WEBVTT

1
00:00:23.840 --> 00:00:45.520
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I am sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. What is up, Bitcoiners? Hope you are all well out there all over the world. We are geographically decentralized, but we're all here together in spirit at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance.

2
00:00:45.920 --> 00:00:49.800
I've got another great one for you today with the incomparable Giacomo Zucco.

3
00:00:50.240 --> 00:01:34.400
But first, a note about shilling in this spot that I'm holding for shilling for future sponsors. This podcast has grown to the point where it could start attracting some sponsors, and I've been reaching out to a few Bitcoin businesses to start discussions toward that end. But I have very high standards. It must be a Bitcoin product or service that I already use or that I at least might be interested in using, and that I think is a boon to Bitcoin and for Bitcoiners. This narrows down the options quite a bit. So I've been using this slot to shill a Bitcoin business that I'm partnered with, layer one. And last week, I started shilling open source Bitcoin projects that I respect. I started with a read at the top here for Bitcoin-only.com.

4
00:01:34.820 --> 00:01:38.900
I'll keep this up going forward until I can fill this slot with a paid sponsorship or two.

5
00:01:39.360 --> 00:01:58.240
So if you're interested in supporting my Bitcoin education efforts and fit the above-mentioned criteria, reach out to me at citizenbitcoin at pm.me. And thanks for being interested in helping grow the diversity of Bitcoin education podcasts and content out there. Alright, that's that. Let's dive into this discussion with Giacomo.

6
00:02:06.520 --> 00:02:27.080
Giacomo Zucco is a technology entrepreneur and Bitcoin advocate based in Milan. He's a serial entrepreneur and has launched too many startups to list here. Similarly, his self-identification changes regularly and has ranged from a seven seven tall black women to CSW is a fraud to seven Asian teen girls, and now carbon dioxide.

7
00:02:27.080 --> 00:02:49.960
Giacomo likes to move from one thing to another, except when it comes to Bitcoin. He's the consummate maximalist and is in it for the long haul. In this discussion, we get into his time as a libertarian political advocate in Italy, his economic education, state-level attacks on Bitcoin, privacy, lightning network, and third layer protocol proposals to be built on top of Lightning.

8
00:02:49.960 --> 00:03:13.960
It was an awesome conversation. Thanks to JGetBTC, Prabjeet, and Fiat Jaff on Bitcoin Twitter for inspiring some of the questions that I asked Giacomo in this one. It's a great one. So let's dive into it.

9
00:03:14.460 --> 00:03:21.820
All right, I'm excited to welcome Giacomo Zucco to the podcast today. I have certainly learned a lot from you over the years, Giacomo,

10
00:03:22.360 --> 00:03:44.920
So thanks for that, and thanks for taking the time to join us today. Thank you for inviting me. So you've been a libertarian since a young age, and you went on to even defend libertarianism and debate it on Italian TV and newspapers. So, how did you fall down that particular rabbit hole, the libertarian rabbit hole, and discover the monetary ideas of Austrian economics?

11
00:03:46.080 --> 00:04:07.920
So I think that I started to follow this kind of topics and this kind of ideals since a very young age. I didn't have like unlike with Bitcoin, I didn't have a aha moment about libertarianism. It's something you know I'm always very, very concerned with logical logical consistency.

12
00:04:07.920 --> 00:04:36.720
And when people talking about politics, there were always something that was not quite logical, consistent about various theories. So I always tried since I was a kid to sit down a little bit and try to imagine. I mean, if I'm with you on a desert island, I can steal your stuff, but if we multiply the number of people who steal your stuff and I say that I'm good and I'm like the government, then I can.

13
00:04:36.720 --> 00:04:56.960
How w what is the difference? Like the key question for me since a very young age was about ethical problems of politics was the same question that Saint Augustine asked in his his in his writings, telling the story of this pirate.

14
00:04:56.960 --> 00:05:16.640
So there was like Alexander the Great who arrested the pilot pirate and he asked the parent, why are you taking other people's stuff? Why are you attacking people stealing their stuff? And so the pirate the pirate answered I do I do that with a smaller fleet of ships and they call me pirate and thief.

15
00:05:16.640 --> 00:05:36.920
You do the same with the bigger fleet of ships and they call you the king. What's the difference? And I always ask myself, what was logically the difference. How is like the Sicilian mafia, Cosa Nostra coming to your home and asking for your money in exchange for protection and services? So they don't come to your home telling that they are stealing.

16
00:05:36.920 --> 00:06:09.720
They come telling that they're offering services and protecting you and like managing the common good, and that's what they say. What is the difference between Cosa Nostra and the government and a national government, except for size and the degree of collusion in society? So the ethical problem of statism of the religion of state in which what will be immoral for an individual to do or for an organization to do becomes magically moral if the organization is big enough and it's called state.

17
00:06:09.720 --> 00:06:29.400
And then there was a little bit later on, I started to ask questions about consistency in the economic field, less less moral, morally relevant, but more economically relevant. I remember asking my father why don't like states just print more money so everybody can be rich?

18
00:06:29.400 --> 00:06:48.600
And then the answer was, of course, the answer was inflation, and so okay, so this I mean the fact that the government is printing money or only to give the money to some parties which are closer to the government, that's like stealing from the parts which are far far farther away from the government.

19
00:06:48.600 --> 00:07:18.560
So that was a very gradual thing. I think that libertarianism was most like was mostly a clarification of this thought, a systematization. So I started to get in contact with with people with with the same kind of interests and concerns, and I started to clarify my position, and I gladly discovered that there was an entire ecosystem and an entire different ecosystems focused on on those very same problems.

20
00:07:18.560 --> 00:07:40.320
And when you what you mentioned about television, that was actually a very naive period of my life. Around 20 11, I there was like the Tea Party movement in in in the US. And back then it was not about is not now it's conceived like well now it's basically disappeared and it was considered considered like a part of the Republican Party.

