Jeff Booth: The Money of Tomorrow Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-05-28 [00:00:17] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners from all around the world. Thanks for joining me again for another day here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Today we sit down with Jeff Booth, tech entrepreneur, board member, and author of the new book, The Price of Tomorrow. [00:00:42] First, as always, we'll check in with Swan Bitcoin. You should get your auto-stacking on with Swan if you're here in the United States. It's super simple. One auto fund USD to your account. Two, auto-stack BTC. Three, auto withdraw BTC. It's that simple. [00:01:01] Set it and forget it. You can get going now. Use my referral link, SwanBitcoin.com slash Brady to get $10 dropped into your account at SwanBitcoin.com slash Brady. You'll get those sweet bonus sats 30 days after your first Bitcoin purchase is executed. And speaking of our referral program, we want you to join SwanFor.com slash enlist. [00:01:30] It's pretty rad with your avatar up at the top. So when your referrals come to Swan Bitcoin, they'll be greeted by your face and a quote from you that talks about why you love Bitcoin or why you recommend Swan. [00:01:44] And of course your referrals will get $10 in Bitcoin. [00:01:48] And you will be earning 0.25%, a quarter point for that referral for up to three years. Alright, so you can be earning on your referrals for up to three years as you go along. This is just incoming revenue. So get out there, start shilling bitcoin, start shilling Swan. [00:02:07] This is an amazing referral program. All right, get on it. Swan Bitcoin.com slash enlist. All right, finally, you guys probably know that I've started a podcast for Swan called Swan Signal. We do Swan Signal live every week. We get a couple of Bitcoiners, we pair up some awesome Bitcoiners, create some great pairs for awesome, unique discussions. [00:02:27] It's I think a very unique bit of content in the space. Really proud to be able to bring it to y'all front through Swan. This week we talked to Adam Back and Preston Pysh, an awesome combo, one two punch. You can check that out on YouTube, Twitter, Twitch, Facebook. [00:02:45] We're broadcasting live there, those videos will be archived there, but also the audio is always goes to under the podcast feed, which you'll find at Swan Signal Podcast.com. So add that into your Bitcoin rotation. I think it's a pretty unique podcast in the space, and I think you'll find a lot of value there. And of course, thanks as always to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. [00:03:05] Subscribe to the feed, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network feed. There's some other great Bitcoin only podcasts on there, like Anita Posh's Bitcoin and Co. The former crypto economy podcast now called Bitcoin Audible with Guy Swann and Peter McCormack's What Bitcoin Did podcast is also on that feed. So lots of good Bitcoin only content in one place. [00:03:23] All right, let's get on with the show. Today we sit down with Jeff Booth. He's the author of the new book, The Price of Tomorrow. Jeff is a longtime tech entrepreneur. [00:03:43] He led Build Direct, a technology company that aimed to simplify the building industry for nearly two decades. And he invests in and sits on the boards of many tech companies. So needless to say, Jeff has his finger on the pulse of the global tech industry. In this discussion, we dive into the ideas he's fleshed out in The Price of Tomorrow, deflationary technology in the time of inflationary monetary policy, the deep societal problems caused by inflationary money, how deflationary technology could combine with deflationary money, that is Bitcoin to really shape a brighter future. [00:04:19] So we soberly examine our current state of affairs, but we also consider a brighter future and the path to get there. Really, really enjoyed this one. Hope you all do as well. [00:04:38] All right, Jeff, thanks so much for taking the time to join me today. Finished your book last night and really enjoyed it. Looking forward to this discussion. Awesome. Thanks. Absolutely. So, all right. We have grown up, or most of us have grown up at this point with this kind of Keynesian fiat monetary policy since 1971 and even a little before that. [00:05:04] I mean, it was kind of formalized in 1971. That we, you know, went off a gold standard. So this is just the way things are now, and I've kind of, you know, been calling this on my podcast and some writing default Keynesianism. You know, it's just we don't know anything different. Don't really challenge it. This is just the way money is now. So the idea of like a deflationary asset-based money is you know, very contrarian these days. [00:05:29] So what kind of feedback are you seeing as being sort of a business leader, you know, advocating or espousing these ideas. I would say it's it's struck a chord. It struck a chord with just about anybody who would read the book and has an open mind and is willing to explore first principles. [00:05:51] For those people, I would say it's or or people that are would have will be willing to explore first principles even if they hadn't read the book. But for those people when they understand what's happening, they they want to look deeper and they they it's it's more okay, how do we make the transition? [00:06:11] And then there's then there's people who will not question the not question the validity of what I've said, not question the evidence of what I point to, but will say, well, what better choice do we have? And then let's just keep going on. [00:06:29] And so it it's interesting to watch the, it's really interesting to watch the what's what's happening as a result of the book. But that's that's actually why I wrote it, right? I wrote it because because I was frustrated that nothing was happening. Like you could see I could clearly see this, and nobody and nobody was talking about it and everything else. [00:06:52] So so it's done that. It's it it's really and I don't know for your listeners who haven't read the book, it's probably worth referencing what it is about and effectively effectively technological progress or it is creates efficiency, and that efficiency is deflationary in nature and it's all around us and it's moving into everything at blinding speed your phone your phone is a really good example everything on it is free or almost free and so it technology creates abundance and that abundance [00:07:31] Is hard to charge for it okay it's cheaper and cheaper every year and more better for you every year and our monetary policy is the opposite it's created inflation so those two giant forces are competing against each other and the competition is driving wealth into very few hands and most people are not getting the benefits of technology are not getting broadly distributed because of the monetary policy is trying to drive inflation against a deflationary policy a deflationary trend that's bigger than anything that governments can do. [00:08:04] Yeah it's so I mean there's a lot there and I think that that answer will sort of guide us through the rest of this discussion. Let's dive in first to the idea of exponential growth because I find it absolutely fascinating. And it it's it's you know the nature of exponential growth is that it gets faster and faster it compounds over time. [00:08:27] And it feels like now we're sort of at we're at this time where it's happening so fast that you know whereas before you know maybe throughout the last century it was sort of happening in the scale of like a single human lifetime then maybe like you know a couple of gener you know generational kind of change, right? [00:08:45] But now we're seeing it every five, ten years. Things are extremely different. The way we live our lives is extremely different. The tools we have access to extremely different it's almost like, you know, if you look at the exponential curve like an X squared graph, we're on sort of the elbow of the asymptote now. So you know, what what are we going to see in the next you know five, 10, 15, 20 years? [00:09:04] I mean, life is going to be dra drastically different, I think. Well, I've done this some on some other podcasts and I've done this on stages all over the world. So this and so I'll do it here here too, but I but I think it's really important to understand human beings are really bad at saying exponential patterns. [00:09:22] We're it we're just not pro we're not designed to see we never grew up with exponential patterns. We don't see them. And so a paper folding exercise is a really good ex example. So if I folded that paper, one that's one fold, two folds, three folds, four folds. [00:09:42] You can see how thick it is at four folds. And if I ask people how thick that is on 50 folds, most people answer at about two inches, right? Some people answer at seven inches. I know it's good, but but i if you don't know the answer, that's when I say most people, I'm saying 90% of people answer there. [00:10:03] And it's not because they're stupid. It's because 50% or 20% of people answered there and a lot of people got the answer, then it it's because human beings are always tricked by exponentials. We can't fathom how how how fast it's good it's moving. So in 50 folds that piece of paper would reach the sun if you could fold it 50 times, you can only fold it seven. [00:10:26] Yeah. But it would re it would reach the sun. And that has enormous. That was that was definitely jaw-dropping to me when I read that in