Steve Barbour: Bitcoin Mining and Upstream Data Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-08-01 [00:00:19] Welcome to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. So, how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing fantastic today. Before we get started, I want to take a second to ask you to check out Layer1BTC.com for some great Bitcoin merch. [00:00:41] Shout out to Nick Ward, who runs the show over there. He's a fantastic designer. He's got shirts, hats, hoodies, mugs, stickers. Many designs to choose from. Great designs. Click on partners at the top and choose Citizen Bitcoin to shop for merch that supports this podcast, including the default Keynesian Recovery Center design. [00:01:00] Bitcoin is teaching all of us default Keynesians what money really is, and that is nothing short of revolutionary in this day and age. So that's layer one btc.com, all spelled out. Go check it out. Alright, let's do this. [00:01:20] Steve Barbour is the owner of Upstream Data in Canada, a company offering modular and portable Bitcoin mining hardware to the oil and gas industry in Canada. A lot of you will know him from Bitcoin Twitter. If you don't follow him already, you ought to. He's at SG Barber. Barber is spelled B-A-R-B-O-U-R. [00:01:42] Steve and I discuss his background and the process of building upstream data, designing the line of ohm mining products that allow oil and gas producers to capture the value of wasted energy as Bitcoin. We also discuss the broader mining industry and what Bitcoin has taught Steve over these last few years. [00:02:01] Hope all of you enjoy this dive into the Bitcoin mining scene. Here we go. [00:02:14] Alright, I've got Steve Barbour with me from Upstream Data in Canada. Welcome to the show, Steve. Thanks for joining us. No problem. Thanks for having me, Brady. Appreciate it. Yeah, I'm excited to get into Bitcoin mining. It's a topic that we haven't dived into too much on the show. I did talk with Matt Odell a few months ago. We got into some Bitcoin mining talk, but it'll be fun to focus on it in this episode. [00:02:36] Can we just get started hearing a bit about your backgrounds, how you got into the oil and gas industry, and then how you found Bitcoin and got into mining. Yeah, well, when I was doing mechanic well, I've done mechanical engineering in school, and when I graduated, I'm from Newfoundland, so went to school in Newfoundland when I graduated. [00:02:55] I moved out to Alberta here on the west side of Canada. And Alberta's being a big oil province, got into the oil and gas with my first employer was Husky Energy. So that's how I started in the oil patch, and I was doing production and facilities engineering. I had a couple roles for Husky. [00:03:15] So very I've always really been really interested in oil and gas production and you know, like just sort of improving existing facilities and optimizing production to see how we can get more oil out of the ground at a lower cost, that kind of thing. So I was I was there for about five and a half years or so. [00:03:34] Really interested in that kind of stuff. Then I left Husky actually to start my own company. It wasn't nothing to do with Bitcoin. I still hadn't actually really heard of Bitcoin at this time. So I left them in around 2016 ish. Sort of started my own company where I do like product design. [00:03:53] So effectively what what the plan was and what I what I ended up doing, what I still sort of do passively, but now it's it's on the back burner just because of this Bitcoin company. But I would basically go look at you know what products sell, what products are useful, what does everyone want in the oil field, like a lot mainly downhole tools. [00:04:12] I'm talking about it's a lot of my expertise is in downhole stuff. So what's what's downhole mean? Downhole being like pumps literally just in the ground. Yeah, like my my primary specialty is progressing heavy pumps, like these rotary pumps that pump heavy oil from the ground. So basically like pump jacks, except instead of being a reciprocating pump, it's a rotary pump. [00:04:33] Gotcha. Yeah, so and then all the tools associated with that pumping system is primarily what I specialize in. And you know, like any industry, there's always room for improvement, right? So I'm I'm looking at these tools and trying to figure out bad ways of doing it. And so that's why I left my former that employer, just because I couldn't really fulfill that my my job didn't really have much to do with like product design and that kind of thing, and that's what I really like doing. [00:04:59] So that's what I was doing or I still am sort of doing, but not really. I basically will we'll find improvements to tools. Basically the plan is effectively to patent improvements and then license them back to the manufacturers and that kind of thing, sort of have a passive income. It's a very good way to make a living, I think, for those of you who are, you know, you know, my minded for innovating and then in product design and that kind of thing. [00:05:25] But so I've been doing that. I actually have a few successful licenses ongoing, but in that time Yeah, yeah, and in that time, so that's when I learned about Bitcoin. Like I was I started that company and I was working on these licenses and yeah, really just for the first time I think it might have been like on Reddit, I can't remember where I you know first saw some talking about Bitcoin. [00:05:46] I had heard of it before, of course, I think a lot of people 2013 time frame. But I'd never put any time into it. And so that's when I started putting time into it, just okay, what is this thing? Like it's still still alive, like you know, like I gotta see what this is all about, right? Right. And yeah, so I just looked into it a bit and obviously like yourself and probably ninety-nine percent of the listeners, it was just there's so much about it that was just so intriguing, you just fall down that hole. [00:06:12] So that's sort of how I got into it. What really drove me to get into it though was I just thought mining was unbelievable. I just thought it was crazy that and I think maybe one of the first times that it sort of dawned on me is probably Andreas Antonopoulos' talk where he talked about you know, like Bitcoin mining as an Hartrage mechanism. [00:06:35] And he I think he re referred to ideas like, you know, like in doesn't matter what country you're in, doesn't matter where you're in the world, doesn't matter how remote you are, stranded energy, like if you have this low value electricity, if you can convert low value energy potential into electricity, well you can get paid for it at the same cost anywhere else, right? [00:06:56] Like one kilowatt hour in I don't know, like Uganda is worth kilowatt hour in Canada, right? So this this was really I just thought that was crazy, like mind boggling. And is that it was at that same time like when I was learning about mining. I mean the biggest problem I wouldn't maybe not the biggest problem, but it's it's gotta be up there in the oil industry is is is stranded natural gas, right? [00:07:18] Like wasted gas. And that that's really just a function of economics, like the gas is so worthless or so low value that it just gets wasted, right? So yeah, some well is producing at a rate that like just can't be used, and so it it like the market is just not like demanding enough gas at that point, or it's just like too costly to transport it, or like is that are those all reasons why, or there's probably more other reasons too? [00:07:44] Oh yeah. I mean there's a there's many there's a few scenarios that you know you can end up having a waste stream. But like I'll give you one example, like this Texas install I did recently, they basically you know well, first of all, if for anyone following