21
00:07:40.320 --> 00:08:01.360
Back then in 2011, there was the Rom Paul champagne, there was a Santilli journalist on television. So the Tea Party was more like a tax protest. It was not something more more strictly political. It was very like a civil movement against taxes. And so I tried to create a single issue movement in Italy.

22
00:08:01.360 --> 00:08:22.240
I tried to gather together people that was very different in in other kinds of political beliefs, but everybody was focused on on tax tax tax issues. And so I started debating politicians, and it was easy because I mean, because I mean w when logic is on your side, it's easy to basically get to debate.

23
00:08:22.240 --> 00:08:58.720
Yeah, and then Austrian economics, like you mentioned, you were kind of thankful once you were awakened to these ideas that there was this whole you know school of thought in political thought and libertarianism and economic thought in Austrian economics. Certainly had the same feeling when I found Bitcoin and I you know came to Bitcoin and spent my whole life as a default Keynesian, you know, just the way things are now, and you just sort of accept without questioning that the government's gonna control the money and that's just the way it is, and central banks know best, and they're gonna really help make the economy better and less, you know, less volatile, etc.

24
00:08:58.800 --> 00:09:17.960
Etc. And then there's this entire, you know, Bitcoin wakes me up and there's this entire school of economic thought that I had never really heard of. I mean, I heard Ron Paul mentioned it a few times, but never really you know explored it or studied it. And it's quite amazing that you know Bitcoin has this kind of real life instantiation of all of those ideas.

25
00:09:17.960 --> 00:09:41.560
How do you think Bitcoin has that real world instantiation of these ideas? How do you think it will change the global socio-political landscape? Well, for one thing, it is a tool that can help spreading these ideas. So as I said, I started to follow these kind of ideas for a logical and ethical reasons.

26
00:09:41.560 --> 00:10:02.760
Then when I discovered like Austin School of So of Economics, it was a good discovery for me because I realized that I mean I know that freedom is good and is just, but what Austin Schools of Economics also tells you is that freedom is not only just ethically, but it's also the only working system at scale.

27
00:10:02.760 --> 00:10:22.600
So it's also convenient and it's also effective. Freedom works basically. So that's a nice thing to add. But still, even if freedom was working in a way because everybody's maximizing his his freedom when when he when he can, still there was no recognition for this idea that were very fringe back then.

28
00:10:22.600 --> 00:10:50.880
It was very difficult to spread this kind of reasoning. And Bitcoin for me was basically after many years in which I knew what was logically consistent, but I couldn't really promote that effectively because the world was taking another direction entirely. Bitcoin started to actually become a like a practical instantiation of the same idea into something that actually works.

29
00:10:50.880 --> 00:11:13.200
It was like so libertarians are used to always lose because when I mean if we think politically, if we think about the political system, the political system is created by the state in order to manage the state. And so if you enter that kind of arena as a libertarian, basically you always rule lose in the in the long run.

30
00:11:13.200 --> 00:11:40.480
There is no way you can play the status game in order to enhance and increase liberty long term, it's just not sustainable because the game is is rigged, the game is like going to a casino to try to win. Bitcoin was actually the first tool to just bypass the game entirely and do something that works it was I think the first kind of instantiation of the agorist theory.

31
00:11:40.480 --> 00:12:10.080
So inside the libertarian movement and the narco-capitalist movement, there is this stuff called agorism, and the stuff called agorist basically says stop going around trying to win election to promote liberty or start stop trying to convince everybody to follow liberty, build tools that can be used following selfish incentives in order to increase liberty and decrease violence and decrease aggression, and that's the agorist idea.

32
00:12:10.080 --> 00:12:29.680
And Bitcoin is the first agorist tool that works at scale. So when you now told me that for you it was the other way around. Like you discovered Bitcoin as something working, and then you started to elaborate about Austrian theory and backwards compared to what I what I did.

33
00:12:29.680 --> 00:12:51.160
So Bitcoin is a tool that increases liberty but also increases the chances for people to question the status quo and to start to learn. I mean, when we see Bitcoin when there is no alternative, all our libertarian talks are just theoretical. So we have to defend this theoretical utopia where there is not a government.

34
00:12:51.160 --> 00:13:11.240
But when you start to build things that disintermediate and make the government obsolete, then you're not talking about theory theory anymore. You are showing something that works, and from that basis you can go back discussing and discovering the fundamentals ideas on which it's it's based.

35
00:13:11.240 --> 00:13:35.480
Absolutely, yeah. And it's it's amazing the you know potential for change that Bitcoin brings is is really I you know Hayek had the quote on a you know TV interview from the 80s that we had to find some sly roundabout way to take money back for the people because we couldn't do it with the state, you know, that we couldn't fight the state and it would just be a losing battle, as you said.

36
00:13:35.480 --> 00:14:08.360
You know, the rules and the incentives are set up to just perpetuate the state, and he knew that we had to have some way to get around that, and that's what Bitcoin is for us. Haig tried as well. I mean, he wrote a book about the denationalization of money, in which basically he proposed a policy, he proposed the nationalization of money as a policy proposal, but then it was of course ignored because it was against the interest of the establishment, political establishment, and so he realized that the only way to have it was to go around the state.

37
00:14:08.360 --> 00:14:27.600
And a similar prophecy was made by Milton Friedman, another guy that wrote a lot of papers about about how to manage. So people is always tempt are always tempted to try to propose the best way to manage things. But then ultimately it doesn't work. You don't have to propose a policy to the government.

