WEBVTT

1
00:00:19.440 --> 00:00:43.600
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey, learning Bitcoin. Hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners all around the world? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. This week we're sitting down with Parker Lewis, head of business development at Unchained Capital and author of the Gradually Then Suddenly series on the Unchained Blog.

2
00:00:43.600 --> 00:01:02.080
First, the latest from Swan. The team is working hard to make our March launch. CTO Jan Pritzer and designer Jorn Ruder are building a beautiful, simple, functional app that will become the easiest way to make recurring buys of Bitcoin with lower fees than Coinbase and about 40 fewer coins to confuse you.

3
00:01:02.080 --> 00:01:24.160
The app is looking so good. We'll share screen mock-ups soon. You can follow us at Swan Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter to follow along. Sign up for early access to the app at SwanBitcoin.com. Oh, and the Swan has a new phone number. You can text any Bitcoin questions to him at 650-282-2107, and you'll get an answer directly from the Swan himself.

4
00:01:24.160 --> 00:01:48.840
Alright, thanks as always to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the pod in their feed. Give them a follow at LTB Network on Bitcoin Twitter and check out the LTBN feed in your podcast app for other great Bitcoin podcasts included there. If you're enjoying the show from the LTBN feed, you can check out the archive of this podcast at citizenbitcoin.world.

5
00:01:48.840 --> 00:02:09.720
The Bitcoin 2020 conference is coming up quick. I'm in the midst of recording episodes with Bitcoiners who will be speaking there, including Parker. It's gonna be even more epic than last year. Definitely recommend making your way out to SF for this one March 27th and 28th, with a lot of satellites, events, and parties taking place around those dates.

6
00:02:09.720 --> 00:02:33.880
All right, let's dive in. Parker Lewis came to Bitcoin from the traditional, or shall we say, the legacy financial industry. He found Bitcoin, he became obsessed and convicted, and he forged his way into the future of finance, the Bitcoin industry.

7
00:02:33.880 --> 00:02:57.800
In this episode, we discuss much that ails our economic system, Keynesianism, quantitative easing, modern monetary theory. Then we get into the fix. We discuss Parker's latest edition to the gradually then suddenly series titled Bitcoin Obsoletes All Money. I steal man some FUD and pre-coiner questions and arguments, and Parker expertly delivers the answers.

8
00:02:57.800 --> 00:03:18.680
In the end, we get bullish on the future of Bitcoin and the society it will create. You're gonna love this one. Here we go. Alright, really excited to welcome Parker Lewis to the podcast today.

9
00:03:18.680 --> 00:03:37.000
Parker is relatively, I mean, pretty famous now for your incredible content, Parker at the Unchained Capital blog. So really excited to talk to you today. How's it going, man? Going doing well. A little rainy here in Austin, Texas, but coming to you live from Unchained Studios. Nice. That's exciting.

10
00:03:37.000 --> 00:04:12.560
Unchained is you know, I think one of the leading companies here in Bitcoin world. Really excited what you guys are doing. Got a great staff, great products. So yeah, congrats on on the success, man. Yeah, appre appreciate it. You know, we're yeah, kind of doing doing work every day and you know, slowly but surely went in the hearts and minds of Bitcoiners everywhere and you know, really at the core of everything that we do is is around Bitcoin security and helping people that have Bitcoin be able to not only achieve greater security but have access to financial services in the ways that we think as ourselves as Bitcoiners would actually, you know, want to interact with a financial institution.

11
00:04:12.560 --> 00:04:31.680
So you know, it it's a process, but we feel like we're making progress every day. Gradually then suddenly. Right. Definitely. And I think I think we actually met for the first time last year at at Bitcoin twenty nineteen. So looking forward to Bitcoin twenty twenty coming up as well.

12
00:04:31.680 --> 00:04:53.120
Yeah, it's gonna be amazing. I hear from the Bitcoin twenty twenty team that it's gonna be twice as big as last year. Last year had about two thousand people in attendance, so they're expecting like four thousand this year. So it's gonna be even more epic. Yeah, I think it's gonna be electric. So if if you're if you're not going, it's not too late. It's not too late, and you know, there will be plenty of content coming out of the conference too.

13
00:04:53.120 --> 00:05:19.120
So I'll be doing some stuff live from the conference. You can tune into this podcast and there'll be just incredible amounts of content, I'm sure coming out on Twitter. So you know, you won't be left out if you're not able to come. All right, man, let's dive into this discussion. You just wrote a new piece called Bitcoin Obsoletes, All Money, the latest edition from the Gradually Than Suddenly series on the Unchained blog.

14
00:05:19.120 --> 00:05:40.520
We're definitely gonna get into that. We'll probably touch on some of your previous writing too. I want to start with, though, some macroeconomic talk because you came from that world into Bitcoin. What did you used to do before? Just to give us a little bit of background. I know you've you've been through this on other podcasts before, so we don't need to spend too much time on it. But just to set the scene, where'd you come from and how'd you get into this Bitcoin thing?

15
00:05:40.600 --> 00:05:59.160
Yeah, so I've you know spent a long time down a meandering path in the traditional financial services world. So started out at Deutsche Bank and worked in the MA group there in New York, and then went went into the world of restructuring and then ultimately found myself working on the buy side at a hedge fund in Dallas.

16
00:05:59.160 --> 00:06:36.280
And that that's really where kind of the timeline kind of allowed for me Bitcoin to really start connecting. And it, you know, it was it was a it was a function definitely of part of the macro work that I had done while I was at Heyman in Dallas, and then kind of that that path converged, not only in in looking at the you know, kind of doing research on specifically QE, but but but particularly as it related to what would then happen when the Fed begun to unwind QE and I was doing that at the same time where when I was kind of fully going down the Bitcoin rabbit hole.

17
00:06:36.440 --> 00:06:46.040
And for me, it's it it's really become where where the where the world of the Feds Fed starts and ends is really where the world of Bitcoin begins and why it exists.

18
00:06:46.200 --> 00:06:58.440
That must have been some cognitive dissonance going on for you there, being stuck in this traditional Keynesian world of the financial industry that we have now and going down the Bitcoin rabbit hole at the same time.

19
00:06:59.160 --> 00:07:38.080
Yeah, yeah, it it definitely was, but it also provided me a I wouldn't say a unique lens, but it definitely helped me understand Bitcoin better. And I think that that is one of the things that that I'm sure we'll talk about today, but that it you know, Bitcoin doesn't exist in a vacuum and that it it becomes much easier to see and it becomes more intuitive once once you really understand the playing field that is the existing monetary system and the existing financial system and that the inherent issues that exist there and the and the systemic issues that exist as well.

20
00:07:38.080 --> 00:08:12.640
So you wrote a paper around that time called Enders Game. Is that right? That was around that time. Yeah, so I actually wrote that piece. I left working at the hedge fund that I was at formerly in July of two thousand seventeen and I had been doing research while I was there on both the Fed QE and then reverse QE, and then when I left I actually wrote that that paper's Enders game and really what it began as was you know kind of y I have a lot of ideas in my head, but the best way that I can you know think to distill them is actually to put them on paper.

21
00:08:12.640 --> 00:08:33.120
And so, you know, kind of it's it started out as as a as an interest, you know, not just intellectually, but then also specifically it relates to the as as related to the work that I was doing to understand, you know, n you not just for information purpose, but then how to, you know, kind of put this to work and to kind of make something of it.

22
00:08:33.120 --> 00:09:04.920
And so when I wrote that the Enders game paper, I'd I left working at the hedge fund I was at in Dallas and I was I was considering either kind of you know, starting up a fund of my my own to trade the traditional markets, like b or based on the work that I had done around the Fed and QE, but but realistically, I had also, you know, I was ninety percent sure I wanted to work in Bitcoin, and so kind of in that interim space, I you know, decided to put kind of the you know, the core thesis that I had developed around the Fed onto paper, and that was Ender's game.

