Basement Bulletin w/ Guy Swann: Looking Back on 2019 Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-01-03 [00:00:19] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. And happy Genesis Day to you all. Today we celebrate the day 11 years ago that Satoshi took money back from the central bankers and returned it to the people. [00:00:42] And I strongly believe at some point in the future, January 3rd, 2009, we'll be known worldwide as a seminal date in human history. It's absolutely incredible what Bitcoin has achieved in just 11 years. And development of the protocol and its ecosystem is only accelerating. This past year has been amazing in retrospect, and today I look back on 2019 with my buddies Tom Pearson and Guy Swann. [00:01:06] Before we jump into it, a word about GiveBitcoin, whose support helps bring this episode to your ears. The 2019 holiday season was the first for GiveBitcoin, which launched back in November. A lot was learned from early adopters about the service, thanks to those of you who used GiveBitcoin these past few weeks. GiveBitcoin is excited to iterate and improve during 2020 and also excited to launch SaveBitcoin, a companion app to GiveBitcoin that is very simply focused on saving Bitcoin with regular recurring buys. SaveBitcoin will be your Bitcoin savings account and help you very easily set it and forget it. 2020 is going to be an exciting year for Give and Save Bitcoin. I'll definitely be keeping you updated here on what's going on. Check out GiveBitcoin at givebitcoin.io [00:01:54] And you can stay up to date with what's happening with Save Bitcoin on Twitter at Save underscore Bitcoin. Alright, a couple more quick shout outs. Let's talk Bitcoin Network first. If you're listening to this podcast for the first time on LTBN, welcome. Here on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast, you can expect fun and engaging discussions that draw out unique insights and stories from the best and brightest Bitcoiners in the world. [00:02:16] I hope to be part of your Bitcoin journey going forward. And thank you to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including Citizen Bitcoin. Definitely follow them on Bitcoin Twitter at the LTB Network. And subscribe to the LTBN feed for more great Bitcoin content all in one place. It's super convenient place to get that Bitcoin education and knowledge. [00:02:37] And a fun way to support the podcast is to visit Layer1BTC.com. You can click on partners and then CitizenBitcoin and buy yourself some Citizen Bitcoin merch. We got two new designs by Nick Ward, the unfuck the money design and the SAT SAT strategically applied toxicity design. You know, most of us Bitcoiners don't condone or practice indiscriminate toxicity, but we strategically apply it to identify shame and drive out scammers and bad actors from this space because there's just too much at stake here. [00:03:08] So check them out. Layer1BTC.com. It's a great Bitcoin only business. Nick Ward's a great Bitcoiner. Alright, let's go. For this one, Tom Pearson and Guy Swann joined me to talk about 2019 in Bitcoin. [00:03:29] For those of you who are relatively new here, this podcast started two years ago now, as me and Tommy sitting down recording the chats that we were already having about Bitcoin. Publishing those chats was a great forcing function for us to learn more about what the hell was happening here. And about a year ago, I started doing the interview episodes. But Tommy and I continued co-hosting review episodes every once in a while with another Bitcoin podcaster. [00:03:53] We called these episodes basement bulletins because we record them from the basement of an old church that's now Tommy's home. Tommy's a bankruptcy and turnaround specialist. He's got a ton of experience. He's worked with businesses all over the US. And it was awesome for us to have our buddy Guy Swann of the Great Crypto Economy Podcast join us for this look back on 2019 in Bitcoin. [00:04:17] All right, let's dive in. It's been a while, Tommy. Yeah, it sure has. We're here back in the basement of the church, the old church in Lawrence, Kansas, aka Tommy's home for a basement bulletin to recap the year 2019 in Bitcoin. [00:04:40] We're joined by our friend Guy Swann. What's going on, man? What is up, fellas? How y'all doing? Doing great, doing good. It's all you guy, man. It's all you. All right, it's been quite a year, guys. We're gonna chit chat, kind of do a laid back, just a few Bitcoiners talking about the year, reminiscing. You know, as we are prepping for this episode, we were all three of us at various times shocked by the fact that things happened in this calendar year. [00:05:08] Yeah. Lots of things. Be well, I mean that because they were, you know, just seem like so long ago, and we talk a lot about how Bitcoin time is just crazy down here in this in this rabbit hole. Time is something different than it is up there on the surface. Yeah, there's something there's something with that like time warp, like some something about being in orbit or I don't know, being deep down the rabbit hole. [00:05:32] I don't know what it is, but time is universal force hugely compressed. Yeah, there's that time Bitcoin time dilation. So all right. Well, we started the year with January 3rd, the 10th birthday of Bitcoin. The birth of the Genesis block. Took six days to mine, right? [00:05:51] And the first transaction happened to Halfinny on the 9th. Is that right, guy? I believe January 9th. That is right. Yes. I would have to check my my calendar here. Yeah, so you know, that's that's a one of those big round numbers. It's a 10 year anniversary, right? We're going on 11. Yep, going on 11 coming up. [00:06:09] Right around the corner. By the time this was 2020. By the time we publish this, it'll be just a few days away to 11th birthday. But that 10 is that is a big round number. And you know, humans love those big round numbers. We talk about that, that the TA guys talk about the big round numbers a lot. I think it I think it is important. You know, a decade of operation with 99.99 continued percent uptime. [00:06:35] You know, growing from no no value, no price, dollar dollar price for 18 months, 18 plus months, to over 20,000 at toward the end of 2017. Exponential increases in hash rates, incredible improvements in infrastructure, on ramps, off ramps, all kinds of financial products. [00:07:01] Yeah, I mean, it's it's it was an incredible 10 year first 10 years for Bitcoin, and here we are in the first year of the of the next 10 years, the second decade. And when we were prepping for this episode, we realized that you know at least half of the things that we came up with were lightning related. Yeah. So I find it appropriate that we're starting off this second decade of Bitcoin's life with an incredible year for lightning. [00:07:25] Yeah, and it's kind of it's kind of neat that like it was like right at Bitcoin's 10th birthday was really when layer two is getting off the ground. One thing, January 11th. It's not 9th. It wasn't the ninth. This January 11th is the Genesis transaction. [00:07:43] Yeah, and I just while we were talking about all the all the things that we were you know set out to mention, or just this shit that happened this year, it's hard to believe that it all happened this year. Like really, like the beginning building blocks for like a thousand things are here, and it's basically all happened in the last last like eight or nine months. [00:08:13] I don't know. I don't know. People like I guess it's just a lack of exposure or paying attention, but when every every once in a while when somebody, particularly from like the altcoin camp, but even just just general will be like Bitcoin is stagnant and nobody's using or doing anything on lightning. [00:08:32] I just I just I'm dumbfounded. I don't even know how to respond. It's like where where have you been? Like this space so fast, so fast, it's crazy. Yeah, there's just that meme out there in you know altcoin echo chambers that you know the reason this altcoin's better is because Bitcoin is stagnant and is it's not innovating anymore, and here we are innovating and improving, and that that's why we're better. [00:08:59] And so that meme is just you know out there with pretty much every altcoin camp. And if they're stuck in that echo echo chamber and is sort of given up on Bitcoin, you know, you can just tell someone comes in a bit and drops to a thread and is like, Yeah, Bitcoin isn't innovating, they don't have anything new. You're just like, Okay, dude, you know, okay, altcoiner. Well, it's it's better just to not even respond to it. [00:09:20] You know, I mean, just keep above the fray. Why even seem like we're competing with Bitcoin competes with the them. So yeah, and meanwhile, I think it was I think it was Ethereum, actually. Just integrated like Lipsec P256K one, the one that Bitcoin put in, but so that they have their validation was like four times faster or something crazy like that. [00:09:45] It's like you're like, oh, Bitcoin's stagnant and you're porting code over there, like what are you doing? You can't you can't do both of those things at once. Well, I mean, this is a Bitcoin, you know, full year review podcast, right? We're talking about you look at Ethereum. [00:10:05] I mean, right now, I mean, just look what's going on with Ethereum in the last couple weeks and what's upcoming with them having to fork to even be able to attempt to scale. I mean, you talk about a an altcoin that's in trouble. Yeah, the Ethereum the fork to like the whole the entire new thing, and then now the additional fork that's gonna happen in like a week to because they forgot to deal with the what is it, the ice age thing, where blocks will continually get slower in like as an effort to push everybody on to proof of stake, which continues to not happen because [00:10:43] They're just pushing it down the road. Well they forgot to kick the can down the road so now they're having a lot of just think about that hey guy guy just think about that in itself okay just the fact that there's an iceberg concept in Ethereum among other things like that they're they're just trying to I mean come on I don't I don't even that's the thing about that by the way by the way that's my fault. [00:11:06] Let's get off Ethereum my fault for digressing but we had we had the year in review would not we had to jump into Ethereum a little bit. Oh well we didn't have to. But it was it was bound to happen. It was bound to happen. It is you know it is part of the story part of the narrative and whatever. You know this was a year of Bitcoin dominance you know just increasing skyrocketing and kind of leaving leaving the altcoins the shit coins behind. [00:11:31] And you know just kind of an indicator of that just happened today CoinFloor a tr exchange in the UK is delisting ETH and Bitcoin Cash to focus on Bitcoin. I expect to see that happen more and more as well. Yeah it's really well yeah let's get back sorry one thing just on that is that I think Bitcoin Cash doesn't have long left there are a lot of people who are turning on Roger right now because he's just come out just gleefully in support of hex all of a sudden just adding it to the Bitcoin.com thing and so many of the B cachers [00:12:10] Actually realized that that's a flat out like obvious scam and like so now they're kind of turning. It looks like or at least our BTC was kind of turning on Roger there. And it's looking, I don't know, it's looking rough for a number of altcoins right now. [00:12:28] Yeah, I mean, vindication. You know, we've been saying this as Bitcoin. I'm not saying that for a long time. That last one, I'm not saying that thing's name. We shouldn't talk about it. That's that's as far as we need to go on that one. Yeah, the last episode, I said that guy's name, and I actually bleeped it out twice because I don't want to, you know, say his name. [00:12:48] So if we say it, I'm gonna have to get that bleep sound effect. I have to commend you for that, Brady. That's fantastic. All right. Somehow we got an Bitcoin year and review episode. We've gotten off on ETH, Hex, Bitcoin Cash. Let's get back on track. All right. We're doing well. This is good. We're doing well though. [00:13:06] Hey, we can't. And I take full responsibility for for dumping on ETH. Hey, I get it, man. I get it. You know, we're Bitcoiners. We have, you know, we've been through a lot. We deal with a lot of FUD from these from these people, from these coins, these shit coiners, and these shit coins. And you know, it's nice to celebrate a little bit when you get some vindication. I think it's important. [00:13:24] I think it's important to celebrate a lot. All right, so yeah, let's get back on lightning. I mean, it's been an absolutely incredible year for Lightning. Lightning has been crushing it. And let's just let's let's dive in. So at the beginning of the year, Hodlanot started the Lightning Torch, the LN Trust chain. [00:13:43] That started sometime in January and really took off in February. Jack Dorsey was passed the torch from Matt O'Dell in early February. And then that day was I think one of the highlights of the year for me, that night. Watching Jack Dorsey hold court on his platform on Twitter and reveal to everyone his Bitcoin maximalism, right? [00:14:09] The fact that he's a Bitcoin maximalist, and left no doubt responded to many shitcoiners saying, Jack, what do you think about this coin? He's like, nope, Bitcoin only. Nope. Don't like that. Nope. I'm only a Bitcoiner. It was amazing. Yeah, dude. I remember that. That was spectacular. That was so great. Well, you got, but you got the torch too. [00:14:27] Oh, me? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We both of us ended up with the torch. I tried to wait. Didn't Brady, didn't you send me a message trying to give it to me, but I was away from the computer? Yeah, I think. Yeah, well, we had been we basically had a deal. Like, if you got it, you're gonna pass it to me. If I got it, I was gonna pass it to you. And yeah, and you know, it just kind of like you know, you're not on computer 24-7. [00:14:48] And I get and I got it. You guys almost are though, kind of randomly. I got it, and yeah, I tried to message you. I waited for like 20 minutes or so, and then Hass McCook was up in my DMs trying to, he's like, dude, you gotta pass it, you gotta pass it. Yeah, so I ended up passing it to Has. That was great, I got it. [00:15:07] Which is a couple days later, something something like that. But yeah, that was awesome. And that was that was actually when it was awesome. I believe I set up no, I did already have a note at that point. I did, that's right. That's right. I'd had one up for a little bit there. [00:15:26] But I did set up a couple of channels in preparation. I was like, I am gonna get that lightning torch. And that was awesome. I cannot believe that all that was this year. I could have swore that was all 2018. The fact that Jack and the whole torch thing, that was crazy exciting. [00:15:45] That was a couple of weeks there. It was just a proof of concept. Like, like, look what this thing can do. And it continued to just work. It was very it was fantastic. It was fantastic. Yeah, that was that was one of my favorite nights of the year for sure. Because remember, at the time, there was a lot of skepticism surrounding Lightning Network, as with any new type of technology or whatever you call it, new new application. [00:16:08] So that was a big deal, you know, and it went all over the world and all sorts of people. It was fantastic. Well, yeah, and that was just the depths of the bear market, too. I mean, you know, we just to have that sort of injection of you know longer term thinking, and you know, this is gonna be here to stay the CEO of you know, one of the largest payment companies in the world, and square, yeah, one of the most important social media companies in the world is a Bitcoin maximalist, was just so invigorating, you know. [00:16:37] All the things actually, Jack has been the amount of like stuff that he's dedicated to like on this front is just really exciting with Square Crypto and then starting the fund for like open source developers and hiring yeah with that group of people that you know, personal, I mean assets people behind it just recently, right within the last couple weeks. [00:17:03] He stayed, he stayed on it. It's not like he was excited about it for like a week. Like he's building, like really building some infrastructure and partnerships, and like he's clearly in this for the long haul. And I'm just really excited to see what will come of all of the all of the groundwork he's laid this year. [00:17:26] Well, and also just to add to that, it is that he's moving to Africa in 2020 because he feels that he feels that that's like fertile ground for a Bitcoin. That's interesting. He's gonna live there three to six, he's gonna live there three to six months, he said. He he finished up that tour around Africa that he did for a few weeks, and he yeah, tweeted out that he's gonna be living there for three to six months next year. [00:17:51] He's not sure where, but that Africa is you know going to be a key part of Bitcoin's future. And that's one of the reasons he's gonna go and live there for a while. Wow. Which I think is amazing. Yeah. And he also has the tweet, the tweet thread that he just dropped a couple I don't know, a couple days ago, week ago, maybe something like that. [00:18:13] About blue sky. About trying to like hiring developers and building an open source protocol, like for decentralized social media. Like that's really exciting. And he linked to a paper which I haven't read yet. I haven't read in full. [00:18:32] In fact I might I might try to contact me if if it's as good as it seems like it is at my skim right now. I might do it in audio. But it's a really really long piece, but it's about the move to platforms from the early days of the internet and like open source protocols, and like what basically how they bridge the gap and then where they where they work really well and then where they fail, and then how we can actually we actually have gotten to the point where the hardware and the technology is actually [00:19:11] Further enough i it's far enough along that we can actually go back and build protocols again. That we can now replace these platforms, and that there are actually a lot of benefits if we can actually pull it off with protocols that the platforms cannot give us. And it's just really it's really exciting. [00:19:31] It seems like a really really really good paper, and particularly the ethos and kind of the mental framework that it's coming from, and to think that that's what you know, Jack tweeted that out, and that's kind of his perspective on this thing is just incredibly exciting for what we could possibly see in the next five years with this and with a tool like Bitcoin, like Lightning, and somebody who is working directly in all of it at once. [00:20:02] The potential in the next couple of years for something like this is just unbelievable. Of kind of giving back privacy and the ownership of your own presence online, is I God, I'm I'm so excited to see like everything to see these building blocks turn into buildings to start turn into structures that we can all utilize is it's insane. [00:20:29] This space blows my mind. Yeah, it's amazing. Jack is an absolute, absolutely crucial leader. Like I think he's one of those people that can make a huge difference as an individual for Bitcoin for open systems, and his commitment to Bitcoin only and to you know, with through Square Crypto, you know, supporting Bitcoin developers. [00:20:52] Like I think what Tommy was getting at was the grants that Square Crypto is is is putting out there. So there was just last week a an anonymous Bitcoin developer, somewhere in the UTC plus eight time zone, and that's all they know about this person, is is their NIM and their you know the time zone in which they reside. [00:21:12] But I'm sure that it was Bitcoin that you know made that possible so they can send can fund this person's work using Bitcoin. And then of course Square Crypto hired its inaugural developer team this year five developers including Matt Carrallo a Bitcoin well known Bitcoin core developer Steve Lee Jeffrey says is says I just looked this up it's oh no sorry ch Jeffrey's yeah Ches is from see where's he from from [00:21:50] Many similar consonants yeah ches's I love it chez's chez's all right yeah so he's he's from Google we had Eric Sossman from actually Facebook who was working on Libra and c and the calibra wallet and then Valentine Wallace from Lightning Labs. [00:22:08] So an all-star cast as the inaugural developer team for Square Crypto. Definitely a top story of this year Jack Dorsey, Bitcoin Maximalist, Square Crypto, and this blue sky project. Yeah yeah that's that's really exciting stuff and I want to see with the clear you know the partnership with Stark and then hiring you know lightning devs and stuff I really want to see and maybe the infrastructure isn't there yet and that's one of those things that and we'll get into this obviously because we're gonna be talking about lightning a lot in this episode it looks like that you [00:22:47] Know what you're looking at when you're when you're looking at the lightning network these days is no longer really users you're looking at the infrastructure and most of the users are actually invisible on lightning now because a lot of channels that are opened with the average user and with mobile wallets where lightning has gone mostly mobile I was actually just listening to what is it the lightning lightning junkies and Will O'Byrne was talking about how lightning has basically gone to mobile it's gotten away from desktop which he's a little bit like half sad about [00:23:26] Just because the web is such a great such a great the desktop experience is actually where it really shines but mobile has really been a huge thing for lightning there's a lot of great mobile wallets now and I mean I use I use them daily basically unless obviously I don't want to spend anything I don't just want to stack my SATs but like Breeze and stuff those are all like wonderful tools and yeah those all came out in the shit I know they're all brand new basically I mean Breeze I think is still no breeze [00:24:04] Might actually be out I realize that most of the apps I'm using are test flight and I forget about that. Like they're not even like out they're just beta. But that the users are behind private channels. So you don't see and which makes perfect sense because you don't want to accidentally try to route something through a mobile wallet just because it's got two channels because that person's not going to be online all the time. [00:24:32] They're gonna be they're gonna be constantly online, offline, they're unreliable. They're not part of the infrastructure, they're not part of the routing network. They're just connecting into the network. It's as if an ISP was trying to use a normal desktop router home router to connect to one of their customers. [00:24:51] Like like like connect through, as as if you know you would use somebody else's house as a part of their mesh network or something like that. Like you would never want to do that. That'd be totally a terrible user experience. I want to see, I'm I'm really excited to see if the infrastructure, if the core of the Lightning Network starts to house enough liquidity to fund something big, particularly like social media tipping that gets integrated on Twitter or something like that. [00:25:22] Some some something that would have a millions of users in very short order. But it's really exciting to see those people all working together, and they're clearly building something. I don't know what it is, but they're clearly building something, and I'm I'm very interested to see what it is. [00:25:43] Yeah, I mean, I wouldn't be surprised to see Twitter integrate lightning in some some way, shape, or form. And you would most likely think it would be some kind of tipping application. There's gotta be exactly something like that. Yeah. That's at least the first obvious use case. And what's funny is tipping has actually been the dominant use case for lightning in my experience for like what I see for like people and stuff in Telegram. [00:26:07] More than a city in China. All over. Tipping has really been one of those things that like not a whole lot has stuck as far as applications in Lightning. It's mostly been experimentation and play. And that's why I think tipping is the one that's really obvious and is most widespread and continues to just pop up everywhere. [00:26:31] Which is why it's sad to see bottle pay go. Yeah, it was sad to see bottle pay go. And, you know, so bottle pay was definitely a big part of lightning this year. Also, of course, tipping.me and another big part of lightning this year. And that that was, you know, really blew up at the early part of the year. Yeah, so well let's let's let's talk about a little bit more about lightning, some of the technologies that have really helped Lightning grow up over the past year. [00:26:58] I think a big one is neutrino. Oh, yeah. The neutrino filters that have improved well really sped up the w like lightning onboarding and also improved the efficiency of like mobile wallets to get data from the chain. Yeah. And neutrino was a I in fact there was actually an improvement to something. [00:27:23] I just I realize I didn't read any further about it. I probably saved it in one of my lengthy, ridiculously unorganized lists of things to get to at some point. But there's something about neutrino figuring out a way to sync much, much faster. [00:27:41] Like it was it is like it was some sort of like ordering or or something. It was it's one of those things that like from what it sounded like to me was one of those like m minor modifications that just has like a huge effect on finding the relevant data first as opposed to downloading a bunch of nonsense before you find it. [00:28:00] And neutrino is kind of that in and of itself, you know, like finding the headers and knowing which way which blocks your stuff is in. But breeze, even if I haven't opened up in like two weeks, I open up this sucker and I get that, you know, syncing, and in like three seconds that little thing's just like zip zip zip, and I'm ready to go. [00:28:20] And it's just crazy on like because of neutrino, I've actually