Michael Goldstein: Trolling, Memetics, Austrian Economics and Carnivory Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-09-19 [00:00:22] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Shout out to you wherever you are in the world today. Before we dive into today's great episode with Michael Goldstein, I'd like to take a moment to say thank you. [00:00:41] Thanks to you for listening, for subscribing, for rating and reviewing, and especially for sharing the podcast and episodes on Bitcoin Twitter. Keep it up. It is definitely making a difference. You guys are all the marketing team that this podcast has, and the other independent Bitcoin podcasts that you love. [00:01:03] So keep sharing, keep subscribing, keep rating and reviewing. This is a great episode to share because it's a fire discussion with an incredible Bitcoiner. Yeah, and with that, let's get into it. [00:01:24] Michael Goldstein is president of the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, and a longtime Bitcoiner who has done much to help educate about Bitcoin. [00:01:34] In this discussion, we get into the art of internet trolling, Bitcoin memetics, Austrian economics and the nature of money, the current global macroeconomic situation and how it relates to Bitcoin, the future of Bitcoin, and we dive into another rabbit hole that he's known for, carnivory. [00:01:51] It was great to talk with Michael, and I hope our discussion helps you on your Bitcoin journey. Here we go. [00:02:11] Alright, really excited to welcome Michael Goldstein, the legendary Bitstein to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast today. How's it going, Michael? It's going great. Thank you for having me on. Yeah, man. So there's lots to go through today. I actually put out a tweet this morning asking people if they had one question to ask ask you, what would it be? [00:02:30] Got several good questions. I'm gonna sprinkle those in throughout. You know, your your pot your story's been out there, you've been on lots of podcasts, you did one recently with POMP, and so I don't want to kind of rehash that material, want to try to make this useful to for for people who would listen to those podcasts as well. So let's just dive right into trolling. [00:02:49] Shout out to American Hoddle on Bitcoin Twitter for this question. Did you dabble in the dark arts of internet trolling before practicing and eventually teaching Bitcoin trolling in particular? Well, you know, is you know, other people merely adopted the internet. I was born in it and molded by it. [00:03:09] Yeah, no, I mean I've always been on the internet, so I've always, you know, had had a finger on the pulse of sort of internet culture. As far as like trolling, I mean, i it's actually like the use of that word itself is a bit of a troll. Just because you know, it specifically means you know, statements that are meant to incite or provoke certain reactions. [00:03:35] And the use of it makes it seem like everything is much more I don't know nihilistic than it actually is. When I talk about memeing, ultimately what I'm trying to get at is theories of rhetoric and how how different narratives and ideas spread and grow and are taken up by society or or discarded by people, etc. [00:04:06] But yeah it and the internet is a is a very different landscape than I think people have have had to deal with in the past, and so techniques are a little more acute and that does take some time to get used to. [00:04:26] For sure. In your recent talk at BitBluck Boom, you spoke about the art of trolling and specifically who to engage in rhetorical meme warfare and trolling and who to engage in this dialectical discourse that you talk about. You definitely triggered people by using the word bully, which as you mentioned, like itself is probably a troll, right? [00:04:48] It's a strong word. Why did you choose to use that word and who warrants this bullying and why? Yeah, I mean that's that's kind of internet lingo more than anything else. I of course never advocate for what would be considered sort of legitimate you know harassment. [00:05:07] But that being said, you know, in the intellectual realm, I don't think that people should be afraid of having very strong opinions. I think in our in our in our current world, people have a tendency to want to be they they want to hedge themselves and pad themselves with all kinds of irony and stuff like that and they don't like when people have a strong opinion strongly held as well as someone who is unafraid to boast it as such and that's not to say that it's necessarily correct perhaps [00:05:46] I have a lot of incorrect opinions but but I do think that it it sort of shocks people because they everyone wants to be nice to one another and be very open-minded but I always think of an old onion article about a man who's so open-minded that he starts believing all kinds of really stupid things and that's sort of the trade-offs that you have to engage with as you're traversing the internet and traversing a world of strange ideas so yeah you know if I disagree with [00:06:24] Someone I'm gonna have fun and disagree with them so but but by no means do I want anyone to be engaging in you know any kind of sort of doxing campaigns or actual physical harassment or anything like that. [00:06:42] I actually I think the larger part of my talk was you know encouraging people to be seeking out a truth based and truth centric method of spreading their ideas. Yeah and one thing that one detail that I really liked in the talk was like when you were talking about bullying, you use that word, you were actually talking about a very small group of people who kind of deserve that treatment, who we call no coiners. [00:07:11] People who have like, you know, just decided not to really learn much about Bitcoin and have formed their opinion and it's not going to change at all. And there's I think one of the reasons that like people really those kind of people really deserve the sort of kind of aggressive, very direct communication is that there's just a lot at stake here, right? [00:07:35] I mean, these people have been complicit in establishing and perpetuating this you know system that's done a lot of damage to society and to people, so it seems like something that's really worth standing up for. Right. A lot a lot of you know, shit coiners felt it the hardest, but you know, I it it's really the Paul Krugmans of the world that that are the big issue because they are the you know intellectual vanguard that support this you know entire system that has you know caused a decline in American progress [00:08:13] And you know just made all of our lives worth worse, you know, given the government the ability to expand its warfare and welfare state. And then when Bitcoin comes across the radars of people like Paul Krugman, he literally wrote a time New York Times column called Bitcoin is evil. [00:08:33] To his credit, he was saying that it was evil specifically for the reasons I think it's good, which means that he at some level understands what is at stake. But the point is like that that's actually like an extremely stark divide. Meanwhile, you know, I actually I was happy that Bology pointed this out recently on his Peter McCormack interview that shit coiners he didn't use that term, but shitcoiners are actually kind of using Bitcoin as their unit of account. [00:09:04] And so it actually is it kind of helps Bitcoin price discovery. So in that sense, like I of course think that all of these shit coins are total scams. But they're not they're not getting in the way of Bitcoin adoption so much as these extremely large apparatuses of you know state education and its offshoots or you know its controllers in the you know media academia complex you know, just teaching everyone that you know this this is how money ought to be when actually it's caused so many [00:09:42] Issues, the you know an endless amount of issues. So yeah, no, these people these people are effectively enemies, and you know, a shitcoiner I think could probably reform much easier than a Krugman can, you know, come back to us with his tail between his legs, you know, pouting that okay, I guess you were right about Bitcoin. [00:10:06] That'll be the day, man. You know, I imagine that even if Bitcoin took over, they would find some way of trying to rationalize why they were actually right the whole time because it only became viable because you know, of some something that some goalposts that they they themselves made up. [00:10:27] Yeah, yeah. That I think the Keynesians have definitely perfected the art of like post rationalization and you know justifying things with once once it becomes clear that they were wrong. Yeah. It's it's kind of it's kind of amazing the acrobatics that they'll go through, the mental gymnastics. Yeah, and this is also coming from the man, you know, it it's it's almost a it's it's a cliche at this point to point out, you know, his his comments on the facts machine. [00:10:58] You know, I pointed