Jesse Berger: Magic Internet Money - E109 Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-11-05 [00:00:14] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners all around the world. Thank you to each and every one of you for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. [00:00:33] Before we dive into this episode with a new Bitcoin author on the scene, Jesse Berger, we will check in with Swan. We're doing something really cool at Swan. We're giving away Jan's book, Inventing Bitcoin for free in an effort to spread Bitcoin knowledge and awareness of the best and safest way to start accumulating Bitcoin at Swan. [00:00:57] You can go to SwanBitcoin.com slash free book to claim your copy. We have it in three different ebook formats and MP3 courtesy of our boy Guy Swann at Bitcoin Audible. All we ask is that you pay it forward by sharing the book with at least three family and friends. We'll send them a brief email that includes the links to the various versions of the book and introduce them to Swan, the best and safest way to get started stacking SATS. [00:01:24] And all the Swan Force members out there, we've got a way for you to give away the book and help you recruit new bitcoiners so you can use the book as a way to get people to show up on your Swan Force landing page. Anybody who downloads the book from that page will be credited to you as a referral when they start sacking sats with Swan eventually. [00:01:47] So if you are not signed up for Swan Force yet, this is a great way to spread Bitcoin and Bitcoin knowledge. Go to SwanBitcoin.com/slash enlist E-N-L-I-S T to get started on the Swan Force. It's a great deal. You'll earn 25% of Swan's fees on their purchases for three years. [00:02:06] And your referral gets ten dollars of free Bitcoin. And of course, if you use the special URL, they'll get a free copy of inventing Bitcoin as well. Alright, finally, the Daily Buys Beta is underway. We just sent out an invitation to another 300 customers just a few minutes before I started recording this intro. Those are rolling out now. [00:02:24] Over half of the invites are out. We've got hundreds of people stacking daily on Swan now. If you want to get on that list, Swan Bitcoin.com/slash daily buys. And thanks as always to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. Subscribe to the LTBN feed for other great Bitcoin podcasts like Bitcoin and Co. Bitcoin Audible and what Bitcoin did. [00:02:44] Shout out to the crew at Bitcoin Magazine. They're putting out great new content on every form of media. Oh, and also check out FedWatch with my boys CK and Ansel Lindner. It's a relatively new podcast on the feed, but it's fantastic. I've really been enjoying it. Alright, let's dive into this one. [00:03:11] Jesse Berger quit his career in banking and finance to find something, anything to do in Bitcoin. And this is what Bitcoin does to us, right? It just takes us in, it subsumes us. It's like a black hole for our brains. Every spare brain cycle starts going toward Bitcoin. And so eventually he landed on writing a 100-page Bitcoin book called Magic Internet Money. [00:03:36] I think it is a fine addition to the growing collection of Bitcoin books out there. And so I wanted to get Jesse on the show kind of early. The book was just released like a week ago. I am happy to introduce all of you to Jesse Berger and his book, Magic Internet Money. Here we go. [00:04:07] All right, hey everyone. Welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. Still getting used to doing these live you know, but I'm having a lot of fun doing them. Last week we had Preston Pysh. If you missed that one, you can find it here on this relatively new virginal YouTube channel. I still have to like build it out and make it look good and fancy and do all the right things with the thumbnails and all that. [00:04:29] But hey, the content's good, and that's what matters. I'm here with Jesse Berger. How's it going, Jesse? Sir, I am doing great. How are you? I'm doing very well, man. I am glad that you decided came to join me today. We have a book to talk about. [00:04:47] I understand that you have launched a new book, a wild new Bitcoin book has appeared as you tweeted out on the scene. And you know what? I love this. I remember talking with Andy Edstrom back when he first launched his book. He had under a thousand followers on Bitcoin Twitter, relatively unknown on the scene. [00:05:08] And that was a fantastic discussion. And Andy has really taken off, become really well known and just his book is fantastic. So I love the fact that we're sitting here talking relatively early. You know, you're you're still you're at a I noticed under a thousand followers, which needs to absolutely change anybody watching now, follow Jesse. [00:05:28] I've read I've read through his book. He knows what he's talking about. Definitely worth a follow. So yeah, welcome to the show, man. And you know, let's hear first of all, just a little bit about your background. Like, what have you been doing before you got into Bitcoin? Yeah, for sure. So first of all, thank you for having me on the show. [00:05:47] I it's great to be here. But yeah, my background, it's interesting. I always thought of my background as pretty bland, but what when you add it up, it it kind of works for what Bitcoin is, and I can explain what I mean by that. I studied economics and philosophy when I was an undergrad. [00:06:07] I subsequently went to work in retail banking at Royal Bank in Toronto, which is one of Canada's big five banks. We only have five real banks here. From there, so not not centralized at all. No, no, there's five. There's nothing, it's not centralized at all. From there, went to a company called Macquarie Private Wealth, which was an Australian it's they're a big bank in Australia, but they opened up a wealth management arm in Canada at the time. [00:06:35] So that was back in 2011 for me. I worked there for three years. Managing stock portfolios alongside a portfolio manager as as an associate investment advisor. But I decided that I didn't want to manage people's money for a living. I've I learned the lesson while I was there that as much as investors will love you when you do well for them, they will hate you more than they ever loved you if you lose. [00:07:01] And I happen to have worked with a very sort of high risk broker, so I saw both peaks and troughs and decided okay, I don't want to do this. I'm I didn't think I had, you know, I didn't who was I to be managed managing someone else's entire you know net worth basically so that was not for me I thought the industry you know just the guys I was with I wasn't happy necessarily and so I left needed to change directions didn't know what I wanted to do went to get my MBA and that from there I went into management consulting I did some consulting for a bank in Canada for a few months before I ultimately went to a small company called [00:07:39] Verde Group where it were there was about 12 full time employees it was a small company but they were a very high performing company that they ran market research campaigns for very large companies so I managed the entire market research program for one of Canada's large insurance companies even more centralized there's only three big insurance companies in Canada so I managed their entire market research program for a couple of years and I left you know after sort of 2017 hit had a good run in 2017 but but my beginnings of understanding and learning about Bitcoin [00:08:17] And sound money began way back when I first started working in in retail banking I was red pilled on Austrian economics in 2007 in the wake of the global financial crisis and you know learning and thinking about sound money has sort of been at the forefront of my mind or the back front or the backburner of my mind for the last 13 years just you know depending on the different thing I was doing whether I was thinking about it a little more or a little less but in recent years it's come back with a vengeance and it's manifested in this book that I wrote. [00:08:48] That's amazing, man. So you have the background to you've been in the belly of the beast. Let's put it that way. Yeah, I was I was on the front lines of financial services for a little while. And you know, you got to see some interesting things. And just learn, you know, meet a few interesting people, have some have some interesting experiences. [00:09:10] I didn't talk about in in one or two of the other interviews I've done so far. And thank you again for having me again. I'm still getting warmed up. You were saying that I have less than a thousand followers. I'm just I'm just getting started. I'm easy, I'm easy. You know, you gotta you get warmed up for the big for the big guns, you know, the Marty Benz and the Stefanas. [00:09:31] I you know, I'm I'm the warm-up, I'm the you know, the batting practice pitcher here. Well, not to me. I'm I'm I'm still only a you know a single A ball player here, right? I'm still trying to make it to the show. But I was I was gonna say, for some reason, I was thinking about this recently. [00:09:50] I remember vividly working, so I was just a retail banker at World Bank. So if you needed to open a bank account or get a credit card or maybe do, you know, oh open a retirement savings account and invest in some mutual funds. Like I was the guy for that. If you were investing more than, you know, call it 50 or 100,000, it's like, you know, Jesse, kick it up the chain to someone who knows what they're doing. [00:10:10] So I was like very sort of frontline bread and butter. But I always remembered, or pardon me, I was thinking about this the other day, how when a client would come in and they'd have