. I misunderstood that. So that that's better than I thought. Sixteen thousand channels and forty eight hundred nodes with a five hundred and fifteen Bitcoin capacity. [00:32:02] That all happened in two years. That's my point though. No, that that's my point. What is five hundred and fifteen Bitcoin? That's the capacity of the Bitcoin in the sixteen hundred channels, sixteen hundred public channels. So if I so that means on an ongoing basis, if stuff's going back and forth, or or maybe not, i is that if in total in in a in a microsecond it it can only go to five hundred and that number. [00:32:25] No, it just means that's the that that's the total amount of Bitcoin that are in Lightning Network channels. The public night public lightning network channels. So for instance, on my Lightning Network node, I have five channels set up. You do? Yep. So I've got five channels set up and I've got a couple channels that come back into that connect to my node that are incoming to my node. [00:32:46] And is it operating right now? Yeah. Okay. So what do you what do you do with it? Do you check every week? [00:32:53] I'm just playing with it, you know. I'm opening some channels to people I know, Bitcoiners I know on Twitter, and just kind of playing with it, [00:33:00] Sending stuff back and forth. I drew on Satoshi's dot place and I played lightning spin and so okay, so let's say let's say that let's let's say that like that that like that briefcase leather briefcase I was talking about. So let's say I put it on to sell that. How how do how would that work? [00:33:18] Well, I mean, there's there hasn't that I know of really a like a marketplace that supports Lightning Network yet, you know? Like a full fully built out web marketplace that will happen but if you knew somebody who was on the I mean it's early right now but if you knew somebody who had a node and was on the Lightning Network that wanted to buy it from you I could you just just I'm just talking as a practical matter could could you just sit there because we're pretty decent sized on on Twitter relatively speaking so if you sit there and said hey look at this picture look at this description this is an item that I've got for sale yeah you [00:33:57] Can buy it from me on the Lightning Network and it's X amount or or you know give me an offer. Yeah and then I could just give them my Lightning Network node ID. Yeah and they would be able to send me money. Okay, so they send you the money but when do you w how would that work or what my wallet address that's attached to my that's attached to I mean I guess the idea would be this is kind of and I know we're off but I think this is important to talk about I would generate so I would generate a payment request is what I would do using either my node or a wallet that's attached to my node. [00:34:33] And I'd send a QR code or just a series of but how so I've received let's say I've got the I've got this leather briefcase. Yeah and so how do how do I know if I send you the money that I'm gonna get the briefcase? I mean same as you would do it on any on like internet based marketplace right like eBay or something. [00:34:56] Poshwash or whatever you would you have to use reputation like if I'm gonna buy something from somebody on eBay, I'm gonna buy it from them because they have a high reputation of go of going through with their own. So in terms okay, so I just need to think so, in terms of somebody doing it at a coffee shop, the idea would be somebody would sign up at the coffee shop to buy coffee through the night lightning network. [00:35:17] Yeah. But that that would really be something where they immediately you would be there and they would immediately know Yeah, lightning network has nothing to do with like how transactions are trusted between people on the internet necessarily. It has to that's what I wanted to clarify for the listeners. [00:35:36] So the idea the idea though, so the idea Yeah, I mean like eBay could just add Lightning Network as a payment method, right? But then I would I would just you use the same solutions to trusting a stranger, buying something from a stranger on the internet as as any of these other people. So we can get back to the history, but I thought we use that just as talking about 2018 on chain, SegWit adoption, segregated witness, which is the way we chose to scale Bitcoin, right? [00:36:02] So we soft forked in segregated witness. And a soft fork means that the upgrade is optional, okay? By and you can choose to run that upgrade by running software that has incorporated that upgrade, or you can continue to run your old software and it will it will continue to operate on the Bitcoin network, it's backwards compatible. [00:36:21] So with SegWit, we enabled or made it much easier to run the Lightning Network as a second layer solution on top of Bitcoin. And really good. And we also increased the block weight limit. So we went from a one megabyte block weight limit to an average to a Is it four? [00:36:40] Yeah, it goes, you know, in ideals ideal situations could go up to four. That's if we had a hundred percent adoption and there