got a wallet that I am not trusting anyone else to give me my source of truth. Like or at least I'm getting I am trusting the network, you know. [00:28:38] Like but not a single source, exactly. It's it's not it's obviously not running a full node, but I'm also not just asking one specific business or one specific node that I'm relying on to tell me my transactions. They don't know my transactions, they don't know what block my channel is in, etc. [00:28:57] Etc. Like that's me. You know, like that's I'm the one that's figuring out the relevant information for my node or my presence, and that's that's that's really exciting to see how convenient and user-friendly that can be at this stage and still maintain a degree of autonomy, and I'm holding my keys and I am holding my wallet. [00:29:20] Like that's just exciting to see. And that's all within this, it's that's all within the year that it started. I know, right? Yeah, I mean it's this is this is the year that lightning has really started to grow up, and I think we're gonna start seeing some pretty exciting applications coming in 2020. So this was the year of lightning really growing up and kind of 2020, I think it'll be lightning starting to really come into its own as you know a full-fledged and much more broadly used part of Bitcoin. [00:29:53] So yeah, I mean, just to kind of list off some of the other, and we can we can you know tick these off and maybe jump in and out of them really quickly but some more lightning technologies that came to fruition this year loop in and out really important for flexibility of getting funds in and out of lightning that really just like changed the game in terms of you know refilling channels balancing channels etc yeah we had that one actually I wanted to mention that moon I didn't realize until very recently that that's how Moon worked is that Moon is like the [00:30:32] Opposite of breeze where Breeze is everything is lightning and a moon is like like all the app and stuff is lightning moon is everything looks like Bitcoin in the wallet but you are paying loop ins to pay for lightning invoices from something that just is a lightning it is a Bitcoin wallet. [00:30:58] And I didn't quite realize that but I thought that was neat a neat iteration of that. Yeah I didn't realize that either that's really cool. That's very cool. Well we merged in multipart payments amps otherwise known as amps atomic multipath payments merged into the spec like two days ago so just got it in under the wire for 2019 and is a big big story for this year it's going to really change the game especially for larger payments on the lightning network right now payments are have to originate from a single channel in your node, which really limits the amount of money [00:31:36] That you can pay for any given invoice. So if you don't have a single channel that has enough liquidity to pay that invoice, then you're not gonna be able to pay that invoice, even though you might have 10 times that amount of liquidity across all the channels in your wallet. But with atomic multipath payments or multipart payments, they're kind of going by by both names at this point. [00:31:58] They were mer it was merged in as multi-part payments by Rusty and C Lightning. L and D guy is kind of called it AMP because you got AMP and Lightning kind of playing off each other. Both are the same thing. But with AMP, you can draw from funds across multiple channels, many channels in your wallet, to piece together the payments. [00:32:17] It also obviously makes it opens the number of routes for larger payments, you know, drastically increases the number of possible routes, and improves privacy for those payments that are using multiple multipath because there's not a you can't really trace it to a single source or one path. It's hard much harder to trace back those many, many other hops on on other paths that the payment is taking before it's pieced back together at the at its final disposition. [00:32:44] That's one of the interesting things is the fact that the L HTLC for each individual payment doesn't look any different because the it's still just a hash. It's just the unlock is the one that requires, you know, like let's say you break up a payment into four different pieces to get it to reach its destination. It's the it's the final person that has that needs the all four complete pieces to actually unlock it. [00:33:10] So anybody in the mix like adds that additional layer of privacy because not only originally is a payment private, because only the node that you send directly through even knows the amount, but has no clue if you are the originator or where its destination is unless you explicitly tell it, and then of course it's not recorded on chain anywhere it's just gone as soon as it's done. [00:33:35] So not only is that they're that layer of privacy, but now because they're only one part of four, which they cannot see. They don't know that they're one part of four if they're part of an AMP payment. They just see a payment just like any other they now don't even have any clue what the size of the payment might be. [00:33:53] So you know if I'm sending $100, I could be sending $20 through node A, $150 through node B, $20 through node C, and $10 through node D. Who the hell knows what I'm buying and where? Nobody exactly yeah it's a big improvement for privacy and just you know making routing so much easier. [00:34:16] So that's really going to open up Lightning and you know it's good timing because Wumbo began this year as well and Wumbo is the channel limit this refers to the channel limit that Lightning's been working under since it's been in beta and reckless and remember Lightning is actually still in beta although it's getting close to being an official version release coming up I don't know in the in a few months when you get to one point oh is that actually like in the schedule is that is that going to be soon do you do you know of like any like specifics on that? [00:34:48] Well I know just by like based on pace that they're gonna get to one point. Unless they say it's like 0.91 point yeah obviously one two obviously right yeah they could just keep doing that. I mean you know they'll do it when they're ready. But and we're definitely I feel like we're definitely getting closer. But the Wumbo limit being lifted indicates to me that the protocol developers are getting you know becoming more comfortable with having an you know a non-beta official release. [00:35:15] Nice, yeah. And that's that's really exciting with I think amps, static backups, and now that we have watchtowers, which we haven't really gotten to yet, but that's you know, live. I think there's there were that core of like four or five things that were still really needed before we got to that point. [00:35:35] But that would be exciting to see 2020 is the year of lightning 1.0. Yep. Yeah, the main problems for me were you know, routing failures, which you know, this this latest version of LND has really big changed the game in terms of the efficiency or the lack of routing failures. [00:35:55] Like I've noticed since I upgraded to LND 8 0.8, it's you know increased successful routes, routing attempts a lot. I haven't had one since then, since I upgraded to 0.8, and I would still have them, you know, one every seven or eight attempts on seven 0.7 and earlier. [00:36:15] So that's awesome. But also you know, amps will help with that as well. The other thing is you know, I'm being having to be online all the time. So watchtowers are definitely gonna help with that. So yeah, and then of course we also had seen some Fiat to Lightning services developed and turbo channels to get onboarded super quickly so that liquidity is available right away. [00:36:35] There's a number Jack Mallers an announced Olympus earlier this year that was like in September, and had a great Bitcoiners will remember on Twitter an awesome video that he dropped of him, you know, adding funds from a debit card to lightning in a few seconds. [00:36:54] It was awesome seconds in total or something ridiculous like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly. And I think just looked the he's got the we've got and we've got three now. And actually a good friend of mine from he's in the crypto economy crew telegram with us is did the spark swap. [00:37:13] So spark swap is the other one, and he actually did one penny from Spark swap to lightning in like a couple of seconds. That's awesome. That's so and he was like, I don't even know how they are enabling that and making any money at all, but you can do it. One penny from from card to wallet. [00:37:36] It's a big deal. And then there's Escher, which I haven't used or really dug into yet. I actually contacted those guys to try to get a conversation with them about that, because it's it's another one that's very much very much like the same thing. And it's the iterative capital guys. It's the guys who wrote the iterative capital capital thesis on like the cryptocurrency phenomenon. [00:38:01] I love that piece, absolutely love it. It's like a this is my first like three or four hour audio book that I ever did on the show, and I still will go back and revisit that one. So I'm I'm excited. Yeah, me too. I've listened to that a couple of times. And that's that's one of those evergreen pieces that you can just go back and listen to once or twice a year and just you know it it it's it's a foundational thought piece on on on Bitcoin and the future for Bitcoin, and it's great. [00:38:30] Yeah, I definitely recommend that. Iter iter iterative capital Oh my god. The iterative capital thesis on crypto economy. And actually on your point with point eight and the route failures and stuff is I don't know, it's one of those things that creeps up on you and God, it really it really shows the principle that Parker Lewis laid out in oh man, Bitcoin is not too slow. [00:39:02] How payments were he talks about really great idea or concept that Bitcoin is a zero to one invention, right? And we've talked about we talked about that with Alex Fetzky like at length at Bitcoin 2019. But how Bitcoin is a zero to one invention for digital scarcity and payments are a one to in. [00:39:25] There's no end goal with payments. Like there's there's no final you know, there's no finish line. Like you just make continual incremental improvements, and as long as you've you're designing the structure in such a way for those improvements to work at an exponential layer at a layer two, at a t at a layer three, all you have to do is make constant one percent, three percent improvements, and suddenly you just end up with Visa and you don't really see specifically how you got there. [00:39:58] It just creeps up on you. And that's kind of been my experience is when I first got on Lightning, I d just like you, I had tons of route failures. It would be really exciting when a payment went through. And I don't know exactly when it was, but over the course of the year, I just started using lightning more and more and more. [00:40:20] And suddenly, rather than getting excited when a payment succeeded, I just suddenly realized one day that I didn't remember the last time a payment failed. And I couldn't ex exactly pinpoint it. And then when something failed, it felt out of the ordinary. It felt weird. [00:40:38] I was like, oh shit, I couldn't get a route. What's wrong with Breeze today? Or something. You know, like it was suddenly that was the norm that it just worked for me. Because I would numerous times go to Starbucks, and then while I'm, you know, I order my my Starbucks, and then while I'm sitting in line about to go to the window, I break out Breeze and Fold. [00:40:59] And when they're selling at 20% discount, I'm I'm buying using Lightning and then restacking those sats at a 20% discount. So I would do it just right there and get the gift card, load it into they now have the little they had the copy button, so I didn't have to like punch in the whole number and paste it right into my thing and put it on my gift card or put it on my my Starbucks card and then spend it. [00:41:25] I'd I'd make it between ordering and getting to the window, I'd use Lightning. And then when it would fail, I'd be like, oh that's right. Sometimes payments fail on Lightning. I'm not used to it anymore. I'm I'm used to being able to it's like getting it's like getting a 504 error on HTTP, you know, like a gateway timeout. [00:41:44] And like, you know, that used to happen a lot you know when the when the web was much younger, and now it's super rare. And when you get one, you're like, what the hell? And you just refresh and it and it works, you know. Yeah, so well, we would be remiss while we're talking about lightning, not to mention obviously we talk about fold, but also Lolly. Yeah. These yeah, these these companies that are helping you know people stack sets where they're shopping are going to be, I think, really important you know on-ramps for new Bitcoiners so you're stacking these sats as you go along and eventually you're gonna have you know enough skin in the game just from collecting those sats back [00:42:23] That you will you know start educating yourself and try to figure out what's going on and I think Lolly and Fold