Francis Pouliot: Privacy, S2X/UASF, Scaling, Governments and Bitcoin
Francis Pouliot, CEO and co-founder of Bull Bitcoin, joins Brady to talk about privacy, S2X/UASF, scaling, how governments might approach bitcoin, and bitcoin’s future in general.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey, learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? I am at the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco right now. It's been an absolutely incredible time meeting so many amazing Bitcoiners here.
I know that things can get heated on the proving ground of ideas that is Twitter,
But in person and to a person, everyone I have met has been incredibly approachable, genuine, and kind. It's been an awesome time.
I was fortunate enough to hang out with a great group of folks Monday night on this beautiful rooftop overlooking the bay, stuffing our faces with incredible beef.
Shout out to Home Slice on Twitter for cooking that up for us.
We washed it down with a bunch of beer and whiskey. It was a freaking blast. And one of those folks was Francis Pouliot, CEO and co-founder of Bull Bitcoin.
And I got to sit down and chat Bitcoin with him today here at the conference. In this episode, we talk about privacy, S2X and UASF, about scaling Bitcoin, government regulation in Canada, and just Bitcoin's future in general. So I hope you all enjoy it.
Here we go.
I'm here with Francis Pouliot from Bull Bitcoin,
A company based in Canada, Bitcoin Company. It's basically the Bitcoin version of Coinbase. And we've been, well, first of all, welcome to the show, Francis. Oh, thank you so much for having me. It's it's a pleasure. Glad to have you, man. Big fan of your work. And you know, this conference is really bringing to the fore this kind of move back toward Bitcoin, an embracing of Bitcoin.
BTC Media is kind of refocusing on Bitcoin. This conference is the first conference in a while that's really just focused on Bitcoin as opposed to blockchain and crypto and all that, all that mess. There's a saying that we say a lot in Bitcoin, cyberpunks write code. And I think that we should kind of broaden that a little bit and talk about how Bitcoiners build.
And there's so many people at this conference that are building amazing Bitcoin businesses. It's really inspiring to see. You're one of those people. What do you think about this trend moving back toward Bitcoin? Yeah, and I'm really happy you mentioned that because cypherpunks write code. That's true, but not everybody can write code, but you can be a cypherpunk and not write code.
You can have the cypherpunk mentality in ETHOS and still want to build. And I didn't start to work on open source project building code until five years into Bitcoin almost. But even during those years, I did consider myself a cypherpunk and I was working on building other stuff like education material, like like meetups, like like businesses.
I think the move to Bitcoin, obviously, as a as a Bitcoin maximalist, I'm very, very happy about the move towards back back into the core of what we're supposed to be doing, focusing on and stopping the distraction. I personally went through that at the pretty much the end of 2017 where I was working part-time as a you know blockchain consultant trying to get people back into Bitcoin.
And I quit doing blockchain consulting to myself get back 100% to Bitcoin. And I started to see that happen just after SegWit 2x, kind of also during the breaking Bitcoin, building on Bitcoin conferences, that kind of I think kickstarted it. And just you know, the it took the industry a little while to admit its mistakes and to try other things out, and the everybody has a learning path, which it's almost a meme now.
It's like you know, you get into mining first and then into altcoin trading and then you know back into Bitcoin. So I think what that's gonna do is the people that are building on Bitcoin are gonna have a much stronger focus, a much much deeper conviction. And I think that the last year we've seen so many people just start to build stuff, really kind of quit their job as a quit lurking and like start start building.
And I think we're gonna see the dividends of that during this this next bull run because now the bull run is starting up now. I don't think we've seen the peak. I think things are just starting to heat up. And when all the normies start to come in, I much rather have the hardcore group of Bitcoin builders that are onboarding them than the previous kind of cohort of Bitcoin companies like Bitpain Coinbase that really dropped the ball.
So overall, I mean I just I just really could not be happier about how the Bitcoin ecosystem is growing. And as someone who like works for Bitcoin, right? I kind of feel relieved. I see a lot of other guys, yourself included, that are kind of taking up the mantle of public education and awareness and onboarding.
And I, you know, I feel I can finally start to relax. Yeah, I feel Bitcoin is pretty well bootstrapped. I think the social scalability aspect is great. I think the idea that the community is gravitating around some core values is is is fantastic. And yeah, I just can be happier right now. Yeah, you tweeted something about social skill the social scalability of Bitcoin that was interesting.
I think it was earlier today. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You talking about that idea? Oh, yeah, totally. So the idea came up because I was preparing trying to think about what I'm gonna talk about for scalability of Bitcoin. I was just like, we've talked about like layered scaling already. Like everybody knows about layered scaling, everybody knows that the base layer we're not gonna change it.
And it just got me to thinking like I think the idea that the Bitcoin community was supposed to come together to make decisions was the infancy of Bitcoin, and it's not supposed to be like that. Like we're not supposed to be making any decision because if we want the system to scale, we must remove everything that like it Bitcoin is gonna scale by itself and was remove stuff that prevents it from scaling.
And what removes Bitcoin from scaling is confusion, is the division of the blockchain, it's hard forks, it's it's people that are fighting for power and that are doing backdoor politics and deals and people are trying to game the system. So the idea that right now what I see is there's not much disagreement about where Bitcoin is heading as a as a software project.
I think people have abandoned the idea to control it. And we're not supposed to be necessarily a Bitcoin community. We are now, but we're more we're more a community of Bitcoin builders, right? Than a Bitcoin community at large because there's no dollar community, like there's no oxygen community. It's right, it should just seep into the back of people's minds. And in order for that to happen, people should not be required to follow social media to know on which change they're going.
