All episodes
Episode 38

Guy Swann: Finding Bitcoin, Bitcoin 2019 Preview, Eltoo, Statechains, Bullishness

June 23, 201977 min

Guy Swann is host of The Cryptoconomy Podcast. In this episode we are regaled with Guy’s bitcoin story, and it’s a good one. We also talk about Eltoo, state chains, atomic multi path payments, and lightning loop. We get all hyped up for the Bitcoin 2019 conference and wax super bullish toward the end of the ep.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. So how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing great.

I had a show planned with Justin Moon for this week, but we unfortunately had to postpone. That one will be coming out at some point in the near-ish future.

So instead, I called in an emergency favor from my friend Guy Swann of the CryptoEconomy Podcast, and he came to the rescue so I could get an episode out this week. But before we dive in, I just want to take a moment to thank Andy Edstrom for the very nice review on Apple Podcasts. I really appreciate the kind words, Andy.

That's the kind of fuel that keeps this thing going. If you haven't rated a review of the pod yet, get on it. It's the best way to help me bootstrap this podcast in these early days. So keep them coming. I appreciate you all. Alright, let's dive into the show.

Guy Swann is host of the Great Crypto Economy Podcast, which is one of the most valuable Bitcoin education podcasts out there, hands down. I've been a listener from the early days of the show. Guy is also an early Bitcoiner, having been in the game since 2011. And while Guy has done almost 300 podcast episodes now, he's not been interviewed much.

So this episode we are regaled with Guy's Bitcoin story, and it's a good one. We also talk about some new coming innovations for Bitcoin, including eltoo, state chains, atomic multipath payments, and lightning loop. We also get hyped up for the Bitcoin 2019 conference, which Guy just decided today to fly out for at the last minute.

We start waxing super bullish toward the end of the episode. It was a lot of fun.

Guy's become a good friend over the past year or so, and we just had a great time shooting the shit and talking Bitcoin today. So I hope you all enjoy it as well. And if you'll be in San Francisco for Bitcoin 2019, make sure you find me. Alright, here we go.

So I've got Guy Swann with me from the Crypto Economy Cup podcast, my my good friend, my good Bitcoin friend. My guy, you're my first Bitcoin friend, I think.

I think you are. I think you were my first Bitcoin friend, yeah. Like like the first person that I really got to know well, you know, outside of just Twitter and kind of on a personal level. So guy's joining me, he's doing me a big favor at the last second. Justin Moon got sick.

We postponed from Friday to today, Sunday, and he's still not feeling well. So we're gonna record in a couple of weeks, I think, after the after the conference, Bitcoin 2019 is over. So I was like, I need to get a pod out. I gotta get one out. You know, gotta keep this weekly rhythm up. And so I'm like, I'm gonna go to my buddy guy and see if he'll join me for emergency emergency pod.

So I appreciate you joining me, man. You're also doing some last minute stuff right now, too. You decided to come out to San Francisco literally today, the like day before you have to fly out, right? Yes. And it might have been a terrible decision, but I'm I'm trying to make it happen. I don't think it's I mean, I think you're gonna be vindicated.

I think it's gonna be a fantastic time. It'll be awesome to meet all these Bitcoiners we've been learning from for years now. Yeah, no doubt. I know. Yeah, I know it's gonna be a good time. We're gonna have a blast. It's just making the decision the same day before was kind of like that was bad news.

Do you are you like a fly by the CD or your pants kind of guy? Like, do you do you do this like regularly or like it's just like what every once in a while you're like on a whim, I'm like, I gotta do this thing. It's kind of fun to do sometimes, you know. Yeah, it's more of a it's more of a every once in a while. With family and everything, you know, it makes it a little bit more difficult, but sometimes you just gotta like just like all right, all right, just make a decision.

Let's just make it happen. Let's do it. So yeah, you're feeling it. You're feeling it. Yeah. I'm feeling it. Feeling it. All right. So I think we should talk about the since you're coming out to San Francisco. And you're gonna crash, crash with me and Tommy and the Airbnb, which is gonna be awesome. I get it. Let's talk about the conference on the pod for sure.

We'll get let's kind of go through the program. Let's let's talk about what we're excited about listening to and people we're excited to talk to. But you know what? I'd love to start with getting your story, man, because you have I think, you know, and I've said I've I've tweeted this out. To me is the most valuable Bitcoin education podcast that's available.

Thank you. Yeah, I think, I mean, every I think all Bitcoiners should absolutely be subscribed. If you like the audio format, you're into podcasts. You know, the crypto Economy podcast is reading the best Bitcoin content out there for you. So it's an audio service for for Bitcoin content. Plus, guy's been in Bitcoin for years now and just adds in all of this context and commentary that really helps you get the most out of the pieces that he's reading.

And you know, I've listened to every single episode, 220, 30. What are you on now? 240, something like that. For just quick reads, I'm at 262. Damn, man. Yeah. So and that's that's with like I think I'm almost at 20, like just solo episodes. My guys take episodes, and then I've got I can't remember which interview is coming out.

I got an interview coming out on Monday. All right. Monday. I don't know. I'm gonna be on a plane. I don't know how I'm gonna get that out. I'm gonna have to scramble to make sure. God got it like episodes to get ahead on. But I'm actually doing a I did an interview with Richard Myers from GoTener and Global Mesh Labs. Oh, yeah, we have fun time talking about like how to how can you actually bootstrap a global decentralized like alternative internet infrastructure.

Really fucking. That's gonna be that's gonna be fucking awesome. Yeah, yeah, I'm excited. Nice. Me too. Did you did you happen to listen to the time traveler one yet? Everybody's been getting kicked out of that one. I've had a lot of fun. No, I haven't. I'm saving that one for travel time. I've got I've got like a list, I've got like a playlist on on pocket casts of like my travel bitcoin episodes to get all hyped up before the conference.

So yeah, that's on my play a little more around with that one than I usually do. I got to do some fun stuff. So I'd be very curious to hear your thoughts on it. All right, you'll hear them. I'm I'm looking forward to it. I'll probably listen to it tomorrow. Yeah, so yeah, so 300 episodes, getting close to now.

260 plus reads of really important Bitcoin content. Yeah, I started listening probably episode 40 or something like that. Went back and listened to the to everything from the beginning, and I just don't miss episodes anymore. I listen, I always get them, you know, it's one of my top priorities in terms of Bitcoin pods to listen to, and it's great.

So definitely recommend the pod, the crypto economy podcast. The small subset of you weirdos that actually manage to listen to every episode. Blow my mind. I don't even understand. Fucking obsessed, man. Just obsessed. That's all there is to it. And I you know, I keep waiting, like I keep waiting. It's been two and a half years now.

I keep waiting for me to like be get tired of it. And I'm just like, you know, just not. I it's it's the gravity is strong. I just get more and more and more interested and I gotta keep more and more of my attention. I gotta keep up with my game. Just yeah, man, I need that I need I need that crypto economy podcast fix, man. You can't you gotta you gotta keep it going.

