Brandon Quittem: Bitcoin Culture Wars and The Bitcoin-Fungi Analogy Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-04-12 [00:00:21] Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. So how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are well, enjoying life, learning some Bitcoin and preparing for a Bitcoin future. [00:00:44] I've got another great discussion for you today with Brandon Quittem, but before we get to the show, I need to take a moment to beg for some more ratings and reviews on iTunes. We're up to 16 now, thanks to listeners Matt Paws at PAZ5050 on Bitcoin Twitter, and Gigi at D E R G I G I on Bitcoin Twitter. [00:01:09] Thanks to both of those guys for leaving five-star reviews on iTunes and for going out of their way to send me some encouraging feedback. It really means a lot and motivates me to keep working on the pod. So I'm glad it's been useful to others out there, and it's always good to hear that it is useful to others. The ratings and reviews have been useful too. [00:01:28] I can tell that discovery is picking up a bit and it's making a big difference. So join Matt and Gigi and leave a rating and review of the pod if you have found it useful. Alright, let's get on to the show. Brandon Quittem burst onto the Bitcoin scene like a mushroom breaking through three inches of asphalt when he published the first part of his Bitcoin Fungi Analogy in December 2018. [00:01:58] I love biology and nature in general and have a particular interest in mushrooms and fungi. I think they're incredibly interesting life forms. And I enjoy foraging for morels every springtime in here in the Midwest of the United States. So Brandon was toward the top of my list of Bitcoiners to talk to when I started doing these interview episodes. [00:02:17] And this one, Brandon and I start out with some talk about this fake Toshi hodlanaut mess and a piece about Bitcoin culture wars that Brandon published a couple months ago. We talk about potential future culture wars around privacy and fungibility versus chain transparency for supply verification, and about the declining subsidy and transition to a fee market to support network security. [00:02:43] Then we, of course, dig into the mycelium and mushroom analogy, and Brandon gives us a preview of the upcoming third and final part of the series. I hope you enjoy it, and please do let Brandon and I know what you thought about the episode on Twitter. I'm at Citizen Bitcoin, and Brandon is at BQM, B Q U I T T E M. [00:03:08] With that, here is my discussion with Brandon. [00:03:16] Alright, hey Brandon, welcome to the podcast. Thanks for joining me today. Thanks, Brady. Excited to be here. Yeah, I'm super excited about this conversation in particular. It's really fun to meet new Bitcoiners because inevitably there's some other thing that they're interested in, or many other things that they're interested in. [00:03:36] You can learn about from them. And this is definitely one of those cases. And I am I am totally into mushrooms. I think they're fascinating. I have not dove nearly as deep as you have into studying them. And so I'm excited to talk about this analogy and learn a bit more about mushrooms in the process as well. [00:03:56] Before we hopped on, I took my daily supplements of mushroom capsules. It's like dried mushrooms. I think there's cordyceps, rishi, lion's mane, chaga, mitaki, turkey tail, shiitake, just kind of a cocktail of these mushrooms I've been taking for a few months now as a nootropic. [00:04:16] And it's awesome. I yeah, it's great. I really feel you know, a benefit from taking them on a daily basis. So do you I think you mentioned in one of your pieces that you supplement with mushrooms as well. It's like so what do you use? Do you use capsules or do you actually eat raw mushrooms and why do you take them? [00:04:36] Like why do you decide to take weed? Good question. So I've been into mushrooms for about five years, maybe a little bit more. And it started with foraging, just as something to do when I'm hiking out in the woods, which is actually very addicting. It's an adrenaline rush looking for treasures in the woods. And that turned into that sort of morphed into a passion for cooking forage food. [00:04:58] And so I host some dinner parties with friends and new mushroom initiates where we go out in the woods, we forage, we find some mushrooms, come home, cook, have a nice, you know, eat drink, be merry, be merry kind of situation. And parallel to that, I'm very into health and supplements and working out and wellness and all the stuff that sort of goes with that. [00:05:19] And I think it was through Paul Stamitz originally that sort of started this train. And you know, since since this has all developed, I've built a little routine with consuming medicinal mushrooms for various different benefits. The majority of the mushrooms that I have, I've actually foraged myself. That's awesome. [00:05:38] And you know, you go out in the woods, you find what you need. Some of them you dehydrate, and then you do a dual extraction. So you do, you know, two months in a jar with alcohol that pulls out all the fat-soluble molecules, and then you do a hot water extraction that pulls out the water-soluble molecules, combine them into a tincture. Yep. [00:05:56] And so that's sort of my standard. But I also purchase mushrooms from Paul Stametz and various other places online, toss them in a smoothie or something like that. But the main ones would be chaga, raishi, and turkey tail and lion's mane. Those are sort of a daily, every day I consume those. And then on days when I'm working out, I take cordyceps as well, which are sort of a very interesting mushroom that attacks a caterpillar or a bug or something like that, takes over its central nervous system, and kind of like a zombie, it drives that bug higher up in the tree. [00:06:33] And then as soon as the mushroom eats all the insides of the bug, the mycelium eats all the inside, it shoots a mushroom out the bug's head, which releases spores and then infects the other bugs nearby. And it's a really interesting mushroom, but it it increases the blood or the oxygen in your blood, and it's really good for high elevation and also for physical fitness. [00:06:56] And it grows mostly or it's found mostly at high elevations too, right? Like in the Himalayas mostly, I think. Yeah, exactly. There's there's quite a few different varieties that are they're found, some are in the jungle, some are in the mountains, some are all over the place. But the most potent ones are the ones that are that grow in really harsh conditions, like you mentioned in the Himalayas. [00:07:16] Yeah, that's amazing. There's I'll include a link in the show notes to the Wikipedia entry and a couple photos, but you've got to check out these photos of these caterpillars that have been turned from caterpillar into cordyceps mycelium, and then these this shoot of a mushroom that just like pops right out of its head. [00:07:35] It's kind of nature is amazing. Sinister. It is sinister and efficient in accomplishing its task. But you know, I'm sure there's a benefit to the stability of the caterpillar populations too as well. There's probably a healthy check on caterpillars with this fungus. [00:07:55] And they've got some kind of like you know, well-balanced ecosystem going on. Sure, sure, yeah. That's probably true. I don't actually know the specifics, but your nature doesn't make mistakes very often. So I think you're probably right. That's amazing. So I definitely want to if we can make it work at some point in time, join you for one of these mushroom foraging dinners. [00:08:18] It sounds incredible. A really good idea, and something that I should try to do here as well. Definitely. Yeah, you're in the Midwest. You've got a similar season, and there's a lot out there. You're you know, open invitation to you and any other Bitcoiners. If you're in Minnesota between May and October, look me up and we'll get out in the woods. [00:08:39] Yeah, that'd be fun. And same goes for the Lawrence, Kansas area. Hit me up and maybe if we can get a shelling point going, we can we can convince Brandon to drive down here. Love it. Yeah, all right. So I wanted to start off the conversation today you know, after we got through the mushroom supplementation bit with talking about this Hodlanaut situation. [00:09:05] All right. It's blowing up on Twitter today. We're talking on like late afternoon, Thursday, April 11th. And this morning, Central Time in the United States, about 12 hours ago, CoinGeek posted an article. CoinGeek is owned by Calvin Ayer, and who is, you know, a partner in this Bitcoin Satoshi's Vision project for with with Craig Wright. [00:09:33] This article says that Craig Wright served papers to Hodlanaut on March 29th, and that Hodlana deleted some tweets that were calling Craig Wright a fraud. And then this morning when this are after this article posted, the Hodlanaut account went went dark, went silent. [00:09:53] So it's it's been disabled on the web now. And a friend of Hodlanaut's contacted me on earlier today and asking me to take down my interview with him, and he was the first person to do a Citizen Bitcoin interview episode. So he helped kind of kick these things off. [00:10:12] And it was a great interview. It was just a few days after Jack took the lightning torch from Matt O'Dell and kind of blew the whole Ellen Trust thing up. So like Craig and Calvin, to be quite clear, I am Hodlana. I've been running that account. [00:10:31] Come at me, bros. This is, yeah, I'm kind of angry about this. What's what's your take? I agree. I cannot believe that Craig Wright and company are digging their heels in so far on this one. To me, it feels like the you know, grasping at the straws, the dog with rabies stuck in the corner, lashing out. [00:10:50] Like, I don't know how, and I'm I'm no lawyer, so I could be wrong here, but I don't have any idea how it's possible that they have some legal grounds to do what they're doing. Right. Not that they necessarily need solid legal ground to cause problems for people, which you know. Yeah. [00:11:09] And it's you know, it's scary. It'd be scary for me to receive some legal papers from billionaires who have far more resources than me. You know, just because even if there is no cause whatsoever, you know, there's you gotta defend yourself, and that that can get expensive. [00:11:28] You know. The response to it has been interesting. You know, there are people kind of expressing some anger, but there's also this sort of I guess movement or whatever, this idea that we all have changed our a lot of us have changed our avatars to Hodlanat's Space Cat Avatar, put our name, change our names to Hadlanot on on Twitter just sort of as a show of unity. [00:11:55] And I tweeted out earlier today because you know, I kind of thought I was like, it's interesting that we're like pretending to be someone as a response to alligate, you know, allegations of fraud from someone else, which is pretending to be someone. I was thinking I was thinking about it, I was like, pretending to be someone in defense of like a common, you know, value or principle is not fraud. [00:12:15] But pretending to be someone because you're you know in a selfish interest to promote yourself, you know, for fame and fortune, that's the definition of fraud, right? So there's a big difference between the two. But that kind of like that response on Twitter of human individuals coming together in defense of this common principle, namely that like we should not use the identity of Satoshi and more broadly Bitcoin and all the potential that it represents for your own selfish personal gain, right? [00:12:47] Seems to be a great example of the sort of decentralized immune response that Bitcoin has going for it. Yeah, I think you I think you speak a lot of truth there. And before we get too deep, I just want to make a funny point. I woke up this morning, you know, I checked Twitter, and looking around, and there's space cats everywhere. [00:13:09] And I mean I didn't know why. I was like, why is he liking all my stuff? What is going on? It took me a minute to understand, and I was like, okay, this is really cool. Yeah, it was totally hilarious. There's