Alex Gladstein: The Orwellian Future that Wasn't Citizen Bitcoin · 2020-02-27 [00:00:18] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today from all over the world for another day here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. This week we're sitting down with Alex Gladstein, Chief Chief Strategy Officer at the Human Rights Foundation and the Oslo Freedom Forum and on the faculty at Singularity University. [00:00:44] But first, an update from Swan. The March launch is coming very quickly. The app is looking absolutely beautiful. Sign up for early access at swanbitcoin.com. Right now, you're going to want to see this as soon as possible. Swan will make Bitcoin investing easy with automatic buys every week, month, or paycheck. We will steadily convert your dollars to Bitcoin savings to build your stack. [00:01:03] You'll be able to set automatic withdrawals for your Bitcoin when it reaches a certain amount. Not your keys, not your coins. We absolutely encourage withdrawing and holding your own keys, your own Bitcoin. I'm going to be hosting AMAs with Bitcoiners as part of our Ask Swan initiative. You know, we're absolutely dedicated to education at Swan. [00:01:24] You can ask us anything Bitcoin related on Twitter with the hashtag AskSwan and we'll answer it. I'll be building out a program around Ask Swan, including these AMAs. The first one is next Tuesday with Jimmy Song. Find the details, register, and submit your question at event.com slash Jimmy Song. [00:01:42] I'm working with another great team on an open source project called Bitcoiners Best. We curate the best Bitcoin content to get new coiners up to speed and keep Bitcoiners up to date. We just launched last week at Bitcoiners.best. The team includes at BinaryDreaming, at Pablo F7Z, at Bootstrap Bandit, and we've got four awesome curators on board now at Full Time Bitcoin, at Sasquatch Muscle, at Jungle Jitney, and the great at Coinicaris of the Fun with Bitcoin Podcast. [00:02:11] We're looking for more devs and curators to join the team. DM at Bitcoiners Best on Bitcoin Twitter if you're interested. And get in there and vote. 1x votes for free, 10x votes for 10k sets, all sats donated to open source projects. You can also vote on which open source project gets those sets every month. So get in there, start voting, Bitcoiners.best. [00:02:33] Thanks as always to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the pod in their feed. They've got several other great Bitcoin only pods on the feed. You can give them a follow at LTBN Network on Bitcoin Twitter and check out the LTBN feed in your podcast app for the other great Bitcoin podcasts included there. And the Bitcoin 2020 conference is coming up quickly. [00:02:52] I'm getting super stoked about it. I'm talking, as you all know, with speakers who are going to be at the Bitcoin 2020 conference, including Alex, and I'm gonna be you know there. The thing's gonna be even more epic than last year. Check you can find me hanging out at the Swan booth, and I'll be roaming around, grabbing audio to share with you all after the conference. [00:03:15] Definitely recommend making your way to SF for this one, March 27th to 28th. Lots of satellite events, parties happening around those dates. Definitely come and join us. Alright, let's dive in. Alex Gladstein really needs no introduction. [00:03:35] He's well known now among big Bitcoiners as a tireless advocate for Bitcoin, as a means to protect and preserve human rights like privacy among others. And in this episode, we focus entirely on privacy. I had several other topics for us to discuss, but the conversation kept gravitating back to privacy, and I'm glad it did. [00:03:53] I think this will be a great episode to share when you get the well, I don't have anything to hide, response from friends and family when you're trying to talk about the importance of privacy. Alright, hope you enjoy. Here we go. [00:04:14] Alright, a hearty welcome to Alex Gladstein, a true warrior for justice and human rights. Alex, how's it going, man? It's going very well. Thanks for the over the top welcome, but you know, I do what I can. I do what I can. [00:04:33] Yeah. Well, I mean, I'm impressed with your work, and I know a lot of listeners here and Bitcoiners really appreciate what you do, and so yeah, just thanks for that. Alright, let's just dive right into the deep end here. I want to start with a broad thought experiment. Let's imagine that Bitcoin was never invented. [00:04:54] Can you paint a picture for us of you know the cashless human society, money is still centrally controlled by the world's most powerful governments? Describe that world without the option of Bitcoin. Right. So we're living in this digital society, and no one has ever invented an asset that is decentralized and scarce and digital. [00:05:24] Right. So all of the assets out there, all of the financial instruments that you would interact with in the future would be one or the other, right? They'd be digital, but they'd either be scarce and centralized, or they'd be, you know, decentralized and not scarce, right? [00:05:49] So because no one had ever invented Bitcoin and solved this like incredible riddle, opening so many doors and so many pathways to the world that we have, you know, Satoshi doesn't exist in this imaginary world that we're describing. And there are you know, digital assets that are decentralized, like files of any sort of file, audio files, data files, you know, but they can be replicated with ease, you know. [00:06:21] So there's there's no real monetary value there. They don't really come into play as like a tool to help with money. Now there are scarce digital assets that are created, but they're you know centrally managed. So while they do evolve money in as much as it continues on its trajectory of being entirely digital, they suffer from the same problems that our financial system has had up to this point. [00:06:52] The problem of centralization, right? The problem of either a person or an entity or a small group of people or entities in charge, being able to make decisions behind closed doors, being able to make decisions that benefit themselves before us, being able to make decisions that benefit perhaps, you know, their friends before us, being able to make decisions that benefit them today and in the next few years at the expense of society in the future. [00:07:24] And you know, things don't really change for the better. In fact, I would say things probably change for the worse, because not only do you have the sustaining of the existing system where the tiny few control the many when it comes to money, but you also have the additional downside for us that care about freedom and human rights of more control and surveillance over your activities. [00:07:54] So even though cash was something that was printed and minted by governments, at least it had like features that were helpful in terms of privacy, right? When you pay for something with a $20 bill, the merchant doesn't immediately know your address or where you came from or what you're gonna buy next or your name, etc. [00:08:19] Etc. Etc. It's just this sort of private transaction done with a bearer instrument. And that certainly had its advantages, and it certainly helps kind of like reduce what's possible with like the authoritarian police state. [00:08:37] It really does. But now you're asking me to talk about this world where we don't have paper metal money anymore. It's easily to it's easy to see how we get there. There are both honestly just like sort of sanitary reasons. Like obviously in a world of perhaps more pandemics, etc., the idea of like having physical money that we have to move around seems unsanitary. [00:09:00] I don't know how true that is. We'd have to ask a medical professional, but just in terms of general common sense, it seems not ideal to have to have the money that we use on a daily basis have to change so many hands, contract so many germs. And it just seems like it doesn't fit in our digital age, right? So it seems like governments would be pretty easily able to convince you to go digital. [00:09:22] They've certainly done that with the help of corporations and different kinds of lifestyles people have chosen where they've made that trade-off, giving away their privacy and freedom for convenience and comfort. So citizens have done it to themselves, companies have gotten in on the action, and governments are rolling up their sleeves and getting really excited because we're about to enter this world where there's no more paper or metal money, and they're gonna control, continue to control money in this highly centralized way, and they're gonna get to get some new features because right now, like the way money is distributed [00:10:01] In society, there are many third parties, right? So the central bank distributes the money to the commercial banks, they distribute it to both like consumers but also smaller companies. And it's not like something where the central bank has a and the government has like a real-time understanding of what's happening with all of the different balances and credits, right? [00:10:25] Especially as you get into like M2, M3 parts of the money supply. And that's a problem for them. It's kind of annoying. Like they'd like to actually know exactly what's going on, right? So if they can actually create a central bank digital currency that's robust, call it a Fed coin, call it a you know a DCP in China, where citizens have like a direct relationship with the central bank, and you know, larger movements of funds are are just sort of immediately trackable. [00:11:00] Then you know I fear the worst in terms of their ability to map and shape and influence people's behavior. You're already seeing the beginnings of this sort of social credit system in China. Which, you know, we can argue about how effective it is or how overblown it is but the reality is that the government there certainly would like it to work well and for everybody to be on some sort of social credit scheme so that they start to self-police. [00:11:31] You know? Like if you can only get fast internet and a fast track passport and access to good schooling and good rates on loans if you're a good citizen, then you know, nine times out of ten or in China's case 999 times out of a thousand citizens are going to go that way just because it's not worth it, you know, to speak up. [00:11:53] Maybe different in a democratic society, but not in a dictatorship. So they've kind of like got this really beautiful setup coming where they'll have more fine grain tune control over the economy. [00:12:04] You know, they'll have a real-time understanding of who has accounts with the central government [00:12:08] As opposed to needing to cut through all of the middlemen of like commercial banks and fintech companies. They'll just have this like they'll they'll know who you are and they'll know what industry you're in and everything about you. So again, if there's like a downturn in a particular sector or a protest among a certain industry, they could just like hit those people with digital credits to their wallets, like boom. [00:12:31] You know, you know, whether it's tax money or helicopter money, who cares? But like they'll be able to administer that, right? Like a surgeon almost, right? Which which has some really compelling benefits, but at the end of the day, this is just a disaster for civil liberties and freedom. And you know, governments will over time tell you that this is better for you, that getting rid of cash and going all digital is gonna be better for you for your life, whether it's health related reasons, stability related release and convenience related reason, and eventually they they will actually outlaw cash. [00:13:08] So I know I don't know when this is gonna happen. I tend to think it's gonna happen even in our Bitcoin world. But either way, I think 2030s, probably by 2035. I'm guessing that cash is like either, you know, ruled not valuable, kind of demonetized, through a process where they kind of say, Hey, turn in your paper money and we'll give you an equivalent amount of digital credits for a year or two. [00:13:38] But after that, like your money's not worth anything anymore. I mean, we saw we saw India do that recently, right? India just like demonetized or made worthless overnight like a couple of denominations of their of their cash. That was like last year or two years ago. Yeah, I mean, look, that's true. They ended up replacing you know those notes with different notes, and we've seen governments do okay, you know, demonetization before. [00:14:03] I'm talking about real demon like like decașification, like right, not just replacing five hundred, you know, increment notes with two thousand or whatever, but or or vice versa, but actually saying, hey, after this day, we will not accept this as legal tender. And then I think after that comes the stage where it actually becomes punishable to actually have it in in your possession. [00:14:26] There's a really great book called The Mandibles, which is a fiction book that was written somewhat recently, and it describes the process of hyperinflation happening in the United States of America. It's an excellent book. I highly recommend people read it. [00:14:45] But there's this scene where like these folks are living in Brooklyn and there's like these like jackbooted thugs coming into their house and searching for gold and silver and stuff, cash. And over time, all money becomes something that is attached to you and your physical identity via like first of course a phone and then a wearable and eventually a freaking implant in your spinal cord. [00:15:09] Okay. So by the end of the book, not to hopefully ruin the narrative, but but generally speaking, it turns into this crazy sci-fi dystopia thing where like by the 2040s, like, you know, Americans have their like ID kind of like implanted inside of them in a way that like is lethal to remove, right? [00:15:29] So you become like forcibly part of the system. We often hear people talk about you know, banking the unbanked. What I think is gonna happen, let's say in our world without Bitcoin, would be that on steroids. Like, yeah, we're gonna bank down banks, we're gonna really bank everybody, and we're gonna force everybody onto this. [00:15:52] I don't know if you know about the ID system in India, the ad heart system, but like we're really gonna force everybody onto this national database, and we're gonna make it so you can't really live your life without compliance here. And it may even be medical compliance. It may even be something you have to have in you. That is not inconceivable over the coming decades. [00:16:10] I hope you would agree. That it might be whether it's a something in your retina or an implant somewhere on your skin, but that we would go beyond wearables and that your ID would be part of you. And you know, in that case, if no one has invented a money that's decentralized and scarce for the digital world, then people have no way out. [00:16:35] They have no way to not comply. They have no way to fight back. And that's a world that I don't want to live in. And I'm really pleased to inform you that we don't have to live in that world because Satoshi Nakamoto invented Bitcoin. And like what there couldn't have been a better time. [00:16:53] Like it was it wasn't too late. It was just I would say for all the people who had to deal with the 20th century, there could have been a better time, but sure, sure, yeah. But it yeah, yes, it it it you know, it was as my friend Dan Heldoffin says, it was sort of planted at the right moment, right? [00:17:15] Yeah, sure. Yeah. So it's it's just a dystopian world of literally no privacy, absolute control by central authorities. You know, when the when the topic of privacy comes up in conversation, I often hear, you know, it's not a big deal, I've got nothing to hide. [00:17:35] That's the trope that I always hear. And that attitude is just so prevalent, right? It's it's especially in like these relatively free liberal democracies of the world. What do you say when you hear that idea expressed? Yeah well first of all I just want to say that like yes it's great that we have this Bitcoin world and someone has figured out a way to separate money from state and create a s like a like a sovereign parallel financial system. [00:18:02] It's it's really truly truly excellent. However it's amazing it doesn't mean that it's all going to end well. Like there are numerous things which we can discuss throughout this recording which I fear but at at least I'm hopeful. Do you know what I'm saying? And you know privacy's really at the whole core of all of these debates that I think are going to start raging in the 2020s with Bitcoin. [00:18:27] I think generally speaking I'll I'll lay out three scenarios that relate to privacy and then you can you can help steer us but when it comes to the example you gave I would go back to my example earlier about the average person in China and how they they don't really want to rock the boat, right? [00:18:46] They're not really gonna want to rock the boat. And actually you can see some Bitcoiners probably even thinking the same thing in m as we move forward. Like they want to be able to buy their Bitcoin from you know KYC compliant exchange they want to play by the rules they're just just you know they're focused on the profits and on being able to hold this asset much like a house or a any other kind of savings technology, like a