WEBVTT

1
00:00:21.280 --> 00:00:39.520
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners from all around the world. Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Today we sit down with Prateek Goorha.

2
00:00:39.520 --> 00:00:59.760
But first, we're checking in with Swan. Swan is as easy as it gets. Just one auto fund USD, two, you auto-stack that BTC three, you can auto-withdraw your BTC, and that's it. You can use my ref link to get started, SwanBitcoin.com slash Brady and get $10 of Bitcoin dropped into your account after you start auto-sacking with Swan.

3
00:00:59.760 --> 00:01:06.480
Speaking of our referral program, we want you to join the Swan Force. You can sign up at SwanBitcoin.com slash enlist.

4
00:01:06.760 --> 00:01:18.760
You'll get a custom landing page with your avatar and a message at the top welcoming your referrals to Swan. You'll earn 0.25% of every Swan Plan purchase your referrals make for three years.

5
00:01:19.040 --> 00:01:32.720
And they get $10 of BTC dropped into their account, so everybody wins. You don't need to be in the United States to join Swan Force either, so you can sign up US-based customers from anywhere in the world. We'll pay you in sats wherever you are.

6
00:01:32.740 --> 00:01:36.260
On the other podcast I host, Swan Signal. I'm really loving the format.

7
00:01:36.560 --> 00:01:56.560
If you haven't checked it out yet, please check it out. We broadcast live every Wednesday on Twitter at SwanBitcoin and on YouTube, youtube.com slash SwanBitcoin. The YouTube channel's really looking beautiful. There's also highlight clips from the episodes there. More plans coming coming up soon for that YouTube channel.

8
00:01:56.560 --> 00:02:16.840
Go to youtube.com slash swan signal and subscribe today. All right.

9
00:02:16.840 --> 00:02:41.720
Today we sit down with Prateek Goorha, an economist, professor, and autodidact. Prateek has written some of the most underappreciated Bitcoin content out there. His writing runs the gamut from price cycle analysis to contract theory to philosophy. In this one, we discuss all three. Be sure to check out the show notes for a link to Prateek's Medium page and dive in for some great reading.

10
00:02:41.720 --> 00:03:05.400
Here we go. Yeah, so let's just get let's start with the background on why you're into Bitcoin. You know, your your work history and what led you, you know, to discover this wonderful new technology that we're also enamored with.

11
00:03:05.480 --> 00:03:27.240
Right, right. It's a good question, you know, and I like this question very much because everybody has such interesting answers to how they came to it and what what I really like about it is that it's sort of like all roads point to Bitcoin. I you know, I did this, that, and the other, and then I found Bitcoin and all of this, that and the other is always very, very different, you know.

12
00:03:27.720 --> 00:03:55.440
So I love that. So I am actually by nature in I don't know how to describe it, an intellectual itinerant, right? Or perhaps less grandiosely, maybe I'm I'm just a dilettant, you know. I just like to dabble a little bit in this and that and the other. That's what I like, I like to do. So I suppose there are a few different aspects of Bitcoin that I hope we can talk about today, right?

13
00:03:55.440 --> 00:04:18.480
But I'll I'll start a little bit earlier. So I was a full-time academic in 2014, when I sort of began this casual romance with blockchains, right? Inspired by a colleague of mine who was really interested into it. And at that stage, my interest was was sort of very very cursory.

14
00:04:18.480 --> 00:04:41.360
It became a bit more sharp after February, I think of that year, when when remember the Mount of Mount Gox debacle happened. But even then, you know, back then my interest was totally on blockchains, right? Nothing to do, nothing to do with Bitcoin, even Ethereum for that reason, even though Ethereum tends to be the sweetheart of academics, if you've noticed, right?

15
00:04:41.360 --> 00:05:09.520
Yes, right. So it wasn't that, it was blockchains. And the reason for that was really because I saw it as this transformational technology that one could use to possibly reimagine institutions that we take for granted, like auctions and voting and stuff like that, right? And so it was and I'll say a little bit more about that, but I got more seriously interested in Bitcoin only in the summer of 2016.

16
00:05:09.520 --> 00:05:31.240
And coincidentally, exactly at the time where I made this momentous decision in my life to stop being considering myself an academic and pursue a few other different projects in my life, such as consulting, which I do for small businesses now, writing, both fiction and non-fiction.

17
00:05:31.720 --> 00:05:58.040
Fascinating. Yes, and bookmark. We're gonna dive into that later. All right. Yes, for it. And then and teaching, which I still love to do. So I teach at a local university at the business school there, and I teach a course on introductory economics at the MBA level. And I do that because I use the back half of that course to talk about Bitcoin economics specifically.

18
00:05:58.040 --> 00:06:16.680
So which I which I really like, and I really like teaching at this school because the school is one of the very rare schools in our country that is uncompromisingly devoted to providing an very affordable education to its to its students. So that's what I sort of do at the moment.

19
00:06:16.680 --> 00:06:45.240
So I've got my hands on all of all these different things. And the thing that I like about Bitcoin is that it is this, it matches well with my personality in the sense that I look at Bitcoin as as this ultimate sandbox, right? Where curious independent thinkers like you, me, and all these other independent thinkers that are up there on on Bitcoin Twitter, that approach it with completely different lenses, right?

20
00:06:45.240 --> 00:07:05.200
Philosophy philosophy economics and cryptography, of course, but also really interesting things like like like paleoanthropology, right? And this is you just you don't and psycho and behavioral economics is all over the place.

21
00:07:05.200 --> 00:07:30.880
Psychology, for example, is it is all over the place, which I find very interesting, and that's what keeps me hooked on on Bitcoin, Bitcoin for has since 2016. And I don't think that this is a this is a love affair that's going to end. But also, so and okay, so here's the first thing that I talk about in the that I that I that drew me to Bitcoin, right?

22
00:07:31.120 --> 00:07:52.480
The thing in economics that I studied was contract theory. I don't know whether you know and you know much about contract theory. So contract theory nothing important. I mean basic, basic idea. Okay, cool, cool, cool. So give us the overview. I assume that I'm probably I'm probably in the same boat as most listeners at this point.

23
00:07:52.480 --> 00:08:18.320
So all right, good. So I'll give you an overview, right? So contract theory is this branch of economics which studies essentially with with the theory of the firm, right? This the shape, size, and scope of the firm, essentially, right? But using contracts. So the theory, the idea is that a firm itself is a nexus of contracts, contracts with employees, contracts with suppliers, contracts with consumers, so on and so forth, right?

24
00:08:18.320 --> 00:08:44.960
So that's sort of the starting point of it. And then there are two types of contracts that broadly, there are two types of contracts in economics. There's the there's an incomplete contract, which is the one that we think of when we think of contracts unit. So, for example, a contract that we might write with our builder when we're building a house, and it's called incomplete because it's characterized by such a contract would be characterized by situations that are indescribable, right?

25
00:08:44.960 --> 00:09:03.000
So you don't know ex ante when you're signing the contract with your builder what everything is going to look like over the course of a year or two years as you're building the house. So they're indescribable outcomes or future states of completion of the house that are indescribable up front.

26
00:09:03.240 --> 00:09:27.080
So that's the first aspect of an incomplete contract. And as a result of that, they become infeasible, hard, but but maybe even impossible to have third-party verification, right? So because you've not been able to describe those out as those outcomes, at the outset, you can't really have third-party verification play a very big role, right?