38
00:14:27.600 --> 00:14:56.160
You have to take back the thing from the government, building something that works in real life. So do you think the Bitcoin can be co-opted by the state eventually? Or in some way? And if so, like how might that happen? So I don't think it could be done in in in the in a sustainable way at scale in the long term for the simple question that Bitcoin was designed in order to be in hard to co opt, to manipulate, to stop.

39
00:14:56.160 --> 00:15:24.480
And all its design principles are designed for that. All its features and its trade-off choices are made in order to make it difficult to control, censor, and manipulate. So if governments want to control and censor manipulate it, they have to butcher every feature, they have to make any trade-off absolutely inconsequential, and basically they have to take Bitcoin and to mutilate it until it becomes a worse version of PayPal.

40
00:15:24.480 --> 00:15:48.160
So Bitcoin cannot win being corrupted by the government. I mean, it's not impossible, but very, very unlikely because it bec it because it becomes it becomes something which doesn't make any sense anymore. So the government can try to kill Bitcoin in a way, and I think there are basically three main strategies that that the government could try to use.

41
00:15:48.160 --> 00:16:26.440
The first one is is practically very it's it's a failure for sure, which is total total war, like war on drugs. In that case they will basically make the white market adoption of bitcoin kind of difficult but they will will actually they will actually incentivize the gray market and black market adoption and that will be basically in a way it will be a pain for people like us that are publicly engaged with bitcoin we would have a lot of problems but it it will create actually a great use case for bitcoin because if you if you I mean when you run

42
00:16:26.840 --> 00:17:05.000
When you when you declare alcohol illegal you don't the you don't eliminate alcohol from society you just create a big big big black market and Bitcoin is optimized for the black market so that that's not going to work also that this is basically politically impossible because governments will have to coordinate around the world at the same time while nation states interests are not perfectly aligned so something which is illegal in China can be used by US and vice versa and also the politicians in inside the government will will have to will also have a

43
00:17:05.000 --> 00:17:32.480
Private selfish incentives to something different let's assume that China launches an order to size and destroy and destroy all the ASICs in China do you think that the single bureaucrat that will size millions of worth of ASICs will actually destroy them as opposed to sell them on the black market or using them and in a hidden in a stealth way.

44
00:17:32.480 --> 00:18:00.000
So there are like private incentives that the that make this first strategy very, very difficult. The second strategy is basically to make Bitcoin useless. This is what cyfediana most always often talks about recently in Riga, for example. If the governments started to get back to private money, to dark money and to hard money, then Bitcoin will just become completely useless.

45
00:18:00.000 --> 00:18:29.040
So if the style if the government stops manipulating the money supply, they stop manipulating the interest rates, they stop creating inflation, and if they also stop censoring international transactions, confiscating money from bank accounts, of course, nobody will use Bitcoin because in that case, if the government go goes back to a gold standard with total financial freedom and financial privacy, there is no reason at all to use Bitcoin.

46
00:18:29.040 --> 00:18:52.400
So that will actually kill Bitcoin or anyway make Bitcoin almost irrelevant. But that's still a win. I mean, that's I'm I'm sad for my for my sets because they will not be worth anything. So it would be poorer but happier because the government basically stopped bothering me and Bitcoin wins anyway, not by providing the solution but by eliminating the problem.

47
00:18:52.400 --> 00:19:17.360
But this is another politically unfeasible scenario. I mean, especially now where the world debt is is is out of control, skyrocketing, and central banks are pushing for negative interest rates in order to keep the system running somehow, and they have to build out banks and to create distortion continually in order to avoid a recession.

48
00:19:17.360 --> 00:19:55.640
So everything is on the on the brink of another collapse eventually, and government cannot just get back. It's like government govern world governments are like junkies they are like addicts yeah and they cannot stop drug right now they can only increase the doses they can only increase the heroin shots because they want to pretend to feel healthy again again they are they have some withdrawal crisis and they have to increase and increase the monetary drug so they if you if you look about that the kind of financial regulation is stricter

49
00:19:55.640 --> 00:20:33.800
Today than it was in the 90s there are no tax havens anymore there is like fatka automatic financial information so they're trying to reduce financial privacy and to reduce money soundness so the second scenario is also in basically impossible so b before you dive into the third scenario one thought that I have about that because I you know I've definitely read that argument from Savedin that the only way the governments could really you know stop Bitcoin or one way or maybe the most likely way I guess is the way he puts it is that they go back on a gold standard and that might make Bitcoin irrelevant one thought that I've had on that when I've heard that you know throughout the years

50
00:20:33.960 --> 00:21:12.000
Is that you know the trust in government is so broken at this point that Bitcoin might still even in even in the case the you know improbable case that governments would re-adopt hard money for base money that the trust is so broken the public would be like I'm just gonna stick with Bitcoin I don't trust you guys to maintain that that standard you know yeah I agree the second scenario is a possibility but even so it's unlikely that they try that, and even if they try, it's not say that they manage to do that the only reason it's I mean maybe you don't go back to government money, but that can kill Bitcoin anyway,

51
00:21:12.040 --> 00:21:50.400
Because a situation, a scenario which is basically impossible, in which the government stops being interventionist and active in the monetary field, then maybe we will switch the Cyfedian's argument is that we may switch from Bitcoin to some kind of new e-gold, like private digital money backed on gold, so a private digital gold standard may provide better solutions than Bitcoin short term, maybe not, because the Bitcoin is is optimized to fight external manipulations, but also internal manipulation,

52
00:21:50.400 --> 00:22:12.080
Like there are incentives that keep internal players honest. So it's debatable if in case the let's say let's imagine the Federal Reserve and IRS just they just say we don't care about your money anymore, you can use whatever kind of money you want, they destroy legal tender laws and monopoly laws, and you can just issue private money.