your book. I was just like, ah, that's yeah, you're right. And then what you what do you do? You go Google it to check if it's right and everything else. And because it's so far out of touch of what we believe is possible is possible that it's it's just so hard to comprehend. [00:10:49] And we have technology moving at that rate. And by the way, that that's exactly why we underestimate technology's impact in the for in the beginning. Because in the beginning folds, it only looks like this. Right. And so you'll see a new technology in 3D printers is probably a good example of a new technology that is people have locked in their brains of what 3D printers were five years ago. [00:11:14] Yeah. And you print a little it takes a day to print a little plastic piece and think and people dismiss it as irrelevant versus the hype and the promise, and it goes through a hype cycle. On the other side of that hype cycle, it keeps on doubling. And so what if people saw where that technology was today, that it would blow their minds, and where it will be tomorrow, it'll blow their minds. [00:11:38] So that's the that is the base layer today. That that technology doubling is the base layer of everything else. So that digital nature is is moving into every industry. So you would expect the same power that you have in your phone versus you had 20 years in your phone, you'd expect that to get that everywhere, that abundance and what will change everywhere. [00:12:05] We will, but but the our monetary policy is not designed for it. So you think then, like I guess getting back to the question, I mean, that's a great basis for this question, and I appreciate you laying that out. So you know, I guess in terms of Moore's law, we're what 30, 40 folds in, I guess, from back in the 50s. [00:12:31] 33 through 33 folds. And if you just for reference, that would take 33 folds would be from Boston to Detroit. Right. Okay. 34 folds doubles that. And so we're we're now in the thick steps to the to the sun, right? Right. And so but all the technology you're using today and all the things that you are in your phone today, you're looking backwards at the last doubles. [00:12:55] Yep. And so when we see self-driving cars come out and everything else, or or or or just recently, Elon said they're gonna go two-way charging onto the onto the grid and everything else from the electric car, so you could charge both ways in peak power power. The things that are coming forward are so mind boggling boggling. [00:13:17] It's just hard to comprehend. And so that's why I use that example in the book, because if you if you understand that example and you can start to think like that, you can get in front of some of the trends that are that are happening and you can you can bet on where things are going easier. Yeah. [00:13:35] So I mean, just the change then that we can expect over the next five, 10, 15 years is because we're changing so quickly now, so fast, like you said, the steps are massive that we're taking. Yeah, it's so we're in store for just more and more mind blowing decades and years to come. [00:13:54] Like it's it's moving it it's moving so fast, it's uncompr i it's hard to comprehend how fast things are moving. So do you think we've reached like escape velocity on the scale of a human lifetime? Like I mean, you know, what will we see as 50 years old? Yeah. So is so that's that's interesting. [00:14:12] You actually bring up a point I forget who I brought them to one of my conferences, but but one of the longevity experts who talks about specifically that that you actually don't have to escape velocity in human lifetime you only have to add years every year right it's actually not very far away from no I don't want to be 90 years old live then live forever right so I hope they do it faster but but there's a whole bunch of things coming that that we haven't been prepared for and or or even prepared to even question and those things that change our [00:14:50] Belief systems and everything else are really hard to accept even if they're true. Yeah. Yeah I mean our brains just like they're not equipped to handle you know or understand expon exponents or evolutionarily not equipped to change this fast right I mean yeah so you know it's already this conversation's already kind of blown my mind let's let's talk a bit about Bitcoin while we're talking about this you know like you said the kind of digital exponential growth is sort of the base layer for everything now all the technology that we're seeing happen now the amazing stuff the supercomputer in the palm [00:15:29] Of our hands you know all of the tools the thousands of tools that have been consolidated down into this little device bitcoin is built on top of that it's built on top of the internet which also you know at work effect and everything else network network effect money is a network effect itself. So how fast, I mean, if Bitcoin is going to be, let's just assume that it will succeed in becoming the new like global standard of money. [00:15:55] How fast could it possibly happen? So I think what's happening right now, it's actually getting more and more trusted all the time. And the on-ramps, and all that's happening is it used to be a little pet project for crypto cryptographers. More some some people got into it, some people got into it. [00:16:15] And actually, same forecast all the way through on how do we create trust in money, right? That's where it starts started that can't be manipulated. And so how fast that can happen. Well, there's a whole bunch of other events that need to happen to be able to speed speed that up. [00:16:37] But if you think about some of the events that are unfolding in real time right now, US with 80% of world trade denominated in US currency, means there's a whole bunch of countries right now that why the US currency is getting stronger is there's a whole bunch of other countries failing because then their businesses are failing and they're trying to get US currency to pay things. [00:16:56] And so that's supply demand equation. So even though the US is printing like crazy, the dollar is still getting stronger, right? It doesn't, but it's because the world trade is denominated in US dollars. And these countries, you're that pain is in countries because as the US dollar gets stronger, that debt explodes in real terms, right? [00:17:16] It gets more expensive to pay back, so there's a race for US currency right now. But you can imagine on the on the other side of this, there's a whole bunch of currencies and a whole bunch of countries that are gonna fail. Right. Right. And if you look backwards, Venezuela, what's happening right now, or sort of in the last couple of years, if you had Bitcoin in that in Venezuela, you could save your family, you could feed your family and everything else. [00:17:43] I suspect at 5 million, 10 million percent inflation rate in in Venezuela, that nobody is gonna give up their Bitcoin. Right. And again, once the when you create a new create a new currency, still people won't give up their Bitcoin. So you develop an on ramp of people that trust that more than another currency. [00:18:07] That's happening in Lebanon right now. It's happening all over the world. And so those on ramps are making making Bitcoin stronger and stronger. I can't predict exactly what time that that happens. There's obviously there's a scarcity rule in it, and they and but I do believe that ultimately governments are gonna be forced to peg to Bitcoin. [00:18:32] Yeah. And I mean the network effects of the dollar obviously are really strong too. So you know Bitcoin has to overcome those as well. But yeah, I think once dominoes start falling in terms of sovereign currencies shifting to Bitcoin, begging to Bitcoin, then it's just kind of a race at that point. And if you're looking at like S curve of adoption, you're sort of on that asymptote at that point. [00:18:52] Yeah, and I think we're still early in that, really early in that. But when you see Polter drones come in, and so it's just moving up, right? And now other hedge funds are gonna be forced to do that to just create the same beta and so they're not gonna be want to be left out. So you're gonna have a whole bunch more people in conversations like this that are bringing more people more people on onto it, and the currency is portable anyway. [00:19:19] So I have this conversation with family and friends about deflation and inflation, what money really is, what I've learned about you know from Bitcoin. And they often ask me, like, okay, I understand why you know the cost of technical goods, technology is going down because it gets better over the years and faster. [00:19:39] But you know, look at tech, you know, sectors, non-tech sectors like education, real estate, healthcare, we've seen massive inflation there. You know, why is that? Why is one deflationary and the other not? And it do you provide them with the sufficient answer or Well I yeah, I see just because you know they're they're human-based and humans don't scale, you know. [00:20:01] So that's not that that's not the reason. Okay. It's well, this is why I asked you. The reason is so everybody says real estate always goes up. In in to try to stop deflation, central banks have pulled forward demand. We've created 185 trillion dollars of new debt in the last 20 years. [00:20:21] 185 trillion to produce 46 trillion dollars of GDP growth. Right. So $4 of debt for every one dollar of growth. Okay. That's before COVID. Going forward, and as you know from the book, if it's exponentially