They shouldn't, like you shouldn't think about Bitcoin that much, right? If you're a normal person, it's just that it's just the grease that allows you to do your commerce and buy your groceries and you know feed your kids and like do all that. So if if Bitcoin becomes just an accepted thing that's moving by itself that we can't really affect or we can't really change, and stop getting the ideas that I can create a better version of Bitcoin.
And there's two ways this is happening. Not only have people stopped the idea to make Bitcoin better with their whatever and put it in there with with a BIP or hard fork, increase the block size, increase inflation, whatever. People are also stopping the idea that well, if I can't change Bitcoin, I'll just do another altcoin because the economic reality of Bitcoin's dominance is is starting to become understood.
People are starting to accept the fact that currencies are not like regular goods and that the equilibrium tends to have one that's a total dominator. So let's not change Bitcoin, let's not create other Bitcoins, let's just build on top of Bitcoin because the biggest adopt the biggest hurdles that I'm seeing right now are not like the technical roadmap of Bitcoin Core.
It's really the ease of use of people that are trying to get on it, that are already convinced, because there's no bigger tragedy than someone who's already enlightened to Bitcoin, but that physically logistically has a lot of difficulty using it or or getting onto it. If you have made the effort intellectually to understand and appreciate Bitcoin, we are supposed to make it easy for you to and that is the cypherpunks write code because if you go back to Cypherpunks write code, what they meant was that you cannot have privacy by yourself in the sense that if I have like a signal app and you have the sick and I want to communicate
In the private way with you, I need you to have a client-side software on your phone that will recognize the protocol. And if you don't have it, I can't communicate with you privately, right? So and because no one else wants you to have that but me, I'll build it for you, right?
I'll I'll build the tools that you need to free yourself so that we can live in this alternate reality, which is either private communications or or or private money. So Bitcoin is useless if we are only transacting with each other, right? Like I like your Brady, but I want to transact with other people in my life.
I want to transact with my cousins, with the guy at the store, and if I want that to happen for myself, I need to do a little bit of effort to make it easier for others, right? Yeah, so like that that idea, and this kind of reminds me of something that Snowden said this morning because we saw Snowden came in to give a keynote this morning, and it was I think great.
But the idea that privacy is an alternate reality, right? That's separate from the kind of world that we live in that everyone else lives in, is a something we need to get away from. So he was talking about how we need to be in a world where privacy is accessible to everyone and it's not just available to the elite or to the you know privileged or rich as it is now.
And did you like what what else did you take away from from Snowden's keynote? Well, I think that was what I think that was one of the key points. I so I think the phrase he said is privacy shouldn't be selective, right? In the sense that privacy should be opt out, not opt-in. You privacy should be conceived as you selectively reveal things about yourself on your own terms on your own time, right?
You shouldn't have to do an incredible amount of effort to get the privacy, should be the opposite, right? And that also speaks to the idea that if you have a certain class of the population which is able to have privacy, and other classes of the population, either because they're technically illiterate or something like that, are not able, it's too hard, you don't have the resources to do that are too or too intense, then you are just creating more divisions in society, essentially.
Like you don't want to have a different classes of people because for for example, if if the minority of people are using privacy enhancing techniques and the majority is not, then there is the idea that maybe the pri the minority is doing something wrong and we're gonna kick them out of some spheres of society, some sort of some business activities or something like that.
And that kind of reminded me of CoinJoin, right? One of the reasons why I'm trying to push CoinJoin so much is that I don't want a minority of users to use CoinJoin and have the majority be targets, right? Think of it like this. If 20% of the transactions are CoinJoin, you used to focus your effort on 100% of all transactions, now you can only focus your efforts on the remaining 80%, which makes it 10-20% easier to de-animize the other users, right?
In that case, privacy is still a privilege of the people who understand how to use Coinjoin or something. Yeah, yeah. Exactly. Privacy is a privilege to the people that have enough time to spend on Twitter and on the and average Joe, again, he should not worry about this. He should just get his money, it should be mixed, it should be mixed automatically by his wallet, and it should be sent after the mix to another cold storage address that he he registered or something like that.
I don't know exactly how that's gonna happen, but yeah, totally, it should not be a privilege. So and also there's a self-interest in that because if I'm using CoinJoin as a company, I'm standing out. Like, do I have something to hide? Or my users more illegitimate than others? So I do have an incentive for everybody to use CoinJoin, so I don't stand out in that way.
Right, right. It makes perfect sense. So, what has your experience been with the government in Canada? I know that you're a vocal and like very well known Bitcoiner in Canada. And you're not like scared to criticize the government and put the words out there. So, what is like what's your relationship with with the government in Canada and have you ever have you heard anything from them, I guess?
Oh, yeah, my relationship is excellent with the government. And like maybe taking a very tiny step back, like the government is a very large set of different entities, right? Surprisingly, for maybe for most people, most agencies they don't really communicate, they don't collaborate that much. You can get six different government agencies that are establishing their own policy towards Bitcoin, and then even they even talk to each other to make sure that it was compatible with each other.
So I've been spending a lot of time educating them. You know, people might think I'm super toxic from my Twitter account, but I can assure you that in a in a conversation with you know regulators and business people, I can I can play the part where I used to wear suits now, I just wear a hoodie, I don't care anymore. But but I mean I can speak their language.
I worked as an economist before, I worked in public policy and public relations, so I can definitely handle myself with them. And it's it's been a journey of education. So the goal of the education towards them has been one, there is an opportunity for Canadians. Like can if Canadians adopt Bitcoin first, we have a competitive advantage globally in many respects.
For example, I talked to a government person from a provincial ministry of let's call it economics or finance, I'm not sure exactly which that one is called, but they were looking at we talked and we started looking at Bitcoin in terms of import-export and import deficits, favorite trade deficits.