53
00:22:12.080 --> 00:22:47.040
In that case, maybe some kind of e-gold could take over Bitcoin, but maybe not, as you said. And yeah, that the third scenario is instead a very soft manipulation in which you don't try to crack down Bitcoin, you don't make Bitcoin irrelevant by by making it like not needed, but you basically do something in between, trying to corrupt to co opt it in a in a in a soft and gradual way, which is a little bit what governments did with the internet.

54
00:22:47.040 --> 00:23:07.960
So the internet protocol was basically unstoppable in the 90s. Instead of trying to ban the internet, they I don't think it was like a conspiracy, I think it happened just naturally. But in the 90s, they just left Bitcoin go unchecked. Sorry, the internet go and expand and increase unchecked.

55
00:23:07.960 --> 00:23:37.800
So people got a lot of enthusiasm about that and they stopped caring about robustness and anti-fragility and security privacy because nobody was attacking the internet in the 90s. So people, the industry that was built around the dot-com and the web fancy hype during the late 90s and the beginning of 2000, it was an environment which was not really using adversarial thinking.

56
00:23:37.800 --> 00:23:58.920
There was no, I mean, nobody was thinking about censorship. The guy who created e-gold, he was not thinking he would end up in jail after 10 years of e-gold. And people building DNS system, they were not imagining governments taking over the DNS system in order to censor to censor websites.

57
00:23:58.920 --> 00:24:37.160
And the people working on IP, they were not really thinking about government agencies spying on on political opponents and so making making necessary stuff like Tor, etc. So the internet was developed the was mostly developed on his commercial side, during a peaceful era in which it looked like the government was not going to attack, and then the government is mostly attacking now, trying to spy on people now, trying to shut down websites in in Turkey, China, the Great Firewall, the

58
00:24:37.480 --> 00:24:57.760
DNS destruction. Now now they want to censor anonymous communication on a newspaper website. So like in the UK, in the UK, they are actually banning porn or taxing porn or something like that. So they want to take over the control of the internet right now.

59
00:24:57.760 --> 00:25:21.200
Which is this mixed strategy is basically a middle ground between the first and the second. In the first one, the total war, you basically lose because you lose control and you incentivize the need for the solution. In the second strategy, which is just defeat and conceding victory, you make it irrelevant by basically allowing it.

60
00:25:21.200 --> 00:25:59.680
In this case, it's a little bit you know the Mao Zetung idea. There was this there was this stuff in in a cultural revolution revolution in China in which they decided to leave everybody free to express for a few years. So everybody was like writing poems, criticizing the government, and state bureaucrats they they didn't they didn't kill these people, they just signed down the names, they started to list the names, and for many years the this kind of freedom, apparent freedom, went on, and everybody was exposing them themselves

61
00:25:59.840 --> 00:26:30.360
Because there was no enemy, there was no threat, no clear adversarial. And then after a while, after a few years, you crack down everyone everybody because they are they are taken by surprise, they don't expect it. So the third element will be basically, that. You for example, you allow Bitcoin as a payment system, you focus on the payment the payment easiness, but you make people forget about the importance of storing the keys, of running full notes.

62
00:26:30.360 --> 00:26:56.120
So everybody ends up using Bitcoin with an exchange. And so when the majority of the population is using Bitcoin toward exchanges, you arrive, and now you regulate exchanges and you are trapped most of the market with you. So this this scenario is the most frightening. What is not really, I mean, I'm not super concerned because this kind of scenario requires a very strong coordination, a very and a very long-run thinking by the government.

63
00:26:56.120 --> 00:27:16.520
And I think that modern bankrupt democracies they are very aggressive in the short run, but they are not very good at planning for the long run. In a way, they are especially in the West, they are like driven by super short-term incentives. So I don't see a politician organizing like this kind of Bitcoin trap for 10 years.

64
00:27:16.520 --> 00:27:36.600
Maybe some state agency can have this kind of long-term singing thinking. So I would not be surprised if if some of the attacks against Bitcoin were actually partially coordinated or helped or pushed or leveraged by state agencies. Yeah, it makes me think of a couple of well-known Bitcoin forks.

65
00:27:36.600 --> 00:28:10.120
Yeah, there was a talk I gave in Prague, I think two years ago, it was like political attacks on Bitcoin, and I basically listed this you can find it on YouTube, and I was imagining what if for example, the part of the big block so-called big block ideology or big block opinion is actually I mean it is not something I'm really stating, but I'm playing with the idea that it could be some kind of psyop against Bitcoin, and that's not so unrealistic.

66
00:28:10.120 --> 00:28:30.320
Yeah, I agree. I agree. All right, I think that was a great summary of potential state attacks or approaches to attack Bitcoin. Let's shift gears to privacy. And I'll start with a softball because I find that the initial reaction from many people when I talk about privacy is why do I need privacy?

67
00:28:30.320 --> 00:29:08.400
I have nothing to hide. So why why is privacy important? Well, basically privacy is important because we cannot we can be good people, but we cannot live under the assumption that everybody around us is good people. That's just that just that's from the very innocent and everyday things like we can have like jealous friends, or we can have unfair business competitors, we can have like jilo jealous ex-wives or ex husbands, we can have we can fight with

68
00:29:08.400 --> 00:29:33.920
Siblings or parents. So even without having without thinking about criminals, the privacy is a necessity because we need wars, we need barriers, we cannot really live on a on on a glass house. I mean nobody was goes around sharing their private bank credentials or or giving away the keys for its own.

69
00:29:33.920 --> 00:29:53.680
If you do, basically you will take an advantage of from from the people around you first, and then from some evil people that do exist in the world. So a realistic attitude toward the world is even if I'm good and I have nothing I should be ashamed of, there is somebody who will actually try to take my stuff.