out which I don't see enough people pointing out when they're bashing on Krugman, people should go take a look at his post-9-11 column where he was suggesting that on the bright side, there were fact he didn't use these words, I don't think. He may have actually literally used them the broken windows, but he was basically applying the broken window fallacy to s September 11th and viewing that as a potential source of economic stimulus. [00:11:28] So this is the kind of people we're dealing with. These people, these people do not deserve any shred of respect nor any shred of kindness. And as I also pointed out in the talk, the only reason that you should ever engage in dialectic with such a person at all is because a third party is watching that you're actually interested in giving the good ideas, but it's not for that person, it's not for Paul Krugman himself. [00:11:52] Right. Alright, let's talk about memes. And you've sort of become a teacher of Bitcoin memes and bringing up Bitcoiners to kind of understand this and you use this phrase a lot, which we're gonna mean bit mean meme Bitcoin to the moon. What makes a good meme and what are some of your favorites or most successful Bitcoin memes in your opinion? [00:12:14] Oh well, that's that's an interesting question. So I mean, first of all, once again, you know, when I when I talk about memes, you know, this has changed a lot over the past decade or so. It used to be that when people generally refer to memes, sometimes it would be referring to sort of the Dawkins, you know, term from the selfish gene, and it would have a little bit of a highbrow connotation of some thoughts around how ideas propagate. [00:12:41] But typically when colloquially, when people were saying, Oh, a meme, it was usually just an image macro. You know, you have like the success kid or grumpy cat or you know, one of these, and it's just you know, it's just the big, large, bold italic, not impact was the font. [00:13:03] It was just that over and over, and it was just these sort of image macros. But the landscape that has built out now, you know, people on the internet have become much more adept at using sort of we'll take like the Twitter platform where there's there's only limited space. [00:13:23] You can you can have you know was it 280 characters, you can include a video or a up to four images, and with that you have to be able to compile you know all sorts of layered information to convey to other people. [00:13:44] And if you don't get all the information in that, someone else will, and it'll be you know the New York Times trying to give you a headline about why you know the Federal Reserve is actually a good thing. So people have adapted very well to these sort of short form things. [00:14:04] And so at that point it's about crafting crafting messages in a way that I think inspire people to perceive the world in a certain way and like I said I prefer doing it to towards what I believe is truth but you know others might disagree or just have frankly a different strategy for themselves what makes a good meme I think I think that's a highly organic process so [00:14:43] It's not something like sometimes someone comes up with something and it might even sound really good but then it's sort of just it's sort of just it's it's stale right from the get go. People don't latch on to it. Maybe it's you know before it's time or something sometimes but it it's a very high organic market process and I actually tend to think forced you know you don't you don't want to be creating a forced meme because that'll be perceived as cringe right and that's a difficult process [00:15:21] And sometimes you know it's like being a comedian or something they have a lot of duds and so not everyone always has perfect memes but you really don't want to go for the forced memes there's a lot of stuff that sort of just happens organically someone just you know the muse hits them or for some reason they just say something and it just works and people start to catch on because it appeals to this very fundamental truth that people hold on to. [00:15:47] And like, you know, I doubt that the person who wrote the I forget what the username was, but the person who wrote the I am hodling post really expected that to become such a rallying cry for for Bitcoiners. But it just it hit the right tone and I remember I remember the day that that one came out and there was something it was like it was it was just hilarious this this misspelling and people started you know just turning it into you know the 300 memes of you know Bitcoiners hodling despite the market process [00:16:25] Like prices it happened like right away too I mean you can see it in that actual thread I mean there's hundreds of replies that that are from that day and the next day that just basically launched that meme right there. Yeah exactly so it's a very that he just happened to come across something and I think this is why like my my general philosophy around this is for the most part try to just roll with stuff. [00:16:51] You know like the term I kind of still use the term maximalist, but it's not because I think that the term maximalist is a it's not necessarily the most linguistically you know definitive statement of what you could characterize my views as but in the current cultural context it certainly is you know if if I say that I'm a maximalist people know that okay well this guy does not dabble in shit coins or hopefully doesn't there's some people who have have used that label or have had that label projected onto [00:17:29] Them that that that do dabble in shit coins but generally speaking people know know that and that you're focused on Bitcoin. It typically carries connotations about you know your beliefs around monetary policy and stuff like that and so for that reason it's actually kind of it works to roll with it point being that these things the best ones tend to just be sort of organic and yeah I mean some of my favorites like hodling is a very good one Bitcoin fixes this I think is is a very good one that [00:18:08] People throw around myself very much included and I think I explained that in my in my talk if people want to go listen to like you know the talk on that but basically you know when I say Bitcoin fixes this to some people that sounds absolutely absurd but to the person who has already found themselves in the Bitcoin world and wants to learn about economics and history and society and etc etc the whole you know litany of topics around Bitcoin when you hear Bitcoin fixes this you know you're a little [00:18:46] Open minded to it you're maybe maybe maybe you're totally wrong maybe this is maybe we found the thing that Bitcoin can't actually fix but at the same time for for that person it inspires them to go look into it is like well why why are buildings built the way they are now or why are why do paintings look like this and you know what kind of things can we what what kind of connections can we draw with monetary policy and I would argue that that's going to be a much deeper connection than than most people think. [00:19:18] And so I think it's a very good meme for sort of inspiring that in in people to go to go study these topics. Yeah, we've got quite a nice library of these memes. And I think when I think about Bitcoin memes, like there's certainly great image macro memes out there too. But to me, the sort of I guess canon of three to five word ideas that we've developed as Bitcoiners over the past you know six, seven, eight, nine years, are pretty great. [00:19:49] I did a thread yesterday where I started off with about a dozen of them, and then I just asked what else. And we've got almost a hundred replies of this a ma amazing library. I guess it's probably I don't know, maybe a hundred up to a hundred or so of these ideas. And I'll definitely link to that in the show notes. But it's it's it's kind of amazing. [00:20:08] And if you read through this, you know, each one of these will teach you what Bitcoin is and is a sort of a jumping off point into the rabbit hole. Right. And you know, some people like kind of boohoo this kind of thing because you know, obviously there's not as much nuance. If you just say Bitcoin fixes this, that really doesn't tell you much. [00:20:28] But it's also not necessarily like the purpose of sharing that message in the first place. For those who like the context can be filled in by the by the receiver of the meme if they're interested in learning about that topic. You know, someone can present the idea that oh, here's a thing about society that I think monetary policy affects and due to Bitcoin being you know having such a hard monetary policy, it fixes this. [00:20:59] The person they can choose for themselves, like, okay, that sounds like a reasonable thing to explore. I will go explore it and fill in all the details. And if they're not interested, they just you know you don't have to, and you can disagree and all of that, but you know, I don't think that there's anything