Phil Geiger: Revolutionary Scarcity, Bitcoin and Austrian Economics, Unchained Capital Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-12-06 [00:00:19] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin. Hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I've got a discussion with Phil Geiger of Unchained Capital for you today. [00:00:37] Phil's been around since about 2014. He's now living the dream, working for a Bitcoin company with other stars like Dreve Bonsal and Parker Lewis. Before we dive into this one, a word about GiveBitcoin, the sponsor of this episode. Alright, y'all. So the holiday season is upon us. [00:00:56] You're thinking about gifts to give to your family, maybe some of your close friends. 2020 is right around the corner. The halving is just five months away. So imagine giving some Bitcoin to the special prequiners in your life. The Bitcoin is time locked for a couple years. So in late 2021, when that time lock is up, if Plan B's co-integrated stock to flow model holds, like we're all hoping it will, your Bitcoin gift is going to make you an absolute fucking hero. [00:01:23] Am I right? So during that time, your recipient will receive a world-class Bitcoin education from some of the top educators in the space. I have tried to give Bitcoin out with a couple of members of my family. They've been holding out for a long time, hesitant to dive in, and give Bitcoin's combo of time lock and education gave them the peace of mind that they needed to take the plunge down the rabbit hole. So you should definitely give it a try too. Become an early adopter. You can help support a great new Bitcoin company and create some new hodlers in your life. It's a win for everyone. Check out givebitcoin.io. [00:01:59] That's givebitcoin.io today. All right, let's do this. Phil Geiger is the director of product marketing for Unchained Capital, the first collaborative asset management firm that offers loans and vaults for Bitcoin. [00:02:22] Phil contributes to the great Unchained blog with product write-ups and recently a great, very thorough piece on the revolutionary importance of Bitcoin scarcity. In this episode, we get into Phil's Bitcoin story, Austrian economics, Bitcoin's economics and the nature of scarcity, what Unchained is up to, and we talk about Bitcoin as a clock. [00:02:44] Phil's a great guy, and it was a blast to sit down and chat with him. Really appreciate your time, Phil. Alright, [00:02:50] Here we go. Alright, I'm really excited to welcome Phil Geiger of Unchained Capital to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast today. How's it going, Phil? Not too bad. Thanks so much for having me on, Brady. [00:03:08] Yeah, absolutely, man. I'm happy to have you here. You've been a longtime Bitcoiner, I gather. Yeah. So I've been a you know, a humble full node operator for about four years now. Consider myself kind of a hodler of last resort, and most recently working with Unchained Capital as the director of product marketing. [00:03:28] So when did you originally dive down the rabbit hole then? Well, I the pieces finally clicked for me at around the end of 2014. So at the time I was living in Madison, Wisconsin, and went to a local nerd night, which is sort of like an informal TED talk type event. [00:03:49] And a grad student at the University of Wisconsin just went up on stage and she gave you know a presentation about money, and it had enough of the pieces that it was able to just kind of click in my mind. So, you know, immediately fell down the rabbit hole pretty hard. At the end of 2014, I think I got my first Bitcoin around you know $360, and I was really excited. [00:04:11] And the next week it immediately crashed to $180. So, you know, the 60% dip. And then I've just kind of played the long game, just waited and started learning about the technology, started running my full node, and was was working my day job for a while. [00:04:30] And then you know, more recently was able to join up with Unchained Capital. So, how did you handle that 60% drop like a week after you bought in? I think I handled it probably the same way that most of us handle our first drop with Bitcoin, where you know you buy it and you're like, oh, this is kind of an interesting technology or whatever. [00:04:50] You get your first few sats and then it just crushes you, you know. I kind of view like Bitcoin is is a bit of a cruel cold bitch, you know. Like you have to you have to go through the trials in order to get the exciting gains. [00:05:08] So you know, at the time it felt like, oh well, there goes all my money, just wasted everything. But you know, didn't didn't end up putting any more in for a little while until I felt a lot more comfortable about what it was exactly that I had purchased. Yeah, that that's the it is Bitcoin is a cruel bitch, and I've heard it put that way before, and I think it's like a very apt phrase. [00:05:31] But that's how, yeah, that's how it forges hodlers out of us. And so if you it's kind of a great filter for creating hodlers. So if you come in and you have like a 60% loss within like a month or two after buying in, like, you know, half so certain people are just gonna be like, screw this, I'm out, and you know, not look at it again for a long, long time. And then, you know, the other set of people are like, all right, well, I'm in now. [00:05:53] I'm not gonna sell at this point down 60%. What I'm gonna do is learn about this thing, and then you're just you're sucked in at that point. And you realize that you know don't need to worry about it for several years. You just gotta hold on. Yeah, exactly. And you know, at the time I was I was a pretty big Redditor. So I was on the R Bitcoin subreddit, and you know, this is like January of 2015. [00:06:15] And there were some people on there, you know, the price had just tanked to 180 dollars from you know, 400, and it was at the end of the bear market from down from a thousand, right? Or 1200. And there were people on there that were like, I just mortgaged my house and put 40 grand into Bitcoin at 180. I was like, who the hell are these people? [00:06:34] Like, what is this and what's going on? And like it honestly made me feel a little bit better that there were these like super super intense people on Reddit just just like putting their life savings in those things. I was like, if people are this convicted about this, there must be something going on here. Yeah, I've been spent the next you know five years trying to figure out like what exactly happened with Bitcoin, what problem did it solve? [00:07:01] Why is it why is it not going away? And why is it still the most popular cryptocurrency? And you know, that led me down an even deeper rabbit hole of not just the technology, but of course, Austrian economics. Yeah, Bitcoin's got definitely an aspect of gambling to it. [00:07:19] It attracts some gamblers because of the volatility, right? It's up and down. And I think at this point, the major use case is speculation. That's not necessarily a bad thing. It provides liquidity to the network and helps bootstrap it. But yeah, there's that aspect of like, you know, just gamblers being attracted to the space. [00:07:38] Yeah, so were you, I mean, did you ever get sucked into the gambling thing, you know, shit coining for a little bit to try to make more BTC or anything like that? That's a great question. And I so when I first got into it in 2014, I bought Bitcoin and I was like, what's what's the what's another cryptocurrency that's the exact opposite of Bitcoin, or like that's doing a totally different thing than Bitcoin and stumbled upon Ripple. [00:08:02] And I was like, oh, this is this is the banker's attempt at making Bitcoin. This maybe you'll buy some of that. And so I've you know put some money into Ripple and that immediately died and was dead for years. Like it did absolutely nothing from I think it was like I don't even know, 2015 through 2017. [00:08:21] And then, you know, near the end of 2017 when everything was going kind of bonkers, Ripple just randomly revived and you know went up a few hundred percent. And I was like, oh yeah, I remember I you know put some money into it and I immediately switch it to Bitcoin. But now, like, yeah, now I just don't I it's either my understanding of Bitcoin or I've just been in it for long enough, but none of the altcoins are interesting to me at all anymore. [00:08:47] And I think like the reason is that I feel like they unsolve the problem which Bitcoin solves, and that is Bitcoin solves the problem of digital scarcity. Digital scarcity is like such a strange concept. And I think it can only be solved once. [00:09:05] Like, you know, anything after Bitcoin is just inherently not scarce because you can create an infinite number of you know, whatever token or currency. Bitcoin is truly the innovation there because it's scarce. Yeah, and you like you said, I think you can only do that once, right? You get like one shot at that, because if it fails the first time, then yeah, like you said, it it just goes to reinforce that you know there's basically an endless amount here. [00:09:32] You think yeah, the innovation was the digital scarcity, and if it doesn't work the first time, then you've kind of lost that innovation as well. Yeah, so that's incredible moat Bitcoin has going for it. Everything else is really