Itching, I'm itching. Yeah. Yeah, so you know, let's let's talk about let's talk about your Bitcoin sale, because yeah, you know, you've done all these shows and you haven't been interviewed a lot, that that I know of, right? So let's let's get your your story out there, man. Tell me how you got into Bitcoin and your your journey learn to like understand it, learn it.

All right, yeah. So I've been in Bitcoin for I've been just utterly down the rabbit hole for probably I don't know. Every time every time I think I have a number, I forget it's been like a lot of time has passed. It's probably like seven years now. Maybe a little bit longer.

It was no it's two thousand and eleven, it's two thousand nineteen now.

It might be eight years. It might be going eight years.

Dude, it was it was a crazy, crazy space back then. Because there was nothing. Like you could talk to everyone in Bitcoin. Like it was just such a non-thing. It was it was an equ 100% an experiment. You know, I mean it had just finally blown onto the into kind of the internet back circles because it had obtained a price.

I didn't even realize then, but it hadn't even had a price up until I get like it went really fast from 10,000 bitcoins for two pizzas to that that $30 rally. Like there were the tick the gap between the like zero dollar market cap to in the millions was was a really short run because it spent like a year and a half as just zero dollars, you know, like there was just no price.

So it's it was like as soon as as soon as the thing pulled in any money, there was just this huge rally and like kind of network effect that happened in a very short order, the same hype cycle we've seen over and over and over again ever since. Yeah, so were there any exchanges around at that time or before the before Pizza Day were there exchanges?

Like, I mean you could there there wasn't a price set. No, it was Mt. Gox was that was considered the first price, was Haslo. Haslo? Laszlo, yeah. Hanyetz, or however you say his name. I think it's pretty good. He he set the first price in in that way.

But yeah, outside of that, I think it was still a couple of weeks before there was any kind of like online thing. And I think it was Mt. Ox. I think MT Gox was the first one for the Magic the Gathering. And that was the only thing that was really there when we were there. Getting money to it was freaking weird.

Like it was this weird dark shady like well actually no before I get into that I'll kind of tell you about like what made me get into Bitcoin at all. Like why it actually like how'd you find out about how'd you discover it? How to get into your brain. So the virus in your brain the mind virus I was having I was in like this weird spot in my life.

I had gotten out of college and I really didn't know what I went to college for film because like kind of stories and like systems like like the whole like those broad ideas just fascinate me. And because of that I've I've always been a story buff.

Books, movies, all of it. And then at the same time like the architecture of like making movies was always like a really crazy thing for me. And so I had kind of always thought that I wanted to go that direction with my life some sort of media or something like that. And but I had run my own business and I was doing like wedding videos and like little like local commercials and stuff like that.

But it just seemed I didn't want to do what somebody else's stuff you know so I just kind of started to feel lost. I started to let my business just kind of fall to the wayside because I didn't even though I seen I seemed to be passionate about film and stuff I wasn't passionate about my business.

I was just kind of getting by at the time.

And I found myself spending all my time funny funny enough debating with my brother about economics. And another one of those things, it's just those big overarching ideas that just fascinated me. And he was majoring in economics at the time.

So he would debate with his professors, and like I think some of the people in the class hated him because he didn't believe, like he'd be like, no, that was a contradiction from what you taught us last week, you know, like both of those things can't be true at the same time. He's like, Well, that's what the book said, so shut up. And then he would come home and we would debate, and then we'd start looking stuff up on the internet, like about economics history and stuff, and we bounced from one theory to the next because there's a lot of different like competing theories, but we kept kind of touching on Austrian economics, and then we would kind of push away and then we would come back.

Like we kept finding ourselves in that little area, and then found like Milton Freeman, and it just started pieces started slowly coming together, and we were clearly moving in one direction with all of our economic arguments, I guess you could say. And then in I'd always been a nerd too, like you know, in the whole idea of just loving systems and things.

The internet was always just a fascination of mine. And one night we were we had just kind of it just kind of been the culmination of a lot of different stuff, and we were kind of talking about the liberating power of the internet, about how it was freeing up information and really kind of changing the nature of how we organize ourselves as humans and like like as a society.

And then we were we were pretty heavy down the rabbit hole for those couple of weeks on Austrian economics, and it was brand new to us. And you know that feeling when you when you hit like praxeology for the first time and you're like, oh my god, this makes so much sense. Like you actually have a foundation to deduce economic like patterns from I guess you could say, you know, like you could you could look at like some large imbalance or like policy and be like, okay, well, this is what's happening at the base of all of this, so this is the kind of imbalance you're going to expect from this.

It just made it so clear kind of the direction that this all was taking. So we were really excited, and we kind of hit this this one or two nights where we were just so deep into it, and it just happened to be all of the things related to Bitcoin, and he was debating with one of his little anarchist friends.

We weren't anarchists, quote unquote, at the time, but we were very close. We were obviously seeing the value and beginning to understand it all. And he was debating with one of his guys on Facebook, and that guy was like, you know, I heard about this thing that you would probably be really interested in. And Jeff was like, what?

And then some 10 minutes, 15 minutes later, it was not much of a break between Jeffrey calling me with in just stupid excitement telling me about this thing called Bitcoin. And that night, and like literally it was like the night after we had just kind of gone down this like liberating internet Austrian economics rabbit hole.

Wow, and then talking about like serendipity. Perfect timing. Just perfect timing. And he he came home that night and we were white paper, Reddit, Bitcoin mailing list, like everything we could find like that night we were just we were just down.

We stayed up all night. I think I think it was nine o'clock in the morning, sun was up, and it was like, okay, we gotta stop and go to bed. But that was it. That was we were we were we didn't we didn't trip down the rabbit hole, we like nosedive, like just straight down like no parachute, no nothing, just went down it.

And ever since then it was like that kind of made it kind of brought like my fascination with economics and then my love for like like my passion for like liberty, like for people being in control of their own lives and like what I found fascinating about the internet and like Bitcoin is just this huge culmination of all of that in in one thing that has implications in a hundred other ways at the exact same time.

And ever since then I haven't quite been able to I'll probably still get back into film because I love film, but I see that as just a means to an end. In the same way that like my podcast is, is that like my goal is to teach people about like liberty and Bitcoin, but I love doing a podcast like in order to do that.

So I'll probably and I've been slowly getting back into doing like film work around Bitcoin and stuff and video and all that good stuff. But I have Are you into like documentary filmmaking? You thought about doing Yes, actually. I have I have very much thought about that. I haven't had any concrete plans or whatever, but I've got I've definitely got a book of ideas for a lot of things like that.

And I know it's I can feel myself getting closer to it with this podcast actually kind of becoming something. Like I feel as as I start to get one thing solidified it will be easier to move on to the next you know so yeah but yeah yeah I just quite I hadn't found anything up to that point like suddenly just everything clicked like like all the things that I loved and that made sense and that like I thought was like a good purpose in life just aligned so well with Bitcoin that I haven't been able to since that night I haven't been able to step away.