there's that the space cat image is everywhere on your Twitter app right now. Everywhere. I think it's cool how people creatively put their own spin on it too. [00:13:29] Yeah, change the colors or excuse me, change or the logo or whatever it might be. I think that's pretty awesome. Yeah, like Dan Darkpill kind of reversed it so that's got that like purple kind of reversed image photo effect going on, and yeah, it's pretty cool. But I think it speaks to sort of interesting thing in the space, and that is the incentives are to scam, right? [00:13:56] Like Bitcoin's here, it's good enough, it's growing, it's got the network effect, it's gonna be really hard to unseat Bitcoin. And if you're not already in Bitcoin, it's hard to make money in Bitcoin land. There's not a lot of jobs there, there. There's still a lot of upside, but there's this temptation to create a new Bitcoin and cheat people out of their money, or whatever you want to call it. [00:14:18] And to me, that's just taking advantage of the information asymmetry there. There's all this energy, everyone's excited, but most people don't really understand what's going on. And it's not their fault. It's complicated, it's hard, it's new. We don't even know what money is as a culture. And so yeah, you have these guys who come in and they can just spout their marketing and just collect the lowest common denominator of intelligence in the space. [00:14:45] And where do you see those people go? They go to Ripple, they go to S Bitcoin SV, you know. There's no intelligent people backing either of those two projects. And yeah, you know, like pretty sad. There are a couple people on the back BSV that I was kind of surprised about that I thought were intelligent people and confused me for quite a while. [00:15:06] And like Daniel Krauwitz, for instance, who was a co-founder of the Satoshi Nok Moto Institute, wrote some great articles on that site that sort of were foundational for my understanding of Bitcoin. And now is backing Bitcoin SVE and these you know narcissists who are using this cryptocurrency and the name of and the Bitcoin name and this and the Satoshi name to make money off of people. [00:15:35] And it's just been it was really confusing for me for a while. I was like, why I thought for a long time, why the heck is this guy doing this? You know? For sure. And maybe when I said there's no smart people who back these, that's not true. But people have loose morals, or they have an ulterior motive, and or their incentives are to scam, like you just mentioned. [00:15:55] Yeah, and it's it's you know, it is so such a complicated thing that you can be pretty smart and still be confused about what's going on here for a long time. And I think all of us are yeah, I think all of us are still confused about certain things. It's just trying to get a general feeling about what what's happening and where things are going is kind of the best you can do. [00:16:16] I like the analogy of climbing a mountain where you're climbing a mountain and you think you're coming up to the peak and you're so excited because you've been working so hard. And as soon as you get to the peak, you realize, oh, it keeps going. This isn't a false peak. So you get back on and you keep learning again and learning again, and then you get peak again, and you finally feel like you understand Bitcoin, and then you realize it's another false peak and you have to keep going. [00:16:41] Right. Yeah, no, it's it's absolutely true. And there's just there's just more and more. And yeah, and it's also that kind of that that process of learning where you start to dive deep into all the parts. You're like, okay, you kind of classify things and you start to sort of separate out the components, and you have this sort of picture of all right, here's all these sort of high level components of this system and idea. [00:17:09] And then you start diving deep on each of those, you know, and you really just start you just get into the weeds, and the part where you can like really start to understand something is where you assimilate and synthesize kind of all of that stuff from from diving deep into the weeds of all of the parts, and then it comes together in kind of this you know, beautiful single tweet. [00:17:31] But it's not, it's not like you can really do that with Bitcoin. You can do that in a lot of ways with Bitcoin. And I think you've done it well with mycelium and mushrooms, and we're definitely gonna get into that. Before we do though, I want to get into this piece you published in late January, which I think is kind of related to this you know BSV, CSW hodlanaut battle that's going on right now. [00:17:59] And it's it's it's titled Bitcoin Culture Wars. So can you can we kind of walk through that piece and talk about how the idea of Bitcoin culture wars, you know the FUD that's used to sort of promote the idea of forks and why someone might you know invest in them, and then what might be the benefits of the culture wars that are going on in Bitcoin. [00:18:25] Yeah, yeah, definitely. What's funny, I'll just make a meta comment about writing is you know, this stuff's so complicated. And I when I when I write something, it's usually because I need to either force myself to learn it or I actually think I have something unique to say. I go in the lab, do a bunch of research, put it out there. [00:18:45] And then what's funny is I sort of stop thinking about ideas once I go out there. So bringing up old articles sometimes I have to go back and read and be like, oh, that was a really good idea because I don't actually retain everything. And so I'll I'll try to break this down and maybe you can help me where you see fit. But the culture war thing, it it's it's kind of just a commentary on the social layer of what we're seeing here. [00:19:08] And you know, I think I think I wrote that in response to a really hostile time in crypto Twitter or Bitcoin Twitter. You know, if I published in January, we had the what we assumed to be the low in December. And so the peak low, people were really, really petty fighting online constantly. And a lot of people point to Bitcoin as a toxic community where people are too hostile. [00:19:33] And I think it's unfair to say that unless you've been in the space for a really long time, because each wave, people come in, they bring up new scams. And the Bitcoiners who have been here for a long time are probably really sick of all these scams. And so they come off vigilant. Sometimes they might come off a little bit too vigilant. [00:19:53] And you could say that could be an autoimmune response to attacking their own, like when everyone was attacking Peter McCormack. I felt that was misguided. Yeah, right. But it was too much, maybe way too much. Directionally true, right? We need to protect and we need to hold the values of Bitcoin very tight and secure, especially in the beginning. [00:20:15] I still feel like you know, it there's so many competing forces that we do need to keep the essence of Bitcoin pure and prevent people from going to the to the wrong side or whatever we want to call it. And so, yeah, it's a commentary on the social layer. And I think what's interesting in terms of like a marketing standpoint is the culture wars actually help Bitcoin market as well because there's all these competing narratives. [00:20:43] Is Bitcoin pride predominantly a store value, or is it digital cash, or is it this or that? And when you have these culture wars, people fighting over ideas and standing up for their points, and it's it's a public debate on Twitter, so you can kind of learn from different perspectives. What you do is you sort of have a colosseum of ideas. [00:21:05] The bad ones get eliminated, and the ones that stick, they persist and they propagate throughout the ecosystem. And so we sort of converge on the most potent narrative. And ideally, the most potent narrative helps with messaging when we spread this message outside of our little ecosystem. [00:21:23] And so if we're all echoing the same message, like Bitcoin is a store of value or a hedge against the macro climate, or it's free speech money, or whatever it is, that really helps acquire new customers that say well lowers the to use a software term, it lowers the CAC, the customer acquisition cost of new users in Bitcoin. [00:21:43] And so I think it's a fundamentally an immune system, and it has benefits for acquiring new Bitcoiners. Yeah, and the idea that and I when I first came in, I definitely saw some older Bitcoiners, longtime Bitcoiners, be pretty like rude, I guess, you know, or really abrupt, or like lack of having a major lack of patience for people asking new questions, you know, noobs asking questions. [00:22:11] And there were lots of noobs coming in in 2017 as the price was going up, and that's gonna happen again at some point. And there's just so much going on. You're trying to find some signal and like ask people questions, ask questions from the people who you think are sending out some you know trustworthy and quality thinking and signal. [00:22:29] I it pushed me, you know, kind of like repelled me a little bit too. I was like, that's you know, that's not that's not great. That gives me kind of this bad feeling. It should be more understanding and patient inclusive. A couple years later, you know, there's this actually I just tweeted about this not too long ago. [00:22:49] Let's see if I can find it. Yeah, so Vijay Boyapati, who wrote the bullish case for Bitcoin, I think, right? Yeah. Yeah, big fan. Yeah, big fan. Has a solid understanding of Bitcoin, has put a lot of time into understanding it. And you know, there's a ripple XRP person that pops into some thread and said says, like, you know, ripple costs a penny, ripple transactions cost a penny and takes three seconds comparing to you know Bitcoin's one to three hours or whatever. [00:23:20] And he just goes, goodbye, shitcoiner, blocked, gone, right? And so I wrote, like, you know, I saw that, and I was just like, yeah, that's what you do. The to a noob, like kind of lacking in that critical information and context, and you're kind of susceptible to the FUD, you don't have that conviction yet. That can come off as extreme as an overreaction or as toxic. [00:23:42] But after you've been around for a while, you've done your reading, you've done your listening, you're on your learning, you get this as sort of a look, I am past this point, and I just can't spare the time anymore to have this conversation over and over again. It's on the web. Go, you know, read about it and figure it out, but I can't handle this anymore. And even Satoshi did that. [00:24:01] I think it was Stephen, it was to Mike Hearn, right? I think that's right, yeah. I think it is, I think it was Mike Hearn. He said, Satoshi said to him, you know, if you don't understand it, I don't have time to explain it to you, you know. And so it's it's that idea that there is information out there, enough information out there for you to arrive at a better understanding than Ripple is is the new Bitcoin. [00:24:27] And I just don't have time anymore to devote to teaching someone at that's at your stage of understanding because there's a there's so much at stake here and there's a lot to do, you know. Definitely. I think that brings up interesting question or dilemma that I have. And you know, I'm sort of a natural evangelist marketer. [00:24:47] I go seek out weird new things and I pull the cultural artifacts I find interesting and I want to tell people about them. That's just sort of how I am. But with Bitcoin, I always come back to the question of does Bitcoin need us, right? Like we have we're naturally incentivized as soon as you own any amount of Bitcoin, you're incentivized to tell other people to use it. [00:25:06] So that's that's useful. And I wonder like, is it our job or a responsibility to recruit new people, or is Bitcoin inevitable? Like if we remove all the people individually, does Bitcoin care? And I think not, but I still feel compelled to explain it to new people or use analogies to cross the divide or whatever it might be. [00:25:30] And I'm just sort of curious about that dilemma. I'm not sure how you approach that. Yeah, that is that's definitely interesting. I don't