Ethereum: Is it a Security? Is it Secure? Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2018-05-03 [00:00:22] Hello and welcome back to another episode of Citizen Bitcoin, the show where we help you along that path to becoming a good citizen of Bitcoin, a sovereign citizen of Bitcoin, a holder of your private keys and your own wealth, censorship resistant wealth. [00:00:40] Tommy, it's my birthday today. It's your birthday? You didn't tell you. It's his birthday, boy. Happy birthday. Alright. And that's thinking back to last year, around my birthday. This is when I forgot you told me it was your birthday. Yeah a couple days ago. Yeah. We're gonna go watch the Arsenal Atletico Madrid match. [00:01:02] Birthday lunch. Looking forward. Birthday lunch, which should be pretty good. Looking forward to Arsenal baby, go gunners. Looking forward to some Europa League action today. Alright, anyway, yeah. So it reminded me that last year around this time was when I started becoming aware of Bitcoin again. [00:01:21] Of course, I kind of had some touch points over the years with it. I remember looking back, so I saw I saw it again, the price started rising about this time last year and caught my attention again. I started watching it. I bought a little bit of Bitcoin toward the end of May last year. It was under 3,000, wasn't it? [00:01:39] It was 1800 to 3,000. Yeah, toward the yeah, right right a [00:01:43] Around that I think. Yeah, there were some people that, it was about the time when a [00:01:46] Bunch of people declared it was. Yeah, there were some people. Which that's happening again now, but anyway, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it broke an all-time high, the previous all-time high from 2014, 2013, I guess. And so started getting some attention and started watching it. So it's been almost a year now that I've been really seriously into Bitcoin. [00:02:07] Wow, what a year it's been. What a year it's been. It's quite a ride from the end of the summer through the fall through the winter, up to that mania peak of almost 20 grand per coin. Then the alt season, alt season came on, and then of course the bear market, which we hopefully have seen the bottom in now, about 6500. [00:02:33] But we have a low time preference, so that's okay. Oh, yeah. We're just this is all just entertainment at this point. It's the nice thing about being low time preference, not really caring too much about what the short term is. Low stress, strong hands. So, glad you're here today, and we're excited to continue to share our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes your journey a little bit easier. [00:02:59] You can find us on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin, medium at citizenbitcoin, and we've got the YouTube version of the show where you can see the tabs that we're working from and the and the information we're showing on the screen. Audio only, podcast. You can find that at citizenbitcoin.simplecast.fm. [00:03:22] Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, wherever you get your podcasts. Just search for Citizen Bitcoin in your podcast app. Alright, so today we're actually gonna take a break from focusing on Bitcoin and take a look at well, we'll talk definitely be talking Bitcoin, but we take a kind of a holistic view of the ecosystem here. [00:03:40] And while we focus on Bitcoin, believing that's sort of it's the driver of this entire space of the crypto economy, and is the coin that has the best, clearly the best long-term potential in our opinion. It's also very important to stay aware of the other players, especially the more serious players. [00:04:01] Ethereum is certainly one of those. Well, and Ethereum's got some significant issues right now in terms of which is what we're gonna cover and also just get into Ethereum a little bit because it's it's important to understand Ethereum as it relates to this whole whole situation. [00:04:20] Our preference would be that Ethereum would would be able to be lockstep with Bitcoin in order to grow the entire crypto asset area. It's just that there's some there's a couple things we're gonna cover on Ethereum, which are problematic, we think. So I think long term you know, I'm I'm it's becoming more and more of a Bitcoin maximalist as the days go by. [00:04:47] In fact, when I first started getting back into Bitcoin, I discovered Ethereum. I hadn't even heard of it really until about a year ago. And you know, I fanboyed pretty hard for a while in Ethereum. I think you probably remember that. Yeah. Watching Vitalik all over you, you know, basically all those YouTube videos talking about Ethereum and the world's game. [00:05:10] Similar to your fanboy with Elon Musk. It's a little bit of a except that's you know, we would have to have a whole different show, but we were discussing I got I got out of Teslo a couple months ago, so I timed that one down. Yeah, so in terms of skin of