WEBVTT

1
00:00:20.520 --> 00:00:42.600
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. Our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. One of the best ways I've found to learn Bitcoin is to listen to Bitcoiners who have been around for a while.

2
00:00:43.020 --> 00:01:04.620
I love the audio format and am a regular listener to many great Bitcoin podcasts and have learned a lot from listening to them. Those of you who have been subscribing to this pod for a while have listened to me and Tommy discuss what we've learned about Bitcoin for a little over a year now. I'm excited to start a new phase in the life of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast.

3
00:01:04.960 --> 00:01:34.440
I'm going to start hosting on the pod some of the best and brightest Bitcoiners for discussions. After spending a year during 2017 reading and listening to everything I could find about Bitcoin, and then another year co-hosting this podcast with Tommy, which has been a great forcing function to dive even deeper and a means for me to network among the community, I am ready and excited to start talking with other Bitcoiners and sharing these discussions with you all.

4
00:01:35.120 --> 00:02:00.960
So we're kicking off the Citizen Bitcoin interviews with a Bitcoiner who has been around for over five years now and has really shaken things up recently with his Lightning Network Trust Chain idea. That's right, Hodlonaut, none other than Hodlonaut, joined me via Discord today to chat about the Lightning Torch, his experience discovering and learning Bitcoin, the recent discussion about small blocks, and much more.

5
00:02:01.200 --> 00:02:19.140
I think it was a great discussion, and I hope you do too. And if you do, it would be super helpful if you could share the episode and take a minute to give the pod a rating and review wherever you get your podcasts. Thanks so much, and here's my discussion with Hodlonaut.

6
00:02:23.440 --> 00:02:48.900
So hello, Hodlonaut. How's it going? I'm fine. Thanks. Nice to talk to you. Yeah, nice to talk to you too. I really appreciate you agreeing to be the first interview on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. I'm excited and I know our listeners will be excited as well. We've got a lot of hardcore Bitcoiners that listen to the show all around the world and there's just no chance that any of them at this point haven't come across your account.

7
00:02:49.920 --> 00:03:09.820
So thanks again for agreeing to join. I'd love to dive right into the LNTrustChain story, and then maybe we'll go back and talk about the beginning of your Bitcoin journey after that. Yeah, sure. So I'll just take a stab at summarizing the trust chain from my perspective.

8
00:03:10.600 --> 00:03:29.000
I, you know, it popped up on my Twitter kind of radar, I guess, pretty soon after it started. And I watched it with curiosity and watched it being passed around. And it was, I thought it was a great idea. And it was, then it kind of like started taking on a life of its own.

9
00:03:29.180 --> 00:03:50.560
And Matt O'Dell really blew it up when he passed it to Jack. And we'll definitely get into that. I got to hold the torch a few hops after Jack, maybe a dozen hops after Jack or something like that, which was a lot of fun. And, and, you know, I got to say it was, there was definitely a thrill. It was really cool. Like, I mean, I wasn't anticipating that it would be, you know, so exciting.

10
00:03:50.920 --> 00:04:28.960
And it was just really cool. It felt like a part of history, and it was in a big moment. So, yeah. So can you describe the genesis of the torch? Can you take us back to that moment? The scene and some context—what were you thinking about that day? Why did you end up putting out the, the tweet that started it all? I had done a form of like a giveaway of sorts a couple of weeks earlier. Just, sending small amounts of satoshis to people who responded to a thread. And of course I'm…

11
00:04:28.960 --> 00:04:58.960
…very fascinated by Lightning technology and actually using it to send to people around the world. So it was just a random idea. I was sitting at home drinking coffee, and suddenly, yeah, I got this idea: what if I send an amount to someone and ask them to send it on and see how far it'll go? But I didn't have any ambitions with it at all.

12
00:04:59.280 --> 00:05:19.880
Just some fun. Right. Just sort of a game to play and see what would happen. Throw it out there in the world. That's what I love about it, though. It's so Bitcoin and it's so internet. It's kind of organic and just took on a life of its own from there, which is really cool. The organic thing has been very cool.

13
00:05:20.460 --> 00:05:45.980
Yeah. I think it's cool that it wasn't too much. Came to be as we went sort of thing. Yeah, it absolutely gives it some legitimacy, you know, that it wasn't some central, central planned, centrally planned, like PR stunt or something, you know? So it makes it more meaningful for sure. So why did you give it to JGG, JDG, at Fartface 2000, which I think is also great.

14
00:05:46.120 --> 00:06:15.860
It's like, you know, just another very internet thing that the first hop from, from you was to fart at Fartface 2000 on Twitter. Here. So why did you give it to him first? He was basically the first dude that posted an invoice that I chose to trust. I knew him from before. We followed each other and it was just at the time I didn't even I wasn't even aware that this that his handle was Fartface 2000.