stock and they they they are like, I got nothing to hide. [00:19:22] I want to play by the rules. And they're like potentially the majority in Bitcoin. And I think this goes unspoken sometimes. But these folks are not willing to look ahead, I would say, is the problem here. Because if we if we go down this road, and this is the road I'll start to describe as like scenario A, is that it's a road of compliance. [00:19:53] So it means what this would mean that like we would become accustomed to acquiring all of our Bitcoin through these like highly KYC regulated exchanges, which is already obviously the case, of course, for the majority of users in countries like the United States. In other countries it's different, but like let's say in the US and Europe. [00:20:12] And you know, one day, what if that withdraw button just disappears on Kraken and Coinbase and Square? What if it just disappears? Okay, crap. Okay, then I can at least send my Bitcoin to like Binance or you know some other exchange. Well, what if the button is gone there too? [00:20:32] So, you know, if you're a smart Bitcoiner and you're owning your own keys, okay, you know, it's been a temporary setback for you. But a lot of people have all of their Bitcoin on custodial services of different kinds of reputation. There's a lot of like highly reputable Bitcoiner endorsed custodial services, right? [00:20:54] And maybe this is this maybe this comes after a big Supreme Court case in the United States. Maybe this comes after a law in a particular state of the United States. Maybe this comes after a executive ruling, who knows? But let's just say this could potentially happen sometime in the next couple of years. Well, I mean, that that's a huge problem. [00:21:13] And I think that people need to really consider that that that could take place, which means that we need to really develop the rest of the ecosystem that is not KYC compliant. So in scenario A, to prepare for that, if we're gonna prep, if we're gonna be preppers here, we need to really figure out ways to have a very robust non-KYC AML compliant exchange on ramp, off-ramp infrastructure, even in democracies. [00:21:44] That's number one. I think number two is gonna be scenario B is gonna be a scenario where maybe we defeat that threat. You know, maybe maybe we just kind of continue on our current trajectory of increased Bitcoin adoption and usage. But there are technological advancements made to Bitcoin, so much so that dramatic privacy improvements are proposed by Bitcoin core developers, and they don't risk the auditability of the money supply anymore. [00:22:15] So I'll just I'll just name one. Let's say let's say some group of people figure out how to add confidential transactions or something like confidential transactions, so that the amount between addresses can be hidden from everybody except for the people involved. [00:22:34] Let's say that that that can be actually added to Bitcoin core in a way that does not hamper the ability of full nodes to audit the monetary supply, right? Sure. Maybe that's five to eight years from now, ten years from now. Who knows? I hope and I believe the day comes, because I really believe that that would combined with like CoinJoin style tactics, really, really help us keep our transactions pretty private. [00:23:00] But I think you'd have a you know, and you and obviously we look at 2017 and you look at the coalition that you know wanted to increase the block size. I think you'd have an even bigger coalition, an even fiercer coalition that would oppose any such addition to privacy tech into Bitcoin core. [00:23:19] And I think that's gonna be a really bloody battle because where I think a lot of the Bitcoin core developers were were were pretty aligned against like this idea of not necessarily adding big blocks, but like of sort of changing the rules, right? And empowering a certain group of people. I think there's a fair number of them that may actually oppose privacy for like the reasons I outlined before. [00:23:42] Like they just want the current system to keep going, they just want their assets. That that's a possibility, something I fear. It doesn't mean it may actually take place. And then the scenario C, the third risk would relate to this idea of like needing a little bit of inflation, right? And again, you would see this similar coalition of people that perhaps was created you know and defeated in 2017, but then kind of comes back and it's kind of like the old money kind of financial legacy folks who got into Bitcoin and they just want to like play by the rules and be KYC AML compliant and you know they don't want you to talk about the [00:24:20] Dark net, you know, they don't want you to talk about drugs or helping dissidents or causing trouble. They just want to steer clear of that and be like legit, right? And you know, these folks are gonna fight privacy additions to Bitcoin, and they're probably also gonna be pro-inflation eventually. [00:24:38] So there's a really good essay called I think like the three eras of bitcoin. That let me see here. Yeah, by Rusty Russell. It's called The Three Economic Eras of Bitcoin. And I think he wrote it about two and a half years ago. [00:24:57] And he's sort of describing this third scenario here, where inevitably, like this kind of more pro-business side of the Bitcoin community, you know pushes really hard for like just a little bit of inflation increase. And that's gonna that's gonna be another big battle. [00:25:18] So I think that these are these are the big battles to come in the coming decade. I think that Bitcoin can survive and win and thrive, but it's gonna take a lot of intentionality from people who care about privacy and decentralization. [00:25:39] You know, a really strong tyranny of the minority here to win out because these these other forces are gonna be really strong. So I hope I hope that people can just think about that. We've been lucky enough to avoid the dystopic future that we talked about earlier, where cash is gone and humans just have to use this sort of centralized digital currencies. [00:26:06] You know, that's not our future because we have Bitcoin. But if we screw up and you know, we kind of fuck up one of these key attributes of Bitcoin that make it what it is from a human rights and sort of liberation perspective, and we allow people to start, you know, changing the money supply, or we I guess without reason block privacy improvements, we're gonna be in a bad place. [00:26:35] So that's that's kind of what I what I think is coming up in in our world. Yeah, there's just so much there. And it's it does worry me that that the complacency of humans, of people who, you know, like you said, there's the majority doesn't really care so much about the reasons that a lot of us hardcore Bitcoiners you could call us, care about Bitcoin. [00:27:01] And that's you know, privacy, the fact that it's a bearer asset and we can control the money, the fact that we don't we have a very a fixed monetary policy that's completely and utterly predictable. These aspects of Bitcoin that we all really care about and you know inspire us to fight for it. You know, it it seems that the majority that are you know maybe come will come into Bitcoin in the years ahead won't at least at first really care about those things. [00:27:31] Well, not but like what if but if we make them into big debates and arguments, then it then it can work, you know, but but the narrative needs to be strong here. I mean, talk about memes. A lot of people who got into Bitcoin in the last two years don't know anything about 2017, in terms of the way that there was this like coup attempt on Bitcoin. [00:27:54] A lot of people still to this day, whether they're you know, concern trolls or authentically skeptical or whatever they are, they keep bringing up this thing about Chinese miners like you know, you know, attacking your ability to use Bitcoin and censoring your transactions and it's like it's like did you not notice that like Chinese miners you know and other corporate miners from around the world tried to like you know seize control of Bitcoin and totally failed did you not see that one and they had like 80% of the hash rate and they failed anyway like I think that that [00:28:33] That part that era of Bitcoin is is not talked about enough. So I know that Peter McCormack is doing like a like a series on it which is exciting but I really feel like that era needs to be revisited and in detail and in luxurious detail. Like there's so many lessons from that like you know 2016 to 2017 era of the battle for big the control of Bitcoin. [00:28:59] And I hope more more people can do more revisiting of that era. What are some of the lessons that that stand out to you like the you know the top