just, I mean, this is the Bitcoin space. This is not a crypto space, right? That's why we always say that as Bitcoiners. Like that's why, and that's why this is a Bitcoin space. If Bitcoin doesn't work out, everything else is done for too. [00:09:52] Yeah, I agree. I mean, and you can just so what I've started doing is just measuring other things in Bitcoin. Yeah, and that gives you a much clearer picture of I think what's happening, and what's happening is that Bitcoin's crushing everything, like all other currencies, you know, gold, fiat currency, all other cryptocurrencies. [00:10:11] You know, any any of the altcoins, they just kind of follow the same pattern, right? They are released, there's a big marketing event, they they spike in value, and then over the long term it crashes, and all of them centralize. So I mean that's another one of Bitcoin's innovations is the way that it solves digital scarcity, is that it does so by increasing and decentralization over time in pretty much every every metric. [00:10:36] And that's crucial to Bitcoin's success, is de you know increasing and decentralization over time. Where do you think we are on that front? You know, I think the case could be made that we're not decentralized enough yet. There are potential prospects for a trend towards centralization in Bitcoin, away from decentralization, the centralized model, you know, custodial exchanges, et cetera, are just easier. [00:11:00] There's a lot of friction for comparatively for you know the self-sovereign use case. So yeah, where do you think we are and what do you think the prospects are for continued decentralization in the future? Yeah, well, I think just like with the you know, the price, we took we educate newcomers like don't look at the daily price because it's all over the place. [00:11:19] It's the most volatile thing we've ever seen. What's really important to look at is the long-term price or the long-term trends. You know, if I look at where we are today compared to where we are two years ago or four years ago, we are far more decentralized in nodes. You know, we're more decentralized in miners, miners are spread out around the world, our hash rate has gone up like orders of magnitude, the price is up orders of magnitude, which means that ultimately an you know, a larger group of people are using it. [00:11:50] So adoption is is up in I think everyone, you know, number of developers contributing to it. All of these things are increasing in the long term. And yeah, you know, for you know, an individual release or a given week, maybe we lose some nodes or don't have as many developers, but in the long term, you know, the trend's pretty clear to me. [00:12:09] Yeah, me too. So you went through that the bear market before this one, so the 2014, 15, and then into a bit of 16 as well. I guess in 16 the kind of started to ramp up into the 2017 craziness. But what are the differences that you see now in this bear market four or five years later than you saw in 2014, 2015? [00:12:29] Yeah, I mean, the 2015, 2015 and 2016 just seemed so quiet compared to what's happening now. I think you know, the Bitcoin subreddit had maybe 200,000 subscribers and now it's at you know 1.2 million. [00:12:51] There weren't really that many big innovations, and the future was really uncertain, I feel like for Bitcoin. Like, you know, big the block size discussion was happening at the time, and you know, people were were talking about you know increasing the block size versus potentially soft forking and using SegWit. [00:13:12] I was you know kind of lurking at that point, still like I said earlier, working my day job. So I wasn't an active you know, participant as as I am, you know, today. But yeah, like I think it's it's worlds different today. Like, you know, we have massive institutional companies launching, like BACT has just launched, you know, Fidelity just received their license to be able to custody for institutions. [00:13:40] We at Unchain Capital, you know, are are starting to build out our collaborative custody model a lot further, and we're getting a lot of interest in really cool businesses and cool clients coming to us. So like, you know, business is is certainly increasing, and the innovations that are happening are way, way bigger and I think yeah, louder today than they were in in 2015-2016. [00:14:07] 2015-2016 was pretty quiet. Yeah, and it seems like like you said, the infrastructure difference is vast over the past four years there were a few retail exchanges back then and even they were you know harder to use there's definitely more friction I remember opening a Coinbase account in 2014 and had a really hard time getting my kind of smaller regional bank to hook up with Coinbase to be able to send fiat in into the into Coinbase and you know as a consequence of that because it was you know there was that friction and I didn't have any conviction at that point I was just kind of a curiosity Bitcoin was just a curiosity for me yeah I just didn't follow through [00:14:45] You know I just kind of that that cut me out right there and so of course in retrospect when I found it in 2017 and started figuring out you know what was really happening here yeah I went and dug up that email from Coinbase and I was like oh my god I don't know why I tortured myself with that but yeah I remember I was like when was that how many years ago what was the price what what did I miss out on in the past three years yeah exactly I mean I remember signing up for yeah like Coinbase and Circle in you know 2015 and they would give you five bucks of Bitcoin which is now you know like a few hundred dollars worth so the thing is just like so volatile and so crazy and it just rewards long-term hodlers [00:15:23] So much more than day traders I think like if you can just be patient and you know stack sats you're gonna be rewarded you know that's the other thing like this whole concept of stacking sats is is pretty much brand new to 2019 like 2018 I think the end of 2018 was when it came out and you know now we have all these I think really interesting companies that are making stacking sats fun. [00:15:51] So you know in Australia, we have Amber, we have pay here in the US and Lolly where you just earn Bitcoin passively for making those purchases that you're normally gonna make, like, or fold. And I think even just today, Lolly just tweeted like the Bitcoin price is up 100% from last year. [00:16:11] Their user volume or the number of sats that people are stacking on Cyber Monday was up like 20 times. Oh my god. Yeah, like I mean, those those numbers are just it's just rocket fuel. Like it's it's inevitable. You know, we have the Havening coming out coming up, and still nobody in the world really knows what the hell's going on here. [00:16:31] So like what I do is I just try to figure out the most frictionless way to help people understand Bitcoin or at least to get started. Yeah, I think the tools are that are available today are just so much better. Yeah, and besides infrastructure, I mean obviously the educational material that's out there, the quality and the quantity, the sheer quantity of it is you know vast compared to four or five years ago. [00:17:01] People coming you know into Bitcoin 2017, like myself, 2018, have a much easier time coming up to speed and learning to ignore you know the shit coins and having a better kind of fundamental understanding of what's happening. Yeah, agreed. And you know, I think like, yeah, the just the quality of the content coming out is it's hard to keep up with. [00:17:25] Like there's so many good podcasts, there's so much good writing and blogging happening, and then there's you know, just like programming Bitcoin classes and books and all these kinds of things. Like I think you know, the Bitcoin standard for me was was when I really understood that like Bitcoin from an Austrian economics perspective, and from there I've like you know just expanded. [00:17:49] I started you know looking mostly at the technology, and ever since reading the Bitcoin standard, now it's like I'm diving really deep into the Austrian economics stuff. So it's like there's just so many better resources for people. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, the Bitcoin standard was you know seminal, and I think has become you know one of the two or three major recommendations from Bitcoiners to new coiners, and I think is was you know, same for me, it was instrumental in opening up that Austrian economics rabbit hole to me. [00:18:17] There's more and more Bitcoiners who are becoming introduced to Austrian economics through Bitcoin as opposed to vice versa. I think a lot of the earlier adopters had you know a higher representation of like libertarians and Austrian economics devotees than than not. The concentration was higher. [00:18:36] So you like you said, you've learned you've been learning Austrian economics diving down that rabbit hole. Can we talk about you know, segue into that, talk a little bit about your experience learning Austrian economics and you know how that's changed your view of the world and our potential future? Yeah, absolutely. So I was thinking, you know, back on my personal experience, like what was my first introduction to this line of thinking or this school of thought? [00:19:04] And I think it was Ayn Rand. Like I read Fountainhead and Anthem and Atlas Shrugged when I was in junior high and high school, and I remember really enjoying them and like thinking, wow, this is this is a different way of thinking. Then I kind of I didn't dig any deeper at that time. [00:19:25] I kind of moved on, but when I went to school, I studied economics but Brady to take your term it was default Keynesianism right like there was it was predictive and using math to try to model things and it really wasn't all that interesting to me because what's interesting to me is like trying to learn something about how humans behave or why why people act the way that they do or how to set up specific scenarios that that have economic incentives aligned [00:20:04] Like that's that's kind of what's interesting to me like the descriptive economics versus the Keynesian econ strollogy or whatever that's a good way to put it econastrology I don't think I think I heard that that term somewhere on Twitter but I just love it it's it's kind of what it is it's like reading the tea leaves and saying well you know if if every person acts like a robot then this is what we would expect but that's just not reality. [00:20:31] So you know Bitcoin and I think you can you can see kind of the breakdown of that style of thinking because nearly none of the economists from that school of thought have any language to describe Bitcoin like they they default immediately to just you know scams the mother of all scams it's evil blah blah blah because they just they can't describe it. [00:21:00] And so then I realized like, oh, this is this is useless. Like, what what are the tools that I can learn or that I can equip myself with to be able to better understand what's happening? And yeah, Safeine's book was was the first step. And then I fell into you know, like reading Mises and Hayek and you know different essays that are out there. [00:21:24] But yeah, I think like if you really want to develop a much better understanding of the world, like that's what I would recommend people do. And I think all those guys are just you know, and Ayn Rand to some extent are just like champions of peace. Like the reason that they're writing these things, so I just finished The Road to Serfdom like last week. [00:21:46] Like the whole reason Hayek wrote that was because he really really wanted to avoid the UK like falling down the same you know path or traps that the Nazis did or the Germans did, and to some extent the USSR, although at the time they were kind of allies in World War II, I think it was right during the outset or I don't know, immediately afterwards or something. [00:22:11] But but yeah, man, he was he was just like, hey, I lived in Austria during the rise of the Nazis, and now I'm living in the UK, and you guys are making all of the exact same mistakes. So that book is amazing. Yeah, I haven't I haven't checked that one out yet, but it's on the list for sure. So what's I mean just kind of going to the fundamentals, what are the basic principles of Austrian economics that have really changed your worldview and that you might share with somebody who's just asking you about Bitcoin? [00:22:41] Like one of the things that we really have to do is talk about because we are in this default Keynesian age, talk about what money really is, and Bitcoin has really done a great job of teaching us default Keynesians what it is. But like to you, if someone came up to ask you and you started, you know, kind of getting into this with them, how would you what or what principles would you know describe to them to help them understand what money really is? [00:23:03] That's a great question. I would say what Austrian economics has really helped me with is a couple things. First of all, you have to look at individual action. Like you must think about yourself individually or what you know an individual would do in a given scenario. [00:23:28] And in that way, most Austrian economics theories that I've come across can be sort of explained with just like a simple gut check. Like it should just make sense to you. So you know, when describing, you know, people are like, oh, Bitcoin, I can't spend it anywhere. [00:23:48] Like, you know, it's it's you know, there's nowhere for me to go and buy groceries with it or whatever. You know, I talk about, well, you know, given give I give them this example. Like, if I were to hand you a US dollar in a Venezuelan Boulevard, and assuming that you could spend either relatively easily, like which one are you gonna spend first? [00:24:13] And the answer is obvious, right? Spend the boulevard because it's losing value, it's a weaker currency. Hold on to the US dollar. And the same thing is happening with Bitcoin. Like the reason we don't see a ton of people spending Bitcoin is that there's a very high likelihood that it's going to increase in value in the future. [00:24:32] So it makes a lot more sense for you to use Bitcoin as a long-term savings currency and use another you know, fiat currency or whatever as your spending currency. And yeah, that's I think that's a pretty clear way to you know describe Gresham's or Theer's Law. [00:24:50] I always get those two mixed up, but it should just pass a cut a gut check. Like, how are you going to act? So the other, you know, and that applies to a lot of different aspects of understanding Bitcoin. Like it's really about how you as an individual, particularly if you're a full node operator, are going to act in a given scenario. [00:25:12] So I knew going into 2017, like this big block thing was a mess. Like I wasn't going to change my software to run, you know, the larger blocks, and I wasn't going to run SegQuit 2X. Instead, what I was going to do, and what I did during the time was I got my my BTC, I had it all you know cold stored, and then after the time of the forks, I moved my BTC from private key A to private key B, and then used private key A to sweep all of the you know forked [00:25:50] Coins and sell them. And for a while in 2017 and 2018, that's that's kind of how I made my living. So I had just left my previous job and I was like, how am I gonna fund my Bitcoin adventure? And it was through selling all these forks. So I got in yeah, I got very efficient at you know splitting my my private keys and sweeping them and then selling all these like crazy Bitcoin forks because I just knew like, oh, this isn't money, it's just an airdrop. [00:26:20] It's given to me for free. It's it's crap. So dump it. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I mean, it I agree with you completely that you know it the Austrian economics and the ideas of money are just kind of intuitive right once you actually think about it right and so the problem is that we don't really think about what money really is anymore. [00:26:42] Yeah. So we just kind of like just accept the way things are government's going to control the money that's the way thing things are now but yeah we have this you know example of like what money really should be and you're exactly right like that's the economic inevitability of you know the what I call the truth of sound money the truth of hard money will exert itself over time. [00:27:00] Like it's just human action economic incentive is to you know give up the fiat money for the Bitcoin the hard money and that will just happen slowly over time and take a matter of decades probably but you know money fiat's already shifting into Bitcoin and it'll just take over because of the truth of hard money it's better money the shelling point will happen right yeah I think like you know the other thing about Austrian economics is it requires you a lot of times to just be ruthlessly logical like you really you really have to look at something head on and dive down to the very first principles [00:27:38] Of it and it it uncovers unfortunately a lot of times a lot of uncomfortable truths about things so you know bitcoin for example it to me it uncovered like oh what we think of as money is is like this big delusion essentially. [00:28:00] Like this isn't real. Why why would I why would I store value in in a currency that where someone else has such a massive advantage over me? Like Bitcoin treats everyone equally. You can, you know, earn money, earn earn Bitcoin, or you can sell electricity to the network to transact Coinbase transactions. [00:28:22] But everyone is, you know, has a an equal footing with Bitcoin. It doesn't know or care who you are. And if you look at, you know, from the network perspective, every individual node is treated exactly the same. You could be processing, you know, hundreds or thousands of Bitcoin through your node, and you have you know, roughly the same technological advantages as anybody else. [00:28:48] Like from the from the network perspective, you look identical. And that's just not the case with other currencies. Like for us to earn US dollars, you know, it requires us to produce something that is valuable to other people, so produce goods or services. But then on top of that, there's just, you know, a layer of bureaucracy that skims off the top. [00:29:10] Yeah. And you know, there's those centralized, you know, middlemen that will, you know, have kind of a say they'll be able to freeze your account, they'll be able to deny deny certain transactions or, you know, kind of overturn them. There's they're all, you know, subject to the