Brandon Quittem and Brekkie von Bitcoin: History in the Making Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-10-15 [00:00:13] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. My name is Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners all around the world. Thanks for joining me again for another day here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. [00:00:32] Today I hung out with Brandon Quittem and Brekkie von Bitcoin. We had a wide-ranging conversation. It was a lot of fun. I'll tell you just a little bit more about the conversation in a minute after we check in with Swan. Swan has Daily Buys up and running. [00:00:50] We just sent an email out to a couple hundred people to invite them into trying out Daily Buys as we slowly roll it out to our beta list of over 2,000 people. You can still jump onto that list and get a notification when it is available for you, when daily buys is available for you at SwanBitcoin.com slash daily buys. [00:01:13] Super excited about that. We've got some other exciting news to drop in the coming weeks. It's quite a few things stacked up to announce. We've been working hard and ready to kind of roll some new features out and just a couple other announcements that I'm excited about. So stay tuned. I, of course, will keep you guys updated here on this pod. [00:01:33] Sign up for Swanforce, swanbitcoin.com slash enlist. One of the cool things we're doing is we are now giving you content to give away to help you earn referrals [00:01:45] So say, like you're, you know, one of your parents has been you know kind of curious about Bitcoin or a little skeptical or whatever. You can now give them a copy of Inventing Bitcoin by Yan Pritzker and a URL that has them go to that to your Swan Force page, get that book, and if they sign up at any point that day or in the future, you will get that referral credit. [00:02:10] So you can send it far and wide to friends to social networks, you're giving them some value with some educational content, and we're gonna add more options, more content to be able to for you to be able to give away coming up. So you'll be able to give away some content, give them some value, and they'll land on your referral page, and you'll earn 25% of Swan's fees on every purchase made by your referrals when they choose a Swan membership plan. [00:02:36] That can be a lot of sats. All right, you can earn those for three years. Swan Bitcoin.com slash enlist. All right. Thanks as always to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. Subscribe to their feed for other great Bitcoin only podcasts. Shout out to Bitcoin Magazine, shout out to Christian, CK Snarks, shout out to FedWatch Podcast on that feed. [00:02:58] I've really been digging that with CK and Ansel Lindner, one of my favorite Bitcoiners of all time. They're doing great work on that. So go check out the LTBN feed. Alright, let's dive in. [00:03:21] Brandon Quittem and Brekkie von Bitcoin are two friends of mine, gotten to know them really well, working with them at Swan over the past you know eight months or so. I already knew both of them pretty well through Bitcoin, but have gotten to know them a lot better, and they're just wonderful guys. We always have some great conversations behind the scenes, hanging, you know, when we're done with work calls at Swan, we end up hanging out for another 15-20 minutes, just having great conversations. [00:03:48] And I thought, hey, let's get on, have one of those conversations and put it out on the podcast. This one was great. We really got into some, you know, topics that aren't explored as much on these podcasts on Bitcoin Podcasts, talking about you know, generational changes, cycles through history, like the fourth turning, and what Bitcoin will look like in terms of the way we govern society, the trends of globalization kind of turning into more of a localization trend, but also allowing for like technologies like Bitcoin and the [00:04:26] Internet allowing for global connection while we actually trend to becoming more of local societies. Really interesting conversation, wide ranging. I hope you all enjoy it. Here we go. [00:04:46] All right, what's up? We're doing this live. We're doing it live. Citizen Bitcoin is going live. We did the first one last week with Ali Hamam of Tahini's Restaurants. That was a fantastic episode. I do have a YouTube channel, which I had neglected for 103 episodes audio only for a long time. [00:05:07] But hey, I'm getting used to this video thing with Swan Signal Live and figured I might as well just start putting this stuff on YouTube as well. Of course, it'll be on the on the podcast feed on Let's Talk Bitcoin Network and the Citizen Bitcoin feed right after we drop this. I'm just gonna stick put it out there. [00:05:27] I've got Brandon Quittem and Breck Ivonne Bitcoin with me today, Brandon Quittem, Brekkie Von Bitcoin. What's up, guys? Brady Swenson. Howdy James show off Neo Cash Cario Video. The eyes. [00:05:47] Everything's fine in Minneapolis, as you can see. Oh, the eyes on that guy, man. That was was he not like the worst, the worst possible person to put in that chair. Right? I don't know. He seems like a hard charger. Like he wants to climb the ranks in the Fed. [00:06:06] Oh yeah. I mean he reminds me of the guy of Xerxes and 300. Like looks a little bit like the eyes. Like that was what I was a vibe I got. Wasn't good. Totally. He doesn't seem to wear as much makeup as Xerxes, but no, maybe how long that'll last. [00:06:27] Yeah, I mean, these guys, these guys at the Fed men, history is not going to treat them well. And you know, talking to Daniel DiMartino Booth, of course, she's the Fed insider, you know. She's she knows these guys, all right. And I've been asking this question do these guys know what they're doing? [00:06:46] Like, are they aware of how fucked up what they're doing is? Are they? That's the I mean that's my question. I and Danielle seems to think yes. At this point, they are. I remember you know, she when she was writing her book, she was talking about how they they didn't really understand this, right? [00:07:06] The Keynesian ideology was so pervasive inside the Fed because all of them were PhDs and they looked down on anyone who wasn't a PhD. Like Danielle had two master's degrees, right? And so she was like, you know, looked down upon by the PhDs. It was that bad, right? [00:07:25] They had had drank their own Kool-Aid like that much, right? And now she's starting to think that these people are starting to get it, right? It's creeping in. Dallas, Dallas Fed president Richard Fisher, who she was the right-hand analyst for, was really the last voice in the past 10 years for or against Keynesianism, or at least run amuck, like it like it did ended up happening in 2008, right? [00:07:57] But there are those ideas are starting to creep in now through the various Fed banks. The Dallas Fed again is kind of leading that charge, they've always been sort of more conservative on that front. The Kansas City Fed has a Fed chair or Fed president that's kind of pushing back. [00:08:15] And man, like this I think I don't think you're gonna they're possibly going to change the you know route that the Fed is going to take. But I feel like they're starting to understand the path that they have they've led us down and where it's going. What we might see is more people like Danielle who are Fed insiders who realize what's wrong and then leave that part of the system and either or maybe stay and try to change it, but I think maybe we'll see an exodus of people who wisen up over time. [00:08:47] But the problem is this is a big institution that's been around forever, so they're just gonna pull in new people, new acolytes to kind of keep it going, you know. There's no shortage of economics PhDs. And you know, the Fed system employs thousands of them. [00:09:06] That's that's where they go. That's you know, where they that's sort of the dream job, right? That's like the JP Morgan Chase, McKinsey, Google kind of you know, aspiration, right? Is to go work at the Fed for a lot of these people. I mean, dude, the whole thing is kind of crazy like that. Like I went to UPenn and the Wharton School that is there, a very famous business school, and part of why I kind of went in a different direction is because I was kind of just disgusted with the mindset of all these people and you know what they were trying to do. [00:09:35] And the funny thing is I'm in a pen telegram group, and I forked it because it's called I don't want to share what it's called, but anyway, all they do is talk about Ripple and all these things that I'm just like, no, what like they don't get it. And so I forked it off and I made a Bitcoin pen channel on Telegram. [00:09:54] And you know, some people have joined, but the incentives of the world, man, a little messed up. Speaking of the Fed, go ahead. Go ahead. I was gonna say, speaking of the Fed, I think that what we're gonna see now is they're a bit more impotent than they would like to be. You know, they sort of exhausted their tool set, and so the only way to get out of this is through spending. [00:10:17] And so I think what we're really gonna see is the population begging for more money to be injected in various ways, and with the Fed targeting as much inflation as we can get our hands on, that's really the only way. Like QA will continue, they'll they'll guard the yield curve, they'll do all that in the background. But I think we're gonna enter a period of massive, massive stimulus. [00:10:38] Everyone's a socialist, you know, just money raining down from the heavens, and I think most people are gonna cheer for it. And I think that in the short term, people are gonna sort of feel better. And in the long term, it's gonna just undermine everything. So yeah, I hear that, man. [00:10:57] What have you thought through the like inflation deflation debate? I'm starting to you know, I've been listening to Ansel Lindner, who shout out first of all, shout out Ansel. Like, oh gee, you know, Orange pilled me in 2017 into being a Bitcoiner from being, you know, shit coiner, I suppose. [00:11:19] And like Bitcoin and markets, and he was calling out all the scams back then, had like no you know, just calling it out before anybody else leading the charge on on S2F, I'm not on not S2F on Segway2X, S2X, I guess it is. Yeah, he was out there, man, and love that guy. [00:11:40] Now he's doing a podcast in addition to Bitcoin