27
00:09:27.080 --> 00:09:48.200
So that's so that's the that's an incomplete contract. A contrast to this is a complete contract, right at the other end of the spectrum, and a smart contract is a kind of a complete contract, so we can talk about that, right? But a complete contract essentially is an implementation, then that's very closely related to this whole area in economics called implementation theory or mechanism design, right?

28
00:09:48.280 --> 00:10:17.880
So there was a Nobel Prize in 2007 given in this aspect of economics. And what is it? Well, the idea there is that you know you can sort of flip game theory on its head, right? Games are what games are where we're studying, we've got a game and we're seeing the strategies of players, how they play the game, right? Mechanism design or implementation is the opposite, where you're you design the game because you have a particular social outcome in mind, and you want that outcome to be achieved.

29
00:10:17.880 --> 00:10:36.040
So, how would you design a game so that everybody plays it? Everybody wants to play it, and then everybody plays it, and then that outcome is achieved. So that's mechanism design, okay. And it's it's it's a complete contract in this sense that right, the that the you the all the outcomes are described, right?

30
00:10:36.040 --> 00:11:02.480
You know what's going to happen, you're right before you've played the game. So an example of this is right, and it gets a bit abstract. So I'll give you a concrete example. The classic case of dividing a cake in equitable halves, right? So you want your your you've got two kids and you want them to both feel that they got their the bigger half, so they're bigger off, right?

31
00:11:02.480 --> 00:11:22.320
So what's the what's the implementation there? You design the game for them. The outcome that you want as the designer of the game is that they've they go away feeling happy, right? That they got what they wanted. And what's the way to achieve it? Well, you sit you ask one of them, then you cut the cake, and then the other one will get first picks, right?

32
00:11:22.320 --> 00:11:42.640
The and then you're hoping that both are satisfied, right? So that's an example, a very simple example of an implementation. It's a complete contract because you describe the outcome, you know the future state, and it's it's verifiable that this is what's achieved, right? So that's the other end of it.

33
00:11:42.640 --> 00:12:01.040
Okay, vastly simplified this this sort of setup, but this sort of covers the entire gamut of contracts that you can have. Sure. Okay, so this is what I was this is where I was coming from, and then I came up came across Bitcoin.

34
00:12:01.040 --> 00:12:20.240
Sorry, not Bitcoin, Zabo's work on smart contracts, still not Bitcoin, right? Sabo's work on smart contracts, so this is like still 2014, 2015, and then you go this is a this is a third type of contract that he's talking about because Zabo is not using the terminology of complete and incomplete contracts, right?

35
00:12:20.240 --> 00:12:53.960
He's not looking at mechanism design or or anything like he's just talking about this thing. There's a computationally feasible contract that can be programmed, and that's how it would work, and it's therefore it's complete in the sense that it can be programmed in time, right? And it can be, of course, made more and more abstract by as it has been done now, by adding all kinds of interesting aspects to it, where there is a role for third parties, so where you've got HDLC contracts on layer two, you've got Taproot, and all those sorts of things, right?

36
00:12:53.960 --> 00:13:12.200
That permit that smart contract to become more and more incomplete in a sense, right? Still nowhere near as incomplete as what that that builder contract would have been. That's like massively incomplete. There's nothing like that that on the that you could do on a blockchain, for example, right? So this is my this was my interest.

37
00:13:12.200 --> 00:13:31.160
Now, like, oh, this is really cool. Okay, this is a really cool, but really cool sort of example of mechanism design. Okay, so 40 years before. So, do you know Brady about the great socialist calculation debate?

38
00:13:31.160 --> 00:13:49.400
No, I don't. Okay, so so I'll I'll I'll start with that very quickly, yeah. So in this was in because Austrian economics economics is so important to most of most Bitcoiners. I guess most people who are listening to this maybe know this, right? So I'm I'll be brief.

39
00:13:49.400 --> 00:14:07.800
I am not an Austrian economic economist by any stretch of the imagination, though I admire Hayek to death, and learned more about Austrian economics now than I did before, you know, studying economics at at university. But the great socialist calculation is as is always the case, default Keynesianism, right?

40
00:14:07.800 --> 00:14:46.400
Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, you have that phrase for it, right? What is it? Keynesian default Keynesianism there's there's a lot of that happening in economics departments yeah it's it's amazing it's like 97 plus percent I think you know just getting the Keynesian straight line Keynesianism and not even mentioning Austrian economics with the idea of sound money absolutely you're in and you know it's all across so I was teaching my my children economics for for a high school right sort of the usual AP economics kind of stuff that people that kids do in high school and you look at this curriculum and it's shocking

41
00:14:46.400 --> 00:15:24.400
How outdated it is right even from the perspective of a mainstream economic economist it's outdated stuff and they so I mean they're you know right right from the very get go this this is a problem but that's a whole different issue so back back to what I was talking about so yeah the great social calculation debate was essentially this idea that the way we're talking about where the USSR was was talking about a central command economy is it possible for prices to be rather than it they rather than prices being organically discovered by markets right as Smith

42
00:15:24.400 --> 00:15:51.880
Would have it prices to actually be calculated so hence calculation debate right and of course my critique on socialism on the on the base saying that of course it cannot be done and then the a very interesting debate ensued 20 years later 15 20 years later don't I don't know the dates very offhand very well but between Oscar Lang and Hayek, Frederick Hayek where Lang was saying that it is possible, right?

43
00:15:51.880 --> 00:16:11.000
That you don't need capitalism to discover prices. And Hayek, of course, said had that that the whole idea of distributed information, right, is being being absolutely necessary for markets to work and for prices to be discovered. So distributed information was paramount. So that was a great socialist calculation debate.

44
00:16:11.000 --> 00:16:36.200
And then in from 1940, nothing really happened all the way to 1969, 1970, where implementation theory or contract theory, right? Sorry, this mechanism design theory that we were talking about earlier was discovered by Herbert's primarily, Leo Rowitz, but there were others there as well.

45
00:16:36.200 --> 00:16:56.760
And he said that, well, that's the problem. Here you can actually design the game, make it incentive compatible for everybody to want to play it, right? And for organically information to be revealed within the game by playing this game by by their participants, and for the desired outcome to be achieved.

46
00:16:56.760 --> 00:17:27.240
Right. So he was, it was like this compromise that for the or for the great socialist calculation debate, not really compromise, was very much in line with what what you would need in terms of Hayek and Lang being able to talk the same language, where Hayek is saying you cannot get rid of distributed information if you want a market to work, and Lang saying that some calculation is possible so that it is actually possible for a designer to have an outcome.

47
00:17:27.560 --> 00:17:56.640
Does that sort of make sense? Absolutely, yeah. I'm following. Okay. So that's the great socialist calculation debate. All right, so I'm coming from that tradition of mechanism design thinking all of this stuff. Then comes Bitcoin. All right? So now Bitcoin makes a lot of sense to me, right? Because I'm thinking, hang on, you know, I mean, there's been first of all, really, it was it really baked my noodle that that for 40 years before the word blockchain became a mania, right?

48
00:17:56.640 --> 00:18:19.600
For 40 years before that, before Long Island Ice Ton Blockchain Corporation or whatever. Oh my god, that's crazy. Yeah, yeah. The stock shut up just because they chained the screen, right? So before that, the study of mechanism design in economics was already studying problems of dispersed information, right?

49
00:18:19.600 --> 00:18:39.520
And it was all we're already using what kind of mechanism can be designed so that we would be able to study things such as voting, trade, regulation, finance, monetary policy, land property rights, all of that sort of stuff. That blockchain somehow became the default thing to be applying to study that in economics, you know.