So this person now is looking at Bitcoin this way. If we are trading lumber, for example, with with China, we're exporting lumber, but we're importing bitcoins, then we have a trade deficit because we're importing more bitcoins that are mined in China than we're exporting lumber to China. And they're just trying to have some good stats.
They want to have a trade surplus. So they want now bitcoins to be created in that province in Canada so that they're exported elsewhere. So there's fiat coming in and Bitcoin's coming out, which is much better from a bureaucrat standpoint. This is what the governments want. In terms of the tax authority, in Canada, after years of contention, they finally followed through on not considering Bitcoin a commodity for value-added tax purposes.
So if like you buy Bitcoin at a Bitcoin ETM, you're not charged a sales tax on it, like which is 50%, which would create like a 25% premium basically, right? Over the price. You still have like a capital gains tax like we did in the US? Yeah, yeah, we have a capital gains tax. So essentially Bitcoin is considered for anti-money laundering purposes as money.
One of the things we did very, very well was that in 2014 we lobbied the government, but more from a like public activism standpoint, not it wasn't like you know backdoor lobbying like in the US. And they amended the law that regulates money laundering to include virtual currency businesses in the existing framework, which is what we convinced them to do.
We said, Hey, Bitcoin is money. You don't need to create a new law, right? We already have laws, right? Yeah, yeah. Currency exchangers, payment processors, check cashers are all regulated the same way. And it's like we're just like these guys, we're a currency exchange. That's it. So now we are regulated under currency exchange laws and regulations, which are you know fairly relaxed.
Has that made things easier for you? No, not really. Technically speaking, the regulations are not in force yet. So we're doing it in a kind of voluntary, yeah, voluntary to be compliant with the requirements of our banking and payment processing partners. Okay. For example, speaking of CoinJoin again, a lot of people think that governments are forcing exchanges to use chain analysis, and that it's somehow a legal requirement for them to track the origin of coins.
I have not seen a single piece of legislation or regulation that mandates this, but I have seen a lot of banking institutions that tell their exchange Bitcoin exchange clients, we want you to use chain analysis, right? So a lot of the KYC and regul and like the KYC essentially, or the deanonymization process you see, is not always driven by governments, and it's very often driven by by the bank partners of the exchanges that are doing the on-rep and the off-remp.
In our case, in Canada, we are arguing that because of the privacy laws of Canada, it's actually illegal not to do CoinJoin. Because if you don't do CoinJoin for your users, you're inadvertently leaking some of their financial transactions to third parties without their consent. And these third parties may be foreign governments, they may be hackers, they may be fraudsters trying to try to identify potential Bitcoiners to defraud their bitcoins or still you know hack them or whatever.
So we're we're flipping the argument completely on said. It's like Coinjoin is not non compliant, it's actually required. And we do KYC for their specials. On bills, for example, it's a $3,000 a day threshold over which we ask for a government ID.
And what that means is if the government asks us, are you our you is this guy our user? Or do you have any transactions with this Bitcoin address? We can find you and we can give that information to the government if they ask. But in Canada, it's a bit different where there hasn't been John Doe summons. I have a warrant canary on my Twitter profile now.
Right. If I never if if there's ever a John Doe summon or something I can't talk about, I'll take off my warrant canary there. But there hasn't been. They there hasn't been like, you know, they don't come to us and say, like give us all your users' information. Right. It's more like keep the information there. So if we need an investigation to have information ready, then then we can send you a subpoena and you can hand it over.
So yeah, it's been it's been it's been pretty good. Like for you know, Bitcoin is a tool for for some criminal activity. So the enforcement agencies, like they're not they don't care about the Bitcoin that was used. They they care about the crime that was committed, right? So so they want to know how Bitcoin works. They're kind of on top of it.
Bitcoin is also not a security in Canada. We are I mean that phrase exactly has not been ushered by the securities regulators, but it's definitely obvious that it is not a security from their new guidelines. It's also pretty obvious to most of us in the industry that everything else is a security in Canada.
Okay. So from that side, you know, Bitcoin's doing pretty well. You mean by that you mean like ICOs? The ICOs and tokens and all coins. Some some analysis shows that maybe two or three others may like Ethereum. I think like Monero was one of them. I saw Dash and Monero once in a in a report.
Yeah, and it's going pretty well. Like the only thing that I think the main places of concern right now are if surprisingly lightning network nodes, custodial Bitcoin wallets or multi-sig, it's not entirely they're not out of the woods yet to not be considered lightning nodes I think are definitely out of the woods.
Okay, but custodial wallets and multi-sig solution setups like split key recovery setups might be considered as a money service business. So that's my last concern, really, is just to make sure that really to make sure that the government cannot make rules that they can't enforce. Right. Because like if they make rules that they can't enforce, that means that the non-technical users are gonna be forced for imagine imagine like custodial wallets like blue wallet, for example, is required to KYC.
Well, the normies are gonna submit to the KYC, whereas the smart ones or the ones who are doing something illicit will not. And again, we don't want to avoid having a two-tiered system where the technically technically illiterate Bitcoin constituency is forced down bad bad practices just because they don't know any better.
Yeah. I know that last year Canada's the government, just to kind of wrap up this talk about the government and Bitcoin in Canada, there was a questionnaire that was sent out to a lot of Bitcoiners and they specifically asked about whether or not or whether you had used CoinJoin services and why did you use CoinJoin services? Yes. Did you get one of those? I'd rather not comment on that one.
And but yeah, but that that's that's a real thing. That's that's definitely a real thing. So are they I mean, was the intention behind that because they're curious about the CoinJoin services, and that and that's why you're trying to t the flip the argument? I don't i the CoinJoin had nothing to do with that specifically. CoinJoin has more I'm I'm more worried right now in CoinJoin from corporate espionage.