the game, so you know, our our view in my my view at on Tesla, which is I'm a Tesla skeptic, is is particularly confirmed after yesterday's earnings call and yesterday's earnings were released. [00:05:36] Anyway. [00:05:37] Tommy thinks it's going to be a pretty spectacular blow-up for Tesla sometime this year, as he likes to... [00:05:46] More or less later in the year buddy, his Twitter buddy Mark Yusko like to hashtag no skid marks. They're not even gonna try to stop, they're just gonna plow into that wall full speed. No skid marks. Yeah, that's right. And that's that's Marks, and there's also another very very good person on Tesla, Charlie Grant, which is Wall Street Journal or he's fantastic. [00:06:09] Alright, so yeah, so I was fanboying pretty hard on on Ethereum for a while there. And you know, over the over the year transitioned more and more into agreeing with the Bitcoin maximalist argument that we'll have one winner, one major winner. There might be some tokens that sort of fill in the space on the long tail, but this is at least an 80-20 situation where Bitcoin will get, you know, the winner or will get 80% of at least of the of the action. [00:06:41] But you know, maybe even there's an argument that it's understandable to say that it'll be close to a hundred percent, if not exactly a hundred percent, because how many how many people are using TCPI alternatives right now. Right, right. And the issue with the all Ethereum, and this is generally getting into is you have a situation with Ethereum where where it's a it's a pre-mine, right? [00:07:01] I mean it's pretty much a pre-mine coin. Pre what is a pre-mine, Tommy. Well it's what do you mean by that? Well, it it's just it's not well if you look at Bitcoin, Bitcoin just started from from nothing and grew out of in it's a software and you had developers that developed it. Pre mine is is that you have the amounts set without any type of mining and it's it's a group that put well in this particular Yeah, there's a before before the coin starts to be mined for distribution, right of the of the coin, there are investors who are able to buy the token before it starts being mined, right? [00:07:39] That's a pre-mine. Yep. Rights. And of course when Bitcoin launched, it just you know, Satoshi put the code out and started mining it. I think how Finney was the second person to start mining it and just grew organically from there. So there were so there was nobody put any money into it, it just grew organically. [00:07:58] There's no central organization, there's no Bitcoin foundation, like there is Ethereum. So Ethereum, Ethereum and another another pre-mine was Ripple. So you have a situation where you have you have these investors that have a stake and also have made a lot of money a lot of money off of it. [00:08:16] There are also incentives with with these particular investors. But the issue you have with Ethereum right now that's important is with respect to Silicon Valley and in terms of a lot of the foundational applications and i well tokens and a lot of work underlying a whole host of different types of businesses, let's say, or or ventures. [00:08:46] The underlying basis, there was a bet made on Ethereum, as that being the underlying basis. So there's there's some powerful interests who you know want to see it's and one one of the reasons why they didn't pick Bitcoin is is that Ethereum was easier easier to utilize and also it was easier for them to get a significant holding right I mean big Bitcoin was kind of already it was more established Ethereum was extremely cheap extremely new so this was an opportunity for them to get into something that could potentially disrupt Bitcoin was the narrative that they were creating and get in very early so that [00:09:24] They could have control some control. Right. So so you so you have it you have a situation where and I'm I'm jumping forward and again remember on this show we're we're going back and forth here because we're we're we're trying to we're we're attempting to learn but also making sure we give you the correct information. We think part of the show in terms of us going back and forth like that also helps helps people get a get a view or determine what you know what where we are with this. [00:09:50] And of course just to just make clear we're not you know financial advisors we're not professionals here just a couple of guys researching and learning about Bitcoin on our own you need to do the same thing but we're here to share our information to hopefully make your journey a bit easier. But make sure you do your research not investment advice. [00:10:10] Right and so and so the other thing and then we'll get directly into the whole issue of whether whether Bitcoin's not Bitcoin Ethereum is a security or not it's pretty much been determined that Bitcoin because of the way it was set up there's no there's no investors and it was set up well de novo or just from