deflationary, it has to be exponentially more debt to start to try to stop that. [00:20:42] Right? That's what's that's what's happening. So I want to pause you right there, real quick. So how do we create how have we created so much money when you know, like we look at numbers like from the Federal Reserve, they've printed six trillion dollars for this this COVID crisis. What are the other ways that money is printed in this way so that you know it's sort of hidden. [00:21:00] We hear numbers from the Federal Reserve, that's not the total though. Yeah, so what I what I'd say is let's start with what I was saying because debt itself isn't bad, right? So when we say printed, debt itself, if the debt could be paid back, then debt itself isn't bad. But if the debt could be paid back, then it has to slow growth in the future because taxes must go up. [00:21:26] Essentially, you're pulling forward demand. It's really easy. These systems aren't as hard as people would have you think they are, right? Think about it in a single person, you and I. If if you have if you borrow a million dollars and nobody knows you borrowed a million dollars, your internal economy, you could hire gardeners, build a new house, everything else, you look really rich. [00:21:53] And everybody's looking, wow, how does he have all that money? And then if if two years later you need to borrow two million dollars to pay back the interest on the and you can get away with it, you still look rich, right? Right. And I and I'm trying to save my money and spend thriftly and everything else, so I can buy things without debt, you look really rich. [00:22:13] At some point, you have to pay that back, and it and it and it revert it reverses. That's just how an economy looks, right? If you just blow that up overall, so if people pull forward demand, governments, individuals, corporations pull forward demand, and they and they can you can live way beyond your means. [00:22:34] And then in the future, you have to live, you have to pay that back. Now, so assuming you could pay back the 185 trillion dollars, right? Or now it's 250 trillion, 250 trillion for an 80 trillion dollar global economy, assuming that that could be paid back, then growth must slow in the future because you have to increase increase taxes to pay for the for the for the debt. [00:23:01] But inherently, that's not necessarily a bad thing. Growth you can if you spend debt to make a business better, you can make you can you can grow faster, it's not inherently a bad thing. But when you can't pay it back and you change the rules to pretend you can pay it back, right? [00:23:19] Or that's when it becomes you warp capitalism, right? So that's what's happening today. And so piling on you're not you're not you're not getting rid of any debt, you're piling on more debt to solve a debt problem in the first place, and you're creating asset bubbles everywhere. That applies straight to the other thing that we're we're talking about, to housing or to any of the asset prices or education and everything else. [00:23:46] If you have let's let's look at China as an example on housing. If everyone in China knows that they're going to devalue the currency, and by the way, they have to devalue again to protect jobs. So the currency is going to go down. Everyone in China says, I gotta get my money out of China and I gotta put it into an asset. [00:24:06] And that asset is US real estate or Canadian real estate and everything else. And so there's massive money chasing mass free money, essentially, chasing assets that are stores of value. And that's what's pushing up those, that's what's pushing up those prices. If if you didn't have student loans that could never be paid back for for education, you wouldn't have the education cost where it is. [00:24:31] So the question you have to look at the inverse of the question. If you didn't have 185 trillion dollars of debt creation in the last 20 years, what would real estate look like in price? Right. Right. Yeah. And then and then you would see that you'd see the trends been there all the way along everywhere. [00:24:51] It's in everything. You would actually have prices lower everywhere. Right. And then the next question is, can you keep doing that and for how long? Right. Right. So I mean basically. Yes, right. We've we've like remove the store of value component from the money. [00:25:10] So store value then is like sought in other places. So you take this like cheap money that's free money basically, and like I'm gonna put it in something that actually has value because it's scarce compared to the money, and then you build up this monetary premium, which makes sense. But the other the flip side is the technology actually is advanced or like is you know doubling in exponentially so and so quickly that it you know de it deflates in spite of all that inflation, right? [00:25:39] But you've set up you've set up an incentive structure that's warped, right? So so let's say I'm a I'm a business owner, I own or I'm a CEO of an airline, right? Okay, and I have two choices put my money in cash or so just take those and save cash for a rainy day. [00:25:57] When the government is saying, I'm gonna penalize you, CEO for doing that, if you do that, I'm trying to make your money worth less money, right? So cash is getting killed. Is the CEO gonna save cash with in a free market where where all the other CEOs are kind of doing stock buybacks because it's the best choice for their money? [00:26:19] Right. So you're so, and then when the system is anything little fails, oh, we need a bailouts. And so when you start to warp capitalism because people then you're really you're really in the later innings of the of debt crisis, yeah, currency crisis. [00:26:45] Right. So I like this framing that you put that where you know you pull the demand forward, and that you know you if you can't pay it back, right? Then you're literally just I it seems to me, it occurs to me that you're literally just stealing from the future productivity of people, right? [00:27:07] So not just you know our future, but obviously like generations down, down the line. And we've seen that. Like, you know, if you would look at a graph of productivity and mean wages about in 1971. And this is the first graph at the top of great website, just a compilation of graphs called WTF happened in 1971. [00:27:26] You know, we mean wages kind of flatline and the productivity continues at the same trajectory. Yeah, so it's almost like time theft or productivity theft. So when you say time theft, and king's so a lot of times things go on there's Keynesian and everything else and they're bad work. [00:27:47] He was actually a really smart economist. Yeah. What he predicted in 1930 was was in a he wrote a paper called The Economic Possibilities of Our Grandchildren. And he predicted a 15-hour work week. Yeah. And it was tracking along that till 1971. At that time, I think there was a 38-hour work week. [00:28:08] Most families, one person worked, not two. And we were tracking along we were tracking along that as that product product those productivity gains would build to society. Going off the gold reserve change that trajectory. Yeah. Slowly at first, right? [00:28:29] And then faster and faster as would be as would be pr predicted predicted. Yeah. Yeah. And Keynes, you know, I've I've thought I've said this before too that canes kind of gets a bad rap now and we sort of labeled this you know this fiat monetary policy that we're in now this inflationary monetary policy with his name but he also you know prescribed a counter countercycle measures right he was like all right we can do this to help sort of you know stem the effects of capitalist cycles the down effects of capitalist cycles but then you've got to raise you know raise taxes and raise interest rates afterwards but it's that [00:29:07] Countercycle measure that just that never happens right i and that's so he he actually advocated in for in bretton woods for something called the bank or and not something pegged to the US dollar so that this wouldn't happen. Okay. Right and effectively US was a power at that that time and they advocated for gold in the US dollar and that's what happened but that's a bit when when a country can unilaterally make a decision and export the problem everywhere else yeah they'll make that decision. [00:29:44] Yeah, every time it's irresistible. It's irresistible in a in a in a crisis. Yeah. So what it what is Bancor? I mean, I've seen this it's an acronym, right? B A N C. Yeah, it's an acronym. It's just it it would it was a way to peg. It would have been an old version of like Bing Cor Bitcoin, right? [00:30:04] So the a weight for governments to agree on a principle that you couldn't you could you couldn't change you couldn't change the underlying currency. Which would be gold in this case. Yeah. Yeah. So we're sort of forced at this point. I mean, this inevitable end of these inflationary monetary policies, you know, Austrian economists, people who have advocated, you know, going back onto a gold standard for 50 years now, have been saying, all right, it's it's been called the crack up boom, for instance. [00:30:38] But you know, every time that one of these cycles happens, it's like, is this the last one? Is this the one, right? And it just keeps getting bigger and bigger. And of course we're all asking the same question now. Is this the one? You know, we can't know for sure. We'll see how it all plays out. But this is the first m big one where we've had a decentralized open