were certain other certain ideal ideals about a block that that you could reach, but on pr in practical per practical you know, real life main net situation, we're gonna kind of average you know two megabytes or so as a block weight limit. [00:37:05] But four is the is the absolute ceiling. So Sega adoption has gone from eleven percent at the beginning of twenty eighteen to fifty one percent at the end of twenty eighteen. Hash rate went from fifteen x a hash to forty-four xa hash, and there were over eighty million transactions on the network in 2018. [00:37:26] So while price was definitely stuck in a bear market, there was lots of development happening on Bitcoin and kind of setting the stage for another a year of accumulation at these levels or maybe a little bit lower before before bull market takes back off again. [00:37:46] So yeah, I think in 2019 we'll see a lot more development on Lightning Network. It's gonna go from kind of the tinkers like me, with a with a node sitting in my in my office. Now when when you do when you so that's that's the Casa node, right? [00:38:05] That yeah. Now when you're doing that, do you update your the Bitcoin all the way? Do you run that through every every week or so, or you know, in terms of checking all the way to the Genesis block and back? What do they call it? No, so it just what do they call that? [00:38:24] Well, when you when you first start up your node, right? You sink to the chain, right? So you sink through the chain, you see don't you don't need to do that again once you're once your physical machine has done it once. And so you just continue to validate it. So what happens is you do the so they come in and then it just goes ahead you're already you already got the full full effect of it so then you can just [00:38:49] Okay. Yep. That's what I thought. [00:38:54] If for some reason you decided that you didn't want to trust that that sinking process that you went through already you could run you could do it again. Well and I just wanted to point so so what you've got with this it's called what's the name of that that you bought Casa Hoddle. Yeah the Casa Hoddle so not only can you do the lightning with that right which is a but but it's a Bitcoin full node and a lightning network node. [00:39:15] Does that chew up a lot of electricity? You need to no because it runs on a Raspberry Pi. So that's right it's a very low electricity it does it does use some bandwidth to run a Bitcoin full node especially if you allow incoming connections but it's it's doable with a you know broadband connection. [00:39:35] So thank you for that. Yeah so I think we'll see a lot more lightning network development over this year. We'll see it I think incorporated into you know much more widely used wallets I think some much more widely used online marketplaces like we were talking about will offer it as a as an option and we'll see it start growing more and more I think we'll see Segwood adoption continue to increase and a lot of this building during this sort of down bare quiet time will continue to happen and I think it's going to be another really [00:40:13] Exciting year to be a Bitcoin nerd. As far as in 10 years where Bitcoin will be in 10 years. So 2029 January of twenty twenty nine you know it's that's such a long time from now it's and it's tw you know another whole another hundred percent of Bitcoin's lifespan and it's gonna double in age in the next ten years I so much has happened and it's come so far in just this first ten years and it's it's could be pretty amazing what happens in the next 10 years so that ten years from now [00:40:51] I think we could be well down well established Bitcoin could be well established as a store of value accepted very widely as as money around the world I think that we could even see perhaps it become the unit of account the main the main form of currency for large online marketplaces that mainly transact in in Bitcoin and not in fiat currencies well doesn't it [00:41:29] I mean from a cybersecurity standpoint isn't it better just from that standpoint too in terms of information and passing stuff through irrespective of the unit of account there are I mean I yeah I Bitcoin can't I mean if you're you're holding your keys so it can't be taken from you right yeah so I mean there's that incentive and there's just I think there will be market demand I mean consumer demand for Bitcoin I and so anyway I think I think it'll be accepted in most places online but I think there will actually be marketplaces that accept Bitcoin. [00:42:05] And price and price in Bitcoin really talking about here right and I don't know but what we'd really be talking about is is is there gonna be a method to be able to over overtake this at overtake the 51% and take it over? Like a quantum computer. [00:42:23] Yeah, the quantum computing kind of threat has is been talked about for open. But it goes back yeah, but there's a thing. There are but but the idea ways to get around I mean there are ways to i if SHA two fifty six is hacked by quantum computer then there are you know you could hard fork and move to a quantum resistant