from scratch. [00:10:29] So there's n no other coin can really replicate that at this point. And that has that is that is that is I think it's beyond significant. I mean, I it it pretty much sets it as the cornerstone or the fundamental basis or bedrock of crypto assets. [00:10:47] So the this particular aspect of Ethereum and Ripple that it was there was a pre-mine situation where there's a centralized authority or entity in Ripple's case, the Ripple Corporation, in Ethereum's case, the Ethereum Foundation, that basically launched or made an initial offering of these currencies or tokens. [00:11:10] And so now the SEC is looking closely at and the CFEC and other regulatory bodies in the United States and around the world are looking closely at Ethereum and similar pre-mine offerings, token offerings, and examining whether or not they're non-compliant securities. [00:11:29] There's a debate going on now. So just from a real simple perspective is is the whole notion of crypto assets is is that you're you're they're they're supposed to be, or I mean the way we look at it, independent. And so you have a situation right here where you got Ripple and Ethereum, and you've got government regulatory bodies trying to determine whether they're decentralized or not. [00:11:52] Yeah. So the argument is So, I mean, so it's a situation where okay, so you've got a coin where you're basically saying, hey, you know what? We gotta prove that we're you know, to the government regulatory bodies, we gotta get lobbyists out there, and we gotta try to f force it so it goes our way. [00:12:11] And so one of the main investors in Ethereum is a VC firm called Andreessen Horowitz, famous VC firm, Mark Andreessen, Ben Horowitz. Exceptional, a top, top, exceptional firm. Right. Very well respected and very successful in the VC game. [00:12:31] They have led a group of other investors and who hold an interest in Ethereum to lobby the regulatory bodies in the United States, saying that Ethereum, although maybe at the beginning when it was initially offered, it's ICO was perhaps centralized at that point. [00:12:51] Maybe it was a non-compliant security at that point. But since then has sufficiently decentralized so that it is not a non-compliant security now. It is a decentralized cryptocurrency similar to Bitcoin. So you end up saying, well, what is what is that what is that real what does that really mean? I mean, from the standpoint of decent, you know, decentralized. [00:13:11] Because if you go actually, if if you if you go actually into Ethereum at its very base level, you have an ongoing discussion right now of going from proof of work to proof of stake. But then you turn around and say, well, if enough enough of these projects have been distributed around, is that enough to define it as decentralized? [00:13:31] Well, I personally a couple days ago was just wholeheartedly all in saying, nope, it's absolutely a security. And then the more I the more I'm looking at this aspect of all these new projects and spread out, and that and there's a there's a situation I think we're probably gonna cover it in terms of these tokens relative to the original the original Ethereum. [00:13:56] There's a separation there. I've opened my mind on it again. I'm not I'm not really certain at this point. So there the debate is that's going on is sort of being spearheaded by Preston Byrne, who is a England-based, UK-based lawyer. Well, he actually he's originally from England, but I believe he's actually in the U.S. [00:14:19] Okay. And he's actually [00:14:23] 100% English law, and my understanding, and I'm pretty certain on this, is that Mr. Byrne is is in the process of being able to practice law in the U.S. So I think he's either finished or close to finishing law school. Alright, so we highly re I mean I can say I don't know how much you follow, but I highly regard his views. [00:14:45] He's been into this for a while. He also was either the chief operating officer or one of the top top players in in a in a firm that's involved in the space prior to deciding to go back and get his U.S. Right. So there so there's one side of the debate leaning toward if the ether is a is an on-client security and kind of being led and spearheaded by Preston Byrne, and then the other side of the debate saying that ether is not a security, being spearheaded by Peter Van Vulkenberg, who is a employed at Coindesk, a what do you call it, [00:15:23] Sort of a lobbyist organization that lobbies in on in favor of crypto crypto assets. There you have a there you the point earlier, there you have a lobbyist. So you need to get a lobbyist to try to figure out whether you're you know a security or not, which for my view is not good. But go to the top, please. [00:15:43] Yeah. So this is the point understanding the difference between a token pre-sale and the token itself. So let's let's just a quick kind of summary of Vulkenberg's position versus