70
00:29:53.680 --> 00:30:19.960
And that's that's always true, especially in big in big in big cities, or but but basically everywhere. You cannot leave your door open forever without somebody entering and taking your stuff. So you need to hide, you need to protect some parts of your life. And also the reason that that you have to do that is that not only random rogue criminals will try to hurt you, but also very well organized governments will do the same.

71
00:30:19.960 --> 00:30:53.880
We always I mean sometimes I sometimes I as I listen to people saying that if you don't do anything illegal, then you're okay. But the point about the word illegal is that it does really mean everything and nothing and nothing at the same time. So every single action that we do, every single action that I did today was illegal under certain circumstances, was illegal today in some parts of the world, and was certainly illegal somewhere in some ages before now.

72
00:30:53.880 --> 00:31:14.600
So I drink wine, and wine was and alcohol is illegal in some countries. I was in a car with a woman driving, and women driving is illegal in some countries. I moved my money without asking for permission, and that's illegal almost everywhere right now. And everything you do during your day is illegal someday.

73
00:31:14.600 --> 00:31:34.040
There is this conception that the legislation is like an abstract, fair, immutable, obvious thing in the in the ether. That's maybe that's the natural law, that's the human rights are like something immutable, existent as a logical constraint.

74
00:31:34.040 --> 00:31:56.320
But legislation, political legislation, is not an abstract thing, it's a thing that depends on the moment and the place and the circumstances and the also the political will. So, right now, if you if you don't if you don't tell the government what what kind of money you have in this bank account, nothing happens.

75
00:31:56.320 --> 00:32:22.880
But tomorrow, when the government is bankrupt because of the debt and they are searching for money everywhere because they are in big trouble, they will retroactively come to take your money and they will hurt you financially or physically if you don't comply. So we are talking about people with guns that want to tell you how to manage your property, and if you don't, they will try to take your property, and if you resist, they will try to kidnap you, and if you resist, they will actually kill you.

76
00:32:22.880 --> 00:33:00.960
It's not like when you talk about legislation, we are not talking about like people sharing opinions. We are talking ultimately about people threatening to kill you if you don't comply. Right. So privacy is important because everything can be illegal, and in China, talking about the massacre of Tiananmen Square is illegal, and in and in Hong Kong right now, walking with an umbrella to protest is is illegal, and in Venezuela, basically doing everything can get you killed, and in and in Saudi Arabia being a woman and doing basically everything is is illegal.

77
00:33:00.960 --> 00:33:24.360
And there is there is basically I mean, even I remember telling this stuff on Twitter a few a few weeks ago, and somebody asked somebody answered, yeah, but what about sleeping? Sleeping is never illegal. So we started to search for all the regulations that make sleeping illegal under certain circumstances, which is basically you can find it for any human activity.

78
00:33:24.360 --> 00:33:45.960
Everything is illegal. So, as you mentioned earlier, TCPIP did not have privacy baked in from the beginning. So, what are your thoughts on improving layer one privacy for Bitcoin? Do you think it's a good idea worth pursuing or not because it can harm the ability to verify the supply? And we can just you know make do with privacy on subsequent layers like Lightning Network.

79
00:33:45.960 --> 00:34:07.000
So the definition of first layer is somehow ambiguous because, for example, for we know that off-chain things like lighting network or script script scripts or must, so all the kind of techniques in which you don't put the data on chain are better from a privacy point of view.

80
00:34:07.000 --> 00:34:33.480
But what about things like snor signal to aggregation where where actually you go on chain with less and less information about what you are doing? So is it's like this kind of techniques can not just create a parallel environment like a second layer where you have some privacy, but they can also seriously increase the privacy of the of the first layer.

81
00:34:33.480 --> 00:34:55.080
So, what I'm saying here is that if you create second layer-based privacy, you are making the first the first layer, the layer one, more private and more fungible. Let's imagine so an important thing would be basically JNAR signature aggregation cross-input, because with that kind of situation, what you have is that right now you do a coin join.

82
00:34:55.080 --> 00:35:14.520
So you coin join with other people, and basically you have to coordinate the coin join, you have to fix the amounts because the amounts have to be all the same. So you have a lot of problems for the for the coin join. You have to pay for liquidity of the guy providing liquidity for the outputs, the output amounts, but you don't gain anything except for privacy.

83
00:35:14.640 --> 00:35:33.120
For so basically, only people who are aware of privacy problems will coin join. But imagine a situation in which if you coin join, you can add up all the signatures of all the inputs into one single signature, and then you can basically save a lot of money in fees.

84
00:35:33.120 --> 00:36:11.360
So that's a we can call it a layer two development because basically you are keeping the single signature off-chain and you are just putting on-chain the final aggregate signatures. But what actually happens is that people on the first layer is incentivized to coin join always because you can choose to spend more money to send your input to with the one output and one change, or you can save money by mixing your input with other I don't know, other 50 or 30 inputs, and then you save

85
00:36:11.360 --> 00:36:31.440
Money because you aggregate all the signatures with with North signature. That's a layer one improvement. The same thing goes for for lighting. So, for example, right now we do we can do chain analysis because every time there is a transaction, typically there is my input, the output to you, and then there is a change back to me.

86
00:36:31.440 --> 00:37:04.360
But what if every output is always an opening of a lightning channel? And so when I have to when I have a UTXO with let's say I have I don't know three million sats, and I have to pay you two million sets. And instead of sending you the output, instead instead of spending three million, sending you two million, and sending me back one million, I just open a channel with three millions, and I give to you two millions over three in the off-chain state.

87
00:37:04.360 --> 00:37:31.160
That's also a first layer improvement. It's not not just a sec separate environment in which we have more privacy. This the second layer privacy falls back to the first layer, making the first layer more private. Of course, there are direct obfuscation techniques like confidential transactions, but I'm a little bit more skeptical of that because one, it's it's very new and very bleeding edgy technology.