So yeah so that was in like 2011 that night man that's that's early crazy crazy time. Oh yeah you don't even don't tell me how early it was because I wish I had yeah I had I had sold my kidney I knew too and somehow somehow I'm still oh man the yeah and you just the wallets I could have had yeah yeah well you know yeah you found it right and like it's in your life so you know Bitcoin is and that's enough as Beauty Yon says exactly exactly go go or like

On the 60 minutes episode with Charlie Shrim and Laszlo he was like they're asking like do you ever think about that about you know the fact that those pizzas are worth you know 80 bajillion dollars now you know he's like I find that it's not good for me to think about that just like he just like dead like dead pans it straight into the camera and he's like, Yeah, we're

Not going there, man. Not going there. But but you know, hey, it's it's almost like you could have all that money, and I you know, I'm sure he has he's got you know a healthy amount of Bitcoin and he's just fine. Yeah, exactly. And like, you know, he is has a seminal part in Bitcoin history, which you just can't buy that, right?

Like I guess he kind of did buy it, but it's it's sort of a price, it's sort of it's sort of a priceless thing, I guess is what I'm trying to say. Yeah, without a doubt. Yeah, yeah. And I heard somebody talking about on this this past pizza day that we don't talk about the dude who bought the pizzas very who like got the bitcoin, the 10,000 Bitcoin.

Yeah, right. And you I know he was like he was like a young kid, he's like 18 or 19 from England or something like that. That's all I know about him. And there his name is out there, but yeah, we haven't heard much about that guy. Somebody should hunt him down. I should get him in an interview on the show. Yeah, man, it'd be interesting to hear from him. Yeah, maybe get him and Laszlo on at the same time would be really fun and talk about it.

But all right, so yeah, so this is way back in the day, 2011. So then you like was Mount Gox even around yet when you read the white paper? Or like did it was it like just like coming online soon afterwards? And it was one of the other reasons. Yeah, yeah. One of the other reasons why it was kind of so like the fire was like exploded so heavily in our little run was because it was in it was at like peak FOMA on that early rally, up to like $33 that crashed all the way back down to like a

Buck something. And we so we were like I think it was like five or somewhere between like five and eight dollars on like that first day that we found it, and so we were like rushing. We were like, Oh my god, we're gonna miss it. It's gonna take over the world tomorrow, and we have to get in.

And I remember so we I FOMO'd so hard. I had I was broke at the time. Like I told you, I was letting my business stagnate, so I was just kind of making it from month to month. Yeah, and I had savings.

I had savings, I had a thousand dollars in savings that I could invest in anything I wanted. From my grandmother. And I was like, okay, and I've been kind of dabbling in like trading and just kind of like stocks and stuff, like trying to learn that because I thought you know that was probably gonna be a thing that I needed to invest in at some point in the future.

And I was like, okay, this is gonna be the thing. I'm going to invest in Bitcoin. And so this was my first foray into quote unquote investing, and I bought at the top, the tippity top of the of that bubble.

And then like within our and this was with us scrambling, we had to do like some stupid there's some like stupid red card thing that you had to put cash in to somebody else's bank account, and you had to put like an exact change amount so they could discern one customer from the next.

Oh, they would give you a credit for this thing online that you could send to this service called like Dewala, or was Dewala later on. That might have been an improvement to it, even. I don't know. It was like a four-step shady on shady process. Like it was just creepy.

I felt so weird doing it. But finally got the money into Mt. Gox as as the peak was happening. And I and we put the money in, and then we watched everything bleed. Like we got that bull market badge. I mean, that bear market badge straight out the gate.

And it plummeted. Plummeted in like two weeks. I think it was like two or three weeks later. I just I was fighting with whether or not I had just done the dumbest thing I had ever, like the dumbest decision I had ever made in my life. All that money from grandma. All that money from grandma.

And it was I watched, I remember I did the math on it. Because it wasn't all mine, it was like we were splitting it and we would decided together to invest in this. And we watched, I did the calculation one day. What we had put in had a thousand dollars, and two weeks later, two and a half weeks later, when I was in the deepest of my despair, and we were broke, we were so broke, like we could not a thousand dollars was everything in the world to us.

Like we had we had missed a month on our electricity bill and our electricity had turned off, and we had to scramble to figure out how to get it back on so we could have the internet. You're you were wrecked on top of being broke. I was wrecked on top of being broke, and I remember I did the calculation today, and it was $74. Like in two weeks.

Yeah, dude. Like in two weeks, I had just taken what seemed like an insurmountable amount of money for me at the time and just destroyed it. And that was when that was probably why I went so deep down the reading about Bitcoin rabbit hole. Like what kind of got me into the habit of just reading like crazy is because I had to fuel that energy, like had to put that energy somewhere because if I had made the dumbest decision of my life, like I was going to at least know that I had made the like I wasn't going to go into this blindly, right?

All that badly burned skin in the game. Yeah that you had. So I took all my energy and I funneled it into reading about Bitcoin and finding out is this really because you know I had a cursory knowledge of it. You know, I had I had a summarized version of what it was. And that's when like I really read the white paper, like really read it, and then started going through anything I could find.

And I would just read about like the incentive system, what are the drawbacks of it, you know. I think it wasn't even long after that that I heard the first convers or I read my first conversation about how the block size shouldn't actually be like really big. And that was I didn't really get into that hard until you know years later when the block size debate happened.

But I remember I'd actually heard that argument before, even though I you know wasn't super important to me at the time. I just kept kept reading about stuff. Right. But yeah, it was a crazy, crazy time. That's crazy. What was even around to read back then? Like it was was it just like mostly Bitcoin talk forum and like were there people right like publishing blog posts and writing about it at that point?

Who was who it was around? There was hardly any articles, and Andreas was around. Andreas was I don't know exactly how soon I found him, but he had been there for a long time. And it's so like yeah, yeah, I know I know he was definitely part of it early on.

And what a Bitcoin badass. Seriously though, dude. Seriously. The number of people who have learned and like gotten their understanding of Bitcoin from him is like the OG Bitcoin educator. Yep. And he's still he's still probably the best, at least mo or most used like resource for noobs.

I mean, just people find him because he's got that track record. You know, he's he's got that he's Lindy. He's Lindy, you know. Yep. You can trust him. He hasn't sold out yet to the shit coins. Even though he wrote Mastering Ethereum, we're gonna give him a pass on that because you know he's interested in the tech. I get it, I get it, you know, you're curious, intellectually curious.

He's a Bitcoin. Mastering Bitcoin is such an amazing book. I swear I think everybody should. Anybody who's like serious about Bitcoin, like you gotta read that. Like you gotta go through it. Yeah, it's a rite of passage for a serious Bitcoiner for sure. For real. Yeah. Yeah, I go back to it quite a bit, you know, and just read little sections here and there of parts of the system that I wanna, you know, like start to understand a little better.

Or like I, you know, I'll I'll read something about some part of the system that sort of makes me think, oh yeah, you know, this part of that I first read about this mastering bitcoin, I'm gonna go back now with sort of this new context and go through this section again and you know come away with a better understanding. So it's it's just it's a timeless work that just keeps kind of giving back as you learn more and more.