a check to deposit from, whether it's the federal government or the city, the rule was you just always clear the check. Like it doesn't matter if there was cash in the account the money was supposedly coming from. [00:10:32] Like the you just clear the check, and you know, there's this list that just goes on and on of bank accounts for the city and the country that are that are just in in debt. They're negative balances, and it's it always blew my mind back then. I'm like, how does this work? How how is it that they just have all these tabs open? Right. And you know, so it was interesting to be exposed to that right as I was starting my career, right? [00:10:54] As I was starting to question, you know, what is money? You know, we just had this financial crisis. I saw the US government magically come up with $600 billion to bail out the banks. Did they just have it in their back pocket? Like, like, where did that come from? So that sort of helped compliment, I would say, my journey. [00:11:14] Yeah. I mean, most people don't think about it though, right? And this is the thing. Like, most people will be like, okay, well, all right, they just apparently found that three trillion dollars somewhere. And just don't understand where the money comes from comes from. And I was that way, you know, and I think most people are. [00:11:32] It's just the way that money is managed now. It's been five, you know, five decades. [00:11:39] That's it. The government controls the money, they can print it. And now we're at this point where it's just you know, open, openly accepted that the inevitable end in this form of MMT is just like, hey, you know, deficits don't matter, debt doesn't matter, debt's forget about it, just forget about those numbers. [00:11:57] They literally do not matter to the health of the economy. All that matters is inflation, and there is no inflation, right? There's no inflation right now, according to our completely mangled and cherry picked metric, right? Exactly. Yeah, you can you know, if if if stake is getting too expensive. [00:12:16] Let's swap in a hop dog in the metric system. So that's the measuring system so that okay, now you're still we still cover the protein, but you're just getting a much cheaper product as a substitute. This is okay. Yeah, yeah. So Savitine talks about that. He's like, your ribeye in the CPI has turned into a soyberger. Yeah, yeah, exactly. [00:12:35] But hey, it's it's just there's that means there's no inflation. You're still getting fed, right? I mean, it's still food, so you know, we might as well just adjust it. I definitely sorry, you were I don't mean to interrupt you. You were saying before about how, yeah, like we don't often think about what money is, right? [00:12:55] That that's a question that not a lot of people ask themselves because I think we you know we've all grown up, our parents, our grandparents, the system was there and it seemed to work. There was no real reason to question it or be upset with it. And so for our generation, right? I mean I think we're we're in a similar boat here. [00:13:14] It's just it was just expected. It was just it was something you didn't you weren't supposed to think about. It just was the way it was. And you know, econom, you know, how to grow an economy, how business works, like it just uses money. Money is a staple, money is a given. And you know, obviously, Bitcoin arrived on the scene and was here to say you know, brought the message that nope, don't take money for granted. [00:13:39] You don't you shouldn't be taking money for granted. And thank I mean, thank God it's here. It's showing people what money really is, slowly but surely. Yeah, because it's it's hard to if you don't have the contrast, right? Like you can look at Austrians, Goldbugs, r Ron Paul. I almost said Raul Pal. [00:13:59] Ron Paul. Have fought that fought that good fight for a very long time and made very little headway. They certainly educated a lot of people, and those people were, I think, fortunate to be educated by the Austrians, by Ron Paul, by the Gold Bugs because they were, you know, more apt or more open to accepting the idea of Bitcoin, right? [00:14:26] And that's I think going to reward them handsomely over time. And that's great. I, you know, I'm happy for all of them. But for the rest of us, the 99.9% who don't know what money really is, and that we're operating under this fiat system, which is really just a currency that's imposed upon us by force. [00:14:46] Not a money. The store of value aspect of the US dollar has been is gone a long time ago. So it's not really a money, it's a currency. Right. We have a money. Yeah. Yeah, and big as Bitcoiners, we like to differentiate between money and currency, and it's a very important distinction, right? [00:15:06] When I in my book, when when I talk about currency and I try to sort of loosely define currency, I refer to it as a promise for some monetary good, for the actual thing that's valuable, the actual thing that's money. But obviously 1971, right? We cut the tie to the gold window. [00:15:24] The currency was the promise for gold back then. We severed that, and we've just sort of tried to make everyone forget about that, or they have tried to make everyone forget about that. Yeah. And we just trade these paper promises that have, you know, you can't redeem for anything. And that's a big problem because money is. [00:15:45] I was on a I interviewed with a gentleman who's a student at my alma mater at my MBA program the other day. He's he started a podcast because of the pandemic. He couldn't be networking with people, so he wanted to stay in touch with people. And I dropped this analogy that I said to him before I said I'm like, this is a really silly analogy, it's a really stupidly simple one, but it might actually be effective. [00:16:11] And the analogy was, is money something or is money nothing? You know, if someone can snap their fingers and just make money, it doesn't cost them anything, there's no there's nothing that goes into it, then maybe it's money is nothing. Like, why are we working so hard for this thing? You know, working so hard for it and then getting taxed on it, right? [00:16:32] Right, that we're working so hard for. We have this the spare change left at the end of the day, we're busting our asses for it. And the inflation. And it's not and it's nothing, and inflation, right? And it's devalued all the time. So it's you know, but it's nothing to someone else, to the to the entities that create money to them, it's nothing, but to you, as the person who's trying to earn it, it's everything. [00:16:52] So do you want to earn money that is nothing, or do you want to earn like something, something real and tangible and Bitcoin, you know, tangible may not be the best word for Bitcoin. But it is created at a very real cost, and that's important. Right. Yeah. So this is something I assume you learned. [00:17:12] I'm gonna put a I have a question, I'm gonna put a big and I want to dive back into the history of money because I think it's a fascinating topic, and I know you studied it for your book, but this is also a great topic. We take a little rabbit hole tangent here. The necessity to use energy, right? [00:17:31] Or real-world work in order to give even a digital or non-corporeal or non-physical asset or money value. Now that's an idea that is hard to grasp at first. At least it was for me as an as a new Bitcoiner. [00:17:50] And there's also the narrative of hey, this uses a shit ton of energy. Why are we why is that necessary? Right. And so answering both questions like why is it necessary to expend energy in the real world to give this digital money value? And why is it necessary at all when it you know it's just it's using all this excess energy? [00:18:13] Like it doesn't we have money without burning all that all that energy. Right. So I mean, historically, right? I we a lot of people in Bitcoin talk about you know, Buckminster Fuller and Thomas Edison, and I think Henry Ford as well, who referenced, or who wanted at one point, you know, a century ago, to create money from energy because I it's something that's sort of ubiquitous, where a unit of energy here is a unit of energy there. [00:18:39] So it's the same and it and it's also valuable no matter where you are as well. You can put it to use no matter where you are as well. So it it has that value for you, you can put it to work for you. So that's you know part of the reason that energy may or may not have been chosen by Satoshi as the thing that we consume or produce. [00:19:00] But in terms of you know being wasteful, initially, and when I say initially for me, I'm talking, you know, five, six, seven years ago when I was first made actually I was for I first heard about Bitcoin in 2011, so that's longer than that ago now. But when mining sort of first started to make headlines for Bitcoin, it was all about mine. [00:19:20] Oh, mining's boiling the ocean, we're using energy, we're consuming energy, we're consuming energy. Of energy as Ireland, the entire country of Ireland. I remember that 2017. Yeah, and right now we use something like 0.3% of the world's energy to mine Bitcoin. But to identify that one data point and say, well, now Bitcoin's a problem. [00:19:42] We need to turn off Bitcoin because it's it's just using energy and it's wasted. You're ignoring a few different facets what it if that's how you approach it. Number one, it scarce money, sound money. There's a social utility to sound money, obviously, for a lot of us. So that's number one. You're you're helping to secure this very important network. [00:20:04] But number two, as you know, guys like we were saying Marty Bent or Steve Barbour in Canada, we