23
00:09:04.920 --> 00:09:41.800
And so I kind of work through and provided my perspective on really kind of describing for people in a way that I think you know, while it's long, provides context that allows them to actually understand what happened and why during the financial crisis. And the ultimate conclusion of that is that we were living in a world with too much debt and not enough money, and that the system had become so overly levered that the that that future QE was an inevitability, it wasn't a possibility, it wasn't a probability, it was a it was a certainty.

24
00:09:41.800 --> 00:10:06.600
And we've since started to see that even though in the last in the last four or five months, despite the fact that the Fed has increased the amount of base money by 400 billion, they're not yet calling it QE. But that would that was really the conclusion of that analysis. And when I was looking at the landscape of really what to do, I could either you know develop a you know put together a fund to you know play in the traditional markets and monetize it there.

25
00:10:06.600 --> 00:10:30.840
But realistically, I thought it would be you know a lot more interesting and a lot more aligned with with my own my own interest to focus on billion on the future, which is Bitcoin. Nice. Well, you start that piece talking about the well, obviously the subprime mortgage crisis, but then you talk about the $3.6 trillion of quote unquote temporary accommodation that was made.

26
00:10:30.840 --> 00:11:08.880
The and then you talk about the that the risk was misunderstood and mispriced. And of course, this temporary accommodation is like a concept that's basic to Keynesian economics the idea that the government needs to print some money to sort of spur the economy in a downturn but the other side of kind of the Keynesian prescription that he originally wrote about that you need to sort of retract or contract that temporary accommodation hardly ever happens right and you wrote you wrote about like when that does happen you know that the prices of these financial assets will fall it'll create instability in the credit system et cetera but in response to that like

27
00:11:08.960 --> 00:11:47.120
We just never really did that contraction or at least not in any significant way and here we are again on the same path toward printing a bunch of money these terms quantitative easing and modern monetary theory are these are fancy terms Keynesians do this all the time to try to kind of confuse people about what's really going on about a really simple matter that we've all learned money is actually a really simple thing so what are these terms mean and what's really going on here quantitative easing you know kind of as a as a technical term all it really means is Fed creates more money and you know there's oftentimes whether it's Keynesian or just establishment

28
00:11:47.120 --> 00:12:15.520
Economists they they often try to draw a nuance or distinction around well the Fed's not printing money when it's doing QE well you know the way that I think about it is through Q you know every dollar is created through the Fed is created through QE and the Treasury may be the function by which those dollars are converted from from the digital realm to the physical world but that that QE in its simplest term is is the Fed creating more money.

29
00:12:15.520 --> 00:12:41.480
And the reason, you know, in in my research and in my conclusions as to which I think are fairly fairly defensible, is that more more QE is always necessary because the dollar financial system and really any fiat monetary system that exists today is one that is inherently wed to its credit system.

30
00:12:41.800 --> 00:13:16.200
If we think about the Fed, you know, the things that are most commonly heard are that the Fed has a quote price stability mandate and a full employment mandate. And in a world where pre-financial crisis system-wide in the United States, there was $53 trillion of debt as estimated by the Federal Reserve themselves, and only $350 billion existing in the banking system, that every every dollar had become leveraged 150 to 1 approximately.

31
00:13:16.300 --> 00:13:42.020
And the consequence of that leverage profile dictates that more and more dollars are going to be necessary to support that debt. And the reason being that if consistent with the Fed's price stability mandate, the credit system, because it is so much larger than the base money supply, pre-crisis it was 151 as a function of quantitative easing.

32
00:13:42.020 --> 00:13:52.940
That the way I think about it, that leverage ratio was effectively reduced by the function of increasing the amount of dollars tenfold, or at least that existed within the banking system.

33
00:13:53.720 --> 00:14:15.840
But that realistically, because that credit system is orders of magnitude larger than the base money supply, the credit system is the price setter. And if the price if the Fed has a price stability mandate, then they have, if not an explicit mandate, they have an implicit mandate to maintain the size of the credit system in order to maintain price stability.

34
00:14:15.840 --> 00:14:50.240
In order to do that, they have to they have to provide more dollars to support the existing amount of debt. And so when we think about the crisis, it was there was too much debt, too few dollars in response to that dynamic and as soon as the market figured it out in a big way and the system as a whole began to delever, the only way to reverse course and for allow that to allow on a system level the amount of debt to be sustained was to increase the supply of dollars to increase the supply of credit to sustain asset prices and then ultimately to allow for further credit expansion.

35
00:14:50.240 --> 00:15:26.480
So QE really at its simplest form is creating more dollars. The reason the reason why it exists is to actually continue to maintain the credit system in its in its existing size. Yeah that makes sense so I was a little shocked by this 150 to one leverage number I've always heard that banks are legally limited to a much lower levered number like 30 to one or so and I think there were some laws passed in the wake of the 2008 you know and 910 crisis that reduce that number so how how does that happen?

36
00:15:26.480 --> 00:16:02.280
I mean how do they get around these laws that try to re try to limit it. Yeah and so one thing that you know kind of I would you know when I when I use the term leverage and you know I think there's many ways that that people can look at leverage I think from a regulatory perspective the way that it is you know kind of when you think about you know kind of like 10% fractional reserve banking, you know, kind of you know, a bank may have you know a hundred million dollars worth of cash or or you know kind of reserves, and then they may have a billion dollars worth of loan, you know, kind of total assets and 900 million dollars of loans.

37
00:16:02.280 --> 00:16:36.360
So when I think, you know, so when I use the term leverage and think about the amount of dollar debt to the actual number of dollars that exists, I think of that as leverage because the only way to pay dollar-denominated debt is to have dollars. But you know, kind of the way that that a bank may look at it is I've got you know a I've got a home that's that that's backing that particular loan, and or I have you know a business that's operating that that can support you know kind of the existing loan balances.

38
00:16:36.360 --> 00:16:57.960
But realistically, and I think a more appropriate way to look at at leverage is not the way that that banks look at leverage in terms of the regulatory capital charge. It is simply down to the brass tax of if there is the if there's x amount of nominal debt and there's y amount of dollars, those dollars that exist are the only thing that can actually go to repay that repay that debt.

39
00:16:57.960 --> 00:17:18.520
And so that that becomes the more appropriate leverage. So I think a part of it is just a distinction in in the actual definition. But when you're looking on a on a dollars to dollar debt basis, that's where you see the 150 to 1 leverage. Right. So like illiquid assets like homes, for instance, in a credit crunch situation aren't the same as actually having liquid dollars.

40
00:17:18.520 --> 00:17:41.080
Like you can't really count those as an asset against that leverage. Correct. I mean you can count it, but it from a from a system-wide perspective, you know, they're the they're the only thing, you know, you a bank may be able to take you know a piece of real estate in return for a loan that's gone bad, but that's not the business of the bank.

41
00:17:41.080 --> 00:18:19.200
And that that that that real estate value can't actually be sustained if those dollars don't exist to repay the debt. So it's all a very dynamic equation, but but kind of at the bottom line of the least common denominator, the only thing that matters is whether or not there are dollars to pay the debt, and that the asset prices are actually supported by debt such that if there's there begins to be a deleveraging event on a system-wide basis that you know kind of a banks if they look at their if they look at their leverage ratio on a 10 to 1 basis, if if in the if in the greater scheme the dollars have been levered 150 to one,

42
00:18:19.200 --> 00:18:55.200
Just true dollars to dollar credit, that the asset values will never be able to be sustained, and so they'll experience a significant amount of credit losses, which will essentially cause the system to begin to collapse. And that that really is the core the core push and pull but between QE if someone really wanted to understand it as to as to why because I think to the point that you brought up as it relates to you know kind of the Keynesian idea that you're supposed to kind of the government is supposed to step in to smooth out business cycles, but you know, kind of in the world that we live in today, they never seem to actually move out of that easing function.

43
00:18:55.200 --> 00:19:20.560
That in realistic or kind of in reality, we did see the Fed try to, and they they did it in a in a significant way and almost in a reckless way, which in which in my world just further demonstrates that they they they don't really understand the true dynamics of how liquidity works and why prices miss or kind of why risk is mispriced, because you know, from October of 2017 to

44
00:19:23.200 --> 00:19:43.000
M the summer of this year, the Fed eliminated approximately 700 billion of actual dollar liquidity from the market. And kind of where the bank, you know, kind of in terms of the reserves or the cash that sat in the banking system before that process, it it eliminated approximately 25% of all of the liquidity in the system.