wrong with with not filling in the details for everyone else. [00:21:22] You know people should kind of do their own research and study up. I in a way like t to the to the outgrows you know people are just repeating things. But the flip side is is you know and there may there's probably plenty of people who just say things that that's a real phenomenon that happens. [00:21:46] On the flip side there are a lot of very smart individuals who have the ability to go research and come to that exact conclusion. When you get all the way down out through the rabbit hole it's just like oh yeah well Bitcoin fixes this. Right exactly it's just memes all the way down. [00:22:07] All right that's great. That's awesome. I want to move on to another topic because I know I'm mindful of your time and I have a lot I want to get in. So let's talk about Austrian economics and the nature of money. So we live in what I've called a default Keynesian world. Like we just sort of all default to that because that's the way things are now there's this monoculture of monetary thought in the world and somehow Austrian economics has survived as a critique and an alternative to this kind of Keynesian ideological Armageddon that we're living in right now. [00:22:38] And Bitcoin is like a real world example of the Austrian economics kind of definition of money and I guess you could call it sort of the secret roundabout weapon that could defeat the Keynesian monetary Goliath. Right. Can you talk about yeah can you can you talk about how you think this battle will play out in the coming decades. [00:23:02] Yeah, well and I think you're right. Hayek even had had a point about this. There's like a popular video that goes around of you know people saying you know people like Friedman and Hayek predicted Bitcoin. And you know Hayek did suspect that you know one of the things someone would have to come up with a way to just sort of route around everything. [00:23:23] Because his own his own plans for nationalization of money and stuff like that it's very good from the perspective of trying to reform what we have but there is a lot to be desired when you're just imagining like some you know kind of you know market run you know basket of goods something it's like nah just give give me a digital gold or you know bitcoin or whatever. [00:23:47] It's way better. As far as like playing out yeah I mean I think it is like this sort of ultimate battle because you know Bitcoin's monetary policy is not going to get changed. It'll just always there will always be this this coin that has a 21 million cap and a certain emission schedule and that's just the way it is and if Austrians are right about the power of this then the whole world will just kinda have to succumb because traditional methods that a government government [00:24:25] Might use to combat it say through its own sort of spin on on speculative attacks on the coin you know you can't do that you can't if you if you try to print a bunch of dollars to try to like buy up bitcoin so you can short bitcoin well you've inflated the dollar more and you've increased the price of bitcoin more and the demand for bitcoin more so it's this sort of self-fulfilling prophecy of doom if you're trying to play that game so you can't use that [00:25:04] Legal tender is not really useful because people will just I mean it might be the case that yeah like you still force everyone to pay up in dollars but that doesn't mean that they'll hold on to the dollars in the meantime and so by time they actually pay that debt you know in the dollars maybe it just like you know it's this is the app part of the app coin model of the dollar that chartalists hold on to which is also you know like oh well you have to pay taxes in the dollar and therefore it's valuable but right you can still hold dollars I [00:25:42] Mean sorry you can just hold bitcoins and then and then you know only on on at the point where you have to actually spend do you know grab some dollars and spend it and so that being said you know like we know that more hodling means more you know liquidity and all of that so that's like that doesn't really help and you know what are you gonna do like ban hodling altogether I know there's some countries like India that have contemplated this but this simply does not it does not match up with I think how how what what's actually possible [00:26:20] To actually enforce such a thing, especially in America where just think of all of the [00:26:31] The anger that so many people in this country have over the fact that other people in this country own guns. So much I mean people explicitly calling for you know what do they call buybacks or whatever you know but you know they they at this point they like you know they speak openly we want to take your AR fifteen or whatever, and yet, you know, everyone still has AR-15s. [00:26:54] So even something like that is not really enforceable. So the idea of somehow forcing Americans to not be able to run computer code and save a number, I mean to enforce that would also just you know bring the entire digital economy to a halt, not just Bitcoin. [00:27:15] It's like what are you allowed to save any passwords? You know, are you allowed to do it like it would just unravel the whole the whole thing. So that that's just not even feasible. Maybe maybe in a you know, developing nation or something, but I have no I don't really have a worry about that in the United States. [00:27:34] So with this all of this being said, I just don't see like what what the methods would be to stop it, except, you know, I think as say Fedine points out, to just adopt a gold standard and make the demand for holding bitcoins less desirable. [00:27:55] Anything else is just it's a crapshoot and it's it's doomed to fail. Yeah, and at this point, the prospects of that happening are basically nil. We've got negative interest rates all over the world, we've got political leaders just pushing and pushing their central banks for more quantitative easing and more and lower rates, and there's just like a race to the bottom now. [00:28:18] And like you said, no one's gonna want to hold fiat money that has negative interest rates. It's just encouraging [00:28:24] You. I mean, no one wants to hold fiat money in their first place. I mean, anyway, [00:28:29] Exactly. Yeah, so they're just making it even less and less desirable, and then you know, every other investment is just going to if you think Bitcoin's a bubble, I mean everything else, you know, I'm sure to a lot of people it just feels like a big bubble as well. You know, m Michael Burry, I saw the thing about him speaking about the sort of index funds that everyone likes investing in. [00:28:53] And I don't have a comment on that. I'm not I'm not really a finance guy, so I don't I'm not an expert on what's what's good and bad in this space, but you know, it's Bitcoin is actually not very risky compared to a lot of these other things, and you know it it can actually see a profit because it's routinely done that throughout its entire history, save for you know, a couple time periods. [00:29:19] Right. I want to talk about this idea that Austrian economics uses and kind of distinguishes it from at the very base from the Keynesian approach. It's called praxeology. Yes. And I think it's something that it we don't really talk about a lot as Bitcoiners, so I thought we could dive into it a little bit and share this idea with everyone. [00:29:39] So what is this idea of praxeology and why is it important to Austrian economics? Yeah, so praxeology is the study of human action, and it it uses an approach of logical deduction based on a set of axioms that we have about human action. [00:30:00] So we can take the fact that someone that we that we can say you know human action is purposeful behavior. Any economic action is someone using a means towards an end, you know. We can also look at the fact that there exists time preference, you know, there's no there is no person in the world who does not have time preference, you know. [00:30:25] Even when we you know make jokes or whatever about low time preference, you can never have a time preference of zero. The question then is you know, what are some logical conclusions that you can you can glean from that? Just that simple fact. And you know, you can you can build out the you know theories of you know marginal utility and diminishing returns, and that can grow into to other stuff, and you know, over time as you as you know whittle out the logic of choice, you get this full-fledged sort of model [00:31:04] Of economics. Why it's important is that many people in the modern world treat economics as yet another sort of physical science. They they've done this with the whole of social sciences, much to the detriment of social sciences, treating it as something that we experiment on. [00:31:26] But you know there's there are certain things that you can experiment on, but it's not it's not economic theory. It's more of like what defines