For the I'm more worried about the traceability of my users' bitcoins for corporate espionage hackers and trusted that may want to know who our users are than governments. That questionnaire is very specific, it's very detailed. Some of the lawyers that I've talked to are telling me that it's voluntary, that you don't have to answer those questions.
So I would say if you did get that questionnaire, you should definitely just get some legal advice to see what's an appropriate response. But that was a bit scary, I have to say. That was like one of the scariest things that I've that I've seen from governments, which is just out of the blue, not really talking to some of the Bitcoin industry leaders.
I like I'd never heard about this coming down the pipeline or anything like that beforehand. And I don't know why they want to know these things. Right, right? Is it are you asking me all these questions because you can? Or is there something you want to know?
Yeah, or are are they building a database of Bitcoin addresses? Like we don't know, right? And this is something that I think as a society should be discussed in like parliament, for example. Right. You should have MPs voting on whether or not we establish a national database of Bitcoin users.
It shouldn't be some some tax authority that just decides, hey, we're gonna start, you know, creating a database of Bitcoin users. I mean, so that's kind of what I want to do is if you're gonna try to do these things, pass a law in parliament and let the political process do it. Like I'm more worried from rogue agencies that are doing the their own thing, extending their jurisdiction over the bounds.
And I think the only thing that can prevent that over time is just like we just need a lot of Bitcoiners. Yeah, right, because if there's a lot of Bitcoin users, like 10% of the country, 15% of the country, they're gonna demand that politicians like get some oversight on what the regulatory agencies are doing concerning Bitcoin. Yeah, absolutely.
Yeah, and it concerned me definitely. I mean, when I saw those questionnaires and I downloaded and went through it, you know, yeah, I would be nervous to get to get a questionnaire like that because you know you've got to be really careful. Obviously the state has a lot of power, and it seemed like this was sort of I don't know, maybe just like a little opening salvo to what state how states might approach.
It was a pretty big opening salvo. Yeah, how states might approach like, you know, I don't know what the ultimate end would be, but yeah, you know, stopping Bitcoin, I think has got to be kind of the ultimate goal, or at least containing it in some way or another. Yeah, yeah. Well, one thing's for sure is that I mean I'm gonna keep an eye on this situation very, very closely because you know, I'm a Canadian and I'm kind of patriotic.
I mean, I like the country and I would really really want Bitcoin Canada to become you know a Bitcoin superpower, where every other country is jealous of our huge Bitcoin reserves and where we can you know guarantee international trade into in if the banking system gets shut down or or collapses or something like that. So no, we're gonna keep an eye on it.
And I think you know the economic reality of Bitcoin is gonna impose itself over time. What I don't want to happen is I don't want to feel pain in the next 10 years, right? The pain of the government intervention. I'm pretty confident that in 10 or 15 years the political process is gonna legitimize Bitcoin because there's gonna be so many Bitcoin holders and it's just gonna be voting for politicians that if think of it like this like let's say that you're a Bitcoiner and the politician there's two politicians debating on five different issues, like healthcare, whatever, economy, whatever.
And one of the issues is Bitcoin, which one is it that's gonna be the one that you care the most about? Like if you have like one Bitcoin or two or three, or even just a few, and you plan to accumulate more, you're gonna be extremely concerned about and it might be the only issue that concerns you about politics, right? So I'm pretty confident that all the government threats to Bitcoin are disappearing over time, and all that Bitcoin needs to do is just continue to do its thing long enough for the base of holders to be like unbeatable, basically too powerful.
Right, right. And we're seeing you know, Bitcoin pol pro Bitcoin politicians you know filtering in too. You know, there's several in the United States, and when there was a congressman named Brad Sherman a few like a couple months ago that basically came out and said, look, Bitcoin is a threat to US power. Yeah, you know, and there were several politicians that pushed back and said, No, Bitcoin is an opportunity for US power.
Yeah, you know, yeah. And it's just really awesome to see at that level that that debate's already happening. And of course, those guys are probably holding Bitcoin. Yeah. And so they're gonna be incentivized, you know, to help make sure that Bitcoin's safe too. Yeah, totally. And most of their monetary policy is not made by politicians. Like a large chunk of their global monetary policy is made by the Bank of International Sun, and then it's made by the other large central banks like the ECB and the in the ACB, it's made by other central bankers, and these are all like kind of beige suited academics that have like post things for life and that are theorizing about how to control the global economy.
Whereas a politician is accountable to its constituency, and the reasons why politicians don't care about monetary policy is because they don't understand it, and it's not really relevant to anyone. Like it's you don't get re-elected on your monetary policy. That's never happened. You've never had a politician win an election based on his proposed chain to monetary policy.
It's just too complex. It's been purposefully made to look like alchemy, like it's unavoidable. But you get politicians like in in in Venezuela, the challenger to Maduro, apparently he's you know, Bolsonaro in Brazil. I'm he looks like the kind of guy that you know might look at the Bank of International Summit and be like, who the fuck are you?
Like, yeah, I don't insert you, I'm fucking president of Brazil. Right. I'm gonna make my own monetary policy with Bitcoin and gold, yeah, or something like that. And I and I think in Canada, for example, there is a politician called Maxime Bernier, which was minister of industry, minister of foreign affairs under the conservative government, and he split off from the conservative to create a more libertarian political party.
I mean, I don't think he has any chance of getting elected this time around, but definitely the next time around. And he is a very outspoken critic of the central bank of Canada and of and he explicitly says we should bring the conversation back to gold in parliament, and we should discuss as a parliament like what are we doing with gold?
Why did we sell our gold? So Bitcoin is driven by these black swan events, and who knows? All it takes is a few influential politicians that just happen to have a stash of bitcoins and that happen to have you know friends and family, maybe that have bitcoins to really look at that, and then you know the net the narrative switches like that really quickly.