Burns' position. So Vulkenberg is saying that the that Ethereum as it exists today is not a security, right? [00:16:02] And so Gensler, who was, and we kinda we had this pulled up at the beginning here. Gary Gensler, who's a former financial regulator for President Obama, spoke out regarding regulatory status Peter and Ripple Ripple last week in an interview with the New York Times. He said that, quote, there's a strong case for both of them, Ethereum and Ripple, but particularly Ripple, that they are non-compliant securities. [00:16:24] And I agree with him there that Ripple is more clearly a non-compliant security than Ethereum, and that there's more of a debate to be had with Ethereum. But that that quote is what prompted. I'm sorry, there we go. Yeah, and while we're on it, Vulkenberg's response. Right, and while while we're at it, on Ripple, it's a situation at some point we may cover a ripple, but it it's it's a situation where we'd rather ripple dumpster fire now. [00:16:51] Yeah, we would rather just spend our time more wisely and not waste our time talking about Ripple. In fact, we've already talked about it too much already. There we go, yeah. So Gensler is and Byrne and that side of the debate are saying that you know the Ethereum Foundation in 2014 was basically the central central entity controlling Ethereum. [00:17:17] You know, the Ethereum Foundation and Vitalik Buter and the founder of Ethereum. And then the Ethereum network as a whole today is different, right? It's now much more decentralized. So reliance, I'll just read from Volkenberg here. Reliance on the efforts of a promoter is a key prong of the Howie test. [00:17:37] The Howey test being the guide for defining whether or not something is a security in the United States. It's based on a court case that involved someone named Howie and like Orange Grows in Florida, I think. So that's one of the key prongs of the Howie test is the efforts of a central promoter. [00:17:57] So in a token pre-sale, there's a reliance on an issuer, and maybe the Ethereum Foundation in 2014 fits that bill. But today, the value of Ether and the functionality of Ethereum network is not relying on the foundation. Rather, it flows from the efforts of thousands of unaffiliated developers, miners, and users. That decentralization is hard to differentiate from Bitcoins. [00:18:16] A cryptocurrency, Gensler suggests, is almost certainly not a security for the very reason we're discussing no discernible third party, no common enterprise upon whom you can rely for the expectation of profits. So the argument is essentially that Ethereum is now sufficiently decentralized. It is like Bitcoin now, and at this point it is not a non-compliant security. [00:18:35] Well, except you know, the one thing I'd point out though is except that the original people in on the gig on the pre-mine, they they are substantially benefit by this becoming you know, being being determined that it's not not a security. [00:18:54] Right. So Bitcoin has nothing to do with it because there's no original it started de novo. Volkenberg goes on to say that it's possible for a useful decentralized token to not be a security, even if it originated in a pre-sale or ICO that qualified as a security issuance at the point of the pre-sale, which is kind of confusing, right? [00:19:15] So here's here's the sort of leap, the logical leap that he makes. He says that securities are legal relationships between issuers and investors. They're not the paper on which the contract or other legal relationship is printed, nor are securities the spreadsheet entries that demarc fractional ownership of a business, nor are securities any of the ones or zeros, the arrangement of which may represent the terms of the deal. [00:19:38] So then they're not the digital version of the paper securities as well. Nor are securities the assets that are derived from the investment deal. Just because Apple uses invested money to build iPhones doesn't mean that the iPhones themselves are securities, right? So he's trying to separate the Ether token from the its its origin with this kind of being offered by the central authority of the Ethereum Foundation. [00:20:06] Alright, so Preston Byrne goes kind of goes against that and says that he doesn't believe that Ethereum's promoters and orbital labs promoters have satisfactorily answered the decentralization question to date. And that the job their job rather than it's their you know the onus is on them to prove that whether rather in the opposite way, right? [00:20:30] So what happens is what he they look back at the pre-sale, okay? And what's interesting is they found that the distribution of the pre-sale purchases, all right. And there's a graph here that we're looking at for those of you on the podcast, and this will be of course, this link will be of course in the show notes, but there's a graph that's sort of rises up, flattens out, and then rises up