It's it's great. Yeah. Oh yeah. Yeah, so then alright, all right. So then you I mean you're just studying and holding at this point, and keeping my podcast actually. Unfortunately, I'm doing I tried to hold as much as I can, but mostly like right now.

Like I care more about the podcast. So yeah, like right now that's that's running through savings, but luckily it's it's I've gotten a lot of donations from people, and that has been a huge help. I'm kind of surprised again and again how much people will just kind of like straight up donate just to kind of yeah, man.

It's it's a valuable like I say, it's a valuable thing, man. It's yeah, I super appreciate it. I wish I hope I hope they get that when they listen to the show that that I really do appreciate it because it it means a lot. Yeah. So you were all right.

What I was saying at this point, I didn't mean like actually right now, it's kind of like still back in the day. Sorry, I was just trying to follow. I got you. Yeah, yeah, it's trying to follow the timeline. I know I know it's a little confusing, but you yeah, so you've you've kind of done this initial sort of like you get burned, you it makes you study, you know, and I think you know, a lot of people probably just would sell out right there and be like, hey, I'm just gonna get what I can, you know, and like but of course if you're down to 74 bucks, it's like might as well just leave it in there, I guess.

Did you did you get your m your like did you get burned by the Mt. Gox exit scam, basically? Or a little bit. Not too much. You had learned to hold your own private keys and everything at that point. Yes. Yes. Luckily, I did not get obliterated there, but I don't think anybody made it out scot-free.

Like almost everybody at the time had some sort of hand in Mt. Gox. That was just a I mean they were like 90% of the volume, like if you were doing any buying or selling, that's who you did it with. Yeah. So but yeah, at the time I was just kind of like holding and trying to get because when it was there was definitely I mean, don't get me wrong, like I threw up when I kind of did that calculation on how much money I had left.

I fought really hard about whether or not I should just dump like I should just like take this as a lesson. But that's why I kind of went, I was like, okay, I have to know. Like otherwise, you know, otherwise I'm just making a decision entirely out of the fact that I don't know because I don't, you know, like I'm just vague idea.

Exactly, exactly. I've got this vague idea of what I've just invested in. And so like I want to be able to answer anyone's question about it before I make a decision about the investment. And so luckily I waited and I said, okay, I'm going to learn first, and then I'll make the decision.

If it keeps falling, whatever, I'll lose another $20. You know, like so like there wasn't there just wasn't much on the line left. Right.

Oh yeah. Which thankfully, you know, that was the decision. That was a decision we made. So yeah. So then you go through like there was goes up to like a thousand or something like that after the Mt. Gox collapse. Rallies way up there, or after the Silk Road seizure, right?

That's when it that's how it rallied up to a thousand. And then I think the Mt. Gox collapse happened after the rally, right? Yeah, that's right. And kind of contributed to prolonging the bear market, probably without a doubt. The biggest avenue for like literally like essentially with the loss of Mount Gox, like 75 or 80% of the infrastructure, like the avenues, the bridges, like on ramps to this highway were just like imagine they just all collapsed and then trying to like you know, you've got this major highway, and 80% of the on ramps collapse.

What's the traffic gonna be like you know, for the next year as we build it all back? That was basically the situation. Yeah, that was a I mean compared to this 2018 bear market. That 2015 bear market was just I mean, 2015, 2014, 1516, because it stretched it stretched into three calendar years.

I mean that was just a long hard like Siberian winter. Yeah, that was the most grueling by far. Even even with the pain of the first one, it was at least much shorter lived, you know. But after Mt. Gox, it was like oof, we're in we're in for the long haul on this one.

It was pretty clear towards the end of 2014. I was like, man, this is gonna just keep going. Like it's gonna take a while to come back out of this. Yeah, and I think a lot of yeah, and I think a lot of them made any difference. Oh, sorry, good. Right. Yeah, that's what happened to the thing. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, right. And I saw I saw a tweet about that recently.

Like the difference between a bear market and bull market is, you know, in a bear market, good news doesn't affect the price. In a bull market, bad news doesn't affect the price. I think that was Vijay. I think it was yeah, I think you're right. I think that's right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I mean what's you can I think a lot of the people who are held through that long bear market, 14, 15, 16, are just sort of in disbelief right now that you know we've had this just insane rally from 3,000.

And it seems the bull the bull market's just like back with a vengeance already. And no one and like, you know, these these people we can't who have held through that long winter, like, no, it's it's supposed to be a lot longer and harder than this guy's, you know. This this can't be this can't be real. This can't be real. Tone Vays comes to mind, for instance.

You know, and just I think they're they're referencing that, but there's there's a b big fun lots of fundamental differences between the state and infrastructure of Bitcoin during that that period, that bear market, and this this recent one. You know, many, many differences. So yeah, I think fundamentally we were all kind of set set up to just have a much faster rebound.

There was, you know, amazing infrastructure and UIUX improvements over the past five years. Mm-hmm. Oh yeah, definitely. And what's funny is that like I originally wasn't sure if we were gonna break. We had such like serious support at like 6,000 that I wasn't sure if we were gonna break down.

And I had kind of had the perspective this whole time that this wasn't gonna be a serious of a bear market, but then I kind of lost hope in that when it went to three. I was like, wow, okay. Like, no, it is gonna be a prolonged bear market. I expected a lot more sideways just because, like you said, the infrastructure is a whole different story now than it was then.

And we didn't lose empty gox. Like we didn't like we didn't have any really event like that. We just kind of had a general bubble, you know. There wasn't really some massive collapse or infrastructure loss or shutdown that really rocked the market.

It was really just a price FOMO and subsequent drop. So like I always wondered it was like it seemed like the bear market should have been less severe, but then it you know three months ago it didn't seem like that at all.

It was like, okay, maybe I'm just wrong. But this rally has been kind of nuts. Like we never had a rally like this. Like even the little we had this little parabolic move in 2015. They corrected really quick. Yeah. And that was basically the breakout of the bear market.

But it wasn't quite this big. I think it was only like a roughly like a hundred percent move, and we're working on almost two hundred percent. Like, we're we've almost tripled the price from where we were at the low. 230, 40 percent. No, yeah, it's so yeah. It's pretty steep. Like, we've had a heck of a move.

It's incredible. Yeah, it's absolutely incredible. So I'm getting I'm stoked, man. We're we're going to Bitcoin 2019 tomorrow. Yeah, we haven't met in person. We're gonna hang out. This is gonna be awesome. This is gonna be so many people to meet. So many people to meet and hang out with. It's gonna be amazing.

So yeah, tomorrow night we're I'm doing the Bitcoin beef steak that Christian put together of the from POV crypto podcast, and he's Christian's also like helping organize and run the whole show, the whole conference. That's gonna be super cool. I was gonna shoot them an email because I'm in a conversation with Christian and a couple other people at Bitcoin magazine.

I really need to hit them up because we were trying to we were trying to hit up and they were asking me if I was gonna be at the conference. I was like, that's not the case anymore as of this morning. So yeah, I need to shoot them a message. I forgot about that. Yeah, yeah. That's gonna be sweet.