88
00:37:31.160 --> 00:37:58.760
So and that's always a problem for Bitcoin because first of all, it's also the reason Bitcoin didn't start with Schnorr in the first place, because when Satoshi started, Schnorr signatures were just out of the patent, and so nobody was using them in the industry. So there were not standard library, there was no no formal investigation of security, there was no no no rich implementation competition.

89
00:37:58.760 --> 00:38:19.640
So you have to wait. So when you use something in production in a critical system like Bitcoin, you cannot just put there and put there the bleeding edge stuff that is the shiny new thing that that is coming out right now. You have to put there something which is bottle tested, proven, studied, attacked for many years, resisting attacks for many years.

90
00:38:19.640 --> 00:38:48.880
So you have to go with something that works a lot. Now, Schnorr is coming to get closer to that stage, while things like confidential transactions are still very, very far away, also because as they are just now, so co things like confidential transactions are the opposite of things like signature aggregation or script script or lightning network, in the sense that the letter, the letter, they they work by omission.

91
00:38:49.120 --> 00:39:11.600
So I will not give some information to the to the global consensus. I will keep some information private and I will write on the blockchain only a small subset of the information. So that's not only improves privacy, but also improves scalability, because basically we are we are you are sharing less data with the global consensus.

92
00:39:11.600 --> 00:39:31.840
While stuff like ring signature or a confidential confidential transaction, they are the opposite. They are they work by obfuscation, not by omission. That means that you share the same amount of information, but in order to protect yourself, you basically make this information cryptographically obfuscated.

93
00:39:31.840 --> 00:40:02.880
So you have to share all the information that you shared before, but more because now you also have all the space taken up by the obfuscation layer. So you have transactions that are bigger, you have transactions that are slower to verify, so you start to have a lot of trade-offs about with the scalability and decentralization because I mean bigger signatures and slower signature means more cost to run a full node and higher and reduce blocks block space for for transactions.

94
00:40:02.880 --> 00:40:28.400
So there is a trade-off between scalability and these and these and this kind of privacy gain. And also, as you mentioned, there is also a security versus privacy trade-off. If you do something like confidential transactions, the amount are obfuscated, and so checking, for example, against an inflation bug becomes tricky.

95
00:40:28.400 --> 00:40:47.960
Right now, if there is any of if there is any inflation bug, first of all, is it's more difficult to have an inflation bug because the code to do X minus X minus Y equals zero or more than zero is super trivial.

96
00:40:47.960 --> 00:41:09.320
While the code to check against some kind of cryptographical assumption is way more complex. The cryptographical assumption itself is is more is less secure because maybe against this mitological quantum computers. I mean, the there could be some kind of development that will break this cryptographical assumption.

97
00:41:09.320 --> 00:41:27.880
And also if they are broken, right now everybody can see the total supply of Bitcoin immediately. While with confidential transactions, that will be impossible to detect for for a while. And when it's detected, it's it's a bit a big problem because you don't know when it happened exactly and how it happened exactly.

98
00:41:27.880 --> 00:41:51.560
So there is a trade-off between scalability and a trade-off between security. I think that this trade-off will be eventually mitigated and minimized in the future, but the problem is that when that happens, maybe it will be too too late to change the protocol significantly, because the base protocols in technology they have to ossify eventually.

99
00:41:51.560 --> 00:42:11.000
It's like TCPAP version six. It's cool, but now the world is based on version four. Everything is on version four, like hardware, big company infrastructures, so you cannot just migrate easily to a new protocol. And with Bitcoin, that's even more true.

100
00:42:11.000 --> 00:42:30.560
And so the point is that now it's probably too soon to switch to those kind of let's say amount of obfuscation techniques. While in the future it will probably be okay, but it will probably be too late in order to change the protocol substantially.

101
00:42:30.560 --> 00:42:57.360
Of course, if that if that becomes required because privacy in Bitcoin is so terrible that it cannot be used for its purpose, then eventually the too late argument doesn't apply anymore, and we will be able to make that change uncontroversially, I guess. Okay, great. Thanks for that. I'd like to talk a little bit about about lightning and subsequent layers on Bitcoin now that we kind of talked a bit about privacy on the on the base layer.

102
00:42:57.360 --> 00:43:28.000
The Lightning Network has I mean grown so much since it was launched early last year, I think it's outpaced the rate that many thought it could mature. Now third layers are being built on top of Lightning. They're being discussed and developed. RGB tokens, which you're involved with, and this week Volturo announced that they will be launching by the end of the year a gold-based coin called VGold that uses the RGB protocol on top of Lightning, and also Storm, which is proposed by Maxim Orlovsky.

103
00:43:28.000 --> 00:43:49.440
And I Maxim is a great Bitcoiner name, right? It's it's a file storage and messaging protocol that's gonna be built on top of the Lightning Bitcoin stack. Can you talk about these two layer three proposals in particular, and then just maybe kind of layer three ideas or like how that might evolve in in general?

104
00:43:49.520 --> 00:44:13.640
So, first I would like to start from the general view. So, basically, a lot of ideas that were discussed as a as hypothesis at the early stage of Bitcoin, they were dismissed because basically they were unrealistic on layer one. Mostly because layer one must be conservative, slow, safe, always security-oriented.

105
00:44:13.640 --> 00:44:31.800
So you can as I with all as we said before, you cannot try the fast the new shiny the brand new thing. You have to be consistent, conservative, absolutely cautious with everything. So you cannot experiment with crazy stuff.

106
00:44:31.800 --> 00:44:50.680
Also at at base layer at layer one, there are a lot of economical delicate economical game theory incentive mechanism, and these mechanisms cannot be tampered with easily because they are they may be more fragile than we think.