pressures of the governments in their jurisdictions, so governments can exert their, you know, force and through those centralized sources. [00:29:35] So the money is technically not yours, right? Any money that's in a bank, or you know, the same applies to exchanges, custodial exchanges with Bitcoin, that's not your Bitcoin, that's not your money that's in the in the bank. It's you know, it's just an entry and a ledger. And really it what it is is debt, you know, that's been resold over and over again. [00:29:55] And you, if you're lucky, will get access to those, you know, entries on some centralized ledger. As long as you know you're in the good graces of a particular company or or a government. Yeah, exactly. It's it's like a I think it was a Trace Mayer on on Tales from the Crip recently, was saying that it's like a master slave relationship. [00:30:19] You have to go to your master and you have to ask for the funds, and they can either approve or deny it. And then if you blow this up at like a larger scale or internationally, what we have is just a system of barter, you know. Like you want to do business with somebody from the other side of the world in the legacy system, you have to you know have bank accounts in two different locations, and then you're working with middlemen to get an exchange rate. [00:30:46] You can't communicate with them. You can't communicate value, which is the key function, one of the key functions of money is storing and communicating value. In the legacy system, you must work with a bunch of middlemen to be able to just accomplish something that two individuals should be able to accomplish without anybody. [00:31:07] And that's you know what Bitcoin then realows. It's a neutral, apolitical store of value that the entire world is using, is waking up to. Yeah, disintermediates that that whole system and disrupts everything and removes the middlemen. We can transact peer-to-peer without permission. [00:31:27] And yeah, it is a beautiful thing that will change a lot of the you know, the people individually and society as a whole. You know, that fact, the decentralization and the peer-to-peer nature, but also like we've been talking about the truth of sound money, will will change people's individual actions based on that that mere economic incentive that's not being you know I guess corrupted by the printing of money, the central control of the money supply. [00:31:58] Yeah, so yeah, yeah, I saw I saw on Twitter that you made a fan a presentation to your family over Thanksgiving, and man, that was I saw that and I was like, that's badass. That's awesome. Like there's a picture of you sitting down next to you know TV and you had your computer plugged into it showing like you know, like stock to flow graphs and stuff like that. [00:32:19] So tell me about it, man. How did that go? What did you present to them and like how do how was it received? Yeah, so I have my my family's been really, really supportive of my you know adventure in in Bitcoin overall, particularly my immediate family. [00:32:38] You know, I my immediate family were all hodlers. And now I'm working on on introducing these ideas to my extended family. So my my uncle, he his career was in traditional banking. So he's very, very curious about Bitcoin, although I think he gets a lot of his information from things like the Financial Times or from mainstream media. [00:33:03] And so he doesn't he gets like a you know kind of diluted version of what's happening, you know, he you know Bitcoin's too slow to be money, it's too volatile to be money, all of those sort of objections that that people spout out. [00:33:22] But he's very curious, and you know, for the past few years, he's been emailing me about it, like, hey, check out this article, check out that article. And this year he was like, Hey Phil, why don't you give a presentation to the family about Bitcoin? So this was by request. I didn't just you know force my my whole family to sit down and rant on for an hour. [00:33:46] But yeah, it's it's a it's a really it it was kind of a tough presentation. I've given a lot of presentations about Bitcoin, but this one was particularly particularly tough, I think, because I really really want my extended family to just understand what's happening. [00:34:04] I'm not I really you know don't care necessarily if they choose to buy it or not, but I really want them to at least have the tools available to know that like this is a really disruptive thing and everybody should be paying attention to it. So you know, I've I've talked to them about it for a while, like I mentioned, and for this presentation, what I wanted to do was try to take a more open-ended approach. [00:34:27] So I can just you know, I can give you how I started it. I started, I said, all right, well, so the title of the presentation was what is Bitcoin? And I said, Bitcoin's money, but more specifically, it's the strongest what was it? [00:34:51] The strongest, purest currency humanity has ever seen. But the deeper question then is what is money? And that's the question that most people don't actually have a good answer to. So I, you know, I posed it to the audience, like, what is money? And people were were giving me different ideas that they'd heard about, like, and they were able to ultimately get that money is a store of value, it's a medium of exchange, it's a unit of account, which is the I think like the Merriam Webster definition of money, but it's still not very precise. [00:35:29] Like the dictionary definition of money is like something that has these properties. So what is it? What is that? And you know, it was my one of my cousins who has recently read Sapiens was like, it's faith. Which is you know, I think faith might be a little part of it, but it's definitely not most of it. [00:35:51] So then we kind of talked about well, what is money? And the most distilled definite definition that I have is money is a tool for storing and communicating value. And just like any other tool, like different currencies can be better or worse at doing this job. [00:36:10] The best currency is one that is scarce, it's neutral, you know, fungible. All of those, all of those traits that we hear so much about. And Bitcoin is the strongest purest currency because it has zero inflation. [00:36:30] There are only 21 million Bitcoin. This is the first time that anything has been as scarce, it cannot be manipulated. So I think ultimately, you know, I at least was able to answer some questions, and afterwards my uncle came up to me and said, like, you know, I didn't really think about it in the context that Bitcoin doesn't exist in a vacuum. [00:36:52] And like so many of these articles are like, like, yeah, Bitcoin will never it can't be a currency because it's too slow, it only does five transactions per second. Well, luckily we have, you know, thousands of other currencies today that can help us with faster transactions, and we have different layers that we can build on it. [00:37:11] But it's it's missing the forest for the trees, right? Like the big issue here is that Bitcoin is still massive and growing in value and increasing in decentralization because it solved this problem of digital scarcity. And that's a really, really disruptive and strange problem to have solved. [00:37:30] Yeah, it is. It's it's almost like a miracle really that it's possible. And like I think the technologies that made it possible you know, had a found a root in, you know, obviously the internet and cryptography. And the idea to create a digital currency goes all the way back to David Shaum in the in the early to mid eighties, even. [00:37:53] And so those you know, ideas had been worked on for decades before Satoshi was able to put everything together. And I think one of the last you know, the last innovations that was really needed that Satoshi didn't produce himself was the peer-to-peer network, the peer-to-peer aspect, right? [00:38:13] So BitTorrent was created in like 2001, 2002, something like that, which sort of perfected the ability to you know trade files, but you know, digital goods or yeah, just basically just data back and forth with in a peer-to-peer way that was not able to be disrupted or stopped by a central central party, a government, for instance. [00:38:38] So that was actually working and you know, it needed to be employed to really develop this solution because we can you know peers need to be able to check the consensus and so that we can you know enforce that scarcity, right? And then the other you know innovation that Satoshi really came up with to make everything complete and bring and bring the whole package together was the you know the difficulty adjust adjustment, which is one of those strokes of genius that just brought everything together and made the you know hard cap possible. [00:39:13] Yeah, agreed. And you know, a lot of people have talked about the difficulty adjustment, but it's it is really just like so crucial to how Bitcoin functions, and kind of in that way, like you should always whenever you're reading any sort of articles about Bitcoin, and it's particularly articles about security, like a lot of times they ignore the difficulty adjustment, which is something that you just can't ignore. [00:39:42] Like the difficulty adjustment is Bitcoin. So I wrote an article last month called All 