15
00:06:16.260 --> 00:06:41.880
But I think it's really awesome that he ended up being first with that handle. It's somehow fitting for sure. So then in the kind of the early days of the torch, she was being passed around. There were a couple of people who kind of decided to sort of take it, basically start helping you out with organizing the trust chain.

16
00:06:42.160 --> 00:07:00.760
Somebody took on the creation of this spreadsheet to track everything. And somebody built a website to, show the sheet and made some kind of really cool visualization of the torch being passed around. Who are some of the people who kind of hopped in to help out, just to give them some credit?

17
00:07:01.740 --> 00:07:39.760
Yeah, bass underscore zero two was the guy who has made the website. And yeah, he just, I think he DM'd me and asked me if it was okay that he did it, and I was sure, go for it. Course i haven't had much to do with the website he's done it completely on his own so that's the website other than that vinda rd has made the google the google doc i think he's probably spent lots of hours on that navigating the threads and stuff i've

18
00:07:39.760 --> 00:07:59.360
Also maintained the document at home with the with the locations as well and those locations are what we used what I gave to Tai Kawamoto who made that awesome video. Yeah, that's it. That video is amazing. Yeah, it's such a talent doing stuff like that.

19
00:08:00.000 --> 00:08:20.360
Well, yeah, so the community starts coming together and supporting it and it kind of starts taking on a life of its own. Like I mentioned, Matt O'Dell of the Tales from the Crypt podcast, the rabbit hole recap episodes. He co hosts with Marty Bent. He calls out Jack on Twitter. Last week, I think it was maybe a week ago today, actually.

20
00:08:20.980 --> 00:08:39.980
Last Wednesday? Does that sound right? Yeah. Something like that. Yeah. He says, yo, Jack, it's time for you to take the lightning torch. And within 45 minutes, which is just amazing, the response comes back from Jack with just a lightning invoice pasted into the tweet reply, which is really cool.

21
00:08:40.320 --> 00:09:02.260
It shows that there's obviously lightning nodes being run at Twitter or Square or both. And we found out from Stephan Livera's interview that dropped on Monday a couple of days ago with Jack Dorsey that there are indeed people running lightning nodes and there's somebody kind of responsible for keeping Jack up to date on what's going on in Bitcoin.

22
00:09:02.500 --> 00:09:39.580
And this person found Jack and let him know what was going on and it got Jack's attention. And within less than an hour, he's holding the torch from Matt and the transaction works. Becomes kind of responsible for the best day Bitcoin's had in well over a year. I mean, that was just so much fun watching Jack just hold court on Twitter and kind of reinforce and reveal all of his Bitcoin maximalist tendencies and talk about lightning-enabled Twitter and Square and Cash App.

23
00:09:39.700 --> 00:10:05.220
And it was just super bullish and a lot of fun to watch. And observe. So yeah, it was maybe when we look back, even have signaled the transition to the next wave of price appreciation and user adoption. So you, you tweeted that that morning that you woke up and, you know, to find that Jack had taken the torch and, you know, proceeded to hold court on Twitter.

24
00:10:05.440 --> 00:10:43.740
And can you tell me about that moment when you found out what had happened? Yeah, just felt kind of unreal, for sure. I don't know. I had already realized that this, this thing had gotten some legs. But, I still didn't think, that would actually pick it up and proceed to—proceed to like basically come out as a Bitcoin maximalist. Right. But I think, I think Jack is, I think he's honestly very…

25
00:10:43.740 --> 00:11:04.980
Fascinated by this technology and rightly so like i mean he's in an extremely unique position as a head of twitter also invested in lightning labs right so he has knowledge about this technology and like the possibilities in the intersection between in Twitter and Lightning are basically mind-blowing.

26
00:11:05.220 --> 00:11:31.460
Like we can see new paradigms come out of this. Yeah, absolutely. And there's been a couple articles that have been published recently too that basically say it's not a matter of if but when that Twitter will enable Lightning payments or Lightning tips on Twitter and Cash App will add Lightning Network wallets.

27
00:11:32.280 --> 00:11:51.120
So that's just, I mean, just the reach of Square and Cash App and the number of merchants that use Square's services in the United States is huge. So that's just at the push of a button, you're enabling a massive network to use the Lightning Network.

28
00:11:51.440 --> 00:12:29.660
I think they basically will at some point be forced to implement it, or else they'll be eaten. In that respect, a little shout-out to tippin.me. Yeah, the tippin thing, the guy behind that has started working on Twitter implementation. Like, get a little, get a little button, inside of Twitter to easily, tip people right in their tweets. Also integrated with Lightning Joule, so it's very seamless. Oh, cool. So it's like a browser extension that will add in the button. Exactly. Nice. That's exciting.