know, I don't think Bitcoin needs us. And that's why, and I've had this conversation with some with some other Bitcoiners and been thinking about it recently, ever since Hasu published his piece about Bitcoin being a social contract, which I know you've read in reference, and kind of comparing it to the idea of a social contract. [00:25:57] And so I had a conversation with Tommy who's co-host of this podcast, and we started it together to as a kind of a forcing function for us to learn more about Bitcoin, and I've since branched out into the interview episodes. I'm still gonna be doing episodes with Tommy once a month. We're gonna start doing monthly episodes and kind of kind of news review type episodes once a month. [00:26:17] And the last episode we did was about this idea, about this kind of social layer, social contract idea. And Ansel Lindner, who's been around Bitcoin for a long time, and I interviewed as well earlier, a few, like six weeks ago or something, and has the Bitcoin and Markets podcast, which is a great Bitcoin podcast, came back and said, you know, this is this is not a great analogy. [00:26:44] It's not a social contract. That's that's what governments are, you know, or the ideas like laws and governments, constitutions and stuff. Those are social contracts. Bitcoin is a market, it's a pure market, and there's there are social aspects to markets, but there are not social contracts. There are there are laws of marketplaces. And that the basic law is, you know, that they are driven by human self-interest. [00:27:09] And I think Bitcoin is the same, like like you're mentioning here. So like the social interaction that Bitcoin is generating is driven at its core by, like you said, us being incentivized because we're holding, we're holding the asset, we're holding Bitcoin as this new money, and we hope it becomes this new money. [00:27:27] And if it does, we're all gonna be rewarded for it. And that's the that's the idea, the idea behind HODL. And that's kind of the ultimate motivation. And then there are, I think, our other motivations that we have sort of like higher on the on Maslow's hierarchy for us, like we think Bitcoin will create a better human society, right? [00:27:50] Which is less self-interested, sort of in its effect, but is still in it at its root, something that will benefit you know, us as an me as an individual, to have a more sane society that you know rewards you know merit and creation, like meritable creations so yeah I've sort of come along like kind of back around is I was drawn to this idea of this Bitcoin social layer and governance layer being like a social contract but I've kind of come out to this point where it's it's [00:28:28] Really just it's market forces in the end that create all of these a line incentives to create all of this you know stuff that's happening around it that looks it's happening it's a social thing it's it it's happening on a social layer for sure but it's not driven by our desire to be social I guess. [00:28:46] That makes sense. And I'm I'm sympathetic to the fact that the social layer could be just considered a social market. I think the analogy that Hasu uses is useful in in terms of differentiating between code base and what is Bitcoin. [00:29:05] Let's just call Bitcoin a market. I think that's reasonable. But then you also have this code and if someone attacked the code and broke the code, that doesn't necessarily mean Bitcoin broke, right? The market will say is still thriving and the market would fork and continue. [00:29:23] And so that's true. That's true. So I guess that's that's where I would maybe push back on the market side or maybe there's no pushback. It's just you know different words here. Yeah I think it comes down to semantics because when we kind of got down to it's just basically like yeah there's definitely this social layer, right? There's social activity and interaction that's happening that that helps us arrive at that shelling point. [00:29:47] And then we ex we express that shilling point in code. And just yeah, do you want to call that like a social contract or a social layer or a market? It is is I think we're all pretty close actually in in describing it's a semantic thing, probably. I agree. But I do like the market analogy because I think that's sort of Bitcoin's essence is a free market, and you participate as you wish, and everyone participates based on their own self-interest, and together emerges an order out of nothing. [00:30:20] And yeah, that's mind blowing and a lot of analogies with biology there. Yeah, that stuff's fascinating to me. Yeah, and it's the idea of market chosen money, which I got from the Bitcoin standard and Safety Namus and Austrian economics, is I think maybe even more accurate to than the idea of a social contract to apply because we are all in this giant global market, all connected by the internet now. [00:30:49] And it makes sense that you know, now that we have solved this these math problems that were, you know, that allow us to have digital scarcity and some privacy and some security for a digitally native money, you know, we're all gonna sort of arrive at that as the market chosen money for the internet. [00:31:08] And it just sort of makes sense when you think about it that way. And that's how the shilling point is that's the motivation for us, the incentive for us to all arrive at a certain shilling point around Bitcoin is that it's just better money for this you know, internet global marketplace that we have. I put out a tweet recently. [00:31:28] I'm trying to force myself to learn more about Austrian economics. I was a default Keynesian, which I think might have been your term. And I love that. Yeah, default Keynesian. We're all default, most of us are default Keynesians. For sure. And you know, I obviously Twitter's great, but the Twitter sphere, the Austrian sphere went nuts for that one. [00:31:49] And so I have a huge list of resources that are so far incredible. I can't wait to keep going down that that path. Yeah I've been slowly going down it as well and been reading well I'm reading the sovereign individual right now. But I'm also reading Holz I think it's Holzman's theory of money and credit. [00:32:11] Is that Holzman? I'm getting my authors confused. But I'm reading the theory of money and credit might be Mises. I think that's Mises actually yeah so I'm reading Mises right now. And then I'm also reading the Holzman book from 2008 and the title's escaping me right now. Oh yeah yeah I'm halfway through that right now I think it's the ethics of money production yes the ethic yes exactly yeah so I'm about probably a quarter of the way through that one and it's really good. [00:32:35] I agree he's a really good writer too. He is and I appreciate that there's yeah it's fun to find deep thinkers who are great communicators like those those guys are our people are pretty special makes a big difference because I've looked at some other Austrian economics papers or something that are older and they are dense they're really hard to get through sometimes yeah it makes a big difference in the memeability of your idea you know makes a difference and I guess it probably does even more so now and in the world that we live in and the kind of the communications [00:33:14] That we use since we're you know, less the I the spreading of ideas are is are less dependent on sort of long, thoughtful works like books and more dependent on tweets these days. Sadly. I try to force myself to do more long form content. It's it's hard to get away from Twitter sometimes, but let's be honest. [00:33:35] The real education where you really internalize something is not on Twitter. Yeah, it's it's true. It's true. I think that's where you sort of get the hook, you get hooked into certain ideas, and then to enough to the point where you're you want to understand something, and then you can dive into the source material, which is inevitably longer than a tweet thread. [00:33:56] Exactly right. Let's talk quickly about before we switch off this idea of culture wars and Bitcoin culture wars and the social layer and stuff. Let's talk about a couple potential kind of upcoming issues that some culture battles might develop around. [00:34:14] So you identified one as the fungibility fungibility versus verifiable supply issue. And then we could also talk a bit about the transition from a block subsidy issue, which I think are both potential battling spots over the next you know few years for Bitcoin. [00:34:35] You have any thoughts about either or both of those? Yeah, yeah, I think I think you nailed it. I think those are the two upcoming culture wars that matter. And I luckily I think the fungibility versus verifiable supply, I think that's generally agreed upon now. I think there's still a contingency of people who want confidential transactions on the base layer, but I would I would have to assume, at least based on my assessment of the market, is that most people agree that we should not make the base layer private. [00:35:07] And you know, just to prevent any unnecessary bugs that might inflate the supply, similar to what we saw with Zcash. And so I think that I think the consensus is that we should push privacy, fungibility onto second layers. And I tend to agree with that method. [00:35:26] And I think when we look at things like Schnorr coming up, that's gonna add a tremendous amount of privacy that you know that that sort of accomplishes good enough privacy where I don't think we need to worry about the future fungibility of Bitcoin. I still don't know whether or not the Coinbases or the archetypal coin bases of the world will try to attack tainted bitcoins. [00:35:53] I'm not really sure. But I think I think it was actually your podcast with Matt Odell when you guys were talking about having Wasabi wallet automatically shuffling coins in the background. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, that was a really, really interesting to me. And you can sort of, if you take that analogy where everyone's wallet is constantly shuffling coins, you sort of taint everything. [00:36:17] And if you do that, it it creates a natural pressure on block space, which is the other concern is what do we do when we run out of block subsidy? And so I think privacy pushing the demand for block space is a really compelling idea. And yeah, I'm I'm fired up about that. [00:36:37] I was sort of concerned with fungibility, but you know, that that kind of stuff makes me optimistic. Yeah, that that is definitely really interesting. Yeah, and I think I agree that the idea, or like if you know, no inflation is one of the kind of central rules that we're we're all gathering around, says one of the shilling points for for Bitcoin, then we've got to be able to verify the supply. [00:37:04] Otherwise, we put that rule of Bitcoin at risk. And if that happens, then you know you could really split the community the network and it could be it could be bad. So yeah, it seems to me that we've gotta find other ways to do privacy besides having absolute, you know, opaque and absolutely opaque blockchain. [00:37:27] Definitely. And Lightning Network will help a lot. And you know, more privacy focused wasabi focus like wasabi-like tools, coin joins, etc. And then Schnorr, right, where you can put all that multi-party computation off-chain, and it you can't tell if a transaction is opening a channel or it's a multi-sig or it's a coin join, right? [00:37:52] They all look exactly the same to the analytics companies. That's really compelling. Yeah, that's really big. So the analytics companies have been using the signature data as one of their main inputs to try to figure out what's going on on the blockchain. And Schnorr, yeah, basically makes like all signatures, no matter how complex they are, look the same. [00:38:14] So yeah, that's that's pretty compelling. So I think between Schnorr and Lightning Network and Coinjoin, we have a pretty good sort of multi-prong approach to privacy without having to compromise you know the verifiability of the of the supply. [00:38:36] So maybe that one won't be such a big culture war. Yeah, that seems more. Oh, go ahead. No, sorry, go ahead. Go ahead. Oh, I was just gonna say, I think more I