again, but it's really perfect. [00:20:56] It's an S curve. It's an S curve that's almost that's almost perfect, okay? And then if you look at some graphs of other sort of pre-sales or fundrais fundraising efforts, so here's a Kickstarter graph, you know, it's a much more you know erratic, kind of organic. And it just kind of goes straight up a hill, right? Gradual growth. [00:21:15] Alright, here is the pre the sale of Tezos tokens, which also is an S curve, but it's not nearly as perfect as the Ethereum preset S curve. And so the implication is that maybe the Ethereum Foundation or or some other centralized you know organization kind of a group or something, but in this case probably the foundation itself, understood or sort of saw where Ethereum was going, that it was going to transition to proof of stake eventually, and when you're in a proof of stake cryptocurrency, you want to own as much of it as possible because the stake that [00:21:53] You have in the cryptocurrency is what gives you power in that in that system, in that ecosystem, right? So if there was some kind of program, some kind of thing. And the key here is and maybe we mentioned this before, but proof of work is stalwart, it's bad rock. Proof of stake is not, it's just it it's it's a weaker form underlying a crypto asset. [00:22:15] Arguably less secure. But maybe if there was some kind of bot or for that was being run by the Ethereum Foundation that was designed to purchase ether along that mathematical curve, right? And that's why it looks so perfect. So the implication being that the Ethereum Foundation has far more ether than anyone thinks they do, and so it's still a centralized entity at this point in terms of control, especially if it moves to a proof of stake consensus system as is planned. [00:22:47] So questions out there about Ethereum, and another thing that we should talk about is the security of the Ethereum platform, right? And we know that there's been some big smart contract hacks, and one of one of the major sort of differentiation that Ethereum offered when it was launched was all right, we're going to be Bitcoin, but with smart contracts. [00:23:06] This idea of Turing complete smart smart contracts, any kind of computation that you can you know do in another system is gonna can be done on the Ethereum platform. And the other part of it is is what Silicon Valley primarily went with is they said we're gonna use Ethereum because we have these smart contracts, so we can build all these businesses or ideas off of Ethereum, and we're not we're not gonna go with Bitcoin. [00:23:31] Yeah. And Bitcoin now has a situation where it's fledgling, but you can do smart contracts, but it's still you know it's still rootstock, so is is turning complete side smart contracts on a side chain of Bitcoin. And this is something we keep coming back to as well is you know, this is programmable money, this is software, so you know Bitcoin can adopt the best attributes or features of its you know competitors or alternatives, and so it's gonna be a good thing. [00:24:01] But you make up a great point here in terms of being being hacked, and you and you also there's a discussion going on right now about that there was an issue where they're they're looking at on Ethereum with where they're they're the group or group is looking at somehow trying to hard fork or go back to get their cash back, and it's tens of millions of dollars. [00:24:22] Yeah, just to give a quick look back at history. So, of course, this happened with the DAO as well, which was the granddaddy of all Ethereum hacks, and so the distributed autonomous organization, which is comprised of a series of smart contracts intended to democratize how Ethereum projects were funded. [00:24:41] So they called it the DAO or DAO, the distributed autonomous organization. This was back in June of 2016, that the DAO was raising funds, and during the fundraiser it was hacked, and 3.6 million ether or 15% of all the ether in circulation at the time was drained from the smart contracts, exploiting a code vulnerability. [00:25:03] And just think about that. Yeah, this is Ethereum, okay? 15% of all the this happened to Ethereum in the history of Ethereum. Yeah, just because less than two years ago. Year and a half year and another thing, just to be clear, and why we get all wound up and so so you know, talking about Bitcoin is the fact that Bitcoin has never been hacked in the history. [00:25:26] So the only way to recover the funds from that hack, which was devastating for Ethereum, and effectively go back in time was for the Ethereum's code base itself to be reset through a hard fork in the blockchain. And so that's why we have Ethereum Classic now. So the community led by Vitalik Buterin decided to hard fork off of the block the blockchain that was hacked, go re go back in time, rewind, and undo the hack, basically redistribute all those funds back to the original