couple lessons I mean I know obviously like the going back to that idea the tyranny of minority what Talib calls the intransigent minority there was you know Bitcoiners that really dug in and stood their ground we found a software fork a way to say you know if you guys do this you know we're gonna do this the user activated soft fork so yeah it was it was just you know a great example of how we can defend Bitcoin with an intransigent [00:29:37] Intransigent minority what are some other lessons that that came out of that for yeah no I for me it's two it's one is the fact that it just shows how resilient Bitcoin is, and it shows how the Bitcoin network can repel you know centralized attacks. [00:29:58] It's really incredible that the immune system was able to repel this attack, which had huge percentages of the you know, mining industry, like a clear majority of the hash power, tons of people on the merchant side, on the on the sort of user acquisition, user, user interface side, a lot of the thought leaders in the space, a lot of the most famous people in Bitcoin, and yet just nothing is is incredible to watch. [00:30:30] So the idea that it proved that Bitcoin has this remarkable immune system. But also you know, and I think that's number one kind of what it was about, like people preventing a group coming in and arbitrary changing big arbitrarily changing Bitcoin to give them more control. [00:30:49] But number two is definitely the whole big block small block thing. And it I don't think it's just about the idea of a slippery slope. Like for me as a human rights advocate, it's really obvious that the magical part of Bitcoin is that like pretty much anyone can just run a full node and validate the system and reject blocks that don't conform and reject, you know versions of the software that they did that they don't want to update to. [00:31:20] That that's in their power, there's no auto update. So the power's in their hands, right? And this idea that like if we just continued to increase the block size, you know, six, eight, ten, twenty megabytes, a hundred megabytes. [00:31:42] I mean, you could quickly see how what happens. Like all of a sudden, like barely anybody can run a full node at home. Not just for hard drive space, but also for like latency purposes, like bandwidth purposes. You need specialized equipment, and all of a sudden, like very few people are are running it, and all of a sudden, like collusion is possible, right? [00:32:05] Among the people who who run it. And you know, in a lot of a lot of ways, this is what has happened to Ethereum, which is really unfortunate. But you know, thankfully we avoided that. But I you know I still can't understand why people who who favor these like massive blocks don't see that this is a problem. [00:32:24] But really like the whole the whole one of the reasons as like a pro-freedom person I'm I'm interested in Bitcoin is because of this ability that it has, where it's like this decentralized network that's in control as opposed to a small group of elites. That was the whole point of Bitcoin. The whole point of Bitcoin was to revolutionize the financial system and break it open and decentralize it so that more people could have a say and that there'd be more checks and balances, so that arbitrary decisions like printing more money to bail out banks weren't possible. [00:32:56] I mean, that's literally in the Genesis block. So, you know, for me, the lessons of that the battle for Bitcoin are about control and also about decentralization. And you know what? Bitcoin, you know, passed with flying colors due to the tenacity of a you know, and persistence of a lot of you know, really committed people. [00:33:20] So bravo, well done. That was great. I think more people should dig into that. But you know, moving forward, we're gonna have more of those moments that may be even more intense, again, because I don't think it's gonna be so clear-cut. I mean, I think you already saw you know, a percentage of the Bitcoin community was like shaved off at that moment and they went off to their own projects. [00:33:42] Well, it'd be naive to think that we're not gonna encounter that again. You know, I feel like a lot of Bitcoiners are chummy with everybody, quote unquote, and it feels like there's a community, but you know that that's not the case. There's gonna be more shaving, there's gonna be more fractures and more fissures. Sure. And again, I think it's gonna be along these lines of like privacy and potentially inflation. [00:34:04] But if you want this money project to exist where it is sovereign and governments and corporations don't control it, you gotta protect this this software, however you can. You know, that that means educating people, that means talking to people about privacy, that means talking to people about scaling the system in ways that don't involve changing the base layer too much. [00:34:35] It involves explaining why having this kind of conservative mentality towards changing the software is really important, like being very careful, being very cautious, like, oh, you know, a taproot or something could take another year or two, like being okay with that. There's no reason to rush this thing, which could potentially be the financial backbone for many, many people for many, many decades, or or or perhaps way longer. [00:34:59] So just being careful, paying attention to developing these like alternative infrastructures in case the whole like KYC circle closes and we lose that ability to buy large amounts of Bitcoin from like essentially banks, like may happen. [00:35:19] Just preparing yourselves. And you know, I think we can look to China for honestly a lot of inspiration to the Chinese people. Hope they're staying strong out there right now. It's really sad to see what this sort of Chernobyl Chernobyl moment has caused from the communist party where they placed loyalty and prestige over the public good. [00:35:41] Same thing that happened in Chernobyl in the 80s and the 70s. But they really buried the truth on this one, and thousands of people are dying. I mean, you and I both know that the death toll is not 2500. Of course. I mean, I mean, there's entire families dying. There's reports of entire prisons being infected. [00:36:00] I mean, I hate to say it, but I think we're looking at you know, obviously a much larger death toll, and you know, that's fair squarely on the on on the blame of the communist party. But pre pre-virus, let's look kind of like what's happened over the last few years. You know, this is a police state. There's no, you know, legitimate property rights over there. [00:36:20] The communist party takes what it wants, and they kind of do whatever they want, and they're above the law, right? So even in this bizarre situation where this is like uber powerful police state that's like increasingly omniscient about how its people interact due to the ability to like siphon and suck up all this data through apps like WeChat. [00:36:41] Yeah, they still can't stop Bitcoin, right? So, you know, regardless of whether you think they were actually involved in the this sort of like bit main you know attack on Bitcoin in 2017 and the whole New York agreement and all that stuff, like, you know, maybe they weren't involved, maybe they were involved, who knows? The point is like that failed and then they you know tried to introduce this ban on you know trading bitcoin into fiat right etc right and you know did that kill bitcoin and that's an interesting question because it's like okay the world's largest government has literally just banned you know at [00:37:19] Least you know you know de jure like by law your ability to buy Bitcoin with like Renimbi right you would think that would be really bad for Bitcoin okay like the price doubles in like three weeks or whatever so you know and I was with Dovey Wan a few weeks ago and she was talking about this how like when you live in that kind of society where it's everything's super controlled and there's just everything's propaganda and then all of a sudden you're getting this like propaganda from the government saying hey there's this asset don't buy it it's really dangerous for you it's a it's a giant billboard for why we need Bitcoin. [00:37:55] Exactly so like boom that like lit on fire and thank God they're so like poor at managing this stuff. But that really backfired and now they're stuck in this situation where like dude there are these apps man I mean I'm not gonna name specifics you guys can go figure it out but there are these apps they're based you know in the Seychelles or Malta or Cayman Islands or whatever these companies and they run these apps where like you can sign up for an account and you can you know use your Chinese credit card or bank account