the oil and gas industry, Texas in particular with all the Hermione activity, the shale gas, fracking, they have a huge oversupply of gas. [00:08:08] So it it's it's been so bad this year that there's been several times where the actual gas prices, the Waha price, I think they call it down there, is has gone negative. Like it's gone like the producer, the person supplying the gas has to pay to get rid of it, which is sort of completely backwards, right? Right. [00:08:26] So that's how that's the severity of it. And I mean that's just an indicate. Now that's a that's a basically a bottlenecked area. There's too much gas and there's not enough demand. So even like I wasn't in that area when I when we installed this Bitcoin miner over east of that area. But they s they didn't have negative prices, but they still had extremely low prices. [00:08:48] So you know, they they ended up drilling for oil, missed it, but found a ton of gas, like some really good gas plays. But they have no I mean, I think the cost of a pipeline in you know the infrastructure to get it into the sales line was over eighty million dollars, and the payouts just weren't there. So I mean the only thing they could possibly do with decimal capital is abandon it and basically let it, you know, the capital is then sunk. [00:09:12] Right. So I mean that that's where you know they're interested in in Bitcoin money because you can just drop it on site, there's a pipeline required, right? So you just you just through the magic of the internet, you earn value. So that's like one example where you just have low value gas and it's it's remote. There's other other cases, like I mean in in so I live in Lloyd Minster and we're just scrading Saskatchewan as well. [00:09:40] So in this whole area, you know, we have all these oil wells, so they're the they're pumping oil wells, but a byproduct of that oil production is gas. Sort of the same deal. Like, I mean, we can we do when it makes economic sense, we'll put in like a compressor and a pipeline and send it down the line to a sales line, or like even tie it into other wells and feed them as fuel gas. [00:10:03] But more often than not, that's not feasible. You're just gonna lose money on a project like that. So what they do is they just vent it straight out of the pipe, just straightened the atmosphere, the gas just streams out into the atmosphere. Right. And you're allowed to do that up to a certain amount. And beyond that, you have to flare it. So there's a couple cases I just you know I talked about, but you know, there's a there's a few, there's a bunch more reasons why these streams are are wasted. [00:10:29] Yeah, okay, so that makes sense. And it's fascinating, like Andreas pointed out, in that video you mentioned, that the possibility for Bitcoin mining, and there's this talk, you know, all over the place that that Bitcoin mining is is wasteful. And you know, there's all kinds of like we I do have I've spent a lot of time on this podcast talking about energy FUD and how to refute it because it's it's such a big one and it's you know one of the top the first or the second thing you're gonna hear from somebody who's new to Bitcoin, the question you're gonna get and the thing that they hear that sticks in their mind is Bitcoin mining is super wasteful. [00:11:05] It's using, you know, this amount of electricity that of an of entire countries, etc. Etc. And of course, like, you know, i if people if there's a demand for it, then it's not a waste, I guess. I mean, we it Bitcoin mining still doesn't use as much electricity as like Christmas lights in the United States, for instance, right? Yeah, I agree. [00:11:25] I mean, like the it's e it's easy to make these comparisons. I just find it like I think this the simplest I mean, at least in my head, I mean, if someone's paying for something, like you can't really you can't really claim it's a waste. Like there's just no I mean, paying for something implies you find it useful, right? [00:11:43] We're Bitcoin miners are being paid by then by the economy of people using Bitcoin. So it's a really like it's like when people bring that up to me. I mean I don't even get into all these you can get into all kinds of different ways to refute it, but you know, like I don't know, like people I don't pay for I don't know, like I don't pay for a beyond me burger or something like that. [00:12:06] But it's not it's not y like it's useless to me, but it's not a waste. I mean it's some other people I find it a waste, but other people like it, right? Like so it's not I would never say that about something people are willing a product people are willing to buy find useful. So I mean, I don't know, like it's it's that alone you gotta ha sort of you gotta have some like cognitive dissonance to sort of think that that's a logical argument, but but then and then you have like companies like myself, like upstream data, but also even like most mining, I mean there's been reports now, like CoinShares has that report on a lot of mining is actually done off of surplus and otherwise curtailed renewable [00:12:45] Projects. So we're talking solar, wind, and primarily hydro. I mean hydro Bitcoin miners, as everyone knows, they flocked to the hydro facilities and the hydropower. Half of that, like most a lot of that electricity they're you know consuming is actually just what have been running down the river. So you know, they had no demand. [00:13:04] So that's another thing I tell people, like the amount of energy consumed by a Bitcoin miners, which we can pretty easily measure, or at least give a range, right? Last time I looked, it was between three and five gigawatts of like constant load on on the network. So that that is not strictly additive to the you know the so people like one of the common ones you'll you see, I'm sure is you know, Bitcoin mining miners are consuming as much power as Ireland and this is getting out of hand. [00:13:35] Right. The oceans are gonna boil. But but the but it's not strictly additive. It's it's first of all, it's using up what's a lot a lot of what is actually wasted or not or not generated because it's it's bypassed the generators, like the solar is curtailed and turned off, that kind of thing. [00:13:55] Or it's displacing. Like when you spend and this this is probably the argument I like the most. When you spend a dollar on something, that's you cannot spend that same dollar on something else, you know, and spend double spending. Right. When you spend energy on something, when you dedicate energy to doing something, you cannot dedicate it towards something else. [00:14:16] So the energy dedicated towards mining is not dedicated on whatever relatively useless crap that it would have been dedicated on. The miners are paying more money for it, therefore it's more useful. So yeah, I mean there's a there's a thousand ways to debunk that crap. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and the you know, then the further point is like the next layer that you can go to is that it's actually performing this really important function for the energy industry, right? [00:14:42] And it's oh definitely in in ways it's in it's it's like you said, it's arbitraging energy across the world so that you know more remote energy sources are then more viable because they have this other revenue stream that can support the infrastructure required to or kind of offset the infrastructure costs, etc. [00:15:00] And it's also in a kind of a roundabout way incentivizing the use of renewables in that sense. Yeah, I agree. So that that's there's some good points. Like I think that it's gonna be really interesting to see over the next, you know, it's gonna take time, but maybe let's say 20 years, how it changes energy infrastructure. [00:15:20] Because you know, like I you know, I don't have I have no experience in large scale utilities like in large scale power generation, but I can imagine yeah, just being an engineer that you know they're probably designing these facilities, like they fit they forecast what they expect the demand to be, and they over design the facilities so that it can handle you know a certain amount of peak load, right? [00:15:43] And they have a plan for handling peak load. Well, now they can really instead of over designing and having this let's say like a generator that's normally running at I don't know, fifty percent capacity from for 90% of the time just to service the 10% of the time where it peaks. Right. You can now you can now really just design it for a hundred percent load run it put all your surplus into Bitcoin mining like the utility even if they were smart they could or at least they could work with manufacturers and just use it as a load bank. [00:16:14] You just load up that generator, have it on a control system as soon as as soon as the c the paying consumer like you and I who need the power at our house and we're willing to pay for it, as soon as we turn on the lights, well they turn off the Bitcoin machines, right? Because the we're paying more than the Bitcoin machines are and that's what that's the feature I see and I th and that's a much more efficient way of designing these systems. [00:16:39] So I think that's like you're saying it's it's gonna be a really really good thing. Yeah. In terms of like I do have some thoughts on the renewables like I think that I agree with people when they say mining is a good tool for renewables. But at the same time it's it's it's like a lot of these renewable projects I guess we'll have to see in the future but right now a lot of them are heavily subsidized and they're subsidized to service grid. [00:17:08] They're not subsidized to service the mining community. So it'd be curious to see what happens once these like because m because miners are kind of come in and obviously snatch up this cheap excess and curtailed renewable power that actually might have an effect on on in the long term on how they're being subsidized because I don't think government and the state or whoever's subsidizing it is really interested in subsidizing Bitcoin miners, and that's actually what they're doing. [00:17:37] You know what I mean? So yeah they there's so much cool stuff we're gonna see. Yeah, I mean maybe it'll get profitable enough to mine Bitcoin that you know renewable energy producers will choose a Bitcoin subsidy over a government subsidy. I don't know. Yeah. [00:17:55] Yeah. So I mean, like with any any Bitcoin business, I've been thinking about this lately as you know, kind of thinking about this Bitcoin education industry that I'm you know trying to become a part of and we're trying to build as demands for for Bitcoin grows, there's gonna be you know increasing demand for education about what the heck this thing is. [00:18:19] And so when you're trying to find new customers, you've got to sell your products, but you've also got to sell Bitcoin. Yep. So when you go into the room and you're you know been you've been invited to pitch your products for upstream to some oil and gas professionals or business. [00:18:41] Imagine that I'm you know somebody you're trying to pitch to. How do you sell Bitcoin to these people? Yeah, I know great question. I mean, so first and foremost, like I've this has been a great learning process for me. You know, having a background in engineering and not really in sales. I've really learned I've I've been learning what people really want to hear. [00:19:03] Yeah. When I first started pitching, I was you know, I d I spent a fair amount of time in the pitch talking about Bitcoin. Now, this was like the first time when I was first started pitching people and telling them about what we're doing and why it's so great for their facilities. This was probably like early 2017. [00:19:23] And there's been a huge change between early 2017 and now. So that was just before the big the last big bull run, right? Most people I would talk to, and I wasn't going too hard on the sales pitching at the time because I was still trying to optimize the products and that kind of thing. But but I was talking to people about it and I would go to the occasional meeting to pitch it and almost nobody really knew what Bitcoin was. [00:19:47] Like a lot of people like literally hadn't even heard of the word Bitcoin. So they weren't they weren't even starting as long as most of us were in maybe 2013. But so I mean what I would start what I've what I did when I started was I was I would get probably a little too much into how Bitcoin's so cool and how it worked and part of it was a learning process for me because I was still learning how it worked and I mean I'm still learning how it works but back then I was a little less polished. [00:20:14] But I spent I wasted a lot of time I think selling them on the concept of Bitcoin. And I think I you know I probably changed a lot of minds because some of the people that had heard of it you know they had they bought into some of this FUD like the energy waste FUD. But of course like our our products fly in the face of that. [00:20:33] Now so what I do nowadays I no longer like I don't even first of all that there's been a change. Like most most of these producers now have heard of Bitcoin and actually a lot of them are starting to evaluate it as a solution for their facilities. Between our company getting the word out there and the news news on us and now there's other companies doing it and a lot more talk in places like Calgary you know which is sort of the oil gas hub of Canada. [00:21:02] Okay. So word has been spreading. So now what I do is I have one slide in my deck talking about Bitcoin. It's just it's called like a compelling features of Bitcoin slide. So I literally like at the end of the deck. I only break it out I usually do break it out for people that I feel like haven't really thought much about Bitcoin and that kind of thing. [00:21:23] Yeah. But there's just the s a r some really high level things in there. I never I don't ever bother explaining how it works to people anymore unless they want to hear it. And I guess I'm just learning that you know as a when you get into the sales side of things, people don't really think like engineers they don't really care about the inner workings. They just want to know okay it works. [00:21:43] It seems pretty cool. Okay, how much money am I gonna make you know so yeah I mean that that makes sense to keep it simple then do you often get like follow up questions are people intrigued by it? Or is it like what percenta what percentage of people usually like ask for more you know details about Bitcoin. [00:22:01] I would say at least fifty percent of people get want to get right right in my head and understand how does it work. Like 'cause it's it's sort of mind boggling when when you get into it how it all works. The mind virus. Yeah and they and they want to understand it and it's a lot easier talking to someone like me who's in the industry a bit and can explain it a bit better than them having to do all their own research but I mean I still keep it high level. [00:22:25] I never go too detailed. Right. But but then there's like I would say five percent of people will come out and still be extremely they just they they think it's a scam. Like they just think it's like a fad. They don't they don't think it's anything of substance you know what I mean? [00:22:44] Yeah. Right. Because it's digital. Yeah, it's not as it's not as great as their you know, it's not in their bank account. I can't spend it anywhere, like you know, that kind of thing. Yeah. The classic arguments. But yeah, and then the most mo most people are just you know, that's pretty cool. They're