Are who are you have you checked out the agenda, the program? Are you maybe haven't even gotten to this point yet? I really haven't gotten to it. There were I know there were a couple that I wanted to look into. The fact that Snowden's gonna be there is really exciting. Or well he's gonna be speaking. Where it was what was my Tim Draper's the other keynote, he's gonna open up the conference with with pomp.

You know, and Draper's a legend, you know, he bought he bought the Silk Road Bitcoins from the US government and just like obviously an early adopter with massive conviction. So he's gonna be interesting, dude to meet. Then there's like a whole run of awesome awesome stuff, layer one protocol stuff, you know.

Matt Carrallo, Lalu is gonna be there, Lombroso, Aaron Van Weirdem's gonna moderate a couple of these things. Palestra's gonna be there. Yeah, so we're gonna get some awesome layer one stuff that first morning. I'm you know, I'm gonna be walking around with portable audio recorder, just trying to get as much audio as I can.

And I don't know exactly what's gonna go through or what I'm gonna end up publishing, but I'll be publishing a collection of audio hopefully with people who are kind of coming off stage from their from their talks and just you know maybe get little snippets here and there and put the compile that into like a day one and day two episode next week.

That's kind of my kind of thing. We need to do a bunch of we need to do a bunch of on the fly interviews. We need to hit one up when we get back, like done with the first night, like do a wrap-up. Yes. And yeah, we just need to have the microphone running at all times. Exactly. Yeah, just get a bunch of audio and then edit it together. Like, you know, there's not gonna be a lot of sleeping going on for those few nights.

Day two is is gonna is like gonna be kind of dedicated to layer two, lightning and other layer two solutions. Lynn Olbricht is is gonna speak that morning, which is pretty cool. And that's the day I think we get we get to hear from Snowden. There's a bunch of stuff about lighting gonna happen.

Daniel Buchner from Microsoft is gonna talk about the layer two identity solution that Microsoft is is putting out, which is just super interesting stuff. And I think no kidding. Man, I think it's a great model. I didn't realize that was gonna be there because I'm really curious about that yet too.

Had a couple of people message me to be like, you should really check this out and maybe do an episode on it, but I have not had any time to actually dig into it yet. And I'm really curious what they're doing with that. Yeah, I've I've kind of gone scratched the surface a little bit, and it's it's fascinating. Yeah, it definitely deserves a nice deep dive because they're I think it's I think it's a great model for how to use Bitcoin for other, you know other solutions where you need digital scarcity and distributed trust and I'm you know major props to Microsoft for like having the discipline and foresight to sort of assess

The situation and the landscape and see that like you know come to what what you know I think you would agree with me is the is the correct solution you know and not some new not some new blockchain which seems like the kind of obvious and easy thing easy route to go so I just I'm impressed by that decision especially by a big corporation like Microsoft.

I think that's amazing yeah yeah I agree the fact that they're building on top of Bitcoin makes gives me a completely different impression than if they were like oh we're going to beat Bitcoin with our new bit bit identity token bitrosoft

There's here's here's an interesting title of a panel Dan held eran Aaron Van Wertham and Warren Tagomi are going to be talking about destroying Bitcoin which should be interesting that sounds like fun that sounds like a good one Randy Brito from BTC Venezuela is gonna be talking about the death of analog money in Venezuela and how Bitcoin's been playing a role in that whole mess there it's gonna be definitely one to catch they're closing out a with a keynote called the ultimate case for ultimate bull case for bitcoin with turdomista and jimmy song and max keiser moderating so and then that so that's

Gonna be just like get everybody hyped up, and then that immediately leads into a rooftop live recording of rabbit hole recap with Marty and Matt. Oh no good it's gonna be epic, man. Yeah. It's gonna be it's gonna be pretty sweet. Yeah, I don't what what are you what are like two innovations right now?

Because you read it, you read a bunch of stuff about you know what's going on with layer one and layer two. What are a couple of innovations like let's say the top two that you're most excited about? Okay, layer one or layer two. Pretty much it's all well, I mean, I guess Schnorr is an obvious example.

But really more than anything, and it's mostly because I do not understand how they pull off a couple of the things that they pull off with it, but eltoo. eltoo and the Sig hash no input, which is being replaced, I think, with the Sig hash any previous out.

Which I have not dug into. I actually Richard Myers in our interview was that was the first time I had actually heard that and I've done a little bit of searching since it just I don't understand how they manage to pull off what they do with eltoo, but it's fascinating to me. It seems like what's the gist of it of eltoo?

What's it trying to accomplish? Okay, so you know how the lightning network it's ridiculous because you have to explain something so complicated to explain how eltoo is better. Lightning Network is basically like a contract with fail safe. And so, you know, we agree to have this transaction, but I don't trust you.

So you're going to sign redemption transaction for me before we set up our agreement. I'm gonna sign a redemption transaction for you before we sign it, and then we're going to lock it with a time lock. So we have time to go to the court of Bitcoin to settle this dispute if anybody publishes a one side one side of the transaction.

So if we're everything's good and we're all on the same page, happy days.

If not, well, then we fall back on to the failsafe of the contract. And the honest player is the only person who can get the money. Right.

And eltoo is different. Where in that situation we have a punishment clause where the one who is cheating or posting a previous state is basically loses their money.

We also have asymmetric transactions. You have half of the transaction and I have the other half. Right.

And there's only one signature on each. Somehow they have it set up where there's essentially like some sort of sequencing with the keys that are involved in signing the transaction. And we're actually holding the exact same state. So even though there's still a difference between a one-sided close and a cooperative close, my final state is not half of it, and yours isn't the other half.

We're both holding the exact same thing. So if I even lose my hat, I can technically just ask you, like, can I get it from you? Because I need it just in case. And there's no punishment clause anymore. What happens is this Yeah, you don't really need it anymore. Because you don't really you don't really need it.

It just outdates the previous one. So yes, you can try to post one that was like three states back, but if I post the newest one, well, then it just gets rejected and the newest one gets done. So no matter what happens, it's it's basically helps with like mobile networks, it helps with the fact that hardware is not reliable.

Because right now, like hardly I don't think there's been one case of somebody actually purposefully cheating on the Lightning Network. But there's been tons of cases of like failures that resulted in the appearance of someone cheating and a punishment clause. So people have basically been getting punished for bad hardware and mistakes. So even though that's a really good incentive, that's why like some people are a little bit iffy about it, about like the whole lightning network going to eltoo because they like the idea of punishment clause to really incentivize someone like people not to cheat.

Right. But luckily they're completely compatible, so it doesn't matter. Half of it can update the eltoo, half of it can stay the old contract, makes no difference. It's just kind of your taste on whether or not you want to take on that risk. But then the other things that you can do with the eltoo because it's part of the you need Schnorr signatures to do it.

And then there's the did you watch the Ruben Thompson a video about state chains. I have not I have not watched it, no, but I did read a little bit about it. I haven't actually watched the source video.