50
00:18:39.520 --> 00:19:06.240
So for me then, so very large degree, there's no such thing as blockchain economics, right? It without acknowledging, at least, without acknowledging the huge debt that it owes to mechanism design first, right? So that so that was the entry for me from my contract theory hat in economics to starting to study Bitcoin, and then the epiphany, right?

51
00:19:06.240 --> 00:19:26.240
So I'm not one of those guys who can say, Oh, I read I read the white paper back when it was published, right? No, I was really late. I read it in 2016. Oh, yeah. Well, people listening to this are gonna laugh at the fact that you think you're late in 2016, right? And imagine, you know, people coming into it five, 10 years from now, listening to this are gonna be like this guy, yeah, right?

52
00:19:26.240 --> 00:19:51.080
But it is seven years. To be sure that it took me that long to get into the white paper. I feel you, I feel you. I was twenty early 2017, so I'm close to the case. Oh you were right. OG in comparison. So yeah, I think so the epiphany reading the white paper to me was that, and I don't think in others, or maybe others have had this epic, and no one's speaking for this, but that it's rare, I think.

53
00:19:51.080 --> 00:20:11.640
That the Bitcoin blockchain, as described by Satoshi was meant as an implementation mechanism. So he's creating a game, like I'm talking about earlier, right? There's me, he's creating a game as an implementation, and for a design, and that game needs to have a designer problem, right?

54
00:20:11.640 --> 00:20:30.360
The designer needs to have a problem. What's the problem? The problem is hard, digitally native money, right? So that's sort of the social outcome that I want to achieve as a designer. What kind of game shall I make? Should I create, which so that people will want to play, right?

55
00:20:30.600 --> 00:20:57.640
Freely revealing their preferences and information, right? Without corrupting that information for that to be played, for that game to be played. Right. So I'm I'm so that so I'm that that was sort of my my sort of eureka moment in trying to trying to see, okay, wow, this is this is completely completely this is a massive a sea change in the way of thinking about money.

56
00:20:57.640 --> 00:21:18.400
Yeah, I think it's fascinating, just to pause you right there, because I think it's fascinating that you know, all this academic debate happened to come back to the idea of money and its natural form, which is a mechanism to allow this game to develop without suppressing information, right?

57
00:21:18.400 --> 00:21:37.520
I mean, that's the idea of the free market, and it sort of naturally arises, you know, and so yeah, we sort of lost the plot there for a while and got stuck in this sort of academic you know entrenchment that we could understand it better than this sort of natural, naturally occurring you know mechanism.

58
00:21:37.760 --> 00:21:59.520
Yeah, definitely, definitely. And I'll add to that by saying that when we when we when we teach or when we learn about what is money in an economics textbook, we get the usual malarchy, right? Of what is money? Well, your money must be your medium of exchange, unit of count, store of value, right?

59
00:21:59.520 --> 00:22:17.520
We get that, right? And we don't we don't we oh I didn't I never thought of asking that this question as an economic student or even teaching economics that well, what's the order here? What which comes before the other, right?

60
00:22:17.520 --> 00:22:38.640
Which which one or does it matter which comes before the other, right? And it's it was only after looking at Bitcoin more seriously does it become clear which the what what that progression is and how should it emerge organically with information being revealed revealed in an incentive compatible way by people playing.

61
00:22:38.640 --> 00:23:00.520
So, what do I mean by that? So when you've got a when you've got a mechanism, right? And you've got a game, you implement such a mechanism, you have that as a designer, you may have a social outcome in mind, but you cannot assume because you're not you're not a dictator, right? So this is you're not forcing that outcome, you're making people play that game, and you're hoping that outcome is going to be in the natural outcome of that game, but it may not be so.

62
00:23:00.680 --> 00:23:23.800
You can the problem could be one of multiple equilibria, right? So one equilibrium is the one that you want to have happen, but you could have other equilibria occur as well. And this is a known problem in implementation theory. For decades we know that this occurs. So this is exactly the same thing with Bitcoin as well, as far as I as far as I see it, right?

63
00:23:23.800 --> 00:23:42.600
I mean, how do we know? How did we are we like to ask this question a lot, right? What did Satoshi actually want for for Bitcoin? Did he mean it to be e cash or e-money? Did he mean it to be store of value? This is this is a garbage question to ask.

64
00:23:42.600 --> 00:24:02.520
If you think that the designer's problem initially was, as I defined it, hard digitally native money, and the route that it took to getting there doesn't matter. So, what I mean by that, I mean by that, what I mean by that is that in this game, you could have multiple sub-games, right?

65
00:24:02.520 --> 00:24:24.200
They're all nested within the game, right? Yes, or sub-game perfect equilibrium being the equilibrium being the one that we're we're trying to achieve. Okay, so so and the benefit of playing this game in stages, right? So as so why four years, right? Why 210,000 blocks? Right, why that number? Why must there be a reset of what you know what was it?

66
00:24:24.200 --> 00:24:45.000
If you think like in in in about the about why it should be, I mean, there are good cryptographic reasons for it, right? In terms of information propagation and all that sort of stuff, but from this sort of grander or idea of why there should be those halvings, it makes a lot of sense because you've now nested the game.

67
00:24:45.520 --> 00:24:58.160
And then you can sort of say, okay, the first stage that I will be playing will be establishing the Bitcoin as a unit of account. Right, because that's the simplest hurdle to cost. Especially if it's a

68
00:25:01.360 --> 00:25:20.320
Especially if it's a if it's a if it's a blockchain, right? Because that's sort of if I just take erased everything and I say, okay, well, look, let's let's just define what the essential nature of a blockchain is, this immutable ledger, then that makes it a way of accounting transactions, and hence that first bars crossed of it being a test, right?

69
00:25:20.320 --> 00:25:42.080
And then you progress, and as you progress, the Bitcoin blockchain gets stronger through participation, right? Meeting the participation constraints of a larger and larger set of people, right? They more and more people big are now playing the game incentive compatibly. As more and more people pour in, it starts to become a medium of exchange across them, right?

70
00:25:42.240 --> 00:26:09.440
And as that when that happens, then you sort of you we can argue about whether you like this idea or not. I know that I know at least there are a couple of people I talk to often. There's a no sort of value comes first, but the way that I think about it is that it goes from unit of unit of account, medium of exchange, sort of store sort of value, and then this final this nirvana stage, which I which I call medium of specialization, which has never happened for for a for a money before.

71
00:26:10.080 --> 00:26:32.120
That's sort of the opposite of what most people you know talk about in the Bitcoin space, right? Yeah, or a value to meaning of exchange to unit of account. Exactly, yeah, yeah, yeah. But but I'm thinking of it. You're talking about within the game, though, is what you're talking about. Exactly, within the game, the sub the substages of the game, right? So it's not like you're you're you're you're side shifting one of these objectives for the other.

72
00:26:32.200 --> 00:26:51.480
I'm just saying that as the game is played, what is the lowest threshold to meet, right? Not that you're therefore abandoning the ultimate goal of the other. All of them need to be met in order to achieve what the designer's original objective was, which is the digital native currency or digital digitally native money, right?

73
00:26:51.480 --> 00:27:19.320
That's that's always the goal. But but these stages is what what's happening with every halving, and halving is sort of this refreshing cycle where you're saying, okay, it's like a check, right? You're saying, okay, I'm gonna flush out those people whose incentives don't match anymore with this with this objective, and invite in those peoples who who who's who now want to participate in this game voluntarily, they'll share a different set of information, right?