Yeah, so as you're running your business, what kind of changes have you noticed in like in terms of your customers, people coming to you to ask for help with Bitcoin? Like are there institutions that you're getting more attention from in Canada? And like or retail investors or both?
Like what's the situation like of the market from your point of view? There's a there's a few. I mean, it's it's hard for us to our our our business is quite automated, so we don't have like a lot of in-person interactions with the user. So unless I ask and they tell me, I don't really know why they're using Bitcoin.
Some things that I've seen is I think the remittance kind of use case has kind of died down a little bit because just the existing payment rails have gotten better and cheaper over the last five years. Like doing international remittance with fiat is a lot easier today than it was like five, ten years ago.
Which could be due to competition from it could it could it absolutely could. I think it's definitely one of the main main factors because imagine you the shareholder of Western Union and you got all these very smart Bitcoiners that keep saying we're gonna eat Western Union's lunch, you might be going to your your you know your board or your CEO and say, Are you doing something about these guys, these Bitcoiners?
Yeah, yeah, exactly. We should we should we should make sure they don't switch over to Bitcoin, you know, let's make ourselves better. So that's the narrative around that has maybe people are doing it more and more, but the narrative has died out a little bit. A lot of what I'm seeing is a lot of it is concern for international trade. So having strategic Bitcoin reserves, I don't know if any of our users does that, but it's definitely a discussion that I've been having with some people.
What do we do if we need to make a payment internationally extremely quickly? And because of an issue with the banking system or some sanctions, we can't do that. A lot of people are a lot of freelance contractors are getting paid in Bitcoin, actually. So the biggest change would be the amount of people that are getting getting earning income in Bitcoin.
I think but potentially the rise of KYC was one of those reasons, because you know, if you don't want to get KYC to acquire Bitcoin, then you don't need to do KYC if you're getting paid in Bitcoin, right? You're if you're a freelance like web designer and you want to get paid in Bitcoin, no one's gonna KYC you, right?
So that's that's a pretty neat way. And yeah, so I think that would be the biggest one I've seen. Just people just getting paid straight up in Bitcoin and then spending it on bills, for example. I've see a lot of that, but a lot of people are keeping it. And but it it's the existing demographic fix of Bitcoin aren't changing, they're just becoming bigger.
Right, right. There's no there's no change in demographics. Like some people say, Oh, it used to be the libertarians and then the hackers and then this and that. No, right. It was always a mix of random people. Yeah, sure. That makes sense. Yeah. So
Eric Voorhees spoke this morning with Eric Lombroso, and it was sort of kind of I guess an attempt to sort of kind of bring Eric back into the folder or whatever, I guess. I don't know. He's kind of been you know kind of singled out, not just singled out, but like he's not not just him, but he is one of the most well-known members of the New York Agreement and definitely helped kind of lead that.
Did you listen to him speak? Yeah, okay. What do you think? Well I think Eric is taking a bunch of the heat because you know all the all the other supporters of that just kind of went into hiding afterwards or they said. Like Wences Cesaris is like maybe the only other one that was came out and was like, yo, like that was probably wrong.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I actually I actually wish that that they would say that. I don't think I didn't hear that this morning. No, I didn't hear that from Eric guy. It was a pretty good opportunity to say that though. Yeah. But I was surprised. I mean, I thought that's what you know the opportunity was for. I didn't take it. Yeah, I think it's kind of the cypherpunk versus libertarian, that if you're these are not related like whatsoever.
I mean, I think there's points in common between being a libertarian and cypherpunk. But the idea of like the censorship resistant self-hosted network of nodes where there is you know there's there's no governance around it. I think these guys are business guys that are really just trying to use their business skills as a C.
I mean, I don't think it was a I don't think it was ill-intended from from Voorhees' part. I think also you know, if if you make one of those decisions like that, he has to kind of live with it. He's he's he he made what he thought was the best call for for all of Bitcoin.
But I think there's fundamentally a point that he misses with backwards compatibility. Like again, this morning he was arguing that Bitcoin needs to be able to change in order to you know succeed. Right. Where I believe fundamentally the opposite, Bitcoin must not be able to change if it is to succeed.
At the base layer. Yeah, because if it is able to change, then who gets to make that decision? And then you are group bringing in governance and governance is an obstacle to social scalability, yeah, or an acceptability of Bitcoin as a neutral money between different people. So I think they they misunderestimate how much people want can use that to change Bitcoin.
And they also I think misunderestimate, like I think they like the idea of a united Bitcoin community that shares the same values, and that they think we can as a community change that thing. But I again I don't want Bitcoin to remain a community. I want the Bitcoin community to become in 15 years a community of IT experts within this normal society and of economics.
And industry, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then it's just you know being used as money. Yeah, but despite everything, I think everybody learned their lesson with Segway2X because one thing I love about the Bitcoin community is that everybody is really consciously embodying the notion that they are like white blood cells, you know what I mean?
Like you kind of feel it, you're pushing back, you feel attacked, and you we spontaneously gather one once someone and it so that's what self-regulation means, right? We need to keep people accountable in a way which is not by threatening to put them in jail, and the subway to X companies were shunned, businesses partnerships were destroyed, it's why they're they're bitter because a lot of people like kick them out of their lives, and that's how they get the feedback that they shouldn't do that, right?
If we don't fight back, they don't get the feedback that this is not something that's acceptable. So, is anybody gonna try to fork Bitcoin again? I don't think so. I mean, what I'm worried about is a company that hasn't learned that lesson. That's maybe a big company that's that's rising the night the past year and a half or something or two years, that hasn't learned that lesson, that doesn't want to learn the lesson, that think they can do it better, and that they are they want to fork Bitcoin for some reason.