not that interested, but they're they're interested in the facility stuff that we talk about. [00:23:05] Right on. So what how how does this process work then when you install a product into the field for a customer? Do like how does the mining work? Are you actually like operating the rigs, the mining rigs and how like how do you share the Bitcoin? [00:23:27] Like the do they usually just want to get paid in fiat? And what yeah, how does that whole process work? Well okay, so I mean, and I tell people this all the time, like upstream data, like my company and our product and service, we're we're a service provider, like first and foremost. Okay. We're not we're not like we're a little we don't operate the same as like traditional Bitcoin miners where you know, we're trying to get a facility and do all the mining ourselves. [00:23:51] We're actually just trying to offer product and a service to the oil company because the reason for that is there's a there's a lot of reasons, but one of 'em is that they benefit the most from our from our service. When they get the let's say they're venting this gas and they're not actually allowed to vent it it's over the regulatory limitations. [00:24:15] Well, they're getting a huge financial benefit from us coming in and getting rid of it. So we exist as a service provider and so what we try to do is build and sell product to them. So and we've been gain getting more success with that recently just because you know, the awareness keeps going up like of Bitcoin and people are starting to understand it, it's becoming less of a let's call it a risk. [00:24:40] And also there's been a lot of really good news on our company releases, so they now see us like maybe a year ago when I was first pitching this stuff they might have s might have saw it as more of a okay this guy's there's an opportunity here he's just jumping on it and but we don't know like how legit they are I'm just guessing that might be what they're thinking but but now there's been a lot more substantial news on us so they're like okay these guys are actually legitimate have a bunch of installations that are working and making money that we can reference right so I basically just to go a little further like we'll build and sell data centers we have clients that bought [00:25:18] Them and they're operating themselves we will we will take on third parties operate so let's say well like we'll sell data center to a third party and operate on their behalf our service is to find maintain the data center make sure it's just like it's basically hosting but I'm hosting the entire data center and miners and a gen set so we do that and we also but our primary objective is to sell these things to oil companies and you know we'll operate them if they want us to or if they if they have their own ID guys. [00:25:53] Like everything we design everything we design is meant to be ease of use like low barrier to entry to the producer in terms of operating this thing it's it's quite easy that's where my facilities and production experience come in like I build all this operator friendly functionality into everything so that they're not intimidated by it and their field guy who has no idea how to even run Windows can basically operate the thing successfully, thus maybe a little bit of assistance from from either us or their IT people, whoever they want to actually manage the ASICs. [00:26:30] But otherwise, like the facility side of it, like what's going on in the power distribution, what's going on with the engine and the genset, they're quite comfortable with that, right? So yeah, so in the product, inside the product itself, you have the miners separated from the like the engines that are accepting the gas and producing the electricity. [00:26:51] So if there's maintenance need to be done, like do you just open one side to kind of work on the engine side and open the other side to work on the computer computing side, mining side? Yeah, yeah, pretty much. Like we have two products out there now. So the one that you're furring to is is the ohm combo unit. [00:27:11] So that's the unit with the like combination gen set and data center. Okay. So yes, you're basically right, like in the in one side of it, you have a gen set, it's open to anyone to walk in and you know it's mainly for the opera to walk in and check and stuff. And then on the other side as the data center which locked off, you can't really get in there without access. [00:27:31] So depending on who owns the data center, if it's our data center, we don't give that access away. If it's their data center, then they get the key. But otherwise, some of these mines that we got out there, some of these data centers like I haven't been there, like no one from upstream's been there in like months, like probably four months for the most the longest one I since I visited. [00:27:56] Because I can do everything remotely, like even ASIC restarts like hard circuit restarts we can do remotely. Oh nice. And they're automate. Yeah, I mean I build in it depends on what the operator needs. Like if the operator if I has a really reliable fuel source and there's no chance the engine getting knocked down on low fuel or overloaded because for example it's it's running another prime mover like it's running a hydraulic pump or something that's running the well site then it's automated so that you know it never knocks down that engine and it's it'll drop the mining load it's watching [00:28:34] The engine so basically if the engine starts sagging due to an overload situation or a lack of fuel it'll drop the mining load to free up power. So it's yeah like I can we basically build it to accommodate what they need but if they have a lot if it's like a gas well and you're never gonna have fluctuating volumes I mean the difference here I'm just saying like a gas well is pure gas the oil well could be spitting gas like it might not be consistent. [00:29:00] For the for the gas well you don't need the entire control system if you don't want it but it's nice to have because it enables us to never have to go outside. So I can pretty much scale up to many many data centers with minimal personnel kind of thing. Awesome. So you operate them remotely I guess you have some kind of cell connection cell cell modem attach to the units and then you like the mining let's say I do usually just r attach these miners to a pool. [00:29:30] Yeah we just do pool mining. Can you explain how pool mining works? Effectively there's a there's a central server like basically all the okay I mean pools came to be pretty early in Bitcoin. It might have been 2011 I think slush slush pool might be the first one. But well they developed the Stratum protocol so that you know instead of everyone solo mining on full nodes, you could have someone host a full mining node as a server and basically Divi out work to miners who who are not mining on their own full nodes. [00:30:05] So basically that's what we're doing. Like we're I have clients that are on slush, I have a f there's a few different pools we're on depending on client, but we're sending basically our work to the to the central server. They're doing all the you know transaction ordering full node software and that kind of thing. [00:30:23] And but it it's nice for us because especially when you're in these remote sites, you want to be well connected with low latency, there's a bit more latency in a cell network in it, I don't know, hybrid network. So latency and then bandwidth, like we don't want to use very much bandwidth just because it's cell cellular billing, right? [00:30:42] Like we want to keep it keep it low. So there's like a lot of reasons why we would continue to do a pool mining, even if like in these in these remote locations rather than you know solo mining or something. Right. So then you