will be in a good position to provide sort of that initial bit of education to get people sort of tipped over the edge of the rabbit hole. Yeah I've got I've got a quite the stack in Fold and as soon as Lolly partners with I'm gonna become a professional stacker as soon as Lolly adds Amazon because they are by far you know 75% of my online shopping I believe. [00:42:54] And I don't know how much I have stacked with Lolly where's my my extension is right here. You know you know Fold has Amazon gift cards up to $200. I know. Everybody know what Lolly is I used to go baby oh yeah of course you do. Yeah I just like you're using that with Amazon right I've been using Fold and then finally I told you the lengthy story which I will not go into but actually got a couple packs full yeah yeah which was a nightmare I'm not a I don't think I can recommend it. [00:43:25] It's amazing that it works and it's pretty crazy for like the fact that it's they're doing remittances with gift cards and you can get that hell of a discount but it is not a simple user experience to get that position so I it's still really cool really cool. [00:43:45] It's still really cool. Everybody knows where Lolly is, right? That's listening for sure. Yes. Okay. Yeah. One more app that I want to shout out, Lightning app is Casa's SATSA app, which you can connect directly to your full node. So you know, your lightning node, it's a it's a self-sovereign way to use lightning. [00:44:06] And it's it's great. It has you have a SATS tag, so kind of like a cash app cash tag, and users people can send you SATS with that with that cash tag. You can also pay invoices in the regular way, scanning or just pasting in a URL, or I'm sorry, an invoice. And yeah, it works, it works well, and I've used it to pay over Lightning quite a bit. [00:44:29] So shout out to SATSAP and Casa as well. They've been doing great work now. Yeah, I've been my Casa node, aside from what I just told you, is it suddenly like I've been having trouble with the last couple of days, which is like the worst timing. Because it's been it's been so great for months. Like I couldn't believe that there's been no issues and everything's been working. [00:44:50] But I thought it was funny because I use my SATS app to refill my breeze. I still use Breeze because Breeze is a little bit faster because SAS app has to talk to my home Raspberry Pi node over Tor. So everything's like a little bit sluggish. Particularly when I'm like in the Starbucks checkout lane, like it's easier to just go straight to the breeze because it's there on my phone rather than talking to something distant. [00:45:14] And but I use SATS app to refund my to refuel my breeze. So if my breeze is getting low, I go to SATS and refuel from my Casa node at home. And I've had I've talked about this a couple times, I think, with like the Raleigh Bitcoin meetup crew or something. I don't know, one of the thousands of conversations I have about Bitcoin all day, all the time. [00:45:36] But the there were there were a couple of weeks there where I was using Bitcoin pretty regularly for a lot of stuff. And I would get tips or donations and things through the website or you know, something else for the show or tip and not me or something like that. [00:45:54] And I would withdraw from Tippin to my casa to just have it sitting at home on my on my stuff. And then I use a lot of stuff on Breeze and I'd buy stuff with fold, bit refill, like you know, there were times where I went at Home Depot and I wanted to give card. I just bought something off of Crate and Barrel last night. And then I use my SATS app to refuel my breeze from my Casa note at home, and I'm constantly just bouncing back and forth, and I use bottle pay a lot. [00:46:24] I just had to empty them because you know, sad to see them go, but you know, I just withdrew all that to my breeze wallet, and I'm bouncing all around between all of this stuff and I'm using it constantly, and it just struck me one day that it had been weeks that I had just been constantly using all of these tools, and I had not sent a single Bitcoin transaction, not one. [00:46:46] Yeah, amazing. All of it was off-chain on a second layer smart contract platform where I was still holding all of my keys and I had privacy in where all of those payments were going to and coming from. And it was just like you're living the you're living the future, man. You're living the future. The future is here, it is just not evenly distributed. [00:47:06] Not evenly distributed, exactly. Exactly. All right, that was an amazing year for Lightning. You know, I think it's 2020 is gonna be even more incredible. And this next decade you know, is going to be the first decade, the second decade of Bitcoin will be the first decade for Lightning. [00:47:24] And I think in, you know, when we're looking at Bitcoin's 20th birthday and Lightning's roughly 10th birthday a decade from now, we're looking at 2030. I think you know, the game will have changed so much, and lighting will be such a huge part of that future 10 years from now. When do you think with the whole idea of maybe lightning 1.0 in 2020, when do you think we'll get Bitcoin 1.0? [00:47:49] Good question. Maybe, maybe maybe in 2030. Bitcoin is still straight beta. I wonder if the whole Schnorr and I wonder if that soft work, because they're putting so much work into that now and it's going to be such a big rollout. [00:48:09] I wonder if they'll call that 1.0, because there are so many people building with that. I can't believe the amount of people working on things with lightning that are related to things that are not in Bitcoin that are derivatives of Schnorr that are derivatives of Taproot and stuff that are people working working out all the kinks and even writing code with this stuff for something that like like we're like years ahead of where of the tools that we're expecting to have, you know. [00:48:39] It's just it's just really fascinating. So yeah, well, let's talk a little bit about Schnorr and Taproot because those are made a lot of progress this year. We haven't seen either implement implemented yet, but we have seen tons of progress on the development. And it seems like Taproot is imminent. [00:48:58] Yeah, yeah. There's see, I don't know exactly how they're going to I don't know the process that they're gonna roll all of this stuff out. But we've got the specification, like we've got the BIP for Schnorr. So I don't see any reason why we won't get particularly Taproot, like you say, it looks like things are really, really close to getting those BIPs. [00:49:22] And once all of that gets rolled out, I think we're gonna see people talking about schedules for a hard fork. So and so far everybody seems to I don't I don't really see a whole lot of contention with Schnorr. Everybody's just kind of rolling with that, and it's been really great so far for from everybody's experience and from what you can do with it and what people want to do with it. [00:49:49] Yeah, I think everyone's sort of like, yeah, Schnorr is the signature scheme that Bitcoin should have had from the beginning, you know, so it's time it's time to get it in there. It's pretty exciting that we can actually do it. You know, but like back in 2011, 2012, 2013, like like during those early days, like it wasn't even it wasn't really even feasible to like talk about it as a soft fork, you know, like like it just may have been, oh well, we might not never get something like that because you can't really do that in Bitcoin. [00:50:22] But with SegWit and some of the things that have happened since it's kind of crazy that we've worked out all of these ways to get that extra functionality and what's the word flexibility in the protocol without actually altering without actually affecting the consensus rules. And that's that's really exciting. [00:50:45] It's a big deal. And the well, that's one of the aspects of SegWit that's underappreciated is the ability to use that upgrade to you know soft fork in additional upgrades in the future. So yeah, maybe one of the most important aspects of that. [00:51:05] Yeah, and for having to being able to do it with the version numbers so that you don't have to wait for the full rollout of soft work A to start talking about soft fork B. Is that you know you can roll out multiple all at once. I think it's like what is it, 29 at once, like based on like their little specification or something. [00:51:26] Yep, sounds right to me. Alright, switching gears, another big topic from this year that I think we definitely have to cover considering you know what we do for our hobbies slash you know, hopefully day jobs is creating Bitcoin educational content. This year has seen an absolute explosion of Bitcoin education content, podcasts, books, you know, articles on a medium, like just all kinds of every way, shape, and form videos all over YouTube. [00:51:55] It's been an it's been insane to watch. The list of good podcasts is like podcasts that I will still like constantly try to keep up with and listen to is gotten insane. Like I have I have an entire one of my apps, like I actually separate my apps because I have so many Bitcoin ones that I try to just at least go through the episodes to see if there's something that I really want to catch up on or listen to. [00:52:24] It's like 20 or 30 shows now. And they load up so fast, too. So fast, so fast. And this really was this year that it really exploded for for that level of content. And as I was mentioning earlier, is the 2015, 2016. [00:52:46] I mean, don't even it's a joke to go back to 2012, 2013, and then but before 2017 and 18 when this really started to pick up when when that we started hitting the bottom of that bell curve, there was nothing. You couldn't find anything. [00:53:05] Find it finding reliable information was the most painful process. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it well, I was thinking you know, there was Adam Levine and Andreas Antonopoulos, right? Let's talk Bitcoin. Basically, basically. And that was that was about it. I mean, there were a couple others, but there was one that was really dedicated to Bitcoin education. [00:53:25] You know, and then we had TFDC, Stephan Livera, what Bitcoin did, cryptoconomy come online in like 20 seven, late 2017, early 2018. Tommy and I started recording our little podcast, Citizen Bitcoin in early 2018. We spent a whole year doing podcasts with ourselves as a forcing function to teach us, you know, help us learn about what was going on. [00:53:46] We started out as a YouTube yeah, we did had zero traction. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Brady Brady figured it out. He was like, hey, we did I think how many we do six. We did six or two. Yeah, we did we did three on on YouTube only, and then we I was like, all right, let's start publishing as podcasts to see we get any more traction. And we definitely got more traction on the podcast thing, so we just kind of gave up on the YouTube. [00:54:06] And Brady said we're not doing YouTube. I said that's cool. It's easier to produce 100% correct. Easier to produce audio. But you should have seen our YouTube's were awesome. We were spectacular. Oh my god. It's embarrassing. So then yeah, then I started doing the interviews February of this year, and that's it, like February of this year. And things just you know just took off from there, and it's just it's been insane. [00:54:28] And you know, crypto economy is the same way, like you know, you've been producing incredible content for a long time, but it seems like this year, you know, you've really taken off. Yeah, it's been like the whole first year, like all through 2018, it just kind of seemed like a hobby. And what's funny is you mentioned that like it's a great way to like learn and stay up on stuff, is that that was kind of my my dominant selfish reason for starting the show was that I just wanted to force myself to read all of these things, and I knew there'd probably be a couple of people who'd get like who were like me and just wanted to listen to the articles. [00:55:05] And so 2018 it was mostly like just kind of a thing for me, and I learned so much. Like it was it was I had been in this space for six years already, and then some maybe, and I felt like I was relearning all of these things that I thought I knew, like something where I would knew like one or two pieces just enough to kind of explain the general idea to somebody. [00:55:30] Like I was finally getting into the nit and gritty and like forcing myself to sit down and really go through this article and then and then actually go through the white paper that the article is talking about so that I had something to add to it, you know. And the amount that I've learned in doing this show is unbelievable. [00:55:50] And that's the best the best thing that this this podcast has done for me. But then in 2009 early 2019, like I've five, six, like a six X for listeners and engagement this year. Like it's just been really taken off. [00:56:08] And now I've got people that are just contacting me and want audio for their work, and it's like, I know you do audio and you love Bitcoin. You want to do it? And I'm like, hell yeah. Like now I'm just I'm I'm practically drowning in