But realistically, I think I was I was on a scalability panel yesterday and I talked to Eric today, and I just said to him, I was like, I think this is the last time we talk about this. Yeah, right. Right, right. I think that's other than for historical purposes, education, education, and I think we can close that door and just you know move on.
Yeah. And yeah, just just it's done. What's done is done. Yeah. I mean, and just for historical and education purposes, I mean, do you think the main cause of the pushback, the motivation for the UASF and the users to gather together and push back was that the approach was a top-down one? Like these businesses were getting together in a closed room, literally a closed door room, and like trying to come with this proposal and then sort of saying, like, alright, we figured it out.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, it it totally was that. And it was also a lack of concern for users that are not willing to engage in this discussion. Like, so do you think if they would have like openly had this discussion on Twitter and Reddit and talk and all that stuff, do you think that would have made a difference? I mean, maybe they would have had more winning their sales, and maybe they would actually have activated.
I think we would have come back to the same same same same result. The fact is I would not accept that. I there would still be pushback, but like I don't I think people were really pissed off about the sort of arrogance that was the perceived arrogance of that helped with the pushback. That it'll help to it it helps to motivate the troops into action.
Yeah, I think. But fundamentally, the issue for me was and remains backwards compatibility. Hard forking is just out of the question. It's just out of the question because if a user bought Bitcoin in 2012 and hasn't been following up, when he syncs his Bitcoin Core node, he needs to be compatible with my service.
I don't want to have to explain to him, hey, actually, you know, like, we're a new Bitcoin now.
And he's like, well, you told me that the rules don't change. Yeah. Well, I'm sorry, sir, I lied. The rules do change. I changed it. Yeah. And I don't want to I no, I don't want to have that discussion with anyone ever. Yeah, it ruins it kind of ruins the Lindy effect. Lindy effect and that continuity and the trust. Yeah. So so not a lot of things in the universe have a hundred percent guarantee mathematically.
Okay. There's a very, very few amount of things. Speed of light. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, pretty much. And the I want the immunity of Bitcoin to be that. Right. I want I want the immutability of the supply to be that. You know, you look at Zcash, there's realistically a 99.9% chance, nine nine percent chance that the supply is not inflated artificially.
We can't audit that. We can never know. We don't have the same and the difference between 99.999% certainty and 100% is far greater than the difference between 99.9998 and 99.999%. Right. And I want Bitcoin to be that that guarantee because I don't want people to think about money that much as a thing, just as a tool.
They don't I don't want to think about the potential problems with using this tool. It's just supposed to work. And sorry, I got a bit lost on the question, but what was the question again? Yeah, we're just talking, I mean, about basically the motivation behind UASF and like how important hard forking are important it is to not hard fork between the combination of the system.
So the idea, yes, exactly. So the idea of the 100% guarantee is the strongest foundation for Bitcoin because that's what gives you peace of mind, essentially, right? And that's what allows people to become those radical Bitcoin hodlers that are so convinced that they don't even ask themselves questions anymore. Like it's because we have that certainty, and any step away from that certainty, I see it as kind of like tainting Bitcoin somehow.
It it should remain the pure like we have it, you have the opportunity, there's you're never going back from that, right? Once you're once you're not backwards compatible, you can never go back to being backwards compatible. Right. And I want Bitcoin to last for like a million years, like a thousand years. No, seriously, like a thousand years. Like, I want Bitcoin to be used on Mars in the future for real.
And they're gonna look back at us and imagine, oh well, 10 years in, they fucked up and they they they they went backwards compatible because they weren't they they couldn't find a creative enough solution for their short-term business needs and they screwed up Bitcoin for the rest of history. Right. And you know, I think we want to all be remembered as the people who kept Bitcoin safe and not the people who fucked up.
Yeah, yeah. So it's time to put it to bed, and I think that's that's right. I don't mean we can't talk about it anymore. I but like yeah, because it's important to remind people that we're not there, that this already happened, so that they don't try it again, yeah, and that they understand that when we say that miners don't control Bitcoin, we have empirical evidence that this is the truth.
Because if 90% of the hash rate was signing on to this, and half of the volume, trading volume exchanges were signing on to this Segway Twix Provocole, and they were not able to change Bitcoin. Who can? Like the insiders themselves, the pa the most powerful insiders could not change Bitcoin.
Right. What does that speak about the capability of a government to attack Bitcoin? There's no there's no other cryptocurrency or any product that can even come close to doing that. Absolutely. And the reason we can do that, the reasons we can do that are that we can run full nodes. We have decentralization. Yeah. And the users basically have the power of deciding what code to run. And that's what UASF was about.
It was literally a proposed you know change to Bitcoin Core. Yeah. That everyone on UI that was kind of behind US UASF, the user activated software, decided that we're like, we're gonna just run this. Yeah, right? Yeah. And it's yeah, and the efforts the enforcement was done because you say, hey, we want this, and you can either and by this I mean SegWit, right?
Yeah and it we want something which is universally good for Bitcoin and which is not controversial. Like nobody thought SegWit was controversial. I mean, 99% of people thought SegWit was perfectly fine, they just wanted to use it as leverage to get something else, which was a block size increase. But otherwise, I mean, I think most people, most businesses, except a few that are very bitter, for example, like BitPay, which is not ex accepting SegWit on purpose or something like that.
Everybody was okay with SegWit. So the idea was that you cannot prevent us from getting something that we want already, and we the whole community was behind it, the whole user base and developer base was behind it, and says, well, if you don't feed us the type of blocks that we desire, we will switch to another supplier of blocks.
We and the idea was that we are so confident that we want this and not the fork that we're willing to basically lose all our money. And because for example, my business at Bill's, we were gonna only accept UASF coins, like exclusively, right?