get a payout relative to your portion of work done in the pool. [00:31:02] So whatever the pool collects, then it just divvies everything up among all the pool participants. Yeah, you know, the pool you get a slice of the pie. So I mean if you're doing 10% of the work, you have 10% of the hash power on the pool, then you'll get 10% of pie minus whatever the pool fee happens to be. [00:31:20] So I mean the bigger the pool, the more often you find blocks, and then you obviously you obviously get paid when you find a block. So it depends on your sort of time preference. Like if you're okay with only getting paid once a month, well, there's small pools with lower fees that you could go to. I mean, I would always recommend that for small miners, but bigger pools like slush pool is nice for people that I mean higher fees, but then it's it's still a really nice pool of mine. [00:31:50] You get more consistent payouts because the pool is larger. They they're discovering blocks more consistently. Yeah many blocks a day and you're gonna you're gonna get paid off more frequently if you want. I mean it but it depends on your level of slush pool for example they're a tr they're effectively a trusted third party holding your your Bitcoin right so you want to like you want to not leave too much coin on on that at any given time. [00:32:14] Just like payout just like it's an exchange. Yeah number one rule man don't don't leave your Bitcoin with someone else. That's right. Not your keys, not your coins. So then you would collect like let's say if you're actually if you have a service contract with a customer you would then basically you would sell that Bitcoin on an exchange and then send fiat to them as per your arrangements, you know, minus your fees. [00:32:45] Oh if I like if I am on a produced well site would I Yeah. Okay well so if I am okay so like let's say that the newest product I got that I we were talking before we went live so I that was bought and is paid for and is owned by an oil company I facilitate their their mining. [00:33:08] I just do that for a very small fee just to because they have no experience. Right. But there's no there's no they own all the Bitcoin. It's in their custody. Okay. And that's one thing. You know, we don't do we do not do custody. So it's in their custody. If they want, I usually you know I give out free advice. [00:33:26] I mean I give that out anyway on whether or not you're my client. So if they want you know assistance in liquidating that you know I can help facilitate it for them. But usually I you know I express to them like you know if you're getting into this you should dedicate some resources to figuring out a plan, like a strategy on on what you how you want to you know run this side of your business, right? [00:33:51] So so realistically like I don't I don't really have any scenarios where I do any selling of coin or liquidating on behalf of a client. Yeah right and I don't want to so let them deal with their own coin. So you just basically set them up with their own like pool accounts and they you never have to worry about touching their Bitcoin they have it sent directly to them. [00:34:17] Yeah exactly like I don't I don't want to see I don't want to understand where they're even holding a wallet. I mean you know I'm here to help them but I stay away from that because it it's it's a it's a risky business because if they ever got hacked and I don't know I was somehow involved in setting up their wallet well they're gonna wonder and I don't want people to wonder so I don't even I get I stay far far away from that. [00:34:41] But what I what I will do is you know I can we have software I'll I can log in and VPN into their network and assist with finding optimization all the all the networking and configuration side of stuff which is at the end of the day we're talking like not very difficult. Any miner listening right now knows what I'm talking about. [00:35:01] It's not it's not rocket science. So I'll facilitate that for them if they want me to. I mean, if it's their asset, if it's my asset, of course I do it, but if it's their asset, it's if they want us to, we'll do it. We usually do also provide like network data piece, like seller fees as part of the ongoing service. [00:35:19] So besides mining, like as you were getting into Bitcoin, you went down the rabbit hole, you're learning about it. What surprised you or what did Bitcoin teach you, I guess, as you were learning about it, besides you know, obviously the mining int intrigued you, but any other aspects of Bitcoin that you that you learned or discovered that surprised you? [00:35:40] Oh man, that's a good question. I would say I learned that Bitcoin is one of the few truths in a world of fake like stuff. I sometimes joke like you know, we live in a world of fake news, like fake people, fake food. You know, like it's so I it's Bitcoin's taught me a hell of a lot. [00:36:02] Like honestly, you know, I think you I don't know where you found me, maybe you found me on Twitter. Yeah. It's not that Bitcoin has taught me a lot, it's the people that are attracted to Bitcoin that taught me a lot. There's all kinds of people that have just completely changed my view on the world, like or how I understand the world. [00:36:21] Like, I mean couple of them like safety, of course, with his economic I theory ideas, these Austrian ideas that everyone seems to love. Eric Voskill has really challenged what I understand and I've learned a lot from his writings. And then like I could name a thousand people, like on in the right in the Bitcoin Twitter sphere, but I would say that, you know, Bitcoin Bitcoin really is just it's it's I guess it's a it's about the people and I think it's the people that the economy of people that use it it seems to reward I've said it before, like I think Bitcoin it [00:37:00] Seems to reward honesty, like it and that's sort of fundamental to mining, like dishonest miners lose money, right? And I think there's some kind of like link there where even people that fUD against Bitcoin, they lose the reputation, right? Like if you say stuff about Bitcoin, okay, it's not you know, you're attacking it all the time, it's not scalable, like you're you're shitting on it, you're you're forking it. [00:37:26] Well, you know, like if your ideas don't end up being right, you end up your reputation gets trashed and you see that a lot, like there's a lot of people who fudded against Bitcoin for so long and they just continuously just trash the reputation and I think like we're coming out of a era where reputation was meaningless. [00:37:48] Whatever happened, say with my company, whatever happened I do, if I hold strong reputation and make a good thing for myself, like that'll pay off in the future 'cause I just think I think more than ever reputation is important. And I'll just give you an an anecdote and in terms of like the in the mining business, and a lot of the a lot of guys listening probably know this, scamming's happening at all the time. [00:38:13] You buy a batch of ASICs, they never show up, right? Like they never actually got manufactured. That's happened a lot in the past. Like buy a bunch of used ASIC, they don't work. You know, you trust someone, send them Bitcoin, they steal your money. So there's it's such a crazy wild west of a space, especially this mining space. [00:38:35] The whole Bitcoin space in general, but mining in particular. Building a reputation is a huge deal. People will like I'm slowly growing a network of people that I trust and hopefully trust me so that we can trade amongst each other and have you know I can help and a third party who I don't really know well they know they can trust me, so I at least can be an anchor in terms of even if it's something like facilitating getting them a few ASICs like that kind