21 Million Bitcoin Already Exist. Yeah. Because I've just I got kind of tired of some of the mining FUD around Bitcoin, like, oh, in the future, you know, fees might have to, or fees will have to compensate miners and there won't be a you know subsidy or whatever. [00:40:09] But I just think that that's a fundamental misunderstanding of how Bitcoin work, because the difficulty adjustment always ensures that it is profitable for somebody to mine Bitcoin, regardless of the value of it. Like there's no, you know, in the beginning, you know, people were mining 50 Bitcoin per 10 minutes, and the difficulty was incredibly low, so you because it wasn't worth anything, so you can mine on a laptop. [00:40:37] You know, today you get 12 and a half Bitcoin every 10 minutes, and the difficulty it to mine is is incredibly high. So people are spending just massive amounts of electricity to secure Bitcoin today for fewer number of BTC. [00:40:59] So we get kind of hung up, I think, as people a lot of times on this idea of like a number. But what's far more important is the value of the currency. So the difficulty adjustment always ensures that Bitcoin is paying market rate for security. Like you can by changing the number, you can't you can't change the you're not increasing the value of security by like adding something like inflation at the end of the issuance schedule. [00:41:31] I think the takeaway from this is that like unsolving the problem of digital scarcity by changing the number of Bitcoin that are available is not going to make Bitcoin more secure because the only thing that we can adjust for or or you know the only thing that can change for Bitcoin is the value of the individual Satoshi and the amount of electricity that the entire network demands. [00:42:03] So changing the number is not going to just magically solve this problem. Like literally all 21 million have to exist today in order for digital scarcity as a problem to actually be solved. Like if there's any sort of doubt that that that number can be changed, then it Bitcoin hasn't solved this problem of digital scarcity. [00:42:28] So like how how does that make sense then in reality, you know, we know exactly where all of the currently locked supply of Bitcoin live. They live in you know Coinbase transactions of upcoming blocks. So you know at 600 blocks 630,000, I know that 6.25 Bitcoin live in the Coinbase there. [00:42:51] Yeah. So what you're doing then is is people are have two different ways of transacting Bitcoin. You can either transact Bitcoin by broadcasting a transaction and signing with a private key or you can transact Bitcoin by selling electricity to the network in a in what we call as mining. [00:43:11] So you're competing then to transact the Coinbase transactions but we know that we know at any given point in time like where exactly where those upcoming Bitcoin live. We have more information about upcoming Bitcoin than we do about what might happen with the currently existing Bitcoin. [00:43:30] Like I think just today you know somebody transacted like 400 million dollars worth of Bitcoin. We have no way of predicting that or planning for that but we have tons of amazing information about upcoming blocks. And then the other thing is that you know, Bitcoin is is as much social consensus as it is technical. [00:43:51] So you can even we can even assume that there's a bug in the future where a block is accepted that has a Coinbase reward that's higher than what we would expect. But what's amazing about Bitcoin is that then the onus is on individual full node operators and hodlers to decide what's more important. [00:44:18] Do we maintain this 21 million limit or do we accept this kind of faulty transaction? And the way that I would act and this is kind of going back to earlier sort of the individual action is I would view a buggy Coinbase reward as an out of consensus hard fork. [00:44:37] So I would just update my software to run software that maintains the 21 million limit because that's the social aspect of it. That's the those are the rules that I opted into 21 million, here's how they're released over time. And then this is I think that's just why one of the main reasons why Bitcoin's valuable because it has a rigidly fixed supply. [00:45:00] So any any sort of suggestion to change that I think is misguided. So do you think you do you see that that social layer that social consensus aspect of the consensus rules as a potential attack vector? Like I could see in the future that there would be an incentive for you know kind of let's say there's a mass adoption is underway and we're kind of on the asymptote of that S curve of technological adoption and a lot of new people are coming in I could see some like people advocating for and drumming up social support for the idea [00:45:38] That we should print more Bitcoin because it's unfair that all these early Bitcoiners bought up all this supply at at cheap rates, and so we should print more Bitcoin now for all these new people coming in to make it more fair for them. I mean, I think we see that today. We've seen it in the past, we've seen this this sort of idea come up. [00:46:00] And I would just say to these people, okay, do it. See if you're in consensus, try it, try it, you know, changing the supply. I know what I will do, what I will do is what I've done for all of the Bitcoin forks, which is I will move my BTC to a new private key, and I will take the old private key and I will sweep it, and then I will sell whatever new token is created. [00:46:23] Because that's my investment thesis is any fork of Bitcoin I sell as soon as possible for more Bitcoin. Right, right. In that way, and you know, I could be out of consensus there, and in which case I get totally wrecked. But coming back to what we said at the very beginning, like Bitcoin is kind of a cruel bitch. [00:46:45] If you're out of consensus, you're gonna get slapped really, really hard by Bitcoin. And we've seen that. We saw it with Bitmain, we've seen it with Roger Rare and all the, you know, all the forky scammers or whatever, like they just get slapped so hard. And because there is no recourse or no way to inflate the supply, bad actors in Bitcoin get taught a very, very expensive lesson. [00:47:13] You know, so if you if you sell whatever fork and you're on the out of consensus fork, like you're you're in for a world of hurt, and that's just how the market maintains the fixed supply. I mean, I think that the fixed supply is non-negotiable, which is you know, because I think that all of them already exist. [00:47:37] So changing that is creating something that isn't Bitcoin. Yeah, I agree completely. And you know, even if people do are kind of you know swayed by that argument that some people make make. And like you said, the argument's already been made by many shitcoin leaders already, you know, yeah, exactly. [00:47:58] So yeah, even if if people are swayed by that, you know, and there is some kind of consensus that's formed around that, and there's already many inflationary you know, coin cryptocurrencies out there that you can choose from, then yeah, you've got that you've got that truth of hard money that's going to exert itself over time. [00:48:19] And yeah, that's it. I mean, you know, in the long run, Bitcoin will win because of that, you know, that fact, that truth of what money really is. Forks aren't scarce. You can create a fork. I think I don't know if it's still out there, but there was this like Bitcoin fork creator software the online that you could just like in 10 minutes create your own copy of Bitcoin. [00:48:41] I mean, it's yeah, it's trivial to print your own money. What's incredibly difficult is to earn Bitcoin because it's 100% scarce. Absolutely. All right, let's talk, let's spend some some time talking about unchained. [00:49:00] I'd like to learn more about what you guys are doing there. Yeah, absolutely. And I think before talking about the specific products, what I what I'd like to talk about is just sort of the vision that I have, and you know, we kind of have as a as a company. And that vision is that I think even even a step further, like we believe that Bitcoin ownership is kind of a journey, right? [00:49:27] You buy your first Bitcoin from Coinbase or from Cash App or Earn It or whatever from Lolly or Pay. But you don't really you kind of own an IOU at that point. So after that, the first step towards true ownership, and this is what differentiates Bitcoin from like pretty much anything else, is that you can hold a private key, and there's absolutely nothing that anybody can do, right? [00:49:52] Like they can if if you have a private key, you are the true sole owner of that bitcoin. We think that that's kind of a one-way exit. Just like buying your first Bitcoin is kind of a one-way exit. Like once you first get into Bitcoin, I just don't think it's I don't think you're ever going to leave it entirely. [00:50:13] You might leave it for a short period of time, but probably not forever. But just like that. So once you hold your private keys, it's unlikely that you will custody or want to send your Bitcoin to another company in this sort of IOU account structure. [00:50:34] So unchained capital, we are trying to build a company using that as an understanding. Like people want to hold their own keys and they should. That's what