hashing algorithm which is already just to bring this up in terms of our discussion on this in terms you know because one of the ones that comes out right away is someone says don't even look at it quantum computer you're dead right now. [00:42:59] Yeah somebody people will say that but there's actually when you dig into it it's it's really not that it's not that simple. No it's not at all. And in fact there's most of the arguments are in favor of the fact that Bitcoin wouldn't get overtaken. So there are I mean people i it is being dis it is being and has been discussed and there are options. [00:43:23] It wouldn't be great but there are options. So that that might be a challenge I need to I need to think about it some more because I think there's I think when you ask me I just decided to you know I don't know. Yeah I think there might be we might see a major state attack on Bitcoin in ways you know to a degree that we have not yet. [00:43:47] Because I think it could be perceived as a serious threat. Well, but it's already is it in what in some cases with some some people it it is perceived that way, right? Right currently. I don't know. I mean, I don't think we've witnessed a state attack yet. [00:44:05] So I don't mean a state attack, but there's certain people. What I mean is there's certain people that just think Bitcoin should go away. It shouldn't exist. Oh I know, yeah, yeah. It's rat poison squared. Yeah. Or you know what it's that one and then and then the Bank of International Settlements Game. Yeah, that guy, but no, the one that Ravina, but I say it in the avoid it like the Yeah, yeah, yeah. [00:44:34] That one. Yeah. Char Charlie Munger. Yeah. Avoid it like the plague? Yeah. That episode. What was that? Episode four. No, I think it I think it was rat poison. Maybe it was six. No, there was rat poison. No, it was there was it's poison. That was it's poison. And then the other one was, and I'm gonna do it already. [00:44:53] Avoid it like the plague. Yeah. But see that's already, you know, that's already rolled out from there, and well let's let's let's make a commitment that wherever we are, ten years from today, we at least get on the phone and shout about Bitcoin and this past and this in the ten years that has passed since today. [00:45:22] And maybe maybe not gonna be recording podcasting. You're not gonna be on your way to Mars. I won't be, no. Okay. Nah. Not yet. Not by then. Maybe later. I'll still have kids at home. Yeah, but Mars is Mars isn't a good pick anyway, or a place to go. Oh, anyway, for other reasons. [00:45:41] That's a completely different podcast. So all right. Well, I think we can wrap it up there. I think that was a good kind of summary of the history and walk back through down memory lane. Yeah, I think it was pretty good. I know I interjected there, but I think part of it is just to that was good. It was a good combo. Yeah, so we'll we'll see. But anyway, I'm I'm in the process of looking at I think they it's a pre-order again on that Casa Hado. [00:46:07] I haven't told you this, but I'm I'm thinking about it. That's part of the reason why I was asking the questions about it because it seems to me it's pretty interesting to have one of those. It's a nice UI. I like it using it because it's I am we need to see the lightning network develop a UI layer that's you know usable by the average person by normies. [00:46:29] Well, I guess the one way it would work is it would be the it would be a situation where if you had a relationship with somebody on a supply basis where you were purchasing product and it was a normal commercial relationship where you already knew the person and it was trusted, you could do the lightning, you could open up a channel and do conduct your business that way. Yep. And that would be completely normalized to somebody purchasing a regular service and paying by check or giving somebody cash or or giving a credit card. [00:46:55] You could just go ahead and make the steps that way rather than completely and totally trustless, right? Absolutely. Yep. It's pretty exciting. So we'll have to get we'll get Tommy a lightning network node so he can start playing with it and we'll report back. [00:47:15] I think it would be fun. Alright, man. It was fun to get together again. It's good to see you. Good to talk about. Good to talk Bitcoin as always. Thanks for joining us. You can follow us on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin. You can follow Tommy at Canon's Call on Twitter. I'm at B Swen on Twitter. And I think that's it for today. Yeah, when one thing real quick for 2019, it looks like we may start doing some have have guests. [00:47:40] Yeah, we're doing we've been covered. We've been talking for 21 episodes now about what we think about Bitcoin. I think it'd be fun to branch out and start talking to some other people as well. So we're gonna look into doing that and figure it out and figure out what's possible. So look for that. Maybe come in to the to the feed sometime in 2019. [00:47:59] So that should be cool. So anyway, thanks everybody. All right, enjoy the rest of your day. Bye-bye.