Start with maybe reading the Bitcoin magazine. I think it's another Aaron Von Wortham article. Yeah, I think I read through that one, yeah. Best one for explaining any of the technical stuff going on. Yeah. Budget. Every everything that got that guy reads. It's ridiculous. Yeah. Yeah. Or that that guy writes.

And but state chains, like the fact that they can do that with the any previous out or whatever it is, that you're actually just moving. It's it's almost it's very much like the Lightning Network, except that you are you're sending keys from one person to another with a sequence.

And the second person, it essentially what what like immediately what I thought of is imagining a UTXO on the Bitcoin blockchain as like a bill. Like if you ended up doing state chains as as like the norm, like you can't actually break it up.

Like so, like let's say you have a one Bitcoin UTXO and it's on a state chain with somebody. Essentially, what's happening is you're having another party hold a key for the whole insurance contract and the revoking thing, very similar to the way that the Lightning Network does, except that the other party to the transaction is being swapped out.

So like first Alice has it, then she sends the one Bitcoin to Bob, and now Bob has the key, and he has it in a sequence that outdates Alice's version of the key, but it's the same key. So you're sending private keys. It's like an open dime, except it's digital. That that seems so crazy to me to that.

It's like, all right, we're just gonna send the private key across the network. What you know, I know it seems absolute batshit, but from the way they describe it, you can actually break up with you write the contract properly with the fail-safe clause, very much like the Lightning Network. And then you can actually distribute that third party that's doing the s the securing of the contract, so that like you could do it kind of like a liquid side chain.

You can actually have like 23 exchanges or something being the one that's signing the safety of the state chain and then obviously the likelihood of them colluding is slim to none. And you've got like a two thirds threshold that everything just works fine as long as you know no more than like half the exchanges go offline or try to cheat.

And what are they going to cheat? You know, out of a thousand dollars and they're gonna split it between eight exchanges, you know, to ruin their reputation. Like it just like the security model is actually pretty sound if you're not moving like billions of dollars on a state chain, which you would never want to do anyway. That's exactly what you need a real transaction for.

But but the fact that you can just move this thing what what's cool about it is it literally it becomes because it becomes like an open dime you could actually have all the UTXOs like you can imagine a world where everything is actually a state chain and all the UTXOs are like specific like bill denominations.

Like point oh oh one oh one or point zero zero two five or something like that. And then your wallet just aggregates them and then signs exactly how many bills and exactly what thing to change, and you've also got this crazy level of obfuscation from the blockchain analysis because it's the same UTXOs that are just being transferred from one person to the next.

Yeah, but you still have visibility into verifying the supply. Exactly, but you're still all the supply is sitting right still. In fact, it's gaining confirmations and hasn't changed for everything that's in a state chain. But I just don't I haven't fully wrapped my head around how it works. I have watched the video and read the article, but there's still a bunch of the pieces that I haven't really legoed together to give me a full picture of it, but it just that is that whole thing that is happening, it could literally change the entire dynamic of what it means to move Bitcoin.

Yeah, it's amazing. It's amazing. It's just amazing that there's you know, this far into Bitcoin's development, you know, you can look at it two way that 10 years is not that long, but 10 years is also, you know, a pretty significant amount of time for an open source project. You know, it's pretty it's matured pretty well, but just revolutionary ideas like this coming out still is is just kind of blows my mind.

Like we're just it just reinforces that it's actually you know still pretty early, and that there's you know, the common FUD that Bitcoin is you know moves too slow, it's old, it's gonna be disrupted by some newer and better better technology. I mean look at look at what's happening here, guys. We can we can do basically anything on Bitcoin still.

Like it's not you know, it's we're we're sort of like there's this ossification stuff happening on on layer one, right? I mean it's kind of getting more and more set in stone, but you know, there's just so much that we can do on subsequent layers that it it to, you know, it's it's sort of limitless. And it's it's amazing.

It's it's crazy because like you just have to change how you think about it. Like you have to change your frame of reference. Like as long as as soon as you're thinking that a Bitcoin like you forget you have to remember that a Bitcoin transaction is essentially the ultimate arbiter as to who the real owner is but it's programmable.

Like we can we can put any kind of elaborate contract behind that that we want and the amount of progress like just I remember being as fascinated about the Lightning network as I was when I first read about Bitcoin.

Like I remember thinking that it was as nuanced and as complicated of a design it was as different of a thinking as Bitcoin was from legacy as Lightning Network was from current Bitcoin and established an entirely new market, entirely new incentives, but it uses all of the key incentives of Bitcoin and the hardened protocol of it to basically be its court so that lightning can never be cheated.

Lightning extends that capacity to a whole new set of dynamics. And I swear eltoo and state chains are both like even though eltoo is really a version of lightning state chains is a completely different way of thinking. And if we've already come up with two designs that are that fundamentally different but you but are secured by the same system.

Right. Like we're we're just at the beginning of this. We are scratching the surface of this. We just lack imagination right now. That's it. Yeah, we're all kind of collectively just trying to figure out what the hell's going on. And then there's people like Ruben who you know, have kind of gathered in and are just you know brilliant enough to come up with something like this.

And shot you know, shout out to Ruben and shout out to the unhashed podcast too, which is a great Bitcoin podcast that y'all should check out if you haven't yet. He's a co-host on that podcast. There's those guys there that's there's a group of four guys there that are just really solid and can learn a lot from listening to them.

Yeah, I have to admit, I until I watched like I knew the name Ruben Thompson and I'd seen him on Twitter and stuff a lot, and I'm pro I've probably listened to an episode or something from Unhashed before, but none of it was like in my cycles of thing until the whole state chain things state chains came out and then I've immediately like kind of jumped on to my list.

Can't believe that I have missed this whole thing from because like the just the whole idea of exchanging private keys without actually moving anything on the blockchain is just kills me. That's just fascinating. Yeah, me too. I literally had like a jaw drop. Like when I r was reading through that article, I'm like, You're gonna do what?

You know, like that doesn't I don't get I don't under all right. This is gonna take a little bit to understand, but yeah. All right, so that's eltoo and that kind of slid into state chains. Was there something else that you're super excited about? Like, like I don't know. Obviously Schnorr's coming, that's so which is cool. But that's sort of like a kind of a drop in replacement thing.

It's not really any a new innovation, but it does enable new innovations. Yeah, yeah. Honestly, like just anything that'll get I think there's still even though eltoo is an improvement just to the Lightning Network, yeah. I think I think there's gonna still be so many things coming with the Lightning Network in general, like because of how like I'm really excited about how people start applying it.

I think we're finally getting to that point where the Lightning Network is gonna start to see people are gonna start to see what's possible with it. The Breeze wallet is one of the most interesting like I love probably Casa and Breeze are the two like products that I'm most excited about right now.

Casa, because they're building like a whole suite of like a whole stack of software to basically all talk to you know, have your own node, have your lightning full non-custodial, and talk from all your devices to it, like everything works together, like you can clearly see the direction that they're pushing all of that, and they keep dropping little updates that make it better and better and better and more and more interactive.