Bitcoin ownership is. But we also believe that there is a present and future demand for financial services. [00:50:53] We think like pre-hyper bitcoinization, post-hyper Bitcoinization, there will be a need for financial services. So how do we offer those leveraging the inherent security properties of Bitcoin? And that's through collaborative custody. And collaborative custody is like multi-sig, but while working with a company or third party. [00:51:17] So it's developing a relationship with another entity and collaborating to secure Bitcoin. The first the first product that we offered was Bitcoin collateralized US dollar loans. So you would deposit Bitcoin into one of these multi-sig addresses into collaborative custody, you still get to hold a key, unchained capital holds a key, and then a neutral third party holds a key, and we're able to offer you US dollar liquidity. [00:51:46] So one of our slogans is friends don't let friends sell bitcoin. This is a way that you can access US dollars without having to you know actually sell your Bitcoin and incur those capital gains taxes. You can get a US dollar loan from there. You know, we expand it this year into our vaults. [00:52:08] Vaults are there's a couple different options. There's a two of three client-controlled vault, and then there's a one of three multi-institution vault. In a two of three client-controlled vault, as a as an individual, you still have full control over your funds. [00:52:27] You can move them at any time, you can spend them externally from our vault platform using Caravan. You know, we are just there to help as help by protecting our individual private key. For a multi-institution vault, it's more of a one of three scheme. [00:52:47] So if you're, and I think this mostly makes sense for maybe like a business, where maybe business as a business, you don't want to have full custody of your keys, but you still want to have some control over your funds. You can hold one of one key, we can hold a key, and then our neutral third party holds that third key. [00:53:06] But in this way, I think you know, at any point in time you can verify on the blockchain that the money is where we say it is. It's not being, you know, rehypothecated or you're not trusting unchained necessarily because we have we always provide you with the information to be able to spend externally since everything happens, but we're still able to offer you financial services. [00:53:31] So yeah, we just think that that's that's the at least to us as Bitcoiners, that feels like the most secure way to be able to offer financial services is through collaborative custody. But you know, just like when you work with any company, you know, you are giving up some anonymity, right? [00:53:56] It's it's always that balance, right? If you want to be fully anonymous as a Bitcoiner, you still can be, and you know well we release Caravan, which is our open source multi-sig coordinator to help those anonymous Bitcoiners like secure their coins using multi-sig, but without working with any company. [00:54:17] And then if you're if you're comfortable or if you want you know a third party as a backup, then you can work with us. But we want to develop a relationship with our clients and because we're all collaborating, we're collaborating to secure your Bitcoin. Yeah, I think it's admirable that you guys are putting out open source alternatives, you know, for Bitcoiners who don't want to collaborate with unchained or neutral third party. [00:54:40] About the neutral third party, like who identifies who that third party is? If is it unchained or is it the customer or something? Yeah, so today we work with Citadel SPV and they work as this function for you know a bunch of different industries, so we're not like their prime customer or anything. [00:55:01] But in the future, you know, we are looking to expand the number of key agents is what we're calling them to be able to work with. So today it's just us and Citadel, and in the future, who knows? You know, as we grow and as we partner, we'll have some more options. How do customers come to like trust that the third party is truly neutral if like unchained is establishing as you know establishing the relationship there? [00:55:28] Yeah, so at all of our clients, you know, before we issue a loan, for example, we sign an agreement and the third party has the standard operating procedures that they follow. So you're signing a contract, and this is where you know, frankly, like you have to sort of introduce the like meet space rule of law. [00:55:50] And we think that like you know, there there will always be that relationship that you'll need to have. And we want to live in a society where like you can feel comfortable working with a company. But yeah, you know, there's still certainly risk and certainly trust involved. [00:56:10] We just want to make sure that the trust is as reduced as possible. So to offer you know, to offer a loan, you're going to have to trust somebody. We just think that this is the most trust minimized way to do it. Right, yeah, that makes sense. And there's always, you know, there's trust is a spectrum in Bitcoin. [00:56:32] So you can there's always the option to run your own multi-sig, two or three keys, you hold you know, all three of them. And then you know, for customers who want to, you know, maybe give up a little bit of trust, a little bit of privacy for the you know, advantages of having a partner to collaborate with on multi-sig. [00:56:52] That you know, that's an option that's available too, which makes sense. So we really want multi-sig to get a lot better and more standardized overall. Like, we just think that multi multi-signature addresses are the standard. Like, if you want the highest level of security in Bitcoin, your funds should be in multi-sig. [00:57:11] Today it's it's tough to do multi-sig, it's just there aren't really good standards. You know, all the hardware wallets kind of have different functionality and different rules that they follow, and so coordinating it is tough. So Caravan is our attempt to help the community to rally around a tool that people can build off of and hardware wallet manufacturers can use to try to integrate. [00:57:38] But additionally, you know, we were thinking like, or at least I've been thinking recently about BTC pay server and Nicholas Dorrier, like talking talking to Bitcoin, the Bitpay, like I will bury you, or I think those are the words. Yeah. I will make you obsolete. Yeah. I think all Bitcoin companies should be thinking about how open source tools can make them obsolete and see you know how else they can service hodlers. [00:58:08] And like this idea behind multi-sig by itself, I think is is an open, it should be open source. It's already native to the Bitcoin protocol. Obviously, the tools to come to do multi-sig by yourself aren't quite there from a usability perspective, but I think they could get there over time. [00:58:27] But there's still, you know, so what do you offer people? Well, financial services, financial services that we don't think is something that can be done as effectively open source. So, you know, if you want to, for example, like pick out a loan, or in the future, you know, we're looking at setting up like group accounts or business accounts. [00:58:47] So if you're a business and you want to maintain some control over your funds, but you'd like a nice user interface, that's why you would come and work with us in collaborative custody. And then you're still, you know, you still are not giving up that most I we think one of the most important factors of Bitcoin ownership, which is your key. [00:59:11] So it's just a different approach. We think like for collaborative custody, it makes the most sense to develop relationships with our clients. Obviously that's not going to meet the needs of anonymous Bitcoiners, but we want to help them as well so we have caravan so you can do multi-sig on your own. [00:59:30] Right on. That's awesome. So okay, so Unchained offers these loans. They're they're backed by Bitcoin. Do you guys take any other cryptocurrency assets as collateral? At this point we're we're Bitcoin only. So in the past we offered I think we branched out to some other cryptocurrencies, but the demand and the hodler yeah the hodler demand just isn't there as in the same way that it is we think for Bitcoin. [00:59:59] So yeah right at the moment we're Bitcoin only. I'm hoping to keep it that way. But yeah that's that's where we are today. Yeah. Right on. All right. So if you guys are taking Bitcoin as collateral, I assume there's some volatility risk for unchained. [01:00:18] How do you guys reduce that? Yeah so it's a 50% loan to value loan. So like you know you if you want a 5000 US dollar loan you would deposit 100k worth of Bitcoin and as we know Bitcoin's price is pretty volatile so there's a little bit of flexibility but we do you know once the if the value of Bitcoin drops down to I believe it's 150% that's when we start doing margin calls and say like hey price of Bitcoin's tanking either deposit more collateral or you know start paying off your principal but get yourself back up to the 200%. [01:00:55] And then the opposite is true as well. So when the price of Bitcoin spikes up we allow our clients once a month and we'll help them author withdrawals so withdraw your