a particular person's preferences. So in that case, it's a very sort of just sort of empirical preference. [00:31:48] Like economic theory doesn't care about you know whether someone chooses McDonald's or Burger King. It's simply looking at in the abstract the consequences of making a choice. So you could do studies and see that this type of person, if we you know do this kind of brain scan, you know, can see that they tend to have a preference towards this. [00:32:10] But that would that would be a separate thing. That's marketing. Exactly. So that's that's looking at something other than economic theory. And so when you're looking at economic theory, it it's it's most useful to take this approach of just looking at the logical consequences of the nature of an economic choice in the first place. [00:32:36] Because it would actually seem almost absurd to go and think that you needed to do experiments all over the world to study whether or not the law of you know diminishing returns actually exists, or if we're just you know making it up. [00:32:56] I think I think it's pretty settled or like supply and demand. We don't have to sit and do experiments on that. We can we can actually just deduce it from the very fact that humans choose. And so it would be the same, like, you know, we know that the pac we the Pythagorean theorem is true in mathematics, because there's a set of axioms, and from that you've been able to deduce the Pythagorean theorem. [00:33:23] You don't have to go to like every continent and draw on a piece of paper a triangle and measure it out to find it. It's like you've you've already defined the logical space that it it exists in. So you can just you can just use that. [00:33:41] It's actually a complete waste of time and resources. So in many ways, like the you know, praxeological method, if anything, is just good as a filter for taking out bad ideas without having to spend all of the time to you know waste money on experimenting on it. Yeah, and so like Keynesian the Keynesian idea or kind of like this mainstream economics these days are have rejected that idea and in favor of this sort of empirical, like you said, scientific method approach. [00:34:12] And even call it that. I don't I don't even know if that's that's accurate. I'd want someone who's who's more knowledgeable on the full extent of Keynesian brain damage to go through that, but or maybe we can call it empiricism or something, I guess. I don't know. Yeah. To me it definitely feels like a more field-based you know economic system. [00:34:35] Right. I think what I'm trying to say is maybe they would they would consider it to be the scientific method, but you can't really apply a scientific method like you said. Right. So yeah, that's kind of the that's basically the difference is you have one approach that's based on logic and one approach that's based on empiricism, and as you said, it leads to a complete waste of time. [00:34:55] So there's been this entire branch of academia that's been you know, wasting time, and then not only that, but like you know, applying it to it to the real world and causing all these all these issues. Right. There's also the problem of translating everything into mathematical language. [00:35:14] So turning it into just you know just symbols. And then with those symbols you can look at them and do interesting things with it. And you do all kinds of stuff and then you pop out a model but in that meantime you sort of lost track of actual reality. And so like mathematics is well overused I think in economic theory. [00:35:37] That that's a general Austrian feeling and belief because you know as is I think it was Rothbard had a great article about this you know just basically pointing out that it as insofar as the mathematics explains every anything in economics it's it's literally just a translation of the you know written language and yet when you do it it also because you've taken it away you've turned you know person into the variable a or whatever suddenly that that gives you a lot more [00:36:15] Room to forget about the sort of reality that your theory does need to comport to and then which I can imagine that that inspiring people to think that you need to experiment because now you have this model well now we need to go test it against reality to see if it's true or not. [00:36:35] And in the meantime like had you just you know stuck to you know the written language perhaps you wouldn't have gotten so far from from everything you could just look at the logic itself. Exactly. That's a great summary. Thanks for that. Yeah I do want to like one one more thing. [00:36:54] Like this has been like a complete bastardization of these ideas. Yeah. It it's actually like been a while since I've I've you know gone deep into the praxeology. It's just like the water I swim in at this point. So I'm not I'm not as much of like a good teacher because I haven't been you know practicing you know teaching people these concepts but I highly recommend people you know go read Ludovon Messi's human action it's extremely dense 100 pages at the beginning but that'll get you really good understanding of the nature of economic thought and how praxeology functions and [00:37:32] Why it's important and all of that. I also recommend a fantastic little book called economic science and the Austrian method by Hans Hermann Hoppe there's also he also has some lectures online on the same topic if you want the sort of the shorter version but that goes deep into it and then finally like if you really want just like kind of the fun stuff there it there's old web series called Prax Girl that I'm sure is still on YouTube that does a very good job of explaining the basics of praxeology is fiat even money like according [00:38:10] To the definition of Austrian economics would you consider this thing that we have now an actual money this US dollar I guess I'll take for instance I would have no reason to not call it money the reason being that money is the most liquid good and despite the fact that the dollar is this you know absurd good, it's still the most liquid good. [00:38:38] And I can take my dollars pretty much anywhere and get anything I want with dollars, and so it is it is by that definition money. Is it good money? I think it's lacking in many ways, and I think we can do better. Awesome. All right, Matt Odell wanted me to ask you is gold a shit coin. [00:39:01] Is gold a shit coin. So I think we should respect gold. Gold has been you know something that has been treasured and prized and monetized to various extents since antiquity. I would say that the heights of civilization, you know, say like the late 1800s and stuff like that, you know, that was that was built off a gold economy. [00:39:31] You know, when you think of the greatness of the Renaissance, you have to remember that that was you know built on the Florin and the you know was it the Ducat and like all these all these Italian you know co gold coins. So I think that in some sense you know I think Bitcoin has improved upon what gold offered, and we've sort of uncovered, you know, gold was always the greatest resource. [00:40:05] Like there it's there's something so incredibly alluring about gold, and that's why people traveled the world to plunder anywhere they could to get their hands on this, you know, resource it's it's a beautiful shiny yellow rock, and it's it has this scarce property that I think everyone sort of intrinsically feels when they're when they they think about gold or they see gold you know it it just it feels like a precious metal and it that that is so baked into our psyches I really like it I think that's a [00:40:43] It's a total disservice to call it a shit coin. Instead we should be viewing Bitcoin as sort of standing on the shoulders of giants. You know we have so much to learn from gold and you know there might be there might be you know a case for gold to you know exist in this interim of hyper bitcoinization and perhaps even after but I don't know I don't think it's a shitcoin I think I think we should save that for the fiat currencies. [00:41:16] Fair enough. Alright one more question from Twitter on this topic. Victor Arum on Twitter asks about the idea of stock to flow ratio which is used in Austrian economics to define hard money. He wants to know what you think about plan B's stock to flow analysis as it applies to Bitcoin. [00:41:36] Yeah well so first of all I mean stock to flow was not a sort of common term in Austrian economics prior to say for Dean writing his book the Bitcoin standard that was actually one of his great contributions was introducing this concept which it's a very simple idea and it's one that we all kind of know about but didn't have this this way of thinking about it such that we can look at different goods and actually quantify the differences between them it it it [00:42:14] It the term basically only existed within like weird gold investment circles. There were a couple professors of economics that