74
00:27:19.640 --> 00:27:37.800
Different types of information, they'll and then they'll play this game out to the next till the next equilibrium is achieved, and then till the final equilibrium. The medium of specialization idea is very simple. It comes from it actually comes from this distinction that Mysies made between classes and costs, right?

75
00:27:37.800 --> 00:28:03.000
So he made this distinction in the basis that look that you're not going to completely get rid of sort of distinctions of groups in society. Some are going to be rigid, which are costs, right? These are sort of they're not fluid, right? Whereas classes are fluid groupings of people based on their on on their on their assets, right?

76
00:28:03.000 --> 00:28:41.840
They add the particular combination of assets that they possess, right? So that's that makes the asset classes, right? So they have they're they're they're the fluid groupings of individuals for these assets so if you if you think of classes in that in in in that way then you want asset ownership to be such that you can use them you can sort of make it extensible right so I can add a few assets in order to do a particular task get rid of some some some of those in order to do something else so in a very elastic definition of what an asset is that

77
00:28:42.480 --> 00:29:20.480
That is something that I think is only possible when you are able to use a money that permits you to specialize in a continuous manner rather than rather than say either or right so this is I so what I'm having so specialization is just such a such an important part of economic theory right that specialization in exchange right or the particular task and you have a you have a particular comparative advantage in doing some tasks so you specialize in those tasks so I mean these are sort of well markets work right this is just this

78
00:29:20.480 --> 00:29:59.040
Is just econ 101 you just need to know this right but what if it it were we're living in a if in in the digital world I think this changes in the sense that for you have avatars that are for different purposes essentially and you wouldn't you would need to have each avatar would need to have different levels of asset ownership in order to engage in that particular task and for and therefore for each of that task, you need to have a money that is equally elastic in its definition, permits that elasticity,

79
00:29:59.040 --> 00:30:23.320
Right? And that only happens if you've got self-sovereignty, complete self-sovereignty, such that you are able to you know get into a into a contract with someone else where you are part of a very very large group of people, and then another one where you're sort of you know not your sort of fit, just you and someone else, right?

80
00:30:23.320 --> 00:30:41.560
Very simple, and this is why we this is why we call Bitcoin the best money ever created, right? I mean it's it's the only money that can fit that like a glove. And it's you know, kind of drawing back to Hayek and what I was saying before is Bitcoin is a mechanism to kind of reinstate natural money in a world where the game has become so distorted, right?

81
00:30:41.560 --> 00:31:18.440
It's sort of it's Hayek's sort of roundabout way to take back the money, and it's not just that, it's it's a almost perfect form of money, at least you know, that like you said, it's continuous almost in a perfect way, yeah. Yes, absolutely. I mean, the this degree of I mean without big without you know going completely off the top in in appreciation for Bitcoin, which which there's nothing I think there's nothing that has permitted us that permits us to use money in this manner before.

82
00:31:19.160 --> 00:31:49.440
So to e to even compare it loosely to gold is actually it I it actually wince at that comparison, right? Because there is no way to use gold as a medium of specialization. There's just no way to do it. Yes, right, there because there is no there is no relation between any existing type of money and a complete ownership over yourself in such a manner that you make your identity an elastic asset.

83
00:31:49.520 --> 00:32:13.360
You just there's just no way to do that, right? Your identity is not given by by in in that in that inuse manner. You just don't have that that flexibility, which big Bitcoin gives you. So the kinds of economic transformations that we will be able to see in the future with a money that is that perfect are is not imaginable, right?

84
00:32:13.360 --> 00:32:32.640
At least I can't imagine them very well sitting here and sitting now. And in the long run, this could just you know be well past our imagination. I loosely call it the Bitcoin Renaissance, and we I don't we don't know exactly what's gonna look like, but I it seems something that's going to be beyond our comprehension in a very positive way.

85
00:32:32.640 --> 00:32:51.760
Yeah, so this leads into one of my favorite pieces that you wrote, and I will link to Prateek's medium. There's you know, his writing is so good. And I just I love it personally, and if you haven't read it and it's completely underread, and Prateek's underfollowed on Bitcoin, so you need to get in here and read some of the stuff.

86
00:32:51.760 --> 00:33:13.200
I know a lot of my listeners are avid readers. Robert Breedlove, you know, Brandon Quittem, Gigi, all of you guys who love great writing will love his writing. So it gets in this conversation leads in to a piece called the Bitcoin Village Commons. So let's dive into into that piece and the ideas and yeah, contained therein.

87
00:33:13.920 --> 00:33:36.600
I don't know, what did I write? Oh, yeah, yeah. This is this was last, so yeah, about a year ago. But I'll just read the sort of the introduction here, and that should jog your memory, I hope. Bitcoin is a meta technology. Moreover, it is a rare meta technology because it directly enables the creation of semi-commons, much like it was with medieval village commons.

88
00:33:36.680 --> 00:33:55.480
The Bitcoin Village Commons simultaneously curates rules for an overarching open access commons as well as those for private use cases within semi-commons. The former fuels the search of technological developments beyond blockchains, the latter fuels the search for uses beyond money. Right.

89
00:33:55.480 --> 00:34:15.000
Right. So I mean, the idea of a of a village commons, obviously, is that you know, one you could we create we are creating the village commons is the you know the class the is where the classic tragedy of the commons is derived from, right? You've got a village and you've got a commons that farmers are sharing.

90
00:34:15.000 --> 00:34:42.600
And then you've got this the tragedy of the commons comes from the idea that each each shepherd has got the individual incentive to increase the size of his herd because he's able to externalize the cost of actually feeding the marginal addition to his herd on the rest of the village because they're all grazing on this common, right?

91
00:34:42.600 --> 00:35:03.800
So he the it's essentially public access to the village commons, but the resource in there is a private resource, which is grass, right? So that's the village, and the tragedy of the commons is that you will keep have you keep increasing your the size of the year till there's open grazing in the in the in the commons of the village and it's destroyed, right?

92
00:35:03.800 --> 00:35:27.200
So that's the idea. The notion of a of a semi-commons is is that you could gate the commons, right? You could have you could you could regulate access to that commons, right? Are you in and that regulation could be of a very overbearing sort of a leviathan could be standing there like a government with a gun, right?

93
00:35:27.200 --> 00:35:53.600
At the entrance of village commons and charge arbitrarily for access to the commons, right? It could make it actually prohibitively expensive to enter the commons, right? In which case the commons just gets you can imagine, right? You can imagine the commons just having an overgrown, overgrown grass everywhere. That could be the complete opposite of the tragedy of the commons, which is the which is the dual of the tragedy of the commons, that we that doesn't get talked about very much, right?

94
00:35:53.600 --> 00:36:20.960
We keep the everybody knows the tragedy of the commons, right? That oh, we will deplete our resources. But the opposite that the problem that comes from over-regulating the commons, that we don't use it, and therefore we don't add to this to the to the herd individually, the farmers don't have any incentive to adding to their herd, then therefore, to the detriment of the of the development of the entire village, right, is this other problem of over-regulation.

95
00:36:20.960 --> 00:36:44.960
So to so the thing that about Bitcoin as a money, especially is that it strikes a balance between those two, right? Regulation is organic in Bitcoin, right? So there is there is no there is no fear of having of arbitrary regulation to the commons.

96
00:36:44.960 --> 00:37:03.720
The commons itself in this case is the benefit of money that we get from Bitcoin, the kind of the bet the public benefits of money, those you can write, which we can commonly share without knowing each other, those are the public benefits of Bitcoin, much like the grass on that on that field. It's limited, right?