it. And I just I can't get enough of it. And I love it. I don't know. The fact that like I'm really doing this full time and I think it's going to fund me full time as something that I can just do is just I can't get over how lucky I am that I just kind of started this and it became a thing, you know. [00:56:41] Yeah, man, I feel I feel the same way. Yeah, and I've been I mean my whole goal, and I now you and I have talked about this you know and have similar goals. I mean, you are you know, as I've said before, when we've had on episode before, you know, you were really my first Bitcoin friend, like the first Bitcoiner that I became you know friends with, you know, that I would consider as a friend, and like since, you know, really since then, since we really started chatting, you know, just as as buddies, like we both had the goal to get hired by Bitcoin. [00:57:10] That's how we always said it. Get hired by Bitcoin. And you know, we're both well kind of well on our way there. You know, I've started doing some advising with Give Bitcoin and getting kind of pulled in more there, which is awesome. What an awesome team they have there, and starting to kind of help them with whatever, whatever I can really do. You know, it's a small startup kind of situation. [00:57:29] So just kind of like come I've been working in tech for 20 years, so I'm just like, hey, Corey, you know, you can use me however you see fit. Just let me know what you need help with. So that's been a lot of fun to kind of get to know those guys and jump on board that that hopeful, you know, hopeful rocket ship, and they're doing amazing work. So it's just, you know, the podcast has really, you know, like you said, taught me a bunch, but also opened up a bunch of opportunities. [00:57:53] You know, I've gotten to know all the Bitcoiners, you know, network with all of them, and it's just, yeah, it's been a great way to really just dive right in like super deep into this rabbit hole. And it's been a whirlwind of about two and a half years. And I think it really goes to show that like you're you're so right about like the whole networking thing, it's just getting like like people. [00:58:16] There's something about this space that just loves to reward contribution. Like everybody is just so excited when anyone contributes something, and that that ethos here is massive. And then at the same time, like the hardcore Bitcoiners, the people who really start to get and like love Bitcoin will consume an ungodly amount of content. [00:58:41] Like everything they can get their hands on. And when when we go through another hype cycle, the foundation that all of these podcasts and all this content has laid is going to it really will just accelerate to an incredible degree how quickly people it's you know, it's like putting a it's like putting a train station and an airport at the mouth of the rabbit hole to get everybody to where they need them all there. [00:59:11] It's traveling infrastructure for movement and navigation of the Bitcoin rabbit hole, which is becoming its own massive underground world and ecosystem. [00:59:23] And it's crazy. It's so much fun to be here. Yeah, there was so much to help me get up to speed. And you know, like I was talking about this with Connor Brown on our episode a few weeks ago. It was like, he, you know, he he got in here like mid 2018, and he's already contributed two of the you know most widely read medium articles and you know, half a dozen incredible podcast episodes, you know, as a guest. [00:59:49] Yeah, and he got up to speed super quickly with all of this sort of foundation of educational content that we've been producing. And 2019 has been just you know an absolute epic year for the production of this kind of content. And I think it's just gonna serve to bring those Bitcoiners that come in, like you said, the next wave, make it so much easier for them to get up to speed on what's going on here in this really you know kind of complex topic of Bitcoin in all of its myriad of rabbit holes that branch out from it. [01:00:17] It's just gonna make it a lot easier and faster to bring all of those newbies up to Bitcoin maximalist status. Yep. All right, let's let's let's shift gears a little bit because it was also a big year for the global macro economy. [01:00:36] And yeah, we've got all kinds of craziness happening on the global macro scene. Tommy, you want to enter us into this section? Sure. I mean I think well, what we've had going on for most of the year, I mean, let's just start with a f a few concepts. When we started the beginning of the year, I don't think anybody really knew what negative interest rates were, or if you brought up negative interest rates, you'd actually have to explain explain those to somebody. [01:01:08] Example, for example, at this point, we've got a situation over examples, for example, negative interest rate. In Europe, they're actually doing mortgage loans. Denmark, for example, this came up on one of our pods, I think in the middle of the summer, where people are actually borrowing money and then they they get paid they get paid the interest payment right from the standpoint are you serious you can take a mortgage loan out at at negative one percent well maybe you weren't aware of this you can take a mortgage loan out and it'll be negative one percent so you get a paym you get a [01:01:46] Payment for you get paid for taking that loan out and then you're only responsible for the principal payment with mortgages you can actually do that yeah it's actually being done and so so when we started the beginning of the year that wasn't going on so that and so you've got a situation in Europe also where and this has come down a little bit and we covered this on a basement bulletin where the number of negative I think it was the number of negative yielding bonds were in the neighborhood of [01:02:25] 10 10 or 10 or 15 it got up to 15 billion dollars worth of negative interest rate loans in other words corporations governments borrowing money at a at a negative at a negative or trading these some of them trading at a negative interest rate upwards over a 20 trillion dollars now it could be i the only reason why i said that is it probably is i have i haven't i haven't checked it and i said i said b I think it's a t right so i should have said t so it's trillion right so if you if you really think about that it doesn't, it shouldn't even be called a negative interest rate. [01:03:03] I mean, it should be called some type of fee, correct? Because that's just a that's just a misnomer. So when we get to the overall, just the first concept of the overall market it is that it it's just it doesn't make any sense. It's not sustainable from the standpoint of having an environment by like this because what's happening is the central banks just print more fiat. [01:03:27] They've they put more fiat into the system. Okay, because why? It's not capped. Bitcoin, I mean, to tie Bitcoin back into that. Bitcoin is in quotes, it's digital, but you know, it's sound, it's sound money or a sound means of exchange from that standpoint. The overall supplies capped. [01:03:46] So you have a situation where these type of trends are are very positive for for for Bitcoin from the standpoint of the of where it is right now. As we sit at this point, at the end of the year, we've we've got an issue in the U.S. And that ties into global markets with is there is there enough liquidity in the overall market? [01:04:10] And liquidity meaning cash liquidity from the standpoint of Yeah, we're basically back to QE infinity, it looks like at this point. Is that they've not even like set up proposition for you know how much they're going to put into the economy in the you know overnight loans to keep the interest rates controlled. [01:04:31] But they're just like open open-ended, yeah, we're just gonna do it as needed. Indefinitely. Well, the yeah, and the re to get to the just briefly on the repo market, well, maybe not briefly, but the repo market, it started to crack at the at the beginning of the year, there was issues with the repo market. [01:04:50] You fast forward to where we are right now, and to your point, the bucket they're talking about is $500 billion at the end of the year, maybe $450, $500. I just saw something within today that they're saying $350, $300, $350 is all they need, maybe not $500. [01:05:11] And the reason that this occurred in a large part, one piece of it, and some of this is anecdotal. I don't know if this is completely true, but historically, you had the largest banks, the four largest banks in the U.S., would be involved with these particular fundings. [01:05:31] So the idea is is that they would provide the cash for an overnight loan, and whoever was borrowing the money, it could be what whatever the type of instrument, it had to be a highly credit-worthy instrument, but they would provide the collateral, and these big banks would make the loans. Well, what the big banks are doing right now, as I understand it, is they're holding their own, they're holding their own collateral to meet regulatory requirements that were put in place. [01:05:58] So they're not in the market. So basically they're sitting there with the ability to possibly do something, and this is as of since October or so. So they're they're sitting there not not in not not playing, not in the market. And they're and who knows if it's true or not, but they're blaming in part the regulation, saying that they have to be more credit worthy, right? [01:06:20] So when you get into a situation with with a global econom, you know, with a global market, but also just say the U.S. Market, because it's a US dollar, right? Which is a reserve currency, which is why we're talking about the importance of this particular market and the global liquidity, because it relates to dollars, right? [01:06:39] And so when you reach a point where somebody can't even tell you how much they need, right? Going into the end of the year, I mean, that's that's that's extraordinary in terms of what what could potentially happen. I mean, in terms of a downside situation, right? I don't understand how disconnected from reality and any sense of like like how forcefully you have to try not to think about what is actually happening when you're talking about trillions of dollars in negative interest rate debt. [01:07:16] To think that that is even remotely sustainable. Like think about what we're what you're talking about in resources when you're moving that amount of capital. The whole point of having money is to utilize actual real world resources. What can you borrow and get paid to borrow? [01:07:37] What is so unvaluable in the market that you will be paid to get rid of? That is what our money is worth. People pay to get rid of garbage and shit. That is what they are claiming the value of our money is, and that's what it essentially is. [01:07:55] I mean, think about it. If you have a trillion dollar loan that you're getting paid 1% of every year, then what why would you ever pay any of it off? You get paid less. You get paid less if you pay off any of the debt. Well, right. Well, I mean, the well, the other, the other to add on to that, okay, in terms of the thinking. [01:08:15] So we're I'm I'm stuck on the fact that they call it a negative interest rate. Anybody would even do it. Okay. I mean, that goes back when they did the first one we were talking about. So now we're all the way to the point. Now we're at the end of the year. So we're talking about the full year in the macro markets. So the US dollar's so strong. [01:08:33] Because we actually and we're in the US, so I say we, okay. [01:08:41] There is an interest rate that's paid on on on those on those loans, right? But now you get a situation where we're talking about the US, I mean, the president of the United States is talking about driving, you know, driving rates down, talking about interest rate cuts. So it's it's like a death spiral. [01:09:01] Yeah, and there's there is no I and I've said it a couple of times this way before, and just people, the fact that so many people just have their heads in the sand about this, and that and I guess it's just you know, when when your your idea of confidence or any knowledge about what's happening or the idea of whether or not it's normal or crazy to be doing is just kind of a derivative. [01:09:26] It's just a you know, you've just got a tube being of vomit spitting out of your TV that you're just watching the news, and then this is what you believe and you regurgitate later. Is I guess okay, it makes sense to some degree, but that anybody thinks this is really this is the most radical financial experiment, like global monetary financial experiment that has ever occurred in the history of man. [01:09:53] There is nothing normal about the situation that we are in right now, and that people dismiss it. When I start talking about Bitcoin as a solution to this, people are like, Well, what's wrong? Stock markets up. And I'm like, oh my God, I have such a I have such a foundation to lay before you even begin to understand where our problems are. It's just it's invisible to most people, and it's hard to believe that something that is so profoundly out of balance that