45
00:19:43.000 --> 00:20:09.720
And then the result of that was boom in September of 2019, the repo markets broke. And the Fed, you know, virtually overnight, or maybe not even virtually, like practically overnight, had to come in and supply more dollars. And so it you know, the you know practically speaking, because of the leverage profile and the size of the credit system, i it it's a catch, you know, it's it's it's stuck between a rock and a hard place.

46
00:20:09.720 --> 00:20:29.480
They you know the Fed may look at the equation and say, hey, we you know, we need to, you know, we need to have ammo for the next time we need to use these tools, but realistically they they can never pull away the accommodation or or the dollars that they provided to the market because the only way that QE actually works is if it induces further credit expansion.

47
00:20:29.480 --> 00:20:48.280
So it's really a world where there was you we started in a world where there was too much debt and there were too few dollars. The only thing that QE can do to quote solve a problem, which is ultimately only delaying the or creating a larger problem and delaying the impact of that, is you know, more QE just means more credit expansion.

48
00:20:48.280 --> 00:21:07.640
And then if you ever t try to remove that that accommodation in the market, the markets respond begins to respond in a way that dictates that more QE be provided because it's ultimately debt that supports or dollars that support debt which support asset prices. So it's kind of it all works together in that way.

49
00:21:08.040 --> 00:21:43.120
Yeah, so the Keynesian prescription, you know, in theory was that governments could, you know, print some money to help smooth out a crisis, then they would, you know, take that money out of the market when things were in better shape. But in practice, that's that's just not the way things work out. So now we're in this situation where you know we've been in this, you know, we've we built this default Keynesian world where everyone's just, you know, all the government central bankers around the world and anybody who's, you know, basic most economists subscribe or you know ascribe to this idea.

50
00:21:43.120 --> 00:22:13.360
And now it's evolved into because I think you know bankers and economists have realized that the counter prescription to the printing of money to smooth out that that downturn doesn't work, right? So the only option then is just to continue printing more money. So now we have this is that basically what the idea of modern monetary theory that they go into is like, hey, we're in this we're we figured out that you know the way that this ends up playing out in practice is that we just have to keep printing money and that's what we're gonna do forever.

51
00:22:13.520 --> 00:22:38.480
Mona so monet m modern monetary theory in my view is not a monetary theory. I think it's a combination of kind of a charterless Keynesian monetarist view that in the last you know year and a half or two years people say oh modern monetary theory always exists and if it did I feel like I would have heard about it.

52
00:22:39.120 --> 00:22:57.200
But you know I'm convinced that there were some mark you know Madison Avenue marketing agency working with you know, people in Congress to term something else to make you know what otherwise would be just you know how do we finance uncontrollable deficits in a way that seems sophisticated.

53
00:22:57.520 --> 00:23:35.560
And realistically I think that anyone that operates a business or manages their own personal finance or their own personal budgets would look at this and say that you know these have to be people that are entirely detached from reality that you know it they they look at the world where you know maybe they you know maybe it's too tort short of a time frame or maybe it's you know a lack of rigor of thought or or just a lack of understanding of basic economics but it it's ultimately resulted in a in a view or at least as it's

54
00:23:35.560 --> 00:24:03.800
Espoused that you know we can run as a as a government or as a country trillion dollar deficits and we can we can just always you know increase the money supply because the Fed has a digital printing press and this can go on forever. And you know whether you know we'll we'll we'll move move to Bitcoin I'm sure but you know whether Bitcoin exists or not that fact is just simply fundamentally not true.

55
00:24:04.280 --> 00:24:31.240
That that that if if you proceed down that course it will end very badly it will end with you know economic instability and it will it will lead to ultimately instability in the underlying currency if if the approach is taken that that deficits don't matter and we can continue to print money to satisfy you know the excesses of government at infinitum.

56
00:24:31.560 --> 00:24:44.480
And more realistically, now that Bitcoin exists as an opt-out path, it it cre you know is not it is no longer a philosophical debate. We essentially have a market test, which is the beautiful.

57
00:24:45.080 --> 00:24:49.420
Yep, absolutely. All right, so yeah, let's transition into Bitcoin now.

58
00:24:50.320 --> 00:24:52.560
But let's start with the basics.

59
00:24:52.740 --> 00:24:59.700
Just because I think this conversation is important to have, and I have it with most of the guests that are on the show,

60
00:25:00.080 --> 00:25:20.960
And sometimes the answers are a bit different for from guest to guest. And I think the you know variety of answers to this question is is helpful for listeners. So let's just start the basics. Why money? Why are money and prices so important to an economic system.

61
00:25:21.040 --> 00:25:59.920
Money and prices, and a lot of my I think I think you know everyone and a lot of my thinking's been in informed or you know, I've I've found Austrian economics kind of as I was kind of finding Bitcoin. But I think that there's a very basic principle that you don't really have to understand anything about either a Keynesian worldview or or an Austrian worldview to understand in a practical application if you simply you know think about your own real world experiences, and it is that that that money is a precursor to price,

62
00:25:59.920 --> 00:26:38.200
And that money is a is a very basic necessity, it becomes the tool that you know we all as humans use to facilitate or to solve a very intersubjective problem that is exchange, and that the output of that exchange and the use of a common medium to solve an intersubjective problem ultimately evolves into a price system, and so the price system is something that we all I think, you know, certainly myself, and likely anybody who has grown

63
00:26:38.200 --> 00:27:13.480
Up with a stable form of money, you know, generally took as a given and hasn't had to actually consciously think about either the function of money or price, but realistically, through money, all individuals are communicating their preferences and their views of a combination of their own subjective of their own subjective kind of view of value, and then you know, from there and through money, prices then are able to be communicated to the market.

64
00:27:13.480 --> 00:27:51.560
And so the idea that there would be no price if money existed, and if money didn't exist, that we wouldn't have a way kind of as individuals or kind of as an economy to communicate value. So when we think about that then in the context of why are prices important, they they ultimately allow for money and price ultimately allow for economic systems to emerge, that that economic systems actually emerge from money and from price rather than you know, kind of economies

65
00:27:51.800 --> 00:28:26.000
Converging on a single form of money because of price, that the price system evolves out of money, and that it is is essentially because of that that supply and demand structures are actually able to form in the first place. And you know, when it when I think about it on a very kind of one to one-to-one basis, if I if I were an individual, it would be, you know, what would I do without money and what what would I do without price if if I want to obtain certain things in my life that I find valuable, that you know, pricing system becomes the very fundamental principle that communicates to me what I actually have to produce.

66
00:28:26.000 --> 00:28:48.160
And if I don't produce X, then I can't consume Y. But it's the very communication of price that allows me to understand those those the interplay between those dynamics. Yeah, so the emergence of price from money is actually, I mean, it's pretty magical what happens because it's like it's a way to stabilize exchange in a very, very complex economic system.

67
00:28:48.160 --> 00:29:08.160
But it it's extremely simple. So it's this very simple mechanic that it leads to this incredibly complex you know like I guess management of an incredibly complex system. Yeah, absolutely. And I, you know, I wrote about this in my most recent piece, Bitcoin obsoletes all of the money.