But then Breeze has the most like no configuration, no nonsense. You don't you don't have to know what you're doing, lightning wallet, and I'm really excited to see that come to fruition. Hopefully I can connect to my Casa Node at some point.

But yeah, but it is a non-custodial wallet, and when you send Bitcoin to it, it is a it is a loop transaction. So you know, Alex Bosworth's loop, I guess it's Alex. Yeah, yeah. I think it was either that or LD release loop.

Yeah. Where you can basically send a Bitcoin transaction. Yeah. Oh, well, yeah, yeah, I guess so. But so like when you're sending a transaction to it, it looks like you're sending a regular Bitcoin transaction, but they're creating a loop on the back end.

Like Breeze is acting like your LSP is what they refer to it in the article that I read, the lightning service provider. Uh-huh. You're automatically setting up a channel with them. They are you're sending Bitcoin to a loop transaction that then immediately when you get it in your wallet, it is lightning, it is in a lightning channel on your side of the channel.

So all you do is send a Bitcoin transaction, and then you're funded in a lightning wallet. You don't then set up channels or care about how many channels you have. You have a channel with the Breeze node, and they're managing liquidity, and they already have upfronted something on your on their side of the channel so that you can receive transactions.

And they are s they're literally just operating to keep everything balanced and working on the back end, so it's as seamless for the customer as possible. So the person who has the wallet. But you're holding your own keys. Right. Yeah, it's non-custodial. Yeah.

And it's it's literally zero configuration. Like you just have money in a lightning wallet, and then as long as Breeze is a is a good LSP, lightning service provider, you can pretty much you're always gonna be able to find a route. And they're actually going to make it oh my lord.

I just realized I'm gonna have to move that interview with him. I'm trying to get Roy on the show to do an interview, and we had it scheduled for Monday, and I'm gonna be in a plane now. I need to contact him because I want to make sure I don't lose that opportunity. I won't really want to get him on the show so I can pick his brain about this.

Yeah, you're gonna have to reach out, ASAP man. Yes, I need to do that. Like, he'll understand that. You're gonna you gotta come you gotta come out to the conference, man. You get you're working. Maybe he'll be out there. I don't know. Oh yeah, that'd be cool. Maybe you could do it in person. Yeah. Yeah, well, you know, speaking of routing, I think AMP is is one I'm really excited about.

Atomic multipath payments. What's the what's the latest on on that front? Has there been any reason like recent developments? I haven't I haven't heard anything lately, but maybe you have. I have not. I haven't heard anything in a couple of weeks. Heads down and going on, basically work on it. That is I know that is being focused on by a couple of people from what I've heard in the past, interviews, reading and stuff.

I knew that that was quick on the list. That with submarine swaps, like looping and splicing. And about the time I got to like three or four weeks where I felt like I wasn't hearing anything, it was like, oh, by the way, here's loop. Use it now. So I'm I'm I've got this little excitement in the back of my mind that like we're just gonna hear something big from AMS pretty soon.

Yeah, yeah. You feel like that. Yeah, because I think Connor and Lalu are working on that. So I mean it's like that's kind of the top guys at LND are are working on it. Because I yeah it seems like it's it's a it's going to be a pretty fundamental part of the protocol and make it and allow lightning to operate more like more like more like packet routing than payment routing I guess yeah you kind of assemble reassemble the payment with multiple packets routed in different different ways over the network which obviously increases the chances of your

Of finding a route seems seem it would be a kind of a drastic increase and that that's really like the you know the biggest issue with lightning right now I think is just that you know you still relatively often especially if you're trying to interact with like a new vendor or new node that you the route sometimes fails.

You know it's probably like one in ten one in five, one in ten times these days and it obviously depends on how well your your node is connected but allowing you to break up the payment into small smaller pieces and then finding different routes all over and then reassemble them really help out a lot on that front.

Yeah yeah I heard or wait did was this one of my analogies I don't know this might have been the one I was reading in the I wrote in the Panama canal episode because I heard I don't remember where I stumbled upon this or what made me think of it.

I think maybe it was just in a conversation, but I was fascinated by how the how the locks and like channels work in the Panama Canal to lift a ship above sea level actually worked extremely similarly to the whole concept of the lightning network.

But amps in my mind were like instead of having like one giant cargo ship trying to you need you need your canal big enough to get the one giant cargo ship across, is that you can just break it up into hundreds of little pieces and send it down all these little streams and rivers and then get back out to the ocean on the other side and park in a bay and essentially reconstruct the whole ship.

Yeah, exactly. It it's just it's a it's a big change, a big difference in the ability to route across the network, which of course is you know the way the internet works too, and the packer routing on the internet. The biggest thing with that is the user hurdle right now, is that that takes out the largest issue of not having one balance, and I think that's one of the major keys that both Casa has talked about in some of their interviews, or excuse me, some of their articles, I'm sure probably some of

Their interviews too. And then Breeze talks about with Roy, and there's a couple people who have been just talking about the user experience, and that there needs to be one balance. Nobody needs to see that you've got these channels and this is your max payment because this is your biggest channel.

Like nobody is like you can't expect someone to understand the ins and outs of the whole protocol, especially if you want this thing to go mainstream. You know, nobody has to know what the heck is going on on the back end of a credit card they just need to know swipe swipe and punch in your pin or swipe and sign you know like that is it yep and your wallet needs to be one balance and I think with I thought we were a little bit further away but now I'm getting kind of antsy because with Breeze and Casa I feel like we're moving particularly with the things that I've been playing with I feel like it's moving like we're gonna get pushing a lot faster than I thought we were but

That we're going to see a wallet very soon where Bitcoin and lightning are just the same thing. There's one balance and it's all on the back end. You can play with the advanced stuff if you want but for 90% of its use and 90% of its users it is just one balance and it just chooses what the easiest way to make the payment arrive at destination is yeah that makes perfect sense man.

Yeah and amps are a big big big part of that yeah and it also helps with privacy too because you're splitting that payment up and in you know it's much harder to track a payment split into 10 pieces and routed across the network than it is just one payment across the network. Exactly yeah yeah so you know all these all these things also tend to help with privacy these innovations so I think people who are concerned about privacy is you know and rightfully so as an antidote to this penopticon that we've built I it's just like each each of these improvements to the protocol come with a little bit better

Privacy, you know. And I think over the next few years, I mean we just kind of like are going to get better privacy because it's just kind of baked into a lot of these improvements, these protocol improvements. So it's pretty sweet. Yeah. It's exciting. It's gonna be a crazy couple of years. And what's funny is we've got because we've got the halving coming up in it's less than a year now, isn't it?

It's like 340. Yeah, it's like yeah, 11 months or so roughly. Cool, man, it's gonna be crazy for the next year. It's we're setting up for some insanity, man. Like I this is gonna be the bull run that really like permanently places Bitcoin into the global consciousness.

Like I think 2017, 2017 was kind of like a test firing of the of the engines, you know, of the moon rocket engines, you know. And like we're this is the launch. Like this is the beginning, this is the global the beginning of the global Bitcoin awareness and adoption. And yeah, it's it's gonna be absolutely amazing to be a part of.