29
00:12:29.660 --> 00:13:07.880
Yeah, so that will, that will force Twitter's hand for sure. And, you know, if Twitter doesn't do it, like you mentioned, some other service will do it. Just, you know, Mastodon or something could do it. I think so. Yeah. Yeah, so that's exciting. And then a day or two later, maybe even I think the next day on Thursday, the torch goes through the Blockstream satellite system, which was really, really exciting. I'm not sure exactly how that worked. I'm not sure if you do either, but if—do you know how a light—the Lightning transaction was sent from Pavol Rusnak, the…

30
00:13:07.880 --> 00:13:30.980
…CTO of SatoshiLabs, who are the makers of Trezor, to Samson? Like, did he—was it just sent, like the invoice sent as like a message through the system or something? Exactly. In the satellite API, there is the possibility to send one-kilobyte messages paid for by Bitcoin that are transmitted through the satellite.

31
00:13:31.680 --> 00:14:10.640
So it was only the invoice that was sent via satellite and then it did a regular lightning transaction. Okay, cool. That's incredible. So that was a big moment. And then of course, I got to hold the torch the next day Friday night yeah which you know it was was awesome and a fun time that night and then the last couple of days we've seen the torch go to CZ of Binance and Justin son of Tron so I think a couple of people you could you know safely call shit coiners or alt coiners or whatever you want to whatever you want to call it however politically correct you want to be exactly

32
00:14:10.640 --> 00:14:48.780
Yeah, so, and they've—to it, both of them, for quite a while. And there's people started kind of including—you were giving both of them some trouble on Twitter, which was hilarious. Then talk started coming up about forking the torch. Yeah. Away from—like, like let's fork it before CZ got it or before Justin got it. And, you know, while Justin, Justin was holding it for so long. Yeah, is that something that—I mean, you, you started sounding like you were kind of seriously considering the idea, and there was some ground…

33
00:14:48.780 --> 00:15:27.020
…kind of a groundswell. What are your thoughts on the idea of forking the trust chain? Yeah, I'm really torn on it. I think it would be extremely cool and in the spirit of Bitcoin to just, reward, that kind of behavior with the middle finger and just fork them off. Because, the way—what Justin did, like five, five tweets or something with, all his shitcoin hashtags and the Lightning Trust Chain, that was basically pissing on the spirit of the project. So, right, it, it would have been cool, but it would also complicate things a…

34
00:15:27.020 --> 00:15:59.000
…lot and maybe create a lot of confusion and stuff. So I think the best road was to just, just let them publicly show their, characters and move on from there. Yeah, I think that makes sense. It would be confusing. But yeah, I, I do see both sides of it like you do. It's, it would definitely be in the spirit of Bitcoin to fork off and, and, you know, give that kind of behavior the middle finger, like you said. Then of course anyone is free to try to fork the chain at any time. Right, of course. It's a permissionless chain.

35
00:16:01.620 --> 00:16:26.060
So then Justin finally passes it to Eric Voorhees, which, you know, he's sort of like, I think he heard a lot of this chatter and pushback against him holding it for a long time and using the attention to promote Tron and whatever other things he's got going on. He's like caught up with Vitalik Buterin on number of followers, which he was like just bragging about openly on Twitter.

36
00:16:27.880 --> 00:16:46.180
During this time. And, and I find it pretty funny that he sort of thinks as Eric is Erik Voorhees is sort of this, you know, hardcore Bitcoiner, which Eric certainly was, he's been around for a long time. But he was also part of the New York agreement, if I'm not mistaken. He was. Yeah.

37
00:16:46.740 --> 00:17:08.800
And of course, kind of caved into the KYC pressure with shapeshift and all that. And so you, you had a great troll on Twitter this morning. It says lots of love goes out to Eric Voorhees, who has tired tirelessly spent the last 12 hours KYC, all the people who have sent him an invoice in a heroic effort to get the torch passed as soon as humanly possible.

38
00:17:11.280 --> 00:17:33.640
So yeah, he's, he's been holding onto it for a while. I, I, yeah. So I don't know. I, this is I do want to talk to you about... Let me wrap up the Torch stuff first, because this transitions into some questions for you about NYA and UASF, and I want to get into that with you, because I know you were around for all of that.

39
00:17:34.540 --> 00:18:01.920
But yeah, just to wrap up the Torch stuff, what's the endgame for the Torch in your minds? I think some form of consensus has built around the idea that we reach the limit of 4.2 million satoshis and potentially do something cool, like one or two transactions more, either with Wumbo or just direct channel transaction bigger than the transaction limit.