of thing. [00:39:08] Yeah, and the mining industry is just insanely competitive. It's like it's almost perfectly competitive. Just because there's you know, there's right, there's one there are two basic inputs, you know, you have your equipment and then electricity. And yeah, it's plug a computer in the wall and you're done. [00:39:28] Yeah. Like it's the easiest industry in the world to get into, like you know. Right, but it's all it's it's also really difficult to actually be profitable, right? Yeah, I actually was just talking I was just yeah, so like it's super easy to get into. Anyone can do it. I mean you do have to be willing to make the investment like A600 free, but anyone can do it. [00:39:52] It's there's no I mean there's practically no barrier to entry. You just have to spend a few minutes learning how to configure the miner once you plug it in and understand a little bit about your electrical distribution system to make sure you don't burn your house down, right? Right. So but then but that's how easy it is to get into it. Now of course it's very difficult to make a profit. [00:40:12] Yeah, that's and that's why, you know, it's for that reason that it seems like there's a lot of people that do get into it because it is so easy and it seems like such an easy win. And when you know, when you look at the you know, if you have a hundred grand, right, and you want to get you know mining in it in this way like not really a big way but a medium way you can you can spend all that money on it on ASICs and you might make a really great return on investment in two years like in terms of you might have you might by the time you calculate your coins value in two years you might have three hundred grand you might have tripled your money [00:40:51] But you might have still lost actually because you could have just used that hundred grand to buy Bitcoin. And so that's what a lot of I feel like a lot of new miners especially the smaller guys they make that mistake they think that six cents per kilowatt hour is a good price like for power and then they find then they find a way there's more fees on top of that or even if they have six cents like you're not gonna last in a bear market at that power cost. [00:41:17] So it might have been a good price in the past but with ASIC you know getting so commoditized and easier and easier to get the power needs to be lower and lower. So yeah you're right in that it's it's it's competitive and hard to do successfully. Insanely competitive so if you're a miner what do you need to think about obviously the like the price of electricity is critical but you also have to think about the efficiency of your miners right and the cost of the equipment and that's also changing. [00:41:49] So what are what are some of the calculations that you have to do on a regular basis to be a profitable miner. Well you know I'm off grid miner I don't mind on the grid, but I think like for the guys that are on a grid, and this might apply to some like residential miners who might even have to be power just commercial scale. [00:42:10] You know, there's peak hours, like of course they have to consider is is the electricity change and costs like over the time of the day or at the days of the week. They have to be take that into account because sometimes you might have to shut down periodically. Okay. So you so you avoid like the super high cost power time the peak hours. [00:42:30] I mean for me I don't I don't I mean once I make an investment in a in a rig, like get a get a get a mine up and running it's really just about uptime. Like I just gotta get this keep this thing up as long as I can. Otherwise it's not making any money of course so up time and then of course I have other things to consider like gotta make sure my gin sets are maintained. [00:42:56] But you know there's not it's really not not a ton to it. You just it's about the upfront. You have before you make the investment you really have to do your homework and I mean just a good rule of thumb is if you don't have I wouldn't even think about it if I didn't have four cents or less power cost. [00:43:15] Okay. Because part of the problem is that the you can get good deals on used equipment. The older stuff like S9s you can get really good deals on it. And you'll make that's a good avenue to be getting into mining is to buy the used stuff. But that's only if you have super cheap power that you can afford to run it. [00:43:36] When it comes to new stuff they price it so high and especially nowadays with so much more demand and people snatching up ASICs just to not even mine with them just to resell it. I mean you have to buy from the manufacturer on new equipment pretty much. Otherwise you're paying an even higher jacked up price. [00:43:56] But even when you pay for the manufacturer, they price it in such a way that the payout is quite a while. Like you don't make the Bitcoin back you paid for or usually like 280 plus days. So you gotta be and then you have failures like when you buy ASICs, they're not all gonna work perfectly. [00:44:14] I don't know if it's the same because I haven't bought any new stuff recently, but like bidding, it was i if you if you had five percent or less like board failures made a new order, that was good. Like there's guys, you know, getting fifteen, twenty percent board failure. Wow. So you gotta account for all this stuff when your s your economics and a lot of people say this, and I and I agree, if you don't have some kind of real competitive advantage, then you shouldn't be getting into it. [00:44:41] You should just buy Bitcoin. That's really all you gotta do. And you'll you'll have the Bitcoin. And at the end at the end of the day, all we're all we're all trying to do is stack SATS, like we're trying to get more coin. You got you gotta figure out what's the how are you gonna maximize your sats? And your your fiat money's gonna run out once you clean it. [00:45:01] Cleaning being, you know, get rid of that crap. Get your coin. I don't mean like laundry it, I just mean get rid of that that garbage. But yeah. Once once you run out of fiat, now you have a stack of sats, and it's incredibly difficult to use your Satoshis to buy ASICs, which are depreciating asset at more Satoshis. [00:45:21] Like you have to have a huge advantage, like close to free power or close to a manufacturer's really, really good price. Yeah, so I mean w how much of a profit can like you know a miner is doing a good job, how much profit in sats can or Bitcoin can someone expect to make? [00:45:42] I mean, you have to sell most of that off to pay for electricity and equipment, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean the equipment, yeah, you definitely have to s sell a fair amount of it. And then the amount you have to sell, of course, is a function of operating cost. I don't really have a good answer to that. Like you know, I wouldn't be excuse me, I wouldn't be mining myself, even with free power if I wasn't providing service for oil companies. [00:46:10] Like if if I w if I didn't think that I could get this business to the point where they're buying my units and we actually have a you know a growing business with sort solving a problem in the oil industry, I wouldn't be doing it because I would be probably better off like for me to for me just to mine myself on oil wells, I would be better off taking the capital. [00:46:33] We're talking about more capital than a typical Bitcoin mine. I got a Genset I gotta pay for. I have a smaller economy of scale, right? I'm not building a 10 megawatt data center, I'm building a well, my biggest one now is that's coming out later in the year will be a one megawatt, but still I'm not getting the economies of scale of a large scale operation. [00:46:54] So I would probably if I didn't think that I'm solving