source alternative that can't be very, you know, can't be easily co-opted by central banks or governments as an alternative. [00:31:07] So you know, what do you do you think that just the mere existence of Bitcoin will change the out could have an effect and change the outcome of this current crisis? It it's hard to say on this one, can we get the can can governments get away with it one more time? Or I don't know. [00:31:26] But it let's just go back to first principles and say where is your money right now? And what are you doing with your money? And what is that and ladder that up around the world? So right now, from so government, we know you have to know that interest rates are gonna go negative all over the world. [00:31:44] Right. Just if you looked at math, they have to try to drive growth, and then they're gonna have to go more and more negative. That breaks a whole bunch of things that we believe in already. Like how do you price insurance with negative interest? Like there's so many things that just break. I go to the bank, I put my money there, and then I get less money out, just like it just it's gonna, it's gonna make people crazy. [00:32:05] Right. Mortgages. Exactly. Like there's just so many things as as as this starts to happen to try to drive growth. But now, so but let's say they get away with it. Effectively, you're doing the same thing at scale that we were talking about before. So I'm a CEO of a company and everything else. [00:32:24] Do I keep cash? So you're you're you have a what are you gonna do? You're going to get a mortgage, right? You keep cash. You're making the system more and more vulnerable in the chase of smaller and smaller growth. Remember, before $4 to $1 GDP, now way less than that, way more dollars of debt to GDP. [00:32:46] And now we're saying, wait, we can solve that problem. Let's make it worse, right? So you're creating instability everywhere. At some point, so now let's say so, so you're actually penalizing cash holders. And if you hold cash in that environment and they get away with it, you're gonna get killed. [00:33:06] Your cash is getting destroyed. And so you're going to go and buy these assets and everything else, and you're making the system, and so a whole bunch of people are setting themselves up for a giant fail. Right. On the opposite side of that, if if deflation happens as it should, right, and they and they don't get away with it, and you hold hold assets and a whole bunch of debt, you're gonna get killed. [00:33:33] So that coin flip for you and everybody else and me and the world and governments and everything else, that coin flip, whether they get away with it, is binary in nature on both sides of that. Yeah. So and Bitcoin protects against that. Right. So Bitcoin is a hedge against against that. [00:33:53] And that's why it's getting more and more on ramps of money going into it. I actually can't think of a no, if you want to if you want to make a ton of wealth, you concentrate everything, right? If you want to protect wealth, you diversify. So so if you want to make a bet on what other governments are gonna get away with and currencies and what what happens here, you could make a bet and go all in on real estate and everything else, knowing full well that at some point they're gonna have to tax that totally different, right? [00:34:25] And you can't move it. Yeah, right. Or you or you could make a bet, I'm gonna stay in cash and watch the deflation happen, and then I'm gonna buy assets for pennies on the dollar. You could make those bets. Yeah, but but both of those bets are binary in nature, and in and again on the Bitcoin, there might not be an asset class better than Bitcoin right now, because it protects against that happening. [00:34:49] Now, it could go down. Maybe governments get together and say, okay, we're gonna create something that looks like Bitcoin, we're gonna do it ourselves. I just see I see the that is a low probability event in this market, in this in this cycle. Yeah. So Bitcoin, like if we in a sound money world, like some would argue that since the government couldn't print money, at least nearly as easily, you obviously could borrow money, but you couldn't print more of it if we have a Bitcoin standard. [00:35:24] It is the most the hardest money that has you know possible basically, and by 2140 it'll be you know have an infinite stock to flow ratio. So if we can't print money, like how do we respond to a crisis like this when there's suddenly 25% unemployment, lots of small businesses at risk, if we can't like print a bunch of money and just hand it out to people to like survive the crisis. [00:35:51] So this is a really interesting because I think this is where we've been so fooled into believing this is the only way because we've lived in it so long that can't see the other side. If you couldn't, savings would go up in value, you would incent savings, right? [00:36:10] So if if the world looked different and you didn't have negative interest rates and there weren't incentives to be able to purchase purchase purchase and everything else, if you and that in that incentive created more and more debt and more and more instability in the system, then the other way would incent savings. And there would be lots of room for events that happen in the market because their savings would be there, right? [00:36:36] And the other side of this is healthy systems are yin in the yang, right? Yin yang. There's day and there's night, right? There's young and there's old. There's birth, there's there, there's death. Capitalism doesn't work if there's no failure. Right. You have to have if you say so government saying, oh, but we're gonna protect and never have failure, you it doesn't work, right? [00:37:03] It's impossible. I mean, isn't that essentially socialism at that point? Like, I mean, what we have now is socialism for the rich for the big corporations. That's what's that's what's happening. And so and with all the and it's easy to get away with too because it look doesn't look like that to governments. [00:37:22] A corporation with tens of thousands of employees says, if you don't save this, I have to fire all these people. And they can easily say, I'm protecting all these people. Yeah, but that's actually not what it's looking like. So let's go into again a little deeper. Three weeks ago, Federal Reserve took 2.3 trillion dollars of junk debt off the off the balance balance sheet and everything else. [00:37:48] And in that in real estate, commercial real estate, it looks like effectively subprime happening in 2008. That's why the reason they did it, because if it started to unwind, it touches everything. Yep. But the byproduct of that is let's say commercial real estate doesn't fall, right? Because you new fresh capital, here you go, the forget the bad stuff, we'll take that on our balance sheet, and when when that real estate price goes, so we're gonna protect it from falling, and then it's gonna go up because we're creating all this capital. [00:38:20] And then because we protected it from falling, and we took taxpayer money and did that, we also have to go and pay for all the people left out of that price rise. That rents go up in price, and those people can't afford to live, right? So, how do we create social safety nets for them? [00:38:39] Well, we have to pay those people more to for to pay for the same assets that we created at the high price in the first place. It's crazy. It's crazy. It's crazy. It's absolutely insane. I mean, we are gonna look back at this you know in in the future as just absolute insane time. [00:39:03] I mean, I just historians will not be kind to current central bankers and their current policy. They when when you see every bag of tricks coming out to oh no no no, it's this. Oh no, it's this we can get it. And by the way, you largely get away with that because you push the asset price higher, right? [00:39:25] And then later on you say, Oh no, I can pay back the debt because the asset price is higher. But you but and then you have to pay more people to work harder and harder more and more hours to pay for the higher asset prices that you're creating in the first place. Time theft. Yeah. All right, so let's let's talk about you know a bit more like a hopeful future, right? [00:39:48] I mean, obviously what we're in now we're going through is it's it's a terrible time, it's a scary time. It's even more terrible and scary for people who are not you know privileged enough to be close to the source of the printing of the U, you know, the world reserve currency. [00:40:07] Unfortunately, I can imagine that a lot of people in in other countries are you know, if they're not already, will be very upset with the United States and the way that they've been treated if what's they you know if that kind of comes to light and understanding spreads. [00:40:26] So how can this how can we transition right you said earlier that your your peers in the kind of corporate world are asking like okay this you this what you're saying makes sense what's the way out like how do we transition is there let's let's hear like a sort of a you know optimistic scenario versus the pessimistic scenario sure i'm an optimist I probably wouldn't have written the book if I wasn't an optimist the but I'm an optimist and I'm also realist. [00:40:59] I cannot I'm an entrepreneur and in a bunch of the different companies you actually you create value by first kind of looking deeper and seeing things that other people don't see and then trying to create a better future to that. To do