40
00:18:02.200 --> 00:18:22.180
And then donate everything to BTC Venezuela. And on that note, I did a poll yesterday because I've gotten a lot of DMs by people frustrated that they can't participate. That they not get in because we probably only have, I think it's like 90 hops left until the limit.

41
00:18:22.360 --> 00:18:44.420
So of course not everyone will get in. So they're asking if there is any other way to contribute. And so I made a poll asking if I should make a Tallycoin Lightning fundraiser. So I'm kind of, I think it has 84% yes, but I'm still like kind of hesitant to do it.

42
00:18:46.260 --> 00:19:05.120
For some reason, there are quite a lot of people looking for angles to criticize this, and I'm kind of afraid that a fundraiser will be taken wrong or something by the community. Yeah, sure. That makes sense.

43
00:19:05.400 --> 00:19:26.620
But I do think BTC Venezuela is certainly a worthy recipient. They're on the front lines down there fighting to spread awareness and adoption of Bitcoin in a place where it's immediately needed very badly for real kind of life and death level situations.

44
00:19:27.240 --> 00:19:46.060
Yeah, I think so too. So it would be cool to get them a more meaningful amount than just the torch value. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, so I know I voted in support of the, in that poll of the fundraiser and will contribute if it does happen. So awesome.

45
00:19:46.560 --> 00:20:04.660
Yeah. All right. So let's head back in time a bit to the beginning of your Bitcoin journey. How did you discover Bitcoin and like, what were your initial impressions? What was that first like week or two like after you made the discovery?

46
00:20:05.900 --> 00:20:44.040
Yeah, I discovered it like severely sleep deprived, lying on the couch with, my one-month-old daughter, keeping me awake. So, and it was, —it went very quick after I, I read it as a mention in some article. I don't remember where. But it immediately clicked with me. I think I read the white paper either the same—and yeah, I just instantly became—I fell…

47
00:20:44.040 --> 00:21:06.080
Down the rabbit hole and wanted to participate in this thing yeah so what year was that? This was 2013 okay so this was right before the 2014 2015 was the last the bull run before this last one In price?

48
00:21:06.320 --> 00:21:15.820
Yeah, this was early 2013. So it was before the big run-up to $1,000. Okay. So pretty early.

49
00:21:18.660 --> 00:21:41.020
Is there something in your past that kind of predisposed you to just to recognize what it was or that it was important and interesting to you? Yeah, I think just a gradual red pilling. A lot of things like fractional reserve banking and global politics.

50
00:21:41.360 --> 00:22:05.600
And I mean, I had started looking into gold a year or two before because I thought it was a frustrating thought to be like to just have the fiat system to save in. So the scarcity aspect of Bitcoin was the first big thing that made me open my eyes.

51
00:22:06.820 --> 00:22:28.160
Okay, excellent. So did you over that period, I think everybody or a lot of people have this, but did you have like a shitcoin phase? Did you go through curiosity where you were exploring alternatives to Bitcoin? And did you kind of, I don't know, become enchanted with any of those?

52
00:22:28.960 --> 00:22:34.660
From day one, I've always been a Bitcoin maximalist in the sense that

53
00:22:37.340 --> 00:23:10.160
…true decentralization is everything, right? If you don't have that, it's just extremely lousy databases. So, and to date, no one has come even close to having the organic decentralization that Bitcoin has. Like, not even close. So I've never been a shitcoiner at all. Always been a huge Bitcoin maximalist, really, but I own countless shitcoin bags in an effort to increase my Bitcoin, with varying degrees of success.

54
00:23:11.680 --> 00:23:30.540
Yeah, it's almost an irresistible game to play. And I certainly played it in 2017 as well. It's a lot easier to play in a bull market than it is in a bear market, for sure. For sure. The shorting game is just less accessible and a bit more complicated to understand and all that.

55
00:23:30.860 --> 00:23:53.560
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so, you know, I don't know. I've kind of come, since I've become a Bitcoin maximalist, have come to sort of be a bit morally conflicted about using shit coins to increase BTC holdings. But just because it's like the idea of, you know, preying on people's confusion.

56
00:23:53.720 --> 00:24:06.440
But I sort of balance that out by, you know, publicly being very clear about the fact that these are scams for the most part.