And I think we're gonna look back, you know, at this this next week here at Bitcoin 2019. And you know, we've got the this this fresh bull market starting, it looks like, and the first Bitcoin focused kind of conference after this era of blockchain not Bitcoin conferences dominating the scene, you know. I think this Bitcoin, I think it was like Bitcoin 2013 or something like that.

It was it was in San Francisco. Was one of the one of the first, you know, kind of big Bitcoin conferences, and th it hasn't happened for a few years. So Bitcoin magazine is bringing it back. And I think this is sort of a just a sign of the times, right? That that we're sort of gravity is court is shifting back to Bitcoin.

Everyone's sort of in the industry is like, okay, you know, Bitcoin is where it's at, right? And there's maybe a couple other interesting, you know, crypto efforts that are happening. And I would I would include Libra at the in that group at this point, even though it's not a cryptocurrency. Like everyone says is, but you know, there's some interesting projects that are going to you know affect the scene and you know, be competitors to Bitcoin and Bitcoin's going to draw from them.

But yeah, the gravity shifting back toward you know Bitcoin only and big or just like Bitcoin first type businesses, and that this is really where the scene is. I think we're gonna look back and at this year and the beginning of this run and this particular next week at Bitcoin 2019 and be like, yeah, this was this was the you know where the countdown started, right?

Yeah for the launch. It's gonna be it's gonna be amazing. Yeah, what's crazy is man, I think you're absolutely right. Like, I think this is going to be the run. I think before 2021, you're going to see you're gonna see governments and central banks actually have to account for the fact that Bitcoin is here.

They are going to when they make their decisions, they're going to be like, oh, we should do negative interest rates, and we need to do this, and we need to get our exports and blah, blah, blah, and blah, and then somebody's gonna have to say, well, what about Bitcoin? And they're gonna be like, oh, crap. Like, like it's going to ruin, like it's going to essentially ruin their ability to enact the policy as a blanket declaration of what this is what's money gonna money is gonna do in the world because the people have chosen differently.

And they just don't run it anymore. And they're gonna find out in under two years that they don't. As soon as Bitcoin is as big as gold like it changes everything yeah everything and even before it's actually being used by everyone when it is that size when that amount of capital is safely in it versus another option it changes everything every decision by every government in central bank suddenly has this giant like elephant in the room is just standing over there saying

Nope you can't make that decision you'll die you can't ignore you can't ignore me anymore you can't laugh at it. That's exactly right and I think this is this is the one where that happens it's kind of crazy to think that we might be that soon but I think I think we are I think we are too I think we are too yeah yeah it's it's going to surprise even the longest you know the longest term Bitcoiners I think yeah you know there's there it's and Bitcoin Tina shout out to Bitcoin Tina on Twitter you know just keeps beating this drum over it's like this is this thing is gonna just like just shock you all man it's gonna shock you all it's gonna go way faster than any of you think

Looking at the past cycles to gauge the future cycles doesn't make any sense in this in this with this technology it's an exponential technology it's gonna you know just you guys are you know your your time horizons are just way too long man it's gonna this is gonna happen in like five years or less you know yeah and I you know I'm starting to be more and more sympathetic to that interpretation of things and so yeah I think it could be absolutely insane we're here for it man we're here for it for the beginning of it and the one thing that I keep the one thing that I keep thinking back to is how quickly that transition happened when like with

Facebook and Twitter when it was all about what like CNN and ABC and like all these like mainstream media it was it was essentially like we were sharing and talking about what like the important thing was what they reported and then suddenly it seemed like out of nowhere all you saw on CNB and CNC CNN and ABC and like Fox and all of these things were what someone tweeted what Facebook post went viral what YouTube video people can't stop watching it was like it was

Like the gravity just shifted from one side to the next like they're not gone but you always see them talking about what's happening online like like the conversation the online world now dominates the entire conversation this whole thing shifted in under 10 years just out completely out from under them and now they're all playing catch up they're trying to let everybody who's not over there yet this is what you think about what's happening on Twitter because Twitter's already developed its opinion you know like yeah and I think we're going to see I think we're going to see that whole thing

That's that's what makes me think that like you know in two three years like it really could happen fast. Like I felt like it happened that fast and I wasn't even like I just didn't see it happen. It just was one day. Yep. Right and this has such the drivers for this one are so much stronger because there's monetary incentive.

There's it there's about security and independence and cross border, cross-country like agreements and exchange that don't want to. I mean, think about like the number of sanctions and the wars and all the things that Bitcoin just ignored. You know, like let's do let's cooperate and make trade and just ignore all of those things.

That's even possible. It's fascinating. Yeah. Yep. And then you tackle you tackle like you stack a sound money and like that's just the contractual and censorship resistant side of it. You put sound money and the speculative side and the network effects side and the technom technological side on top of it, and you're like, like, how could it not happen that fast almost, you know?

Like once the ball starts rolling, how could anybody avoid being attached to it in some way? So I don't know. It's it's amazing, man. It's it's blowing all our minds, it's happening right in front of our faces. I yeah, I am just as bullish as could as ever.

It just it keeps I my conviction is as strong as ever. I'm so excited to be a part of this the scene and just yeah, watch it unfold and it's gonna be incredible, guys. It's gonna be amazing. It's gonna be a fun conference.

Oh yeah, I'm stoked. I'm stoked, man. I'm excited that I finally it's gonna be a it's gonna be an endeavor, but I'm I'm really excited that I finally that I'm gonna be able to do well. I know you got you got some like you just kind of shook up everything. So you got some some work to attend to, I think, to kind of get everything ready, ready to fly out to Sancho.

I will see and I am excited. We're gonna drink some beers and hang out and not sleep and just like publish publish Bitcoin content and it's gonna be it's gonna be fucking great. So I'll see you.

Bitcoin content right now. Yeah. Hell yeah. Hell yeah.

Yeah, the scarcity of Bitcoin content on these on these feeds is gonna go down this next week. So prepare for a price drop. All right, man. I will see you tomorrow. Safe travels and Absolutely enjoyed it. All right. As usual, thanks for joining me in probably a couple hours. Yeah, exactly.

All right, cheers.

All right. All right. That was a ton of fun. I am fucking hyped for this conference and bullish as ever about Bitcoin. Keep an eye on the at Citizen Bitcoin Twitter account for special content drops from the Bitcoin 2019 conference.

Subscribe to the Crypto Economy podcast at CryptoEconomy.life and follow Guy on Twitter at The Crypto Economy alright that's all for this week take care out there Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Guy Swann is host of The Cryptoconomy Podcast. In this episode we are regaled with Guy’s bitcoin story, and it’s a good one. We also talk about Eltoo, state chains, atomic multi path payments, and lightning loop. We get all hyped up for the Bitcoin 2019 conference and wax super bullish toward the end of the ep.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the show:

The Cryptoconomy Podcast

Bitcoin 2019 Conference

Statechains article by AVW

Eltoo article by AVW

Downloads