is so profoundly anti sort of sense at all could just be not visible to like 95% of the people out there. [01:10:34] Well it's even it's even more than that. And so so this I agree we could I could go on and on. I mean the other part of it is just the whole idea is the first time I brought up negative interest rates I was around about a half a dozen people and they basically told me I was insane that I did that I didn't know what it's talking about and what the hell have I've been reading. [01:10:54] Okay subsequently they've all come back to me and said wow we didn't realize that that was actually true right but but that just tells you so so so where are so where are we? So we've got the we've got the macro financial markets which is which is what what is most important with Bitcoin and then what we've also got going on is a there's a slowing a slowing global economy and you've got this ongoing trade war between the United States and China. [01:11:22] Yeah and the Trump basically using our trade as a weapon is just ridiculous. And I don't know I guess everybody's like stuck in their camp to root for their color or their team or whatever the hell it is but the number of people who like like friends or family members who were you know fiscal conservatives. [01:11:47] And now they're just like, yeah, trade tariffs are great. They they're just like where where where did you did you remember, you know, what you the arguments or the discussions we had just five years ago when that was not at all, you would never in a million years defend tariffs or a trade war with people. [01:12:06] Like it's like sanctions and capital controls. The famous quote I don't I don't remember what it is, but it's the first act of war, you know, like putting sanctions on a country like capital controls and like starting a trade war is the first step to bombing somebody. Yeah but I mean but I mean people think about think about you know the tariffs and leading to the last so the last called depression the previous one was 1893 then there was a panic at 1873 in the US but tariffs have have been you know and I know we're getting off we're getting off [01:12:44] The overall subject of Bitcoin but tariffs have been around for a for a long time and in some cases they've actually worked well worked well for a while but you're right they did lead to wars and whatever so I guess the point is right now it's the whole thing the whole thing being the entire macroeconomy and just is just completely volatile and it it doesn't make any sense in terms of how the pieces of the puzzle are gonna be put back together in any manner without kind of breaking it's almost like you have to break the whole you have to break the whole thing and reconstruct [01:13:23] It. Yeah. You know so because if you just start doing if you just start doing math on debt owed by countries and it almost gets you to the concept of should there be some type of jubilee? Because if you look at history, that's what used to occur is there used to be jubilees where they just the debt would be zeroed out and things would start over again. [01:13:44] But I don't see how you can it's just diff, it's very difficult. I don't there's so many moving parts that I've got an aspect of I don't know. All I can all I can tell you to your to the main point is that negative interest rates don't make any sense. Yeah, so it's gotta be something that's gonna end up being bad. [01:14:05] So what does all this mean for Bitcoin? Sounds about to bring it back to that. Yeah, keep going. Sorry. That's exactly yeah, yeah. Yeah, so we've never had a situation like this when Bitcoin has been an option, a backup option, an alternative option. Bitcoin was born out of the 2008 financial crisis, but you know, was just really grown like a tiny little project for some cypherpunks in 2009-2010. [01:14:32] And then by that time we were sort of coming out of it through, you know, the printing of ridiculous amounts of money. So yeah, I mean, we're we're starting kind of what it amounts to QE4 now, quantitative easing four with the this printing of money to feed into the repo markets, sort of a backhanded way to print some money again. [01:14:51] I would guess that the federal government is US federal government and the federal reserve are going to try to you know just keep kicking the can down the road like they have been, especially and I know that you know the Trump administration will you know angle for trying to keep things going through the election period. [01:15:10] So we have Bitcoin here now as an alternative in the midst of all this. What does some kind of global economic meltdown mean for Bitcoin? And two, is it possible for Bitcoin then and either the case where we have some kind of meltdown or we have some kind of slowdown, you know, for Bitcoin to sort of step in and become an alternative economy that it, you know, it's already kind of become, but in a in a much more meaningful way. [01:15:41] Say well, we have examples, right? Of it, we have examples where just on a on a specific basis of Venezuela, right? I mean it Bitcoin was utilized there, right? Cyprus, but it was much more of a minor, minor minor type of example. [01:15:59] But my main point that was great what you just laid out there, Brady. My my main point though with this is first of all, Bitcoin's never been in a situation where there was an economic downturn. Yep. So we don't know as a first point, we don't know if the way capital's gonna move around and all that, where things get in into a down cycle where whether money's gonna move out of Bitcoin or into Bitcoin, it could be a situation where you have it moving out of Bitcoin for a while. [01:16:31] I don't know. But it would seem to me th the case would be laying that first one out. Then the second one is it would have it would seem to me it would be very similar to gold being a safe haven, as to as has been discussed historically. Now gold is I don't know, held up relatively decent lately, and I don't know exactly how that's gonna work out, but it would seem to me at this point would be would be a good it's a good alternative for people relative. [01:17:02] So that would be one positive for you know Bitcoin, you know, Bitcoin being utilized in this particular type of situation. So and I don't know. I mean it it may be you know it could be possible that it's still a little bit too early. I don't know. I'm just being honest as to how I look at it as a because if if you look at the actual institutional financial markets and that type of thing, and in terms of the size and amounts we're talking about moving around, the gold market's already established, right? [01:17:31] It's a seven trillion seven trillion dollar market. Now that's the other crazy thing. We're talking about negative inter I'm jumping around a little bit here, but like I always do. But you get negative interest negative interest rate debt that's higher than the that that's higher than the gold market. Now how does that work? A lot higher. No, how does that work? More than double. So so the idea is I think there's a place there. [01:17:52] It's just a question whether institutions, because that's what the money's gonna where the institutions have the capital being available to go into it to really, really m move Bitcoin. I think the high net worth in the other individuals, there's that that strong possibility there. And I and I think it's a definitely an option. [01:18:11] My my view is the timing as to where we are just if whether Bitcoin's got enough of a of a mass following, if you will, or enough to have it work at this at this time. [01:18:26] Thing I actually disagree on is I actually think we're in the middle of the meltdown. I think we've been in it for a couple of years. I mean, if you look at Venezuela is actually a different decent example because the meltdown, I think it's going to be less obvious when they are not going to they're always going to turn on the money spigot whenever anything shows. [01:18:49] I'm not a hundred percent sure we will have a explicit crash and huge credit crisis. I think we'll we have we will have a slow, poisonous drain, and things will get increasingly incrementally worse, and people won't quite know where to pinpoint why it's happening. And I think that's what we're in the middle of. [01:19:10] And I think Bitcoin has been in a bear market, because I think we're in a bear market right now. Look at Venezuela's stock market, it's done nothing but go up. Like Venezuela looks like if if you measure it the way we sort of measure our crap, it's just bad measuring sticks. We're measuring the wrong thing. Like, you know, we're measuring how much water we have in the bucket and completely ignoring the fact that all the water is, you know, completely is full is gonna give us a dysentery and it's muddy and disgusting. [01:19:39] So we're just measuring the wrong things. Like Venezuela has had a stock market skyrocket, like they look like they're golden boys if you use the same measurements that we go by. So in that in that way, I think Bitcoin has existed in a bear market. However, if we're seeing it like the torch is a great example. [01:20:02] You know, the torch went to like 80 different countries or something crazy like that. And you know, one of them was Iran. In a matter of seconds, people sent money to Iran and then sent money out of Iran. And we're talking about trade wars, we're talking about sh sanctions. [01:20:20] And we jokingly, like in just a show of fun on a beta network that has hardly any users or applications yet to speak of, particularly back then, that just started on a social media viral fun campaign, laughed at those sanctions, like just forgot that they existed in the process of sending tweets and money to each other. [01:20:48] And Bitcoin is growing up in that environment. That is the that is the wild card that Bitcoin presents in all of this. Now, if we do have a huge credit crisis, like a you know, a massive sharp collapse, I think that would be terrible for Bitcoin in the short term. In the long term, I think it only continues to prove Bitcoin's case and will make it absolutely a safe haven, more and more of a safe haven because any risk associated with Bitcoin is less and less if the alternative looks more and more risky, you know. [01:21:21] Like if you've got a if you got a building with, you know, just the deck is on fire, and then you've got a skyscraper where the whole thing is engulfed in flames, you're like, oh, well, this building over here is pretty great. Only the deck is on fire. So but in the short term, a credit crisis would cause a massive liquidity problem. [01:21:41] And that's how you know Bitcoin's prices held up. That you need highly liquid markets. And Bitcoin is, despite its continual growth and the fact that it has reached the position that it has today, it is still relatively illiquid in comparison to a lot of other markets. [01:22:00] It's still a guppy in the pond. So if we had a huge liquidity crisis in the traditional markets, I think we would see Bitcoin plummet with all of the rest of it, because people would just not have the capital to get into Bitcoin quickly. But in the midterm, I think people would start racing to Bitcoin if alternatives just showed no viability whatsoever. [01:22:27] If if things that people were used to being norms or always being available, money that everybody took for granted is being there started to dry up or shut down. That you will see a flight to safe haven assets. The reason I think gold is not really playing that role in, you know, as you talk about mentioned that there's more negative yielding debt than there is gold. [01:22:54] I think that's because a lot of major players don't trust gold. And it's not because gold is not a reliable asset, it's because if they don't have it in their vault, I don't think many of them believe that they actually have gold. That they trust that it's actually it actually means that they're holding gold. [01:23:14] So if they I think they might kind of see it, at least this is my position in where I've seen a lot of discussion in other markets about like there's a lot of iffiness in those contracts. There's an institutional market where that's taken care of. [01:23:34] Maybe maybe I'm maybe I'm speculating a little bit. [01:23:38] Here. Even to the point where people wonder on the vault doors whether it can be blown up. And [01:23:42] There's there's deep, deep in terms of that piece of it was serious institutional players in terms of the gold actually being a good idea. I mean in the sense that's been an issue for a long meaning like like Germany trying to repatriate their gold sometime not too long ago from the US and then just being like, no, no thanks. [01:24:03] We're not gonna do that. Well, I thought I thought I thought you meant actually somebody buying like twenty five million dollars worth of books okay. No, I'm I'm example in the institutional market. So because in the last couple months there's been an increase in just activity and high net worth and investors talking about putting putting their you know putting some of their a piece of their overall portfolio and into gold just as a yeah a safe hit and I think that's probably the one that will benefit