a problem for people and they're gonna want my service and payment for the service, I wouldn't be doing this business and I would probably just be buying Bitcoin. Right, yeah. So I mean you're you're motivated because you want to help the industry progress and both the oil and gas industry and the bitcoin industry. [00:47:14] Yeah, but and the but the theme of that is just you know, if you're not i if you're if you really have to have a monstrous advantage to get into this mining thing. The manufacturers have that advantage and they don't give it to you because they price it in such a way that effectively I have close to free free power to make a run of it like in the in a three, maybe four cents is good enough. [00:47:37] I don't know what the threshold is. I don't really need to worry about that, but it's around that three four cents. I would do it unless I was down there. Yeah, so I mean speaking of the manufacturers, what's this like the latest on Bitmain? I haven't really been keeping up much with them, and I you know I assume you probably followed their actions and like you know, whatever that followed the company pretty closely over the years. [00:48:04] Could you give us like a you know kind of a summary of the what happened with Bitmain, the kind of saga of bit main over the past few years? I'm not I'm not a bit coin or bit main hater, first of all. I don't hate them. I do consider them a bit of a bad actor. I don't and I'll and I mean I'll talk about some stuff, but I don't I'm not a I'm not a hater of Bitmain. [00:48:26] I buy Bitmain's equipment. I'm happy that Bitmain exists because it's helped my business. But they they're a bit of a bad actor. Like I mean so I mean the I guess the first fun thing about Bitmain is is there's a lot of things there's a lot of things, but the first fun thing is like their whole backing of Bitcoin Cash and this fork of Bitcoin. [00:48:51] And you know, I don't actually I personally have never really cared or faulted them for that. I always just thought it was a really bad business decision. Yeah. For a few reasons though. Like it's one thing to s to start accumulating all this fork coin that you know you're you're just you know, they're they're trying to pump to make it make it something substantial to make it a like I don't know, a thing. [00:49:15] But besides I'm not really gonna get into what I think of B cash right now, but the but Bitmain like so they only would accept like BCH for payment. I mean as a guy mining Bitcoin, like that you're you're doing a disservice to your customer, right? They're building Bitcoin ASICs and they won't accept my the Bitcoin, right? [00:49:35] Like if I wanted to pay them. So that was a that was a huge pain in the butt and I thought a disservice to their customer base doing that. So that was one screw up. Obviously the big screw up with that whole saga is the fact that they did accept so much BCH and they did support it so much that they're left with a monster bag and if if Bitcoin Cash doesn't if it doesn't outperform Bitcoin, then they've suffered a massive opportunity cost, right? [00:50:04] 'Cause they could have just got Bitcoin. So that that's one thing. Then they've been bad actors. Well it must be the l the biggest shitcoin bag of all time. Oh no doubt. It is, yeah, it is. And I mean like I'm not I d I don't see the use case for for Bitcoin Cash, but that's aside from that, like Bitcoin Bitmain, they've done some other things, like they've had backdoors in their ASICs, that was sort of revealed their ant lead a year and a half ago or whatever, and that was a bit of a big deal. [00:50:32] That's a huge security issue and like network security. I mean these are things that like yeah you know, this is what I'm talking about earlier, like being dishonest and being like they've trashed the reputation and of course I think it's hurt them now because they were trying to raise some money. Yeah, they were trying to IPO, right? [00:50:52] Yeah, and I'm just like you and everyone else, I have no inside information, but you know, there's that guy yeah leaking information about what was going on and if that's all true and they're acting pretty shadily and that's like a horrible I just think BitMe's reputation is forever tarnished and them as a company will forever have to pay that debt even you know assuming they they survive. [00:51:14] So and aside from that like they're not very open with the mining community on on their firmware and giving access to the firmware like they're they're violating copyright licenses I think I don't know it in that much depth but I have talked to some core developers talked about it how they're using firmware that has open like open source licensing or whatever that's called where you know they're they're not supposed to be able to it's gotta be open source right so it's not right it's like yeah so like if they use open source software then they need to open source the products [00:51:53] Right of that of whatever they change or something. Yeah part of that open source licensing MIT license. Yeah and they're not doing that and I mean they've just been you know they've done a lot of things like even like okay they just came out with firmware for example that allows you to boost your hash rate and like basically you know overclock and underclock your your ASICs. [00:52:14] Okay. And we all know we all know that they could have done that from the very start like given that service to their customer. But they didn't do it. And it we all know that they had ASIC boost capability like covert built into their stuff as well as the ability to do over ASIC boost and they don't do anything for their customers. [00:52:35] So that's all I'll say about Bitmain. I think they're s a bit of a bad actor, although I don't hate them and I supply the product. Right on. Well what's the state of the ASIC industry aside from Bitmain. Has their kind of I guess reputation hit opened up opportunity for other producers. [00:52:56] Yeah, I think in the ASIC industry is very healthy right now. At least compared I mean I guess it's getting better and better and healthier. And I expect the quality and reliability of the product will continue to improve. But especially when you think about what's happened historically. But I mean like Bitmain was the first company to really mass produce a really great ASIC. [00:53:19] And then and because of that like the S9 mainly and the S7 with primarily the S9, like they've had a huge market share. But I understand like a lot of really great people at Bitmain that got them there left the company and started other companies. So I know there's like there's eBang out there which doesn't seem to service North America very well but they they make pretty good ASICs. [00:53:40] Watts minor of course is great. They have great product as far as I know I haven't heard a anything bad about WattsMiner yet in terms of you know even quality obviously very important but customer service I haven't heard anything bad about them. So and then there's like Avalon I haven't used their stuff but I haven't heard much bad about them a little but mostly good. [00:54:06] So I mean there's there's multiple manufacturers now and there's rumors that I mean Samsung makes chips for a lot of these guys but I heard a rumor that they're possibly coming out with an ASIC if they're a brand or not. But so it's getting more competitive and there's and it's always been getting more competitive. [00:54:24] There was there's been a misunderstanding, I think, by some people that mining is getting more and more centralized. But I think all the signs are showing that it's not. It's getting more decentralized and seeing the manufacturing get more competitive. It's gonna be great. And I think that's just the what it's just natural. [00:54:43] You're gonna see like like