57
00:24:09.120 --> 00:24:47.720
I've been going back and forth because I'm waiting for this next cycle and price to come and trying to decide if I'm going to play that game again or not. Yeah. It's interesting that you're like—the thing about calling out scams and stuff like that. I try to be about calling out stuff I think is, scams and lies, on Twitter. But I also don't like, —I think there is a very big tendency to binary thinking, black-and-white thinking in Bitcoin. And like, I don't see the—I don't think it's right to like call…

58
00:24:47.720 --> 00:25:26.360
…everything a scam because, yeah, I basically don't think it is. There are many—everything is on a, it's on a, on a scale somewhere. And there are shitloads of projects that I think definitely deserve the term scam. But calling everything a scam, I don't think that's very constructive. And it also kindles this very tribal thing that I think—we have enough extremism in Bitcoin already. I think that's a really good point. I have that same sense. I don't, I…

59
00:25:26.360 --> 00:25:52.980
Sort of have a natural tendency to respond. I think it's important that we keep a flexible mind and are able to see nuances. There's nothing to be gained by digging into the trenches and just having this dogmatic mantras that we chant together. Yeah, and it's difficult because the idea of a scam certainly takes into account intention.

60
00:25:52.980 --> 00:26:20.340
And it's hard to know another person's intentions. And I think it's also true that there are a lot of projects with talented developers that are trying a different approach than Bitcoin that could have a chance of working, I suppose, and an alternative approach that might actually be better.

61
00:26:21.760 --> 00:27:00.420
You know, I—there, I don't know. I—some of those are, I guess some of those are legitimate attempts. But once you do the research and look at everything, you know, I guess we both made the same calculation that you come back to: it's not—that's not going to happen. That's not going to work in the long run. And so I think the other maximalists that sort of label everything else a scam and are, you know, not—are just maybe their calculation is that it's, you know, a lot more clear and a lot more simple for people to understand if there's only a certain amount of attention that, that…

62
00:27:00.420 --> 00:27:21.920
…noobs, you know, are gonna, gonna put into understanding Bitcoin when they first buy in, then you should just make the message as direct and clear as possible. You know, just don't even consider these things. Yeah, that's basically what I'm telling—if anyone asks me for advice that there's a noob, is I always tell them Bitcoin. Buy and hold Bitcoin.

63
00:27:22.460 --> 00:27:31.080
And also it goes without saying that I would never ever shill any other kind of project than Bitcoin. I never have and I never will.

64
00:27:31.640 --> 00:27:32.080
Yeah.

65
00:27:34.140 --> 00:27:54.600
So you have your pinned tweet, I think is good. It says the moment you really get Bitcoin, what it changes, what it makes possible, you go all in. At least I did. No other choice. And that was tweeted on October 26, 2018.

66
00:27:56.040 --> 00:28:14.340
Do you remember the moment that you really got Bitcoin really early on? And what will it change? What does it change? And what does it make possible? Yeah, I think I had two avenues into making my first maps of Bitcoin.

67
00:28:15.880 --> 00:28:51.040
The one avenue was the scarcity, the lack of inflation thing, which really resonated with me and which was something I had been looking for. But also I've been using BitTorrent basically since I was a kid, or since BitTorrent became a thing. And I always really loved how BitTorrent enabled people to share stuff without anyone being able to tell them they can't.

68
00:28:51.940 --> 00:29:21.720
So my experiences and the limited understanding of BitTorrent was my entry into really grokking the importance of decentralization and how that gives us censorship resistance. And yeah, so basically the economic free speech thing combined with it being a very scarce and inflation-free store of value.

69
00:29:23.160 --> 00:30:01.300
Yeah, and that's the BitTorrent piece, or the peer-to-peer networking piece, was really the last bit of the puzzle that needed to be put into place, because there were definitely digitally scarce money—it's kind of ironic that the BitTorrent has been reduced to being shilled by [unclear]. Right. Yeah. Yeah. So they're releasing a coin, right? Or something like that? Did—I think they basically made a coin out of it. Yeah. Interesting. I, at this point, I just don't even spend time on most of these, you know, these things. I think…

70
00:30:01.300 --> 00:30:29.560
Yeah so i don't i don't know of the details of what they're trying to do, but that is pretty ironic. Yeah, so there were several efforts in the 80s and 90s, but they were all doomed because of centralization. And so the last piece that Satoshi put together was the peer-to-peer protocol that was inspired by BitTorrent and added that to the recipe, and boom, it worked, which is pretty cool.

71
00:30:29.560 --> 00:30:59.940
Yeah, but of course, I, I learn every day, and by no means do I have the full understanding of what Bitcoin is and what it makes possible. But it's a journey, and I think that that goes for everyone, because Bitcoin has such incredible promise and potential that having all bases covered regarding understanding is basically impossible. So we just have to keep an open mind and learn while we go.