are kind of on the fringe, not necessarily because they're actually fringe economists, just because they're not they're not touting the spouting the party line or whatever that that were using it. [00:42:39] But it was it was rather it wasn't a well-known topic, or well-known concept or or term so I do want to clarify that. But yes, I think it's extremely important. I think I think Safe Dean is is totally right that sound money is is almost synonymous with hard money because a market will naturally want the hardest money because that protects you the most against other people diluting the money and basically hacking the money. [00:43:14] You want that. You also don't want something that is going to dilute, especially at a an uncertain rate. So I think that there's something about that as far as like plan B's specific model of it. [00:43:33] I think it's very interesting. It's something that everyone should have their eyes on. And I think 2021 will you know show us if there's there's even more to it. But I do think, like, generally speaking, that that is the model we've kind of always been talking about, just not with that term specifically. [00:43:56] And I do I do suspect that that Bitcoin will see more very extreme hype cycles that end and culminate with a Bitcoin that has a baseline much higher than it previously had been. Let's talk about kind of the macro situation that we find ourselves in right now and the macro global economic situation. [00:44:20] Like we talked about earlier, we're seeing negative in interest rates all over the world, pushes for more money printing from political leaders, perhaps most notably President Trump seems to be calling out the Fed like every week now to cut rates and print money so that we can keep up with with all these other central banks that are doing the same thing. [00:44:39] And this week in particular, Wall Street's kind of buzzing about this unexpected rate spike in the market for repurchase agreements, the repo market. One financial journalist said that that they've never heard of this happening to this scale outside of a financial crisis. Another said that the repo squeeze is kind of amping up pressure on the Fed to expand its balance sheet, may accelerate the move to reignite quantitative easing. [00:45:04] So is this another canary in the coal mine kind of warning us about this big crack up boom potential? And do you think Bitcoin is ready for such an event? Yeah, I mean I'm I'm a weary, weary libertarian in that sense. [00:45:24] Like, you know, there's been talk of crack up booms and stuff you know, since forever. And maybe, you know. I actually I've come to think that these I actually think that these central bankers are more competent sometimes than we like to think, in that they can keep kicking the can down the road quite a bit. [00:45:45] So I don't I don't know that like I don't know if I should believe that there's some kind of looming crisis. I think that's also people always want to think that. And I also don't want to have like the reverse I don't want a black swan. I don't want to like reverse black swans. It's like I don't know anymore. I also I also as a Bitcoiner don't I don't want a crack up boom, you know. [00:46:08] That's because that's that's terrible for the economy. I just want everyone to switch to Bitcoin. I don't want everyone to you know, be dying in the streets and have to accept Bitcoin because their lives dependent depend on it. I actually want a much more peaceful transition to a better money. And I think a lot of Bitcoiners over the years have had that vision where one, they think that there has to be this, you know, total destruction of the US dollar or something for Bitcoin to take its place as opposed to Bitcoin just taking over. [00:46:39] And with that comes like this sort of like, I don't know, doom doomsday porn. So I don't know. A lot of this stuff is just such absolute voodoo. I don't really have have you know good good comments on how to I don't know much about the repo market, so I can't really speak to that. [00:46:59] But it definitely shows, you know, I think that the regardless that the economy is a very fragile thing, and I think it would be less fragile with you know, Bitcoin. And I think Bitcoin adoption is happening and we should continue pushing that so that whatever might happen, we can have a peaceful conclusion and a good one where everyone has an actual actually good money to work with. [00:47:27] Well let's say that some kind of crisis does happen in the next couple of years how do you think it will affect bitcoin not just in price wise but like you know also you know the rate of adoption and you know the technology itself is it is it ready to you know be a for to onboard a you know significant like hundreds thousands of times more people than than are using it now in such a like kind of quick way I guess that might happen in a in a crisis yeah I mean that's that's an interesting question. [00:48:02] I mean I think I like to think that the protocol itself can handle that you know it's just ready. But in terms of all of the infrastructure of people knowing how to properly deal with the protocol I mean we're still trying to figure out a lot of different you know questions around custody stuff like that which you know if an institution needs to get their hands on tons of bitcoins stat you know they need to know how to store it. [00:48:29] And so stuff like that I'm not totally you know sure is is ready. At the same time, you know people people learn under pressure pretty well so I don't I don't know if it would just you know get figured out I think you know when people feel I mean when people get into Bitcoin and suddenly they they find themselves having to face this thing down is I how how do I how do I store what I have they start learning. [00:48:53] You know people start learning you know what is a full node how do I run one why do I need one how do I store it people start, you know, looking up you know, stuff and very non-technical people are getting into rather technical things like cold card wallets and stuff like that. So I think there is room to have plenty of faith in humanity around that. [00:49:13] The protocol itself, like, you know, there's peep people should be ready for for seeing high fees and stuff like that. And hopefully I think now a lot more practices are put into place that hadn't been in the past, such as batching and stuff like that such that people will know how to mitigate high fees a bit better for their particular needs and time preferences. [00:49:44] So I don't know. I kind of have like a faith in c in humanity that people would be able to learn. I don't wanna I don't want to be doom and gloom about people flooding in. That's actually like I want more people to be using Bitcoin. But I do think I do think that there is the benefit too of things happening slowly so that we can have time to learn and not make judgment in haste. [00:50:10] Absolutely. Yeah, me too. But you know, humanity will do what we need to do. Bitcoin is the is the exit. And whether or not, you know, people are rushing for the exit or quietly cueing out, you know, they have to get through it somehow, and they will. And Bitcoin itself will be just fine. [00:50:33] What do you think about central banks holding Bitcoin? Do you suspect there might be some out there that already are holding Bitcoin? And maybe just for some like game theory fun, when do you think that might be disclosed publicly? That's an interesting question. [00:50:51] I have no connections to any central banks, although they're welcome to contact me. I'm happy to tell them how to turn their nation into a prosperous and viable country for the twenty first century. You know, maybe. [00:51:13] I don't know. I don't know what their mindsets are like. I don't I don't know I don't know enough about what actually goes on in central banks, although I can I can hope that someone does because I think that would be actually better for the nation that is under that central bank. [00:51:34] Because if something went bad, well at least like they wouldn't go to shit because they'd have Bitcoin at the ready to help kind of have that capital base for for the country. So I actually think it would be a good thing. Not that I you not that I like these people and get happy about them having Bitcoins or something, but hey, Bitcoin is for enemies, right? [00:51:59] As far as like, you know, if they would reveal it, yeah, I don't know. I think I think you probably wouldn't want to reveal it until you have a stash that you're happy with, and I don't know if they'd ever find the stash that they're happy with. So maybe it would be I get the sense that maybe it would be after, you know, like let's say Bitcoin followed the path of you know, what plan B's model suggests, and you see like a sixty thousand dollar Bitcoin followed by, you know, I've what is it, a million dollars for the twenty twenty four halving? [00:52:37] Yeah. So like by then, you know, perhaps it's