think that one's more or less trending, right? We're we're sort of all in agreement on what needs to get done. As long as we can do the things we see ahead of us, I think we'll be okay. [00:38:56] Yeah, I think what most people are hostile about right now, and it sort of seems like a lot of us is coming from the Ethereum community, like, hey, take the heat off of us. You guys have problems too, you know. That's sort of how it felt a while back there. But is looking at the future transition between block subsidies making up the majority of the security spend transitioning to fees. [00:39:19] I think that's I don't think we're anywhere near need we don't really need to be concerned with that today. We're nowhere near that stage. But I think we should talk about it. And I don't like it when people shut down ideas on Twitter. And I think people need to be able to freely debate these ideas on Twitter. [00:39:40] And some people are kind of like, hey, that's blasphemy. You can't even say the words, otherwise you're a trader. And I think some of that goes a little bit too far. And yeah, we need to get the ideas out there. If you're concerned trolling, that's one thing, but if you're debating in good faith, the more the merrier. Yeah, and like the block subsidy thing is like basically, you know, I've heard people, and I don't understand this idea completely yet, but like JP who goes by at JP Thor on Twitter. [00:40:12] He's I'm actually gonna have him on the show in a few weeks. And he he wrote the recent medium piece that introduced the idea of a volume-weighted market cap. So it's like an improvement to the way to measure the dominance, the Bitcoin dominance, instead of just the basic market cap. [00:40:32] And he says that the fee market, like that the subsidy has nothing to do with security. Like the subsidy is not for security, it's just for coin distribution. And that the fee market is what was intended to provide the security of the network. And that there's just like basically, I guess, as a side effect, the subsidy can you know provide security for the early security for the network. [00:40:58] But all along, the idea for ongoing security into the future was on the idea of the transaction fees. And so it's like always sort of been like this. And yes, we should like have the understanding that we always we need to develop a fee market. With that's always been the case, you know. It's not like we are sort of just realizing this. [00:41:18] True, true. I would say the there's this other competing narrative that's mostly dead now, but the narrative of Bitcoin is a better PayPal, fast, cheap internet instant payments, sort of the fractured off Bitcoin Cash kind of congregation. That narrative is is kind of the only contingent that's against fees and new people who don't really understand it yet. [00:41:41] But I agree. The base layer of Bitcoin is a container ship. And each transaction, each block space transaction needs to be an aggregate of multiple transactions or very, very, very large transactions that you're willing to pay for the security guarantee. Yeah, absolutely. [00:42:00] Yeah, it's the base layer is more competing with central banking and Swift, kind of in like large settlements between maybe nation states, large corporations, that kind of level of settlement, or a large aggregation of retail transactions. And then that's why we need another re yet another reason why we need something like the lightning network on a second layer to provide the transaction capacity that we'll need to actually use this as a payment network. [00:42:27] So yeah, it all makes sense. Yeah, so maybe I guess maybe we're a little bit more. I mean, you and I, I guess are more into then maybe these things aren't gonna be that big of a deal in terms of like a creating contentious forks and things like that. [00:42:49] That that'd probably be a good thing. Yeah, I really hope we don't get to a point where you know, I mean, there's theoretically a scenario where the block subsidy runs out and the Bitcoin usage has not matured enough to warrant a high security spend in terms of not a lot of fees. [00:43:09] But I tend to agree with Pierre, Richard on this one is it's not necessarily a lower security, it just means your time to settlement is greater. So instead of six confirmations, maybe you wait 50, maybe you wait a hundred. And that's not necessarily a problem, right? [00:43:28] Transactionally you'll be on Lightning Network anyways, so you just have to plan ahead a little bit more on the base layer. And I think that pretty much counteracts the issue. Yeah, so if you're on the lightning network, for instance, you can just you can afford to wait you know two, three, four times as long for your channel to close because you're still it's not like you're unable to transact at all during that time. [00:43:52] You've got the lightning network. Exactly right. And if not, we'll we're gonna see a whole bunch of people and the Bitcoin network will be kind of chaotic for a period of time and people will learn. And the next round when fee pressure increases, there's gonna be a bunch of more smart consumers. Which I think miners can set fees too, right? [00:44:12] They can set a you can a miner can set like a minimum transaction fee essentially. So if they if a miner discovers a block, they're deciding which transactions from the mempool to include in that block. It is within the miners like ability and I guess right for lack of a better word, to only accept transactions with a certain fee level in for that block. [00:44:38] So I think one thing that miners can do is be like, hey, like we want to secure this, you know, payment network for you, and I know it's valuable for you, so we're just gonna start saying like we need this much money. And miners can come in and undercut them, but you know, there's this this could be this kind of this sort of level of I guess you know, cooperation between miners to set fees that are you know adequate for them to sustain a certain level of security. [00:45:05] And I'm sure there'll be like a shelling point around you know what that level of security is, and I think it's already sort of like six confirmations, we seem to all sort of agree, or like one hour or so. It seems to be a reasonable level. Right. I in terms of the miners creating a cartel price floor for fees. [00:45:24] I don't know if that would actually occur because there's always gonna be a miner who's incentivized to undercut them and take the blocks. And so there will be I don't know. That's true. But you know, it will take a lot of m money to have enough hash power for that miner to you know be able to re like regularly compete for blocks, you know. [00:45:46] That's true. So so there could be some level that would work to sort of drive fees up. I think that there's there's pressure the other way as well, like you said. So there might be some sort of way for miners to sort of like force fees up a little bit, just like in the cases where like you know we aren't able to afford to maintain this level of security without you know these this price level or this fee level. [00:46:13] And it seems like the market would be like, okay, that seems reasonable, you know, and just sort of like start to converge on a level a fee level that is you know we all agree on is is like reasonable, reasonable level of security. Yeah, that could happen. I could also see the mining industry just continue to be ruthless, sort of a survival of the fittest, and anyone who doesn't have near-free electricity costs are just forced out of the market. [00:46:42] Oh, yeah, absolutely, me too. It'll be it's just gonna be fascinating to see how that how that all plays out. Okay, I am ready to dive into the magical multiverse of mushrooms and mycelium. And I'd want to start with this idea that you had at the top of the first piece in the series, which is the idea of polymathic responsibility. [00:47:08] And I think this is a really cool idea, and I Googled it, and it looks like you've coined this term. Is this something you came up with? I definitely didn't come up with the term polymath, but polymathic responsibility, I guess I just made that up. I don't know if anyone else has said it before. Yeah, it looks like it. [00:47:26] That's cool. All right, so can you describe this idea? I think it's really interesting. Yeah, yeah, sure. So the concept is essentially that every person, whether we think about it or whether we believe it or not, we each have a unique perspective. And that's simply because we've had our own life. We are we're our own observer, we've had our own responsibilities, and the sum total of our life experience is unique, right? [00:47:50] There's some people who are more unique and less unique, but we all have a unique thing there. And so it was sort of a call to arms saying that okay, we have all these unique people that are surrounding the Bitcoin ecosystem. What I'm trying to call to action, what do you know outside of this ecosystem that may or may not overlap even in a small way with Bitcoin? [00:48:12] And do your best to combine those two and explain it in a new way. And you know that that sort of came from the idea that I have a fair amount of knowledge about the fungi kingdom, although I'm by no means an expert, but relative to Bitcoin land, I am an expert. And so, you know, I saw some parallels, I dove in the lab, researched it and put it together, and people found some interesting analogies there. [00:48:36] And so if everyone, or not everyone, if a larger percentage of people spit out their overlap, then we would have a whole bunch of new content and we would start to understand Bitcoin more as a whole. I think that's really cool. And especially because Bitcoin will it like it already is and it will in the future just continue to touch more and more aspects of human society as it becomes sort of this fun this this sound money foundation for our socioeconomic operating system. [00:49:08] And I think that that that approach that kind of call to arms will yield a lot of like understanding of what Bitcoin is and the and like you know, healthy adoption of Bitcoin as we're moving forward over the next few decades and kind of transition away from this fiat-based system to a Bitcoin-based system. [00:49:28] I think it's gonna be, I think it's an important idea. And just a quick shout out to another podcast I listened to listen to called Bitcoin and that has sort of this same idea of polymathic responsibility. He is exploring the intersections of Bitcoin and several other you know, things that he's really into, including like permaculture and other ideas. [00:49:49] And so he talks a lot about just what's going on in Bitcoin, but then sort of spends a good section of the show just taking this kind of understanding of what's happening in Bitcoin and applying it, you know, analogizing it to stuff that he's interested in. It's a really underrated podcast, so check it out. Definitely. I've listened to a few shows. He knows a lot about various topics, so I agree. [00:50:09] That's a gold mine for new ideas. Yeah. All right, so we have this mycelium archetype, which I think to set the stage, you do it well with this quote from Paul Stamitz at the top of your piece. And I'll just read that to kind of set the stage. [00:50:28] So this is from Paul Stamet's false stamet's book. Is it staminates or stamets? Do you know? I think it's stamets. Stamets, all right. But I could be wrong about that. So this is from Paul Stamet's book. We'll go with that for now. Mycelium running, how mushrooms can help save the world. And he writes: I believe that mycelium is the neurological network of nature, interlacing mosaics of mycelium infused habitats with information-sharing membranes. [00:50:54] These membranes are aware, react to change, and collectively have the long-term health of the host environment in mind. The mycelium stays in constant molecular communication with its environment, devising diverse enzymatic and chemical responses to complex challenges. So you chose, I mean, you saw the archetype of mycelium and Bitcoin really working together because they're both they're both archetypes of decentralization. [00:51:24] Can you take us through your mycelium Bitcoin analogy and