and Markets with Christian at Bitcoin magazine called Fed Watch. So I've been listening to Christian and Ansel, and Ansel's been pushing this idea that he's really he really thinks we're leading we're heading toward deflation for quite a while before inflation shows up. The idea being, you know, you have this interplay between the euro dollar and the US dollar, and that there's a lot of dollar denominated debt out there, and so the world can absorb a lot of dollars, right? [00:12:13] And so taking all of you know, trying to pay down all of that debt and getting that, you know, getting those dollars out into the world will actually cause some deflation at first, because there's just it's gonna be spread around the world. There's so much appetite for it, right? That the hyperinflation won't show up until later. [00:12:33] So once all that debt is like sort of under control through all the money printing, then you get the hyperinflation, right? So that yeah. It's sort of like it's a Kanteon effect, but it's it operates different levels, you know. Like here in the United States, like we as a country, we are the money spigot. So we're closest to it, you know. [00:12:53] Like I do think we're gonna see more hyperinflation everywhere else in the world, but like the last place it'll hit will probably be here. But even like you look at like what you know, look at what Michael Saylor did and why he did it, you know, there inflate there's the official inflation numbers, and then there's the unofficial real inflation numbers. [00:13:11] And the way people like Michael are calculating it, I mean that's what I'm I'm looking at. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. CPI is absolute garbage, bullshit. So is GDP and you know, all these measures that we you know use to measure success of the economy. They just keep getting it's it's all politicized, man. It's it's a ton of it's just all bullshit. [00:13:31] But yeah, real inflation rates, you know, seven, eight percent over the past ten years since since the financial crisis. And Saylor argues, you know, upwards of like 20, 25% this year. That's rough, right? We started seeing it with food already. [00:13:51] I don't know about where you guys live, but like I think I haven't been keeping track, so this is all anecdotal, but like seems like food's a little more expensive than it has been. Oh man, I can't go to the grocery store without spending 200 bucks. I mean, we have a family of four here. We probably spend I don't know. [00:14:11] I don't even want to I don't I don't even want to think about it, honestly. At least probably like six to eight hundred dollars a month. [00:14:19] Well, yeah, I mean you want to buy quality stuff too, right? Like you want to eat some steaks that aren't, you know, like you want to need some farm raised, like you know, grass-fed beef. But that's off the charts, you know. You're talking $20 a pound in some places. Yeah. However, if you get to know your farmer and you throw a chest freezer in the basement, you can get top tier beef all in for seven bucks a pound. [00:14:43] Now that's average with ground beef and ribeye, right? The ribeyes are 25, the ground beef's five. But if you buy in bulk, you get an average around seven bucks. And yeah, then you just shop in your basement. We're actually here in LA. There's somebody on Telegram that we were talking to. [00:15:02] It's like anybody want to go in on half a cow? Yeah, I'll do that. I got a chest freezer. So food and G U. Yeah, it's definitely true. We do the same thing. We have a chest freezer and we just load up on beef from our local butcher. Fortunately, like our butcher is has been a longtime family friend. [00:15:23] And so that's massive hookup for us. But still, it's expensive, man. So yeah, we're seeing it happen in in you know, in CPI numbers that aren't being reported, right? And the stuff you actually want is going up. [00:15:41] So yeah, yeah. So in the CPI, but I haven't looked lately. It's always two percent. Yeah, right. Well, Brekkie's looking that up. I think one thing to think about long term is you know, we're end at we're at the end of a Ray Dalio credit cycle, which means if history repeats, we're gonna have to do some sort of a monetary reset. [00:16:05] And the question is, will the US dollar hyperinflate? I think a lot of Bitcoiners have been pointing to that, a lot of gold bugs have been pointing to that, but it hasn't happened yet. And you know, we printed a lot, a lot of extra money since I don't actually think we're gonna see a US dollar hyperinflate. I think what's more realistic is we have all this debt, and we kind of have a couple options. [00:16:27] One, we inflate away the debt slowly, you know, sort of hidden tax by printing money, and the nominal debt stays the same, but the real value of the debt goes down over a decade or so. I think that's most likely. Otherwise, we can do a decade or two of austerity and you know, decrease spending and try to balance the budget, but there's absolutely no political willpower for that. [00:16:53] And so, you know, along the lines of a Lyn Alden type thesis is we're going to devalue the currency over the next period of time. And so why would you want to hold on a currency that's strategically being devalued? Right, right. So that's where the reserve asset narrative comes in, right? [00:17:14] And we've been we were talking about like we always talk about what what's the next what's the next thing that's gonna come up, right? It's gonna be you know, it's been gold, digital gold for quite a while. I think people kind of understood that. Now it's reserve asset, right? Corporate reserve asset in particular is is hot right now. [00:17:35] It's so hot right now. So yeah, of course, micro strategy. We have Square. I feel like these guys, and obviously, especially MicroStrategy in such a big way, are planting a flag, right? They're planting a flag in a on the real estate of the blockchain, which is obviously very scarce. [00:17:56] And MicroStrategy has taken a big old like Montana ranch size of the of the blockchain and just planted a flag and been like, all right, we are we're all in, and I feel like they're gonna become a Bitcoin company, right? I mean, it's in their interest, obviously. [00:18:14] I think the bulk of their revenue, their gains, their paper gains, right, are is gonna come from Bitcoin over the next couple of years. I think that's obvious. I mean, because they're netting 30 to 50 million dollars in revenue a year, 450 million dollars worth of Bitcoin, all it has to do is 2x, you know, and you've you've you've doubled your revenue in within a year, a yearly revenue. [00:18:36] So man, I feel like these companies, once they get Bitcoin on their balance sheets, they're incentivized to get into supporting development, right? To get into mining, to get into providing financial services, you know, Bitcoin strategic services, and supporting the network in general, just like we have all been sucked in by Bitcoin and spending our brain cycles on it, right? [00:19:03] But they just have a lot more money than we do. Corporate Bitcoin standard is incredibly interesting. And I think it caught a lot of us by surprise, and we all haven't really taken the time to kind of consider the implications, but Bitcoin Tina has talked about this a lot in terms of like what happens when you become a Bitcoiner and how Bitcoin incentivizes people to improve Bitcoin over time. [00:19:25] It's pretty incredible. And to touch on the sort of real estate metaphor, what's really interesting about the real estate metaphor, and I love it, you know, like there's a limited amount of real estate on the blockchain, like get your stats now. The cool thing is that there's no like there isn't beachfront real estate versus you know across the train tracks real estate, like there's all real estate's the same, it's just a matter of when you buy it and what price you get in. [00:19:47] So go get your real estate, right? And yeah, exactly. This is super scarce real estate, and you're buying up chunks of it, massive chunks of it, 0.1%, 0.2% now, right? 0.2% now, micro strategy has 45,000 Bitcoin. [00:20:06] That's a big chunk of real estate. Imagine buying 0.2% of the world's land. I gotta stop comparing about the micro strategy, you know. I'm like, oh my god, I want to have even a fraction of that, you know. But I'm not a company, I'm an individual. So what we have is what we have, and it's it's gonna be a more than we need, I believe at some point. [00:20:31] Do we think that this is gonna be the driving narrative for the next bull run? Because when I think about this, like from a corporate standpoint, they're gonna run the same brain cycle Sailor did. He obviously did it quickly because he's predisposed to Bitcoin, he's been a Bitcoiner since the last ice age, and it just became uncovered now. [00:20:51] And that's why it took him so short to pull it off. But other CEOs are gonna come to the same conclusion, and you know, they're not gonna go all in Sailor style, but they probably will dip their toes in over the next year or two. And what I found in my personal life is the normies love this narrative. If you say public corporation buys Bitcoin, they don't even have to think through the implications. [00:21:14] They just put a lot of weight towards that. And so dragging retail back in is kind of part of the next step if we're going to have another blow off top. We want big capital from the corporations, and we want the normies, you know, stacking sets as well. And so to me, this feels like the obvious next catalyst. [00:21:33] I don't, I don't think we even would need anything else. Like that will create FOMO enough to it's just gonna keep expanding and building and building, you know. Why have why didn't we see this coming? We've been talking about the institutional money for so long since 2017. We were talking about the CME, we were talking about backed and watching those grow, watching, you know, watching the growth of CME and marveling at how big backed be has become since you know four months after it launched, it was at this tiny like 30, 40 Bitcoin volume in a day, just laughable. [00:22:09] It's way up now, and we were watching this stuff, but no one and we and we were talking about sovereign reserve assets, central bank reserve assets, right? We I'm sure there were people talking about it, but it was not a broadly discussed narrative, the corporate reserve asset