real great engineers split off from the company and start their own company. Right. It's sort of what I was doing with Husky. I was trying to develop stuff and I wasn't able to do it the way I they like they weren't allowing me to do what I wanted, so I just left. I mean that's why you're gonna see with these ASIC guys. It's great. [00:55:02] Awesome. That makes good sense. And it's it's good to hear that you think that we're sort of progress or moving toward a more decentralized mining system. Have you looked much into Matt Carello's better hash proposal? I haven't looked a ton into it. I like the concept, like I think it's a net benefit for sure. [00:55:22] Yeah. It makes sense to you. Yeah, I wouldn't even be able to explain it in detail. Like if you asked me to explain it to everybody, I wouldn't be able to explain it to detail. I know that it's it's more about taking the transaction ordering away from the pool operator and giving it to the successful miner, finds a block, which is great. [00:55:41] I think that's a good thing. But the pool operator of course still needs to divvy out shares and work. And so it's splitting out some of the responsibility from the pool operator to the to the miner, which I think is really good. I actually was just reading this morning, so at that mining disrupt conference. [00:55:59] I wish I wish I was there and sort of got the FOMO over that, but I have only been to one mining conference, but that was one I definitely wanted to be at. The or the guys at Slash Pool, a bunch of great guys over there, they released some information about and I was just reading it this morning, it's talking about they were inspired by Better Hash and they're doing something very, very similar. [00:56:27] But they actually have a bunch of other improvements like the actual stratum protocol. They they call it version two. And I think maybe those are the guys actually developed Stratum in the first place, but anyway, it doesn't matter. So that some of you listeners can go check out on when we read more about it and seeing if it's good to implement my operation. [00:56:47] I think it might be because they're talking about lower bandwidth consumption and that kind of thing, which is important for you know, cell networks. Awesome. All right, this has been really fun to talk about and just catch up on on what's going on in the mining scene. It's something that I don't follow as closely, because I'm mostly mostly focused on you know, code stuff, tech stuff and then and then you know, the economics side of Bitcoin. [00:57:12] And so I have a lot more to learn on the mining side and it's you know, I need to dive dive more into it. I would love to try it out, like try you know, actually get an ASIC and try it out, but I've been really intimidated by the thought of that. And like you said, you know, it's yeah, it's super competitive and unless you have like a major advantage, it's not really worth the time. [00:57:33] I think just from an educational perspective, just the experience would be maybe worthwhile since I'm you know, interested in just like learning about Bitcoin, just doing it is the way the best way to learn, I think. If I just wanted to do it sort of not looking to make a profit, just to kind of help the network and help me learn about how mining works, what should I like what what there are the resources I can look at that you would recommend? [00:57:57] You know for someone that way, yeah. Well yeah, I well first of all, definitely. I mean it's I think it is a great thing to go. I got should go get a used ASIC and just for fun and look to learn. Even if it's in your garage and you have high power costs just for a bit of fun. [00:58:19] But if you're gonna do it that way, I would probably recommend you go get a stick miner. Because if it's really an educational thing, a stick miner will do you just fine, like you learn the same stuff. That doesn't sound as exciting because you know we're talking about a USB stick mine miner. But they're they're sort of cool actually. [00:58:37] There's these geco science one. These guys just so I guess they're a good resource to go, and this is where you'd find these Dick Miners, is on like just the Bitcoin Talk forum. That place is still pretty active and there's there's a lot of great community there that will help you. And I mean there's already so much on the forum of people learning in the past, so you probably don't even need to ask any questions, just go do some research there. [00:59:03] But a good way to start is and to get into it. I wouldn't even just that's what I did. I the first thing I bought, actually no, the first thing I bought was an S9 in 2016 and I put it in my garage. [00:59:19] I gotta at least get get your toes wet before you go large scale, right? So yeah, do that, like go get an S9, like use S9 option. If you want to actually mine and make honey to money, you'll probably still actually make a profit in your garage. You just won't make too much if you just spend on Bitcoin. [00:59:39] Right. Still. It's not the end of the world. Yeah. Right. Cost of education. [00:59:52] I'd never seen these USB sticks before or heard of them. I'm looking at them right now. I'm looking at the Gecko Science. The Gecko Science ones are pretty cool. Like you can overclock them. People. It's a cool little community. I mean, it's it's we're talking hobby, right? Like, but they these guys like will some guys have like, you know, 50 and they'll have like a few just fans just blowing over them to keep them cool. [01:00:18] Umbs and stuff. But I think it's cool. Like it's not something you would do. I bought one literally just to have one. And I, you know, just earn CG and see what how it worked is to have it collector's item. That that kind of thing. Right. [01:00:36] You can get other ones that are oh sorry. Yeah. You can get some other ones that are really cheap, like sort of cheap looking, like they're just sort of lame with those gecko signs. Yeah, they do look pretty rad. They got this kind of like, you know, the open circuit board and the heat sink on there and stuff. Yeah, this looks like a good good solution for someone who just w wants to like get the experience of Bitcoin mining and attach to a pool and just see how it all works. [01:01:06] Pretty cool. Right now, unfortunately, but I will I will put some of these links in the show notes for listeners who might be interested in doing the same. I'm all about the hobbyists. I got a bunch of nodes running at home now and Raspberry Pi setups and got a Casa node and a Nautil and just want to test all that hardware out. [01:01:26] So this is a great next rabbit hole to dive down into. I'm excited. Very cool. Yeah, I think this is a good place to wrap things up. How can people follow you, I guess, on Twitter and do you have a website for upstream? Yeah, definitely follow me on Twitter. [01:01:45] You know, you'll suffer a major opportunity cost if you don't. So at S G Barber B-A-R-B-O-U-R. And then this terms of website, upstream data.c. Alright, man. Really appreciate your time, Steve. Keep up the great work up there in Canada and best of luck to your business. [01:02:06] Yeah, thanks, Brady. Thanks for having me. [01:02:15] What did you all think of that discussion? What's your take on the state of the Bitcoin mining industry? Are you interested in learning more about it? I know I am. Let Steve and I know your thoughts and questions on Twitter. Steve is at SG Barber at S G B A R B O U R. And I am at CitizenBitcoin. [01:02:34] If you appreciate the podcast, you can give back. Help me bootstrap this thing by sharing the episode with your friends and family and on Bitcoin Twitter or leaving a rating and review on Apple Podcasts. Appreciate all your support so much. That's it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.