I'll jump in with questions as I have them? Yeah, yeah, definitely. That's a great quote to start. And if anyone's curious about mushrooms, Paul Stamitz is the guy. He's got a great TED Talk. You can't miss it. That's a great starter. Called Six Ways Mushrooms Can Save the World. [00:51:43] I can second that. The TED talk is amazing. So, okay, looking at mycelium, first, just to give a quick primer. In the fungi kingdom, which is one of the seven kingdoms in biology, whatever it is, there's plants, there's animals, there's fungi, etc. So fungi are a separate kingdom, they're not a plant. [00:52:03] And they're more closely related to humans than they are with plants. We both inhale oxygen, exhale carbon dioxide. Long time ago, we diverged evolutionarily different branches. They decided to have their stomach externally, and our stomachs are internally, and from there we diverged. And most people think of mushrooms as the animal that sort of encompasses fungi. [00:52:27] But in reality, the fungi is a predominantly in the mycelium form, which you can think of as an underground root structure that lives either underground or in wood. We're starting to find it in the bottom of the oceans as well. And so, pretty much mycelium's everywhere on our planet. And then the mushrooms that we think about, you go by at the grocery store or whatever, that's just the reproductive organ. [00:52:51] So that's like the apple on the tree. And that simply just pops up very quickly, releases spores, which are just seeds to reproduce, and then quickly dies. And so the real magic of the mushroom is the mycelium. And like the Paul Stamitz quote you mentioned, mycelium is a one-cell-walled root structure that lives underground. [00:53:11] It sends information bi-directionally, it sends resources bi-directionally, it consumes its environment, it uses chemistry as its language, it produces novel compounds when it needs to fight off competitors. And you know, it it's actually the most powerful chemist on our planet. [00:53:32] The majority of our medicine is inspired by mycelium. And we're actually really similar to mycelium in our biology. And so over time, all these people, all these people, all this biology attacking the mycelium underground. It's forced the mycelium to create compounds to protect itself. And so it has a very broad and expansive sort of immune system library of medicine for its own use. [00:53:59] And since we share so many similarities, the mushroom medicine that it uses for itself also works on humans, which going back to the supplements we talked about, that's why all the mushroom medicine is so good for us, because we share the biology. And so that's sort of the primer for mycelium. And you know, now we can sort of talk about what that means from an archetypal standpoint. [00:54:20] And you can think of mycelium as like the natural internet, right? It connects all the trees together, it sends information, it brokers resources. The entire forest is alive because of these connections with the internet, the natural internet. And it also creates an immune system for the forest. And we've all we've measured all this in science now. [00:54:41] You can go do some research if you find this interesting. And what you sort of have is this network archetype that we start to see appearing over and over again in the natural world. And so if you look at dark matter in the universe or neurons in our brain, or the internet or Bitcoin or other decentralized networks, they all form this same resilient network. [00:55:05] They all kind of look like they have the same topology, they're all anti-fragile, they're all hardened from hostility. And so when you look at it from that angle and you map Bitcoin to this really old archetype, it starts to become obvious that Bitcoin is inevitable, or some sort of network-based money is inevitable. [00:55:25] And so you know, once I sort of put that together, the whole world of Bitcoin opened up in my mind because there's this foundational layer that is very very real and persistent and very Lindy to use a term that Bitcoiners like. Yeah. [00:55:43] Lindy effects. The longer something's around, the longer it will be, basically. Right. There's another interesting thing in this this first article. [00:56:03] Are you there? [00:56:05] Yeah, I'm here. Are we cutting out? It went crazy. Yeah, I'm here. So what I was gonna say is there's another interesting thing I broke down in the first article, which is about proof of work and comparing that to how fungi breaks down things in its environment. So if you think about a forest, and periodically leaves fall and branches fall and animals die, etc. [00:56:29] So all this organic debris collects on the forest floor. But over time, this this debris does not build up. In fact, it disappears. And where does it go? So fungi actually, as soon as leaves hit the ground or sticks or whatever it might be, mycelium leaps out of the ground and starts breaking down this organic material immediately. [00:56:51] What do you what do you mean it leaps out of the ground? Like it literally comes up above ground to like grab leaves or something? Yes, little white tentacles, one cell wall. They they work together. And if you go flip over a stump or a log or a rock in the forest, you'll see these little white roots. And that's the mycelium. [00:57:10] And so Paul Stametz actually measured when you walk through a forest, there's mycelium all underneath you, and they can measure the mycelium responding to you walking. So anytime you walk, and let's say you step on a leaf or you break a stick, that opens up new surface area, which is a weak point for mycelium to get in there and start breaking down the woody the biological material. [00:57:34] And what it does is it takes these complex, more or less useless things like a broken stick on the ground, breaks it down into the base elements of carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, etc., and it uses that as currency. Some of it it consumes as food, and some of it it trades with other trees or other fungi or other plants. [00:57:55] And this is very similar to how proof of work can go into areas where energy is being produced, but it's dying on the vine. So this could be rural areas of geothermal where it's not anywhere near the demand. And essentially you're producing all this excess energy, but it's not reaching a consumer in time, so the energy is wasted. [00:58:17] However, if you plug in a Bitcoin miner in these rural areas or you capture the natural gas outflow, whatever it might be, you're converting a resource that's wasted into a tangible resource, which can be then exported. Right. Yeah. So in the same way, mycelium and Bitcoin's proof of work sort of serve the same function in their in their environment. [00:58:39] That's amazing. So, like in the energy industry, there's this sort of excess energy or these inefficiencies. And then the like Bitcoin mining can basically be seen as sort of this mycelium that's like, oh, look at this inefficiency. We see this sort of new weak point that we could you know attack. [00:58:58] And it's it's basically just like a way to be a use our energy production as as a species much more efficiently. Exactly right. And that's what mycelium's doing for nature. Just that if we if we didn't have mycelium, first of all, there'd be no other life on this planet, but if we didn't any other complex life, I should say, but if we didn't have forests filled with mycelium, we'd be buried in hundreds and hundreds of feet of sticks and branches to the point where the whole planet would be unusable to humans. [00:59:33] Yeah, so the all of this material that organisms are not using anymore, waste products of organisms, is being basically taken apart and converted into usable, a usable form, and then either used by the mycelium or and this is this is fascinating to me, traded with other organisms. [00:59:57] So can you give me an example of like a mycelium trading some form of like resource that it gathers from all of this detritus with another organism, like maybe a tree, I guess. Absolutely. I think the most salient point here is that if there was no mycelium, first of all, there'd be no forests, and trees could only survive to about 18 inches, maybe 24 inches tall, because trees do not have a way to acquire minerals. [01:00:30] And so all trees have roots underground, and those roots fuse in with mycelium, and the mycelium is decomposing rocks and bugs and whatever it finds underground, and it takes those minerals and sends them up through the roots where the tree accepts the mycelium connection. [01:00:51] They sort of create a base layer and lightning network connection, and they trade resources. So the tree receives minerals, which it needs to build its size to be rigid and tall to support its weight. And at the same time, the tree through photosynthesis produces its own food and it it sends sugars, which is food for the mushroom, down through those same roots in exchange for the minerals. [01:01:18] So the tree will actually expel sugars from its roots and then the mycelium will take that up. Exactly right. Yeah, the tree has a budget of resources to trade with its fungal allies. And another cool point here, which we've proven with with some scientific experiments recently, is that if you think about a forest and a dense forest, and on the forest floor, there are small baby oak trees. [01:01:45] And those baby oak trees receive no sunlight, which they need. And how does a baby oak tree with no sun grow? And the main reason is because the mycelium mediates a transfer, it sends resources from other trees and feeds it to this oak tree. [01:02:04] And what the mycelium is doing is it's creating a resiliency in the forest because it allows different organisms to specialize and it allows different organisms to support each other so the entire system is improved. And in part three, which we'll get to, Bitcoin does a similar thing. [01:02:23] I don't want to steal the thunder quite yet, but there's lots of examples of the forest. Yeah. That's I mean, that's just absolutely fascinating from a biological perspective. But I think it is it's amazing also how it maps to Bitcoin so far. [01:02:43] Now the mycelium is there's no central point of control, right? So that's why the decentralization of mycelium maps well to Bitcoin. There's this part of the TED talk where Paul Stamets shows mycelium forming, and there's like a I think it's an electrophotogram of mycelium forming. [01:03:08] And it's sort of it's a movie, it's animated, or it's like it's a bunch of fixtures put together over time, so it's a movie. And the mycelium will come down in like these these columns, like kind of grows out in these columns, parallel columns, and then this thinner like lace network forms between them. [01:03:26] And Paul Stamet says in his TED talk, he says, you know, take this archetype and you go way out, and this is kind of kind of like what you mentioned, right? Dark matter conforms the same mycelial archetype. He says, I believe matter begets life, life becomes single cells, single cells become strings, strings become chains, chains become networks. [01:03:47] And this is the paradigm that we see throughout the universe. And just the thought of strings becoming chains, and strings can be represented by bits of code, right? Little chunks of code, become chains, which is like a blockchain. So we, you know, Satoshi has invented and Bitcoin Core represents a bunch of code strings that have built this chain, this blockchain that we use as a ledger for the network, and then chains become networks, right? [01:04:17] And then to me, I just looks like screaming lightning network to me, right? So we have this base chain that has sprouted this network that is fundamentally different than the broadcast network of the base layer. It's this unicast network that allows routing from different points in different nodes all over all over the network, just like TCP IP. [01:04:39] And it's it's essentially this kind of more complex form of life, I guess, or a more complex organism that has sort of sprouted from this maybe like less complex foundational organism that's supporting it underneath. That's incredible. I've I've actually never