the most despite the fact that I think there still is some uncertainty depending on amounts and [01:24:41] Guarantees in in in that market because it's heavily dominated by governments that don't seem to care if somebody else owns it if they have it in their vault. No the gold the gold thing with with some of these with the US vault and some of these countries that that issue's been going on for for for qu for quite some time as from the standpoint is if if it's really there or not or we want our gold back. [01:25:09] What what what I was talking about is from the standpoint of the actual functioning financial market, understanding that a big chunk of the gold market is central banks and governments holding that gold I was just talking from the standpoint of the overall market, let's say the institutional and big big billionaire investor market in terms of them actually saying I'm gonna go from zero percent gold to five percent or ten percent. [01:25:39] So why are there guarantees for those investors that they that their gold is actually in that vault, but there's not that guarantee for nation states who want to hold some, you know, US gold or whatever. Well, as I understand it and in in w as a con I think this goes all the way back to World War II. [01:26:00] And so just given that the situation in some of those countries over there, they wanted to be able to safely store their gold. So the US raised their hand and said, We've got vaults here, you can store your gold in the United States. So over a long period of time, they just said, Here, you can come look at it. It's in here, it's it's your gold. [01:26:19] There's no reason to repatriate it back to the your country. And then over time, most recently, and guy's exactly right, it's become a point now where some countries are saying, you know what, we don't care, you know, about coming and visiting, and we don't care about about seeing our gold because we're not sure whether that's really our, you know, that we really we just want to have a hold of it now, okay? [01:26:42] So they want to hold their own keys. Yeah. So exactly. So that that's that's totally true. I just was talking from the standpoint of a functioning of a functioning market and somebody what I'm confused about then is I guess it's just the difference between you know the United States not having an interest in necessarily maintaining the gold reserves of another nation. [01:27:03] Sounds to me though, like you're saying that an individual, high net worth individual, for instance, could do they do they do gold and then have a very high you know, high confidence that their gold is actually in that vault and that they can go and inspect it. Yeah, exactly. [01:27:21] That they have those in Switzerland, there's other places, there's some parts where they say the actually the best place to put is in Singapore. But the point is is that it's actually a system all the way through where you actually go all the way through where you say, How do the doors open? Yes to get in there, the whole thing. What happens if somebody blows it up? I mean, it's James Bond James Bond type stuff in terms of looking at the security for the stuff. [01:27:43] When was the last time the nation a nation tried to withdraw its keys, so to speak, from a US gold vaults, and were unable to do so. I don't know, but I believe, and guy, you since it sounds like you're up on this more than I am. I thought didn't London give didn't Ven this is in US, but didn't Venezuela have gold stored in London that they had brought back. [01:28:09] I thought they got denied. I know they got denied from the US. Right, I'm just saying, but they did get some, right? I do not know that. I'll I'll it's very possible. Like I would I would believe you if you thought I'm not sure. I thought maybe they were just maybe they were just talking about it and it didn't happen. [01:28:29] I know but this but see this gets gets to the whole I guess this gets to the whole store of all value argument, right? So we're talking from the standpoint of a store of value. Obviously, if you can't get your gold or your physical gold or your keys, then it's not a store of value, right? I mean, if you can't get it, right? Yeah, if you're not holding it yourself. [01:28:48] And then if we're also saying, given where the where the financial markets are right now, given we know historically, at least as I understand it, usually in a serious downturn, there's a flight to safety, and gold's been known for decades or or years for being a flight to safety from the standpoint of it's notwithstanding the other issue we just talked about with the countries switching, you're not being able to get their gold repairs. [01:29:15] Yeah, see the thing in treated. The funny thing is is that I think Bitcoin will be seen less of a safe haven because you're right, gold definitely has the market, it definitely has the network and the mind share of I am the safe haven. And I think probably the big difference between whether or not you can trustworthy, like you have a higher degree of trust in buying and holding it is a is sort of an inter versus intra jurisdictional problem. [01:29:45] So if you're doing it, if you're joining it across countries or across economies, you have less assurances than if you have if you're within the economy that you're you're purchasing or trying to hold it in. I agree. [01:30:05] But the other point I was going to just make is that in terms of earlier what I said about maybe possibly being too early is just because too early in Bitcoin's you know, where where it sits, is that in terms of a store of value, not only do you have the issue the issue of right now what we're talking about is is it in a in a in a fall off that it it may get caught up. [01:30:29] Bitcoin may get caught up more than say gold. You also have the issue where you're talking to investors that you still have to convince them that Bitcoin's okay. The in other words, would if you've got somebody that's worth a billion dollars and they're very conservative, would you be able to convince them instead of putting their hundred million dollars for a store of value play as part of their portfolio? [01:30:56] I'm gonna put a hundred million dollars, tell them you should put a hundred million dollars of your money in Bitcoin, and that should be restored value. It will actually play the best role. I think this will I think these will kind of go hand in hand. So I think there will be a large part of the market that will begin to see Bitcoin as a safe haven asset, particularly if this meltdown and this situation continues continues to get incrementally or progressively worse as we get to the halving and go through another hype cycle with Bitcoin. [01:31:29] But more importantly, is I think people will that's fair. I think there will be a lot of using of Bitcoin for movement of capital, is like what we're seeing with like we see this now in the retail and like the small markets with like the Paxville as the example is that there's this huge like hundred million dollar multi a remittance market happening with gift cards on all these countries where capital is incredibly hard to move around. [01:32:02] And as our global financial systems situation deteriorates, there will be larger barriers, there will be higher costs, everyone will be fighting to make it incredibly difficult to get out of their currency into something else because we're all they're all fighting to control and manipulate their own the prices of their own currencies in relation to others, and the only thing they can do is choke the pipes that move from one to the other. [01:32:29] That's their one tool. And as everything becomes more and more just packed with friction, Bitcoin will be the one way that they can actually send money to this country, that they can actually [01:32:44] Begin with. That they can actually keep business running. This is what got me interested in Bitcoin to begin with. And but business has to continue to thrive. Like you still have to move things. Like you can't just pretend that because the government says, Oh, you shouldn't move money to this country anymore. That oh, well, that means that we don't need any oranges or wheat from this country. [01:33:02] No, this bullshit. Like we have to, we are so interdependent. The economy is getting more and more global every single day. And when these barriers go up, people will find ways around them and the tools for doing it, the tools for cutting out a little brick in that wall and sliding some value through are getting more and more widespread, easier to use, and a plethora of options. [01:33:35] Well, it tie it right. Well, it tie ties into what we covered with with the lightning network and all what that's going on there. It's it's it's like a trust net or an inf infrastructure to be able to be able to put all put this all together, right? And that takes time. I mean, the other the other part of it is education. [01:33:53] Because if if you try to talk to somebody that's not familiar with Bitcoin, and let's say that this person's buying product from China, or let's say they're buying it from Vietnam, okay, just because everybody uses they're buying it from Vietnam, and you tell them, listen, if if you get a hold of your, you know, you get a hold of your supplier and get it set up, you don't even need a bank. [01:34:15] You can set it up so you do all your transactions between each other, okay. They just don't they don't get that. A lot of a lot of people don't don't get that initially. Or they're not comfortable not having a bank handling or or or an intermediary of a in quote trusted bank handling their their situation, right? [01:34:37] But then when you start talking about, well, look it, you got to put up a letter of credit. Then you know, you guys already know everybody that's listening to this knows the drill. So it makes all the sense in the world to have it set up peer to peer. Yeah. And I think it's gonna get increasingly that direction. And I think too that we really need the next hype cycle because one of the issues with moving large amounts of money, like I think that's why the next crash probably won't be as as vicious and why it seems to be less and less vicious every single [01:35:15] Time we go through these cycles. Is just because you get a greater market, the Bitcoin is able to move more value the more value it's securing. So if it's a trillion dollar market, well, suddenly you can move a hundred billion dollars in a transaction. And when you can do that, there will be an entire market of people who now are like, holy shit. [01:35:41] So you're telling me I can move a hundred billion dollars from China to the US or vice versa, and I don't have to care about any of the sanctions or any of the trade war stuff that's going on. I can actually move that amount of money in a matter of minutes. Like those people are not going to those are not the amounts of money or the markets that don't know what tools are at their disposal. [01:36:06] They're the ones who know every tool at their disposal and will pick the right one. And if they don't know, they'll hire a team of people to find the tools. So and I think as Bitcoin reaches that point, you'll see this massive you could call it remittance, but that's I don't think it would just be a global foundational monetary underground that is moving money as if all of the legacy systems don't exist. [01:36:38] It's just it's a big market, man. Okay. It's a it's a huge parallel economy. That's that's in a parallel universe. [01:36:50] You might say nudge nudge wink wink. Well, I think that was a really great conversation. Thanks, Tommy, for leading that, and thanks, guy, for your takes. I, you know, I learn a lot from listening you guys talk about this macro stuff, and I certainly have learned a ton about just economics, what money really is and what's going on in the world because of Bitcoin. [01:37:13] And I think you know, most of the listeners out there are in a similar similar situation as I am, just learning a ton about all this stuff from Bitcoin. So there's that. I think there's just a couple of things I want to wrap up with that we haven't mentioned yet through the course of the conversation, hadn't come up, but are on the list. That what that I definitely think deserves mentioning, it's a big kind of happening in Bitcoin from this year, and that's the growth of CoinJoin. [01:37:40] Wasabi and Samurai, the coin join markets that have really grown up this year, that are you know really amazing. So yeah, guy, you want to tell us about you know what happened with Asabi this year, and then Samurai came on the scene soon afterwards. There's definitely some back and forth between those two teams. [01:37:58] You know, I think the competition is great and you know will drive you know new innovations on both sides. You know, if you get down into the weeds, there's definitely a lot of drama that happened between the two, the two teams, which is also interesting. But yeah, let give us kind of a background on on what happens in the world. Basically, all of the user-facing implementations are all this year. [01:38:20] They they were all 2019. There was a like see, CoinJoin used to be for like an implementation of it. I think