owners. [00:25:56] Ethereum Classic said, look, we immutability is important, not changing the history of the blockchain is important, and so we're going to continue the original Ethereum blockchain as Ethereum Classic, and we're going to retain the mantle of immutability. And Bitcoin is also immutable and isn't it [00:26:16] Relates to Ethereum. Is if you look at it, you usually want to be able to say, okay, so Ethereum, if it are you compute completely immutable? Have you ever had an issue? And it's like, well, yes, we had an issue once. And this is what happened. So then you say, as of today going forward, can you say that it, you know, just us looking at it objectively, can we say, well, will the same group do that again? [00:26:41] And it happened again and not too long ago. Parity is a wall an Ethereum wallet, and last year there was a freeze of a bunch of funds because of a bug in the parity wallet smart contract, and it froze more than almost half a million ETH inside this wallet. [00:27:03] So it's not lost, it wasn't stolen, but it's frozen and can't be retrieved, and that ether is gone unless there's another hard for it. And what so just so our our our you know listeners and viewers, a half a million ETH is roughly how much. I don't know what the conversion is. Well, what's the ETH right now? [00:27:22] Do we know? I don't I don't even know. I haven't been keeping track. I haven't either. It doesn't really matter. The point is, well, it's just it's a lot of money. Yeah, I'll look it up, I'll look it up real quick, keep going, I'll look it up real quick quick. But I mean it's a lot of dough. I mean, it's not like we're playing with kids with this amount of money we're talking about. Right. And the point is it's gonna happen again and again once you've hard forked 750, roughly 750 dollars times a half a million. [00:27:48] Yeah. Once the ledger has been changed, there's going to be pressure to do it again in situations when it inevitably happens again like this. And there is pressure on Vitalik to go back and unfreeze these funds with another hard fork. [00:28:08] And there was a big hack last week as well to some ERC20 tokens, somebody you know found a loophole in the contract and created tokens that were worth five octo decillion which is which is something like five followed by like 60 zeros or something like that US dollars obviously just impossible but it was another hack or another mistake in smart contract so unreliable but well but the point though is not immutable any longer yeah well that that happened and the whole the whole thing is there wasn't a stop sign up that's it said wait a second wash this through [00:28:46] It's it's not gonna happen this actually impacted and hit ethereum so you really have to say sitting back from it say well well why would you starting right now have anything to do with Ethereum yeah and then you have a situation we go back I'm going backwards here but you go in a situation with this whole idea of whether it's a security or it's not a security well not only do you have that issue and if it becomes deemed a security it's gonna wipe out all sorts of value okay right and then you not only have that is the immutability issues not even solved. [00:29:20] So if you had a situation where you were an investor and you invested in somebody and said they were gonna go ahead and do some like a nice new new thing and then later on you would figure okay well they're gonna use the right underlying you know crypto asset and then they go ahead and use Ethereum and you might say well why why did you use Ethereum? [00:29:42] I mean you knew all this stuff was going on why didn't you something else right? Yeah, so definitely some questions that have not really been answered sufficiently by the Ethereum community. It's a platform that's less reliable. It's now been you know, sub it's been changed and hard forked to undo a hack. [00:30:05] It's gonna happen again at some point. It's more centralized than Bitcoin. There's just a lot more risk investing in Ethereum in my opinion than in Bitcoin. Again, non-investment advice, our personal opinion. Do your own research. And so that's that's a summary of the thing. And it's it's it's our opinion. [00:30:24] Well, yeah, the only thing I've got is is that I guess our opinion on on Bitcoin is a little bit more hardcore because we're basically saying that the whole crux of these crypto assets is is a mutability, right? And cryptographically being anonymous and just being stalled, I keep using stall word or solid, really solid, above reproach. [00:30:48] Bitcoin we know right now is that case. And there's nobody that's even remotely close. So it's almost you can go ahead and try to cut corners or whatever, right? But by using something else. But I agree with you. Yeah. Alright, that's all we have for today's show. Thanks for tuning in, and we will see you next time. [00:31:07] Take care. Thank you. All right.