I've heard that TED talk probably a dozen times, and I've never put it together quite like that. [01:05:02] But I think you're onto something there, right? The Bitcoin layer, the base layer is enough to be valuable and useful, but for it really to be this interconnected web that infiltrates all aspects of our our lives as humans, there does need to be a second layer or third layer on top. [01:05:23] And I think you're right, Lightning Network does represent that. It's amazing. Any anything else that we need to touch on mycelium before we go into mushrooms? Yeah, I would say one more thing that sort of hit home with a lot of people I've spoken to is this concept of horizontal gene transfer. [01:05:46] Yes, yeah. Traditionally, what you what you think about in genetics is parents have offspring and the parents transfer their genes vertically to their offspring. And there's this concept discovered in fungi where under certain stressful situations, fungi actually slurp up genetic information from their competitors across species lines. [01:06:10] Think two organisms living in the same environment, harsh conditions come, and before that mushroom dies, it steals genetic information from a competitor, which could be useful in surviving this tough time. Okay. And fungi does this. We've we've proven that. [01:06:28] And Bitcoin also does something similar. And what that is is it allows other organisms to do their thing. And when other chains create some new cool idea and it's useful, then theoretically, Bitcoin can borrow those concepts and either bolt them on as a side chain or somehow integrate them into the base layer. [01:06:51] And I think there's some controversy there because there hasn't been very many use cases where Bitcoin actually has done this. But I think over a long enough time frame, all of that is theoretically possible. And I think it's a useful framework to look at competition with other altcoins. Yeah, very cool. [01:07:09] So yeah, the idea that I sort of developed before I read, and I think this is a better analogy, but the analogy that I was using in my head before was that like Bitcoin is this is sort of the trunk of a tree, you know, the longest chain and the shelling point is this is this trunk. And the branches that come off of this trunk are not just like the forks of Bitcoin itself, but also the altcoins that may not share any code or chain history with Bitcoin. [01:07:37] But they're you know born because of the ideas that Bitcoin brought into the world, they're possible because of that. So all these branches of altcoins and forks sort of come out and test different ideas, maybe, or explore you know different like changes that we could make to the to the trunk, and then eventually, sort of after all this exploration is done, it's sort of the tree sort of like just sucks back in, and everything that was good has been absorbed in the trunk, and then all of that kind of the branches sort of just go away, so it's sort of this like a like a tree sort of reflected on itself from the top, you know, and it just kind of sucks back into the single [01:08:16] You know, I guess money or system that is is left, and that's where the idea of like I guess Bitcoin maximalism sort of comes from is that the eventually after sort of this kind of Cambrian explosion of ideas that were fueled by the invention of Bitcoin, can go and explore all these different topics and safely explore it without kind of compromising the base chain, and then we can take all the good stuff in and eventually, you know, who knows how long that process will take, but decades later, sort of arrive back so that 99 [01:08:54] Or 100%, effectively 100% of the value in the economy is represented by Bitcoin. Love that analogy. Yeah, it's biological analogies are really useful for Bitcoin. I feel like we just kind of naturally like start to think about them, but it's I think it's a it's I guess a consequence of just observing you know archetypes that work, smart people observing archetypes that work and replicating them. [01:09:28] Absolutely. We are of nature, we are nature, and to think otherwise is just silly. Yeah. All right, so that's mycelium. And part two, which is up on on Medium as well and available now, is about mushrooms, Bitcoin as a social creature. [01:09:47] So can we dive into into this one? You want to lead the way on this one? Yeah, for sure. So this is kind of looking at Bitcoin as a social organism, kind of looking at the people that are involved, looking at cultural norms, looking at how people have religious tendencies in Bitcoin, how people compete, how people get really passionate ideologically about it. [01:10:11] That's kind of the point of that article. If you're interested in those types of things, I think you'll like this one. And I also did a deep dive into ethnomycology, which is essentially the study of humans over time and how they related to fungi. And so this is things like many of our religions are potentially based on mushrooms. [01:10:30] Our oldest ancestors that we found their bodies, they all carried mushrooms with them. They were buried with mushrooms. So there's always been a reverence in throughout our human life with these mushrooms. And so I think that stuff's fascinating. And I'll I'll point to one quick analogy here. [01:10:51] And I wrote this one also kind of in the depths of the bear market. But if you look at Bitcoin's hype cycles, they actually parallel the reproduction cycle of fungi as well. And first I'll explain the mycelium, the mushroom reproduction cycle, and then I'll do Bitcoin. [01:11:09] So, in in the mushroom life, it's almost all spent underground. Mycelium is just you know, doing its thing, humans walk by, you wouldn't know anything of it. But then each mushroom has their own sort of timing code when when conditions are right. So we're coming up on morel season in the spring, and the mycelium is waiting for humidity, temperature, the amount of sunlight it receives each day, all these environmental factors. [01:11:38] So it's just it's boring, and then all of a sudden the timing's right, and the mushroom converts a ton of its energy into reproduction, and out of nowhere, mushrooms pop up like crazy. And sometimes they grow like yeah, so fast. And it's incredible. And then as soon as they mature, they release their spores, which are a little tiny seeds lighter than air, and they flutter about and land wherever they land, and some of them reproduce, most of them die. [01:12:07] And those little mushroom colonies form, and you know, hopefully some of them will reproduce. And now, if we compare this to Bitcoin's hype cycle, it's almost perfect analogy here. To the casual observer, as in right now, most of Bitcoin's life's pretty boring. We hear we hear our normal friends say, Isn't Bitcoin dead? [01:12:27] Right. Nonsense. And you know, from their perspective, it's true, right? The buzz is gone and months go by, years go by with relatively little action. And then when the conditions are just right, Bitcoin explodes into growth, grows massively in size, and sort of hijacks the consciousness of all the observers, price goes crazy, everyone's talking about it, and you get CNBC telling people how to buy ripple at three dollars. [01:12:55] And pretty soon it crashes, it dies, and it goes back into the boring time again. And yeah, but what's interesting about that is a certain percentage of those new people who get drawn in during the hype cycle, they they stick around. And those are kind of like the spores that form new colonies. [01:13:16] And during the bear market, those little colonies grow into bigger mycelium colonies, and they they build new businesses, they create new podcasts, they help build and foster this ecosystem. And then all of a sudden, the next time a hype cycle comes, the ecosystem is more mature, more resilient, et cetera. [01:13:35] And you know, there's a larger base of hodlers of last resort, which kind of have a steady. I like the I like the analogy of tithing. You know, stacking sats every Saturday. We're all sort of tithing the Bitcoin monster. And pretty soon the natural demand for Bitcoin on a weekly basis is going to exceed the supply that's being pumped out from the subsidy. [01:13:59] And when that happens, I don't know, that that hype cycle is going to be bonkers. Yeah. Yeah. It's amazing. So those the tops, the tops of those hype cycles are so brief, just like the existence of the mushroom. So it's it's a kind of a perfect analogy because that I think in 2017, you know, basically like 70, you know, 70 plus percent or at least a large, I don't know the exact numbers right now, but the a large percentage of the gains happened over about a three-month period. [01:14:29] And then, you know, just as quickly within about three months, they were gone. It's, you know, and then we kind of lingered at 6,000 for a long time, but it only took us, you know, a three months or less to get all the way back down to 6,000 from the peak. So another aspect of this article that I find interesting is that mushrooms have inspired a sort of religious fervor throughout human history. [01:14:57] And the same is often observed about Bitcoin. Mostly that's like derisive or intend intended to be durisive and a critique of Bitcoin. But obviously there's the benefits to these sort of religious aspects that we have, the inspiration behind you know, Bitcoin, not just the incentive of hodlers, the financial incentive of hodlers to promote the network, but also that we have a lot of sort of beliefs in how Bitcoin could help society for the better. [01:15:34] And we like to share those ideas and you know, in in a process is not dissimilar to evangelizing, right? Yeah, exactly right. You don't you don't have to look very far to kind of feel that there's a little culty, cult-like tendency going on in Bitcoin land and the greater crypto space in general. [01:15:55] And you know, you could call that a bad thing because generally humans are we're we learned that cults are bad. And so when we feel like we're being sold something or we feel like we're in a culty-like environment, we're sort of allergic to that, and that's generally good. But in this situation, in order for Bitcoin to succeed, the people need to agree that it's money. [01:16:18] And in order for a new scarce commodity to be monetized, that is gonna take this core nucleus of people to bootstrap the network at least up until a certain point, sort of the event horizon, the point of no return. And I think that the fact that Bitcoin and other projects create a cult-like religious following is a very bullish sign. [01:16:45] And you know, people like David Girard try and use that as a negative thing, but that's insane. If if it gets people to divert their life and dedicate their life here, there's something there. You can disagree with it or whatever, but it definitely creates evangelists. And speaking from experience, I think it's the most addicting, interesting, has the most gravity of any space I've ever been around in. [01:17:12] And I tend to bop around into weird niches throughout my life. Yeah. And that's a phrase I've used a lot before is that Bitcoin's gravity is strong. And you know, it'll just slowly kind of suck you into its orbit until you just you know are crossing the event horizon and into the black hole of Bitcoin. [01:17:32] It's it's just it's done that to me as well. And I think, you know, as like the I that's kind of like the spores that live, right? The spores that sort of get captured by Bitcoin's gravity and then nourished into new colonies. It's it's it's insanely strong. [01:17:54] And it's because it's so fascinating and because it has so much potential, and you know, not just the like we've said several times in this discussion so far, not just the financial potential for us as individuals, but the potential for society, and to really just kind of fundamentally fix a lot of the problems that have resulted from you know, centralizing too much centralization, I guess, in the organization of society. [01:18:23] And I'm not gonna, you know, be this decentralist utopian and say like it's gonna fix all of our problems or anything. Humans are humans, and we're we're gonna have we're gonna have problems. But I think