97
00:37:03.720 --> 00:37:31.160
Just like the grass is limited, so it's the number of bitcoins are limited in that sense, right? So it's it's so it's limited, but yet regulation isn't arbitrary. So we get this efficient regulation organically emerging in Bitcoin, which is which is something which is very unique between in in in assets generally, in public assets generally, and in money, it doesn't exist.

98
00:37:31.640 --> 00:38:01.480
I cannot think of a money that has that that that feature where it isn't either arbitrarily regulated by central banks or not regulated at all, and it's just sort of a free-for-all, right? So so that so that's a very interesting aspect of Bitcoin, which which which I admire very much as something very genuinely unique and to the benefit of the flood of social flourishing, right?

99
00:38:01.480 --> 00:38:31.160
Which is an important point, I think, the long-run social flourishing, which makes which which also isn't it very cynical to be to be criticizing Bitcoin on its sustainability issues, right? That oh well, is this sustainable on the amount of energy we use, blah blah blah? Because we are not looking at the long run benefits that accrue to society from having established an infrastructure in the present for that kind of commons to exist at all, right?

100
00:38:31.240 --> 00:38:55.040
Which is which is which is something I think about often when I think about Bitcoin and its end states that for for social flourishing generally. So yeah, I mean, I yeah, maybe make I'm I haven't read in very long time, so maybe I'm not really engaging to your No, you are you summed up the first half of the article very well.

101
00:38:55.680 --> 00:39:14.480
Yeah, you know the second half gets into and this is why I brought it up at this point in the conversation because we are talking about you know Bitcoin's a potential future on in a Bitcoin world. And the second half of the article is is about you know lessons for the future, the de despoiling the commons.

102
00:39:14.480 --> 00:39:34.240
So you kind of contrast the examples of the village commons, the anti-commons, the semi-commons, and you know, the village the tragedy of the village commons that you just described, with what you call the Bitcoin village commons and kind of some similarities between them.

103
00:39:35.600 --> 00:40:13.760
Yes. Yeah, I haven't read in a while. I don't really know what else I can add to it, but yeah, I mean I be if it spoke to you, I'm glad. Yeah, it absolutely did. It was great. So read that piece. I mean, I'll just read these these one, two, three to kind of sum it up. So he Prateek writes contrasting this to the Bitcoin Village Commons, we might note that there are some similarities, such as one market-based rules for purchasing bitcoins and thereby for gaining access to its semicomons, such as the Lightning Network, which I think is a great example, two rules for providing resources to cultivate or mine bitcoins, essentially providing a boundary

104
00:40:13.840 --> 00:40:39.480
Gated commons for the Bitcoin Village Commons. Oh, yeah. Yeah. And peer review consensus rules for contributing to the code base, which is another great example. Right. Right, right, right. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, I mean, I do remember having this this this idea of looking at the open field system.

105
00:40:39.480 --> 00:41:09.560
Wasn't that was in this article, right? Yes, yeah. Right, yeah. Yeah, it's been a while. So I'll maybe I'll read it and I'll get back to you if you want me to talk about talk more about it. But sorry, I didn't know that you wanted to talk about this. I should have given you a heads up. I should have been like critique. Reread your stuff. I've been more I lately at the most this has been the thing that I've been thinking about most more recently is this idea of cycles in Bitcoin.

106
00:41:09.560 --> 00:41:28.360
So I guess that's been sort of front and center in my mind. But but yeah, I sort of jump around a lot in my thinking about Bitcoin, right? About moral philosophy, religion, all kinds of different things and so it's sort of hard to keep track, so sorry about that. That's totally fine. What about the cycles stuff for you if you're interested?

107
00:41:28.360 --> 00:41:53.480
Yes, I do want to get into that. You're you're it's okay that you're you know offloading some of this out of your RAM and committing it to hard disk, and you know, like you've you have it recorded here for posterity here on Medium. So yeah, well, okay, I would love to talk about price cycles. I do want to mention kind of circling back to the contract conversation we had toward the at the opening of the of the podcast.

108
00:41:53.720 --> 00:42:12.440
You wrote an a very interesting sort of a map or a what's what's a good word for it? It's almost like a white paper in and of itself for you know how we could organize contract law in a Bitcoin world. You wrote that with parabolic trav.

109
00:42:12.440 --> 00:42:42.720
Yes, yes, yes. This is a fascinating one. It was from 2017 this is the article that put you on my radar and you know I've been following you since then so anyway just encourage people to go back and take a look at that because there are so many good ideas there that I think will become you know very useful in a future near future hopefully where smart contracts being written on on Bitcoin and kind of moving the financial system over to Bitcoin they will become those thoughts will become very useful.

110
00:42:42.800 --> 00:43:01.600
Yeah yeah I hope so Brady I really hope that the idea of Bitcoin as a as a contracting platform right which is essentially the thrust of that that piece with with Trev is something that that I just don't I just don't see it not happening.

111
00:43:01.600 --> 00:43:39.680
As a matter of fact it already is happening but the amount of the num the amount of innovation that has happened in the types of contracts that are now representable on Bitcoin on the Bitcoin blockchain now in 2020 compared to when I got interested in Bitcoin in 2016 is an order of magnitude higher right in terms of the and so smart contracts is of course is is just sort is sort of a catch all right but there are so many different types of them there are HDLCs within it and discrete law contracts and script scripts and all kinds

112
00:43:39.680 --> 00:44:03.560
Of different sorts of things that are happening in there that some of them are well beyond my understanding there's so much stuff that's happening there. But what what when I when I'm because I don't understand because I'm not a cryptographer, I don't understand the tech side of it, but when I'm reading them right about what they're trying to do, I'm trying to create an analogies back to where they would fit in this continuum of incomplete contracts to complete contracts.

113
00:44:03.560 --> 00:44:24.120
And the good thing is that you see them fitting all over the place between them, and that's what you need, right? You need them to be, you need we need a variety of contracts which will then permit us to move financial transactions or more and more types of transactions in a meaningful way to Bitcoin.

114
00:44:24.600 --> 00:44:52.360
I just want to say one thing that is it may be a complete non-sequitaire because it's got nothing, but I want to talk, I want to just very quickly talk about why I think that it makes sense to be studying Bitcoin alone and not anything else around it. Because people have people have different reasons for why they think right Bitcoin maximism or is is obviously Bitcoin rationalism, whatever you want to call it, is makes sense.

115
00:44:52.360 --> 00:45:30.440
To me, it makes sense for a very, very simple reason, which is that of the law of rent, right? Ricardian rent. Do you know what that is? I mean, the I it makes sense to me to look at Bitcoin as a land grab, right, because the regarding rent for those of your listeners who don't are not familiar with the term, is the I is the idea that there is an economic advantage that you get from a given piece of land, right, that is higher than you would get for using the land that is

116
00:45:30.440 --> 00:45:50.720
Sort of adjacent to it, right? Mark, so the margins of this land for exactly the same thing. So imagine building a skyscraper in one area of New York, and then you know, exactly the same same skyscraper, just two blocks over on a different piece of land, but it happens to be in a different sort of area.

117
00:45:50.960 --> 00:46:15.440
It's not just it's never going to have the same value. The difference between that value is the recardian rent of having that build, of having that building. Now, if you know that you've got this building in this particular piece of land, right? The resources that you are now spending over and above the economic value of that of that building that you've now created in that in that other part, the undesirable part, right, is waste of resources.