BTC down to that 200% level but yeah and at no point in time is the is the Bitcoin being like rehypothecated or anything because it's all just living right there on the blockchain. [01:01:21] Right, which you can verify since you're holding any sort of keys and obvious. I mean it's publicly available information too. Yeah. Yeah. So okay. What other financial services are you guys thinking about offering in the future? Yeah, we're so we have a kind of an exciting roadmap. As I mentioned, what we're focusing on next is like group accounts. [01:01:42] So we really want to be able to offer Bitcoin businesses a good way to custody their funds without giving up ownership. So group accounts is are going to be that additionally you know we're we're gonna have things like joint accounts for you know you and your spouse or your partner can set up a joint account where on our platform it looks like you have the exact same ownership and then we're able to you know open this account under the legal framework of today so so that can be helpful and then in the future you know offering things like inheritance planning and stuff like that so selecting [01:02:20] So uploading information about somebody and selecting them as a key holder in your quorum and then should something happen to you that person can come to us and we can work with them to facilitate transactions. So that's kind of on the on the vault side in terms of additional financial services you know we want to we want to start offering cool things like potentially interest earning accounts but only if we can do it in a way where we can do it under collaborative custody. [01:02:52] So we're we're still trying to work out how that's going to function but ultimately we just want to provide financial products and services to help Bitcoin hodlers hodl for the long term. Have you guys, I mean, you're already providing some legal assistance in the terms of like setting up you know trusts or things like that. [01:03:13] What about taxes? Any thoughts about like providing tax consultation services to hodlers who may sell every once in a while and then incur some kind of tax burden. What services do you guys offer now that are like already help Bitcoiners with taxes? Yeah, so we've had some some conversations with some people in the in the like Bitcoin tax space and we're trying to figure out how to best move forward there. [01:03:37] But today what we have is we have statements at least. So you can you can check out like here's my vault statement for the last month and see the transactions and stuff like that. And also for loans. So for vaults and loans you can get your your statements. But yeah we you know as we expand we want to keep adding those different services. [01:03:59] So it's funny like in some ways we are sort of re recreating like the history of banking but under this entirely new paradigm right like under this paradigm where clients should have as much ownership over their private keys as possible. [01:04:21] So for every service like we want to push ownership to the individual Bitcoiners. So yeah it's just kind of funny we're like looking at the history of banking like where should we what what type of product should we offer next and then how do we build that so that our clients hold private keys right yeah yeah I mean it makes sense and what's cool is that like you know companies like Unchained will act as like a forcing function for the fidelities of the world and the larger, you know, legacy banking institutions to start practicing practicing the same you know Bitcoin standards basically. [01:04:57] Yeah, we just think collaborative custody is like the only it it it's just by far the best and most secure way to offer any sort of financial services because like the Bitcoin is locked in multi-sig, publicly visible and there's no single point of failure. And you know we've seen so many exit scams and exchange hacks and all of this crap because of because like a lot of the early Bitcoin companies are building they're they're building their companies like under the same security framework as the legacy system and we just think like you have to rethink it. [01:05:35] You have to be building these services leveraging native Bitcoin security properties. Yeah absolutely otherwise there's like no reason to be doing this right yeah yeah like I don't know I personally just wouldn't I don't I no longer trust like businesses that don't give me personally access to my private keys but you know I can foresee a scenario where I want to you know work with a company on some sort of financial service so that's what we're building. [01:06:06] That's awesome man. You know props to you guys unchained and keep up the great work. I think it's really important in the space and I think you guys are leading the way on all on all of those fronts. Thank you. Yeah I think our big initiatives in in 2019 have been like education so growing the number of Bitcoiners we've put out a ton of I think really really good content with the like Parker's gradually then suddenly blog and Drew's data science. [01:06:36] Recently we just in time for my family Thanksgiving Bitcoin presentation we put out our greatest hits page which is like all of our most popular articles and research from the past few years. So yeah growing growing the number of Bitcoiners is obviously good for us it's good for we think Bitcoin and then additionally like open source stuff so let's get let's make multi-signature the standard how can we get multi-signature to a place where it's simple enough for everybody [01:07:15] To use by themselves and then you know you reduce so many of the problems of self-custody which is you know not having redundancies so yeah so multi signal standard you know educating Bitcoiners that's what we did a lot in in 2019 2020 we're gonna push hard I think on releasing valuable products to groups right on man yeah you guys have done a great job on the blog Parker isn't is an all star Drew stuff is always like the data science is super valuable but you know he's always he always has some really fun stuff too just kind of getting cosmic and looking forward [01:07:53] At at awesome questions like like the mining horizon yeah he was the first person so I used to be like super toxic maximalist like Bitcoin is it but he introduced a limit like physical limitation which is the speed of light and now I believe that there will have to be additional currencies as humanity expands into the universe just because of the light lag and the benefits of having settlement in a in a local in a local like area or your planet or whatever so [01:08:31] You know the data science I think got me thinking a little bit more but yeah that article was fantastic and it was super fun to work with with Drew on on creating that and also with you know helping Parker out with gradually then suddenly series has been awesome for me I feel like I'm working with celebrities at least in in the in our at least in our little bubble yeah so I mean I assume you've probably done some thinking and like talking behind the scenes with Parker and Drew. [01:09:02] Give us some insight into some of those conversations like where are we going you know in the distant future long you know long time from now just for some fun speculation. Yeah so well I personally believe that Bitcoin has already won and I you know talk is cheap, right? I think you what and I and I do this through my actions like I continue to stack sats. [01:09:27] So yeah I for me like I don't see myself using another currency for long-term savings other than Bitcoin so it's something really catastrophic would have to happen for Bitcoin to go away. So I think it's kind of a done deal and so now it's just trying to like help people understand what's happening. [01:09:49] But you know in the future I can't really I don't even know what it's going to be like to be able to just travel anywhere in the world and not have to deal with a pile of like dirty paper and coins. So I think that's just gonna be really interesting. Like I feel like already Bitcoin has connected me with so many different people around the world. [01:10:11] And I've done a lot of traveling myself, just you know, personal travel, but since getting into Bitcoin more full-time, like I've worked with people based in Beijing and based in Thailand and you know in in Europe. And so it's like already my coworkers are just global, they're around the world, and it and it feels in some way like it's connecting us. [01:10:35] Because we have a common language, right? We have a common language of value that we can now use anywhere. So I don't know, I just see like a period of much more peace and prosperity, and I think like it's it's just gonna make governments have to be so much more honest and careful about how they spend, which can only be, I think, a good thing. [01:11:01] And yeah, that's that's sort of where I see it. I just think it's a driver for human peace and cooperation. The really cosmic stuff that I've heard about is and what Drove is thinking about is for his next piece is is the is the Bitcoin blockchain like a clock? [01:11:24] Is it is it tracking time in like a on the long term like an incredibly accurate form of time? So you know, because we have the difficulty adjustments every two weeks, it's sort of like this heartbeat that on average makes the