have these companies now that are solving for things like gas flaring using Bitcoin mining. And what that does is it is able to drive energy efficiency. [00:20:22] And so this is one of the things I learned while writing the book during part of my research was I think I found this from Steve. He put out I want to say it's from the World Economic Forum. I'm I might be wrong about who put out this data point, but regardless, the world burns 145 billion cubic meters of natural gas into the environment every year. [00:20:45] It's just burnt, wasted CO2 that that we just emit into the atmosphere. It produces no electricity because we can't economically send it to the grid. So we have to get rid of it, so we burn it. If you were to plug a Bitcoin miner on site, you it's very minimal infrastructure, right? You don't have to actually send the energy to the grid. [00:21:05] You can consume it on site, and now what you're doing is you are A, adding more power to the Bitcoin network, which has its social utility as sound money. And B, you are reducing CO2 emissions. Then the another part of that is the renewable energy argument, where apparently something, you know, call it three quarters of Bitcoin's energy comes from renewable sources, a lot of it located in China. [00:21:32] But if you plug a Bitcoin miner into a renewable source, which again is maybe far away from where it might be consumed, it's not economical, send it to the grid, plug a Bitcoin miner onto that, all of a sudden you are now funding renewable energy sources. To understand how Bitcoin is incentivizing the efficient use of energy is is difficult to wrap your head around, and I still struggle a little bit with it, but it's a really fascinating development that seems to be coming up pretty quickly right now and making its mark. [00:22:05] Yeah. I mean, it's there are two costs, right? So to Bitcoin mining, it's pretty simple. The business let the ledger, you know, whether or not you're gonna be profitable in Bitcoin mining. It's it's the cost of your energy and it's the cost of the machines themselves. Now the machines themselves are your, you know, it's hard, you're you're not gonna find much of an advantage on the cost of the machines over your competitors, you know, unless I mean some competitors might have like a special deal with you know a mining producer or something, and they might get a little bit of a of a discount, whatever, but it's not gonna be that much. [00:22:40] The big advantage to be gained is on the energy cost. And so it creates a race to the bottom in turn in terms of the energy cost. And so miners will go wherever's cheapest, and where energy is being wasted is where it's cheapest. And you're you're getting it for zero, very cheap, zero, or sometimes even being paid to consume that energy. [00:23:02] The energy, like once energy is created, right? It it sort of has to be used. Otherwise it it it you know. Yeah. Oh sorry, I just knocked out my earpod. It has to be used. Yeah, it's gotta be used. It has to be used. So if if it's you know an off hour, you can't send it, you can't send it around. [00:23:21] No one's there to consume it, again, by putting the Bitcoin by putting a Bitcoin miner with it, you can offset some of that waste and make it profitable. Yep. Yep. Or at least at least more economical, if even if it's not profitable necessarily. Yeah. So that's the energy side of the thing. Have you thought much about the reason that like how using energy in the real world gives this digital asset value? [00:23:48] Like it's required to give the digital asset value. And just you know, juxtapose it against and compare it to the alternative, the other plan, the other idea, the of using of a consensus algorithm, consensus system without using energy, proof of stake or similar ideas. Like you wrote a book about Bitcoin, you've become a big coiner. [00:24:09] I assume you looked at like these other alternative ideas, right? So like why in your opinion, or how did you come what what did you come to understand in terms of why we need to actually expend energy in the physical world in order to achieve consensus and provide security? Yeah. So for me, I think it it comes down to money being costly. [00:24:32] That that be a quality of money. And again, it's it's sort of, you know, is money something, is money nothing. Can we create it for free? With something like proof of stake? You know, they've been, if we're talking about Ethereum or it can be whatever, it doesn't matter, but with staking, those that already have money now can earn more money from doing absolutely nothing, right? [00:24:58] Just from sitting on it. In Bitcoin, that's not the case. If you want more Bitcoin, you have to earn it, whether that is through mining, whether that is through purchasing it at a real world dollar value cost or any currency cost, or providing some valuable service, valuable enough that someone's willing to part with Bitcoin for it, right? [00:25:19] So money being costly is a very important quality. And I think, and so in my book, I you know, we talk a lot about scarcity, fungibility, meaning like that money is recognizable, portability, I'm losing my head right now, and I can't remember the other two off the top of my head. [00:25:41] Scarcity, fungibility, portability, durability, and here I'll cheat real quick, just to fungibility and divisibility, of course, divisibility. Those are sort of five traditional characteristics of money. [00:25:59] And in my, you know, earlier days, you know, we talked about gold as being, you know, inherently valuable. And when you call something inherently valuable, I think it it misses the mark a little bit because inherently valuable is very subjective. Whereas something that is costly, you can establish a real basis, like a real world basis for value because it was a cost to procure it, whether again, whether you're mining, whether you're earning it, whether you're purchasing it. [00:26:29] Right. So yeah, that that for me differentiates from why Bitcoin can and should be more successful as money, and why staking, you know, can lead to potentially some some issues. If we're talking about, you know, it being money where you're you're centralizing money with the rich, right? [00:26:47] If you if you already have a you know a big position, you're gonna keep earning on that for doing absolutely nothing just for sitting on it. Yeah. Yeah, to me, it's all I've always thought about it as like a balance of an equation, right? Like if you have work on one side, right? I mean, it's the easy versus hard money idea in in you know, a Keynesian versus Austrian economics. [00:27:09] Like if you have easy money, it's easy to inflate away, it's easy to adjust the value of it, repeg it, debase it. If you have hard money, that it's resistant to those things. And if you want your money to maintain value over time, then you've got to have it be hard. And you need that requires there to be work. [00:27:27] And so, yeah, I mean it Bitcoin is pretty ingenious in that sense that you can, you know, take work from the physical world and transmute it into value in the digital realm. Just amazing and beautiful. So let's dive back into the history of money real quick, because you know, this has been this kind of pendulum between hard and easy money has been swinging back and forth for a long time. [00:27:52] You can go way back in time. You could talk about like the gold standard that the Roman Empire was built upon, the Denarius, which was kept you know relatively unlike debased for quite a long time until that you know, you have some rulers that come in that can't resist, or there's they overextend themselves and there's into massive wars and they have to fund it by debasing currencies, etc. [00:28:20] All the way up through, you know, the United States, which was kind of revolting against a system that was unfairly taxing the colonies, and so they wanted to control their own money. And there was a debate, very thorough and very well thought out, and very interesting debate about how to handle money at the beginning of the United States. [00:28:48] Did you go back and look at or study any of these guys' like ideas like Jefferson and in Washington, Hamilton, on the way they thought and talked about money at the as the founding principle of this country, and then you know, we can juxtapose it to where we are now. Yeah, I would I would say, you know, I'm somewhat familiar with it. [00:29:07] I'm I'm not gonna proclaim to know exactly what each and every one of the founding fathers thought on you know how money should be handled. Obviously, they wanted gold and silver to be money for the same reasons that gold was successful as money when when it was properly used as such. But to your point about the denarius and some of the other currencies of you know, a day gone by that have failed, you know, when you have the ability to whether it's debasing the metal content or inflating the paper supply, when you can debase if if the ability is there, [00:29:45] Then the temptation is there, and ultimately someone's gonna fall for it, and you know, someone's gonna take it. But what makes Bitcoin so special, right? For us is that there is no ability to debase it. There, there, you know, and so there's no temptation. You, you know, why would you even try because you can't, and you know, that's something that makes Bitcoin very special for us. [00:30:04] But yeah, it you know, the idea of gold sort of being inserted, gold and silver being inserted in, you know, at the inception of the United States was a very important role, you know, piece of its prosperity for a long time. And it's just sad that you know to see how it's unfolded over the last 50 or so