68
00:29:08.160 --> 00:29:46.480
But one of my favorite excerpts from from Hayek in the use of knowledge in society is where he you know where he says, you know, I'm convinced that you know if price was in the pricing system was you know a product of human design and of conscious control, that it would be it would be one of the greatest inventions ever created by man, but it's you know it it the consequence that it that it isn't of conscious direction and that it is just a very or organic kind of spontaneous order causes

69
00:29:46.480 --> 00:30:24.760
Those that that view the you know view the world through you know social engineering or that that that that something that is designed by conscious control will always deliver some greater output than than something that that that's formed very organically it it causes those people to struggle very mightily with the beauty and the simplicity of the price system that evolves from from a single source of money yeah that's beautiful that's exactly right and that's one of the reasons I think it's so hard to understand Bitcoin is just that's conven that's just the conventional thought right that's there's a monoculture of thought that

70
00:30:24.920 --> 00:31:03.000
That we can manage the economy in a way that will you know not affect prices I guess in the long run but that's you know it's proven not to be true so like how how are prices affected by a stable monetary policy like Bitcoins versus you know an ever inflating monetary supply like we're have now well I would I think it's always helpful to not necessarily use analogies but to use tangible examples because I do think it it is you know a primary reason why what the Fed does is is so pervasive that

71
00:31:03.320 --> 00:31:41.160
By manipulating the money supply they essentially manipulate the price signals and Hayek also describes the price system as the greatest distribution system of knowledge in the world because it is ultimately the output of those communication preferences and so when we think about well what does the Fed do when they increase the money supply if if if if the money is the mechanism through which price and knowledge is communicated, then when when you when you I and manipulation of the money supply isn't just increasing the money supply, it's also when they decide to shrink the money supply.

72
00:31:41.160 --> 00:32:01.120
Ultimately, what it what it adds into the equation is a level of distortion that then sends false signals to hundreds of millions of people, and all those people, they you know, say 99% of them, they don't understand you know that what the Fed's doing in the background. All that they're seeing and all they're able to react to is the concept of price.

73
00:32:01.120 --> 00:32:30.720
And so if we use the tangible example, I often like to pick on real estate and housing, is that you know, if if you think about where prices are manipulated the most, it's well what what industries are most dependent on on the supply of credit, because that that's ultimately kind of what QE is and how how QE, you know, quote unquote out could ever work, is that the only function by which it is is that is the manipulation of the supply of credit.

74
00:32:30.720 --> 00:33:05.280
And so when we think about the manipulation of pricing, it is, you know, if we go back to the financial crisis, you know, when when when people that that weren't credit worthy could you know get a get a you know no money down mortgage and you know buy a $500,000 house, and maybe if they could buy two $500,000 houses, and if they wouldn't otherwise have been able to access that if not for the manipulation of the money supply and the manipulation of the supply of credit, and part of that is is the manipulation of the money supply, part of it's a market structure problem.

75
00:33:05.280 --> 00:33:29.920
But what that ultimately results in is a manipulation of housing prices higher to unsustainable levels, such that when when that accommodation is removed, or when the market figures out that it's unsustainable, it's very difficult to find a balance because no one knows kind of where equilibrium exists because it's been manipulated for so long.

76
00:33:30.600 --> 00:33:50.840
And that the more pervasive part of that is not just, oh, well, the price of houses need to drop, and then they'll correct and we'll figure out where to go from here. It's more that the consequence is so much more far ranging that higher prices of housing then dictate more supply of housing to be made.

77
00:33:50.840 --> 00:34:28.520
And you and if you if you're just thinking about that in terms of the number of houses or the type of houses or the number of skyscrapers, it's not really where it's it stops. You know, kind of that that that's just the symptom. It's well, our whole our whole economy and certain resources and specifically kind of human skills have been geared toward a sector of the economy based on those priced on those false price signals that couldn't cannot otherwise be sustained, such that when the market actually figures it out, you have a large mismatch between skill and what the actual preferences in it in an unmanipulated world would have been.

78
00:34:28.520 --> 00:34:52.600
And that's ultimately what you know results in significant and very quick financial shocks and ultimately kind of mass displacement of a workforce that you get you get a you know if you are manipulating the price signals, you are ultimately going to manipulate the underlying supply and demand structure and the dynamic that plays out as you know a mismatched workforce.

79
00:34:52.680 --> 00:35:18.960
Yeah. So then on the other on the flip side, using the real estate example, you know, Bitcoin will obviously have an effect on availability of credit. How will you know the this this more, I guess, stable credit market and perhaps less profligate credit market, how will that affect the ability, I guess how will that affect our society?

80
00:35:19.120 --> 00:35:41.280
We've kind of been dependent on this, you know, easy credit for a long time. We have this sort of we become accustomed to a certain way of life, and you know, Keynesians and I guess expansionary credit advocates would say that you know we've lifted a lot of people around the globe out of poverty with this sort of monetary policy.

81
00:35:41.280 --> 00:36:19.280
What would you say to that argument? I would say that it's a combination of you're looking over too short of a time horizon and you're probably not looking, you're probably failing to see the forest through the trees. That when we think about, you know, so kind of you know using a short example, but then I'll kind of move more into the fundamental view, is that you know, kind of if you're if you're saying, oh well, we've lifted all these people out of poverty, but then you know, kind of you see, you know, since 1971, and then also, you know, particularly since the

82
00:36:19.280 --> 00:36:47.840
Financial crisis in QE, the disparity and wealth gap increase so significantly, you know, where someone will say, oh, that's just you know, that that's a certain amount of fault tolerance that we're willing to accept for bringing people out of poverty. But then when you when you look at you know surveys or statistics of you know how many how many Americans have you know access to $500 of savings, it's it's it's not more than 50% of people, which is which is mind-boggling.

83
00:36:47.840 --> 00:37:25.960
And so you know, the reality is that that people can look at the things in their life and the access to technology and they can say, ah, you know, we're you know we're we're doing good here, but but the reality is that that economy isn't working for the vast majority of people and that the practical end point of that of essentially using the manipulation of the money supply and the manipulation of credit to pull forward demand ultimately it you know kind of debt is you know kind of the way that I think about it a root principle and if you think about it on a one-to-one basis you're you're you're consuming something that you have not yet produced at least in terms

84
00:37:25.960 --> 00:38:03.960
Of value and individual value and individual output and that the consequence of that and doing that on a on a system wide level for so long is that there will be economic instability in the future and that everyone's going to pay for it. So you know kind of one one small anecdote there there was a 2004 speech where Ben Bernanke wrote about or kind of gave a speech on how monetary policy had contributed to the reduction of price volatility and output volatility and then and then suddenly volatility in 2008 goes off the charts and there's mass unemployment

85
00:38:04.120 --> 00:38:42.200
And the output of production declined precipitously and then suddenly there's not a there's not a you know a moment of introspection to say well you know is what you know was this really working or was this the volatility that we suppressed in the short term was it ultimately exacerbated kind of in in sudden events and so I think that you know kind of if if people zoom out from the chart or from the economy, they will, you know, and I'm not a not somebody who predicts or worries about a dystopian future, but but the but the end case of that is something that devolves into a scenario like Venezuela.

86
00:38:42.200 --> 00:39:20.240
And if it weren't for Bitcoin and having essentially a you know, today maybe it could be considered a backup switch, but but increasingly it will become the predominant engine that fuels the global financial system and the global economy, that the consequence of having a money supply that is not manipulable and is ultimately internally fixed, is that the communication of prices in that system will be far more reliable, and that we won't have the booms and busts and the and the periods of low volatility met with the periods of significant volatility that

87
00:39:20.240 --> 00:39:46.960
We saw in the financial crisis and kind of from a real kind of fundamental economic perspective that is you can't manipulate the supply of money, you can't manipulate the supply of credit. You essentially can't manipulate the preferences that millions of individuals are communicated in to the market in terms of what they demand and what their preferences are, that that in that world you get you live in in in a in a in in a world of greater balance, essentially.

88
00:39:46.960 --> 00:40:16.160
So it's not that that the Bitcoin truly fixes all problems, it is that by not manipulating the money supply, individuals have a more reliable and a more stable way to communicate preferences. And in that world where hundreds of millions, if not billions, people are communicating those preferences all dynamically, all ever changing, that the that the economy is in a in a much better position to react to changing preferences and not to be faked or not to be behaving on false signals.

89
00:40:16.160 --> 00:40:36.360
And if they are, then those those are not system-wide. And you know, if there are credit expansions, which there will be in the world of Bitcoin, that you know, as soon as they arise, they will be, you know, naturally course corrected far sooner and not allowed to sustain themselves for for decades, like they have as a function of the Fed's manipulation of the money supply.