72
00:31:01.080 --> 00:31:21.940
Absolutely. Yeah. And your, your pseudonym is very fitting in that regard, because we're sort of out exploring this new frontier altogether and trying to figure out what's going on. And, and so, I remember I tweeted, the day after Jack took the torch and all that happened, I tweeted that we're all hot the nuts today.

73
00:31:22.300 --> 00:31:52.880
And I feel like we're all sort of on this journey through the unknown together and trying to figure out exactly what's going on. It's pretty fun. Yeah, I agree. That's another thing that I've realized during these last three weeks that we are actually, there are a lot of us, there are more people aligned with what I believe in than I maybe was aware of.

74
00:31:55.460 --> 00:32:27.180
This whole thing is just basically the community making itself shown. That's really cool. Yeah, it is really cool. Yeah, I tweeted about this the other day too. There's a conversation between Marad and Matt O'Dell and Marty Bent on a recent episode, Tales from the Crypt, and they were talking about, and Marad was basically saying that no one cares about self-sovereignty.

75
00:32:28.840 --> 00:33:07.140
When he says no one, he means very few people, not enough people to really move the market. That's not why Bitcoin is valuable or the way the price is going to move. There's a huge amount of people out there that care about self-sovereignty. I think he might be underestimating the number of people who that idea resonates with and the number of people who who will resonate with that idea when it's presented to them the idea of the separation of money and states and this alternative view of economics that you know most of us if you know went to college or or

76
00:33:07.140 --> 00:33:25.440
Got economics lessons in high school you're taught the Keynesian line like that's really what but there's no other alternative the idea of Austrian economics is not me. Yeah. Yeah. And so we're all kind of default Keynesians at this point.

77
00:33:25.500 --> 00:33:43.500
And the whole world is operating under this approach, this economic approach, which makes sense. Governments are attracted to the idea that, you know, an economic philosophy that says that they should have power and central control over the money supply, right?

78
00:33:44.620 --> 00:34:14.500
And gives kind of gives them cover for that power grab. So it makes sense. And I think that there will be an awakening that Bitcoin is bringing in waves, right? And when it's easy to be self-sovereign and the user experience and the user interfaces are simple and understandable and easy to use, and we're getting closer to that with hardware wallets and hardware nodes.

79
00:34:14.940 --> 00:34:40.740
You know, it's the Casa node that I have. The experience has been great. It's very simple to use. Yeah. So I think the combination of, you know, technology and the increasing awareness of Bitcoin will reveal a large market for self-sovereignty, financial self-sovereignty.

80
00:34:42.120 --> 00:34:43.560
Yeah, I hear you. And

81
00:34:43.900 --> 00:35:16.940
I mean, exactly how and when this will play out is very hard to say, but I do think Murad is being a little bit overconfident in estimating exactly what moves around in the deeper Bitcoin consciousness. Also, I think that this time in history is we're at some form of cross point with a lot of different stuff driving what could be broader enlightenment on some issues.

82
00:35:17.320 --> 00:35:40.980
Like just look at all the outrage that Joe Rogan got after he had Jack on because people felt he didn't address the censorship issues good enough. So like as soon as Bitcoin is explained by the right people in a way, that people can grow up, I think things could potentially move pretty fast.

83
00:35:41.980 --> 00:36:01.360
Yeah. It'll definitely be fascinating to see what happens and be a part of it. Yeah. So who was or is what Bitcoiners were influential or economists, I guess as well, were influential to your current understanding of Bitcoin?

84
00:36:01.600 --> 00:36:37.580
Who do you listen to learn from? Yeah like i'm not i'm not the most technical guy i think possibly what has been my the reason i have been able to navigate at least in the beginning to navigate well in the space is my ability to see bullshit and to see people that are not being sincere so So I remember back to like three, four years, maybe four years ago when I thought Gavin Andresen was like a good guy.

85
00:36:38.180 --> 00:37:16.300
And the way—but pretty soon after he started pushing for big blocks, I think it became pretty apparent that he had an agenda, and he wasn't being sincere. And so the people that have consistently been sincere and have turned out to be people I can use to navigate by is like—I can think of Giacomo Zucco. He's like a super solid guy. Pierre Rochard, Francis Pouliot. Yeah, that—those are some, some names that have been valuable to me. Excellent. How do you, I guess…

86
00:37:16.300 --> 00:37:38.420
…a good way to put it is, what do you—what have you learned about how to learn Bitcoin, over the, over the five-plus years that you've been studying it? When you say how to learn Bitcoin, do you mean like the best approach to, to get into it and get a mental map on what it is? Absolutely, yeah, exactly. Yeah.