years. [00:30:26] And beyond that, you know, and go and going back, you know, whether we're talking about 1933 or 1971, there, you know, 1913, the different, you know, big markers that you know were were sort of pivot points in monetary American monetary history and by by effect global monetary history. Yeah, it's just it's a shame what's happened. [00:30:47] It's terrible how we don't understand the ramifications of these things, right? We don't we have trouble as you know the population understanding all the downstream effects of debasing and destroying the integrity or the credibility of money. [00:31:09] Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it the history is fraught with the you know, the pendulum swinging back and forth and the I guess taking over of the power of the control of money from you know from the banking institutions or however in whatever way possible. [00:31:28] And a lot of times it comes down to crises, wars, for instance. So the United States was on a pretty solid gold standard, silver standard until kind of a biometal standard until the Civil War and the gold standard, silver standard was completely removed, and the government issued greenbacks, which were no get like did not have a promise for redemption whatsoever. [00:31:55] And then we had a gold standard again for during what the Bella Polk is called, you know, like the last kind of 30 or 40 years of the 19th century, going into the 20th century, and then of course Federal Reserve, right? And the idea is always that there are these periods of demand for money, and that whether they come out of crisis, some kind of business cycle crisis or war or social crisis, there's this demand for liquidity, this demand for money. [00:32:28] And if you have a fixed supply asset that is acting as the money, then you have you know, basically a seizing up of the system and it and it it causes the this economic pain that can be remedied by printing some more money or depegging or debasing this hard asset. [00:32:51] Yeah, well, it's it's palatable to print more money, right? Like it on the surface, it seems like injecting more money. Oh, you know, there's a deficit of money, there can be a solution. But you know, someone had had talked about how money is something you can't run out of money, it's like inches, you can't run out of inches, right? It's it's a measuring stick. [00:33:10] If there is a certain amount of money in the system, if there's economic crises, it's not that we need more money to solve it, it's that the resources are clearly misallocated. And if we're going to fix things, we need to re-you know, readjust where we're we're allocating resources, and that can create the balance. [00:33:29] And to do that, price signals need to function properly, right? We need to like clearly identify why, you know, where and what the demand is versus the supply, so that we can we can find that new equilibrium. But when we inject money, we confuse that mechanism, right? Yep. Because now you're changing the measuring stick. [00:33:48] And so, you know, as much as yes, there's there's always, you know, historically, understandably that that demand, oh, you know, rain money down on us. That that's not the that's not going to be the solution. It's a really hard sell, though, like you said, it's a very political sell. Politically speaking, okay. So like we need to be we need to take our lumps right now and not borrow from our future and future generations under the assumption that we're going to recover and make all of that economic value back up, because because we're gonna be able to recover faster, sooner, better and be that much further ahead. [00:34:26] And so we can't sell that, right? I mean, any like any any any government, any type of government, you can't sell that, right? You could have a monarchy, you could have an autocracy. They have an incentive to print money to ease the pain in the short term. That well, you just said it, yeah, to ease the pain and sort of appease the populace, right? [00:34:47] If if the natives are restless, you're you're trying to appease them, but every time you do that, you're just causing more harm down the road. And like you said, it's to create that very long-term vision, that that low time preference, it's extremely difficult, especially for just wide-scale population and you know it's it's great that you know us Bitcoiners, we now have this tool that allows us to start looking that way and you know it's our job basically to get more people on board to understand that you know if if we want human prosperity for a thousand [00:35:25] Years you have to build the systems that will endure for that time and the systems we have right now are are not meant for that. Right. So we have a system okay we society inevitably seems to fall into these fiat systems because like you said it's politically expedient the this the cell that we should be thinking seven generations ahead unless it's in a an extremely you know deep set cultural ethic like it has been in some in some cultures right that aren't necessarily as dependent on on trade [00:36:03] With like other populations right because that what once you start you know becoming dependent on trade with other populations which is the foundation of civilization is is how hum humanity advances how technoles you know technology develops so I'm not absolutely not like you know we shouldn't be trading but one of the you know downfalls or pitfalls of trading and then development of money is the centralized control of that money and if we cannot find a way throughout history and have not been able to find a way throughout history to resist the you know co-opting of the money [00:36:42] And therefore the you know, choosing the path, the short-term time preference, the short-term path to ease the pain in the short term. Which, like we said, like any any form of social organization that has some some relatively advanced like trading or economy of some kind are going to choose to have the incentive anyway, to choose to print money, debase the money in the short term, and not think about the long term. [00:37:13] So what we have now is something fundamentally different, right? We have something that cannot be debased, and has been proven to not be able to be debased over the past decade, to almost twelve twelve years now, since you know, a couple months until the Genesis block, it'll be 12 years that this network's been up and running. [00:37:32] And the 21 million cap has not been changed. It's on it, you know, it can't be compromised. You could fork it and change it, but it's not going to be Bitcoin. What do you think it becomes a cheap knockoff when you fork it? Yeah, it doesn't work, right? What do you think happens then? [00:37:51] Let's say, okay, like right now we have we have a crisis going on, just like we did in 2008. We're still on the global US dollar standard, we're therefore printing a bunch of money. What about the next crisis? Let's assume in a future, a future crisis where we're on a Bitcoin standard, right? [00:38:12] And more Bitcoin can't be created. What how do you see that playing out without the tried and true sort of instinctual like recourse to go to debasing or printing more money? Well, I don't know if I'd call it tried and true. Maybe we could call it tried and true. [00:38:31] We could call it tried, but maybe not tried. Thank you. Yes, absolutely true. Absolutely right. It'll be very interesting to see how people react to that. You know, again, we're we're assuming right now that we're in a future, whether that's five years or 50 years, where we're generally on a Bitcoin standard, and now we're coming into an economic crisis, whether it's because of natural events or just some dramatic economic change that that we're not thinking about. [00:39:01] But what has to happen then is relatively straightforward where the prices adapt. You know, things that were expensive may become cheap. Things that were cheap may become expensive. Yes, it's shocking. Yes, it's different, but it's the only way we can get back to prosperity again where we identify where the gaps, where the pe you know, where there's excess and where there's I mean where there's a surplus and where there's a deficit, so that we can rebalance and find sort of economic equilibrium to get back on that sound footing. [00:39:32] Accurate prices, they're the only signals that that can get us back there quickly and efficiently, right? When we distort the signals, that's how we're blowing financial bubbles, right? There. So we need, and the only way to get accurate signals is to have that very consistent measuring tape for money. And Bitcoin, because of its absolute scarcity, you know, we all believe is going to be that great, you know, ideal measuring stick. [00:39:57] Yeah. So I mean, I can see in the future when you have that crisis that people are gonna be like, hey, you know, and Keynesian scholars already blame the many of the devastating effects of the Great Depression on being on the gold standard, right? It's everywhere. It's everywhere in the economic literature. [00:40:15] Yeah. Yeah. And I get I get pushback on that all the time when I talk to friends of mine about Bitcoin and a you know, potentially being on a Bitcoin standard, and then be like, look, well, what do you do in a crisis? Look what happened in the you know Great Depression. You're just gonna ruin everyone's lives or like two decades just so you can keep a fixed supply. [00:40:35] That yeah, go for it, please. I was just gonna say, yeah, you know, if if you say, Oh, there's a Great Depression, it's gonna ruin everyone's lives, well, you're you're discounting human ingenuity, right? You're discounting, you know, the human spirit to, oh, there's problems. Well, if I happen to be someone who is either benefiting from that scenario or I happen to have means because I tried to be responsible in my yeah, you know, my financial life, well, there's opportunity for me to help lift people up and provide value to people. [00:41:02] And that's what gets us going again. But when we all sit back and say, Well, the producers of the world aren't gonna do it, let's all just rely on the state to do it because they control the purse rings. You know, they don't exactly have a reputation of being efficient or effective. And I don't think they can be, because they are distorting things, right? [00:41:24] They're they're taking money out of the economy and re and you know, using resources that otherwise productive people would have tried to use. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, go ahead, finish up. I'm sorry. Yeah, no, I mean I think I was basically that but but people's reaction, it's gonna be very curious. Sorry, I guess I'll keep going. [00:41:42] It'll be it it will be very curious when we do have because it it is probably inevitable that there will be some you know echo bad negative economic event if we if we ultimately get to that's Bitcoin standard, how people react and how deeply that understanding of you know scarce money has taken hold, and then how again, how people react to it, both in terms of the people who are have nots and the people who have, and what they try to do to create balance for the world and to get back to that sort of economic equilibrium. [00:42:17] Yeah. Yeah. You know, the other government or governmental interventions that happened during the Great Depression, like, you know, burning of crops or like dumping of crops, right? To try to maintain a price. Like you have these people starving, but they're trying to enforce, impose this artificial price, lower price on food. [00:42:39] And so they they they dump or dump a bunch of it, or for sorry, a higher price for farmers to be able to make money. So these kinds of so counterintuitive, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And just it it is this is why we need to have a money supply that is not you know a manipulable, but manipulable by humans, that is completely you know run by code and machines, because we just can't like it can't help but like we've got to do something. [00:43:11] We've got to do something. We're gonna do this, this, this, and this. And like, even if those desires, those plans, those ideas start out with well-intentioned, which I'm sure most of them do a lot of the time, especially in situations like that, it's we have to save ourselves from ourselves because that instinct is actually wrong, right? [00:43:31] In the long term. Well, I think you know, if we're talking specifically about something like burning crops, I you know, I have a hard time seeing that as the individual decide, oh, I want to burn crops. It's it's more like, oh, there was some instruction that we need to burn crops to keep the price up, right? I don't think any rational farmer would intentionally burn their crops, that why would they burn the thing that they're trying to earn their livelihood from? [00:43:56] Yeah. That that there's no there's no sense for that. Makes zero sense. Makes zero sense. And that's the effect of fiat money, right? It it it not only does it distort prices, right? It starts to distort logic and clear thinking. And that's sort of this, you know, second, third, fourth layer of effects of fiat money. [00:44:19] I love this quote that you have at the top of one of your chapters, and you pulled out some great quotes for the book. But this one seems applicable to the to the current discussion. The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design. [00:44:37] By Hayek there. Yeah, I'm we're we're lucky to have you know these guys to have come before us to give us those gems, right? Right. It's yeah, you there's a whole economic lesson in that one quote. Yep. It's essentially what we've been blabbering on about for the last 20 minutes in about 15 words, summed up. [00:45:00] Yeah, we you know it's it's this conceit that humans can manage the economy better than the you know the simple form or technology of money itself, right? Well we are just a simple idea, but it has magical effects. [00:45:20] There's sort of there's two sides of the spectrum, right? There's the side where we try to push all the power into the central hands, and no individuals are we're we not taking responsibility for anything? They try to do everything, and because they cannot possibly have the complete information, the complete picture of everyone's unique scenario, they can't possibly solve things for as many people as possible. [00:45:45] The other side is we try to empower as many people as possible to make their own decisions and be responsible for for their actions. And when you know you bear the brunt of your decisions, you are more likely to act in a way that is going to be beneficial to yourself and others. Yeah. And so, you know, I mean, you know, the election mess that's sort of happening right now is is a little bit of an example of that, where just we keep seeing this, you know, power accumulating in central hands every you know, year after year, election after election, the office of the president gets a little bit more power, a little bit more power, a little bit more power. [00:46:20] And every time that happens, we are disempowering the individuals who need that power most and who know what to do with it best, who have the most information about their scenario or their situation. Yeah, yeah. I was talking on Swan Signal Live about this yesterday with Marty Bent and Alex Gladstein and the idea of that we have we sort of have this natural evolution. [00:46:43] Again, it's going back to this idea of the pendulum and just kind of change natural changes through a history of phases, where you have this kind of revolution and a decentralization of power, a breaking down of those centralized authorities, right? And institutions. And you have this decentralization. So, like in the case of the American Revolution, we really had a pretty limited federal government, and we had decentralized power to states and to counties and municipalities. [00:47:12] And now that over time has has you know just slowly increased more and more power to the federal government and taking more and more power away from the states through legislation and supreme court decisions, etc. And that just sort of seems like the natural course, natural evolution, right? [00:47:31] And now we'll get to the point where we want to kind of rebel against these ossified centralized institutions that become rigid, that have become you know, just ultimately they be ultimately they become too overbearing, right? They they just they try to do too much, they push people into too many corners, and ultimately, you know, you push someone into a corner, eventually they spring back and they can't, you know, they've had enough and they need to push back on it. [00:47:58] And so, you know, ultimately that's what's likely to happen. And how you know it'll manifest in different ways, I'm sure. What you know, in terms of monetarily and socially, or economically and socially. You know, thank thank god we have an escape hatch. [00:48:18] Yeah. For the first for the first time ever, right? For the first time ever. And it's not just, you know, you and I in North America, it's everyone everywhere, the whole world has the same opportunity of if you're feeling cornered, if you're feeling like you know, your government's closing in, well, you can you can take a degree of power away from them by taking their their power of money over you away from them. [00:48:40] Yeah, yeah. It is absolutely a gift that we have this technology. And I do also believe that the kind of revolution that we're staring at right now is not one of political or social that will not be accomplished th through political or social unrest. [00:49:03] Political means, whether you know peaceful or not, or social unrest, although we're certainly going and are experiencing those things. But I see it as this kind of the cypherpunk vision of unstoppable technologies. Like you build some kind of magical unstoppable technology as your book is called the mat you know pulling on that beautiful meme from early the early Reddit days, the magic magic internet money. [00:49:28] That's the revolution, right? [00:49:31] And that's what we have to follow. That's what's gonna work. That's what's going to actually free us is this unstoppable technology and not an amendment or a Supreme Court decision or you know a certain president. And Bitcoin's meme ability you know may make this one of the most enjoyable revolutions you'll ever get to be a part of, right? [00:49:51] The fact that you know there's an army of us out here playing sort of 4D chess it it's it's different. It's I it's different from anything the world's ever seen but it's a very complicated thing to really wrap your head around because it's it's not just money. It's not just technology it's you know property rights and you know understanding the principles of freedom and why it matters like why why personal responsibility matters why that's inseparable from freedom putting all the little pieces together to get this you know to have that light bulb moment go off where you have this vision [00:50:29] Of that hole and that thing you know once you see it that you can't unsee it and there's no you can't put the genie back in the bottle either it's it's yeah won't it it that can't happen basically. The idea is out. Even if something happens so it's so it's it's going to be a very different kind of