it's going to become a difficult enough to imagine your your stash increasing by an order of magnitude even as a large institution because like for for individuals that that time would be closing fast in terms of you know if if if it got to 60,000 like you know most American individuals simply are not going to be able to afford to get an entire Bitcoin but large institutions certainly can so I'd imagine you'd still have that game between the large institutions of [00:53:15] Wanting to you know you actually kind of want the price to be lower so that you can keep hodling and stacking sets. So at that point it's it is stacking bits or whatever at the institutional level and they'll be playing that game and perhaps you know boohooing it to each other or whatever trying to do try trying to imagine they can they can stop the stock to flow or whatever and maybe once they start to see that this thing like okay we're not going to be able to really increase by an order of magnitude then I could imagine someone wanting [00:53:53] To step out and say hey we have a lot of bitcoins and then it as a way to just get everyone excited so as to accelerate that process that everyone kind of yeah I could imagine something like that perhaps happening. Seems like there would be some kind of first mover advantage in that sense because you could say hey we have a bunch of Bitcoin we're switching our economy to a Bitcoin standard. [00:54:17] Move here and build your Bitcoin businesses, you know? Yeah. I think the I think the more likely situation that just pops into my head right now is not so much that a company, sorry, that a country wholeheartedly just say, oh, we're adopting the Bitcoin standard. The real advantage would just simply be a country being completely open to Bitcoin innovation and development and culture and hodling and every the whole nine yards, just saying like Bitcoiners are safe here. [00:54:49] And with that, you know, they'll they'll naturally be becoming a Bitcoin economy, w without having to, you know, even necessarily, you know, go off the dollar immediately. They can they can do it at a at the more like they can transition with the economy itself, but they can set themselves up for a future of you know knowing where the winds are blowing and taking that to heart. [00:55:20] You know, the way that, you know, people like to point out, you know, Estonia doing the sort of digital citizenship type thing, like more countries that can adopt that mindset in a in a real tangible fashion, I think will will fare much better in the 21st century. [00:55:41] Awesome. You know, a country, like a good government, if there is such a thing, would be one that basically operates as a business where it's trying to increase the capital value of its territory. And with that in mind, you know, they themselves, it doesn't really matter what they denominate the profits and losses in, so they can easily just switch to the better currency. [00:56:11] It's actually like I think an aberration and a mistake for a country to want to control their own money and have to wield that kind of control in which which creates this fragility instead of just being this sort of quote unquote I use the term very very loosely, but like a market actor just trying to increase that capital value. [00:56:35] And it's just like, okay, well, you know, the world the world doesn't accept our money anymore, so but they do accept Bitcoin, so we're switching over to Bitcoins. And so I think a country that does that will necessarily be a much more peaceful country and one that we should all we should all desire. I think I think politicians should be m carving a safe world for people to engage in peaceful competitive money, monetary alternatives. [00:57:06] And that's one of the things that really gives me some optimism that we'll have a nice peaceful or you know, more peaceful transition than not to you know a Bitcoin world. And we've seen you know a few representatives in the United States Congress really talk positively about Bitcoin, calling it a force, an unstoppable force, and then of course Warren Davidson's famous like there's Bitcoin, there's shit coin, entering shitcoin in the congressional record, which was just epic. [00:57:34] I think I laughed about that for a couple hours that day. That was amazing. It was a fantastic moment. I think a very historic watershed moment in in American history. Absolutely. I agree completely. But yeah, that and that's happening, you know, at the state levels too in Ohio and Wyoming and some other states that are you know being more friendly to Bitcoin. [00:57:58] And yeah, that I mean once those politicians, you know, are become hodlers, then they're incentivized by the protocol itself, by the money itself to, you know, make this country more Bitcoin friendly place. And the more the more their constituents are hottling too. And hodling Bitcoins is is just as American as you know you know baseball and apple pie and all the rest holding guns and you know all of that. [00:58:25] It's just it's a it's I think it's a very American thing. Not not that it's solely American. I'm saying within the American context it it fits right in. Freedom and per personal responsibility and I mean we founded this country with one one of the main ideas was you know separation of church and state the freedom to choose your own religion and not have it held against you and the separation of money in the state is of you know very very similar idea. [00:58:51] And they thought that too there's a great Thomas Paine essay you can read on Mises.org where he was saying that anyone and any any politician who so much as suggests that I think it was even just legal tender laws but he was basically also implying you know paper money that there should be paper money instead of coinage of medals should just be executed so bitcoin maximalists are actually very tempered in our our political stances because we do not call for the execution of shit coiners and no corners we simply want the economics to be allowed [00:59:29] To work itself out, which it'll do regardless of our meme, regardless of anything we do. It's just harder money wins so people people should be happy that maximalists today are are not not like the you know political rapscallions of the 18th century. [00:59:49] All right, let's talk about a little bit about carnivory. We'll close up with this because I know this is your other love besides Bitcoin. And I'm really interested in I've I've certainly become more carnivorous since I became a Bitcoiner, and I think that that's partially due to you and the other Bitcoin carnivores out there. [01:00:08] So how and when did you fall down this this car you know carnivore rabbit hole? So I first learned about the paleo diet, the sort of you know, Marxism had the primal blueprint, that kind of stuff in I guess it was about 2011. [01:00:27] Actually through sort of libertarian circles. So of course it's it's always been tied to this kind of questioning the government sort of mentality. And that certainly made me more conscious of how I ate, you know, as I was avoiding more breads and stuff like that. I was never extremely strict, but it certainly made me more conscious. [01:00:49] And eventually in I guess it was 2014, my my my friend came across a short little clip of actually Zuko O'Hearn of today of Zcash talking about the ketogenic diet. And it was just enough that it was like it really like kind of drove home, you know, ideas that have been floating around, especially enough for me to actually want to go like look into this thing. [01:01:15] And so I had I had looked into the ketogenic diet, and specifically the first one was his first blog was his him and his ex-wife Amber O'Hearn had a website called ketotic.org and she also had one called Empirica which like that spelled out with the dot C A. [01:01:37] And it was quickly like their suggestion was the best way to do a ketogenic diet was to simply eat an all meat diet. And that was you know absurd, but it was like that was fascinating. I looked into it a little bit. About a year, it's about a year and a half after that. I that that was I was I was thinking about that again, and I had some extra time and I was just kind of doing a lot of research on it, and I fell out down that rabbit hole. [01:02:05] I was reading her writings. I found forum posts by Owsley Stanley, the LSD manufacturer and Grateful Dead sound guy who was a carnivore for for a good 50 something years before he died in a car crash. And there was also the works of Wilhelm Stefenson, who is an Arctic explorer who who talked about his his time in the Arctic and how he ate when he was with the Inuit. [01:02:34] The medical establishment was very confused by his claims that they were eating only meat. That that that sounded you know ridiculous. So he he actually underwent a year-long trial at Bellevue Hospital where they just they controlled his diet and only made sure he ate meat, fat, and some organs as he wanted. [01:02:59] And