107
00:44:50.680 --> 00:45:14.760
So things like Colored Coin, for example, they had problems of this kind. They were they were problematic because they were not necessarily incentive compatible. So let's think that maybe the you have so you have a miner trying to roll back the chain for some reason, try to re-org the chain in order to get a profit maybe to double spend.

108
00:45:14.760 --> 00:45:41.640
If the only thing that they can get from that kind of double spend is Bitcoin itself, then there is some kind of incentive alignment because if they disrupt the chain, they will make the price of the token itself arguably possibly collapse, and that can be like a counter a counter incentive in order to do that.

109
00:45:41.640 --> 00:46:02.560
While if you do that with the Colored Coin, then if you can prove that you have the color coin after the re-org, the price of Bitcoin is irrelevant for you in order to do that. So you can have more disaligned incentive, or the other kind of disaligned incentive is like block space, scarce resource, conflict over scarce resources.

110
00:46:02.560 --> 00:46:25.280
So I remember counterparty counterparty developers, they were asking for a bigger operating space because they wanted to use Bitcoin in order to store the information of the metadata of the counterparty layer. While Bitcoin developers, they wanted to maintain Bitcoin node agile and light for Bitcoin users.

111
00:46:25.280 --> 00:46:48.640
Bitcoin users they don't necessarily care for counterparty parasitic layers, and so they were basically in opposition because one party wants to leverage for free to piggyback to free ride the infrastructure, and the other party was wants to keep the infrastructure more more like light and efficient for for the actual users of the primary function of Bitcoin.

112
00:46:48.640 --> 00:47:15.840
So there is like the all these this kind of controversy of conflict in layer two and layer three and so on, this kind of problems is mitigated. In layer two, you can mess up, so you can try new things because if you fail, you will fail on a upper layer and you don't disrupt the entire infrastructure, especially you don't disrupt the monetary infrastructure, you just disrupt the technical infrastructure.

113
00:47:15.840 --> 00:47:37.720
And I mean, if lighting fails completely right now. Let's assume that a bug like there was a bug in the BOLT implementation that was there like it was solved, discovered and solved a few weeks ago. Imagine a catastrophic bug that isn't solved in time and basically destroys the entire lighting network.

114
00:47:37.720 --> 00:47:58.600
That would be a bad thing, of course. Many people will would have to spend money in order to rebuild their payments to infrastructure if they want to use lighting. Some people may lose some money in the settlement of lightning channels. Maybe there will be some chaos, but basically, the base infrastructure of Bitcoin will be safe.

115
00:47:58.600 --> 00:48:22.360
It will be messy to rebootstrap a second layer after, but we could do that in a few years. The Bitcoin will not die because of that. We would have a monetary base ready to bootstrap again a second layer. Well, that's even more so for the third layer. If we mess up with a storm on RGB, no problem, we take lightning network again and we build again.

116
00:48:22.360 --> 00:48:41.800
So the more you go up in the in the layers, the more you can experiment, mess up and try things, and also the faster that the far the farther you go from incentive problems. When you move to lightning, you don't have the mining problem anymore. Like in the case of RGB. So now I enter in the specific.

117
00:48:41.800 --> 00:49:07.240
We what what basically we did was to get some people, mostly initially Peter Todd, and then some people involved in Lightning Network, in order to try to do something a little bit like color coin, but on on top of lighting. So what happens now is that you don't use block space in order to encode asset properties, unlike in counterparty Omni or ESC20 on Ethereum.

118
00:49:07.240 --> 00:49:36.480
You don't use the blockchain for the asset, you just use Bitcoin transaction as anchor in order to avoid double spending for a layer which is entirely separate and entirely off chain. So on this layer, you don't have a problem of conflict over block space anymore, and you don't have very few problems of messing up with new things you can experiment with with new cryptographical signatures, you can experiment with complex scripting systems.

119
00:49:36.480 --> 00:50:01.120
You can do whatever you want because if you fail, you don't destroy the base infrastructure anymore. So you are removed, you are farther away from the fundamental layer. So RGB is basically a typical token system. So from the use case point of view, it's nothing new, it's the same old stuff that everybody is trying to do since 2013 at least.

120
00:50:01.120 --> 00:50:23.520
But this time it has been done on as a layer three solution, so on top of Lightning Network. So this should mitigate a lot of previous problems with this kind of this kind of experiments and projects. Storm is basically another step in the in the direction of upper layers.

121
00:50:23.520 --> 00:50:45.520
The idea is this the lightning network is a payment system for Bitcoin. So you send Satoshis to pay. But in order to send Satoshi to pay, you have to route payments, and in order to route payments, basically you have to move around encrypted messages and you have to pay people to route liquidity and to move around these encrypted messages.

122
00:50:45.520 --> 00:51:19.560
So the intuition is what if you turn this specific payment payment system into a generalized message passing system, encrypted message passing system. And when once you have a generalized message passage system on top of Lightning, then you can also take your data, you can send your data around, encrypted, of course, and you can pay people to give you back the data when needed on a per need base, which is basically something that a lot of people was thinking about since years.

123
00:51:19.560 --> 00:51:52.360
Think about like there was factum file coin store Jata coin, there were a lot of projects trying to do that, but instead of being layer three solutions, they were always layer one solutions, so they tried to start a new their own infrastructure, which is basically always a failure, and they tried to build directly a layer one solution.

124
00:51:52.360 --> 00:52:22.120
This should be better because in this case, instead of just having to code and maintain and bootstrap a storage system, a distributed storage system from scrap, you actually from scratch, you actually build it on top of all the code base of lightning. You just leverage the lightning system itself in order to send around this kind of data chunks, which should be more safe and more sustainable in the long run.

125
00:52:22.120 --> 00:52:43.560
Of course, it's still very, very experimental. One of the reasons because we one of the reasons of the for this experiment, is that layer two solutions do require some kind of decentralized storage so help.