or whatever and make purchases of Bitcoin, and it's just like it seems to be entirely [00:38:33] Unregulated. Like Ali Pay or whatever will see that you bought and it'll just say an amount and like this company's name. And like they're cool with that. And then on the other side, you can withdraw those Bitcoin funds or whatever crypto you buy, like into private wallets. [00:38:52] And like this is just like rampant, right? So right now, in like early Q1 2020, like Q almost Q2, this is just like you're doing talking billions of dollars a day of people acquiring it. And you know what? They're doing it, you know, probably mainly to speculate, but it's still pretty crazy that like despite the fact that this government has arguably the most control in a fine-grained way over its citizenry from a technological perspective, they have not been able to stop Bitcoin. [00:39:19] Now, maybe they're not trying, maybe they can't. Maybe maybe the communist party is too involved in Bitcoin. Unclear. But whether they can't or won't or don't or whatever, we should certainly think about the reasoning, but the fact is they they they they aren't stopping it, which is really really interesting. [00:39:39] And like I think we the community needs to just kind of see that as a canary in a coal mine situation, just monitor China very closely. But it is pretty incredible, and I'd say inspirational as an American to look at that and realize hey, like, even if the American government started to really crack down, I mean, I mean, what are they gonna do? [00:39:59] I mean, it it'll be bad, yeah, price may go down. But I mean, what what they can't stop mining everywhere, and they they certainly can't enforce a ban on possession. I mean, they can't enforce a ban on possession of marijuana, dude. Or or or production of marijuana for that, for that matter. [00:40:18] I mean, look how much of a failure that's been. Now imagine this asset that instead of like requiring a huge field or a hydroponic system and smelling really bad or or really good or whatever prefer. And it's like, you know, sniffable by dogs, like now all of a sudden you've got this asset which you can freaking memorize the seed for in your head. [00:40:42] So yeah, how are you gonna ban that? Like, I just don't see that happening. So they may try, but yeah, and nothing. Not only that, but it's you know, it's it's a good or an asset, right? That that you that every human needs to in order to live the way we want. [00:41:00] So it's the same thing. I mean, I love look, I was talking about this today with some students. I was speaking at I went to Golden Gate University in SF and gave a little presentation. Some students we were talking about this, but like, you know, they're like worried about the fact that nobody cares about privacy. And I'm right there with them. But at the end of the day, like, yeah, your friends might not use signal because like they're lazy or whatever, but like if Bitcoin continues on its financial trajectory, they're gonna want to use Bitcoin. [00:41:27] You know what I mean? It's got this like incredible element to it that Satoshi design that's just so brilliant, this this scarcity piece that like as it continues to improve and thrive, it will become more wanted by everybody around the world eventually. That the price will increase over over time. [00:41:45] And you know, as long as the network can be developed in a way where it is privacy preserving to an extent, and where it continues to be censorship resistant, and fights off any attacks to kind of change the monetary policy. I mean, this thing's gonna get really powerful, and it'll be such a powerful way to actually introduce these things to society without them, you know, knowing even. [00:42:10] In the same way that you might be using a messenger now that like and this is probably a bad comparison, but like, you know what? Like, okay, so like WhatsApp sold to Facebook, okay. Now, like, I don't know, like hundreds of millions of people are basically using encrypted encrypted messaging. Now, I know it's not like fully peer-to-peer encrypted, but it it's it's an example of like how one might unknowingly adopt a new privacy technology, like not caring at all about privacy. [00:42:41] Do you see what I'm saying? Like it's just it's just maybe part of how you adopt stuff that's popular. So if all of a sudden everyone uses HT HTTPS now, it's just you know the way things are these days. So I mean, we should definitely talk about the privacy piece. It's just you know, it's fun arguing with the Monero people about this. [00:43:01] And they're they're absolutely relentless. The problem is it's unclear. Some of them are authentic technologists who want to build a better world, some of them. The others are just bag holders. So it's it's it's really difficult to actually know who you're talking to, right? It's and it's always hard to deal with someone who literally has the three-letter acronym for their favorite coin in their Twitter handle. [00:43:24] Like that's not it's not a good look, man. But okay, I digress. The point is, you know, I think that of course we have to admit that we're not gonna get a huge amount of privacy gains if if like the way that everybody's gonna be buying Bitcoin is like through these like regulated entities. [00:43:43] However, however, if people are still able to withdraw, and if people can, if they wish, figure out relatively easily, and we're certainly not there yet, but how to do something like CoinJoin, or if even the base layer continues to improve, and in five, six, seven years we have something that resembles something like CT or some way to kind of hide the amounts. [00:44:10] I mean, that would be really amazing. Then you know, like I don't know how hard they have to think about it. Like, it just might be just like a better money to use. It might be just like less prone to exploitation and censorship and surveillance. I mean that that's how it is today. And I haven't even gotten to lightning, you know. [00:44:30] So, you know, there is there is a way, you look, who knows? May not work out this way, but but there certainly is a real a future where a lot of the first exposure that people get to Bitcoin is lightning based, and like a lot of the way that they deal with Bitcoin on a daily basis is through lightning, and there's just obviously a huge amount of privacy benefits there, simply because you're just not on the chain and you're not exposing yourself as much to Yeah, and even when you settle the chain like like we're looking at, you know, with Coinjoin combined with like Taproot and Schnorr, you know, we're actually already like looking in the next couple of years for great increase privacy [00:45:08] Increases and combine that with lightning, then even the you know the settlements in and out are more private. Again, people kind of underestimate some of these core features, but like yes, like it's kind of like the Tor browser, like in many ways a government could like tell you're using Tor, but they can't really tell what you're doing inside of it, you know. [00:45:26] And like, you know what, that might be a reason enough to arrest you. But it's better than not using Tor, you know what I mean? Like for for a lot of people. So yeah, same thing with CoinJoin. Like, okay, well, hey, I know that you are part of this like large anonymity set. Like, okay, well, you can't prove anything about me though, you know. [00:45:46] So, especially for people in democracies where there's rule of law, I think CoinJoins will be like increasingly helpful. I really believe that this is gonna go to like the Supreme Court in the next couple of years. Wow. This you know, can America you know is it okay for businesses to work with Americans who coin join their funds? [00:46:06] Something like that. And you know what? Like First and Fourth Amendment, baby. So we just gotta hope that some of these justices are on the side of protecting citizens as opposed to enlargining this the police state. And maybe that's the case, man. We'll see. We'll see. I mean, you the beauty about Bitcoin is it brings together people with like such a staggering diversity of political opinions. [00:46:27] But say what you want about the folks in the Supreme Court, but if there are more like sort of strict constitutionalists there, there is this possibility that we do get a more favorable outcome with regard to this particular. So let's see how it goes. [00:46:46] But but don't be shocked if you see something like that at a federal court or even a Supreme Court ruling the next two to four years on this issue. And just just for the listener, this whole like alpha bay thing was really frustrating to me because the media totally conflated a centralized mixing service with with open