at the end of that, they found that he had no deficiencies, deficiencies at all. So that work kind of just like it it shatters a lot of assumptions that people have around nutrition. And to me, that's that's been the biggest thing is just a lot of the a lot of the things that people believe about nutrition, perhaps they're actually true to some extent, but I don't think that they're as warranted as people believe. [01:03:34] So I think that people tend to just say it as more as common knowledge than as actual scientific statements. And this even goes down to the level of making the claim that vegetables are good for you. And people ask me all the time, oh, where the where's the science for carnivore? [01:03:54] And the interesting thing is is if you actually try to look for scientific studies about the shall we say, the safety and efficacy of vegetable consumption, you actually find that you have quite a bit of difficulty. You know, some very intelligent people, you know, Harv Harvard trained scientists have have written great blog posts on this of trying to search out the entirety of the scientific literature for information on this, and they find that there's about seven when you really take out a lot of the like sort of you know epidemiological stuff where it's like you just you're [01:04:32] Just asking people, hey, what did you eat for the last 50 years? It's like I you know, do people even know what they had for breakfast last week, let alone you know, 40 years ago. That that's not really a good study to look at. When you break it down, there's like seven, and then half of those are showing that some something like green tea or something like that, they find has a rather negative effect compared to the you know, when you have the control group and the non-control group so it actually sort of you know helps helps my position so to speak in that in that in that case the point is is we have all of these beliefs where you know perhaps [01:05:11] Those beliefs were more coming from acculturation than from actual knowledge about human physiology and nutrition and so it's it's an extremely I find it a very interesting rabbit hole and I think you know people generally speaking would probably be more healthier if they were eating more meat because it's been a highly treasured part of the human diet for 2.5 million years now and everywhere around the world animal fat has been prized as a food for health and fertility and [01:05:49] All this stuff we also see an endless supply of stories from people whose whose health have has rapidly and like quite incredibly shifted for the better from this like various autoimmune conditions and metabolic disorders stuff that is typically treated by mainstream medicine as incurable such as Crohn's disease given you know a particular approach to a carnivorous diet we have seen actual reversals of this [01:06:27] And that's that's huge and so I think I it's it's happened in in my life personally, just another you know anecdotal evidence, but my wife has a metabolic disorder, and so we started doing a ketogenic diet about a year and a half ago, and my wife's you know, like symptoms of her metabolic disease are basically gone. [01:06:47] She she either brain fog or just like being overly tired. She's got so much more energy and just vitality. And it's it's been amazing. So we haven't we haven't gone full carnivore, but you know, we still we still have some Brussels sprouts and asparagus, but we don't, you know, we don't eat many vegetables anymore. It's becoming more and more meat, so yeah. [01:07:07] Well, you know, i the other thing too, like I you know, I never claimed to be in perfect health. There's plenty of ways that that my own you know health can be improved, but you know, I've I've seen many incredible benefits for myself, just just feeling much better just all around. I was I grew up on on a lot of you know fast food and even even in my paleo days when I was I was being more conscious and I also went through a keto phase, you know, I there I felt better in certain ways, but nothing like when I went carnivore and so you know you know hopefully hopefully time will will be good to me and I'll [01:07:45] I'll become even healthier and stronger every day. But compared to where I had been, I could not be more thankful that I came across this information. But there was something else I wanted to say about that, but I anyway, oh oh I remember. So first of all, I am very happy for for you and your wife. [01:08:04] As far as like the vegetables, you know, I'm not a Puritan. People think I'm some kind of Puritan with the meat. I happen to keep a I you know, I don't I don't I don't cheat, you know. I don't have any desire to cheat, so it's not even really not cheating, because it's just I would be cheating myself more than anything. [01:08:26] I just have no you know, if someone puts a donut in front of me, it does not register in my brain as food. But I'm not a Puritan. I really don't care what people eat. What I want people to consider are you know what you know what are the consequences of foods in ways that we may have not thought previously but are very real. [01:08:47] And from there, people can make choices about how they want to treat their own bodies and if they want to you know enjoy certain foods. I know plenty of people who, you know, they just like beer and so they drink beer and they, you know, sometimes it makes them feel less than optimal. Sometimes they just feel fine after drinking it, but regardless, like they just enjoy it, so they continue to drink it. [01:09:09] And like I'm not gonna s I'm not gonna stop someone. You know, I'm I'm I'm a libertarian, not a Puritan. My big sort of memetic battle that I feel like I'm I'm fighting is not so much that I want the whole world to go carnivore, despite the fact that I do think that that would probably be beneficial. [01:09:29] My hypothesis is it would be beneficial. But the real crux is that for many decades now, meat has been treated as something that is harmful and dangerous for both humans and the environment and you know, everything in between. [01:09:50] You know, saturated fat is going to kill you. All of these diseases of civilization could be traced back to meat. This is how they present it. And my biggest battle is just like, no, that's not that's not correct at all. In fact, you can live a life on only meat and you will become not only healthy, but perhaps way healthier. [01:10:15] I think that once that shift can happen where people no longer fear meat, then they can start making better decisions about that meat consumption. So for y'all, y'all find that brussel sprouts work just fine. That's wonderful. Someone else might be in that same situation and they might find that even a small amount of Brussels sprouts causes this sort of nonlinear negative effect on them, such that they have some they have some autoimmune condition where even the smallest amounts of a certain plant, the compounds [01:10:53] In that plant, the phytochemicals, can trigger that autoimmune condition. But they may have never thought that, oh, maybe it was the Brussels sprouts. And with this in mind, when they're going to try to eliminate foods, if they think of meat as the healthy food, then perhaps they'll they'll try just giving up the Brussels sprouts for a while a little while and finding that that alleviates the problems that they're handling. [01:11:18] And so I think when you can make that shift, you know, suddenly people will be able to make the I think smarter choices in terms of you know what what foods to eliminate and how to approach nutritional intervention r regarding various various symptoms that they might be facing. [01:11:42] What is your answer to the argument that carnivore is not scalable to everyone on the planet? Maybe just for environmental reasons or I don't know what other reasons people argue, but I've certainly heard that brought up to me when I when I try to talk about the ideas of carnivore with some of my friends. They're like, oh, that's just not scalable. [01:12:01] We can't do that for everyone on the planet. Yeah, well, then maybe we have too many people. No. No, I think that I think grasslands, I think that we have a lot, there's a lot of land that we can put a lot of cows on. And I think, you know, I think we underestimate just how much cruft exists in this, you know, giant Monsanto food monstrosity. [01:12:27] That we can convert into you know a more scalable meat production factor. It's like if there was a will, there is a way, you know. Like that that's how the economy functions. When people have more demand for something, people find the means to produce it. [01:12:47] As far as that though, there's also these there there's this conflation and this happens a lot, especially I think when talking to certain types of vegans. I don't want to implicate all of them because I know vegans that do not fall into this camp, but there's a certain type that they are arguing from a position of animal