90
00:40:36.920 --> 00:41:05.640
Yeah, and be limited to you know, the people who have taken those risks and not, like you said, systemic and punish people who had nothing to do with that, you know, credit expansion. So that's yeah. So I've said in the past that there's two pillars of Bitcoin maximalism, you know, which which to me is the idea that there will, you know, that Bitcoin will be the one money and your piece that Bitcoin obsoletes all money, concludes has the same conclusion.

91
00:41:05.640 --> 00:41:33.400
So the two pillars of Bitcoin maximalism, the technical side, the digital network protocols tend toward one, and then the economic side, the money side is that the you know money in an economic system tends toward one. But those relatively new to this idea, you know, no coiners, new you know, pre-coiners, I guess we should call them, they may not have a correct understanding of money, and they'll say, you know, hey, this is demonstrably untrue, right?

92
00:41:33.400 --> 00:41:53.400
We have hundreds of currencies that coexist now. Why will we not have hundreds of currencies or thousands of currencies that coexist in the future now that it's you can you can, you know, anyone can make their own money. So why do you think it's true then that we'll have one money in the future and you know that economic systems do converge on one money?

93
00:41:53.720 --> 00:42:31.920
So if you know, f first I would say to those people that that if we look at the world that we exist in today with with hundreds of fiat currencies, there are only two or three of those that are actually you know considered reserve currencies or or or that are accepted cross border so you know there may be you know a fiat currency in in every different market but more more practically speaking we see that convergence if if somebody who is in Venezuela could have access to the dollar system they would most

94
00:42:32.080 --> 00:43:10.560
People in Venezuela don't and so the fractured nature of you know of our current monetary system is is less a natural function of money and is more a function of government intervention and then I would kind of go one step below there and then you know have people recognize that before fiat money monetary systems evolved the world had previously you know kind of for all intent and purposes had had converged on a single monetary medium which was gold and that the existing the existing fiat systems

95
00:43:10.640 --> 00:43:48.880
You know where where they exist within their jurisdictions wouldn't have ever been possible to exist if not for leveraging that that convergence on gold or on you know kind of whether whether it was gold or silver that that really that entire system evolved on the on the back or on the shoulders of prior convergence and so I view it as more of a you know again a temporary phenomenon that is a function of government intervention rather than the natural function of money and that it was able to happen because of and I think this is something that gold bugs

96
00:43:48.880 --> 00:44:13.560
Will probably hate, but they're gonna have to continually face, is that the mo that the current monetary system and the fiat system that exists today exists because of gold's limitation as a form of money and because it was susceptible to centralization, and if it was susceptible to centralization, that it was inherently going to be dependent on trust.

97
00:44:13.560 --> 00:44:51.800
And that you know, in in that way, the fiat system to me is really the manifestation of gold's failure. It's the communication of that failure, and most people don't yet see it, but you know, kind of increasingly in a world where someone is i is evaluating you know gold relative to Bitcoin relative to the to the dollar, I kind of frame it as you know the that Bitcoin, you know, Bitcoin is often referred to as digital gold, but more realistically, Bitcoin combines the benefits and the strengths of physical gold with the benefits

98
00:44:51.800 --> 00:45:29.960
And strength of the digital dollar, all wrapped up in one without the limitations of either. And so when we you know, when we kind of that I think you know gives some color on, well, you know, kind of what about the world that exists today, and I think that the core tenant, if we go back down to the first principle, is and really I don't think that someone would truly understand this or it may be not maybe saying truly understand it is not a fair way to present it, but I think that they would never be in a position to see the world of monetary convergence if they didn't first start at that principle that

99
00:45:30.040 --> 00:46:08.080
You know kind of in in the piece that I wrote Bitcoin obsoletes all the money, it's starting with the principle that you know money is a necessity, and really taking a step back, and despite the fact that you've taken money as and just thinking about it on a very personal level that if you if if you in your current day you know had to get through the day if you didn't have money then how would you procure the things that you need to consume in your life and starting with that very basic principle that it that it is a necessity it is it is the thing that allows food to show up at the grocery store or you know for your

100
00:46:08.080 --> 00:46:46.080
Cell phone to work or for for gas to be at the gas station like all of that coordination and economy is facilitated ultimately by money because because it is a is is the is the solution to the problem of intersubjective exchange then when you build off of that it becomes well well what you know what is the money what defines money is money a collective hallucination because that that becomes another trope of I think in my view non-rigorous thinkers that we all we all of you know kind of coalesce around a certain form of money because of a belief system or you know because we're all just idiots

101
00:46:46.080 --> 00:47:24.240
Or crazy but but more realistically it it's not a collective hallucination nor is it a shared belief system it is kind of a natural and individualistic recognition that there is value to exchange and that exchange is an intersubjective problem and if if you're recognizing of those problems which are problems that every individual has then it becomes a tangible you know kind of a tangible decision point as to an evaluation of a various set of market goods and making a determination as to which good is going to facilitate that exchange the

102
00:47:24.240 --> 00:47:42.520
Best. And so then we could talk about the various different properties, but it's really built on that those two principles that money is a money's a necessity. It's not a collective hallucination. There are kind of like tangible and objective ways that people evaluate it and people converge because the problem is intersubjective.

103
00:47:42.520 --> 00:48:20.760
And then and then if you take it one level higher is that if you just think about price and the existence of price and the importance of price and that that it is the output or the expression of what is inherently subjective value, that a price system could not emerge if convergence on a single currency was not a precursor such that you know I you know in in some of my writings I'm a little bit loose and I say that economics converge on a or monetary mediums converge on a single medium but it's more realistically because of that function

104
00:48:20.760 --> 00:48:31.560
Of money to price is that economic systems actually emerge from a single currency that rather than converge on one. I like that that makes sense.

105
00:48:31.800 --> 00:48:42.700
All right, so just continuing the sort of steel manning the naysayers a little bit. You know, maybe they might say that we have the wrong protocol, right? We have the wrong monetary instrument.

106
00:48:43.480 --> 00:48:55.320
Something better you know is bound to come along as technology improves. So what are the properties of Bitcoin in particular that could possibly make us confident that it's the one

107
00:48:58.920 --> 00:49:32.800
So I think that you know, first and foremost, it's kind of an assessment of what it you know again, coming back to the root level objective, which is communicating subjective value, what is it, what is the medium that's going to do that most effectively? And realistically, if we're thinking about price and the form of money that leads to the most unmanipulable form of money and the least distortion in the pricing mechanism, it is ultimately the form of money that that has the lowest rate of change.

108
00:49:32.800 --> 00:49:59.680
And the reason being that kind of if we're looking at a you know, I have a diagram that I lay out that's just because is a simplistic representation. But you know, if if there are six variables and on on one side there's the demand and supply of good A and the demand side demand and supply of good B, and then in the center of that you have money, and the demand for money is constantly changing.

109
00:49:59.680 --> 00:50:32.560
But if the if the supply were constant, then that that constant that exists in terms of the supply of money creates the anchor, the point that doesn't move for people to then understand all the variables that move around that single constant. And so when you know, if there is a single attractive thing about Bitcoin, it is that it in a terminal state of existence has an unmanipulable and a fixed supply.

110
00:50:32.560 --> 00:50:57.280
And that's the 21 million supply of Bitcoin. Like that that is what everything is is built off of. But kind of recognizing that that scarcity for scarcity's sake, you know, it is not necessarily what's important. It's more important that the rate of change of the currency is low, and that zero being the optimal kind of and the lowest the lowest bound, because again, it's the absolute change.

111
00:50:57.280 --> 00:51:17.320
You know, something lower than zero isn't better than zero. It's actually zero is the optimal number because of the communication of price. But but but then kind of extracting a layer from there, if you just had a scarce resource but it was impossible to move, it's not necessarily functional in either measuring value or facilitating exchange.

112
00:51:17.320 --> 00:51:45.240
And so you know, I think that there's a number of properties, but if I were to simplify it, it's that 21 million is a fixed number. And then Bitcoin is divisible to 100 million units such that it can it can precisely measure any and all value. And then on top of that, it is is very easy to not only divide in terms of the unit itself, but then it's it's very easy to transfer those units.