source software. [00:47:07] And there's just that they couldn't be more different. I mean, this was a dude who, if I understand it correctly, you were just like sending him your Bitcoin and he was like sending you someone else's Bitcoin. It's like, okay, yeah, it's obviously single point of failure, terrible idea. But like these folks who are creating the software that's non-custodial, like that's not a money transmitter, you know what I mean? [00:47:28] Like, and if you look at what CoinCenter's been writing, it's just hard to imagine the US government being able to somehow you know punish people who who just write the software. I think this is such an important lesson to bring away is that you are if you don't cut if you don't take custody of funds of anybody, like you're pretty in the clear. [00:47:48] Do you know what I mean? Yeah. For now. We'll have to see how it goes. But certainly keep an eye out on that. Yeah, the argument that Bitcoin is speech is a powerful one. And you know, we fought for this in the American Revolution. Basically, it like freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and separation of church and state, I think were you know the two most powerful ideas of freedom that we fought for in that revolution, and definitely separation of money and state is is on the same order, if not even more important, because like we said earlier, like it's you know something that that is half of every single transaction that humans absolutely need [00:48:26] To survive and live in the society, the interconnect society we live in these days. You know, barter's just not really a viable option. So yeah, it's it's it's something that it is a revolution. And it there's going to be more of a fight than we've experienced to date. Yeah. [00:48:45] Well, I agree. And maybe we can talk a little bit about a chain analysis company. Really, you know, they claim to be, you know, upholding law and helping grow a responsible Bitcoin ecosystem, whatever. Actually think about how privacy is at risk in Bitcoin. [00:49:04] Let's actually play out a scenario. So I'm an American citizen, I buy some Bitcoin on Coinbase, I send it to my private wallet, and that's it. I'm just holding on to it. This is like a probably a very common kind of process that I imagine millions of people have gone through, right? [00:49:27] Literally millions. So, okay, so how would my privacy be broken in this scenario? You know, to pair an address with an identity, you need you need a way of linking those two things together. The pseudonymity feature, the permissionless features of Bitcoin are so powerful in this way, like where these addresses can have amounts on them, and like you don't know by looking at the blockchain who whose money is that? [00:49:57] You just don't know. So Coinbase would have to be compromised, or Coinbase would have to give up the fact that that address was paired with your account, right? As you withdraw those funds, they have in their record book, they're like, oh, okay, Alex withdrew to that address on this day, and they keep that, and then they give that up. [00:50:18] I'd like to see a scenario where like someone needs a warrant to get that data. Do you know what I'm saying? Like, yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't think that they should just be able to like sell that data like chain analysis companies. That's insane. So I really think we need to think about this similarly to like telecom companies and mass surveillance. [00:50:40] Like, this sh this shit should be illegal. Unless there's a warrant. Okay, so Alex broke a law. Hi, knock knock Coinbase. Did you have a customer named Alex Gladstein? Yes, we did. Okay, okay. Okay, we're gonna need to see the records of where he withdrew the funds. Because we're doing an investigation. [00:51:00] I would like to have a judge sign off on that. I don't know about you. Yeah. And maybe we can fight for that, but like currently the situation is pretty whack, dude. And I don't know how these people at chain analysis companies look at themselves in the mirror and think that they're doing anything good. It's the Coinbase acquisition. [00:51:19] The Coinbase acquisition of the chain analysis company that was you know associated with really like assisting people. Neutrino yeah oh my gosh that was pretty whack. Well it just shows you that like no and look a lot of these companies are I don't even know if they use the chain analysis. They basically just hire the chain analysis company so that they can go to the US government and say hey we're good man, right? [00:51:44] All good all good okay cool. So it's it's sort of unclear but there's also just like if you actually dig into some of this there's some some really good stuff on on Livera's podcast recently with like people who make privacy tools. And yeah man there's a lot of witchcraft in chain analysis and a lot of assumptions made and a lot of probabilistic kind of guesses and I can I mean a lot of that stuff's not gonna hold up in a court of law and like a lawsuit. [00:52:09] I mean some of it will but not all of it that's for sure. And there's a lot of stuff people are developing to kind of like confuse the hell out of people trying to read chain analysis like decoy coin joints and stuff. I mean the limited the limit the effects are limited if only a handful of people are doing them but it is kind of cool to see people start to start to help kind of frustrate these spies basically I mean chain analysis companies are we need a better word for these for this industry. [00:52:38] I mean it should be the you know financial surveillance industry or something i mean we there should not be any euphemism for them to hide behind like hey yeah what oh what do you do oh I work for a financial surveillance company exactly oh I work for a chain analysis company the average person has no freaking clue what that means how about yes oh so you work for a financial surveillance company okay okay cool I'm gonna hopefully start doing that in conversation but really I mean it'll hopefully it'll just make them think about what they're doing they could be applying their skills and knowledge to the other side of the fight you know and it really goes back to those three scenarios I traced out at the beginning of this conversation [00:53:17] Of like risk kind of vectors for Bitcoin and like you know this group of people who think that this industry just needs to be like regulated and safe and like if we play by the rules everything will be okay and let's just work with chain analysis companies and let's not add privacy tech to Bitcoin and let's just be sheep it's not gonna end well for you guys. [00:53:42] Let me just tell you that's not gonna end well. Your freedom will eventually be taken from you. So I hope you're listening. Wow yeah I want to dive back into this KYC attack vector. And you're talking about the fact that we need to develop you know alternatives to the KYC system that basically like a you know a parallel economy Bitcoin economy you know as Bitcoin is a parallel opted opt-out economy to the you know the traditional financial system, we should also have within Bitcoin [00:54:20] A parallel economy that's that's non-KYC. And I know that there's a few projects out there, like BISC, for instance. But I also know that you know, non-KYC projects like Shapeshift and local Bitcoins you know, eventually succumbed and implemented KYC. Yeah, I look, I would break this into two things. [00:54:41] I mean, there's stuff just sort of happens organically, like not in the United States, but like look at Nigeria. I mean, the volume of people who do transactions over WhatsApp not through a KYC exchange is astronomical from what I understand. [00:54:59] I mean, you're talking a country that by 2050 will have the same population as the United States of America. Look at China. You're talking about people using these apps, which for the smaller amounts are just straight up non-KYC. You could just have burner email to sign up for an account. [00:55:18] So, and there's just you know, a huge number of like OTC action that that is kind of done, kind of in that, let's say a peer-to-peer way, where folks are doing stuff and they're not necessarily reporting everything. There is a lot of that in the world. And I don't know if we can sit here and say, like, hey, in America, we should work on developing a parallel economy. [00:55:41] Like, I don't know if I don't know if that's like the way it's going to be done. I mean, you there's only so far you can go in like earning Bitcoin and spending it. Like, that's just not where we are right now. I think what we can do is look, we're just you know, the on-ramps are the on-ramps at the moment. I mean, yeah, more power to you if you can use stuff like