that the pendulum has swung too far toward, you know, centralization of power, and we need to have another, you know, disruption of that centralized power. [01:18:44] And we've had examples of that in you know, political history. Like the one I'm most familiar with is the US revolution revolution, which resulted in a more decentralized governance system than the one that you know the English colonists were rebelling against. [01:19:03] And I think Bitcoin can have a similar effect. I think you know, in the future we'll have a more decentralized form of government because of the what you know the incentives that Bitcoin is establishing. That's the new the changes. Yeah, definitely. That that's actually a good segue into part three of the series, if you want to go there. [01:19:24] Perfect. Let's go. And so I'll just give you a quick overview of what I'm trying to get across, and then we can dive into some of the interesting focal points there. But I'm essentially framing it up in in a sense where we're ending the we're ending one era and we're heading into the information age to use the sovereign individual as a framework. [01:19:44] So we're kind of going into this great unknown period where peak centralization, the fiat experiment, big governments, all these things, we're starting to see the cracks in these system. And central banks don't know what to do, their audit tools. I mean, the Japanese central government owns shockingly large amount of their business ecosystem, you know, there's all these crazy stuff going on. [01:20:10] And either it collapses and we just rebuild the same thing, or you know, we don't know what's gonna happen, or maybe Bitcoin is the antidote. And I'm framing Bitcoin as the antidote. And in in the Hayek's quote, Bitcoin is a sly roundabout way to introduce a new money. [01:20:30] And you know, that begs the question: okay. If Bitcoin's new money to come in and replace our central banking regime, won't these central banks and states and et cetera attack Bitcoin to prevent this from happening? And of course they will. Once Bitcoin is sufficiently competitive, they're going to put everything they have against it. [01:20:51] And I call that the great filter, which is a term used looking at civilizations. So at a certain point in a civilization's life cycle, they reach these very challenging points. And maybe that challenging point will be we invented nuclear weapons. [01:21:10] And if we survive 100 years after creating a nuclear weapon, that that would be a miracle potentially. And so we can look at these global killers as great filters, or maybe we can't harvest enough energy to get off our rock, and so we consume all the resources and humans are gone, something like that. [01:21:28] And so I propose that the great filter in the cryptocurrency space is being able to survive a state-level attack. Yes. And I would I would argue that most cryptocurrencies today are are unable to survive this. Actually, I would say everyone besides Bitcoin would be squashed very easily, and potentially even Bitcoin today. [01:21:49] But Bitcoin is being built to survive this great, this great attack here. And, you know, that's evidenced by the conservative approach to development. It's evidenced by things like routing around ISPs with mesh networks and satellites and ham radios. It's evidenced by the fungibility and the privacy stuff that Bitcoiners are so serious about and the self-sovereignty and all these different things. [01:22:15] So from day one, Bitcoin's built to be this adversarial environment to withstand that inevitable final boss. And I think that's a really important concept. We're not quite there yet. I think governments and banks still sort of think Bitcoin is this little thing that could never really attack them. [01:22:33] Right. And so yeah, I see Bitcoin as building this this is sort of a threat, right? We don't actually want to route around ISPs. We don't actually want to have to show the fangs of Bitcoin, but instead we want to demonstrate the fact that Bitcoin is so resilient that no matter what you do, you can't kill it. [01:22:53] And as soon as that perception is acknowledged by the powers, then we've won the game, right? And it's sort of like having a security system sign. You don't even need a security system. All you need is that little sign that says you have a security system, and then the burglar will look somewhere else. And so, you know, I'm gonna bring up this concept where Bitcoin is should have a sign that says honey badger lives here. [01:23:18] And you know, if you know what that means, that you know, then you think okay, James and Lopsen's side with a bunch of guns. I shouldn't rob this house. And so not that we could ever find Jameson's Jameson's house at this point. That's true. He's he's sufficiently Bitcoin. He took the pill. [01:23:37] Yeah, and then just to finish up this outline, I then go into sort of okay, if Bitcoin is going to compete against nation states and it can't be killed, what is the future look like where we sort of have a Bitcoin backbone financial system? That's sort of exploding Austrian economics. [01:23:55] That's why I put that tweet out recently because I have to check my assumptions and learn a little bit here. But that's looking at things like dampened the financial volatility of the business cycle. We can do things like proof of reserve to minimize fractional reserve banking. Theoretically, a sound money-backed banking system would prevent wars because wars are expensive. [01:24:17] And if every individual had to pay for the war or there was any transparency, let's say, in what the war in the Middle East costs, I'm pretty sure the average person wouldn't be willing to pay $5,000 a year to send teenagers to the Middle East or whatever the number is. And so yeah, looking at the benefits of that financial system shift, and then also looking at the second order effects of sound money. [01:24:43] So if we have this system, it is successful. Where does that get us? And that's sort of playing around with time preference and unleashing human potential because now our work is stored more effectively in sound money instead of eroded away. We can look at things like becoming a type one civilization, going to Mars, space money, all these different fun, wacky things. [01:25:07] Oh, that's so awesome. And that is that is like the question I usually like to end on is you know, 50 years from now, what does a Bitcoin future look like to you? And there it is, the Brandon Quittem's outline of a possible Bitcoin future. And we're gonna get a lot more detail in part three, it sounds like, which should be dropping sometime soonish, right? [01:25:29] So I hope I've been working on it every chance I get, but it is going slow. I have a tendency to become a little bit too ambitious, so it's like 30 pages right now of notes and this and that. I'm gonna try and cut it down to 3,000 words or less. I think I'm at sitting at 4,500 now. I would say within a month, hold me to it. [01:25:50] I appreciate all the notes from you guys saying, hey, when is part three coming? That is motivating to me. So I appreciate it. Awesome. It's gonna be really exciting. So I'm just gonna let that sit as a little preview, and we'll wait for all of the details on Brandon's thinking about and speculation about a possible Bitcoin future. [01:26:11] So let's drop one hint actually. Yeah, let's hear it. One more okay, because that's the outline. That's sort of that's not as interesting to me as these little nuggets. And I'm gonna try and get this one out. I've never said this on a podcast before, but so I'm gonna use an analogy with the honey bees. And if you paid attention at all in the last few years, you're noticing that the honey bee populations are declining. [01:26:34] Yes. And the main reason that this is a problem is because honey bees are pollinators, and pollinators are required for certain plants to produce their food. And so things like almonds and avocados and many other things would be completely gone if we don't have pollinators to do their provide their role, perform their role in the ecology. [01:26:56] And the main reason why the honey bees are dying is because of a parasite called varroa mites. They're these tiny little little bugs that live on the bees, and they cause all kinds of problems with the bees, the main one being deformed wing virus. And so essentially they just kill the bees and the colonies collapse, and you know, this is happening at staggering rates right now. [01:27:20] Okay, so this is I'm gonna pause you one second, but the I had read, I guess somewhere that one of the main causes of the bee colony collapse was some chemical that was used in in agriculture. So is it is that not true, or is it mostly this natural, this this virolamite? [01:27:41] Oh, that's definitely part of it as well. We don't actually know exactly what percentage comes from what or the other thing, but certainly both have play a role. I don't I don't know the ratio of what one's more important or anything like that. Gotcha. Okay, cool. But what I no, no, it's good to bring it up. But what I do know is that the varroa mites are a good analogy for our current monetary regime. [01:28:05] They take down the bees, they infiltrate the system, and when the bee goes, once a bee is infected, everywhere it flies to, it actually leaves varroomites there. So then unaffected bees who come to the same flower then get the same disease. So it spreads really rapidly. Okay. And so that's sort of the monetary regime we're living under. [01:28:24] This thing that makes our our wings not work, it spreads everywhere, our colonies collapse, everything's not going well. And what Paul Stametz found out is that you can feed these bees a fungal medicine. And the Paul Stametz actually observed the bees do this on their own in real life. [01:28:44] So these bees were going around and they were dancing in the water that had mycelium or had spores in it. And so the bees knew that fungi keeps their immune system high. So he observed this, then he created an antidote, which was a combination of Rishi and agaricon mushroom, and just put that in some sugar water and fed it to the bees. [01:29:06] And in the isolated trials so far, it's having massive effects. So essentially feeding the bees, this fungal medicine gets rid of the varroamites and saves the bees. And if you think about it on a small scale, just saving the bees is one thing, but it also provides food security, which saves our lives. [01:29:27] It provides job security for all the people working in this industry of food, which is a lot. And it also keeps our ecology going, right? We can't have our all of our ecosystems collapse because the pollinators are gone. And Bitcoin's the same way where if you have this sound money system, this fair money system, it's going to infiltrate the system and it's going to have all kinds of downstream effects. [01:29:53] And that's what I'm super excited to get into in the article. Awesome. I am super excited to read it for sure. And I know many of the Bitcoiners listening now will be waiting for it to drop as well. So thanks thanks for the little preview. And that's that's really exciting. [01:30:11] To explore the potential like downstream effects is something I've been thinking about quite a bit. And why I like to end the pod on that question like 50 50 years from now, what does Bitcoin future look like to you? The I think we have a lot of work to do, not just to educate people about what Bitcoin is and how it works and all that, but you know, I think maybe even more important is to sort of fight this idea of default Keynesianism, which we which you brought up earlier, that you know, we have this monoculture of economic thought that has spread around the world. [01:30:48] And Bitcoin is sort of this, as Hayek says, this kind of roundabout way to introduce a sound money and thus also introduce the idea of sound money. And there's a lot of education to be done about, you know, Bitcoin is so important because of the potential that it has to improve society, human society, in ways that we can't even imagine yet. [01:31:12] And yeah, I think that that's an important thing to explore a bit more and talk about more. Definitely. I