that first job what people don't see you actually have to explore things that you questions that you might not ask, right? [00:41:24] And so that's what drove me to write write write the book. So you went so what we've talked about so far are are fact based, evidence based, and you can see it everywhere. This is a fact there's two forces monetary using technology deflation competing against each other and technology technological deflation is going to win in the end no matter what. [00:41:50] Yeah. The path to get there could be wars revol on this path on the current path will be war's revolutions. I hate to say that, but it will be. Because when you steal a whole bunch of wealth from some people and give it to certain people, it's easy for politicians to get elected and say, it's not your fault. [00:42:13] It's those people over there. Right. Sure. And the assets get taken back. Right. So and typically, or it's easy to blame another country and say they're stealing your jobs. It's not our, it's not our fault, right? China right now. [00:42:31] Right. And so and all of those things are missing the root cause of the problem. And most people will be blind to the root cause of the problem. They will believe the narrative. And once they believe the narrative that's happening, that it's hard to unring that bell. It's hard to change somebody's mind. [00:42:49] So that's why I wrote the book. So so people could understand the first principles and what what narratives they're likely going to hear next step, next step, next step. So if technol if technological deflation is a good thing, I can't understand why why the value of your money going up and us getting more and more every year for less is a bad thing. [00:43:16] Let that ring for you, right? [00:43:21] So so so, but it changes the current environment and it changes what's valued and asset prices and the debt. And if you have deflation against too much debt, the debt can't be paid back. So that transition is going to be hard because governments probably won't allow that to happen. [00:43:39] Right. So now we're going to assign a probabilities of distribution of what ends up happening to get there. But it's not impossible. Right. You could governments could say right now, okay, this is the this is the this is what's happening. It's happening all over the world. [00:43:58] And this is what do we build to that? And they could come together and say we agree on a common currency, and they could say, okay, we're gonna have to somehow reset this, pay this back or or whatever, and that's what it's gonna have to look like. And maybe current stores of value like real estate, taxes must go up a lot on on that to be able to make them less stores of value as you as you transition to a digital economy, right? [00:44:31] And digital economy everywhere. And I often ask the question here instead of asking how do we grow our way out of this? Because that's what every government is doing, and we'll manipulate currency, we'll do whatever it takes to grow our way out of this. I often ask the question, what would it look like if we weren't building for growth? [00:44:53] Like what if what what if we instead of what if we looked at the world and said, if technology is gonna do more and give us more for less all the time, and we don't have to pay for it, why are we trying to pay for it? Right. Right? Why are we trying to create more jobs in a world where there's clearly going to be less of them? [00:45:14] Right. Why don't we accept the abundance that technology will give give us? It's just that transition that what that thought experiment that we're talking about right now is so difficult for current policymakers because and actually current people to understand because they've never been in an environment where that that could happen. [00:45:37] So do you think then that's and I don't think this would happen, but you know, just as a thought experiment, maybe the most humane and ideal way to transition would be to just wipe all debt have like a debt jubilee you know on a wide scale and then just you know basically I don't know in in a way like with whatever assets if there are any that are left in the US government I guess there's probably not many you know just kind of give Bitcoin to people well so so and no because it and I get asked that question a lot but but and so so remember let's [00:46:15] Just and I'm not going to use me as I'll pretend this is me. I have tons of real estate holdings across across the country and everything else and I'm an individual so and because of monetary policy and because of inflation everything else because of everything else I wasn't allowed to accumulate tons of wealth and in the current environment because of monetary I'm also I'm able to create way more wealth because of protecting it from falling right and by stimulating [00:46:53] The stimulative monetary policy it's gonna go up again right and now so I have all of that real estate now somebody says okay debt jubily all debt is wiped out yeah what happens to my real estate so do I just get that gift forever right and now just roll that up if that's a country do they get that gift forever do they they get and so I don't think that that's the way to solve it because it's because essentially you've locked in the you've locked in the wealth inequality yeah well wealth inequality, but you've yeah you've actually locked [00:47:32] In gains, not by productive gains. Right. Right. You've got it's so there's a lot of people in my in my group it's other CEOs, other everything else, and wealthy people that they call it the one percenters. [00:47:51] There's a lot of people in that group that that actually think they got their wealth because of their ingenuity. Right. And they didn't. And there's a lot of people that are investigating this way deeper as well and saying this doesn't make any sense. But there's some people in in that that totally believe in in kind of these the these the frameworks that they've always had, and they that the they have no idea it's just been a gift from monetary easing. [00:48:19] Right. And that's you know, generations like the millenniation generations coming up behind them are you know, seem to understand that pretty well because they have not benefited from those policies. Well, so that's when you as you as you keep going down, that's why I said what ends up happening is revolution war, you just get it and maybe that starts with socialism, but socialism isn't the answer to solve this, right? [00:48:44] It's it it it so why Bernie Sanders gets really popular and from from a new generation of people and essentially is the same thing. It's not your fault, it's those people's fault. They stole it from you and everything else, we're gonna redistribute it. But that's not solving it from a root cause problem either. [00:49:03] So you have politicians on both sides of the aisles screaming at each other, both wrong. Yeah. Yeah. So then I like you said, maybe the way out of this might be through socialism, or at least we might get there because of the anger from the those resources with young people. [00:49:24] That path. Yeah, so that path, if you actually chose that path, I don't think you'd get there. What you're going to get to is the revolution war faster. Okay. Right. And that's what I'm getting at. That that path, if you start doing doing that path, how do you how do you think Hitler got elected? Right. And what did he do? [00:49:45] He he he chose the people who had money and those were the enemy. Yeah. Right. And this pattern repeats in history all the time. [00:49:56] It's a whole bunch of people lose hope in a better future. [00:50:00] Yeah. They rise up. They're easy, it's easy to manipulate people. Right, right. Yeah. So how do we solve this? I mean, obviously not I think solves the wrong word, but how do we improve this wealth inequality situation in the short term? I mean, if we transition into a you know a Bitcoin world, you almost sort of stamp that inequality into the kind of the new money as well, because that's you know where we're actually don't I don't think you do. [00:50:28] You don't think so? I think I think I think in Bitcoin you don't stamp that because because there's there's a whole bunch of people that can buy it. It's too late. I think you're so so no, I don't think you stamped that into Bitcoin. [00:50:47] Yeah, great. That makes sense. So like as wealthy people who wait around too long, basically will be trading in you know, bad money for much less of the good money. And so there's a big redistribution based on green adoption. Yeah, huge redistribution. [00:51:06] Yeah. So then you've got money in the hands of Bitcoin early adopters. A lot of money. And you know, the ideals of you know Bitcoiners' monetary ideals are obviously a lot different. And it'd be interesting to see how sort of those, I guess, libertarian or you know, sound money monetary system ideals will dovetail with an abundant future. [00:51:31] Do you think it it's a good match? So I think you mentioned this with Keynes and everything else. Because we can't understand the complexity of an individual or somebody's idea, or when you say libertarians or canes and everything else, people want to put people in these little boxes and say that's who they are, they always the this. [00:51:55] And so if you look at actually all of the different economists and some of them very, very thoughtful, right? But they don't get known for the wide range of thought they got the narrow, very narrow and every that it's like that. And because because our brains can't accept that complexity, yeah. [00:52:16] And so we label people really easily, right? And so even when you said libertarian or everything else, if you just said libertarian, I bet you there's a giant spectrum in libertarian, right? Yeah, of course. And all these spectrums and everything else. And so I do I think something like Bitcoin and if governments pegged to it over time and sound money came, I think we would have a different way of living where prices would fall everywhere. [00:52:47] Where we wouldn't have to be on a treadmill of work forever for rising prices everywhere. [00:52:55] And capitalism would work perfectly. [00:52:58] People who wanted to work more would work more. You drive you'd drive higher say you'd drive higher savings rate, and you wouldn't be on this endless treadmill for growth at the expense of for growth that is actually a mirage, right? The entire growth model right now, if you accept four dollars for every one dollar, and now it's way worse, and it's gonna be way worse coming for all of this any real growth is just a total mirage. [00:53:26] Right. Yeah. So okay, let's talk a bit about the future, some more about the future. And technological abundance. So I know that you are on boards and you've been CEO and founded several tech companies. So you have your kind of fingers on the pulse of the, you know, the kind of the upper echelon of the tech scene, probably more so than most than than most of us. [00:53:54] So I'd love to hear from you what kinds of tech that you're seeing that you know maybe the knowledge of is not you know well distributed among the people who aren't in that world. And you know from the book I wrote about some of these things in the book, but the pace of AI is it's it's so staggering how fast that's that's moving, and not just what people think AI to is today, deep learning algorithms and gener and narrow purpose AI. [00:54:29] And again, you know from the book, but even if you said AI is better at one domain than than a human being, so it forget general purpose AI where Jay AI is better, smarter than all of us, just like a narrow domain and say AI is better than us, because it can see more errors, right? [00:54:51] It can see and it can it feeds back and it gets better and better with deep learning. But if you just accept that, then and you and you say, What do we do for our jobs? Right? We go to school, we practice something narrowly over and over and over and over again, and we get better and better at it. [00:55:10] And that race to get the best at something and the highest and the best at something gets paid way more than the second best, right? Is what drives our careers and our learning and the things we do, right? And AI is already starting to do that job in multiple industries way better than the best. [00:55:32] And it's moving into countless industries. So if you just what are some examples? Well, well, well, so radiology today. Radio radiology today, you'd go to school to be a radiologist, AI can AI can pick up way better than doctors today, radiologists today, what breast cancer, a whole bunch of different different things. [00:55:55] So now you have a technology that effectively at some point is is free. Do you as a person, if you need to see a radiologist, are you going to go and pay the doctor and spend the time there, or use the free technology that's that's 10 times better, right and maybe right now it's not 10 times better but in a year it will be in two years it'll be the hundred times better and so that that path is across everything it's across and so that's something I'd say people don't realize how fast that's moving and then I'm [00:56:33] Close to some of I'm close to some of the research scientists that are the next generation of AI probabilistic programming and in different areas of AI that Frank Wood from the UBC I'm helping him in one of his companies but he's the foremost researcher in the world in this area of AI which could be one of the missing links to move AI from deep learning to general purpose and so there's there's a whole bunch of people working on this type of stuff as well but what I would say and then some of the companies I'm involved in some of the technologies there's [00:57:12] There's lots of opportunity there's tons of opportunities still it changes like this that that are moving the this fast break existing industries at a crazy speed and provide new entrance to if you know where to go amazing opportunities one of my one of my companies that i that i co-founded projected 46 million no projected 40 million dollars in in april and that was up 40 times over last year and ended up doing 86 million in April. [00:57:48] Wow and so so there's tremendous opportunities if you know where to build, how to build, how do you build network effects, how do you take advantage of data into the system so it feeds back on itself tremendous across agriculture, across health, across a whole bunch of different domains that haven't been digitized yet. [00:58:10] But but but will be. So there's tons of opportunity, but it's but why I wrote the book is that opportunity. If I just roll up that opportunity of that of creating those companies into an overall system, it's way less jobs. Yeah, yeah. So at that point, you know, the people if prices are falling and approaching zero, like I there's a couple of other books that reminded me of yours, Abundance by Peter Diamandis, which was which is very interesting, and one that I read right before I discovered Bitcoin, and I was kind of in the place [00:58:48] Where I think a lot of Bitcoiners tell the story a lot, where sort of like kind of hopeless about the future, and you just you know don't think there's much opportunity to really grow, and you just kind of like in like politics, you know, politics doesn't really work. You just get the sense that things are just like stagnant and not fair and sort of degrading over time. [00:59:09] And I read the book abundance by Peter D. Mandison, and you know, was got a lot or a little at least a little bit more hopeful about the future, and then I found Bitcoin and was like, okay, this really solves like the root problem. So if we can make this happen, then we can really rebuild society from the bottom up based on Bitcoin. [00:59:28] And then the other book was Zero Marginal Cost Society, I think it's called by Jeremy Rifkin. Yeah, so yeah. So have you have you read those books and I guess did they have they influenced you? I read both. One of the things, and I know Peter Peter's a friend, and so one of the things that that I think the entire abundant by the way his book is awesome the abundance is a really great book but super inspiring yeah but the one thing that a lot of the people in the tech sector missed and still miss is that it it is this when they talk about that about [01:00:06] The abundance from tech without talking against a monetary system that's put stopping that there they're only one side of the equation and they don't realize that that distribution to society is not going to happen it's going to break it and so that's the thing that actually got got me kind of going down the rabbit hole away deeper because it doesn't make sense I had a I had somebody a friend I won't mention the friend of the company but but working on general purpose artificial intelligence and came to me for an investment yeah in the [01:00:44] In the company and their pitch was this is a 10 trillion dollar opportunity right our business is going to be worth 10 trillion dollars because of the of the displacement of all of these companies that it creates and if you buy the hypothesis that it it creates that displacement and it does this job for no cost then you cannot buy it's a 10 trillion dollar opportunity it's impossible yeah but but that's the logic fallacy that so many people they're talking about existing systems applied to technology and thinking that the bus and [01:01:23] Really and missing the fact that technology changes the changes these massively and changes the and by changing them changes the size of those industries. [01:01:34] All right. [01:01:38] So do you think then that then the future like ultimate trajectory of this like a deflationary society combined with or deflationary monetary policy combined with a deflationary technology, then is like some sort of technological, you know, I guess utopia for b lack of a better word, that you start like Star Trek like or something? [01:02:00] It's it's more like Star Trek instead of Star Wars. Yeah. It's yeah, and where people who want to work will work, but you'll have way more time. You actually could have a whole new re renaissance of time. We would value time. Right. And if you just why do you do the things you do, right? [01:02:21] If you kind of full pull pull that back. So I spend 80 hours a week in work to do more and more and more so I can save enough money so that one time I can retire and I can have more time with my family and or travel. Right. When your kids are all grown up and it's like it never happens, you don't get it. [01:02:41] How many people are trapped in that? Yeah, so they and they think that that w I'm doing it for the one day I can finally enjoy my life. Right, exactly. Right. What if you could have that all the time? What if you could have it right now all the time? And actually you know, I know there's a lot of people who would listen to this that can't because they've lived in a different world and everything else, but I would say that that's gonna be easier and easier and easier. [01:03:08] And if you value your time and really value your time, it's amazing how much time you actually have. Yeah. Yeah. And that's, I mean, that's what we talk about as Bitcoiners all the time is the idea of long-time preference, long-term type time preference versus a short-time preference. Which, you know, this is the society we live in, is you know, short-time preference society. [01:03:29] It's you know, it's based on the money. That's where it comes from. That the money sort of pushes society that way, pushes individuals that way. And one of the things that you know I talk about a lot on this podcast is like the shift in the mindset when you understand kind of long-term thinking and deflationary money and the way money should be, is to start to value your time, right? [01:03:49] The only the scarcest asset that we have is our time, and the second thing should be the money, right? So that you know it closely represents our time, which is what it's supposed to do. So when you think about that world, I mean, the opening to this podcast is the tagline is welcome to the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. [01:04:08] Right. Which I love that you mentioned that. You know, if you look back to the Renaissance, and we can dive into a little bit of history here, but you look in back to the Renaissance, and it was you know an era that was based on a gold standard that was really enforced by you know some very wealthy merchants, but I think that they understood the value of sound money and kind of enforced that that standard for the most part. [01:04:32] But you had an era where humans were able to really pursue their crafts, their passions, and really yeah, just really hone that talent and create just generational works of art and architecture, and that's where that came from, you know, it's not because literature, everything, yeah. [01:04:50] Yeah, all of that, all of that, yeah. So I mean, I guess that's a period that we can look back on. I think the phrase Bitcoin Renaissance is is completely apt there. So then do you think in the future, if we get to that that society where you know technology is essentially free and our time is completely freed up, we're not you know wanting our our needs are basic needs are met, and that we have you know this time freed up to basically pursue whatever we want to do. [01:05:17] Does money even matter at that point? Like do we even need that anymore? And we're going way out there right now. This is hundreds of years. It's gonna be hard, it's gonna be hard for people to get there. And if you think about along that way, so take Elon Musk's neural lace, right? [01:05:35] Yes, yeah, and where there's going to be people and then more people and then more people, we're going to mind and machine is gonna melt. Yeah, right. And so some of the things on on the path that's like before hundreds of years, there's gonna be different things that are going to change our the way we think what what we need, what we need, and they're gonna just break break a whole bunch of things. [01:06:03] But yeah, you mentioned it. If you're in an ecosystem, a monetary system, that is it has way more effect on you than you know, right? Way more effect. It it drives everything else. We think we so we say we need the environment to be really great, yet we'll drive if there if the cost of a gas car is is cheaper, we'll buy the gas car. [01:06:30] Because because cost and our life, we need to be able to do this, exploded in a in a currency in a in in an economy. If coal is cheaper for China, they'll use coal because if they don't do it, because if they don't, they're a disadvantage on their energy costs, and energy cost is the number one input for just about everything else. [01:06:52] So it's hard to stop things like this. So much of what we think we do is based on based on economics and trying to get more of the pie and everything else, and that energy cost example you know from my book. Now now solar is moving to lower cost energy, right? [01:07:12] So so it that's deflationary in nature as well, because it's gonna drive lower and lower cost energy. Eventually, energy this is gonna be so bold to say this on it because people take it out, but eventually energy will be free or almost free. And so when you add some of these things that are happening, I can't see why wouldn't we want that? [01:07:34] Wouldn't that be a good thing for society and all of us? So if you if you add up some of these things, it means you have way more free time, you have way the number of secondary effects that can happen, it's just true, true abundance, and we're stopping that from happening, stopping stopping that from happening. [01:07:53] And people don't know it because they're so caught up in a loop of the existing system that we live in. Yeah. So a quick tangent on on energy since you mentioned it and brought it up. When you were first getting into Bitcoin, you know, m almost always the first response or reaction to it is criticism is the energy thing. [01:08:14] Like it takes all this energy to mine it. It's completely wasteful. I think it's probably because that narrative's out there in the mainstream media a lot. So did you balk at that that idea and have like how is your understanding about Bitcoin's energy use evolved? So actually I some of that I accepted, right? [01:08:33] And if that energy was coming from coal, they're right. Right. And over time it's not as big an energy c drain as as everything, even if you forecasted it forward. But but but ultimately that's a lot of energy, and if it was dirty energy, but that's not what it'll look like. [01:08:52] Yeah, it it'll it'll look totally different and that energy cost will decline and it and it'll be cheap and it's right the energy costs will decline and it'll be clean energy in time. Yeah. And in fact, in fact, the race for innovation there will create an incentive to drive it faster. [01:09:12] Yeah. And that's that's the argument that Bitcoiners have been trying to get out is and we see evidence of that, right? I mean, it's it's a race to I mean, the only two inputs into Bitcoin mining are the CapEx and the energy. Yeah. And so, you know, i the capex is obviously coming down as well through deflationary, you know, digital technology. [01:09:30] And then the energy inputs, the need for energy for Bitcoin mining is gonna drive down the cost. I mean, everyone th mining is just a search for the cheapest, you know, energy. And so it's yeah, it's incentivizing that and more and more, of course, it's it's solar, it's excess energy from like solar, I'm sorry, hydro dams, you know, because there's lots of excess energy that you know is generated during like rainy seasons that can't be used, right? [01:09:57] And that's just kind of going to waste. But you throw a Bitcoin miner out there, you can turn it into money. We're ca we're capturing you know, like methane that's being vented, you know, and turning it into energy. In fact, there's a company in Canada led by Steve Barber. You should check it out. He's on the forefront of capturing excess like oil and methane out in in the in rural Canada and turning it into Bitcoin. [01:10:22] He's got these really cool mining rigs that just go and drop it off in a field. So yeah definitely passionate about getting that argument out there because it's it's not intuitive and it's easy it's one of those arguments it's like you look at the numbers or you make a comparison like it's using more energy than you know the country of Ireland. [01:10:41] But then you look at the other you know another analogy is it's less energy than Christmas lights in America used every exactly exactly it's like yeah yeah so I think I want to wrap up your the end of your book the last chapter is is action items which I love because it's very sort of a corporate phrase or term that we use in the business world and I let's take the action items out of this meeting. [01:11:07] What can we as in what should we in your opinion as individuals do in the next five 10 15 years to kind of move to a deflationary monetary policy so as individuals get the message out but get the message out in a in a in a positive light so i've said this on a couple other podcasts I it boggles my mind that there's a whole bunch of Bitcoiners fighting with gold bugs and viciously right it boggles my mind and because if you actually look [01:11:45] At the at a higher level. Both believe in the same thing. They both believe in the exact same thing, sound money, right? And yeah, and one could be right and one could be wrong, and maybe gold, maybe central governments go back to gold standard. [01:12:04] I think it's implausible myself, but I don't disrespect somebody for having that opinion. Sure. Right. I just think there's an asymmetric beta Bitcoin's at a 150 billion market cap and gold's at a eight to ten trillion dollar market cap, and if Bitcoin wins, it'll inverse. [01:12:26] Yeah, right. So but but the people that believe in gold, I know why they believe in gold and I respect them for it, right? So so the bigger are the bigger I think you can build bridges, and I think there's a whole bunch of people in your community and others that can build bridges. If you go one step above that in governments and everything else, on the socialist side or the capitalist side and everything else, it's the same thing. [01:12:51] Like people are what's happening is is people are are believing a narrative and they're getting further and further away from somebody else, and they're trying to and then dividing it and everything else. And if