And I said, Well, great. You don't want to produce SegWit blocks, then don't use my exchange. And you're gonna be incompatible with all my users and all my users I know care about this very deeply. So the idea that the miner is a service provider for the community of hudders which are expressing their preference through the nodes, right, is pretty deep ingrained, I think now.
Like anybody that says you know, hash power is vote, I mean that was a big step in Bitcoin's maturity, right? So the idea that hash power is vote was really ingrained in people's minds. Right. They really truly did believe that. They they believed Bitcoin was a democracy of miners, and now they don't anymore because we can show them that that's not true. So that was very powerful.
It's it it it wasn't necessarily and it it happened it it's so great that it happened like that, actually. Like everything about it, I wouldn't not do anything different. It happened early when the it's like you know as a kid you want to get your antibodies when you're younger, right? Like it happened very early, it gave us a layer of protection, and our advert our the adversaries of the Bitcoin consensus were even though they were insiders, they clearly were not you know the smartest and the best.
So yeah, it's I'm just happy it happened the way it did, and we can move on to you know, stop talking about how we want to govern ourselves to let's just build right now. Right. Now we know how we govern ourselves, we know the way it happens. Yes, yeah, yeah. And we didn't before actually, and to be honest, the whole USF SegWit 2X episode taught me so much about how Bitcoin works.
And I think a lot of us truly finally understood Bitcoin after that. Yeah. Because of that. Yeah, and we had to see it happen to really understand it. Like you just, you know, you could theorize about it, but yeah. Yeah, living it is a different thing. 2017 was was a just a massive year for Bitcoin. Just UASF and then the Bcash hard fork.
So we also learned that hard forks don't work. Yeah. As an altcoin after the fact. It'll just go to zero. And I mean, or you know, whatever. I don't know how long it'll take to actually get to zero, probably a while. It's still way too it's like three percent of a bitcoin. Yeah, it's tiny. It's it's meaningless. Some miner could just destroy it for fun.
Yeah, you know, we could if we if people cared, they could, you know, screw with the exchange rate, screw with the mining, they could they could DDoS it like Bcash is surviving because nobody cares about it. Right. So let's talk about scaling then if we're not gonna hard fork to increase the block size. I mean, we have SegWit and Seg was an effective block size increase.
We switched to block weight, we have a four megabyte block weight limit now, and which is you know, kind of through regular use gonna be like a sort of two, two and a half megabytes sort of average block size once we once gave it. I mean we're already seeing two megabyte blocks with about 50% SegWit adoption. Yeah. So we're scaling that way. Do you think that we'll have a block, a hard fork block size increase in the future?
No, no, I don't think so. I think the What about this? Isn't there like and I don't know if trip I don't know much about this, but isn't there like a point, there's some kind of like date thing, like a Y2K style thing with with dates in Bitcoin Core, where like yes in in like 10 or 12 years or something, it's gonna require a hard fork to fix.
That I think you're talking about the size of the nods when you're mining. Yeah, I think I'm gonna be right. Because the more the higher the difficulty is the more tries you have to do, the more nonsense there will be, yeah, it'll be bigger. That's a that's an excellent question, actually.
I don't know that much about it, but I know a lot of developers want to do a cleanup hard fork. Yeah, but to me to me the hard fork is like emergency only. Yeah, and by emergency I mean like I don't there's there's no scenario that I think right now would require a hard fork. Right. Quantum computing, I don't think it requires a hard fork, we can soft fork probably something else.
So and I think the creativity of Bitcoin developers is like is very very high. For example, you got guys like Luke Jr. Which conceived of SegWit as the soft fork deployment. For him, it seemed super obvious. Yeah, that's what he said.
He's just like he's like in the matrix. Yeah, yeah, he's he's like those are in the matrix. So I think it's Dozer, the guy who sees the matrix, but he like sees Neo fighting at the same time. Yeah. I think there's always gonna be something, I hope. And if there is you know an inevitable Bitcoin hard fork because of like something that we don't know, what we're gonna have to do is we're gonna have to take a lot, a lot of a decade, 10 years.
10 years to get everybody to a grade. Screw one year upgrade time. Like the Bitcoin backwards compatible upgrade time should be like 25 years of farm certain. Sure. So if if we're gonna just plan it ahead and say, Yeah, yeah, yeah. If if we're if we absolutely need to hard fork because there's some quirk, and I don't think there is actually. So I think if this might be a mood discussion, but if there is, yeah, if there is, let's let's say okay.
I've heard rumor of something about this. Yeah. And because I heard somebody say that, well, if we do a block size increase, this would be the time to do it because we're gonna have to hard fork to fix this thing anyway. Yeah, but I don't know if it's true. I didn't dive in. But I think I think that there's possibly a few things that hard fork game would fix, but again, the maintaining backwards compatibility is like almost like a religious goal for like a few people, myself included.
It's like I will do anything in my power to make sure it's it's always backwards compatible. Right. And someone smarter than me has the same fervor to and if they don't, I will convince other people that are smarter than me to believe this very deeply, and they're gonna figure it out. Right.
And so yeah, and we can sc and we're scaling now with with second layer solutions like lightning and so forth. There'll be other in liquid, there'll be others on top of that, and then there'll be third and fourth layers, and essentially we'll be able to just keep increasing the efficiency of the base layer, so that you're just m packing massive amounts of like value transaction into one, you know, one basic transaction one settlement transaction on the base layer.
Yeah, and with Schnor, we can take like really complex, like massive multi-sig transactions or whatever, and they're the same size. Make them very small or tiny. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, totally. You know, Bitcoin has a native payment method within so bit when we're talking about medium of exchange and currency, we don't we're not talking about method of payment.