revolution than any other we've ever had and recently, you know, you know, listening to sort of everyone, it's so much fun listening to like everyone on Bitcoin Twitter and everyone on the podcast circuit talk about how you know this is the first time as well where global communication networks are still basically open and functioning or mostly functioning. [00:51:06] Obviously, there's little pockets. China, there's little pockets where there's problems or or block it. But for the most part, you know, we're all able to communicate with one another and reinforce each other's ideas and validate each other's ideas. And that's something that again is very different from what we've ever had in the past. [00:51:27] Yep. Yeah, it is. How did you get into Bitcoin, man? You mentioned that you found it in 2011. Yeah, and you were working in banking and finance. So yeah, tell me the story. Yeah, yeah, we'll get I'll give you my own little origin story. So around the time I switched from retail banking to wealth management, which was in 2011, I remember hearing about Bitcoin through basically Max Keiser and a combination of Max Keiser and Business Insider, I think, and probably Zero Hedge as well. [00:51:57] And it was, you know, call it trading at 50 cents, 25 cents a buck. I saw it in this little range. And I remember going to a few friends when I was when I was at McCorre and going, like, oh, should we maybe you know put 500 bucks, a thousand bucks, like we should maybe put a little money into this thing, because we as you know, but my little group of friends there, we understood the monetary principle of, you know, we liked gold as we were, I was more of a gold bug, I guess, but understanding that okay, sound money is is is an important thing. [00:52:29] Bitcoin replicates that to a certain degree. Mining, there's this predetermined schedule for coins. I had no idea how the underpinnings of it all worked. I under I knew it consumed energy, so it didn't come for free. And so I was like, Oh, we should put a little money into this. And then, you know, we all start looking it up for an hour or whatever, and we have no idea what we're doing. [00:52:53] It's like, even if we tried to buy it, a, you know, there's no exchanges, there's no easy on ramps. And then even if we did manage to buy it, we don't know what a private key is. How would we store this private key? We were we were completely oblivious to it. So let it go. You know, the opportunity passes, and then suddenly the price goes up, you know, five bucks, ten bucks, thirty bucks. [00:53:15] And okay, I guess we missed the boat. And so turn our back on it, you know, obviously see the headlines for the next bunch of years as it goes up and down and up and down. But basically, I didn't really pay strict attention to it in the years following that sort of 2011. I didn't I didn't follow it following 2011. [00:53:35] And then in I think it was early 2016, you know, Dan Top Don Tapscott came out with the blockchain revolution. That was do, you know, making its rounds here in Canada, and I'm sure in the US a little bit to some degree as well. So I started that a buddy of mine was referring me to it. I check out blockchain revolution. This seems really interesting. [00:53:53] So I started learning about blockchain. And then by dumb luck, bumped into an old friend. Oh, and I'm, you know, I was working at Verde, so my my most recent job that I left. Was working at Verida, and he's like, All right, I said, Oh, hey Brian, you know, long time no C. [00:54:11] How's it going? What are you up to? He's like, oh man. All Bitcoin Ether, like, ether is the most valuable commodity in the world that nobody knows about. And I was like, oh, Brian, that's that's a pretty bold statement. But you know, I'm I started looking at it as okay, I guess it's this like operating system for these decentralized apps. I guess it's kind of interesting. And so I started I sort of got started participating in Bitcoin, Ethereum from you know, as a financial market, right at the beginning of 2017. [00:54:39] So just dumb luck with sort of my timing. Yeah. And basically from there, the next couple of years are just this evolution of my sound money roots all of a sudden come roaring back. Me watching the shit show that ETH has sort of become, yeah, and all these coins where you know, I was you're trying so hard to a certain extent to justify the valuations of the of these things, like oh yeah, this decentralized Airbnb, this decentralized this, decentralized that coin, like and so that you know it starts with that FOMO, the excitement, but then you know, that fades to the back and the sound money thing comes to the fore. [00:55:18] And oh, oh yeah, like we don't want a million monies. How will we calculate what each one is worth against each other? What's the basis? Right. This is all garbage. Let's just have one really, really good money, and then the social benefits of you know, if we're gonna have quote decentralized apps, I mean, we don't even necessarily need some of them. [00:55:40] If we just have decentralized money, we'll just have higher quality applications and higher quality businesses and higher quality outcomes that come as a result of this. So a lot of the decentral XYZ that's not money, oh yeah, it's kind of it's useless. It's not really, you can't really justify it so well. [00:55:58] Like, like I still have a hard time now that I'm like thinking, I you know, when I think about it, I'm like, what really is the value proposition of some of these things? Like, you know, if you think about a computing coin, and I'm not saying Ethereum, I'm saying, you know, I remember Gollum was a coin that I had bought in my in my own. I remember Gollum, yeah. [00:56:17] They were like a file system thing or something. Yeah, it was like a decentralized like computer processing of whatever some nonsense. And sounded off. It sounded great. It's like, oh yeah, you'll only be able to pay for our services in Gollum. And then at some point it's like, well, they're also going to open it to accepting ETH. [00:56:39] And it's like, well, if they're gonna open it to accepting ETH, then what's the point of Gollum? Or now they you can accept Bitcoin. I don't I don't know if you can accept Bitcoin. I'm just saying, like, unless it is hard coded and enforced by the protocol coin company itself, that only this thing will be legally and technically accepted for its service, which you can't really enforce. [00:57:02] Like money is the only thing that can be enforced. You know, it's useless. It's the value proposition is suspect. Right. And so basically left my job in 2018, knowing that okay, I'd gone through the shitcoin casino. It I knew where it was going, I saw the writing on the wall, and I knew that I needed to be involved in Bitcoin. [00:57:24] And ultimately it was a little while after I left my job that I decided to write the book. So you were like basically you were able to dedicate full time to writing the book? So yeah, I had left my job. I had taken out like let's call it a year and a half of kind of runway money to okay, I know I'm gonna try to do something in Bitcoin. [00:57:43] I have no idea what it is, but I know that you know I have this background in money and investing. I have looked at the technology, I became a certified blockchain professional, not because I'm trying to impress any Bitcoiners, but because you know, the suits might be impressed by that. So okay, so I got that little designation. Yeah. And so I had this sort of mixed background, and it was all just kind of coming together. [00:58:07] And at first I thought, okay, I'm gonna try to put together something so I can explain Bitcoin a little bit more easily to like high net worth investors. I used to work in wealth management. I don't really want to manage money, but I guess I'll go back to that. I think there's people are gonna want Bitcoin, so why why not be the guy for that? And as I started working on this this project for explaining Bitcoin, basically it it morphed into a book. [00:58:29] Someone, a friend of mine, suggested, hey, this is a weird project, but make it a book and you might have something here. So as soon as I slept on it the night he told me, and then I woke up the next morning and I was like, oh yeah, of course this is a book. And once I had the idea of the book in mind, it was it was just a racist for me. It was it was it. [00:58:48] Yeah, like once once I knew, once I decided, I was like, I'm gonna write, I'll actually I'll tell you this. I told myself that I would write the impossible Bitcoin book. That's what I was telling myself. I was like, I'm going to condense as many difficult arguments as possible into this short, you know, into these brief little segments. [00:59:09] And not only am I gonna make them concise, but I'm gonna try my best to make them like really friendly and approachable so that if you're not familiar with Bitcoin, it doesn't seem intimidating. And so I employ a few different devices in terms of like the images and the quotes and things like that to just make it seem a little bit more alluring and not as daunting. [00:59:27] And then again, sort of very meticulously stacking the arguments one behind the other so that they come in this order that you're slowly bl you know, melting away the facade of what you thought money is, this thing that was ingrained in you, and now you're slowly realizing what money can and probably should be. [00:59:45] Right. And while I'm at it, I'm also gonna take my hacks at blockchain, I'll take my hacks at crypto and shit coins, I'll take my hacks at forks, I'll take the I'll take those guys out and you know, put my put my thoughts on those on paper so that we can dispel with