think that to the average person who may be not familiar with Austrian economics, just the phrase sound money or hard money or whatever, that doesn't mean anything. [01:31:32] And I think we sort of saturated the people who currently are exposed to that concept. Like if you're a if you're an Austrian economist or you're interested, you already know about Bitcoin. So that meme is hit its its peak. And so I think it's time to, you know, going back to the polymathic responsibility. [01:31:51] What other what other angles can we use to help explain this to a broader audience? And yeah, I'm I'm hoping to do that with some of my writing. And it's so cool to see all the other content creators out there. Podcasters are springing up, producing great content, writers are popping up everywhere, and I can't keep up and I consume a lot of content. [01:32:13] Yeah, me too. And this is a great transition into the next and I guess last topic that we don't that I want to talk to you about, and that's the idea about of learning about Bitcoin. And you know, I've I've observed that you know, with every wave, and we've talked about this with the spore analogy, every wave there's this you know massive increase in attention to Bitcoin until it's you know, for a couple of months, sort of just you know, everywhere. [01:32:40] It's I think this this past cycle, you know, it reached obviously a new peak of just it was it was everywhere in the mainstream media and people were talking about everywhere. Everyone, all the Bitcoiners are getting texts like, hey, you know something about Bitcoin, right? I heard you mentioned Bitcoin before. Tell me about it. Where do I buy it? What is what's going on? What's Ripple? [01:32:58] What's Bcash? What's you know, all this stuff? You get all these questions, this massive amounts of attention. And from that massive amount of attention, we've got these new waves of content creators and educators that come through every cycle and build during the bear market and then prepare to sort of deliver these new messages that we've all sort of synthesized and derived from our learning over the past you know a couple of years. [01:33:25] And like it's I think the experience for noobs in this next cycle is going to be even better. It will still be very noisy and very confusing, and there'll be a lot of challenges to learning Bitcoin and coming away with a clear understanding. But I think this kind of foundation of what is the beginnings of a Bitcoin education industry, which I think will be massive over the next couple couple of decades as people realize you know the gravity of this thing that is being built and growing, you know, all the time before us, is [01:34:03] You know, i'm irresistible. So basically, there'll be this sort of point where a mass audience, kind of the vertical part of the technological you know, S curve, the adoption s curve. People are just like, oh, okay, I need to understand this. I've got to understand this right now. Like it's I can see this is the next thing, and there's this big change coming, and I need to figure out what's going on. [01:34:26] I that's the that's gonna be there's gonna be massive demand for reliable, clear Bitcoin education at some point in the coming decades. And I think that's kind of that the beginnings of that is really building now. So, how did you get your information? [01:34:44] What have you sort of learned or thought about in terms of improving the ways that Bitcoin education is transmitted to you know the people who will be coming in in the next cycle and the cycle after that? Yeah, yeah. I'm I'm super into this topic. I'm just a lifelong learner and I'm obsessed over this kind of stuff. [01:35:04] And so it's it's fun to play around with the this this topic. First, how did I find information? I mean, I started with Bitcoin is interesting in terms of okay, we have a non-state money, but then I was seduced into blockchain land and how this magical blockchain can do everything. [01:35:25] And I think a lot of people get stuck right there. And so if we're gonna point to a part of the education process that needs improvement, it's differentiating Bitcoin from the pack. And I think that's a really hard thing to do. Because the siren song of blockchain is so powerful. [01:35:44] And you know, another way to look at this is the blockchain siren song, which Ethereum does a good job of, it actually recruits a ton of new people into the industry because blockchain saves and solves everything. And then soon they realize, well, hopefully they realize that that's probably not true that a blockchain should be used for very specific things, maybe only one thing. [01:36:09] And, you know, so it it's kind of hard because we need to differentiate between Bitcoin and silly pipe dreams, but we also sort of want this pipe dream to draw people in. And so I'm conflicted there. But you know, I eventually I found myself to Twitter, and that's where I was exposed to better debates. [01:36:32] And so preventing people from getting stuck on Reddit or Facebook groups and getting them on Bitcoin Twitter as soon as possible, I think is probably the best place to learn. I'm hoping there'll be some YouTube Bitcoin content creators. Bitcoin content creators are agnostic to blockchain, and that's probably a function of them needing to make money. [01:36:54] And so it's true. I'm hoping there's a better education base specifically for Bitcoin, but it actually seems weak rel for newcomers relative to generic blockchain. Yeah, it definitely does. And you know, I've been doing a lot of thinking about this as well, and kind of working on the background to lay the foundations of you know a better more coherent approach to Bitcoin education, a trusted source to go to get that kind of foundational knowledge that hopefully could like really save people [01:37:32] A lot of time and energy and frustration. You know, all of us have to kind of like pick it, pick it all out ourselves and figure out who to trust and which you know pieces of information make sense logically and hear all sides of the debate. And I and I think that there's definitely something there, like it's that's important. [01:37:51] I think that that process was good for all of us Bitcoiners to go through and maybe even necessary at this point at the points in time in which we did it. But I think that there will be Bitcoin, there will be businesses that just provide a service of you know, providing basic and then you know increasingly complex education about Bitcoin and just Bitcoin. [01:38:18] And I think that that's gonna be a big industry in the coming decades for sure. Yeah, I could see that. And I think no matter what they're gonna pop up, I still have in the back of my mind though, and what that is is does Bitcoin scale that way? Like, can you reduce the onboarding time? Can you mass produce content which then onboards Bitcoiners faster? [01:38:42] And I'm not convinced one way or the other because there's so much here. And in order to really grasp big Bitcoin, you have to be motivated to suffer through an intense learning process. And so I wonder if Bitcoiners or people fall down the rabbit hole only when they're ready, right? [01:39:02] Like, yeah, totally. I don't know. Like, I'm trying to play that balance in my head, and I'm not really sure. But what it leads me to actually as sort of like a north star here is young people are gonna get this, and so starting earlier might be the most effective strategy. And the Bitcoin rabbi, check him out on Twitter, he just published a book. [01:39:25] It's maybe you've seen it, but it's aimed at it's a children's book, it's got pictures and it's short and easy to follow. And it and it kind of talks about how kids start using different types of money and then they eventually use Bitcoin, and you sort of learn different aspects of money and why Bitcoin's good. And I was fortunate enough to read it before it's published, and that's gonna be my new Christmas present for young people and also anyone who just doesn't understand money, which is a lot of people. [01:39:52] It's it's sort of a an adult message disguised in a children's book, and so that leads me to okay, let's get the young people involved. They're gonna understand digital money very quickly, and they're gonna understand things like free speech money, right? We can sort of have a targeted messaging for young people. And I'm I'm talking with some sort of the Bitcoin or whales here in Minneapolis who are going to fund some education programs locally where I'll speak at high schools, maybe colleges, and just do some basic introduction to money and why Bitcoin talk. [01:40:27] And you know, I'm not sure how effective that's going to be, but I kind of think starting younger is the most effective approach. Yeah, that's really interesting. I like that take a lot. And yeah, the kid like my children, thinking about my kids, you know, I have I have a seven and a half year old daughter, four-year-old son, and you know, I've talked with my daughter they're definitely curious about Bitcoin. [01:40:51] They know that I'm interested and I spend spend time doing the podcast and things like that, and they ask me about it. To them, it's just they I they've kind of taken my word for it that this we're just gonna have this kind of this new money, you know, in the future. And my daughter said to me the other day, I was paying with something with cash, and she was just like, it seems so silly to have money be paper, dad. [01:41:14] You know, it's amazing. It can get wet, you can tear it, like you could just drop it and get lost. She's like Bitcoin makes so much more sense. She was just like it seems so much better, just in general. And you know, just from the simple mind of a child, like it's just that's one of those big endorsements because it's just it's just makes sense in a world that has the internet that we would have an a digitally and an internet native money. [01:41:43] So I think that you're right, these kids are gonna it's gonna be a no-brainer to them. It's gonna be intuitive. It's incredible. You've got a sharp daughter. Yeah, she's pretty sharp. All right, man. This was a ton of fun. I think we've got to call it quits here. I gotta get home to my kids, as a matter of fact, and turn into dad for a little while. [01:42:05] Thanks so much for your time and really looking forward to part three and all of your Bitcoin work in the future. Yeah, keep doing what you're doing, man. I love the pod. You got some great guests coming up. Appreciate your time, appreciate the invite, and I also enjoyed the conversation. All right, man. [01:42:23] Hey, are you gonna be out at in San Francisco for Bitcoin 2019? I am, I just bought my flight this week, actually. Will you up will you be off there? Yes, I will be out there as well. So we'll definitely have to hang out. Awesome. Definitely. That's gonna be an event. Don't sleep on that one. Yeah, it's it's coming together to be maybe the one of the best Bitcoin. [01:42:42] Well, I think certainly one of the best Bitcoin events of the year, maybe the best one in the United States. So should be a lot of fun. Just by magnitude. Right, yeah. Bitblock boom is also gonna be really good down in Austin. But it's you know the space, the block space at BitBlock Boom is a little more scarce. So yeah, that's a good one to check out too. [01:43:04] All right, man. I will see you out in San Francisco, and until then, take care and keep Bitcoin in. Awesome. Thanks, Brady. Have a good one. Take care, Brandon. Bye-bye. [01:43:23] Thanks again to Brandon for making time to join me on the pod. It was a ton of fun. [01:43:29] One last plea to log into your iTunes account, [01:43:33] Rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin pod if you have found it to be valuable to your Bitcoin journey. And follow me on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin. Follow Brandon on Twitter at B Quitum, B Q I T T E M. Follow him on Medium as well, medium.com slash at Brandon Quittem, to make sure you don't miss part three. [01:43:53] And of course, check out the show notes for links to everything discussed in this episode. [01:43:58] And with that, good night and take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.