118
00:46:16.440 --> 00:46:19.020
Does it make sense, right? And when you're trying,

119
00:46:19.200 --> 00:46:38.080
So it makes a lot more sense to be building up this building, right, rather than trying to emulate building that building in in that other part of town just because you want it to look like this one. It makes it almost foolish to be to be doing that sort of thing. Are you talking about wrapped BTC critique?

120
00:46:42.080 --> 00:46:44.560
No problem.

121
00:46:44.560 --> 00:46:50.760
I mean, that's like a very direct example, but I get the analogy to, you know, the rest of cryptocurrencies as well. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

122
00:46:51.120 --> 00:47:10.400
Yeah. Okay, well, let's get into the cycle stuff. Yeah, okay. I know that you and Trav love to talk about this stuff. I'm in a Discord group with you guys. Yeah, it's fun to watch you guys go back and forth. Yeah, he put me onto it. He means he was saying that, oh, you know, you should look at kitchen cycles. I'm like, I've never heard of kitchen cycles. I don't know, go look it up. Like, all right, fine, I'll go look it up.

123
00:47:10.400 --> 00:47:48.600
And he's got so essentially so I had to do some digging up in like what kitchen cycles are and how they're relevant for Bitcoin, but they are relevant, right? So Bitcoin is definitely a story of cycles, 100%. We've already talked about that implementation and then those stages, right? Of stages of money with the final desire outcoming, right? So that's already a cycle there, but there's an even there's much more empirically when when you do the econometric work on this it's it's even more often right so if you do the spectral density analysis of Bitcoin's price over time you see what is spectral density analysis so it gives you periodicity in the data so in time series it'll give you how much

124
00:47:48.600 --> 00:48:26.680
Period what is the is there a periodic element in in a time in a time series is that what plan B is doing with his you know stock to flow asset thing no he's not looking at he's not looking at periods he's looking he's he's not he's looking at co-integration of price of Bitcoin price with the stock to flow ratio right that this but he's not looking but have you have you seen the cross asset model that he came out with yes yes to effect on right yeah there he's talking about phases that's yes yes yes yes yes but again not an organic thing coming out of the time series itself he's he's he's saying that these are phases and he's got a very very very valid and interesting point

125
00:48:26.680 --> 00:49:02.440
There as to what those phases will look like and what's sort of you know the impetus in each phase very interesting but but say that I don't have a subjective bias at all right I'm just completely objectively looking at at the data and I'm saying is there a what's it called a period here right like a cycle and you actually find it you don't have to look hard you don't have to add anything it just you see that about 1.8 to two years there is this there's a there's a cycle in the in the price data right so so it it's now incumbent upon you to ex to have an explanation for why there is once a cycle like that, right?

126
00:49:02.440 --> 00:49:21.760
I don't have a very good explanation for it, but there, but the fact remains that it is there. Whether I can explain it or not is irrelevant. It's there, right? So anyway, so where where what about these cycles so sh so Schumpeter, in in in in late in the late 30s, he wrote a book in which he stopped, he spoke about cycles.

127
00:49:21.760 --> 00:49:40.160
And very briefly, the idea was that these cycles are motivated by sort of this interplay between the fact that between an innovation and entrepreneurship. And he observed that there the fact that innovations tend to sort of cluster around, right? One another.

128
00:49:40.160 --> 00:50:01.680
And because they do that, right, they they exert differential pressures on different variables in of economic activity, right? And entrepreneurs, according to their ability, are going to try to leverage these pressures that that innovation is creating on different aspects of economic activity.

129
00:50:01.680 --> 00:50:30.640
They're gonna try to leverage it, some will be better off but better than others at doing it, and that's why entrepreneur entrepreneurship is relevant, right? So that's sort of his framework for why innovation and entrepreneurship work together. So why cycles? Cycles come from this fact that innovations are happening in cycles, they're clumping together and they're having they're going on in cycles. Okay, and for him, the longest one of these, or the most famous one that everybody sort of, I think knows, is this the chondrati of wave, which was this long cycle of 50 years, right?

130
00:50:30.640 --> 00:50:48.720
Roughly 50 years is what he was talking about, as his Kondratiov wave. And then below the Kondrariov wave was the juglar wave, right? And jugglar wave, I think was was a wave that sort of spanned eight to ten years, something like that, remember exactly, but something like that, eight to ten years.

131
00:50:48.720 --> 00:51:27.320
And then below that is the is the is the kitchen cycle or the cycle that Travis was talking to me about, which was roughly four years. So four years, of course is is is a sacred number in in in Bitcoin and so what what's the kitchen cycle but it's got really it's got to do very much with inventory management right so so that put me onto this idea of okay well look there is this there's this cycle there is this this established cycle that people talk about but that might pertain to inventories how can we look at at this in in bit in the context of paper so by the way from from the 1930s

132
00:51:27.320 --> 00:52:05.400
To now all of this went out of favor of the cycles that all mainstream economists did the econometric work right not that they were biased and did the economics it doesn't show up in the data it's all rubbish there's no such cycle in pay there's no there's no such cycle that is as regular as should be direct but the thing that is interesting and unique about Bitcoin that we tend to miss is that Bitcoin imposes a structure you don't have two ways about it you have to play the game by its rule you don't which is different to a regular market remember we remember that that that we're in

133
00:52:05.400 --> 00:52:31.200
A mechanism design that Satoshi created so we have to play those rules right and from so with that structure imposes a certain amount of rigidity that no amount of which sort of interacts with our incentives and then we put that interplay then creates certain effects and the way to look at that I thought was to look at a cobweb supply model.

134
00:52:31.200 --> 00:52:58.080
And the idea of a cobweb supply model, it's really, it's really, really nice. Once you once you look at it and you're like, oh, yeah, of course, that's what's going on over here so the a cobweb supply model was created for commodities. Okay. It was spotted in early in the early 1930s by Calor in the context of the sugar market and others in the context of other commodities, the hog market, right?

135
00:52:58.080 --> 00:53:18.640
And metals. Okay. And so it's sort of in it was developed for the idea of for commodities. And the idea is very simple. The idea is that there is some prevailing market price, which inspires suppliers to produce particular quantity.

136
00:53:18.640 --> 00:53:36.640
But this is going to be a lag. There's a lag that it that you can't get, you know, can't get out of between between production and that and that price that is prevalent in the market. And so you produce you produce too much, right? Which serves to depress the price when the price then falls, right?

137
00:53:36.640 --> 00:53:59.040
And when it falls, then you produce too little, right? When it produces too little, price then rises, right? When price is higher, then your next period producing too much. So you sort of keep playing this game. And hence you, if you if you draw this out on a demand and supply diagram, you'll convince yourself that you will you sort of you know bang around from the supply curve to the demand curve to the supply curve to the demand curve, and you'll create a web.

138
00:53:59.040 --> 00:54:18.880
It'll look like a web. Okay. And the web could be explosive, as in it could go, you know, the price could keep going up faster and faster, because sort of the cobweb could be sort of if you can if you imagine built outwards, right?

139
00:54:18.880 --> 00:54:40.600
So keep going explosive, or conversely, it could be built inwards and could converge to a price, right? So this is this is essentially the idea of a cobweb. And what is determining whether it's built outwards or built inwards? Nothing but the relative elasticity of demand and supply, right? So if supply becomes more inelastic than demand, you get you have explosive growth.

140
00:54:40.600 --> 00:55:01.960
If supply becomes less elastic than demand, then it you get conversion growth, right? Simple. Now the long-term story is clear, right? You know, why are you talking about this? But we know that the long term it's the supply curves is a straight line, so that's it, right? But actually that's not it, right? Because it the in the short run, we do have variance, right?