These are two different things. Yeah. For example, we don't call PayPal a medium of exchange, we call it a method of payment for the dollar, which is a medium of exchange, right? Right. So the good thing that makes me bullish about scalability of Bitcoin is that very quickly we were able to develop a functional prototype, which is Lightning Network. Very quickly, I mean, 10 years in, we were able to develop liquid, right?
And I think that what this shows is that, and we are also able to develop custodial solutions which are moving bitcoins off chain in another. So I think what this shows is that there's gonna be a wide variety of mechanisms which move the ownership of Bitcoin with a different gradient of complexity, of liquidity, of censorship resistance, of different levels of ownership of keys.
And I think that Bitcoin transactions, we should start to think them Bitcoin more as a court, like as a as a as a justice system, right? Where when you disagree, Bitcoin is useful when you disagree. Like if everybody's happy holding hands and no one's a scammer and everybody's following the rules, we don't need Bitcoin.
We don't need all that sensory, like we need Bitcoin for when there's disagreement and when someone starts to try to attack you or revert a transaction. So think of it like this like a Bitcoin transaction requires an insane amount of energy for one of it to be successful, and it should be used as least as possible, right?
It's kind of like the final the final step is that confirmation on the blockchain that moves the ownership of Bitcoin from one place to another. So a Bitcoin transaction is gonna power payments, right? And it's gonna really just be used, I think, I hope, when there's some disagreement, when one of the parties to a transaction goes offline or someone has to cheat, or there's uncertainty about who where the ownership lies for some reason, we refer back to the Bitcoin blockchain.
And I think that's that's perfectly fine. And we shouldn't have some kind of weird nostalgia to like on-chain trans. I remember when I was buying coffee on chain, it was super fun. Like I so do I, like I it was super fun. But then I just bought it, now you bought this coffee with Lightning, and that's also super fun. Yeah, right. And then maybe in in 10 years it'll be like, Wow, lightning's so shit.
Like there's this new third layer protocol, and bing bing, like payment gets made right away, instantly, blah blah blah. So I think that's how Bitcoin's gonna scale. And it needs to, it needs to. This this it's not even like I don't think I think that's how it's gonna scale because I think that's what it needs and what people need. And I think this is kind of an under-appreciator, under talked about idea of the of the block size limit is that it's a forcing function to make us build more efficient solutions.
Because if we have this big, you know, unlimited block size, then it's you don't have to build this other stuff that that is more efficient and better in the long term. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And people want it very, very much. People do want to make Bitcoin payments, people should make Bitcoin payments, they should buy stuff with Bitcoin. I don't think that people should huddle forever. I think that huddling is more the idea of being very conscious with your spending and being mindful of your opportunity costs, right?
And being mindful of the value of your own time. And the demand for Bitcoin payments is a force in and of itself, and if people truly do want to get paid in Bitcoin and pay with Bitcoin, then these solutions will continue to start to pop up. And as you say, the business opportunity and the intellectual challenge of building those solutions is much bigger knowing that you can't do that on the main blockchain on the on the base layer, and also it it allows for a lot more experimentation, right?
So I don't want people to fiddle with the consensus rules, but you know, if you guys want to build lightning this way, you guys want to be extended that way, liquid, you want to go this federation model, drive chain, this model, like go for it because like none of what you do has an externality on me. Right. Right. And that's the that's the concept of Bitcoin. Like you're you're not supposed to externalize the you're not supposed to have externalities on others for decisions that they're not, you know, you know, consciously participating.
The risk gets pushed out of the edge. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Exactly. Well said. Yeah, yeah. Let's wrap it up with one of my favorite questions to ask, and I'd love to hear I'm I'm really excited to hear your answer in particular. What's a Bitcoin future look like to you in 50 years? Oh, nice.
I think it's so impossible to comprehend. I don't even know. I have no idea. I think the reason why I have no idea is because people have different ideas and people are so diverse, and it's it's like we're gonna finally see what the creativity of humanity is like, right? It's not gonna be a certain class of people that are that are good at politics that decide the way we're going.
So politics is predictable, right? Without the existence of Bitcoin, I can sh I can tell you exactly what the world's gonna look like without Bitcoin. It's gonna be a dystop dystopian totalitarian regime. It's exactly like it's gonna be. It's gonna be a hundred years the same as it is today, right? There's gonna be another boom, another bust, another period of war, another post-war period where we're all coming together again, doing the same mistakes again.
I don't know, it's just people are gonna be, I think people are gonna be happier. I think people are gonna be safer. I think people are gonna live longer. I think we're gonna be we're gonna find much better ways to collaborate on international projects. I think we're gonna go to space I think Bitcoin is gonna literally put like man on Mars.
I think Bitcoin's gonna be the driving force behind space exploration. And I think we'll just be looking back at the as as like Fiat as like the Dark Ages. I seriously do maybe 50 years I don't know but I just I don't know what it is but it's gonna be significantly better than than what the world is today.
Very nice man appreciate your time it was awesome to meet you my pleasure man by guys nice all right how'd that go that was fucking great man cool yeah you like it
All right alright big thanks to Francis for his time please do let us know your thoughts any questions or feedback you have for us after listening to this episode you can follow up with us on Twitter Francis is at FrancisPulio with an underscore at the end that's at F R A N C I S P O U L I O T underscore and I am at citizen Bitcoin if you find this podcast to be valuable to your Bitcoin journey please do take a moment to leave a rating and review wherever you can it's the best way to help me bootstrap this thing right now and I really do appreciate it.
Alright that's all for this one take care out there Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Francis Pouliot, CEO and co-founder of Bull Bitcoin, joins Brady to talk about privacy, S2X/UASF, scaling, how governments might approach bitcoin, and bitcoin’s future in general.
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Citizen Bitcoin Layer ONE merch collection
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show: