Bitcoin's Governance / Social Layer and JPMCoin Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-02-28 [00:00:25] Hello, Bitcoiners, and welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. And today I'm back in the church basement with my good friend Tommy. [00:00:44] Yes, Tommy lives in a church. And we record the podcast in the basement of this old church. [00:00:50] It's a pretty sweet place and we have a lot of fun hanging out there and talking Bitcoin. [00:00:55] So today, Tommy and I talk about a little bit about JPM coin and rant about that at the beginning of the podcast for a little while. And then we get into Bitcoin governance, Bitcoin's social contract. Tommy and I go back and forth on whether or not there is such a thing and w what we should call it if there is. [00:01:16] So I think it's a fun discussion. And hope you all enjoy it. And before we dive in, just wanted to chill one more time. The lightning enabled e commerce site that I put up just for as a kind of a test to test out Lightning Network e commerce. It's at citizenbitcoin.shop. [00:01:36] Right now there's four emoji-based sticker designs. Of course, they're Bitcoin themed. Check those out. Probably throw up a couple of t-shirt designs just for fun. So check that out. The proceeds support the podcast, and if you buy the lightning torch sticker, the proceeds will go to support BTC Venezuela doing important work on the front lines, spreading awareness and adoption of Bitcoin where it matters most. [00:02:07] All right. On to today's episode. I am sitting in the church basement with my good friend Tommy. [00:02:26] Tommy, how's it going? It's going fantastic, actually. Except that it's a little chilly here today. Yeah, ready for springtime. But outside. Ready for the springtime. That'll be good. So what'd you think about the last couple episodes we've done since we have kind of branched off into doing interview episodes as well. [00:02:44] I found them extraordinary. I think it's a good good add on and I think it's I don't know I learned a lot from listening to them plus I just I think I thought they were very well done and I commend you for your interviewing capability. Thanks I thought you did very very well. I'm a noob when it comes to running interviews but I guess not so much of a noob when I when it comes to just talking about Bitcoin. [00:03:10] So I look at it I look at it more of just just a discussion than an interview I guess. Well that's true but remember how we started the you know what we started the podcast with the idea of I guess we said teach you know the way you know the you know the way you learn is through teaching I don't know how you ties to I guess while interviewing your your I don't know if you're exactly teaching it's like bringing in a guest lecture. [00:03:34] Yeah the idea is is to yeah it's it helps the process right in terms of learning. Well it they seem to have been a hit out there in Bitcoin land very much so I mean from the actual what you sent me on the on particularly on the results on Twitter. Yeah I'm gonna be talking to Peter measure it somehow right so that's right. [00:03:54] I'm gonna be talking to Peter McCormack next week actually the host of what Bitcoin did. That's fantastic. Probably the I don't know probably the biggest Bitcoin podcast out there at least in terms of subscribers and all that as far as I can tell. So I'm excited to talk to Peter fan of his work and kind of talk to him about how he grew his podcast into the force that it has become today. [00:04:15] So look forward to that one and working in you know in the background for a couple other cool interviews in the coming weeks. Tommy and I will continue to sit down and record our Bitcoin talks as we have for over a year now you know at least once or twice a month and it we will keep doing that as well and putting them out on the feed. [00:04:36] So what do you want to talk about today Tommy? Well I think we should talk about JPM coin a little bit maybe not too much but I think we have to speak to it and also go you were interested in JPM coin. Well I just was interested from well it's just from the standpoint of just the genesis of from the just the process of Jamie Diamond in terms of the who most people would know who is the CEO of the lead guy for JP Morgan and JP Morgan's also a member of the central US [00:05:14] Central bank as well so I can touch on it because I studied a little bit and so this is kind of the summary as to as to far as far as I as far as I see it. And the I guess the way I should say this and I don't want to spend too much time on it but JP JPM coin comparing it to Bitcoin is an insult to Bitcoin. [00:05:39] Sure that I mean that seems I guess obvious to me just because it's it's a corporate coin right so I mean it's not even it's not even the same thing like it's so you know completely centralized shit coin right and so what so what happened I and I noted this down I took this as part of a note but JP Morgan's announcement of a new digital token that it is referring to as a cryptocurrency has been met with wide ranging responses from Barons which which it it declared or on a headline said it was a fatal threat to Bitcoin through opinions that it's [00:06:17] Offering was a nothing burger as a cap as its capability already exists. So that's the range of what we're I mean ripple right I guess it I could see it being a threat to Ripple. Right. Or maybe Binance coin or something like that some other corporate coin. Right but I mean you know so so let's just so let let's just go through real quickly how how as we understand it first of all it's a pilot program and it's it's backed by it's backed by it's internal jp morgan accounts and the way we understand or I should say I understand it but I think we kind of talked through this already too a little bit so let's so if you want to use JPM coin [00:06:55] The way it works is is that you get approved as an institution because this is only institutional money right now or institutional accounts doing this you deposit if you get approved by JP Morgan you deposit US dollars into into an account of theirs and then you can receive jpm coins one one jpm coin per one US dollar and JP Morgan makes sure that that's the that's the exchange on it them independently that's how the how they do it so then if you want to use the JPM coin let's say you've got [00:07:33] A transaction which happens has to be with another JPM customer as we understand it on the pilot so you have to have to have another customer that's approved by JPM Morgan and let's say it's a it's a transaction where you're going to buy something and we'll just say just in the category of let's just you're you're gonna buy some securities or something say it's 10 million 10 million US dollars you can go ahead and pay 10 million jpm coins and the other party will accept those JPM coins and then that's that's as simple as how you know that's as simple as how it works within the system. [00:08:12] So what the hell's the point? Right. Why not just use the US dollar right and so well and then well the I the idea well the idea is the point is is that they're saying that they have a enterprise right an enterprise system it's called quorum yeah which is an like a fork of Ethereum I think they forked off Ethereum and created some kind of blockchain right yeah system baseline theory yeah so it's a it's a it's like a it's like a corporate version of Ethereum yeah and it's yeah well it's ERC it's let me up here a second here I hand it here it it's [00:08:50] What's it ERC20 so it's on it's no I don't think quorum is an ERC20. I think a quorum is actually like Ethereum. And then JP Morgan, their JPM coin would be like an ERC20 token, but it's on built on Quorum, which is like a private version of Ethereum. Quorum is an enterprise focused version of Ethereum. [00:09:08] Yeah. Quorum is ideal for any application requiring high speed and high throughput processing of private transactions within a permission group of known pers participants. Quorum addresses specific challenges to blockchain technology adoption within the financial industry and beyond. Right. So they're they built JPM coin on top of their private version of Ethereum. [00:09:30] Right. So this is just a centralized corporate. I don't I don't understand why they're using a blockchain. Why did they why did they build Quorum? Do they have any like any have they announced any benefits of using Quorum as opposed to some like SQL database or just some centralized database? Well, it here's what it says. [00:09:49] Trust is one reason why you use Quorum. The core innovation of blockchain is digital trust, provable and intrinsic to the system without reliance on external authority. Similarly, open source code can be transparently vetted and validated to ensure it does exactly what it says it does. [00:10:07] Well, it is cool that they're that they have it open sourced. Button is a good thing. But if it's all within the JP Morgan system, then it's only it it it you have to you have to trust ultimately have to trust JP Morgan. Do they who is validating the blocks on Quorum? Is it well signature validation? [00:10:27] Well well while signature validation in a permission network adds a piece of mind not present in autonomous networks. Quorum doesn't compromise on distributed block validation creation or a single chain architect architecture, it's the best of both worlds. Okay. [00:10:45] Well. I don't know what you know, you really don't know what that, you know, you really don't know what that means, right? I mean, if they have like a federation of block producers, sort of like liquid or like EOS, like liquid on the side chain to move Bitcoin between exchanges. There's a federation of like 14 validators, block validators, and that's you know, a step more trustless than a single entity validating blocks or or a centralized SQL database. [00:11:16] However obviously decentralized network is far more trusted. This is says what what experts and industry leaders say about quorum. And this is a quote. One of the key features we need for a blockchain to be used in enterprise settings is privacy. [00:11:34] Incorporating zero knowledge cryptography to quorum is a great step forward since it makes Ethereum a lot more suitable to build enterprise grade solutions. Okay. So they're not going to be able to do that. But but the quote, okay, is from Julio Fora, chair of the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance, right? [00:11:54] So I mean, if that's who's saying it, sure. So they added from Ethereum, and that's the quote. Well, of course they're gonna say that, right? Sure. So they added ZK Snarks like style cryptography, which is what Zcash uses. So that makes sense. [00:12:12] Cool. Well it sounds to me like it's have you seen that show, Mr. Robot by chance? It was on USA, I think. Yeah, I saw a little bit of it, but not a lot of it. I think one episode. Somebody told me Yeah, Mark Andreessen loved that show, I think, right? From 16Z. It's a great show. [00:12:31] There was a e coin or something, e Corp released their own their own coin called ecoin. This that's what this reminds me of. It's just a centralized corporate version of Bitcoin, which you know, like you said, isn't you know, comparing it to Bitcoin is an insult because it might use some of the you know technologies that have been developed or like based on Bitcoin or whatever, but it's if you don't have an you know distributed, decentralized network of validating nodes, then it's well the idea is as long as you're as long as you're a hundred percent comfortable with JP [00:13:09] Morgan, then and you're gonna go ahead and do these transactions, I right, I'm s pretty certain that they'd be a lot quicker, that'd be a lot more efficient, be a lot more from the back office standpoint, would be blockchains aren't more efficient or quicker than a centralized database. That's that's my point. Well, what I mean, what what well I guess what I'm saying is is my understanding that it is that it's quicker than the Swift system. [00:13:32] Okay. Except that, and again, this for our listeners, this is an area where where I should say more I don't know, I don't know, or I this is on the category of I think this is correct. But the idea on the Swift system is my my understanding is is they've done this some of this within the within the Swift network to make it quicker. [00:13:51] Because the whole idea where people talk about or mention, oh my gosh, if if you're gonna send if you're gonna send money from the middle of the United States through a bunch of banks overseas to you know Asia or something, just how how long that takes and the how costly it is and so on and so forth, instead of just having a system which this might be one where if you had somebody that both both parties at multinationals that were in this JP Morgan system, it it it could be really good, understanding that you'd have to understand up front that that you know it's it's it's completely centralized. [00:14:25] Right. Right. And it and the big difference between something like a JPM coin and or like a ripple and Bitcoin is the social layer, right? It's the fact that the governance of the social governance of those coins is completely centralized. [00:14:48] It's owned and operated by JP Morgan. I think it's cool that they're open sourcing their code for quorum, but they're you know, it's not like Bitcoin where anyone can develop and contribute to the bigger. Well, but the issue the well the th the issue with Bitcoin, if you're sitting there as a you know, and you need to make usually need to make money, right? [00:15:08] But I mean the issue with Bitcoin is it's all set up that that somebody can go ahead and utilize it as a mechanism to go back and forth without anybody, you know, you know, if you get if you get a supplier in China and a company in the US and you get it set up and they decide just to use Bitcoin, then they can just go back and forth with one another without any third party making any money any money off of it. [00:15:30] Permissionless and open. Right. Yeah, and so so that you know, so that's it's also a way of just they're having to figure out a way a way to continue to be a third party in these deals. I think another I think that's one of the main things is is that right? I mean, if you got comfortable enough with it, you could sit you start running pilots and say, okay, we're gonna go ahead and start start doing our our our trade transactions, you know, with just with Bitcoin, and we'll get some people internally and we'll just do it amongst ourselves and we'll just cut that we don't need anybody if we get comfortable with it, you know, that's a big issue, right? [00:16:07] Because a lot of people are very concerned the fact that you some folks want a third party. So if somebody in their organization screws up, they can go back and get the transactions reversed, right? So anyway, but that's part of it also trying to figure out how to you know how how to you know and I always used to like to use the analogy of automobiles, and I don't know if this is correct or not, but like the automobiles and the horses, right? [00:16:29] People in the horse and carriage business, I mean they wanted to continue to doing whatever they were doing in that business when autos were coming. And so, you know, you had a situation where some people were talking about breeding, you know, trying to breed faster horses, right? It's like sure. Yeah, keep their edge. The other kind of analogy that comes to mind is I don't know if that's a good one or not, by the way, it just comes to mind. [00:16:49] Is the open internet versus which would you know be like Bitcoin? Open and permissionless, anyone can build on it, anyone can use it. And JPM coin, which be which would be like AOL, you know, a walled garden that doesn't, you know, allow access to the open internet. It's this closed, centrally controlled version of the internet. [00:17:11] Well, that's what that's that's they're they're to the Morgan, you know, the Morgan Creek guys talked about, I think. I think Mark talked about that. It's a wall, you know, it's a walled garden. Yeah. And it's just kind of like okay. So how can you I mean in the end, how can that wall garden compete with you know open and permissionless? [00:17:30] Because there's gonna be a lot more activity happening on the open and permission system in the end of the year. Yeah, and so what what it what ends up happening with it is that is that it's kind of w we have this discussion right now that we're having this discussion, and why should we ever even bring it up again for the time being unless there's something else they come up with? Because it's just okay, so you're doing that, okay, fine, whatever. [00:17:50] It's it's substandard. So [00:17:57] We're talked about one of the big differences here being Bitcoin's social layer. It's it that it's the governance of it is completely open and distributed. Anyone can participate, it's permissionless. The ability to transact is open and permissionless. So we have been sending we I've been reading through an article by Hasu, which is called it was actually published in December of last year, December 3rd, 2018. [00:18:26] I missed it the first time around, but it popped up into a Twitter thread that I was reading and got some pushback from some people on on Bitcoin Twitter, and Hasu is sort of like mostly because of the using the pushback against the term social contract. [00:18:44] Which by the way, I'm I'm I'm a pushback. I'm well as we talked about this. I'm pushing back. I'm I'm kind of need to be convinced on that whole name for that and that concept. Sure, sure. So I brought that up to you. And I was like, here's an interesting article to read, and you're like, oh no, well, I have some qu I have some issues here. And so I thought it would be good for us to talk about. [00:19:04] I think it's great. Yeah. So the article is unpacking Bitcoin's social contract. It's on medium. And it is the second part in a series of three articles that Hasu wrote called that he calls the series the skeptics Framework for skeptics, a kind of a skeptics guide to Bitcoin. [00:19:24] The first post is about fiat money, so it's like an honest account of fiat money is what it's titled. It just basically looks at what fiat money is, what it what its strengths are, what its weaknesses are, and what you know the Bitcoin alternative. This is part two, and it's talking about what what Pierre Rochard would call Bitcoin's governance model. [00:19:49] Right. And I'll link to Pierre's article about Bitcoin governance as well, which I think is definitely informs or like gives some context to this article, and I'm pr and I'm sure that Hasu was you know had it in mind when he wrote this this article. So the basic idea is that there's an idea of the social contract, and the idea of social contract theory, which has been around for a while and in philosophy and political thought, right? [00:20:18] And the way to organize a sort of absolutely has been. Yeah. I mean, it goes all the way back to the Stoics. I mean, yeah, it absolutely has been. Right. And so the basics of a social contract theory is that you know there's an assumption that we start out in this hypothetical state of nature, which is unorganized and violent and unbearable for people to live in, right? [00:20:42] And so we have this desire to collectively improve our situation, and so we empower a sovereign government, or what's been called in in philosophical literature, a leviathan, to protect the people and kind of provide some order. [00:21:00] So the contract is we each give up some of our freedom while the state is granted the power to create laws and enforce them and protect people from violence. So we've granted this sort of monopoly on violence to the state. And then that creates another layer above like the ability to create sort of a legal framework, framework contracts and laws and so forth on top of this stable environment provided by the government because we've all given up the ability to be or the legal ability to be violent to the state, right? [00:21:36] And then you can have on top of that you know, markets and trade and so forth. But you kind of need to develop this stack of you know, up social operating system, sort of right to which is where I just you know I'm right, you know, which my like we've talked about which my point is is that the paper, the white paper established established kind of like the basic rules, right? [00:22:03] And the basic rules haven't been changed, right? I mean the basic rules are only the owner of a coin can produce the signature to spend it, which is compensate station resistance. Anyone can s transact and store value in Bitcoin without permission, censorship censorship resistance. There are only gonna be twenty-one million bitcoins on a schedule, inflation resistance, and all all all users should be able to verify the rules of Bitcoin. [00:22:27] Sure. So my whole point is is that that's kind that's the protocol. And then that hasn't been changed as far as I understand it. That ground piece protocol piece. Yeah. Now maybe I'm getting caught up. I just don't I mean that's I just don't like social. Hold on, I don't want to actually concede that point. Because it has like there have been attempts to change this, and every single altcoin is an attempt to change this. [00:22:50] I understand. The only the only thing that keeps but the only thing that keeps I understand those in place is not the fact that they're in the protocol layer, it's the fact that there is a social layer of node validating node operators that continue to run the software that produces these rules that enforces these rules. Well, I don't know, but see I'm caught up on the term social layer. [00:23:13] Okay. And maybe that's it. It's just I'm caught because I'm I'm sitting here saying these original rules are put in place, and maybe there's a been attempts to change it or whatever, but it has not is has not been changed. So this whole social layer But why hasn't it been changed? Because there's been plenty of proposals to change it. [00:23:32] Well, because the original p protocol that was that was written up by Satoshi Oko Nakamoto in the white paper was spectacular to the point where to the point where people can sit around socially and try to figure out how to break it, but they can't break it. So there's a point there's a there's a social consensus around the protocol. [00:23:54] I guess there is, but except that the protocol guy the protocol guy so that was the whole idea where we talked about protocol layer, right? Mm-hmm and social layer. Right. And if it's the protocol layer, it's a protocol layer. So how can you call the social the protocol layer the social layer? [00:24:12] So Hasu's idea is that there is a protocol layer that enforces the rules, right? Well, no, actually the protocol layer is the rules. Right. They are you don't enforce it, it it it is the rules. Same thing. I think that there's the what do you mean? What's the difference between enforcing the rules and is the rules? Well, it's just it's there. [00:24:31] You don't if it's there, you don't have to enforce it, it. It's just it's just there, right? Well, I think you can use the word the v the verb enforce because those the no the computers that are running that software is validating fair, totally fair. I agree. I agree. [00:24:49] Right. I agree. Okay. So it's enforcing and validating those rules. Okay. They exist. Now, there have been plenty of attempts to change these rules. I agree. I agree. So those proposals are made in in a society. Like in they're they're put out to other people. They're they're they're on Twitter, on Reddit, on whatever. [00:25:11] On the internet in general. They're made. These proposals to change Bitcoin. Like B cash. Sure. I mean, they they often end then result in either a fork or an altcoin. But why what why do those people have to resolve have to resort to a fork or an altcoin, producing an altcoin? Because the social consensus. [00:25:30] Because the original because the original protocol was so solid that they can't figure out how to get around it. It it wasn't it's not because it it's unhackable. That's not the point. It's not it's not unhackable. Well it's never Bitcoin's never been hacked. Right, but that's not what we're talking about here. Okay, what are you talking about? [00:25:49] We're talking about a consensus about what Bitcoin should be. What should the rules of Bitcoin be? Well, we already know that we already have We know what they are. We have the four rules. Right, but I think this is the point. This is the you need to separate the idea that there is a conversation among humans that that's ongoing about what Bitcoin should be. [00:26:17] Okay, and that conversation arrives at a consensus. And we've for in general in general have to be. You think there's a so there's a conversation going on that Bitcoin should be different something different than the original rules? All the time. There's all there's people that Well, yeah, like somebody will say they want to lift the lift the at the 21 million, right? [00:26:37] So there's a constant conversation. And then what happens to them is they just become Bcash or whatever. Okay. So how does how do these rules not change? It's it's I'm not sure. No, I'm not saying it's not about hacking. No, no, I don't hack it. No, listen. I've got it. Well, the other component I have to this is I understand what I would call tweaks and improvements with respect to the underlying protocol and system of Bitcoin. [00:27:06] Yes. All right. So I understand that. But those are more for my mind, they're more engineering improvements. Yep. And they're more hard science and don't have anything to do with this social. Let's set aside the core consensus rules, the four core consensus rules right now. Okay. How did those engineering up like improvements become agreed upon? [00:27:26] Well, basically what they as I understand it, it it's like, hey, this is this is what we're planning on doing, and it looks like a really good idea. It's not idiotic, and in fact it adds value, and you got people sitting around and going, like, you know what? Sure. Okay. And that's what that's what you're doing. So there's research that's done, there's a proposal that's made, there's a there's a Bitcoin improvement proposal that's written up, which is called a BIP. [00:27:48] Yeah. That's all formalized, and then it's that's implemented on the test net and whatever, able to be tested, thoroughly proven. And what I would call that is what I would call that is instead of calling it a social layer, I would just call that engineering improvements. Right or or development improvements. [00:28:07] I mean, why would you have to call it a social, you know? I mean, why do you have to call it a social layer? I mean, for me, it just and I guess it's because of my engineering background and some of the some of these other areas where you get involved with the with the, you know, I consider it like like economics, right? Is is a social science, economics typically, right? [00:28:27] So you can close and the more I think like it was hard. Like you know, a f a factory that we're engineering or a machine, right? This is this is money that we're engineering. This is the protocol. I mean the this Bitcoin's gonna end up that's what's gonna end up being the m the money for machines, right? [00:28:46] The machine for money? Yeah. Well, no, and the money for machines. Yeah, both, right? So I mean, but wouldn't it be closer to that? The point is it is that we're we're engineering a machine that is money or for the transfer of value. For part of it, yeah. So there is so there is a sort of social there's a social and economic component to it, right? This is well, yeah. [00:29:04] I mean, if you're building I guess my whole point is if you were saying governance, okay, and I understand that but and I don't know why I'm so caught up on it, but I and I notice some other people are caught up on it too. And part of this, I can be i as and we probably should share this apart, is that I think it's important that you know I'm more in in the camp that I'm defending, but I think it's also important to go through it this way. [00:29:28] And so some of what I'm doing here is is devil's advocate with respect to how we're walking through this, right? So it can be full 360 as to looking at this and kind of ties in to what we started citizen bitcoin with was that the Feynman concept is is is that those who those who try to teach something, learn something about it in terms of trying to figure it out. [00:29:49] But So and maybe it's just the fact that I'm caught up with the term social layer and I and I shouldn't be caught up on that term, that specific term. What is it about that about the idea of social contract that well it just leads me to believe that a bunch of people well I it leads me to believe that it i it get i it it gets off of actual facts [00:30:13] How so say more about that [00:30:19] You can well you're you get into a s well it and it ends up probably getting hard forked I guess you end up in a situation where you get a group of people trying to convince convince other people and stuff that may not s things that may not be in their best interest that's all and try and you're be able to through through that being able to convert it over. [00:30:37] But I guess that could happen no matter what but I don't know I just don't like the term social layer. And I should have a better answer I should have a better answer in that what I guess the closest thing I could come up with is is it social science and social science is is not a hard science either. So yeah but the I don't think the process of Bitcoin governance is a hard science. [00:30:59] I think it is a well it's a hard science on the protocol layer. I mean it's pretty much just laid right out the protocol itself the code is that's not hard science well I would say if I would argue that let's let's separate out in sort of three the code into kind of three sections. [00:31:17] Alright you have one the [00:31:22] Basically mining the operation of mining the proof of work layer all right which is which is which is a math mathematical hard science, all right? Correct. And then you have the next layer up from that, which would be sort of the cryptography layer, right? [00:31:42] So public key catalog cryptography. That's math and hard science. Mm-hmm. Okay. Alright. I'm two for I'm two for two. Then you have this third part, the incentive layer. Okay. And that's there's a subsection in the white paper that's titled Incentive. That talks about the subsidy for mining Bitcoin, which provides security. [00:32:05] And then once that subsidy runs out or is very small, you'll try will transition into using transaction fees as an incentive to provide security for the layer or for the for the network. So that gets into behavioral economics, right? And incentives, and the whole ide like the system would fall apart if you if basically the assumption that humans will act rationally to you know be a good actor on the network because they're getting paid. [00:32:35] If that assumption falls apart, which is based on economics, right, and human behavior and social science, then so I would say even at the protocol level, there's a there's some social science mixed in there. But then at the social layer, like all of us talking about what Bitcoin is and what it means to us and deciding together, arriving at a shelling point, a consensus on what it should be, and whether that means changing it or not changing it, doesn't matter. [00:33:02] Not changing is is the same deciding not to change it is the same as deciding to change it in terms of you know the result of the city. Well, but there's three things, right? That we always have well, I always mention this when we talked about it. Well, there's three things, right? There's either the decision to change it and actually making a decision not to change it, or just sitting there blindly just doing nothing, right? [00:33:23] There's three three three possibilities, right? So Hasu has a thread talking about why he chose to describe it this way. All right. Because Elaine Ow you know basically replied and said, I you know, I hate this the term social contract. [00:33:42] It's not, yeah. Social contract isn't worth the paper it's written on. Bitcoin should be able to survive without the help of crypto Twitter, which is like kind of a reference to the social layer, which is kind of where a lot of the social interaction happens, or a lot of the Wells. [00:34:00] Let's talk about that for a minute. It is surviving without it, right? She's right right now, right? Bitcoin's surviving without crypto Twitter right now, so she's right. I think it can survive without crypto Twitter, right? I think the point is that but it is right now. [00:34:19] What do you mean? Well, it's just it's marching along. I mean, if tw if if crypto Twitter in in like two minutes from now, just there was no more crypto. But we would just march we would just find a new place, a new venue to talk about Bitcoin. There's still I mean, as long as people are using Bitcoin, correct? There's going to be a conversation about what it is and what it should be and whether or not it should stay that way. [00:34:42] I agree. I think we're I think where I'm caught up is is probably semantic. Yeah. So it's semantics. Yeah, and I think Elaine's you know protest was about semantics too. So here's what Hasu says, right? He says with Bitcoin, users enter a voluntary agreement that restrains them from acting in certain ways. [00:35:04] Okay, so that looks like a contract, but what kind of contract? A legal contract is recognized and enforceable by the law, and Bitcoin users explicitly can't rely on a third party to enforce the contract for them. Instead, they check on each other with validating nodes. The checking creates the incentive to follow the rules voluntarily or fall out of consensus. [00:35:25] Right. Okay, it's binding in the same way that we're only going to be there in the same social network as long as neither of us treats the other like an asshole. Okay, so that makes sense, right? So neither can someone force me to be friends with you, nor can I sue you for treating me poorly. But while we both follow the social protocol, we can be friends. [00:35:45] The social protocol is an emergent equilibrium, and the more people follow and enforce it, the stronger it gets. So Bitcoin works the same way. The property these properties are socially emergent, and we can also call it economically emergent. I don't care about that. No wonder Elaine's an engineer. Yeah. [00:36:03] Okay, so that makes sense to me. Social choices are ultimately economic choices anyway. So that's his reasoning, is what he says. And he would love to get her feedback on it. Elaine never responded to that, but and then Haasu says to sum it up, I don't really understand the dislike for s for social contracts. They guide our daily life in more ways than legal contracts. [00:36:23] Isn't the law and legal system itself just a scaling solution for interpersonal protocols that emerged on the social layer? Hmm. [00:36:34] So maybe it's just semantics, but but we do agree that there is this sort of this important aspect of Bitcoin that is not part of the protocol, but is that lives in human society in the discussion of it? I agree. Yeah. So you like the word governance a little better. [00:36:52] I don't even know if I'm sure you well, yeah, I'm I'm not I'm still this has been great because I gotta think about it some more, and I've got to go back and read I gotta read some more on on I'll go back and re-look at social contract theory and I understand this this is just it's not exactly that because you get the idea, you know, but I'm just saying I'm gonna have to look at that. [00:37:15] The other thing is I want to read that that that a couple of pieces that you sent me. I think the one is governance and blockchain technology and social contract theories. Oh yeah, that's a jerk. This long 40 page paper. Yeah, I want to I want to I want to read that. I do too. I haven't as I read the admin track. Thanks for sending that over today, but I didn't get a chance to take it. [00:37:34] No, I didn't get a chance to finish it either. And then the Austrian ec you had an Austrian economics paper you sent over to me too that looked really good too. It was all good, but at least I was able and I think Hasu did a nice job of you know laying laying these out, and I think it's it's important to lay out, you know, these concepts. [00:37:55] And then the other one was just we were gonna talk about Bitcoin and the promise of independent property rights. Did we already cover we didn't really cover that? His third part three. Yeah, he so the third part of the series is great too. I actually I did read that today. [00:38:14] It gets into [00:38:18] Let's see. [00:38:19] Well, it's just Bitcoin's property rights are detached from local monopoly of violence in the legal system. So it kind of runs on on top, you know, on top of the legal system and the monopoly and violence, which kind of gets to our point of the fact that you know, like some somebody can send you know, two people can send two different parties can send without an intermediary, right? [00:38:42] From two different countries and just but it's you know yeah the idea is the fact that it's a trustless the idea is that property rights which is you know super important well integral to you know capitalism and you know human advancement and then of course to markets the viability of markets and firms has always relied upon and needed a state that has a monopoly on violence and a legal system and then you can develop property rights and markets and all that and that's what kind of what I was getting at toward the beginning of this conversation but then until [00:39:20] Until I derailed it. Well no I mean I and I was just pulling it from this this article without remembering that it came from this article. Oh cool. But yeah s Bitcoin has der has created a system where you have property rights and markets without the need for a state or a legal system. [00:39:39] So it's separate from those from those two things. Which means that you know it's super useful to states that don't have a stable you know a stable state or stable legal system. Well if you look at for example like what happened in so if even if you go historically when there was problems in Cyprus Bitcoin played a big role when that was going on Venezuela. [00:40:00] Right currently right yeah there were times also around that with Argentina where they had that early on or Argentina and I think they still it's not as much now but they were using you know using it because the their currency just hyper hyper inflated their underlying currency. [00:40:20] Did you see that opinion article that was in the New York Times this weekend? This past weekend, it was opinion piece titled Bitcoin is save My Family. And it was a Venezuelan that has Oh I got actually I didn't see that. I got I gotta get that and send that to one of my no no coin or a couple of my no coiner buddies. [00:40:39] Yeah. But yeah, it's it's a compelling argument that you know Bitcoin has a very extremely important use case right now. Well I guess it is, but but well I guess I'll have to read it, and maybe we should cover it because it because you know the argument could be made, and I guess it's maybe they'd be stolen. [00:40:58] I mean if they were holding if they were able to hold like US it somehow had their hands on US dollars. They're using US dollars too. But if they had a hundred, you know, if they had US dollars in instead of Bitcoin, then the argument would be that the US dollar saves their life, right? Because I think, right? So it'd be simple. Well, I think I think the US dollars are playing a role in in other or not. [00:41:17] Well, yeah, it's gotta be huge. I'm just saying in terms of an argument. I guess the argument you could make with Bitcoin is is if you memorize you know your your codes and all that, you couldn't get robbed. You're you know, if you had US dollars, you'd get robbed, right? Pretty easily. Yeah, true. I don't know. I'm just it is just to make it just to make it full circle here. The idea is is that somebody said Bitcoin saved their life. [00:41:37] Well, if they had US dollars, it probably saved their life too. Yeah. And you can use a brain wallet. You can memorize your your you know 24 word backup phrase or your private key. Oh, I didn't know actually I this is something I didn't know. It's called what's it called? A brain wall. People could refer to it as a brain wallet, basically. You're just carrying around your private key in one form or another in your brain. [00:41:57] Well, I'm not on the head of that. I didn't realize that was a term. Okay, cool. It's not on yeah, it's not on a piece of paper. It's just in your head. And you know, that it that's the most unconfiscatable version, I guess of the case. Yeah, except the key, you know, all that's all I you know, I can't even remember like a password I put up from you know. It's like which one was it again? [00:42:15] Did I capitalize it singing? Did I use it? Which noob, you know, which yeah, you'd have to really have I'd have I'd have to really work my short-term memory out. It's way out of practice at this point. No, I'd have to work it out too, and then I'd then I'd have then have somebody else memorize it, and then we sit there and go wait a second. Was it was it a four or was it a seven? Yeah. [00:42:34] Yeah, that seems a little a little risky. I guess well, but actually if you were in that, but you think about it, if you're in that type of environment, you'd probably I don't know, you I think you'd step up. Yeah, pretty quickly. Yeah, make it happen. And the fact that you could use a 24-word, you know, seed phrase basically. I would have to have MCT oil and put butter in my coffee, probably for a while. [00:42:55] Have a grass butter. Have yourself a nice mnemonic device, a little song that you just sing in your head all the time. Wake up every morning, go to bed every night. Okay, we're digressing. We gotta get back on track. Okay, so what else we got for this? I think we've done pretty well, right? What what else we got? I think that's about it for this for this week. Right, thanks everybody. [00:43:13] I hope that we decided on this right to just kind of go we were discussing prior to the podcast this whole area of the social layer, and it got to the point where we felt it would just be good to just debate it on the on on the on the pod rather than try to get some consensus on some of it. So hopefully hopefully you enjoyed that piece of it. [00:43:32] We went through a lot of great articles on Medium and found some lar longer like PDF like academic pieces that we started getting into but didn't have time to read today before the pod. And I'll link to all that stuff in the show notes. Okay, everybody, thank you. Thanks, everyone. Take care out there, Bitcoiners.