BISC and try to obtain your Bitcoin in ways that doesn't require going through a KYC service, but you also kind of have to admit that you live here in 2020 in the United States. [00:56:09] So I think you can what you can do is help develop the mixing software so that you can be ready for the day when that happens, right? So if there's a big hack of Coinbase or of Square or whatever. And several million people's accounts get you know that information gets taken. [00:56:34] Obviously this has happened at other less secure exchanges. But you know let's be prepared for that so maybe in the next couple years these fine folks making these mixing these these non custodial mixers can can get them to the point where they're pretty easy to use and it just becomes like second nature for folks to like okay buy the Bitcoin okay mix it okay and then I'm through on the other side. [00:57:01] And if if 30 to 40% of the Bitcoin community is doing this like I mean good luck to the chain analysis folks seriously especially if a lot if if if folks are mixing and then opening a channel and going into light. So and if we've and if if if in the next couple years we've had taproot schnor has gone through and it's difficult to distinguish these things on the blockchain, right? [00:57:27] Different kinds of multi-signature transactions, right? So yeah coin joins are really easy to see right now really easy to spot but yeah I think they still will be I don't I don't think Schnorr or Taproot will make coin joins any less easy to see but but they will make light opening a lightning channel from what I understand yeah fairly fairly indistinguishable from like a normal transaction so we can hope for that and pay attention to the space and just talk a lot about Bitcoin privacy like all you know you'll get into these tussles with these Monero people and it's great because they're like either [00:58:05] By choice or by necessity they're like super into privacy and it's really good and you know what like I view them as really valuable because they're testing something like I don't know if you saw this I think it was in God what was it in optech or something but there was some paper that came out today that was like oh hey like it you know in bulletproofs you know when transactions like interact with nodes there's like some sort of leakage that happens that could de-anonymize like the transactions so I think it's really helpful that these folks are running these systems so we can see what the potential pitfalls [00:58:44] Are. Because I can guarantee you that like the Bitcoin community is not gonna add not gonna want to add any sort of privacy tech in a mean in a dramatic privacy tech to Bitcoin unless it's like a bulletproof that there's not gonna be issues with with monetary supply. You know what I mean? Right. And ironically like that's not the case for Bruce. [00:59:03] And you know it's great that it's on liquid and you can you can have CT on liquid and people are playing around with that is really really great and probably has some enterprise use cases too but we got a you know a couple more years to go of experimentation. But there's just you know who knows maybe there's an awesome announcement in in a you know 2022 or something like that where you know again someone's figured out a way to have a soft work where where we could start using a new piece of you know a new version of Bitcoin that that allows some sort of you know amount hide ability [00:59:41] And I know at the end of the day that it's kind of like you know we can only have kind of certainty with the with with the monetary supply we can't have we can't really have certainty with both privacy and the monetary supply so obviously we gotta we gotta choose monetary supply but I think we can get pretty close. [01:00:04] So I would look forward to that and I would applaud the Monero and Zcash folks for what they're doing in in experimenting with this really important technology and then at some point the Bitcoin community will probably add parts parts of that. I mean obviously it's already been added to sidechains so great. But you know at some point hopefully the wider Bitcoin you can start benefiting from some of this stuff. [01:00:27] I don't know what what's your sort of take on that on that kind of the interaction between privacy coin and Bitcoin sidechain. Yeah I mean I th I think it's important to have you know s some projects that are pushing forward privacy technology and I like I like to see that it's happening you know I like it better that it's happening on sidechains on Bitcoin obviously I'm not a big fan of other blockchains that just you know yeah I mean like the look the opposite the altcoin folks are doing it at their own risk like it's the money they're playing with and obviously it doesn't go so well over time. [01:01:05] I mean that like I it's just look at the evidence like the value of their exactly assets are decreasing but like I mean in Bitcoin terms at least, but but I think good, more power to them as long as they're authentic about it. What what you know, look, at least I guess all I'm saying is that there's obviously some people who are like so hardcore about privacy that they they can't deal with Bitcoin for the obvious reason. [01:01:30] I think the mistake they're making is in moving on to a different project instead of helping Bitcoin become more private. I agree. Yeah. Use of your time long term. Do you know what I mean? Like do you really think Monero's gonna be around in 25 years? Really? Yeah, really. It's a time preference thing for sure. You know, and it is it's fine that we're moving the ball forward, and like you said, that there are you know, people in Monero that are there for the tech and they're they're really like building. [01:01:55] They're not in it for the money, they're in it for the tech. Yes, exactly. And I don't mean that as a difference for profits. I mean it in terms of creating a new money for the world. So exactly. I mean the only reason you would leave the Bitcoin project to work on a more private money is if you didn't understand the money part, right? Exactly. Or at least to me. [01:02:15] So more power to them. I hope they do well. Be careful. I can't say the same about the other like obvious just profit coins like Grin or whatever, but Yeah. Or God knows this whole mimblewimble coin thing. Mimblewimble. Yeah. It's it's a dumpster problem. [01:02:35] It's it's tough, man. But hey, I mean I hope I hope I wish the Monero folks well. I look forward to welcoming the welcome welcoming welcoming them back on the Bitcoin train at some point in the future. Exactly. Yes but like they should keep pushing. I mean it's nice to see people with like really advanced privacy techniques. [01:02:55] Pushing forward. I just I don't know, I just wish they figured out a way to apply their passionate talents to making Bitcoin better. But but it is what it is. But yeah, I mean they're always like, oh, like why don't you like promote this as a tool? [01:03:18] And it's like well, because it's like unpredictable and unstable, like you know, at a base level, right? Yeah, it's it's an experiment. You're not gonna tell someone to be like, hey, put some real money into this thing. Like it's not like it's not money, it's it's not money, it's an it's a technical technological experiment. [01:03:36] It should be taken seriously, and it's it's certainly born in part out of a frustration about certain aspects of Bitcoin, but like it's not to be taken seriously in the same way. Is Bitcoin, at least for me, from what I've seen at least. But we'll see. [01:03:54] We'll see. We'll see. What else do you want to cover here? Yeah, I want to cover Bitcoin 2020, because I'm doing this series in partnership with them to kind of preview what's going on, get people hyped up about the conference. So yeah, you'll be speaking there. [01:04:13] Can you give us a little preview? Do you know what you're gonna be talking about? Yeah, it's hard to say. I'm trying to work on I have two possible things I'm doing. It just sort of depends on how the next few weeks shake out. But I'm working with like a new graphic designer, which is really exciting. [01:04:33] So either way, it's gonna look really cool. I'm either gonna do just like a you know, I've never spoke spoken at this particular conference before, so either way it'll be a new talk. It'll either be kind of like continuation of my what I've been talking about recently with regard to why Bitcoin matters for human rights, but like updated and revised and with new visuals. [01:04:58] I'm also thinking about doing a talk that brings to life this idea of like a world without Bitcoin. But obviously that's a bigger project. It's it's something I'll either I'm gonna do it at some point this year. I'm also gonna speak at at MCC and at at the event in Riga later this year. [01:05:22] So I plan to do this at one at one of these three events. But I'll try and bring this thing to life and do it with some really unique visual elements and try and just create a presentation that's kind of walking the audience through without Bitcoin. [01:05:40] With the knowledge, of course, at the end that I spill the beans and inform them that that is not actually reality and they do live in a world of Bitcoin grateful, you know. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I like that. So I guess I opened with the right question then for your for your talk. [01:06:01] Yeah, no, certainly what I was what I was thinking thinking about. That's awesome. So yeah, I wanted to kind of close up. I have a couple questions. We'll see if if we get to the second one. But you know, I know that you're you know, kind of painfully, I guess, aware of kind of the ugly face of humanity more than most people in your line of work with the human rights foundation. [01:06:25] I seem to gather that you're generally optimistic, but you know, if you kind of balance those two things, like are you generally optimistic or do you pessimistic? Does that because it kind of swing back and forth for you about kind of the state of human society? Yeah, I mean, how can you look at something like Idlib right now in Syria with these poor people or these affected hospitals in China, or God knows what could be happening in North Korea. [01:06:55] I mean, you know that there's a lot of cases in China and in South Korea. And we know that North Korea is in the middle. And we know that it's freezing there right now. It's like Siberian turkey. And we know they have the absolute worst healthcare system in the world. And we know that they have open air prisons and concentration camps. And it really doesn't take that much more to think about what's probably happening in North Korea right now, and it's really sad. [01:07:19] However, I have also met the people from these places that are that have survived and escaped or are rising up against them in a peaceful way to challenge the system, these future leaders of these places, and that fills me with just like absolute very aggressive optimism hearing them, what what keeps them going and helping them is like something that really really fuels Miami. [01:07:48] Yeah, it's important to remember that you know there's there's evil, but it's it seems that like you know, I think it's the quote that I'm probably gonna get a little bit wrong here, and you probably know it. But the you know, the arc of what is it, the arc of history bends towards justice, I think is Martin Luther King quote. [01:08:12] And I like that. I mean it's it's there's a lot of suffering that goes on, but the suffering it inspires the heroic efforts of goodness out of people and yes, but not necessarily, man. We're at the point where I think technology is shifting that paradigm. Like before the age of artificial intelligence, and what I mean by that is like big big data analysis, basically. [01:08:35] But before the year 2000, largely that was true. But now we're at a point where like if we don't take the right steps, the arc the long arc of history is gonna be pulling us straight into a panoptic. So we need to be aggressive about minimizing the amount of information that we reveal and leak about ourselves every day. [01:08:55] We need to minimize the amount of information that goes into the cloud willingly. We need to be more data sovereign. It doesn't mean we can't be more innovative in what we create. I mean, just think about what Bitcoin thinks possible. Think about what lightning thinks possible. It's mind-blowing innovation, but it it it is innovation in the service of decentralization and privacy and sovereignty, right? [01:09:18] So if we don't make the right design decisions based on morals and principles, then I think that arc of history is gonna drag us to a place that we don't like there. So it's a new paradigm now. The good news is that we have Bitcoin and you know, we have something to build on. [01:09:37] We have this digital network that is you know truly peer-to-peer and is programmable and is basically just gonna allow us to do some amazing things. Alright, so to sum it all up, then you know, if you were talking to Bitcoiners, you're at the conference, you're even you know having one on one having one on one com conversations, you know, what is your inspirational call to action for Bitcoiners? [01:10:07] My inspiration. Yeah, like if you want to inspire a Bitcoiner to be like, hey, you know, we've really got to get off the sidelines, stop being passive, be active. Like if you could put it into, I don't know, just a few sentences, like what is that call to action to inspire inspire action in Bitcoiner to really take control. [01:10:28] And like you said, like we can't be passive anymore. We've got to do something about it. Yeah, just just imagine being helpless, I think is something you should just consider carefully. Mm-hmm. Imagine being helpless. Imagine being in that world we pay in it where there is no other option. Where all of the transactions that you do and the money that you use and all the energy and time that you spend turns into money that is not only controlled by a centralized authority, but also digitally controlled. [01:10:56] So very easily taken away from you, very easily confiscated, very easily surveillable. I mean really if you think about it, money is is your time and your energy personified in a way or or you know kind of like turned into something. And if that something is now much more controllable away from you into the hands of somebody else, then you're a slave. [01:11:20] So imagine being helpless and now imagine that you can actually fight that in a really effective way. You have a tool that can fight that and you have a tool that can fight that for all of humanity. And I'm not exaggerating here. You can build something that can turn into the foundation for the protection of our rights and freedoms in an age where that very idea seemed inconceivable before Satoshi. [01:11:49] We were we were headed for really a dark place. But now we have this tool. We can build on it, we can learn more about it. Every day is a learning day, right? With Bitcoin. We can share information about it, and we can spread the word, and we can really just push, keep pushing those key core concepts of decentralization and scarcity and privacy and see where it takes us. [01:12:20] But I mean it I couldn't imagine a more exciting time to be alive. I mean, how could you not be fired up, you know? Yes. Yes, we're the cons the custodians of this this the wielders of this potent weapon for freedom against this you know reality that's bearing down on us. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I prefer to think of us as humble educators, but sure warriors of freedom works fine. [01:12:43] But that's that's the in that's the inspirational image. Stay humble. Teach other people how to stack sets, and let's keep going. Let's do it. Alex, thanks for your time, man. Really appreciate it. Looking forward to meeting you in person out in San Francisco in about a month. In about a month. Alright, man. Take care. [01:13:08] Thanks to Alex for joining me. Thanks, Alex, for your time. I really appreciate it. It was an honor to have Alex on the show. As I said, I'm really impressed with him and his work. Let us know your thoughts about the episode. Alex is at Gladstein at G L A D S T E I N. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin, of course, on the Bitcoin Twitter. [01:13:26] And that's the best way to share the podcast. Support it by sharing it out on Bitcoin Twitter. Ask your family and friends to check out the podcast. The website is citizenbitcoin.world. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin, my peoples, for sponsoring the episode, and to LTBN for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast on the feed. [01:13:47] Don't forget to check out Bitcoin 2020 just around the corner. Hope to see you there. Check out my merch store at layer1btc.com. Shout out Nick Ward. You can click on partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. There's cool stuff up there, including my favorite design, the Unfuck the Money shirt. And also check out Bitcoiners Best. [01:14:06] It's the open source shout out for this week. We curate the best Bitcoin content to get new coiners up to speed and keep Bitcoiners up to date. We just launched last week at Bitcoiners.best. We're looking for devs and curators to join us. DM at BitcoinersBest on Twitter if you're interested in joining our Keybase team. [01:14:25] Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.