ethics, you know, like sort of an animal rights type position. [01:13:16] Whereas carnivores are by and large speaking from a human health perspective. And the vegans tend to take this position of well, you know, damn human health. What matters is the environment. And so when I hear people, oh, it's not scalable, you know, you do have the question. [01:13:37] It's like, okay, even if that's true, we still need to know that, you know, if it's the case that a certain type of carnivorous diet can alleviate someone's autoimmune condition. If if someone out there is dealing with that, you don't want to deny them that kind of intervention to help them because that person will not be as as useful to society if they're in pain all the time. [01:14:07] And so I it it's it's it's a conflation of two separate arguments. One is is carnivore healthy or not? And one is there I guess there's almost three. Then there's one is can it scale to production like if everyone decided they wanted to eat this healthy diet would there be enough resources and three is that okay or not regardless of any of any of what we've just determined. [01:14:38] And I am of the position of yes it's healthy for humans. Two yes I think I think we could probably scale meat production way more than it currently is the amount of biomass that used to exist on this planet in the form of megafauna it's just astounding. And I think we should just be aiming to get that back. [01:14:58] You know we had what 60 million bison roaming the American West [01:15:05] Without you know human ingenuity coming up with methods of herd management and stuff so I think we could you know even do better I forget how many cattle head are in in North America at the time. Point is like there's plenty of space we could we could fill up with with cows. [01:15:25] And then as far as the ethics, I am of the position where human health should actually be a primary factor because in determining any of this, because the reason that we can sit around and even have positive thoughts about what we think nature ought to be is because we are healthy humans living, you know, we exist such that we can value that stuff. [01:15:51] Like nature itself is not is not inherently a good or bad thing. Like nature is a is a it's a it's a brutal place, quite frankly. There's no there's not like the noble, you know, primitivism. There's there's a great old I've quoted it a couple times now, but there's a great Werner Herzog interview when he was filming one of his movies in the Amazon, and he just there's all the sounds of the jungle, and he just calls it the sound of overwhelming and collective murder. [01:16:27] So it's like when you're hearing all these birds chirp, it's actually just like nature killing itself. And that's just like the way nature is. So that's nature, but like we're here to actually be able to you know appreciate very as various aspects of nature and specifically how it relates to us humans. [01:16:46] Like even even those people who have that extreme view, you know, they they want the sort of destruction of humanity because it gives them good feels. You know, ultimately they they themselves. It's still like it comes down to this subjective valuation. [01:17:04] And so ultimately I want people to be able to understand the costs and benefits as a whole, and from my perspective, it's like I can't I can't function in this world if I'm not if I'm not healthy and so you know anyone who's trying to force me to eat pea proteins or you know lab grown whatever you know bugs whatever they're gonna try to force down my throat I don't have reason to believe that that is an adequate substitute for for what humans have just sort of always eaten and what we've always treasured and so I [01:17:42] Just I disregard it as a viable solution we should we should look at the sort of what what are those sort of axioms of human existence one of them is there there are certain nutrients we need from from animal foods and go from there. Makes sense man and you definitely represent the ideas of carnivory well and I you know I've I've really enjoyed just eating more meat and it's delicious different ways to prepare it yeah it's absolutely delicious different cuts different ways to prepare it making making jerky [01:18:20] And you know preserving meats in different ways so that you know you have you know lunches and snacks already are always at hand yeah and it's there's a lot more for me to learn on that front but it's it's been really fun to kind of start down that rabbit hole and I think you know a lot of people always have the question of like what does how does that have anything to do with Bitcoin? [01:18:42] Because we just started saying Bitcoin carnivore and it became a thing. But you know, going back to you know, all of our beliefs about the effects of money on time preference. If if the carnivore claims about human physiology and nutrition and health are true, then a lower time preference person would tend towards a more carnivorous diet, by virtue of the fact of wanting to maintain their bodily capital or increase their bodily capital over the long run. [01:19:19] In which case, like it would be a lower time preference mode of eating, assuming that that we're correct. Of course, if we're wrong, then you know perhaps people would point being people will tend towards whatever the actual diet is that can prolong health. Right, right. [01:19:38] Makes sense. And there's the connection. All right, let's end in on some fun speculation, kind of bringing it back to Bitcoin. Million dollars. What? Yeah, price. Tell me that's all we really care about. I'm gonna cut everything else out and just publish that part. But what do you think a Bitcoin future looks like in 50 years? [01:19:59] Just for some fun speculation. Moon colonies. Nice. You know, grasing cattle all across the Mer American West. Thorium reactors dotting the planet with with Bitcoin citadels having grown into a fine patchwork of you know decentralized political experimentation. [01:20:27] That's the world I want. That's beautiful, man. I love it. I love it. Alright, thanks, Michael. This has been a ton of fun. I really appreciate taking you taking the time and it's really fun to get to talk to you. Yeah, thank you so much for the same. Anything else you want to if absolutely man, man. Anything you want to finish with? I'm gonna collect a bunch of these links in the show notes, but your you know your Twitter address and the Nakamoto Institute, any events that you have coming up that you want to share? [01:20:52] Yeah, so like us like you said, basically follow me on Twitter at Bitstein, visit the Nakamoto Institute, Nakamoto Institute.org. If you're interested in learning more about the Carnivore Rabbit Hole, I do have a website about that as well called Just Meet.co, which I recommend visiting. [01:21:12] And of course my my DMs are open. I can't I can't guarantee that I'll get to everyone, but if you ever have questions about this, I'm always happy to kind of give you my thoughts or or help you. I one of my favorite things to do is just help people find the literature that they're looking for for a particular topic they're trying to learn about. [01:21:32] So if you ever need any any recommendations of you know where where to learn some information, my DMs are open and please don't hesitate to reach out. All right, man. Thank you again, and take care. All right, thank you. [01:21:53] All right, that was a fantastic time. I have learned a lot over the years from BitStein, and I can't overstate how valuable the Nakamoto Institute's website at Nakamoto Institute.org has been to my Bitcoin journey. It is a trove of content, including all the publicly available writings of Satoshi and Bitcoin related research, literature, and articles. [01:22:17] You should make it part of your week. Every week. Just find an interesting resource on Nakamoto Institute.org and read it until you've gone through it all. You probably already are, but if not, go follow Michael on Bitcoin Twitter right now. He's at Bitstein at B I T S T E I N. Share the episode on Twitter. [01:22:35] Let us know what you thought about the episode. Tag both of us. I'm at Citizen Bitcoin, of course. You can also email me with any questions or thoughts or concerns at citizenbitcoin at PM.me. And like I said at the top of the show, it would be amazing if we could kind of collectively make a concerted effort to share the podcast in general or an episode in particular on Bitcoin Twitter over the next few days, next week or so. [01:23:01] Really create a lot of visibility for the show and help me with a little gross spurt right now as I try to bring in the first official sponsors of the show. If you're interested in sponsoring the podcast, please reach out to me via email. Again, that's citizenbitcoin at PM.me. Alright, thanks so much for listening. [01:23:19] I appreciate you all. Hope you all have a great weekend. That's all for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.