113
00:51:45.240 --> 00:52:13.880
And that really is the function of money, which is exchange. So when you put all of those things together and understand the problem of money, that is why Bitcoin is the optimal currency and the optimal protocol for money. So, you know, if somebody, if some government comes along or a big corporation like Facebook, we've seen try to make an attempt and they say, all right, look, we realize let's just like take the example of a government first.

114
00:52:13.880 --> 00:52:36.680
We realize the error of our ways here. We've you know, we apologize for fucking everyone over for so long. So we're going to you know, we've learned this lesson for Bitcoin. We're gonna take take that cue and create our own Fed coin, and we're gonna have the same monetary policy as Bitcoin, and we're gonna make it just as divisible, just as easily transferable.

115
00:52:36.680 --> 00:53:00.080
But you know, the difference is we have, you know, it has the full faith and credit of the US government behind it. Why, you know, at that point someone might say, okay, well, obviously that that's the new money because it's you know backed by government. We're so used to governments being in control of money. If and when that happens, how does Bitcoin emerge the emerge victorious?

116
00:53:00.160 --> 00:53:21.840
So I think that answer is very simple, which is that and this is something that I glossed over about the 21 million fixed supply, but that if the if the US government did that and created the exact same protocol and you know had a 21 million you know mining schedule, that system would always be inherently built on trust.

117
00:53:21.840 --> 00:54:00.560
And that a the reliability of and the credibility of the monetary supply is you know kind of a precursor to anyone actually believing or or understanding why the supply is actually fixed. So in a world where whether it's a government or another altcoin that's created by a group of individuals, you know, the inherent amount of centralization and trust that will be involved in those protocols will always be greater than Bitcoin because Bitcoin already exists and is more decentralized and only becomes increasingly decentralized

118
00:54:00.560 --> 00:54:38.680
Over time. And so, you know, kind of if we if we think about you know adoption of ad adoption or adoption waves of Bitcoin, recognizing that there is a fixed supply, that the decentralization of the ownership of that currency increases over time, and that as that decentralization of the ownership of the currency becomes greater, that 21 million actually ever becomes a more and more reliable number and so the world of money and because you know because monies you know are essentially the root of a

119
00:54:38.680 --> 00:55:11.160
Price system and the root of a of an economic system it it's always you're it's always an A B test you're always having to make the most critical decision which one of these two things do I want to hold and so you know Bitcoin doesn't live in a vacuum such that if any altcoin was created or any you know Fed coin or China coin was created, Bitcoin is there as an option and it provides more credible monetary policy because it's trustless and it only becomes less dependent on trust over time as it as it decentralizes.

120
00:55:11.240 --> 00:55:49.240
Yep exactly all right so can so that I guess given all that then and Bitcoin's you know it's it's gonna it's divisible it's very transferable it's got a perfect monetary policy you know even if governments come at it with their own coin you know they've they've built up so much distrust that you know the one one very important property of money is that it's you know based on trust Bitcoin wins in that department too so you know is Bitcoin then inevitable at this point I'm gonna be bold I think so yeah

121
00:55:49.400 --> 00:56:19.040
I it you know it's certainly my base case and I try to take a step back and to try to assess blind spots or yeah, what what causes Bitcoin to fail? And I think that they're you know ultimately we kind of recognize that it's a dynamic system and that certain changes could be made that that could compromise the security of the protocol.

122
00:56:19.040 --> 00:56:39.200
But more realistically, and it's not necessarily just kind of the idea of a Lindy effect that the longer something exists, the longer it it will be expected to exist. It's that the larger that Bitcoin becomes the less susceptible it is to any sort of critical failure.

123
00:56:39.200 --> 00:57:01.120
And you know, there and I still have you know you know a certain degree of recognition that you know what what happens if the CIA you know kind of backends all the Bitcoin mining chips and just zaps the network all at once and causes mass mass you know confusion.

124
00:57:01.120 --> 00:57:19.760
Like is that a practical reality? And I think that more realistically, as we think about kind of Bitcoin in total, at this point, in my view, Bitcoin only fails by human action. And what I mean by that is that gold failed by human action.

125
00:57:19.760 --> 00:57:57.760
Gold as as a as a as a monetary medium had certain limitations, it being that it would you know while it was while it's possible to buy gold and it's possible to transfer gold, it's very difficult, it was susceptible to centralization, and ultimately it became co-opted by by human action. And so if if Bitcoin were to fail, it would it would it would less likely be a technological reason at this point, it would more be you know a combination of failure to act or or people kind of bowing down to you know 6102 type, you know, people saying, Oh, suddenly Bitcoin's illegal, but more realistically,

126
00:57:57.760 --> 00:58:15.960
In that standpoint, Bitcoin's global and money is a necessity and Bitcoin provides such a value proposition to virtually you know an addressable market that is everyone in the world that that it becomes so important that it just immunizes around every threat.

127
00:58:16.040 --> 00:58:54.120
It's amazing man we're all sort of like a lot of us you know are just coming to this realization sl you know gradually then suddenly like you say in your the title of your blog series and you know it's it's been gradual thus far but it feels like it's accelerating and it feels like this you know the process of this realization you know across all of society is accelerating and it feels like this sort of this next run is going to be you know get us maybe close enough to that inflection point where it's gonna happen sometime in the middle 2020s or something that you can just feel this momentum building

128
00:58:54.200 --> 00:59:32.600
The infrastructure being built out and the conviction of those who are here is just just sky high at this point. Yeah and I think that you know part of that is a function of distribution of information and that it be exponential right you know as as soon as you know and I've I've written a piece on this that Bitcoin isn't a pyramid scheme, but it's it's almost like when someone figures out the secret the secret that exists in the world like rather than wanting to keep that to yourself it's it's it's a you want to go cu communicate that to all

129
00:59:32.600 --> 01:00:10.800
Your friends and family and why because it is it is such a rare and unique phenomenon. But you know I also think that you know a big piece of this is that you know value draw you know value pays for infrastructure as more people demand Bitcoin and as Bitcoin's value increases it's actually increasing by a function of that adoption and then that affords for additional capital formation so it it it really feeds on itself part of it is you know and maybe that can just be an extension of the distribution of knowledge but but at but you know kind of

130
01:00:10.800 --> 01:00:47.760
On one hand it's people you know resources like your podcast like Marty's podcast like Stefan's podcast but but then but but it's actually the value that's affording all of those opportunities in the first place and then and then and then the other side of that value is the development of additional infrastructure more wallets you know kind of whether it's Pierre working on a node launcher or the folks at Lightning Labs the folks at Trezor you know cold card whoever may be what we're doing here at Unchain we're all able to do this because people in an increasing way are seeing the value in Bitcoin.

131
01:00:48.000 --> 01:01:17.720
And so I do think that there's a very natural at least in in the world that we exist today that you know just dictated by human psychology that that you know people move in herds and so you know naturally that means that people adopt Bitcoin in waves and people are drawn into Bitcoin because you know they may have forgotten about it for a couple of years but then you know at some point in time Bitcoin's going to be at an all-time high and then they're gonna realize that Bitcoin wasn't dead and that maybe they should start paying attention.

132
01:01:17.720 --> 01:01:36.280
And it's actually that price and that value that draws more people in and it draws people in in waves. And then slowly when those waves come in, then they then it's like a wave happens, you know, say an order of magnitude, more people begin to own Bitcoin. That is that's like the price of entry.

133
01:01:36.280 --> 01:01:58.600
And then you start falling down, you know, there then becomes a path of people that start to fall down that rabbit hole that that figure out, okay, you know, I just bought this because I didn't know why, but everyone else was doing it, so I did it. And even if a small percentage of those people are so curious that they go they want to figure out why, then the base of holders doubles and triples very easily.

134
01:01:58.600 --> 01:02:32.520
And so and then more and more people figure it out. So it's a combination of distribution of knowledge and human psychology, and then and then just the survival instinct and the common sense that everybody needs money. Yeah, it's just kind of a step ladder up the adoption curve. The price is like a stepladder up the adoption curve. So it seems like I think so far in the cycles, and we'll see if this continues to play out over time, but we've had a couple three you know, three of these cycles at this point, and you know, you had one that kind of peaked at a hundred and then it fell down to you know, like a third of that, and then it peaked at a thousand, kind of fell down to a third of that.