126
00:52:43.560 --> 00:53:12.480
So think about a lighting channel. When you have a Bitcoin address when you have some Bitcoin UTXO, you don't need to store a lot of complex data. You just need your passphrase. From the passphrase, you can you can basically deterministically retrieve your your tree of private keys, and with the privacy key you can spend, so you just save the passphrase and you have everything with you.

127
00:53:12.480 --> 00:53:40.880
Well, that doesn't work with Lightning, because with lightning you have to store all the old states of the channel because if you lose the old state, you can be blackmailed by the counterparty and you can be attacked, and this these states are also toxic cryptographic toxic waste, so you cannot share them with others, you have to keep them encrypted, so there is a storage problem, and there is also a viability problem because you have to stay online all the time.

128
00:53:40.880 --> 00:54:06.400
This is basically the trade-off you have when you go layer two. Layer one is is bad for privacy and is bad for for scalability because it's a global consensus where everybody has everything forever, but it's simple because you put a transaction on layer one and you know that everybody with the gossip style will receive and keep this transaction forever.

129
00:54:06.400 --> 00:54:28.880
While on layer two, you are saving space and time and privacy, but as a trade off, it's less simple because you do have to store information somewhere. So in RGB is the same. When I send you an RGB token, like Tether will will do with the USDT or Voltoro with the V Gold, I send you a token.

130
00:54:28.880 --> 00:54:47.160
What I do is I send you a an off-chain information, include including the my signature for the token, and I use a Bitcoin transaction as an anchor to avoid double spending without writing every anything on the Bitcoin blockchain.

131
00:54:47.160 --> 00:55:06.600
So the block space footprint is zero. But I have to send you something off-chain, and you have to keep this something on chain, off-chain somehow. So you need storage. Of course, you can just use Google Drive with encryption, but it's there is a censorship problem.

132
00:55:06.600 --> 00:55:25.080
So all the centralized solutions are okay, but they may create some kind of censorship problem in the long run. Very cool. So then you that that's where Storm might come in to be able to provide like some decentralized censorship resistant file storage. Yeah, it's a double relationship in a way.

133
00:55:25.080 --> 00:55:43.160
RGB needs something like Storm, and I will actually argue that Lightning itself needs something like Storm, and Storm may use something like Lightning in order to move around the data chanks. Okay, last question because I'm mindful that you have to leave in a few minutes.

134
00:55:43.160 --> 00:56:03.560
Last year in Riga, you gave your famous speech dissecting toxic bitcoin maximalism, why it's necessary, which is essentially that there's just too much at stake here to sit back and let scammers ruin the reputation of this revolution. This year, though, you apologize for the suffering you caused with your presentation. So what gives with this bipolar behavior, man?

135
00:56:03.560 --> 00:56:29.120
Like when shit coins are flying, you're toxic, and when they're dying, you're apologetic. Is that what it is? A little bit there is that. I mean, after I mean, we add the vindication. So my my kind of posture is a little bit reactive. So when I see a lot of bullshit goes going around, I feel the need to try to break the hype to fight the buzzwords and to and to try to expose the bullshit.

136
00:56:29.120 --> 00:56:51.280
But when we had a vindication like last year, collapse of all the ICOs and altcoin apocalypse. In this case, I feel that there is a little bit of redundancy in in what they say about that. So I and also I Max Caden of Hodle Hodle, the great organizer of the Riga conference.

137
00:56:51.280 --> 00:57:29.440
We were discussing, and he said basically, how can you be more toxic than this year? I mean, you arrive to the top, you cannot outdo yourself. And so my only choice was to actually go in the opposite direction. The funny thing is that more people was so this kind of tolerance and nice niceness based presentation was perceived as most more offensive than the other one by some people because you know sometimes being more subtile with with with sarcasm can be even more effective

138
00:57:29.440 --> 00:57:48.720
And annoying for people who are trying to scam other people. Yeah, it was a textbook course on how to troll very directly and then troll very indirectly with sarcasm the next year. It's good stuff. Yeah, all right, man. Thank you so much for your time. I really enjoyed talking to you.

139
00:57:48.720 --> 00:58:00.840
It was a lot of fun. Like I said, I've learned a lot from you over the years, so it was really cool to get to talk to you and hope to meet you someday at one of these Bitcoin conferences. Sure, with pleasure. Thank you for having me. Thanks, Giacomo.

140
00:58:07.320 --> 00:58:26.840
Thanks to Giacomo for his time. That was amazing. What did you all think about that? Share the episode on Bitcoin Twitter with your thoughts, questions, doubts, counterpoints. Tag Giacomo at giacomozucco. That's at G-I-A-C-O-M-O-Z-U-C-C-O and myself at CitizenBitcoin.

141
00:58:26.840 --> 00:58:49.720
Sharing the episode with a favorite quote or whatever hyperbolic emoji-laden compliment you can think of is also super helpful. Thanks to everyone who gave last week's episode with Robert Breedlove a shout-out. You helped make it the fastest downloaded Citizen Bitcoin podcast of all time. So keep it up. It's definitely helping a lot. Together we can cement this podcast up there with the best Bitcoin pods available on the web.

142
00:58:49.720 --> 00:59:08.440
As a little treat for those of you who listened all the way through, most of you have probably already listened to my first episode with Gigi, 21 Lessons from Down the Bitcoin Rabbit Hole, episode thirty-four. It's a perennial favorite among Citizen Bitcoin fans. You can start getting hyped for a very special episode with Gigi next week.

143
00:59:08.440 --> 00:59:37.000
He'll be my first repeat interview guest for what promises to be a next level mind-bending trip down the rabbit hole with him. I'm excited to drop that one next week. Alright, that's it for me. Take care out there, Bitcoiners. Wherever you happen to be in the world,