87
00:37:41.120 --> 00:38:19.900
Basically to, to use it, I think. To, send transactions and, like, reflect on what you are actually doing and how there's all of a sudden there is no, no, no one in the middle, okaying this. I think Lightning is pretty powerful there, because it, it's instant, and the custodial wallets are easy to use, so people feel like, kind of empowered using them. Right. I, I've shown it to some family members that have been rather…

88
00:38:19.900 --> 00:38:38.380
Uninterested in Bitcoin. But Lightning has made them kind of open their eyes a little bit more. So basically, to understand Bitcoin, I think you need to use it. Sure, that makes sense.

89
00:38:38.960 --> 00:39:01.500
And then you'll find, I guess, through that, and after you sort of have some skin in the some Bitcoin and using it, you'll be sort of led or inspired to understand it better or not. Not that every user needs to really dive deep and go down the rabbit hole to use it. But I think that there are a lot of people who want to after they are exposed to it.

90
00:39:02.140 --> 00:39:23.320
Yeah. I think it's like how easy it is to get Bitcoin depends a lot of where in the world you are. It's much easier for Venezuelan to understand why Bitcoin is important than it is for a Norwegian. Because in my country, we're just used to everything working and people trust the authorities.

91
00:39:23.780 --> 00:39:32.380
And they're very much like, but why do I need this? I have these other systems that work. Right. Yeah.

92
00:39:35.620 --> 00:40:01.260
So the last topic that I want to get into with you for our discussion today is this recent discussion about small blocks. All right. Yeah. Yeah. So the past week or so, there's been a Twitter discussion going around amongst Bitcoiners about decreasing the block size, a soft fork to decrease the block size to the number I've seen thrown around is 300 kilobytes.

93
00:40:01.260 --> 00:40:23.380
I think that's come from Luke Dash Jr.'s research and proposals. You've been active in the discussion. I saw you asking for more study and aggregation and presentation of the arguments for and against. So they're kind of in one place instead of strewn about Twitter and hard to find. You seem to be in the keep it at one megabyte camp.

94
00:40:24.180 --> 00:40:47.560
And my early guess is that the consensus will already has formed around keep it at one megabyte. I think the whole block size debate that we went through in 2017 and prior to that was going on for years, the consensus there was not necessarily that increasing the block size was bad.

95
00:40:47.860 --> 00:41:09.800
Although there was that. I mean, that argument was made. But I think the consensus was really, let's just keep it the same. There's no reason to change it right now. That was a big factor. Right. Yeah. Well, I mean, the hard fork, right? Big difference. So that is a big difference in this discussion is that a decrease in the block size is a soft fork, and that's a major difference.

96
00:41:11.560 --> 00:41:49.740
What's your take at this point? Do you think it's worth discussing, or is this just kind of a pointless distraction and might cause more harm than good that could be done from having the discussion? Yeah i think it's very good to discuss it i think nothing should be off the table for discussion for sure i do think it's extremely premature and potentially dangerous to push it the way it's been being pushed now like actually trying to make this uasf happen i am of the opinion that the most

97
00:41:49.740 --> 00:42:28.620
…dangerous attack vector for Bitcoin is this, is the social one. And the creating division and uncertainty within the community again at this point is very misguided, I think. And I think 2019 is going to be a key year for adoption. And instead of now riding the wave of all this amazing infrastructure that has been put in place in the bear market, that we shall once again give the mainstream another huge rift and conflict based…

98
00:42:28.620 --> 00:42:47.100
On a perceived and very unproven theory of how this will play out. I don't like it. I think it's dangerous. And yeah, I think we need much more clarity and data on this before we make any kind of moves.

99
00:42:47.780 --> 00:43:15.420
Yeah, so the idea is that, I mean, I've found some of the threads where Lucas talked about this, and it sounds like the idea is mainly that there will be a syncing issue in the future as the blockchain grows in size if we keep the one megabyte limit, and that we should restrict it now so that it doesn't grow so fast and we prevent that from becoming an issue.

100
00:43:17.100 --> 00:43:40.900
He's talking a lot about the initial block download. Okay. Sinking, yeah. Right, yeah. So right now the chain is like 220 gigs or so. Yeah. And it does take some time to download. If you're on broadband, it's not terrible. And that's, you know, obviously access to broadband is improving all the time.

101
00:43:40.900 --> 00:44:02.080
We have 5G coming online. And that wireless technology is more easy to install as infrastructure in poor and rural parts of the world where we want to make sure that the ability to run a node is available there as well.

102
00:44:02.480 --> 00:44:26.660
And I agree with all of those principles. I guess my initial understanding of the numbers doesn't seem to make the situation seem super dire. No, I mean, I think we need to have at least two things clear in this discussion, and that is if we change the block size to 300k instead, nothing will change short term.