135
01:02:32.520 --> 01:02:55.880
But there's this, you know, you can demonstrably see this this floor at each wave, and that's you know, I think you could could say is the product of you know the amount of the hodler base, the hodlers of last resort, as Trace Mayer calls them, is is growing with each, you know, with each wave. And then correspondingly we grow the infrastructure and that helps out you know with the next wave and everything.

136
01:02:55.880 --> 01:03:23.520
Yeah, and when you begin to see it, it becomes like almost rhythmic or you know, highly explainable, where you know, and I don't know how many people actually own Bitcoin, but I like you know, we'll just pull out I think numbers that are directionally correct. If if five to ten million of people own Bitcoin before 2016, in that adoption wave, then you have 50 to 50 to 100 million people then began to own it.

137
01:03:23.520 --> 01:03:45.680
And they likely you know owned it purely for speculative reasons, didn't understand why, didn't want to miss it. But then if you think about that order of magnitude increase, that even you know, even if 10% of that new base of people figures it out and takes the time, which is a very low percentage, then the holder base doubles.

138
01:03:45.680 --> 01:04:06.720
And that that's why we kind of never retrace those those prior lows, because you now have you know 2x, 3x, 4 people, 4x, you know, the number of people that are all competing for what is an otherwise you know scarce resource on a fixed supply. So supply is completely inelastic, but demand is is practically infinite.

139
01:04:06.720 --> 01:04:30.960
And so you know, the that that rise and fall, you know, to me becomes rhythmic and becomes a function of human psychology, but but that really kind of becomes mathematical in the sense that like I think you're right, that as price rises, it really that's what draws people in, but then it's the conversion of those, and it can be a very small percentage that provides for sustaining at you know multiples of levels higher from prior highs.

140
01:04:31.040 --> 01:04:51.920
Yeah, and that's I mean, just one of the incredibly genius aspects of Bitcoin is that it incentivizes its own growth, it incentivizes the spreading of that knowledge, both because you know there's a monetary you know incentive, there's a there's a speculation that that it might go up in price and you know, incredibly it's the most it was the best performing financial asset in the past decade.

141
01:04:51.920 --> 01:05:22.520
There's you know plenty of reason to believe that that might be the case for the next another decade or two, maybe even more, depending on how long this takes to play out but and then also through just the inspiration the cause like we've been talking about that this is you know a reason a deep reason to you know it's it potentially changes the world right I mean in all the ways that we've been talking about it's fundamental money's fundamental to human society and if you fix the money you're gonna fix a lot of a lot what's you know a lot of what's wrong about human society.

142
01:05:22.520 --> 01:05:44.280
In fact I would I would argue yeah go ahead go ahead no I mean I just I think about it because you know at times I try to kind of like re reduce my role in the world and think of it as yeah I'm I'm I'm just here trying to help you know me and my closest friends and family figure out a better way to store value and if if some other strangers are helped along the way like that you know that's a good positive externality.

143
01:05:44.520 --> 01:06:15.240
But but more realistically I think that the people that that have you know that really get involved in Bitcoin and that that see the potential for Bitcoin are also in in ways motivated by and at least at least this is the case in my in my you know kind of personal perspective it's you know whether Bitcoin existed or not there is a systemic problem in the existing monetary system and that Bitcoin is the most viable solution.

144
01:06:15.240 --> 01:06:37.640
And so if if someone is choosing to contribute in in some form or fashion it you know it's it's generally guided or at least let me just speak in my sense it's it's guided on this idea that you know, I'm working in a in a small way, I'm working on the solution to the biggest problem that exists today.

145
01:06:37.680 --> 01:06:56.640
And it's a big problem that you know, I'm working in a very small corner of it, building, you know, a business to help people better secure their Bitcoin and provide financial services. But in that value chain, everyone has their own interests, and because Bitcoin isn't guided by conscious control, that's why the output of it is so great.

146
01:06:56.640 --> 01:07:19.200
You know, someone that's focused on the Lightning Network or focused on building the hardware, or someone that's, you know, my you know, one of my good friends, Gideon Powell's building, you know, wildcatting Bitcoin, you know, mining farms out in West Texas. They're like everybody looking at the problem, they see that they see that there's A and B, you know, A being Bitcoin, B being the legacy system, legacy system is is dying.

147
01:07:19.200 --> 01:07:41.600
And do I want to contribute to the solution? Where can my skill set contribute, or where do I see acute problems that I can help solve? Yeah, yeah. I mean, I would argue that, you know, the two most development, two most important developments in human history are human language, you know, spoken written language, and then money, which is the language language of transferring value of the value of your time.

148
01:07:41.600 --> 01:08:03.120
So they're I mean extremely powerful in in the foundation of human society and progress. You know, and that's why governments, you know, and any, you know, throughout history, kind of centralization of power, centralizers of power, they seek to control them, right? Governments and centralizers of power seek to control language, that they use propaganda, they control media messaging, they restrict access to information.

149
01:08:03.120 --> 01:08:22.240
And then they also, of course, have sought the control of the money. You know, I mean, the freedom from control of speech and the freedom from control of the money by centralized parties are incredibly important to combat. And I don't think there's any more pressing moral imperative today than them fighting for Bitcoin.

150
01:08:22.800 --> 01:08:49.560
Yeah, I mean, I would I would definitely agree that the co-option or coercion of money has such pervasive effects on the entire economic structure. Like it it there is no one that it doesn't impact that that that is what causes kind of the problem that Bitcoin stands to solve, to elevate it to kind of, you know, in my view, that you know, collectively the greatest project that anybody could work on.

151
01:08:49.560 --> 01:09:23.480
And the, you know, it's it's funny, one of the one of the things that causes me to, you know, when I when I take my time to you know check my biases, it's it's that you know, if there's a thing that gives me pause, it's it's not anything that's based on reason or rationale, but it's that are we, and when I say we, you know, it's collectively like anyone who's alive today, to are we are we the people that get to see the you know monetization event of you know the solution to this problem?

152
01:09:23.480 --> 01:09:50.520
Because I think it is such such a rare thing, and that you know, if we if we looked back toward the monetization of gold, you know, kind of we're obviously all more technologically advanced today and it can happen more more rapidly that you know, if if gold monetized over the course of decades, Bitcoin could very easily monetize to a steady state in a decade, in my view.

153
01:09:50.600 --> 01:10:11.160
Yeah, so I mean that that's actually the last question I was gonna ask, and I think you just answered it was the you know, we have the showdown, the A-B test, as you put it, between the dominant fiat money, the US dollar, and Bitcoin, and we've now agreed that Bitcoin's inevitable. So I mean, is your sense that this will take or could you know could take another decade to play out?

154
01:10:11.160 --> 01:10:49.600
Where's your kind of time frame range on the end game for this between between the dollar and Bitcoin? So I kind of I think about it as you know, how long can the existing monetary system survive and you know as kind of one end of the as one end of the spectrum, but then I also recognize that that it is a dynamic equation that if someone is choosing to own Bitcoin, they are they are making maybe not in all s situations, a con you know, whether it's conscious or subconscious,

155
01:10:49.600 --> 01:11:12.640
They're they're making a decision to opt out. And so I do think that or at least I take a realistic view, and you know I don't know, man many people or most people may not agree with me. I don't think that there's a seamless transition from a world of excess and unsustainable debt to a new utopian vision of money.

156
01:11:12.640 --> 01:11:39.360
I think that the that the pain that you know at at some point like there is no world of debt jubilees, because ultimately, you know, kind of w what happens is you know, when that when the existing credit system and the existing monas monetary system devolves, it will cause economic stability, and we all in some form or fashion would be you know paying for for those past decades of excess.

157
01:11:39.360 --> 01:11:57.440
But if Bitcoin didn't exist, there wouldn't be a system to reboot. And that that that's really what it offers in in terms of the global, you know, kind of global monetary system as a whole. And so I think that there's there's two things.