Bitcoin blockchain super accurate, so over the long term. [01:11:46] Yeah, that's that's fascinating. I love thinking about that too. And I've I've spent some time thinking about the idea of Bitcoin as a clock. And I've got this little like meme idea that I hope will catch on over the over the coming years to sort of communicate that idea, which is TikTok next block. [01:12:06] And you know, plan B on Twitter also talks a lot about how you know like the stock to flow model shows Bitcoin sort of working like clockwork, you know, and sort in in terms of its adoption and you know the advancement of the price. So one thing I'm I'm gonna definitely be curious to read Drew's article about this, but one thing I've thought about is like, all right, how can we describe you know the blockchain as a super accurate like source of time when you know obviously like the block time is approximate, even though you know it's we're adjusted. [01:12:41] So it's like it's probabilistic, right? Well, yeah, in the short term, but this is where you know he's diving into some of the numbers, and it looks like in the long term, so over the course of years, for example, like it's super accurate. And then it's so funny because like this it's sort of mirrors like like you said, how Bitcoin grows. [01:13:02] Like in the short term, it's all over the place in terms of value, in terms of when blocks are gonna show up. Like it's crazy. It doesn't make any sense to us like our meat brains, but in the long term, like it's it's just such a clear trajectory, and you know, it becomes incredibly accurate as a form of timekeeping, and it becomes increasingly more valuable yeah, the longer term you look at it. [01:13:29] So it's all about just changing your time preference. And you know, we talked so much in on Bitcoin Twitter about time reference, but it's just kind of funny that you know blockchain is in some way keeping track of time, but only accurately if you have a very low time preference. Yeah, that makes sense. [01:13:49] Yeah. So yeah. So like you know, in a human kind of scale, you know, in a lifetime of like 80 years or whatever, and we're maybe thinking in days and weeks, you know, that's like a super short time scale, and you know, the kind of solutions we've come up with to coordinate with each other over that you know small scale is you know probably gonna stay useful in that context. [01:14:10] But you know, that's kind of an atomic level context compared to like the stellar level, maybe of you know, the blockchain being used as a box. So then it could be useful for like communicating time with like other you know civilizations or other stars or other planets, I guess. I wonder in some way we sort of have like a default Keynesian time. [01:14:32] Sure. Yeah, right. Like we're thinking in like days or you know, Twitter kind of speeds it up as well. Like I feel like Twitter, you know, if everything happens within the course of a day and like after a couple of days, it's just totally forgotten. You know, and in terms of like big business, you're thinking quarterly, but in terms of you're thinking like years or block like at least the smallest heartbeat, I feel like is the difficulty adjustment. [01:14:59] Yeah, every two weeks. Yeah, getting cosmic man. Yeah, yeah. I love it. Yeah, I lived in in Guyana, South America for a couple years. I was in the Peace Corps, and the idea of time is different there, you know, like it's a cultural thing too. So in America in the West, we sort of have this tyranny of the time of time and it's down to the second, you know, down to the minute. [01:15:21] If you know hop on to like a conference call at like 5 01 or whatever that's supposed to be at five, you know, you're late. You're considered late, right? If you don't get there right on the five o'clock dot. You know, whereas like in Guyana, you know, time was more relative. You know, the clock the clock wasn't watched, it was the days where it kind of started with sunrise and ended with the sunset. [01:15:44] You know, the bus came when it came. It wasn't you know, on a precise schedule, and you know, it it didn't matter, you know. So you'd sort of like plan to get together within you know like an hour or two kind of time frame, and people you just expect people to like show up at some time in that zone, and you know, you'd think like, all right, so how can we like live our lives like that when you're used to you know, like just really planning out everything down to the minute? [01:16:09] You know, and you end up filling that time with other things, you know, like kind of spontaneous conversations that arise, or you know, some extra time to dig into a book, or just some time to like kind of let your brain wander and think about things. And it just it kind of takes off this pressure to sort of compartmentalize your life according to the clock. [01:16:30] So, you know, there's other ways to kind of understand and interface with the idea of time for sure. Yeah, yeah. I think you know, you bring up a kind of a cool cultural example, but I was born and raised in the US but lived, luckily had the opportunity to live for almost three years in Europe, and there's so many different cultural differences that you that we don't recognize until we live in a foreign country. [01:16:56] I imagine you know, that was probably a really hard thing to get used to. For me, I was living in the Netherlands. And in some ways it's it's like more like you have to be more cognizant of time. So I didn't own a car or anything, so I was biking everywhere and taking the trains everywhere, and you have to be on time for your train, otherwise you're late. [01:17:17] But on the other hand, like everybody's late for trains. So if you're you know 30 minutes late to a meeting because you miss your train, people are like, eh, it's it's all right, time for a coffee break. But then you know, trying to trying to schedule like just getting dinner with like a local Dutch person, you have to schedule like three weeks in advance because their schedules are so booked. [01:17:40] So [01:17:41] Right. Yeah. Yeah. [01:17:44] All right, man. I gotta jump off. But really appreciate your time and thought it was a great conversation. It's good to spend some time talking to you. You know, it's after interacting on Twitter and Telegram and stuff for a while now. It's good to talk. Yeah, I had a great time. Thanks so much for having me on, Brady. And yeah, if you guys are you or any of your listeners are interested in talking Bitcoin or multi-sig or collaborative custody, feel free to reach out to me. [01:18:11] My email is Phil at unchained-capital.com. You can find me on Twitter at Phil underscore Geiger. Awesome. All right, man. Yeah, take care, man, and we'll talk again soon. All right. Later, ready. [01:18:32] All right, thanks so much to Phil for joining me today. Phil's doing great work for a great Bitcoin company, and I'm glad to have had the opportunity to share this discussion with you all. Let us know what questions and thoughts arose for you while listening today. You can tag Phil on Bitcoin Twitter at Phil underscore Geiger. That's at P-H I L underscore G E I G E R. [01:18:54] And myself at citizenbitcoin. If you want to reach out to me privately, my Twitter DMs are open, and you can also email me at citizenbitcoin at PM.me. You can support the podcast by sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter or with your family and friends. Send them some git Bitcoin with GiveBitcoin and that Bitcoin education that comes along with it, and tell them to subscribe to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast, and together we'll help you turn them into wise and toddlers. [01:19:21] Also check out the Citizen Bitcoin Layer One shop. Go to Layer1BTC.com. Click on shop partners, then citizen Bitcoin. Layer one is a great Bitcoin only business. It's run by Nick Ward, a great designer and Bitcoiner. He's got a ton more designs to choose from as well. [01:19:41] So check out Layer1BTC.com. This week's open source shout-out is the BISC network. Bisque is a decentralized Bitcoin exchange. In that sense, it's the most Bitcoin Bitcoin exchange. Bisque's mission is to provide a secure, private, and censorship resistant way of exchanging Bitcoin for fiat over the internet. [01:20:02] It's more secure because it's non-custodial. You don't have to trust the security model of a centralized exchange. It's more private because you don't have to KYC or docs yourself to use BISC. And it's more censorship resistant because it's peer-to-peer. Where Bitcoin's motto is be your own bank, Bisque's motto is be your own exchange. [01:20:21] So if you haven't yet, download and check out BISC today at BISCBISQ.network. Alright, I've got some fun interviews lined up for you all as well as we wrap up 2019. Watch for drops from a couple of my favorite Bitcoin designers and artists in the space, Brecke von Bitcoin and Lucho. [01:20:41] And excited to drop one with the OG Bitcoin educator himself, a man so many of us have learned from Andreas Antonopoulos. That one should drop just before Christmas as my gift to you all. Thanks so much for listening and being here, repping and supporting the podcast. Really appreciate all of you. [01:20:59] It's been an awesome year. I'm really excited about 2020. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.