141
00:55:01.960 --> 00:55:40.040
I mean, if you look at the stock to flow model of plan B, right? I mean, these got huge confidence bands around the price, right? Which permits the price to have a lot of areas, and there is indeed a lot of volatility. So the carbon supply model is a good way to try to understand where that where that volatility is coming from, and how by looking at Bitcoin as a commodity, you are able to apply this lag between production and that that of a good and the prevalent price

142
00:55:40.040 --> 00:56:05.480
In a market, right? And we know this, right? We know this intuitively, as I'm saying this, you're thinking, yeah, the amount of network hash power that's deployed, and how how difficulty adjusts with that, and right, we know this. We know we there are all kinds of metrics out there for for miners on on their cash conversion cycle or or the generation versus the first spend, right?

143
00:56:05.480 --> 00:56:24.320
That that's a there's a great chart out there on one of the websites on generation versus first spend, right? And we know that's exactly that's showing this idea, right? Because if first spend is higher than generation, then you know that that they're drawing down inventory, or and conversely, if this is the other case, then inventories are building up, right?

144
00:56:24.480 --> 00:56:43.040
And cash conversion cycles got to is related to the amount of if you need to build up inventories for sale, right? Then the cash conversion cycle is how long does it take for you to run run out of your cash, right? Right to convert cash into inventory, right?

145
00:56:43.040 --> 00:57:04.640
How long did it take you to run out of cash? So so those sort of cycles are things that miners are are are are very aware of when they're when they're thinking of how to plan inventory. So the long-term story, Brady is stock to flow, sure. The short-term story, however, is inventory to sales, which is exactly the same thing.

146
00:57:04.640 --> 00:57:22.800
Inventory to sales, inventory is a stock and sales is a flow, just like the long term you've got a stock and a flow. The short-term story is an inventory to sales, which sort of goes along with the government supply and water, which is very interesting, I think. And then you ally that to the idea of a reservation demand.

147
00:57:22.880 --> 00:57:49.520
A reservation demand, so so is the is where which side do miners appear on? Supply or demand. Well you would think that well, they're sort of mining bitcoins, so the suppliers aren't they? Well, yeah, but they're also reserving the a part of the of the of what they mine of their blocker board, and to the extent that that changes, they have a reservation demand.

148
00:57:49.520 --> 00:58:13.320
Reservation demand is the demand that the supplier has for his own goods, just like the big producers might have. And we know the sort of thing is very important. I mean, right now, with this whole pandemic, we sort of see the stories of how you know what was it, a few just a week or two ago, 200,000 pigs were killed by farmers because there was nobody to buy them, milk was thrown, right?

149
00:58:13.320 --> 00:58:40.520
So there was excess inventory built up because of a particular price that they were expecting, or the contract of a particular length that they were signed up to. So they were so they were managing their inventory to sales ratio by destroying it, by destroying what they had then produced. So that sort of cycle is a very interesting thing and relates really well back to cycles that you see in paleoanthropology with gold.

150
00:58:40.520 --> 00:59:01.720
So, which is very interesting, right? This is this is there's a paper that maybe I should send over to your to use, maybe you can think whether your your listeners would be interested in reading. But the whole idea that that is made in that paper is that gold was used as for in a cycle of concentration to circulation.

151
00:59:01.720 --> 00:59:21.160
So the idea is that when you're when you're trying to build up a social hierarchy or your kingdom, or indeed a state, there are periods where you will concentrate holdings of your money of the good money, and periods where you will circulate it, you know, right?

152
00:59:21.160 --> 00:59:40.120
So, and this transmutability between concentration to circulation is all happening in the pursuit of power. You concentrate it in the pursuit of power, you circulate it into buy obedience for it with your power, right? So, this is the sort of this concentration to circulation thing with which was with with that was happening with gold.

153
00:59:40.120 --> 01:00:05.600
That cycle in with in concentr of concentration and circulation, right? Which we sort of don't think about when we think about money, that concentration circulation cycle is something that Bitcoin does organically. There is nobody sitting up there on top who's deciding, oh, there should be X concentration and X circulation happening or circulation happening right now, and that's going to be you know accretive to the benefit of someone else.

154
01:00:05.600 --> 01:00:27.200
It is what it is, right? There is a structure, we're playing it. At times it'll be concentrated, times there'll be there'll be more circulation. And we're clearly on a circulation period right now. Right now, yes, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. Oh, that's fantastic. So, what is what do you think then the implications are for this next price cycle?

155
01:00:27.200 --> 01:00:48.720
The one you know that we're in the midst of right now in the next couple of years. I think that we're it, yeah. I mean, I am terrible at price prediction. You know, I like to do TA only because I like to see how each how each leg of this is all working with my with my with my econometric side of stuff, right? So so which models do you like kind of gravitate toward, I guess?

156
01:00:48.720 --> 01:01:06.960
Cobweb. I think cog web works really well. I think I might have a training new chart on my Twitter feed where I've suppressed the price axis because it's just stupid if you have the price access there. But if you but if you if you look at that chart, you'll see what I mean.

157
01:01:06.960 --> 01:01:39.560
Because it's all of the stuff that I just explained on cobweb supply and reservation band mill, that sort of stuff, it works so nicely with those cycles that we've seen so far. Okay in in Bitcoin. And then of course, I keep thinking back to each of these cycles playing in that grand mechanism design that Monakamoto has has created for us, where we're moving, inching forward step by step towards this, you know, the ultimate goal of a hard digitally native hard money or hard money, right?

158
01:01:39.560 --> 01:02:01.160
By going through these cycles of unit of account, medium of exchange, store of value. I mean, all the work that's happening with privacy right now in this space is proof positive in my mind that we're moving from towards medium of specialization and on route right now building store of value.

159
01:02:01.160 --> 01:02:19.640
So I think that's if in a very, very broad high-level way, I think that's really where we are right now. We're building this equilibrium, we're in the game of store of store of value. Medium of exchange is long gone, right? We're building in the store of value thing, which will permit us to have medium of specialization.

160
01:02:19.640 --> 01:02:39.480
Once that's happened, game over, because then it becomes once you know, just like Pandora's boxes open, you can then the whole idea of government regulation is this, you know, Tina's heal. It it isn't anymore, because at that time it becomes a serves a completely different role in in economic activity.

161
01:02:40.520 --> 01:03:07.480
So enmeshed with your identity that it's hard to separate. Yes. Yeah. Weirdly. Yeah, exactly. And I so I'm curious then how the kind of the timeline you have in your head. Everybody sort of has their timeline that they've settled on through gathering as much information as possible and synthesizing that and sort of saying, like, okay, it's gonna be five years, 10 years, 15, 20 years.

162
01:03:07.480 --> 01:03:28.480
Do you has that changed for you over the past few months, given, you know monetary circumstances? Yeah, yeah. You know, I'll I'll I'll give you a try to answer to that question. You know the Greek virtue of sophine.

163
01:03:28.480 --> 01:03:49.840
I don't know, there's somebody in your your listeners might be Greek and they're like, Well, stop butchering the word, but the word sophersing, I just love that word. It's it so pressing is a virtue, right? It's a virtue where you've got this ideal balance of the mind, right? It's like zen, complete ideal balance of the mind.

164
01:03:49.840 --> 01:04:08.320
Okay, so when you start your journey in Bitcoin, you have zero sofracine. Okay. Balance of the mind. There is this and sophersine is all these other aspects that are related to the definition of risk, by the way. Okay, like the first derivative of the utility function, second derivative.