158
01:11:57.440 --> 01:12:19.320
It's kind of how many crises can the can the Fed and the ECB and the BOJ have beat down but then also recognizing that Bitcoin actually accelerates the conversion away from the legacy system because if you think about it from a very individual transaction level it's like how do you get Bitcoin?

159
01:12:19.320 --> 01:12:57.560
Well you know generally today you know well whether you're doing this today or not you're just you're deciding not to demand dollars in an increasing way or or euros or yen or bolivars or whatever but in the most practical application today people are converting some form of fiat directly to Bitcoin. How do you get fiat you've got to you've got to sell some other generally financial asset given how financialized the economy is well if you're selling those financial assets you know whether it's equities or credit to get dollars to get Bitcoin you're essentially causing that that credit system the preemption of that credit system to collapse because it has to be sustained by asset prices that are priced in dollars.

160
01:12:57.560 --> 01:13:35.560
And so as individuals increasingly do that what it's going to cause is the acceleration of the Fed's reliance on QE or QE everywhere whether it's the Fed or other central banks. And so I really do believe and then and then also kind of independent from that but recognizing that it is a dynamic equation and that the you know the paths of both are are it's like you know two trains running full speed at each other that you know independent from that and even if we lived in a world where the problems that existed in the in the Fed's world weren't so systemic and acute, it would be that

161
01:13:35.560 --> 01:14:11.680
That Bitcoin still presents a better form of money. And that you know with the distribution of knowledge and understanding that that can happen at a very rapid pace that you know I while I'm not a you know carrying card member of the of the stock to flow model I do believe that you know it it's it it may not be more than a few halvings away you know within within the next decade I think that is is a is a is a non-crazy world in which the world could be kind of fully monetized in Bitcoin.

162
01:14:12.000 --> 01:14:50.160
Yeah I mean you know three halvings from now Bitcoin will be by far you know the most scarce asset that humanity's ever seen it's gonna be well under gold at that point. And you know I financial the financial industry has to take notice of that and I think you know once this next halving comes which is just a few months away now and Bitcoin will be just about as scarce as gold I think that's gonna wake a lot of a lot of people in the financial industry up who are you know looking for you know more stable assets stores of value you know hedges against financial volatility et cetera

163
01:14:50.400 --> 01:15:11.360
And yeah and I hadn't thought about this but you know you mentioned this idea that that Bitcoin sort of sucks the lifeblood out of the current economic paradigm through you know draining it of the credit that it needs to survive so then it forces governments to you know more money to put credit back into the system and accelerates the Bitcoinization process.

164
01:15:11.360 --> 01:15:49.480
And I that's that's a novel idea for me. Yeah I think yeah, work work that one through a few kind of you know kind of steps of the thought process. And I think that it's something that I'm still developing, but I but I do think it's you know it it like the you know I think we all recognize that the systems are dynamic and that you know one one thing that's that's easier to understand is like when when you see the price of Bitcoin on a screen, and while it's you know typically quoted in some fiat term, that every time that a Bitcoin is transacted on a on a secondary market, the exact same of dollars and the exact same of Bitcoin in the

165
01:15:49.480 --> 01:16:10.120
World didn't change at that point in time. The preference of holding one or the other did. And that increasingly, as people adopt Bitcoin, it is an expression that they would increasingly like to hold Bitcoin rather than the dollar or any fiat pair or any other sort of monetary medium, whether it be fiat or gold. And so it is it is a very dynamic equation.

166
01:16:10.120 --> 01:16:28.120
And I think that you're also right that and I often have these conversations when I go talk to people in the in the prior worlds that I used to live in and their resistance to Bitcoin, I often just casually casually throw out. I don't try to press the matter, but I just ask them when do they think that they're gonna get stopped into Bitcoin.

167
01:16:28.120 --> 01:16:49.800
That that's kind of my you know, kind of the old my the old language around you know, like as Bitcoin increases in value, it becomes more more relevant to a wider base of people. That you know, at you know, if Bitcoin was 15 billion in whole, it was only relevant to a small niche of people.

168
01:16:49.800 --> 01:17:07.880
If it's 150 billion, it it's more relevant to a wider net. If it's 500 billion, if it's trillion, it it becomes impossible to ignore. And so while we all we always joke about or we you know, people you know joke about number go up and price, but it but it's a real thing.

169
01:17:07.880 --> 01:17:46.000
That you know the more value that exists and that that you know can facilitate commerce within the bitcoin world it tangibly causes bitcoin to be more relevant to more people and generally higher net worth or higher net worth institutions if bitcoins 100 billion is it relevant to Apple if it's a trillion does it become relevant yeah probably yeah you know so so you know everything derives is a function of value but ultimately d value is derived as a function of adoption which which is you know a derivative of

170
01:17:46.000 --> 01:18:24.320
People increasingly seeing the value on average of holding and demanding Bitcoin as a monetary meaning yeah those that those big numbers that have psychological you know impact on people and institutions and as number goes up you know 10,000 was a big one in the last run you know that we just kind of blew off to about 2000 which was also a big number and I think that's kind of why we stopped there people are like oh it's 2000 dump you know we gotta this is this is crazy and you know I think having a market cap which is about you know of a trillion dollars which is about five X from here which seems very likely

171
01:18:24.320 --> 01:18:46.400
To happen in the next in this next cycle if you know if things play out as we seem to think they are the rhythm the rhythm continues yet yeah the crossing a trillion dollar market cap is going to be you know just make in no one in the financial world is is not is going to be unaware of that and it's gonna be talked about for for quite a while and seems like it would cause some piling in.

172
01:18:46.400 --> 01:19:09.080
Yeah, they they will not be able to ignore it at that point. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Oh man, it's gonna be exciting. It's gonna be a lot of fun to watch. It's you know I say this most episodes now, but I'm all jacked up by the end of them, and I just say it's you know, it's it's such a privilege to be here at this relatively early stage and to be able to talk about it with you know the player the players that are that are in the game.

173
01:19:09.080 --> 01:19:35.240
It's still small enough, you know, that we can you know have access to you know people who are you know basically driving this industry right now and working on spreading adoption. And it's just it's just really exciting. And I think looking back in 10, 15, 20 years, you know, I think we're all gonna be able to you know be really proud of the work we did here and in helping Bitcoin you know become become the new money and really change the world.

174
01:19:35.240 --> 01:19:53.880
Yep. What a time to be alive. What a time, man. All right, Parker. Thanks so much. That was a really fun conversation. Looking forward to you know, doing this again. You know, probably off the record, but doing this again, hanging out at at Bitcoin 2020. Yeah, I'm looking forward to seeing you out there and everybody else who's who's gonna be out there again.

175
01:19:53.880 --> 01:20:14.680
If you if you don't have a ticket yet, it's not too late. Let's see in San Francisco. Let's do it. All right, thanks, Parker. Take care, man. All right, talk soon. Thanks to Parker for joining me for a fun discussion.

176
01:20:14.680 --> 01:20:34.360
Let us know your thoughts and questions about the episode. Parker is at Parker A Lewis. That's P-A-R-K-E-R-A-L-E-W-I-S. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. And that's the best way to support the pod. Sharing it out on Bitcoin Twitter. Let people know a favorite bits or a question you had or something you didn't like.

177
01:20:34.360 --> 01:20:53.040
And also share it with your family and friends. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to LTBN for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast in the feed. Don't forget to check out Bitcoin 2020. It's just around the corner. I hope to see you there.

178
01:20:53.040 --> 01:21:15.680
If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at CitizenBitcoin on Telegram and Keybase as well. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. This week's open source shout out is Armory. Armory is a secure and full featured solution available for users and institutions to generate and store Bitcoin private keys.

179
01:21:15.680 --> 01:21:34.400
This means users never have to trust the Armory team. And this can be used with the Glacier Protocol, which is a protocol for high security Bitcoin storage. Armory pioneered air gapped cold storage and distributed multi-signature. Check out BitcoinArmory.com for more.

180
01:21:34.400 --> 01:21:54.560
Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