narrative. [00:22:27] Yeah. I mean, there's something in there. Go ahead. I was gonna say my opinion here is that the biggest thing is we had COVID, and that's gonna force people to reevaluate, check in, you know, it's not business as usual anymore. So a lot more people are just generally doing a little inventory, a little house cleaning. [00:22:48] And at the same time, the whole buy Bitcoin thing has been de-risked tremendously in the last couple years. And you know, people listening to this podcast know the names, but you know, the Paul Tudor Jones and the Jax and all these guys, they made it okay, right? And so as soon as reputation flips, now all of a sudden it always made sense. [00:23:10] We just didn't think anyone would pull it off, and now the reputation risk is gone. To me it could be just that simple. I think it also, you know, it was definitely a like a confluence of circumstances, you know, like someone like Michael Saylor probably having having a lot more free time these days, being you know, stuck on you know on his boat with nothing to do but figure out how to save his business, you know, in terms of their purchasing power. [00:23:31] And so I don't know. The other thing though is like when we talked about institutions, we were talking about like big institutions, multi-trillion dollar endowments, blah blah blah blah blah. You know, and I think for whatever reason, we just didn't think about the more middle players, and they're still gigantic, you know. But like how many publicly traded companies are there? [00:23:50] How many of them have have cash on their balance sheet? You know, like it was sitting there right, you know, it was right in front of us, and maybe maybe it was COVID, you know. Like I think this is what we needed a few people like Michael Saylor to kind of get it going, and now we're here. When Apple Ryan, Ryan's asking when Apple. [00:24:09] And that's a good question, right? Who's next? I tweeted this out today, right? There's there's limited real estate on the blockchain, it's getting more and more expensive. Who's next? Is it gonna be Apple? Is it gonna be Facebook? I don't think it's gonna be Facebook. I think I think Mark has a thing, you know, doesn't really get Bitcoin or even has perhaps a chip on his shoulder about Bitcoin because the winkle vibe, like and run did an end run around him and took you know the 80 million dollars of Facebook stock and turned it into two billion dollars worth of Bitcoin, and you know, it's gonna be a trillion at some point and you know like that that story didn't end [00:24:48] Well for for Mark and I don't think he I don't think he likes that too you know like what nothing's happening with Libra so it's like what's he gonna do but on the flip side like he isn't a dumb guy as much as he might be an evil guy. And so at some point he will have to face the facts that Bitcoin is what it is and you know it's probably a good idea for them to get on board rather than try to fight it. [00:25:12] Yeah I see two narratives driving corporate adoption and the first is that it's economically rational and that's what Saylor did. And after finding out it's economically rational he became pretty ideologically motivated which is just a nice byproduct not everyone's gonna do that. And then you have Jack coming out and saying Square's gonna dip their toes in and their corporate language was around this is good for the planet this supports our corporate mission of open finance or inclusive finance around the world and that's an entirely different strategy. [00:25:45] And so the apples and the Facebooks and the Googles they have so much money buying Bitcoin doesn't help them materially but maybe they would want to be positioned in a well that looks good from a PR perspective. And so I think those two different angles are going to be both you know those threads are both going to be weaved in through the discussions now. [00:26:05] And maybe there's more narratives I haven't thought about but I think those are quite unique and they're you know quite different. There's gonna be almost two different FOMO cycles there you know there's the economic incentive but you're I think you're right. Like how many companies out there are already political and you know supporting movements and things like that you know like when Nike realizes that Bitcoin is good for the world just do it Nike just do it [00:26:30] Yeah. [00:26:33] Laughing at my background thank you for laughing right how how do we find more Michael Saylors pre-Bitcoin like where are the Bitcoiners that are just hiding in their corporate clothes right now that's who we want to reach out to the predisposed power and we find the harbor where his yacht is and we go to each yacht next to the yacht we say repeat it knock knock knock have you ever heard of Bitcoin you're we've been talking we've been talking to Michael three boats down about Bitcoin and he's really into it. [00:27:09] You know can we can we talk to you about Bitcoin? Yeah I think you're you hit on something there Brandon that the big big companies the Apples, the Microsoft's Bitcoin's not going to move the needle for them, right? And so if they don't have an ideological objective like Square, you know, using the terms and the phrases economic empowerment in their press release like if they don't have that sort of imperative then yeah they don't necessarily need it. [00:27:41] They're sitting on tons and tons of cash and they can wait. They can afford to wait and see a year or two down the road if this thing really is still sticking around they'll still be able to buy 5000 bitcoins with like a small portion of their horde. But the micro strategies of the world right the second tier kind of publicly traded companies especially who are trying to survive in a world of inflation and you know watching smaller corporate treasury you know deflate i in value like that's that's where i think we're headed and small companies like snappa and tahinis right [00:28:20] Like they can't mess around like with their reserves there's that that's a larger threat to smaller companies inflation is over time you know and of things with bitcoin like a lot of some people bring up the idea of it being like a mass redistribution of wealth right and that worries some people but i'm not really that worried by it and i actually think it'll be a good thing because you're gonna see these people who have have a lower time preference and are smarter about the ways of the world adopting bitcoin and benefiting from it tremendously you know tahinis could [00:28:58] Be the biggest chain in the world in in five years right all the shoreman and micro strategy could be the new Amazon so I'm saying man microstrategy could be a behemoth slight tangent but around wealth redistribution there's a theory called the great leveler theory and that is essentially saying that the natural state of human society is that wealth gets concentrated and so if you think smart people who work hard they're better right so that naturally they're gonna get more money over time. [00:29:33] And this theory says the only way it gets redistributed is through cataclysmic events like plague, war, currency collapse, government failure, etc. And so it's almost just like we build up you know, wealth inequality rises and then something bad happens and we start over. And that that wave pattern sort of reinforces itself, right? [00:29:55] Like if it gets too bad, too in unequal, you have civil war or something like that. And so I think that's an interesting thought. And I don't know if we want to get into this now or later, Brady, but there's some interesting cycles being played out right now, according to some other theories. It's definitely let's definitely talk about the cycles. My first thought when you're talking when you're talking about this cycle of wealth concentration and then redistribution, is I wonder how much of that has to do with co-optable money, right? [00:30:26] Certainly plays a part, but how big of a part, right? Because if you can co-opt the money, it makes it way easier to concentrate the wealth, you know. And there are still other plenty of other ways that you can do that. Certainly, like you said, by just being better than everyone else, right? And like winning in 80, you know, network effects and winning an 8020 battle, and all that. [00:30:49] And certainly there's going to be wealth concentration without without money that's co-optable, you know, like Bitcoin. But I wonder how much of that effect is driven by you know money that can be co-opted and controlled by such a few number of people. It's gotta be significant though, because if you think about it, like look throughout history, whenever there were times of currency devaluation, like currency devaluation in those cases, it it always hurts the poor most because they are trying to save in that asset, right? [00:31:19] It's only the rich that can afford real estate and to buy a company and like store their wealth in ways that will survive through these transitionary periods. And so by getting onto a Bitcoin standard, I mean, that's part of like when people are like, oh, like they see that post on Reddit that's like, you know, Bitcoin's gonna destroy the world, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. [00:31:38] And I'm like, no, because if you look at, let's say we have a Bitcoin standard, it means everyone from the top to bottom is going to be able to earn in Bitcoin and save in Bitcoin. And so over time, I think the effects are gonna kind of melt away. At least I hope so. Yeah, I think there's always gonna be inequality, right? Because some people are more gifted, they work harder, luck, all those things. [00:31:59] But what Bitcoin does is it gives everyone a fair chance. It's equality of opportunity. The game is set, the game is fixed, it doesn't change, it's not hyper-politicized. And so people can hopefully just do a job, like create some value, and then the value that they create, they get to store. [00:32:18] And if they create a surplus, they maintain that surplus for their life, right? They're guarding that real estate on the blockchain versus the ice cube between their fingers. And I think that's important. There needs to be inequality also because there's going to be incentives, and whether we like it or not, the people that create the revolutionary scientific breakthroughs, inventions, companies, whatever, that risk that they take, most fail, but the ones who do succeed get outsized payouts, outsized returns in their life and their reputation and everything. [00:32:51] And then what happens is that value created ends up trickling down to everyone else, right? We have mobile phones everywhere on the planet, they're cheap now because someone did that in the beginning and took a risk and they should be wealthy for creating those things. I mean, that's the other thing is like equality, we should strive for equal everyone should have the same rights, in my opinion, you know. [00:33:12] But you look at the American constitution, which constitution decl declaration, it's the pursuit of life, liberty, and happiness, you know. You know, you can't ensure that for everyone, you know. You know, look at every socialist attempt to do so, it fails miserably. Because we need incentive to grow and to change and to build. And if there's no motivation, then we stagnate. [00:33:30] So [00:33:33] Agreed. Can't hear you, Brady. Oh, I'm still muted. What was the that was Michael was saying on Swan Signal yesterday? It was like everyone, every creature is at their best when they are being challenged. You know, the height of challenge. [00:33:52] So the more challenged you are, the better you are, right? We're anti-fragile. And Bitcoin is the same way. And you have to so you have to have that competition, right? Otherwise you just stagnate. You know, if you same same reason why, you know, when we used to be a nation dedicated to capitalism, you had you know anti-monopoly monopoly laws, which were interesting, like debate, right? [00:34:19] That's an interesting like government intervention. That was always to me. As a as a free market person, like how do you think about breaking up monopolies, which could bring about arguably inefficiencies and stagnation because there's no competition, right? [00:34:38] I mean, I don't know. I just it's it's one of those interesting questions that I've always like, you know, kind of it's a it's a conundrum if you're a free market person. But you also have to get into like what enabled those monopolies in the first place? Like, were did the Canteon effect enable them in the first place? Because if so, then you know we've never truly seen pure capitalism in this country, maybe at certain points over the in the aggregate. [00:35:02] I mean, I think the historic the most obvious historical example, Mob L, as it was called, right? Being broken up into regional companies. That was probably just straight up network effects. I don't know if they were doing anything illegal or not to like take over like mergers and acquisitions and underhanded dealings and stuff like that. [00:35:26] But that was one of the first network effect communications technologies that humanities had, right? That could really spread far and wide and have a really deep reach into the populace. So it really could have just been network effects, and we just hadn't seen that happen before to such an extent that you had this absolutely dominant monopoly that was crushing any or not allowing any competition to arise again. [00:35:55] Yeah, I think you touched on a really important point there. Both of you guys did, which is some businesses, some companies, whatever, they naturally turn into a monopoly. And that is the most efficient, right? Like Amazon is the most efficient because their supply chain is the most efficient, and it doesn't make sense to have two Amazons. [00:36:13] That's you know, that's something we have to deal with in free markets. I think it's as long as it's not being unfairly abused, it's good for most people. So we should call it a net win. But the other kind of monopoly, Brekkie, you were touching on is okay, now I'm a big company, I have deep pockets, I have relationships with the government, and now I help pass laws in which build a moat around my business so that startups can't actually compete. [00:36:39] And that's anti competitive. That's not that's not part of a free market. That that's actually very bad for individuals. And so trying to figure out a way, and I don't know if there's a way around this because if we live in a democracy, we're gonna have lawmakers, and those lawmakers are not going to know what is the best law, right? They can't be specialists everywhere, so they have to rely on industry to tell them how to make a law. [00:37:01] But the problem is I'll slip you 20 and you make my law versus the law that's best, and I don't know a way around humans, you know, we're kind of stuck there. Yeah, we can we can do our best. That's you know, this is why people libertarian. So well, so you know this kind of gets back to the idea of cycles, and I want to circle back to talking about the fourth turning. [00:37:25] But we can kind of get there through this idea too that government and democracies and governments in general go through cycles, right? And this this is the kind of the main idea, main thesis of the fourth turning is that we sort of build up institutions and then we tear them down, right? That's that was my takeaway and like the very high level takeaway. [00:37:44] And governments they they just get bigger, that's what they do, right? You just like you go in and you're there to legislate. That's like the default position. And you get elected and you have an agenda, and your default position is to, you know, pass your agenda, and that is almost always additional laws, right? [00:38:09] It's hardly ever let's get rid of these laws. That doesn't that agenda doesn't seem to win out over time in a democracy. There's a great quote from Thomas Jefferson that reminds that that I love about this. I don't know if you've heard it about that he talks about what needs to happen every 20 years. Have you heard this? It's fantastic. [00:38:28] God forbid we should ever be 20 years without a rebellion. The people cannot be all and always well informed. The part which is wrong would be discontented in proportion to the importance of the facts and misconceived. Anyway, basically they're saying that like they need a rev you need a revolution in the country every 20 years or so. [00:38:47] You know, and we've been resting on our laurels, and the system's been growing ever more complex and crazier and bigger. And you know, we haven't had that. This guy's one of our founding fathers, you know. So yeah, there was lots of wisdom that has been lost from the founding fathers about central banking too and the threats paper money, you know, as opposed to actually using the specie itself, the direct actual money to trade in. [00:39:17] And yeah. I would say we go back to cowrie shells, go back to cowry shells and glass beads, call them a day. Wampum. Another Jefferson quote, the tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants. That's the same. [00:39:36] Yeah, okay. And the fine the finishing line there is it's the natural manure. And I think that's an under underappreciated part of his point here, which is that it must be we must tear down and get rid of the old decrepit institutions so that we can rebuild. You essentially tilt the power away from the old and the people who hold the power, and you tilt the game board back towards the young and you know the where all the energy is, and then that gives them enough opportunity and excitement and optimism to go and rebuild the world with what we've learned in the last 50 to 100 years. [00:40:12] And I it does feel like we're coming to a head right now. I don't think anyone would disagree 2020 is the most interesting year in a long time. And so, you know, this is normal if we go back to the fourth turning, these 80 to 90 year cycles, they end in a crisis, and these crises are not necessarily bad. [00:40:31] This isn't a doom and gloom thing. It is a necessary process. It is the winter, right? We clear out the underbrush and we can rebuild again. And I think Bitcoin's coming to that point right now where we have these cyber hornets around the world. And like, yeah, of course, that's and the Bitcoin mushrooms grow up from the mycelium. [00:40:54] I don't know how I missed that opportunity. Thanks for thinking about us, Greg. But what I was gonna say is Bitcoin has a lot of challenges left, a lot. Like the incentives are right, we all believe it's going to win, but it's not like we're going down a slide into the kitty pool. We're we're we're increasingly coming across larger challenges. [00:41:14] And Bitcoin on its own can't do this. What does this is a decentralized network of individuals who really give a shit about this and who are willing to I don't want to say spill blood, like I'm not gonna go whatever, I don't need to get into that. But point is we're gonna have to fight some big battles here in order to keep Bitcoin what it is and to get it through the finish line, essentially make it too big to fail. [00:41:38] I like this this pool metaphor. It made me think, you know, what are we as Bitcoiners doing in this pool? You know what we're doing? We're pissing in the pool. And if enough of us start pissing in the pool, they can't do anything about it. I'm still working on the metaphor. I don't know if it actually works. I'm not sure that's one that's gonna take off, Rick. [00:41:57] But yeah, sorry. Maybe, maybe if you keep working on it. Yeah, yeah. So let's talk about these 80, 90 year cycles. And Neil Howe. Let's dive into it a little bit more. Let's talk about the generational changes, the archetypes of the different generations. All this stuff is really interesting. [00:42:16] And it's especially interesting now because we are at the fourth turning. And that's probably the most interesting cycle, at least at least to my mind. So they're all interesting in their own ways. But yeah, Brandon's been studying this quite extensively. I've read the book as well. [00:42:35] Give a quick overview for me and the Yeah, definitely will. I was just gonna say that Brandon has been work studying it very closely. He is working on a piece, so his next opus will be inspired by Neil Howe's fourth turning. So if you want to kind of give us a summary. [00:42:54] Yeah, so I think the best way to give a summary is just to rewind to the previous cycle so we can kind of juxtapose two periods of time to show how they're related. And so the previous fourth turning, which is the last quarter of this 80 to 90 year cycle, it started in 1929 with the stock market collapse. [00:43:12] So you've got 1929, the Great Depression, FDR and the New Deal, leading right into World War II, and then after World War II, we essentially rebuild the world. That's NATO, IMF, UN, World Bank, Bretton Woods, everything, all the institutions got re-architected. [00:43:33] And then after that fourth turning period, you go into the high. And so that's like the first quad, first quarter of that 80-90 year cycle, which is when okay, we just built all the things, we re-architected it, inequality goes down. Generally, people are happy and content. We invented suburbs, then, and we took a lot of wealth from old people and gave it to young people. [00:43:55] And you know, then you have that period where the external world's nice, but we're all kind of sterile, and it's the white picket fence, it's the leave it to beaver type time. And what happens then is the young people they grow up in this time when everything's so rigid that the interior world is bankrupt. And so the young people create a revolution in the second turning. [00:44:15] That's the conscious revolution, that's African-American rights, that's civil rights, that's all that kind of stuff in the 60s and 70s. And then after that, those young people who are very ideologically motivated, the boomers, they grow up and become yuppies. And they try to convince the whole world that it's all about just being an individual, and so individualism's high. [00:44:36] Then we go into the third turning, which is also called the unraveling. That's sort of like the getting's pretty good still. And nobody really cares. Culture sort of decays, individualism's high. What was that? Like the high time preference 80s, like extremely high time preference. [00:44:56] Yeah, yeah, where the boomers don't raise the Gen Xers, so they become these weird latchky kids, and then the millennials are sort of a backlash to that. We're like, well, the kids are horrible, we have to overparent the next generation. So the millennials are 13th place ribbons, and we're all leaders or whatever. [00:45:15] And then we go back into the fourth turning, which started in 2008. Again, that the analog would be 1929. So we have this shock, and all of a sudden people go, Whoa, like we've been asleep, what's going on? And you start to see culture change. And what's scary in fourth turnings is the people start to in order to make these large changes, we do have to centralize power. [00:45:38] And so every time throughout history, these fourth turnings, you see flirting with totalitarianism, populism, McCarthyism in the 30s, etc. And so we're entering that period now, and you can kind of see culture doing that-the cancel culture. If you're not with us, you're against us. Populism on the left and the right, all over the world we're experiencing this. [00:45:59] And so it's sort of that period where we have to get together to make a change, but we do need to be extremely mindful because fourth turnings don't always turn into a good period next, right? It could be fantastic next, or it could be pretty bad. And so previous fourth turnings are World War II, civil war, the American Revolution, etc. [00:46:21] Etc. And they almost they all end in war. Now the question becomes is COVID the unifying force that's strong enough to gal like galvanize the whole population to make a change, or are we gonna have some other conflict coming up here, whether it's American civil, a second American Civil War, conflict with China or Russia. [00:46:41] I don't know the answer to that. But I six months ago I thought COVID was going to be big enough to re-architect. Now I think that we have another kind of a larger conflict coming, and if we believe the this theory is more or less true, we probably around 2030 is when we'll exit this and move into a new period. [00:47:00] So I'm planning as if we have another decade of chaos, and so you know, we can talk about ways that I think make sense in the chaotic period to prepare yourself. But that's probably enough for one monologue. Yeah, that was my assessment as well that we're sort of at the beginning of the fourth turning here, we've got another decade to go. [00:47:22] There will be surprises, obviously. There is so much Tinder out there, right? And right, and who knows which spark like you know, which piece of tinder or pile of tinder is gonna get sparked and then sort of spread to the rest. [00:47:42] COVID is certainly a spark and I think is kind of set set ablaze the central banking policy tinder box. A lot, you know, it's it's the that one is catching fire a lot faster than I think it would have. [00:48:02] And so yeah, we're overcommitted. I think some like an outcome of that could be like, you know, more monetary socialism, more socialist ideas like UBI, directly, you know, a Fed coin coming sooner than later, money going straight from the Fed. [00:48:20] So the Fed like the Fed basically takes control of the dollar. They also become the fiscal arm of the money control. So they're both both parties that legislatures don't have any control over the f or fiscal spending anymore, basically. They have to go to the Fed to get the money. And the money goes straight from the Fed to s American citizens' accounts and American citizens have accounts at either regional Fed banks or the Fed reserve itself, the central the Central Federal Reserve. [00:48:53] I think that's happening a lot faster, right? That's coming. So that's one of them. That's one of the things I think has been sparked by COVID. You know, the other trends as well, right? Like that are gonna shake up the way corporate America works. I think that was a part of the Tinder that was sparked by COVID as well. [00:49:15] So yeah, those are some some things I see coming. There'll be other surprises. Got a question. Brandon, in your research, when these events happen, have you looked and seen whether they had sound money or not sound money at these times? Because you know, my natural state is is bullish Bitcoiner. [00:49:34] And so every what here in hearing this, the first thing that popped into my mind was, well, now we have Bitcoin though, so maybe it'll be different. Yeah, so that's a good question. And I think that's probably one of the first criticisms people have, whether it's the introduction of Bitcoin, would that stop these cycles, or now we have social media, so the rules are all changed or whatever. [00:49:56] And from this thesis, they would actually come the opposite way, and they would say the people at the time create the mood, and that mood is is the primary force here. And what what I mean by that is let's say we create new technology or an event occurs. That event alone, you know, that event alone, it doesn't matter. [00:50:19] What matters is our response to that event. And so for a tangible example, in 1917 they sunk the Luftanza, and we didn't want to go to World War One, right? We dragged our feet for four years, and it wasn't until they like I forgot I forgot exactly what happened, but the Germans were bombing our commercial ships and we said, all right, shit, I guess we're going to World War One. [00:50:39] Yeah. That was in the third turning. That's when there's not motivation, the mood is not right to go to war. However, in in Pearl Harbor, we went to war within 12 hours. Like it happened, and then the next day we went to total war and everyone was on board. And so I think I think the same thing with Bitcoin, where it's not gonna change these fundamental human cycles, but it it is a large player in the next cycle. [00:51:04] Like theoretically, like I think I haven't written this part of the paper yet. Like, how does Bitcoin play out in the end of the cycle? But I have a feeling that if we have another decade before we're sort of settling the dust of this transition, Bitcoin might actually be ready and needed to be a large player in the global financial system, like backing central banks. [00:51:26] And if it happened in two years, I don't think there's a chance Bitcoin's ready, but if it happens in 10 years, I think Bitcoin might actually underpin the financial system. Yeah, I mean that that makes sense. It's with the whole philosophy, right, of the cycles. We tear down central banking and rebuild it with a new institution, Bitcoin. [00:51:51] We're just gonna centralize all the power in Bitcoin instead of fascist institution. Decentralize all the power in Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, yeah. [00:52:06] What like what are the archetype of the kids who are growing up now? First of all, I'm tired of these boomers running the political show. All right. So again, we're choosing between two like 70, you know, 78 year old men, and the boomers have had their run. [00:52:26] Like even Obama was on the young end of the boomers, right? Yeah, so you know, we this is part of the fourth turning, right? See, Brandon, like generations basically that like this hero, is it the hero generation that the boomers are? Is that what they think they're part of? The boomers are actually the prophet. [00:52:46] If you want, I can give a quick rundown of that. Yeah, the prophets, the heroes, the yeah. So the thesis says there's there's four archetypes and they repeat in the same order each time. So it'll go prophet, nomad, hero, artist, profit, nomad, hero, artist, like that. And what how the mood is set is at which stage of life those different archetypes are at. [00:53:10] And so right now the boomers are in in power, they're the old people. They're controlling politics, essentially. And the prophet archetype is the most ideological. So they're stubborn. If if we don't agree on our on our politics, we can't be friends. And that's it particularly explosive because the millennials are the quote hero generation. [00:53:33] So we're the ones who go to war. We're the ones who take orders from our gray champions who have these strong ideals, and we're and the millennials are like, we have to do what needs to be done, and we sacrifice for the greater good. And so that's that's why it's so explosive is you have ideologues and then you have people ready to take orders and centralize. [00:53:53] The other two archetypes would be the Gen Xers or the nomads. They're kind of the bad boys, they're the they always they always do the hard thing, but they never get credit. And they're the ones who when we go to war, they'll be like the badass general who does the horrible thing that no one else is willing to do, but it needs to get done. [00:54:12] And then the young people now are the artists, and the artists are the kids who grow up during a crisis, and so they witness all this chaos. They're sheltered, they live internal, they're pretty meek, and they grow up to be like very contemplative and just sort of like in the background giving good advice. [00:54:33] We've seen it and we're empathetic. But it's the real big things are when the millennials come of age, crisis, that's now, and when the boomers come of age, we have a consciousness revolution or a religious resolution. And those are essentially times when we re-architect the inner world. So the ideologues change culture, music, rights, politics, and then the outer world is all the institutions. [00:54:57] Damn. And you can see it playing out. Yeah, right? Yeah. 500 years over and over and over the same cycle. I didn't want to believe this. I it's not astrology, it's not like hyper-predictive, but these themes play out, and what's interesting is they're so human. [00:55:16] It's an emergent, it's an emergent thesis, which is that we're millennials, let's say, so we all grew up roughly at the same time, and we're all parented by people who grew up similarly. So our parents parented us the same, and then we grew up all in the same time, so we share an identity, and that cycle is symbiotic. [00:55:36] It's essentially history, so the times create the generations, and then the generations grow up, and then they create history. So history generation, generation, history, it's just that same cycle. And each archetype is important, it's not like heroes are good, heroes are in collectivists, right? [00:55:57] But there's a certain point where we become too individualistic that culture decays, and then the collectivist people say, Well, we should probably work on our institutions because they actually have some benefit. And if we get too rigid there, we have no internal life, and so yeah, they all just sort of keep the cycle going. [00:56:15] Right. The world's a wild place. So yeah. I mean, the sense that we all have that it's a crazy time. Is I guess predicted by this sort of generational cycles in this book. [00:56:34] So check out Neil Howe. And Brandon's gonna publish this piece. I'm excited about it. I would love the dream, the dream is to get Neil Howe on with Brandon to talk about this stuff and really get into the weeds and the details and talk about what the next 10 years might look like based on these cycles. [00:56:58] I'd love to hear his predictions. Brandon, tell us how tell us what your predictions are since you've been thinking about this and how you are preparing. Yeah, so quick quick thing before I do that. On Neil, he he works for Hedgeye, the same company that Keith, I think Keith McCullough, who had some controversial thing, he sold his Bitcoin, whatever. [00:57:19] Generally speaking, that group is not super bullish on Bitcoin. And what one of Neil's things, he made a video in 2017 saying why Bitcoin doesn't fit in with the thesis. And one of the things is that millennials are the collectivist generation, and so in that environment, we want strong institutions, and that's typically a political structure. [00:57:42] So we'd rather have the central government dictate who gets money, we all get UBI, right? That'd be a very millennial idea. And so when we're pitching Bitcoin to millennials, I think it's important that we realize that by and large, millennials don't want to separate money from state. They wonder why that would even be a good idea. And so I'm not fully forming these ideas, but my sense is that the millennials will appreciate the fact that Bitcoin is owned by the users, right? [00:58:08] It's not 12 guys with white hair pulling the strings for the whole world's economy. It's everyone's consensus. And so I think just Bitcoiners out there be mindful on how you pitch millennials, I think that will land better in the masses. It's funny because there are two sides of the same coin, but you got to show them the right face of the coin, yeah. [00:58:28] 100%. You're not changing Bitcoin, you have you have to do anything, you just the framing. So the this idea of consensus, right? Like, I mean, these ideas, the ideas of socialism are seem to be more widely held in the millennial generation, right? And is this part of the like reliance on the institutions, trusting in the institutions that you're talking about here? [00:58:52] So yeah, so I get it what you're saying. Like, so they want to build consensus, they want to you know, find find a way for everyone, like equity through institutions, basically. So if Bitcoin is an institution, we could call it like consensus money or something like that, right? [00:59:13] And talk about how the Fed is not really an institution so much as it is you know, a few guys who are operating without any consensus whatsoever. It's not a democratic institution, right? This is what we're like if you look at if you look at like communism and socialism, and like you look at why you look at history and you see that they they come back and they go away, they come back and go away. [00:59:39] I think there's a good reason for that, and that some of the ideals and the aspirations of these movements are not bad, you know. Oh, I want everyone to have health care. Who doesn't want everyone to have healthcare? That's that's great. But it's really it's about how you achieve these these these good things, you know. And what worries me is that you know, seeing the rise of socialism again, like the education isn't out there, the knowledge isn't out there, and it seems like we're gonna have to relearn these lessons all over again. [01:00:05] Sorry, doing gloom, but no, I think you're spot on with that. And I see this this cycle wrapping up with a fundamental debate between individualism and collectivism. I think that's sort of the theme of this crisis. And the previous theme was capitalism versus socialism. [01:00:25] And I think going isn't there, I can't remember who said it, but there was a it's like a way to understand where these philosophies have a place. And it was like, you know, at the world level capitalism, and then it goes down to like the so like the community level socialism, and then it's communism at the family level or something, you know what I mean? [01:00:44] And it it I forget what that quota was, but it's yeah, it's it's like a way to live, it's a way to view the world, right? And it's it's decreasingly socialist, right? So from the top down or increasingly socialist from the top down. Which yeah, it makes sense. Like you want to share everything with your family, and you know, with your community, you are more willing, you know, these people, you have skin in the game with them, you're more willing to sacrifice for them, help them out, use you know, spend your time supporting them, etc. [01:01:17] Yeah, and then as you go further out, then it's like you know, you don't have those relationships, right? So you need to use like modes of society that are you know, like Bitcoin, where it's it's can it's can it allows consensus without trust, right? Which creates the ability for us to trust people without knowing them at all. [01:01:39] That's why Bitcoin can scale so far, social scalability, right? That idea from Exabo. Brandon, what's the difference between socialism and capitalism and individualism and collectivism? Because I would think think that like those are closely related, but what's the nuance there? Yeah, I don't have a probably a great answer here, so I'll just stumble through my initial thoughts. [01:02:01] But I think the socialism capitalism is like how do we run our economy? Like, do we want more free markets or do we want the state to run the economy? And I think individualism and collectivism is much more of a cultural thing. And I think that they're they're practically the same fight, but with just different skins. [01:02:19] And so this feels more like a culture war, right? We're we're debating about speech, we're debating about how to be and yeah, just like general cultural things. And it comes after a time of cultural decay in in the 90s and early 2000s, and so we're sort of trying to remedy that and realize that we got off the rails culturally. [01:02:40] And I think you made a strong point there, Brady, that Bitcoin actually is an institution, or it could be viewed as an institution. And so when we are rebuilding, do you want to you want to rebuild with institutions that are again run by old white guys, old white guys? Or do we want an institution that increases our social scalability above that way to architect humans? [01:03:03] And so I think that's that's probably the most important point here is that we're gonna move to a period where protocols replace people in those in those institutions, and that that allows us to build way taller. It's like building a steel skyscrapers, which can go really high versus wood, which is three stories, you know, whatever it might be. [01:03:24] Like let's rebuild the institutions from steel and see how high we can build society from that. I love this this idea as of Bitcoin as an institution, as like a new type of institution. It's really it's pretty powerful, you know. Like institutions like allowed us to go from you know hunter-gatherer tribes to actually having civilization, but you know, there were flaws. [01:03:46] So now we're improving on those flaws, and who knows where what we can build once we do that. Exactly. Back to Brady's favorite theme of the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. You need massive upgrades to our institutions if we're going to call in something like that. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I do like this idea too, is that a new the new idea of institutions are based on decentralized consensus building. [01:04:12] And if you think about it, like monarchy moves and like autocracy moves from and then the shift to democracy is from decentralization, right? A movement toward decentralizing governance. But it's still, especially when you grow it to the scale that it is now, you know, is like what 10 million people at the beginning of you know you know the when the constitution was ratified to 350, 370 million people now, and you try to scale those ideas, it's not it all of a sudden becomes way [01:04:50] Less decentralized than it was than it was before. I mean, we're not even in a direct democracy, like we always call ourselves democracy, we're in a representative republic or democratic republic, which I don't think accomplishing what what the founding fathers set out, thought it would. Oh, certainly not. Certainly not. [01:05:08] Yeah, I mean, it's become more and more centralized, obviously, over time, and part of it is because we've grown just the number of people, and we're not increasing the number of representatives, but also because the you know the federal government has just become so much more powerful than the state governments, and that's not the way the constitution was set up, right? So we've we've slowly centralized, but we have these institutions like Bitcoin that are can't be can't be centralized. [01:05:33] Like we're much more resistant to it, right? Than democracy is. [01:05:41] And so you start with the money. What comes next? Like what other protocols can we use to achieve decentralized consensus, right? [01:05:49] How does this affect the way we govern ourselves? I have some I have some thoughts, but I'd love to hear what you guys think. Like, how does Bitcoin change the way we govern ourselves? It's interesting because I think then we might kind of get into like the territory of like decentralized governance, like like voting mechanisms, things like that, and which I'm not sold on at all. [01:06:12] Like I think they're flawed. I think you know the only things that blockchain is generally good for are things that are endemic to the blockchain, which are like bitcoins. So I don't know. Like these are issues of human failings, you know. Like we have humans have faults, humans are greedy, you know, and when you centralize power, you know the greed comes up. [01:06:32] So I don't know. I don't think we can fix everything. I know. [01:06:43] Yeah, what what I see here is that like long long term, the large epic nation state, and I'll go in the sovereign individual. That large nation state, the incentives for that are just slowly declining. And we can speak to defensive technologies like cryptography or Bitcoin or whatever. But essentially what this allows us to do is empower the individual, which is fundamentally a good thing because individuals who have freedom and left to their own devices will create value because it's in their best interest, and that value spills over to everyone else. [01:07:16] And so optimistically, this next period will be a time of reinvigorating the individual, getting out of the individual's way and letting them create in a way that is culturally accepted in a socially responsible society. So we essentially need to convince the collective collectivist side that doing what's best for an individual is actually ultimately what's best for the group. [01:07:39] And those risky taking individuals, they shoot the moon and we all benefit from it. And it again, Brekkie, same thing, same side of a different coin. It's it's about framing and it's about the nuance here. But I think that's the most optimistic we can be here is atomize the state because we've outgrown it, and we need to outsource the protocols instead of people. [01:08:02] That's how we outgrow the state. And money obviously is an easy one that that pulls on a lot of different things. And you can also say identity, we can be pseudonymous online, we can be citizens of anywhere, we can own second passports, we can move our capital, you know, disincentives for war because you don't get any money by taking over the other guy. [01:08:23] Yeah. One of the hurdles to this though, and you said something that that resonated with me was the idea that if you know people will do what's in their best interest, and the one problem I see there is that people don't always know what's in their best interest. And I'll take an example from like the idea from ideas and meditation and like understanding happiness. [01:08:47] And I operate on the belief that I think every single human being on the face of the earth now and forever wants to be happy. If you're not, then there's something there's a chemical imbalance with something wrong. But the problem is we don't always know what makes us happy, you know. Like part of this is that you know, greed is a good thing, I think, but understanding what real greed is in terms of actually benefiting the individual, you know, accumulating as many things as possible isn't necessarily going to make you happy, like helping others will make you happy, but to understand that that takes another level of thinking. [01:09:21] And so Bitcoin might help us achieve a more low time preference way of thinking, which could result in these shifts of attitudes in terms of what is important in life and what we should be doing and what is actually good for me as an individual. So I think you're right, but you know, there's a there's a row, there's a hurdle there that we got to cross. [01:09:41] And yeah, I see the individual seeking wealth or power or you know, potentially bad motivations as a way. Like it's it's a necessary thing and it's always gonna be there. And the difference with Bitcoin versus non Bitcoin is in a fiat's fiat system, if the inventor, creator, whatever world builder creates something new, only a small percentage of that value actually trickles down to the people and society. [01:10:13] And in it in a Bitcoin standard, if money is less politicized, I think that there will be a greater socialization is the wrong word, but like the benefits of new technologies and new innovation will actually be more spread out around the world instead of being siphoned away by parasitic state and middlemen. [01:10:32] So I have one more question then. [01:10:37] I can see that playing out, but to me it seems like a sovereign individual future where the you know the rise of the individual, it seems more achievable or more possible in a world that isn't where there isn't as much power that's concentrated. You know, like I could see power of the state weakening in the US or in you know on a lot of the Western nations, but like I don't see China giving up their you know, letting go for a very long time. [01:11:02] You know, how does how do you see that playing out? Like, well, I don't know an expert on Chinese society, but like I feel like they are a very collectivist-minded people, you know, you know, very many. So yeah, I would I would point to it, we just have to zoom out here. [01:11:21] Like the sovereign individual looks on very long timescales. They say we entered the information age in like the early 80s or something like that. And so on that type of timescale, we're speaking generations. Will will we go into this full-blown cyberpunk anarchists, libertarians, microstate world in our life? [01:11:40] Probably not. But what we're doing is we're already witnessing the trends. Like you can go buy a passport wherever you want now. If you have not wherever you want, but the opportunities are are ample. And you see people being more like I'm in a citizen of the internet, I don't identify with my state. Already, if you have Bitcoin, it's not going to be easy to seize our communication we can hopefully keep private. [01:12:02] And so, yeah, I think we're just trending the right direction. But you know, I would speak to generations. Maybe the next fourth earning will actually fracture. I don't know. Well, our grandkids figure it out. There you go. There is a lot of momentum, right? [01:12:22] Inertia of the of the massive states. And if you look at Corey has turned me on to this guy named Peter Zihon, and I'm just started reading his latest book, Disunited Nations, and he talks about you know how we're sort of we're at the end of globalization. [01:12:43] United States is withdrawn basically from you know military, essentially withdrawing the military, you know, there's still skeleton forces out there and stuff, but like so there are vacuums of power, right, around the world that are going to be filled by regional powers, and the United States has all the demographic advantage. [01:13:09] We now have oil independence. That was kind of the big last thing that was sort of a security risk for the United States on a on a national level, that we were willing to go to war over. We don't have that incentive anymore. And we are we you know, just geographically sort of in a perfect situation. [01:13:30] We have you know a good demographic match with Mexico in terms of like the age of the populations, et cetera. And so we have a naturally good trade relationship there. We're on good terms with Canada. And we're gonna see a re-shoring of a bunch of American, you know, production, basically, especially electronics production. [01:13:57] And this is happening already. And so, yeah, we're gonna see like we have there, the fracturing that's happening now is the there's de-globalization and this idea called globalization, which is combination of globalization and localization. And so it's what's interesting is we're still all connected globally. [01:14:17] So we're not like in isolationist sort of trends in the past, like where you really become a lot more isolated. We have technologies now that still unify us globally, like the internet, for instance, communications technology. Now we have Bitcoin, which is a global borderless money that will unite us. [01:14:38] So we can build these like local, you know, like atomic or atomized sort of societies. And that's to me, sort of the natural human state, right? Like what's the name of the idea that you know you only have like a hundred Dunbar's number or something like that, right? [01:14:57] Dunbar's number, like 150 people. Or something like that. Yeah, right. So you know, it allows to like scale Dunbar's number, you know what I mean? So we can still all be connected, but we can still have these little societies and live sort of this way that we have evolved to live, and we naturally sort of want to live, but still be connected and in and trading and have a lot of the benefits of globalization, but having localized society. [01:15:26] So it's a really interesting trend, I think. George Washington has an awesome quote, kind of mimicking the period that I think we're gonna enter in now, which is he said the great rule of conduct for us in regard to foreign nations is in extending our commercial right relations, but to have as little political connection as possible. [01:15:47] So let's trade, but let's not be tangled up in this web of allies, like essentially how we got into World War II. And Yeah, let's just be economic trading partners. And if if there's no money to be stolen from war, then what's the incentive to go to war? [01:16:07] Like, okay, some companies make money on the back of war, but generally war is massively unprofitable for the planet. So let's stop doing that. And now that it's less profitable, maybe we'll be able to. [01:16:22] And the fact that the US actually is self-sufficient now, to Brady's point about not needing to go proxy war in the Middle East to secure oil, that's actually massive. We have no incentive to go elsewhere besides trade. And so that what if we do enter a period of peace and you know, like America first type thing here. [01:16:42] Maybe we don't go to a next civil war here. It's I mean, it's possible. I never I didn't think peace in the Middle East would ever be possible. And if you look at what's happening now, I mean, like I saw I was watching something on I watch mainstream news every now and then just to see what the enemy's up to. But they did a great piece on on the like the burgeoning diamond trade between the United Arab Emirates and Israel, you know, and Israel has been the economic powerhouse in the region forever, or for a while now. [01:17:10] And you know, I kind of always hoped something like this would happen, but you know, when you become economically interdependent and help each other, and the val everyone the value created goes up everywhere, you know, this is exactly what happens. You see that war just doesn't make sense. So it might happen. I'm optimistic. [01:17:29] We'll probably see regional wars as if we go through a period of isolationism. Think about the countries who don't produce food or energy. Yeah, they're going to war. And I don't know a way around that. I don't know if America's role is to play world police. I think it's gonna be less and less that. And so I think we're gonna have winners and losers like there always is in fourth turnings. [01:17:50] And it's gonna be d unique, at least in our lifetimes, that America's not there waving the political flag from day one. Yeah, I think there's gonna be a lot less of you know, the America being the global police. Tearing down on the institutions, man, these global institutions, lack of loss of trust. [01:18:12] The WHO has gotten hammered, you know, in terms of trust. I think there's lots of other international institutions that are in the same boat. Yeah, so I think this has been a fantastic conversation, guys. Like you know, we jumped off on like this one sort of bullet point on an out like this brief outline that we made and turned into a really fascinating discussion about the future of society and you know, wrapping Bitcoin in there too. [01:18:45] Let's wrap up with this, Brandon, because I don't think we've heard this yet, but you said you had some ideas on how you're preparing for the next decade. Definitely. So let's just assume this is a period of chaos and uncertainty, and a lot of things are going to change. And so facing change and uncertainty, you want to be anti-fragile, right? [01:19:07] So, what can you do to make yourself like a duck's back? Water just flows right off of you. Couple things. One, buy Bitcoin, right? Bitcoin's your fuck you money, that's your cross your border money, that's your doesn't matter what my state does, I'm protected money. Water flows off of a swan's back much better than that. [01:19:28] I think you're probably right about that. That's one. Another thing is like consider being mobile. So if you and your family can find a way to get a second passport, great. Reduce your risk of your nation state having problems. Okay. Another thing, since we're in a culture war, don't be cancelable. [01:19:48] And how how do you can you do that? Number one, you can try to stay out of the cover fire, but you know they're hunting people down. So I would say a better method is stay away from the political nonsense, but also don't be economically tied to a something that can be canceled. So if my job is cancelable because I tweeted something bad in college, that's not a very anti-fragile position. [01:20:11] So maybe get a side hustle, maybe work for a company that you know allows you to be an individual, whatever that might be. Another one that Bitcoiners gonna like is find like-minded people, right? You're you're weak on your own, doesn't matter who you are. And so relying on a like-minded community is super helpful. [01:20:30] The Citadel idea and also just having Bitcoiners to bounce ideas off of. Being able to defend yourself with a firearm or some other method, I think is important. Yeah, watch your debt levels. I think people on Twitter are talking about taking out cheap debt and buying Bitcoin as sort of a speculative attack, and there's actual economic justification for that. [01:20:53] But don't go into debt to where you know a short-term market cycle can wipe you out. Home debt and mortgage is okay, but you know, save some money, don't be crazy. That's probably enough. There's plenty more, but those are probably the most important ones. Food, food independence is a good one, right? [01:21:13] Like make connections in your in your community with food producers. If you can produce your own food as much as possible, you know, like even just a little garden can go a long way. We always, I mean, we have a vegetable garden that always produces more than we can eat, you know, and we're giving it away. [01:21:32] So yeah, find a find a butcher slash a rancher and make a connection with them for have a meat source. Find someone who can get you eggs and milk if you if you're into milk, and then grow some vegetables, and that's really all you need, right? A couple connections locally and then you know, grow some of your own food, and you're in good shape. [01:21:58] Anyone needs a bison guy? I've got a bison guy out in Colorado, good made DM. I'll put you up. [01:22:03] Grass-bred. It's just eating bison every day. [01:22:06] Bitcoiners need bison guy, all right. DM Burke. All right, gentlemen, thanks for this. Really appreciate it. We didn't even talk Swan, which is, you know, maybe we just needed a break because we're always talking Swan with each other anyway. So whatever. [01:22:25] I mean, there's cool stuff going on with Swan. There always is. We got we do have a lot of announcements coming up in the next like couple months. Kind of lined up to drop. So daily daily buys is is is out, it's working. And we have a list of a brand is running communications for us, so we have a list of people to email about daily buys. [01:22:47] So if you're on that list, be watching out over the next couple of weeks for an email, and you can switch over to daily buys. I'm stacking daily, it's awesome. Every day. I get a I get I can look at my little stack. It's it's not much. It's a it's a it's a modest daily stack, but it adds up. [01:23:10] Exactly. Stack hard or go home. Do you stack, bro? Do you stack? Oh my stack. Keep stacking, friends. Talk to you later. Thanks for watching live. If you did, there's a few of you that hung out and appreciate that. [01:23:29] Appreciate you. Greg, BTC Moon Guy. Mervin, appreciate you, man. Merv. Ryan Dracot, RD is hanging out. Nice. What's up, BGC Moon Guy? I want to talk to you, but I want to see you again, so come hang with us. [01:23:48] BTC Moon Guys, hey, he's got vet meet and veggie CSAs. That's a good that's a good hookup. He's been good. He's been watching a whole bunch of our streams and had some great comments. Yeah, BTC Moon Guy, you just watch Bitcoin stuff all day. You are living a good life, man. Getting those meet and veggie CSAs and consuming Bitcoin content. [01:24:08] That's sounds like a good life to me, bro. He's a great dude, too. Awesome. I may or may not have met him at some point, not to do it anyway. Brandon, we should do a new food pyramid where it's like, you know, a real food pyramid with meat and veggies and mushrooms and you know no grains and then bitcoin content as one of the foundation of any good diet. [01:24:33] Bitcoin content. Think about the food pyramid while we're just on this one little post script. The food pyramid was invented based on what we can produce, not based on what you should eat. Just kind of think about the incentives. I mean, you look at the like recommended like daily intake of carbs and for like 200 grams of carbs a day or something crazy. [01:24:55] Like you we'd all be like ginormous if we actually follow the food pyramid. What do you mean we all would be? Have you looked at America? Right, right. I appreciate that. People on Twitter are like, don't fat shame. And then the other people are like, no, no, we should fat shame because you're gonna save their lives so they get healthy. [01:25:18] Some fourth journey culture were there. Yeah. Don't get in the middle of it. Don't be cancelable. Or do, I don't care. See you guys next time. Alright, bye, guys. Bye. [01:25:43] Thanks to Brandon and Brecki for joining me today. You can find Brandon at B quitum, Q U I T T E M. And Brecki at B V B T C on Bitcoin Twitter. I, of course, am Citizen Bitcoin. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with your family and friends. [01:26:03] The bowl is coming. Get a Swan Force URL. Give your friends and family some free Bitcoin education and get them on board at Swan. Earn that referral credit. Stack sats for recruiting new Bitcoiners. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin, of course, for sponsoring the podcast. [01:26:22] Thanks to LTBN for helping spread the Citizen Bitcoin podcast around the world. Check out my merch shop at layer1btc.com. Shout out to Nick Ward, the great Bitcoiner and designer running the show over there. Click on partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. Lots of cool stuff to check out. And also check out Swan Signal Live, the show that I'm doing for Swan. [01:26:45] We pair up great guests for compelling discussions about Bitcoin and economics. This past week we had Danielle DiMartino Booth, a macroeconomic analyst and former Fed Insider. She wrote the book FedUp. She's fantastic, and Michael Saylor. So Michael and Danielle were on for the first hour of the show, and then we hung out with Michael for like another 40 minutes. [01:27:08] Cory Klippsten came on and we just nerded out on Bitcoin. It's a great episode. Check it out on the Swan Signal podcast feed, SwanSignal Podcast.com. And we're also at YouTube on YouTube.com slash swan signal. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to DM. I am at citizenbitcoin on Telegram as well, of course, at citizenbitcoin on Twitter. [01:27:29] My DMs are open. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.