you go up another level, you kind of go, what is wait a second? We're all caught in this little loop over here, and we're fighting with each other over the stupid stupid little thing when it doesn't matter. [01:13:16] And that's why I tried to go really at a high level in the book, and then try to drive in how we easily get stuck in our current framework. Yeah, right. And the biases that we carry and everything else. I'd because at the highest level, if technological deflation is going to happen anyways, right? [01:13:36] And that and have any I'll debate anybody on that, right? And so it if and it's going to accelerate from here. Yeah, then there's few choices. Yeah. Right. Let's have that conversation. So how do you how how do you how do you have that conversation? [01:13:56] Unite people on that. Unite people on that, have them have them have them tell you why that can't happen. And if that can and if that can happen, then the other things are a byproduct of it. Right. Right. Yeah, and I think it has to happen outside of the put you know political system. [01:14:16] Like I don't, you know, I see some Bitcoiners in the traditional, you know, this political system, which I think is good, you know, we need the conversation to happen there as well. But there's just this you know, trajectory of division, like you're talking about in political sphere, where it's just arguing over these little band-aids, you know, and using you know, wedges between two people to just like separate them and be like, okay, you guys fight, we're gonna go ahead and control the world while you guys are doing that. [01:14:46] So here's the here is the one difference. I don't think they I don't think they're trying to do it. Sure, yeah. I so that it's it's a product of a system. If you and if you think of system-based thinking, and that's why I said that's why I say you have to question the system, and it's hard to businesses fail all the time. [01:15:05] Kodak invented the digital camera, and twice Steve Sasson, who invented it, was rejected by by by executives be because it would kill their business. And yes, it would kill their business. And they invented it and didn't take any of it, right? [01:15:25] And ended up in bankruptcy. That's what's happening in a system today. There's a whole bunch of people that are stuck in a system and are rejecting the kind of the first principle that we're talking about. And so they're trying to they don't see it. Most of them don't see it. Right. [01:15:46] One of the top central bankers from it actually was one of the reasons for me really getting off my ass and writing the book. [01:15:54] Central bankers in Canada said to me about technological deflation, [01:16:02] And he goes, Yes, but what would you have us do? And I went, that's not an answer. That is not an answer. And so, yes, what would you have us do? Is not an answer. So I thought we need to talk about, okay, yes, how do we build a better future? [01:16:24] That's the answer. Yeah, yeah. All right, one more question. Sorry, I thought was supposed to be the last one, but I meant to ask this earlier and just reminded of it. What do you think about UBI? I think that UBI without dealing with the root cause problem creates a whole bunch more problems. [01:16:42] Okay. Yeah. So so again, the assets are unnaturally lifted because we're unnaturally lifting them, and now we're trying to give a whole bunch of gift of UBI that we can't pay for to a whole bunch of people to pay for the prices that we are artificially manipulated. So without dealing in a system, you're just gonna create more and more division. [01:17:01] Yeah. Do you think it's marginally better than than giving that money to banks and corporations? So [01:17:11] I think there has to be something like it as a social safety net as we transition. Okay. But again, and so so that but I want to I but I want to be really careful with doing it without like blindly, because right now what's happening is you're it's gonna cement divide into the society. [01:17:31] Yeah. And if and a whole bunch of people that are gonna taxes are going up is saying, well, why am I paying for those people? And you're gonna divide people more, right? And without dealing with the root cause of the problem in the first place. That's the that's the so it's not that I'm necessarily against it in some sort of principle, because I think you need a transition mechanism. [01:17:52] Gotcha. Yeah. But but the tr a transition mechanism without understanding the first principle of the problem you're trying to solve is is is pouring more gas on a fire. Yeah, it only makes sense in the context of, you know, hey, we're in a transition to a new money, and so we're gonna do this as a policy as part of the transition. [01:18:11] Otherwise, yeah, it's that makes sense. Well, it's gonna be fascinating to see how this all plays out. I think we as as Bitcoiners who have sort of stumbled upon this this knowledge, I guess, that was sort of lost to a lot of people around the world, have that responsibility, like you said, to really carry it forward. And I've been saying this on the podcast too, especially the last few months, that really now is our time as Bitcoiners that we really need to be out there and talking about this and be responsible about the way we present things and that's the that's that's the piece, right? [01:18:43] So if we're that the that that that's the piece. In this in the community, there there is too many because because and I get it, I'm gonna say when when I was early in an entrepreneur like effectively they're going up against a system, right? And when you're doing that and you have one or two people, it's you against the world, and everybody calls you a fool. [01:19:08] Right. That's what happened. And when it starts to win, you what you want to do is is say, told you, you jerk, right? That's what you want to do because the urge I'm I'm right, I'm right, you're wrong, right? And you your ego gets away on you and everything else. [01:19:28] If I apply that, by the way, I did it, right? And in my own company and learned a terrible lesson by by doing it really like so that humility right now in Bitcoin, I think a lot of people in Bitcoin are largely right and from from but that humility to build bridges and go to a higher level and for us on the on the reason we'll build bridges way faster and drive and drive that. [01:19:59] So that's the that's the piece, and I don't see that everywhere in the Bitcoin community. Sure, yeah, absolutely, yeah. And you're never gonna see it, you know, completely in any community. There's always gonna be, you know, there's just a range of people, and Bitcoin is, you know, it it it is already a pretty big tent in terms of the types of people it's brought in, lots of across the political spectrum. [01:20:22] You know, demographically, I you know, maybe not so much, at least but I'm I'm kind of trapped in the this kind of Western you know viewpoint. I'm trying to branch out from that more and talk to Bitcoiners in South America and Africa and Asia a bit more. So I hope that that will help on my perspective and my listeners too. [01:20:41] But yeah, I think we have that responsibility. We need to think about that very seriously as Bitcoiners. And one of the big kind of well-known Bitcoiners, he has a podcast along with Marty. He does like a weekly recap on Bitcoin news with Marty, who, and you've been on his podcast, Matt O'Dell. And his sort of meme that he's put out there is stay humble, stack sets. [01:21:01] Love that. Yeah. Yep. I love that. So I think that's the message. We'll end it right there. Thanks so much, Jeff. Go get the book. It's fantastic price of tomorrow. And enjoy it. Let's talk about these ideas and spread them around. Thanks for the time, man. Appreciate it. Awesome. Thank you. Thanks. Okay. [01:21:27] Thanks to Jeff for joining me. It was an absolute honor, a pleasure to speak with Jeff today. You can find Jeff on Twitter at Jeff Booth at J E F F B O O T H. I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. Jeff's website where you'll also find the book is Jeffreybooth.com. [01:21:46] Podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. I'd love for you to share this out with family and friends. You know, the bowl is incoming. We can all feel it, right? So get them on board with some great Bitcoin content. Sign them up at SwanBitcoin.com, Swan Signal Podcast, the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. Get them hooked up. All right. [01:22:04] Thanks again, of course, to Swan for sponsoring the episode, making this possible to bring it to you all. Let's talk Bitcoin Network for including the podcast in the feed. Thanks to BTC Media, Christian Carolish. Shout out there. You can also check out my merch store. Shout out Nick Ward, great Bitcoiner, layer one btc.com. Click partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. [01:22:23] Lots of cool stuff there to check out, including some optech friendly stuff. Check out the podcast that I've created for Swan, Swan Signal Podcast. Again, two awesome guests. So make sure you get this feed into your podcast app, Swansignal Podcast.com. Adam Back and Preston Pysh will be on the most recent podcast when you add that to your podcast app. [01:22:48] So if you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. I've been hearing from you guys more and more, and I really love chatting with you all. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at citizenbitcoin on Telegram. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.