103
00:44:27.060 --> 00:45:04.940
It won't be a magical button. We will still have the same size of the blockchain. It will take several years before any meaningful difference between those two chains will be there. Also at a certain point down the road i'm not sure exactly how many years and i'm sure that is also up for discussion at some point the increases in in tech advancements like bandwidth and the processing power will outpace the percentage growth of the blockchain like the percentage growth of the blockchain will decrease every year and the increase in

104
00:45:04.940 --> 00:45:06.940
Tech advancement will stay

105
00:45:08.040 --> 00:45:27.220
Pretty much the same. So at a certain point, this won't be an issue anymore. So rushing into this blockchain decrease right now when nothing will be solved the moment we do it, we have to have a big discussion about this if we ever are to do it.

106
00:45:28.000 --> 00:45:49.640
Yeah, and just to give some context to what it would mean, Can you talk about the UASF during the block size debates? Because you were around during that time. I think your Hodlonaut account goes back to early 2017. Is that right? And you were probably on Twitter with a different account before that, I would imagine.

107
00:45:50.540 --> 00:46:12.660
Yeah, that's true. Yeah. So you were definitely around during the whole UASF. Can you talk about that process? What is a UASF and how would, if someone or if the community really did start rallying around this idea, how would it come to actually exist?

108
00:46:13.880 --> 00:46:38.140
A block size decrease. The UASF in 2017, it was all about forcing the hands of the miners. Because the miners were claiming that they had the consensus, right? In reality, social consensus and economic consensus was behind activating SegWit.

109
00:46:38.440 --> 00:46:56.620
So it was just a way out of this standstill situation. And Litecoin had proved a month or two earlier that that was a way to actually put pressure on the miners by activating SegWit before Bitcoin.

110
00:46:57.440 --> 00:47:24.420
But yeah, this time I haven't, I haven't looked too much into the technical side of how this new proposal works. But basically I think they just start enforcing—like the nodes running the UASF code will just start enforcing—I think it's maximum 600k block weight or something, which amounts to 300 kilobyte on disk.

111
00:47:27.960 --> 00:47:47.180
So, yeah, I don't think I'm the right guy to ask to give you a deep explanation on Luke's code. Sure, right. No, I wasn't really asking that, but just the process of how a user-activated soft fork works. So it's...

112
00:47:47.180 --> 00:48:08.380
It works by nodes running the soft fork code and enforcing new rules. Okay. So in this case, Bitcoin Core would add Luke's code to soft fork to a decreased block size.

113
00:48:09.720 --> 00:48:30.260
Or Luke would fork Bitcoin Core and create his own implementation and node software that would implement the soft fork and those who support the idea would start running that software. That's basically how it works. Yeah, as far as I understand, that's exactly how it works.

114
00:48:30.380 --> 00:48:49.500
In this case, I would be very surprised if Core implemented it. So I think you would have to fork it. Right, yeah. Cool. All right. So thank you again so much for taking the time to join all of us today on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. It was a lot of fun having you as a first interview.

115
00:48:49.660 --> 00:49:27.780
Thanks for inviting me. Yeah. Is there anything that you would like to wrap up with that you want to, any word that you want to share with the audience or? Yeah, maybe I'd like to say that I think it's very important that we try to avoid the divisive going forward because I've seen tendencies that people who basically agree on 99% of stuff end up in pretty divisive discussions and that we just remember to have a respectful debate around

116
00:49:27.780 --> 00:49:46.660
This block size reduction proposal and potentially other stuff that shows up because yeah, between being honest and critical and also trying to build bridges. Absolutely. It's a good message to end on.

117
00:49:47.160 --> 00:50:06.400
Thanks a lot for joining us, Hodlonaut. Take care. Thank you, man. All right. So that was my discussion with Hodlonaut, the first of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast interviews. So what do you think? Let me know on Twitter. You can find us at Citizen Bitcoin.

118
00:50:08.380 --> 00:50:32.400
Discussion. I had a lot of fun talking to Hodlonaut. It was really good to get to know him a little better during this process, setting up the interview and obviously having the discussion. So if you enjoyed today's podcast, it would be a huge help for Citizen Bitcoin if you would take a minute to leave a rating and review wherever you get your podcasts.

119
00:50:32.420 --> 00:50:54.040
We don't have too many right now. And so just a handful of them will make a big difference in terms of the visibility of the podcast. So if you did appreciate it, it would be awesome if you took a moment to rate and review. And if you do ping me on Twitter and I'll give you a shout out for doing so really appreciate the help if you haven't been to do so.

120
00:50:54.540 --> 00:51:06.020
So that's it for today. Look forward to some more interview episodes and I'll be back with Tommy for a news kind of roundup episode again, hopefully next week. Take care, everyone. Bye.