165
01:04:08.400 --> 01:04:29.600
So you've got you've got a risk aversion, and you've got risk preference, if you've got a convex utility function for for wealth. And then there's a third derivative, you've got something called prudence, right? And the I the definition of prudence is the accumulation of wealth in the face of systemic risk.

166
01:04:29.600 --> 01:04:48.720
Okay, that's literally the definition of prudence, right? The accumulation of wealth in the face of risk. And I think you and so that's the economics of it, right? The economics of risk. So for scenes it it the virtue of sophersing encapsulates prudence as one of its virtues, of its sub-virtues.

167
01:04:49.200 --> 01:05:12.360
So I think hodling, right? The idea of hodling, that idea of having of having the ideal time preference, developing that, right? All of that, I think, is not just garbage talk. I really think it is in inherent in to Bitcoin.

168
01:05:12.360 --> 01:05:32.760
It's inherent to Bitcoin. It's inherent to this idea of cycles playing out. It's in it, so it's it's it's in it's vital for you to wait for those cycles to play out. And while you wait, it's in it's it's vital for you to have prudence, right? And prudence means avoiding systemic risk.

169
01:05:32.760 --> 01:05:55.720
And we know where those systemic risks are coming out, right? Don't you spell them out to you of all people as where those systemic risks are coming from to us? So yeah, I mean, my answer to this is you know, I'm going, I'm going to I try to devote as much attention on developing that virtue of substance, and yeah, I'm gonna accumulate meanwhile.

170
01:05:55.720 --> 01:06:14.760
Yeah, yeah. And I haven't I don't mind waiting for a while. I don't think that this is a short-term thing anyway. My my gut feeling is that we should be talking in terms of you know decades rather than mere years.

171
01:06:14.760 --> 01:06:38.200
Not saying that prices are not going, pricing will be all over the place, right? That's the interesting thing. Have you noticed this, right? That Bitcoin has massive volatility as one of its characteristics, right? In price, but it has almost this serene steadiness in a great many of its other characteristic variables, right?

172
01:06:38.200 --> 01:07:16.400
Yeah, I mean, you just build you forget price, for example, you just pick up, say, difficulty or hash rate or you know, one of those right block times block times right block times is the is much better than than the others right you just see this it just keeps going and that is software scene for you right you know because you it prices irrelevant you just see this going and I quite like that I quite like that about Bitcoin so I think I'm I'm quite happy to stay here for a long time it's fine I hear that man tick tock next block as I like to say it's

173
01:07:16.560 --> 01:07:54.560
Yeah Bitcoin's a beautiful a beautiful clock of value of time and you know of virtue I would say as well yes yes it is yes I mean this stuff this this time preference thing is I tell you it's really true because you know I've become a lot less frivolous in things that I spend my money on right I think about it more things you know I think and even when I don't have to I think about it more it's just become habit yes right it just be and I don't

174
01:07:54.560 --> 01:08:17.480
Think that you get that habit easily some for some people it comes very easily yes some people some people are just born that way but I'm not I was not born I'm you know I just love spending right I'm in your campus yeah but I think once what sort of going through the going going into this rabbit hole of Bitcoin.

175
01:08:17.480 --> 01:08:38.920
It it just sort of puts that discipline for me, it definitely has has given more of that discipline to, you know, well, would you rather be doing this or would you rather be, you know. And it's not just about stacking sacks. Of course it is that. But it's also about, you know, how you spend time on on doing other things. You know, would you rather watch Netflix or read another paper or something?

176
01:08:39.560 --> 01:09:05.320
You know, and not just spend time with your children. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Definitely. It makes you recognize scarcity. And this is actually with Father's Day. I sort of got inspired in Sentimental and posted, you know, a tweet about how you know we talk a lot about scarcity on Bitcoin Twitter. And you know, our life is scarce, our time is scarce, but you know, even more scarce than that is the you know subset of time that we get to spend with our children when they're young.

177
01:09:05.320 --> 01:09:27.080
So true. And you know, my kids are five and nine right now, and so I'm sort of in the midst of it. I'm just really in my my nine-year-old daughter's sort of on the precipice of you know, kind of moving away from needing care from us and moving more into the realm of like you know, spending time with with friends and getting more influence from friends and guidance from friends.

178
01:09:27.080 --> 01:09:46.520
So it just it's such a short time that you can have with with them as children. And so yeah, I mean it's as a parent, I sort of I mean I had that notion before Bitcoin, of course, that you know, to appreciate to be present, you know, for my children's childhoods, but I don't know. It just makes it keener, right? It just makes it reinforced, yeah.

179
01:09:46.520 --> 01:10:00.920
Yeah, yeah. Yeah. It keeps making you focus on put you putting your focus on time. Yeah, that's very it's very true. It is true. Exactly. Well, this has been a fantastic conversation, Prateek. I'm really glad to have the opportunity.

180
01:10:01.280 --> 01:10:03.000
I'm so honored that you let me speak to you.

181
01:10:04.840 --> 01:10:28.480
Oh, well, I mean, I'm surprised that we hadn't done it sooner. And you know, I really appreciate your thoughts and writing and really happy to have had you on the podcast. And I hope some other Bitcoin podcasts. Although I don't remember what I had written, but yeah, so that's quite all right. I mean, that's actually a sign of a of you know, a brain that is you know, full of thought and moving moving from one thing to the next, and that's okay.

182
01:10:28.800 --> 01:10:47.520
That's that's great too. It's it shows, you know, like you read Zabo's blog and it's just all over the place. It's you know, yeah. Oh, it's brilliant, isn't it? That's the other thing. I think Bitcoin breeds polymaths, right? Nice. Yeah, I think it does. That's what I like about Sabo so much. I mean, it's just brilliant flexibility of mind.

183
01:10:47.520 --> 01:11:12.240
It certainly attracts polymaths, and I do think you're right that it breeds polymaths too, because it's you know, look at all of us on on big you know, hodlers and bitcoiners, how much we've learned about different subjects that I would never would have delved into or dived into. And you know, I was saying that I've said this before on Twitter too that I didn't realize I was so intellectually bored until I found it.

184
01:11:12.240 --> 01:11:16.000
You know, so yeah, anyway, thank you again for your time and it was

185
01:11:16.140 --> 01:11:18.320
Great. I really enjoyed it. Thank you. Yeah.

186
01:11:29.280 --> 01:11:50.080
Thanks to Prateek for joining me. You can find him on Twitter at Gurha at G O O R H A, and I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with your family and friends. Share it out on Twitter with your fellow Bitcoiners. The bull is incoming. We can all feel it. It's time to get hyped and get your friends and family educated.

187
01:11:50.080 --> 01:12:10.360
You should also get them stacking with Swan Bitcoin at Swan Bitcoin.com/slash Brady. Also, thank you to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast in their feed. Check out my merch shop at layer1bdc.com. Click on partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. Cool stuff there to check out, including some opsec friendly gear.

188
01:12:10.360 --> 01:12:20.200
Purchases do support this podcast. And check out the podcast of Creative for Swan, the Swan Signal Podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal Live broadcasts.

189
01:12:20.560 --> 01:12:24.420
It's a pair of bitcoiners getting together for some unique, awesome discussions.

190
01:12:24.760 --> 01:13:08.920
You can subscribe at Swan Signal Podcast.com. Add it to your rotation. If you have any questions from me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter and I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