the only thing that you could do was terminal. And I never even used it. I believe I downloaded something that could do maybe it was join market, if I'm not mistaken. [01:38:43] And but I never actually utilized it. That you can like connect it to like a ledger or or Trezor, that you can just like run a hardware wallet off of it so that you've just got it plugged in while you're using it and then you know yank it out. While Wasami still isn't normie friendly, like you have to know what you're getting into, but as a tool, it is a very, very fascinating thing. [01:39:10] And I've only really used it once, and I've been eager to really take the time to go through and set it up again from scratch, maybe even do videos or something. I don't know. Not sure if I have any time to do videos, but it's always one of those things that I just [01:39:30] Guy, you've got to pare [01:39:31] Down that to-do list, man, not not the other way around. And but I love the just the fact that this is coming to like the user interface, like like the these things, these kinks are getting worked out and it can actually can be used. Samurai, I used on which samurai has a slightly different, I don't think they now connect directly to their node, because that was what some of the drama was about was the fact that you were still just it was still a light wallet, and you're just still talking straight to Samurai and asking for data. [01:40:06] So it was like wasn't private from them. So all the privacy tools that they were creating were great, and it's awesome that they were being built, but you weren't really having the trustless privacy in the way that a lot of people were assuming that they had. And even though it was basically known that that was going on wasabi, I mean Samurai wallet guys weren't exactly being like, by the way, you don't really have privacy from us, like it's coming, but let me give you a little warning or a disclaimer here that wasn't really happening. [01:40:43] So I think that's where people were claiming there was malicious acting involved, and everybody like got at each other's throats. And there were some other things too, but I didn't keep up with the drama too well. That and then the combination of like what you can do with these coin joins with Schnor as we get to implementing these other technologies, that and Taproot, this is the most exciting part of the entire privacy idea for me is that because we have limited block space, a coin join transaction that can aggregate signatures is [01:41:22] Smaller, has a smaller blockchain footprint than a normal transaction. And because of that, privacy is the more efficient option. Privacy is the more cost-effective option in that scenario. And I really, really hope that that's how we see this get implemented is people are seeking to save money rather than getting privacy. [01:41:48] Because I think privacy is mostly a fringe thing. Most people don't care unless they specifically get hit. They they specifically pay a terrible price for not having privacy. Most people don't think about it. Most people don't care, particularly on the internet. They don't know exactly where or why they've lost their privacy. [01:42:08] So they just kind of let it go. You know, it's not like they can see somebody looking at them through the bathroom window as they take a crap. Like then you know, oh my God, I don't have privacy right now. But on the internet, none of that is there. You don't know who's looking, you don't know where the information is going. It's it's all in a black box for the for the average person. [01:42:29] So when privacy actually becomes a price incentive, when it becomes an incentive to save money and be efficient when somebody sees that one costs 20 cents and then this other alternative costs four cents, they're just going to pick it and they're gonna have no idea that it's because they've got that they've got an extra privacy with it. [01:42:50] And that increases the anonymity set and the fact that these awesome teams are building out all of these tools to make them work seamlessly together. It becomes just a matter of porting it to a new piece of software or re-implementing the same idea behind, you know, a point and click button. [01:43:09] This is all the infrastructure that's going to make the future that I was always hoping we would get to with Bitcoin. And then there's the whole other level of why don't we coin join all the opening of our lightning channels for an entirely private payment network, which we won't even get into, but there you go. [01:43:29] It's just there's so many layers of this, and it's it's it's crazy. Been a been a hell of a year. Hell of a 2019. Yeah, 20, I mean 2019, yeah. We called 2019 the year of lightning, and it's just absolutely grown up so much this year. But you know, looking back, it's also been an incredible year for Bitcoin privacy. [01:43:48] This year too. All that stuff landed. Yeah, yeah. Which was proposed this year as a as another possible like base layer privacy implementation. Yeah, I mean, I've used Wasabi and it's actually really simple to use. It's you know, it's not like straight up, you know, any like your grandma can use it kind of thing. [01:44:13] But you know, it's it's very, very simple to use. Really it's not it's not as intimidating as it might seem. It's a download, and then it's a Bitcoin transaction, and then it's a couple of clicks, and everything else from there is automated. You know, you'll you'll get in, you kind of queue up whatever amount you want to try to be coin joined, and the app will take care of it after that. [01:44:36] It'll it'll insert it into the next available round, and you know, at the end, you have to you do have to leave the Wasabi running, so you can't like close your laptop and run away. You need to have it like sitting there and running, otherwise you won't make it into the into the round. But yeah, it'll take a few hours. You'll get in the round. The round takes a little while to execute, and then you'll have you know, a coin, a UTXO that has a certain anonymity set. [01:45:02] And right there in the in the UI, you'll get an indication about how anonymous how how high of an anonymity set that particular UT UTXO has. And that's it. It's pretty simple. And Samurai has a very simple interface on their mobile wallet as well. So lots of advancement on the base layer privacy. [01:45:22] Of course, Lightning Network is also just a huge advancement in and of itself in terms of privacy and payments. So yeah, we've taken some big steps forward in 2019 on the privacy fronts as well. Yeah. I would say I would say probably Wasabi, like just as you kind of go through the process, is that it's really intimidating if you don't know what you're getting into because you're constantly in like a setup of like, wait, okay, what stage? [01:45:47] What is the what is this? Like so like like you say, it's like not like a grandmother is never your grandmother's never gonna be able to do this easily. But if you're like a if you're a bitcoiner and you know you're you're used to Bitcoin transactions and you also have a general overview of what's happening, it's not really that unfamiliar. [01:46:10] So like I would definitely say if anybody is looking to play around with those things, don't be intimidated by Wasabi if if you know Bitcoin, you know, if if you're familiar with the tools. Yeah, and Max Hilibrand has done some great videos. There's a whole video series on an ocean of that stuff. [01:46:29] Yeah, there's an ocean out there, and like you know, there's just the basics, there's a whole playlist of just the basics, you know. It's maybe a few videos takes you through how to do it. If you just want to like see it happen first before you actually you know go through your first round, that's a good place to just kind of watch what happens and how it works. But it is actually really simple. [01:46:47] You can do it in half an hour, you got half an hour one night, and you want to try out Wasabi, you can just you know send some Bitcoin into Wasabi, cue it up for a round, and you'll you'll be able to watch it kind of go into that round, and then you can kind of walk away and come back after you've you know watched your Netflix and ready to go to bed. [01:47:06] And there it is. You'll have some anonymized UTXO to do whatever you want with, you know, put it into cold storage. Yo, yup. Yep, yep. All right, guys. That was fun to sit down and look back on 2019. We should do this again next year. Guy, thanks for joining us on this. [01:47:26] Really appreciate it. Yeah, man. Always. Good to hang out. We hadn't talked in a while. So yeah, it was good, man. Catching up. Well we'll hook up again at Bitcoin 2020. We had quite a the three of us had quite a time last year. Oh, hell yeah. And we're doing that's in that's like really that's like really soon. We like we gotta need to get out of Airbnb and stuff. [01:47:46] Like, we need to start talking about that. Yeah, it's four months away, man. So it should be a good time. Hope you all come out to Bitcoin 2020. It's gonna be off the chain. You know, no pun intended. Yeah, it's it is fantastic. It's supposed to be twice as big this year. 2,000 people last year, 4,000 expected this year, is what I've heard. [01:48:06] 4,000? Yeah, that's what I've heard. Nigzabo is gonna be headlining. We've got Tony Hawk, who is a who is a bitcoiner, he's been a hodler for years now, is gonna be there and talk about Bitcoin. Yeah, seriously, that was crazy. I had no idea that that that all happened very recently. Like this yeah, that happened this year too. Tony Hawk outed himself as a bitcoiner. [01:48:26] Are you a skateboard guy? No. I had a lot of skateboarding friends in school, like back in the day, but no, I never skateboarded. I was the I was the nerd who would like take video of them skateboarding. I was a wannabe skateboarder for like a couple summers. I bought skateboard shoes to be cool. Thanks. Yeah, exactly. [01:48:45] I had a skateboard. I had a skateboard with metal wheels. That's how far back I go. Metal. Like the actual wheels themselves are metal, not just like the wheels themselves are metal. Oh god. Boomer. How did that work? Bought it at Sears. Okay, boomer. [01:49:05] It's just the most [01:49:07] He thinks I had a skateboard with metal wheels that I bought at Sears. Two shame, man. I have to credit you guys with that one. That was that was actually got me got me good with that. Actually, that was that was that was perfect. Hey, we give we give boomers who are bitcoiners a pass. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is a whole different whole different realm of boomers. [01:49:27] You're you're the best of all the boomers by far. Absolutely. Yeah, exactly. You're very kind. You're welcome anytime. Alright, guys. Happy holidays, happy new year. See you guys on the flip side. Thanks for joining us. Thanks everybody for listening. Take it easy, guys. [01:49:45] Take it easy. Alright, that was a great time. It was really nice to sit back down with Tommy. It's been a few months since we had the chance to record a basement bulletin episode. And you know, guy is one of my favorite people to talk Bitcoin with. [01:50:07] I hope you all enjoyed it as well. And let us know what you thought about the episode, any questions you had on Twitter. Guy is at the crypto economy, and Tommy is at Canon's Call. I am at Citizen Bitcoin. And you know, if you're not subscribed to the Crypto Economy podcast, you gotta do it right now. [01:50:26] It is one of my favorite Bitcoin podcasts. It's one I've been listening to for years, and I have gained so much knowledge from listening to the podcast. Guy reads the best articles in Bitcoin, so it's like an audible for Bitcoin, and then he's you know just super smart, incisive, and gives you delivers some great commentary after the after the articles, brings in some context, great stuff. [01:50:48] Definitely subscribe, Crypto Economy Podcast, if you haven't yet. The really the best way to support the podcast is sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter. Also with your family and friends. You can share the podcast website, citizenbitcoin.world. And don't forget to check out layer one BTC for those two new designs. [01:51:07] If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I am at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram and Keybase, and my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. This week's open source shout out is Electrum Wallet, originally created by Thomas Votlin in 2011 as one of the first Bitcoin wallet alternatives to the Bitcoin Core Wallet. [01:51:28] Until recently, Electrum has been one of the only accessible ways for Bitcoiners to establish multi-sig setups and use hardware wallets. Since its inception, almost 250 developers have contributed almost 12,000 commits to the Electrum GitHub repo. Check out Electrum at Electrum.org. [01:51:48] Alright, next up, I've got episodes with Yan Pritzker, author of Inventing Bitcoin and CTO of GiveBitcoin, and Kiara Bickers, author of the new book Bitcoin Clarity, that I had a chance to go through over the holidays. It's a really good one. You should check it out. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.