those and move on with it. Because you know, it it seems to me, and I and I quote safety in in the book because he was the first to really sort of point this out for me, like the number one best and most you know commercially viable use case for blockchain is money. [01:00:12] Yeah, and Bitcoin and Bitcoin is sort of the perfect example of that. And so, okay, I tried to experiment that idea only, you know. Yeah, exactly. So okay, so let me let me explain that to the average person so that we can stop having conversations about oh, let's use a blockchain blockchain to solve this, that, or the other. And then again, the shitcoin casino with the incentive mechanisms are suspect, they can be changed on you, they're not consistent, so the rules of the game aren't set in stone. [01:00:39] Like, let's take those out, get rid of those forks. They're kind of cheap knockoffs. If they were if they were proposing something that was gonna be useful to Bitcoin, it would have been incorporated into Bitcoin, right? Exactly. Yeah. We rejected it, we rejected some of the changes, and they went their own way because we didn't think it was valuable. And lo and behold, you know, time has proven that I think we made the right choice. [01:01:00] And you know, Bitcoin has, I think unquestionably at this point emerged as the king of that domain. And it's it's you know, for anyone to even try to unseed it at this point would be foolish. You would have to come up with something completely different and new and just better on all fronts. [01:01:20] And yeah, which it's I don't think it's it's it's not possible, right? Because I mean, this is this is working. And it has all the qualities of ideal money so like you can't you can't come up with an idea that's better like in terms of an ideal money like you can't you can't come up with a money that is 10 100x better in terms of its ideal form yeah you can't and you can't replicate that sort of inception where there was no there was nothing before it to set the precedent right it set its own precedent everything that's followed has been an imitation of that precedent. [01:01:56] Yeah I like to say that you can only invent absolute scarcity once. Yeah exactly because if Bitcoin is replicable of value and value you know it's valuable that replication is valuable then it's not scarce anymore because in the future we can just create another one and you know you have a form of inflation which is you know the market choosing one money it's first is a product the fact that there's no you just can't make a substantially better product than Bitcoin. [01:02:29] And two the market is chosen and it's a it's a network effect. And so Michael Saylor Michael Saylor talks about how you know he made a bunch of money you know betting on you know networks that were worth a hundred billion dollars or more where their competitors are worth you know 90% less than that 10 10 billion 20 billion dollars the most and they've effectively won. [01:02:55] And so then you place your bet on that network and you watch it grow because of Metcalf's law, right? Which you talk about in your book. And that's yeah, that's why it's it's it's clear that Bitcoin is one at this point. It's been de-risked so much. There is no, I think, better point in Bitcoin's history in term to invest in it in terms of risk to reward. [01:03:18] It's the risks have been so diminished over the past 12 years. It it almost seems crazy to think about it that way, but it but it's true, right? Like it had to go through these trials and tribulations to prove that it was battle-hardened and resistant to you know forces that would try to control it or manipulate it. [01:03:37] And it's done that, and there's very large value in that. Yep. So yeah, even at you know, $14,000, whatever the price is right now per coin, there is unimaginable upside, which is also something you know to think about that that's just can a little mind-blowing sometimes. [01:03:58] There's it it's it's it's really the best risk-to-reward play that exists, period, right now. Like we're what do you what else is out there? And on top of that, it's available, it's accessible to basically anyone on the planet. Anyone with an internet connection and a mobile phone can buy some Bitcoin. [01:04:19] You even without a mobile phone, you can find a way to buy some Bitcoin. It is the yeah, the most accessible asymmetric opportunity in in human history, probably probably the most accessible and most asymmetric investment opportunity in human history. It's a it's just a once in a you know millennium species event. [01:04:41] We'll like we'll be telling our grandkids about you know these early days when we're, you know, Bitcoin was still five figures. Yeah. And we saw this opportunity, and we tried to tell everyone we know, like, this is it. This is the opportunity this is the opportunity. Like, there's no reason not to consider it and just have some exposure to this opportunity. [01:05:03] It's it's once in a like a millennium. I don't I don't even know how long. It's it's the discovery of gold, right? Like 5,000 plus 7,000 years ago or whatever, right? I mean, that that hasn't been unceded as the best form of money available on the planet that we have arrived at over and over and over again, you know, on a shilling point through through human history. [01:05:27] Yeah, 7,000 years, it's been gold. And now we have something that's 10x, 100x, 1000 X better than gold. And it and it has this, you know, this force field that just lures people in. And it, you know, it's very sticky. It's very sticky. Exactly. [01:05:46] Like, I, you know, my future for a little while there was very unclear. I had no idea if I was gonna be able to make it. But now I feel so good, you know, about what's to come because you know, writing the book was very much a learning experience as well. I had preconceived notions about Bitcoin, I had ideas about okay, the direction of the book and some of the topics I would cover, but to then explore them in sort of detail and try to really understand them as best I could, it, it, it really solidified my conviction in Bitcoin. [01:06:21] Like, like going through that process was proved immensely valuable to me, even even if I have made much money selling books. It's been immensely valued, which which is which is like irrelevant because I'm just I'm happy that I'm helping the few people that are interested in it so far. And yeah, just to have that conviction now, like that was worth it. [01:06:39] That was worth the all the effort that I went through. And it was it was a lot, it was not an inconsiderable amount of effort no writing a book is a really difficult thing just writing you know an any an article of a few thousand words is a very daunting thing to do let alone straighten together you know dozens of them I am in awe of some of the writers that Bitcoin has like we have some serious you know intellectual titans in Bitcoin and you know yeah I was able to write this because some of these guys you know they inspired the work that I did right like some of the ideas they put [01:07:17] Out the things like that like it it it's amazing it makes you feel so good to be a part of it and to sort of feel optimistic for the future as a result of it. Yeah it's it's very it's very very special. Yeah I hear you man the sense of hope and optimism is such a wonderful aspect of Bitcoin and it certainly has changed my perspective on the way our potential future and the path that we're on what do you what do you think you know happens like in the what's your everybody you know [01:07:56] Every Bitcoiner with skin in the game has their moments of speculation their fantasies of thought about how this all plays out and not you know Bitcoin is one of the reason that it works is that it has this fundamental incentive that plays on you know human self-interest yeah and so we, you know, although we are you know convicted about the potential good for humanity, about the you know privacy and freedom and all of those things that Bitcoin can really help, I think, bring about in this world or like, you know, improve in this world, [01:08:34] There's the money thing, the value. Like we are, this is an asymmetric the opportunity. And if there's going to be if we're right, a massive wealth transfer and us early Bitcoiners are standing to benefit greatly from it. So we all have these moments where we're like, you know, fancying what how this is going to play out. How far can it go? [01:08:53] How soon is it going to happen? You know, what do you think? What are your thoughts when you're having these moments? Again I'll I'll sort of fall back to you know the research in the book and the deepening of the conviction right you start to Bitcoin has this habit of forcing you to think further and further into the future and try to project further and further into the future. [01:09:17] And so yeah in terms of like wealth accumulation, you know, how much is one Bitcoin going to be worth you know obviously we all want to get to the point where it's not about what one Bitcoin's worth dollar wise. It's about what Bitcoin buys versus land or gold or art or other you know traditional assets or things that you know people just human preference we find appealing for for or useful so just very curious to like get to that point. [01:09:44] You know that's a generation more maybe away probably maybe less I don't know I'm but you know at least a decade but it'll be very interesting to see what the next you know five ish years holds how the transition of wealth manifests not necessarily among Bitcoiners because I think we'll as a group we're pretty consistent. [01:10:08] You know, we're gonna be, you know, obviously people are going to sell a little bits along the way because we're still in a mostly fiat denominated world, and you're probably gonna pay for your house or you know, your rent or your mortgage or whatever. [01:10:24] How we continue to hold and solidify our ideals and the knowledge that we'll continue to dig up and uncover, right? I said something about in the book about you know, Bitcoin has been sort of fanning the flames of monetary discourse. You know, we're creating new knowledge in a sense of money that was previously not there because we had no basis to think about it. [01:10:47] Now we have this new basis to think about how money can and should work. And so we've created this new knowledge base. So, you know, what are the next big ideas that come out of Bitcoin? I love it. So it's gonna I'm yeah, like I'm super super fascinated to see because things come out of left field all the time, right? Like, you know, I tried to come out of left field a wild Bitcoin book emerges. [01:11:07] What's another another set of ideas that that emerge as a result of all this? There's so much potential, so much fertile ground in Bitcoin. The base layer is just the beginning. We're seeing innovation on top of it. Lightning is really promising and really come along. [01:11:27] Really interesting addition to lightning called Lightning Pool was just announced from Lightning Labs yesterday. Yeah, right. It's kind of the beginnings of finance on top of Bitcoin, establishing you know a decentralized non-custodial yield curve for donating, not no dating, but staking liquidity into the Lightning Network. [01:11:51] It's these kinds of things just keep happening. And you know, layer three is happening, RGB tokens, which we're seeing a product called Atomic Finance, Atomic.finance, which is being built on the I'm from I know Tony from Atomic because we're but we're both in Toronto. [01:12:12] I met him actually I met him a year and a half ago when I started working on the book before it had I decided it was going to be a book. I was telling him about this thing I was working on. I'm going to try to explain Bitcoin and make it friendly. So yeah I actually it's funny you mentioned atomic finance. I know him and Matt I've I've met the team a little bit so yeah it's I mean it's just it's it's kind of the cutting edge man they're building on the you know the third layer of Bitcoin right now. [01:12:36] It's great to see and to them specifically those those guys are like 22 23 years old these are young guys who like they they get it now they really get it and they are they're super talented and that's one team in one office in one city and we got teams like that all over the place doing crazy things doing super interesting things. [01:12:59] Yep. It's amazing man it's it's really exciting. It's really bullish. I think you put together a really great book I think it'll be a good contribution to the growing canon of Bitcoin literature. How can people get their hands on the book? Yeah for sure so you can first of all you can go to Amazon it's on Amazon magic internet money a book about Bitcoin I also have my website www dot magicbitcoin book dot com and then you can follow me on Twitter at J-A-Y-B-E-R-J-A-Y. [01:13:32] J A Y B E R J A Y J Burj Magic Internet Money on Amazon. Add it to your collection, guys. I know a lot of you out there, you Bitcoiners, love putting together your the your shelf, the growing shelf of Bitcoin books in your on your in your library, your home library. I love to do the same thing. I'll be ordering a copy myself. You know, thanks to thanks to Jesse for shooting me over a PDF version so I could peruse the book before we had this conversation, but I of course will be buying my own copy to add to my personal library, which will be going into my chosen Bitcoin Citadel at some point in the future. [01:14:09] I'm also gathering from issue one, however many they print, the Citadel 21 stuff. So I'm keeping those in mint condition. Going back to like my baseball card and comic collecting days, I know how this works. All right, these are rare, scarce commodities, and I'm gonna keep them in mint condition. [01:14:29] And you know, it's gonna be fun in 50, 60, 100 years from now, we're gonna have our our little libraries in these like isotheric chambers. You'll we'll be amazed at what some of these collectibles might go for. You already see it with you know, I think there's two or three copies of the original Times from Jan 03 that are out there. [01:14:50] Yeah. Or Jan Jan 09, I mean. January 3rd, 2009. So there's a couple of them that are out there, and those are worth a pretty penny. Cassaceus coins, from the country. [01:15:02] Casatius coins, exactly. So like Bitcoin, you know, it's got its little collectible world and [01:15:08] Those are gonna be worthwhile to hold on to, I think. Plus, you know, the Citadel magazine, just you know, their art is wicked, right? Like they they put together some great material. I'll throw on I'll throw on one more little plug for the book. I've buried a lot of little Easter eggs, both on the cover and within the book. [01:15:27] So for instance, I you know, if you're not gonna see it very well, but I got the actual inscription from the Genesis block coming out in South. Yeah, January 2009. Yeah. Banks on the verge of the just what is money. I love it, man. That is the question. That is the question. As Robert Breed, I so it's funny. [01:15:47] When I heard Robert Breedlove first say the question, what is money is the rabbit you chase down the rabbit hole. He like connected the missing dot that you know I've been ruminating on for over a decade. Like when he said it just that way, not put me through a loop. There you go, man. [01:16:06] It was amazing. Breedlove has the has the propensity to do that. That guy, that guy every time he gets me, every time. I actually I tweeted at him in I forget if it was December or January after reading tyranny and the time scarcity of money. After he printed that, I tweeted him, I'm like, I have to change like three chapters of my book because I was not correctly accounting for the factor of time as it relates to money. [01:16:33] Like I mentioned low time preference, I talk a little bit about it, but like building things for the future, like that. This is like a real super long-term game planning with with Bitcoin. I hadn't he clicked that idea for me. And I changed like three different chapters after after I read that article. [01:16:52] I was like, just upended everything, but it was great. Like I made a write a product for it. So thank you, Robert Breedlove. Shout out Robert, man. Rob has been putting out some fire stuff, and actually his latest piece, Swan actually has started commissioning some work from him. So we're gonna try to get we're trying to get Rob to write 10 minute reads. [01:17:14] All right, like a couple thousand words. We got to we got the first piece out of him at 19 minutes, which is considerable feat. So hopefully we'll be seeing, you know, some more digestible chunks of Robert's thoughts on a regular basis on the Swan blog. And yeah, he's he's gonna be working with us a little bit more closely over whoever however long that we can make that happen. [01:17:37] But it's it's been a lot of fun to get to know him a little bit better. And you know, just the zoom calls, the meetings behind the scenes kind of getting things going. Like you said you set up like a you know like a one-hour meeting to kind of get things organized, go through some ideas, try to get an outline put together. And like three hours later, you're just like, you know, it's you just jamming on Bitcoin, right? [01:18:00] Yeah, we gotta we gotta get back to work, man. I don't know. Are we working? This is work, this is work, right? We can keep going. Yeah, yeah. All right, Jesse, really appreciate it, man. This is a ton of fun. Go follow Jesse on Twitter. And you know, just congratulations, man, on the book and welcome to the to the Bitcoin scene and the canon of Bitcoin literature. [01:18:22] Thank you so much, Brady. I really appreciate it. I had a lot of fun chatting with you today. Yeah, this was great. Well, I'm sure we'll do it again at some point. We'll keep in touch. All the best to you and all and everyone at Swan. Yeah, thank you. Appreciate it, man. Take care, Jesse. Take care. [01:18:57] Thanks to Jesse for joining me. Find him on Twitter at JBur J, J-A-Y-B-E-R-J-A-Y. And I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with family and friends. A great one to start with is episode 57, I believe it is, with Robert Breedlove, titled Bitcoin Time and Money from First Principles. [01:19:26] You can find that on the website if you go back into the archive citizenbitcoin.world. Share that episode in particular with family and friends. I think it's a great primer on what money is, on why we need Bitcoin, on how money and time are instrict intercably inextricably interlinked with each other. [01:19:45] And how fiat is essentially time theft. So all of those basic ideas, those first principal ideas are presented by Robert Breedlove and myself in that episode, and I think it's a great one to start with. Check out my merch shop at layer1btc.com, click on partners, and then citizenbitcoin. There's cool stuff there to check out. [01:20:04] And check out Swan Signal Podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal Live broadcasts. We're pairing up great guests for discussions about Bitcoin and economics. You can subscribe at Swan Signal Podcast.com. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. I really do love to talk to all of you. My DMs are open on Twitter. [01:20:23] I'm at citizenbitcoin on telegram. All right, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.